Close encounters of the Naxalite kind



My mother was frantic this week when I failed to make my usual morning call to her a day after the Dantewada massacres of CRPF jawans by Naxalites. Actually, I had an early morning meeting to attend and, in that rush, I switched off my phone and simply just forgot about it. When I switched it on again at lunchtime, there were so many furious messages asking me to call that it was now my turn to get into a panic.

When I finally got to talk to her, she said, “I thought you had rushed off to Chhattisgarh. I was worried something had happened to you. I was switching channels on television all afternoon to see if there was any word about any further ambushes of either journalists or policemen. How was I to know? That is what you have done all your life, after all!”

I did not really blame my mother. As she said, I had cut my milk teeth in journalism on coverage of riots, massacres, communal and other conflicts and a lifetime’s habit is hard to shake.

Moreover, even if I had forgotten about it, my mother recalled how a couple of decades ago, I had got caught by Naxalites in the Allapally jungles of Gadchiroli. Actually, I hadn’t been alone. We were a group of reporters who were being given a tour of the jungles by the local legislator (he had promised us a tiger sighting or two). We were in the middle of nowhere when two armed men jumped into our jeep (the old fashioned jonga type, not one of today’s modern-day SUVs), held aloft rifles (I don’t quite remember now if they pointed it at any of us) and said, “Chalo!”

Of course, that put paid to our scheduled trip – we had to go where the armed gunmen took us. Soon enough we discovered they were Naxalites. They hadn’t been sure if we were cops (they thought we could be because the jeep was an olive green), but then they discovered that all that we were armed with was pen and paper. However, after that initial scare things went smoothly, though we had to abandon our tiger safari.

They took us to a jungle clearing where some more Naxals were gathered, sat us down and gave us all a sparse, rustic meal. And told us their end of the story. Among one of the chilling stories was about how they had tied up one particular exploitative landlord to a tree near an anthill, poured honey all over him and left him to be slowly eaten by the ants – he was screaming for hours and died in utmost agony. And these cold-blooded killers told that tale with relish! When it was dark, we were led back out of the jungles and we heaved a great sigh of relief as, hearts in our mouths, we all speeded to our respective homes and hotels.

My mother scolded me for days after that for putting my life at risk in such fashion. But when I got back to Bombay and told a cop friend of mine, he said, “I know.” And recounted the names of all those reporters who had been caught by the Naxalites in the jungles that day.

“How do you know?” I asked.

“If a Naxalite even sneezes in the jungles of Gadchiroli, we get to know about it at the police headquarters in Bombay a few minutes later,” he said matter-of-factly. “Not to say we were not worried when you guys were kidnapped. But we knew they would not harm you. They needed you to tell their version of the truth to the world. Moreover, they knew they would have been thoroughly dealt with, otherwise.”

Obviously, there was an impressive intelligence network in place. And when I asked him to explain, he gave me many off-the-record insights – many of those surfacing nationally only this decade. Actually, I now recall, Maharashtra had virtually succeeded in wiping out its Naxals – now they have to contend with those migrating from the adjoining jungles of Chhatisgarh. But when, in the Eighties, the Naxals cut off the head of a village sarpanch after kidnapping him the previous night and left it on his front doorstep for his wife to find the next morning, my friend told me, both the politicians and the police knew it was time to act – and act strongly.

Long before the word `encounter’ got into the national lexicon, as my friend said, the Maharashtra cops had decided that they would not let a single Naxal get away with, well, murder. “If we arrest him and take him to the courts, he will get bail, jump that bail and massacre again. In addition, we would have to contend with Naxal sympathisers and human rights activists who cry foul all the time, never mind who’s the killer and who gets killed. So we have decided upon a policy that we have kept classified: shoot to kill and drive them out of the jungles of Maharashtra.”,

I do not think it was a coincidence that virtually a similar policy drove gangsters and dons out of Bombay several years later (the very same cops who had been in charge of Gadchiroli had by then been posted in Bombay), ridding the state of these trigger-happy extortionists and gunmen.

But then the cops also had the backing of government – then Chief Minister Sharad Pawar had decided that cops will be sent to the jungles of Gadchiroli not on punishment but on promotion postings – and double promotions at that, sometimes with triple increments. If they lived to tell the tale, they would have gone up in rank over their colleagues when they returned to safer zones two years later. A Tribal Commissionerate was also set up on the same principles, bureaucrats receiving similar incentives. And the government decided there will be schools, hospitals and employment opportunities easily available in the forests.

Maharahstra’s cops then discovered that the Naxals hated this more than they had hated the lack of development – and jungle dwellers came more under fire from the Naxals for seeking to be part of the development process than they had been when they had no opportunities at all. But when Naxals, in turn, discovered that they were being quietly eliminated by the dozens, they quickly shifted base to neighbouring states and Maharashtra had its Naxal menace licked—for a short while.

