Red in the BJP’s veins, ink in the Congress’s blood



If dereserving a plot meant for weaker sections of society in Karnataka and handing it over to your son is not illegal, just immoral, then, pray, why is the new Maharashtra government and the whole world going for former Chief Minister Ashok Chavan’s blood and that of his bureaucrats for assigning to themselves and various assorted members of their families prime flats in the Adarsh housing society in Bombay?

I must say I was appalled by my good friend Nitin Gadkari’s justification of corruption in Karnataka by its own Chief Minister Y S Yedyurappa, who seems to have sought a truce with state Governer H R Bhardwaj simply to escape any more flak on this count.

I have heard of one man’s meat being another’s poison but this justification goes much more beyond that. One cannot deny the fact that corruption of any kind is poison to the common man (though it may bring meaty sums to its practitioners) but it is only since the advent of the Bharatiya Janata Party that we have begun to see regular justification of the adage ‘one man’s terrorist is another’s freedom fighter’.

So whose freedom were saffron terrorists like Sadhvi Pragya Thakur and Colonel Shrikant Purohit fighting for? While they have killed, maimed and destroyed in near-equal proportion to Islamic terrorists, Gadkari’s predecessors in the BJP would have us believe that these saffron terrorists were national heroes and they should not have been singled out by former ATS chief Hemant Karkare for action, let alone arrested and brought to trial.

The saffronists were all over Rahul Gandhi attacking him with gusto when Wikileaks revealed that he had expressed concern about saffron terrorists as more dangerous than the Islamic ones. But there is little they have been able to say in justification, except cry foul against the government, when it is revealed that the saffron forces are actually planning to incite riots – just sample the conversation recorded between Milind Narvekar, secretary to Shiv Sena president Uddhav Thackeray, and their Pune leader, Neelam Gorhe – asking for trucks, buses and shops to be burnt by early morning and highways blocked so that television channels could catch the visuals early and play it through the day (on the day of the Pune bandh on December 28).

I do not agree with Rahul Gandhi’s assessment of saffron terrorism – these saffron terrorists are, after all, homegrown and it is in the hands of the government and the state to nail them and adequately punish them for their crimes. By contrast Islamic terrorism is incited from across the border. And even when there is ample proof – like in the case of the 26/11 attacks – there is little we can do but cry hoarse that Pakistan take action and stop these terrorists from violating Indian territory.

But, yes, if Rahul was referring to the corruption of the Indian Army by these saffron terrorists, I think he was right to be concerned. Because we are, by far, too guarded about Muslims in the Armed Forces and too little concerned about those among the majority community who might indoctrinate innocent minds and wreak havoc within the country. It is possible, after all, for saffron terrorists to infiltrate the Indian Army as it is not for Islamic terrorists to do the same. And, I believe, the Indian Army is an institution that should not be messed around with. It is high time that the Indian state take action against all those other officers, both serving and retired, who have been named in the investigation into saffron terrorism.

But we hear no peep out of the saffron parties at this real threat to Indian security and there is a deafening silence when Shiv Sena activists are caught planning a major massacre in Pune as they did in Bombay during 1991-92. It was Bal Thackeray who had then incited Shiv Sainiks and if the Srikrishna Commission could indict him for that, it was only because of the absence of television journalism at the time and the fact that, because of it, a relatively unknown reporter could impersonate as the assistant/friend of a political leader and sit in on Thackeray’s instructions issued from Matoshree to incite riots all across Bombay.

Though in a different time and context, the BJP’s attitude reminds me of that famous scene out of Sidney Poitier in To Sir, With Love. When he hurts himself and his finger bleeds, a white student says, “Jesus, its red!” (He means blood.) To which a non-racist student replies, ” So what did you expect? Ink?” By that she meant black.

So by Gadkari’s justification for his party’s own corruption it is clear that when the BJP bleeds, ‘it is red’. But when the Congress does the same (the Adarsh scam is identical to the Yedyurappa one, after all), it clearly is black!

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (18 votes, average: 2.56 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Al

    Well said.

    A tainted Congressman turns a saint if he joins BJP. Do we remember Sukhram?

    Decades ago Ramakrishna Hegde too played similar politics to embarass Indira Gandhi. But then it was rumoured most of the influential media persons were being kept in good humour by him.

    [Reply]

  • ashok

    One can hardly blame Gadkari for shielding the man who picked up the tab for the small wedding in the family.

    [Reply]

  • Satish Haldankar

    The RSS/BJP have always indulged in doublespeak and double standards. For them, there is justification whatever they or their associates do and try to paint themselves as some sort of saints. On the other hand, they waste no time in pointing fingers at those, who do not subscribe to their world view, for the similar acts of omission and commission.

    BTW, where are the Internet Hindutvavadis, who normally swarm the forums to blast anyone criticising the RSS/BJP? Have they been embarrassed by the utterances of their own heroes?

    [Reply]

  • Mohan Ramchandani

    Sujata Anandan ,

    I was very disapointed to read your article. It is because of people like you create the problem by regularly comparing Islamist terrorist with Safron . How can you compare the corruption of
    Yedyurappa with teorrorism. The burning of shops and buses by Shive sena – it is strongly
    condemnable – was not done in the name of hindu religion. And yes, BJP should strongly condemn this or they should actually cut their thies with Shiv sena, but what is the government doing about
    it when they have a proof of Shiv Sena leaders instigating for violence. Why the governemnt
    of Maharashtra not taking any action against these goons. Is BJP responisible for this too ?

