Sonia is family, said Amitabh



I was working for a wire service when Rajiv Gandhi was assassinated. A few months later, I received a call from my editors in New Delhi: the Amethi seat was up for a by-election and Sonia Gandhi had decided she wanted to give it to Amitabh Bachchan. Her children were too young, she was not into politics (then) and she would rather it stayed with “family”.

They wanted me to talk to Bachchan and confirm if he had been spoken to by Sonia Gandhi and/or if he had consented.

I was not a film correspondent. Moreover, it was the era before mobile telephony. So I dialed ‘197′ and looked up the book for Bachchan’s number. A minion picked up the phone and said Bachchan was out shooting.

“Out of Bombay or just out of the house?”

“He is in Bombay. But he is on a triple shift. We don’t know if he will be home for lunch. Think its unlikely. Mostly, he’ll be back only at 10 pm after the last shift.”

No amount of pleading for a number where I cold reach him at a studio had any effect. “You leave your number with us and I will see if he wants to call you back,” said the secretary.

I called my Delhi office and told them they would either have to hold their story for a day or go with it without Bachchan’s comments. They were frantic. “Can’t you keep trying? If we hold, the newspapers might have it by tomorrow. We want to be the first to break it nationwide.”

I called Bachchan’s house again. Same man, same pleas, same replies. I gave up.

Then as I was snacking at tea time, a peon walked across to the ringing phone, listened with a bewitched expression on his face for a minute, broke into a beatific smile and then yelled excitedly across the room, “Madam, Amitabh Bachchan! For you!”

I choked on my samosa. I was not sure if I was being had because the whole office had been in on my conversation with Bachchan’s secretary earlier in the day. Even as I headed for the phone rather tentatively, I scolded my peon, “I will boil you in coconut oil if I find you are lying or pulling my leg. As though Amitabh Bachchan would be calling me ever! Dimaag kharab ho gaya hai tumhara!”

I took the phone from him and said a rather cautious, “Hello?”

“Sujata, this is (he put a stress on the ‘is’) Amitabh Bachchan.” There was no mistaking the deep baritone and I almost dropped the phone in shock. Quickly, I launched into a stumbling apology for my lack of faith in both my peon and in Amitabh Bachchan. “I’m sorry, Mr Bachchan,” I said. “I was not expecting you to call me yourself. I thought your secretary would put me through to you, whenever. And I did not think he would pass the message on to you so quickly. He told me you would be home only at dinner time.”

“Well, I am home now. So ask me whatever you wanted to ask.”

I did. And Bachchan was clear. “No. Sonia Gandhi has not spoken to me about contesting at all. She knows my views very well. She knows I am out of politics and wish to stay out of it forever. But she and her children are family. I will always be there for them every other way. But I will never contest another election again. Not even from Amethi.”

I was too much of a rookie at the time to exchange more than a few awe-stricken pleasantries with him. But I let out a whoop of delight as I put down the phone and filed the inputs back for my Delhi office.

My next encounter with Bachchan was face-to-face. He was launching a French perfume named after him the year he turned 60 and by then I was less awe-stricken. So I asked, “How are you sure that this perfume, too, will not bomb as those named after Zeenat Aman and Lata Mangeshkar did?”

“Well, I would certainly hope this is more successful. But who can say?”

He was polite. I apologised for being rude. “No, don’t,” he said, ever the polite gentleman. “As a reporter I know you need to ask all the unpleasant questions. You were only doing your job.” I heaved a sigh of relief that he had not been offended.

I still have a little bit of that perfume (‘Amitabh Bachchan for Women’) thar I got at the time, though  I have not seen it on any shop shelves, lately (it bombed). However, by the time I got to meeting him I had gotten more confidence. So I had no problem asking him the next question: why did you give up politics when so many from tinsel town are dying to join up various political parties?

His answer was very revealing: as a Congress MP, he had been to Assam for campaigning. There was an insurgent movement on in that North-Eastern state at the time and the Assam Gana Parishad was going very strong. Bachchan said there was some kind of demo organised against his rally (there were other political leaders accompanying him) but seeing the angry crowds, they decided to take off again even as they had just landed. At that time, a youth came running across and slapped a piece of paper on Bachchan. When he later unfolded that chit inside the aircraft, it said, “Mr Bachchan, you are a great film star; I am a great fan of yours. But I hate the Congress. So please do not put me in a situation where I have to choose between your two personalities.”

Said Bachchan, “I then decided it was not fair to put my fans who came from all sections of society through that turmoil. I would stay out of politics. I would concentrate only on films.”

But somehow, now, all these years later, it is sad that he is being drawn into politics against his will. And his own towering film persona, which he chose over the greater pull of politics, is what is leading him into these controversies: if he hadn’t had to seek a tax rebate from the Gujarat government for his film Rann, he would not have had to endorse Gujarat and be equated with Narendra Modi. Ditto Kerala. And now his presence at the opening of the new carriageway on the Bandra-Worli sea link has stirred up yet another political controversy.

But this one’s really petty. And I think also downright disrespectful and insulting. Even an ordinary man does not want to be invited to a party and then told he is not welcome. I can feel Bachchan’s hurt and would like to say to all those who started the controversy: don’t try to be more loyal than the King.

For, Sonia Gandhi was once family to the Bachchans. She could return to being family again.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (30 votes, average: 4.63 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • http://incorrectpolitically.wordpress.com/ Akhilesh

    Hi Sujata,
    Congratulations on taking a principled and correct stance on this issue. For once.