Even today, though, Gadchiroli is not as bad as Dantewada or Lalgarh and Jharkhand. Probably because no political party in Maharashtra is dependent on Maoists for survival and the police are allowed to do their job and get on with it. As they did in even Andhra Pradesh, too. So wherever the buck might stop, it can be done. Provided we stop romancing these cold-blooded killers and treating them as some latter-day Robin Hoods.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (10 votes, average: 4.9 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • http://www.datatrackonline.org Ashish Kolarkar

    It was good to read about your encounter with Naxalites. I’m told chilling stories of Naxal atrocities of Chhatisgarh by fellow travellers on my business journies. The situation is grave and in certain areas only Maoists rule. There is no Govt control. The naxal panchayat rules the area. They Maoists have special hate for Police force.

    As Maharashtra experience suggest political will is necessary to root out this problem. Sharad Pawar is lauded for his mandate to Police force to eliminate this menace. I’m not sure the same method is applicable in Chhatisgarh or Jharkhand or Andhra Pradesh. The area is too large and local politicians have vested interest in keeping this problem alive.

    [Reply]

  • Jai71

    Hi Sujata,

    You have very correctly noted that the Germans would know just what democratically elected means. We have numerous criminals being elected while serving a sentence in Jail!!

    Being democratically elected is certainly not a “clean chit” for anybody. But, Hitler & all his men received fair trials – and not all were held guilty.

    But I want to ask you: Why have you failed to mention, two points about the German delegation:
    1. Who was this delegation & why were they visiting india – who organized their visit? A bit about that organization would be very helpful.

    2. Who did the delegation meet in India / Gujarat to make the assessment? How extensive was this.

    And by making such statements, the Germans are not throwing dirt at our democracy – they are saying our justice system is not acceptable to them!! And I do have a problem with that. (It is a little difficult to defend our justice system, but then it is “our” system – and they have no right to comment on that!)

    I can even appreciate if they said that they will hold Modi visa in suspense until the court verdict – but they have decided to give their own verdict!!

    I know you are not a fan of Modi and don’t expect you to glorify him, but I sure expect high integrity from you as a journalist – in atleast stating the facts – am I being fair?

    Thanks!

    Jai!

    [Reply]

    Jai71 Reply:

    Sorry for this offtrack post – but there was nowhere else to bring this up!

    Jai

    [Reply]

  • Diwakar

    Mam,
    You have once again demonstrated your clarity in the understanding of the core issue and minced no words as to the way forward in dealing with this problem. Alas, if you have happened to listen to Ms.Arundhati Roy (somehow more popular and attention-seeking journo) yesterday on CNN-IBN, you will be shuddering as to how this licence to talk and make headlines is more damaging than the actual menace.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.ecomenow.com veptReems

    zithromax renal dosing
    zithromax angine
    dosage for zithromax
    zithromax tripak
    strep children zithromax
    tri pack zithromax
    zithromax tri-pak
    zithromax expired
    zithromax for chlamydia
    zithromax 5 day pack
    zithromax cure chlamydia
    zithromax ear infections
    zithromax to cure std
    zithromax cure sifilis
    zithromax dosage for kids
    zithromax chlamidia
    vaginosis zithromax
    zithromax online a href
    zithromax pyelonephritis
    zithromax side effects
    uses of zithromax
    zithromax price
    zithromax no prescription
    side effects zithromax
    information zithromax
    zithromax std
    zithromax fpr prostate
    zithromax allergies
    zithromax in cats
    zithromax and uti
    zithromax to dissolve
    levaquin zithromax
    zithromax yeast infection
    zithromax
    zithromax and marijana
    strep throat zithromax
    zithromax regimen
    zithromax fdog
    hcpcs zithromax
    zithromax wiki
    zithromax expired
    zithromax safe pregnancy
    zithromax std
    zithromax mucinex
    zithromax ear book
    zithromax order
    prescribing zithromax
    buy cheap zithromax
    zithromax doses
    std zithromax dose
    zithromax tinnitus
    zithromax dose chlamydia
    zithromax z pac
    zithromax and avelox
    alcohol and zithromax
    dose zithromax
    generic name of zithromax
    z pack zithromax
    zithromax descriptions
    zithromax otitis media
    zithromax susp
    is zithromax bad
    zithromax z pak dosage
    zithromax for cats
    buy zithromax single dose
    zithromax for infants
    zithromax 2008 warnings
    zithromax sale
    zithromax 3 day
    zithromax information
    zithromax dose
    what is zithromax
    free zithromax
    uses of zithromax
    zithromax fed ex
    zithromax generic prices
    zithromax for bronchitis
    zithromax and arthritis
    zithromax tablets
    zithromax effects
    zithromax 1 gm
    can zithromax cure thrush
    zithromax bad reaction
    vaccines and zithromax
    zithromax pfizer
    side effects of zithromax
    zithromax z max 2 grams
    zithromax pregnancy
    sinus infection zithromax
    pneumonia zithromax
    zithromax injection
    indications for zithromax
    gonorrhea zithromax
    zithromax purchace
    zithromax dosing
    can dogs have zithromax
    bone infection zithromax
    zithromax oral

    [Reply]

  • http://gamertalk.invisionplus.net/?mforum=gamertalk&s=d49e47c8ffb9540e98152c9dc595ecdf&showuser=99933 Deborah Jillson

    HCG diet dangers are a hot topic with people who are thinking about losing weight with this incredible diet. Majority of human body part consists water.