    [Reply]

  • Krishna

    I wonder why nobody talks about Kashmiri Pandits ? Islamic terrorism has systematically forced out Kashmiri Hindus from Kashmir by using means what they know best – Torture, rape, burning and occupying their properties. Millions of kashmiri Hindus are living in refugee camps in their own country. Not even a single drop of ink is shed for them by our great secular media.

    [Reply]

  • jay

    rahul may be a christian but he should remember indira and rajive was hindus and they loved hindus and indians . and a soft hinduwadi like me are looking at rahul and sonia and ak antoney as if they have more love towords paksitan than india. they hate hindus because some hindu rightwings beats up christians. but they sure know hindus are not going to abuse chrsitians as christianns themself do all over the world . look ruwanda or congo for example. as a hindu we are very concerned that ak antoney put an air marital who is a minority christian when he could chose a panjabhi or a jatt rajastani or some one loyal to india. as if in his eyes hindus or sikhs are useless to india. but remeber it is those people who will fight for india even if india govt goes bankrupt. so please respect indians and hindus and do not be rude to hindus . and we hindus are softline in majority but if you do not respect us we may have to think about your party and its policy. we dont want you to pick up a war with pakistan and prove we are for india( indira gandi did that ) and i sure dont want to see such thing going on. i sure dislike pakistan but i dont want some congress party people picking up gun to vent all the steam on pakistan that would be anorhter bad move to attract our hindu vote of soft hindus. we want you to be considereable to hindus as you do to muslims of india when you rule india. just be considerable . we are not all hard line hindus and we have lots of love for peace and prosperity. and we want congress party and communist party showing consideration to hindus . that is it . try to bring some hindu leaders in your congress party even communist do that in india why cant you do this in india. yes you can . you can win our vote . but you must do a lot of hard home work

    [Reply]

    Ganesh S Reply:

    :There should be some way to stop such idiotic insane and stupid comments from being published.Even as hush hush comments inside doors these cannot even be called trash and rubbish.But then such is the depravity among these middle class Indians that at least a thousand times we are reminded that Rahul and Sonia are Christians and every act of governance or non governance is attributed to that.These I suspect are those RSS cadres online who are trying to ordain and condition the netizens into believing such piles of nonsense.Talking of Hindus,let me remind this RSS apologist that once the RSS chief was asked a question – do Hindus exist only in BJP and RSS ? The answer as always was STONY SILENCE.Even today they are all back to their crowing due to scams in Congress party -NOT BECAUSE THEY HAVE ANYTHING TO OFFER AS ALTERNATIVE.Yes,we the people of India were are and will be fed up of Congress ways till it improves ( God knows when – and when I say this I mean both Hindu and Christian gods !!!) but WHERE IS THE BLESSED ALTERNATIVE ? These idiots as alternative ? Well not even God can save us – Hindu god or Christian god !!!

    [Reply]

  • ram

    Hi Sujata

    Congress is party in power in Maharashtra and Centre. BJP is bad thenm CPngress in WPRST as it divides INdians in name of caste and religion. 85% Hindu is population of INdia INdia is ruled by minority individual PM Singh (who is dishonest enough to be a Rajya SAbha MP from Assam where he has never been resident!) who is personally honest but institutionally corrupt as he condones corruption so who is guilty? PV NArasimha was berated and hounded by your tribe for bribing 5 MPs for minority Govt to continue while PM Singh and Soniaji have sold copuntry to DMK for USD 40 Billion and ———scams are just starting —————————————

    Regards

    Ram

    Singapore

    [Reply]

  • jerry

    well said.the present ruling parties(cong & ncp) dont have the guts to go after the masterminds in the shiv sena even with evidence.the authorities are just warming their seats.if similar evidence was found against the minorities then everyone would be ganging up to apply mcoca ,pota, and sedition charges.the weak are bullied.

    [Reply]

  • Kishan

    One did not expect such low level of intelligence in Sujata’s post. I think she should stick to writing about past anecdotes which are much more interesting to read.
    When Sujata calls the protests against shifting a statue of a venerated personality, planning major massacres; it shows the mind-set of the secularists who are more responsible than the saffronites for deepening the divisions between major Indian religious communities. Remember these divisions have existed from before independence.
    Why doesn’t Sujata use her pen to pressurise the govt to bring those accused of saffron terror to speedy justice ? Because it helps the vote bank politics of the secularists to keep the pot boiling but never finish the cooking. They are really sickening !

    [Reply]

  • http://- Rajeev

    Paid Journo at work..After all she works for Vir Sanghvi the master dalal.

    [Reply]

    Ganesh S Reply:

    Why dont you understand Ms Sujatha Anandan ? Certificate from these RSS loyalists posing as netizens is so important.To earn that certificate you have to do a few things like :

    1.NEVER i mean NEVER criticize BJP
    2.Call Mr Yeddiyurappa a virtuous man
    3.Ignore any BJP related scam
    4.Prevent yourself from taking any objective fact driven view of Congress scams
    5.Jump to conclusions and damn everyone in Congress and sing the BJP song
    6.Keep praising BJP as a party with a difference
    7.Colour your column SAFRON

    Then you will stop being abused,vilified and commented upon by these idiots in replies to your columns.Or else,suffer the same fate as Vir Singhvi and Barkha Dutt !!!!

    As a citizen am asking myself,what cheek this party (BJP) has to even ask for a mandate to run the country.Lessons of 2009 have never been learnt.In fact it is a party that NEVER learns lessons.Come 2014 people of India will teach one more BIG lesson to BJP.Be sure of that.

    [Reply]