    [Reply]

  • rajiv

    Very correct , if we doa SWOT analisis of Indian economy you will stuck to define how it exoists and how is it growing with no plan and agenda .

    ”These guys like MMS and montec singh in the planning commission are like some of the guardian sports ministers like abdullah who feel they are permanent positions and this is their back office to take care of their extra costs. They underestimated indian Colour TV requirement by 1000% less saying it is a poor country and did not allow the colour tube manufactiring industry to develop in india.

    The import of mobile phones went up from $16B to $120B in last 6 years and the planning commission has no plans to star manufacturing in India .

    last 8 years the milk production in india is constant and price has tribled . the planning commission feels the milk requirement is same as 8 years ago .

    26% of indian manufacturing industry has shifted to china in the last 5 years . wonder what planning they do. they plan how to seel the country to china . how can we import more food commodity . all the friuts and the various dals that india eats today are imported . china , australia and canada are growing masoor etc Dal for india . India does not have a deep and mechanized seaport .

    because of the planning commission dubai / srilanka/hongkong etc ports have grown at our cost . the best port spot in cochin was handed over to dubai ports knowing fully well they will not develop it as it will be suisidal for dubai ports .

    and then they will say they followed the bjp policy like in 2G scam . all chors who can not see the world has changed in the last 8 years . they shd be sacked . an amm Admi can do a better job, we do not need these Harvard MBA and ex IMF guys to plan for china at the cost of Indian tax payers money . Jai anna

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    We need Patriotic & decisive leaders like Narendra Modi to keep the country on track of progress. Nominees like MMS & Mukharjee have doomed the nation. There is sole aim of grabbing power & looting the country. The Janlokpal would have gone a long way in bringing accountability in the system.

    [Reply]

  • Frie

    This “holier than thou” attitude and habitually crying “wolf” will make them the laughing stock of the world.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Khagaraj-Sommu/100003261520163 Khagaraj Sommu

    Many Western journalists are also wrong in blaming Bashar Assad in the Syrian crisis.They completely ignore the part played by the wahabised Sunni residents of Homs,who were incited by the Saudi Arabia.Like some Indian journos in the Praveen Reddi case the Western journos exhibit a one track mind that echoes the political views of their governments.Freedom of the press seems to be a myth in the West.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Suman-Mukherjee/744925892 Suman Mukherjee

    Very well written. Indeed, the latest trend of hysteric & sensationalized reporting in Indian media is worrying at best, sickening & irritating at worst. But personally, though I am not in a position to opine on the declining quality & standards of journalism in India, I am confident to attribute at least a part of the blame to the new found confidence of Indian Middle class on all matters concerning them including what they want to see, read & hear in the media. Today’s journalists are only left to catering to that at their own expense, can we really blame them for not doing something they are not allowed by their seniors to do?

    [Reply]

  • Gyan

    Indian journalists are the lowest paid in the world. Please pay them well, provide food and education, most importantly teach proper English and then recruit
    as reported for Newspaper.

    [Reply]

  • Abu Ahmed

    As a matter of fact, a constant watch on what and how is being reported in the print and elctronic media is very much needed. Inefficiency, callousness and negligence have become norm rather than exception with Indian journalism.

    [Reply]

  • Prasad Mantrala

    Very well said Mr. Sarkar. I am the Press & Media Secretary of United Kingdom Telugu Association (UKTA) who rushed to the hospital upon hearing the stabbing news of Mr Reddy. While I have repeatedly warned the media not to cook up stories, the fact that there was a lady among the 11 arrested became another loose end for the love triangle conclusion. We sincerely appeal to all media representatives to approach a reliable source such as Minister for Press & Information of High Commission of India or an association like us who are willing to help Indians in distress instead of probing the case from different angles and trying to tread on the Police’s toes!

    [Reply]

  • Dipankar

    Pranav D, I don’t know if I have the answers to your big questions, because I actually think that we have hit a point where we need to (re)familiarise ourselves with the basics of good journalism.

    But certainly the industry can devise schemes to seek out people who are passionate about journalism. It needs to train them well in all aspects of the craft before encouraging them to specialise. This is happening already in some parts of the industry but it’s obvious that there are gaps.

    Skills that you speak of, such as reasoning, analysis and balance, are not acquired overnight. They need time, resources, hard work and patience.

    [Reply]

  • Chris

    Fair comments, but the media’s audience is not only the government. I would say that the Indian public has a legitimate interest in violent attacks carried out against people of Indian origin even if they are not citizens of India (though I agree reporters need to make clearer what they mean by “Indians”).

    [Reply]

  • Bohumilsmith
  • Anatoliasmith

    Police and CRPF are always alert about Naxalities in the tribal area.

    http://savingnext.com/coupons/ashford-promo-code-exclusive-discounts-coupon-code.html

    [Reply]