    The media was right in castigating the Sena for its ungainly attitude against SRK in the MNIK controversy. In the last few weeks there have been spate of articles in print media lambasting the new culture of hate, especially from Hindutva brigade, spreading on new media like Twitter etc.

    I agree that what Sena was doing against SRK was hate. When Hindutva warriors use personal abuse, albeit for right cause, then too it is hate.

    I also believe that what Congress is doing with Bachhan is HATE. Had Bachhan been canvassing for votes for Modi / BJP, and Congress had discomfiture with him, it would have been understandable. But what AB is doing is simply asking more people to visit places like the Gandhi Ashram in Gujrat. And that, the Congress finds objectionable !!! And for this reason it humiliates Amitabh Bacchhan publicly.

    But none in the ’secular” media had the guts to lambast the Congress for this utterly despicable act. The media elite have not done this because it would mean questioning the Gandhi family – which is like blasphemy !!

    So Kudos to you for saying it like it is – what Congress did to Amitabh Bachhan, a national icon in the league of Lata Mangeshkar and Tendulkar, is simply HATE.

    And for your forthrighness alone, I have started following you on Twitter ( and thereby increasing your followers list) :) Infact on Twitter, there we have already interacted on the Maria issue.

    Here is my account link : http://twitter.com/amishra77

    [Reply]

    Sujata Anandan Reply:

    I always take my own stand on various issues and always tell it like it is. Those I write about recognsie that well — that if I am with them today, I may not b with them tomorrow. it depends on the issue but if you are not for somthing, it does not ncessarily mean you are against it (closest example in my context being the women’s bill). I am glad you agree with me about this, tomorrow you might find yourself violently disagreeing again. But that’s ok.That’s what democracy is all about, ain’t it?. And thanks for giving me your twitter link.

    [Reply]

    Nandakumar Nair Reply:

    Hi akhilesh

    It is true that Amitabh is not campaigning for BJP or Narendra Modi. But this is politics and things are not that straight and simple as they look. What has happened in Gujarat in 2002 cannot be forgotten and should not be forgotten ,but instead of regretting at what happened they have tried to clean up things by pointing to congress’s hand in the sikh riots of 84 and other reasons. They try to justify things by pointing to modi’s victories in the past elections .As if any criminal in this country can get away from punishments just by winning a verdict in the so called people’s court” Another way in which justification game goes on is the endorsement of industrialists like the Tatas ,Ambanis and the mittals.
    Remember they have invested in Gujarat and not on Modi ,but there is always a game on to equate Modi with Gujarat. Can Amitabh or for that matter other celebrities ensure that a person like modi does not take advantage of their presence to clean up his past. Yes congress may be petty but are the others in the clear on this

    [Reply]

  • Manish Kumar

    Dear Ms Anandan,

    For the second time we agree on an issue. Congress is trying to be more loyal than the king and that has been their falling since independence.

    Anyway as an ordinary middle class guy i can only say that Mr. Bachchan’s movies have given me far more joy than all the policies of Congress and their reservations and subsidies put together. Just because Congress has absolute power it has stopped to think of common man’s sentiments and my prediction is that this will take them down one day. As a wise man once said, be nice to people on your way up as you would them again on your way down. Hope the Congress learns from this.

    [Reply]

    suren Reply:

    Mr Manish All these celebrities (including Tendulkar who begged Mahajan for tax rebate ) have to beg the govt of the day for tax rebates which shows that they are ordinary citizens and not gods. So why are you Indians worshipping them? This is the only curse which stops your glorious india from developing into that huge super power (Which I wish should happen recently despite your foolishness). I am a sri lankan tamil who want to join Indian army to fight and kill at least one taliban or pakistani. Thats my dream . I love my surrogate mother india.
    Meanwhile you want to say that Bachan is a neutral Figure in politics? His wife is Samajwadi MP which is enemy of congress. He was flirting with Mulaayam again to get tax rebate from Mulayam’s UP govt. He drew all benefit from Rajiv govt then when cong was in crisis he stabbed gandis in the back . I am sure bachan was thinking that cong will never come back to power (Even I was not sure as a staunch supporter of the Gandis from sri lanka) so he ignored Sonia and she was hurt, natural no? Of course bachan commits all this oppotrtunism just to get tax rebate so that show he is ordinary person. Sachin also sought tax rebate from Mahajan but one difference between Sachin and Amitabh is that Sachin never repeats his mistakes he learns from them but bachan repeatedly flirts with the govt of the day. Even then I will not worship sachin like you worship bachan. Still Sachin is my favorite crisketer not muraldaran or sanath jayasuriya from my sri lanka. I am sure sachin will break lara’ record. Jai hinth Inkulab Jindabadh!! – Suren from Colombo

    [Reply]

    Sujata Anandan Reply:

    Suren, there are lots of others who thibnk like you do. I didn’t want to say all that because it would ahe been very uncharitable

    [Reply]

    Trushar Reply:

    Why people do not understand that tax rebates on movie Paa is at least 1000 times less than Amitabh’s free endorsement for Gujarat tourism!!!

    Sujata Anandan Reply:

    Congress never learns from anything. I always say there are only two things that win them thei elections — God and Sonia gandhi!

    [Reply]

  • http://incorrectpolitically.wordpress.com/ Akhilesh

    Hiren Bhai,
    Possible that you do not understand English well. If you did, you would realise that I am amongst the internet band batting on behalf of Modi.

    [Reply]

  • Ganesh S

    Dear Ms Sujata,

    As always your write – up has been focussed.

    I have always been a Congress sympathiser.I have always voted whenever I have voted.My views on Sonia and now Rahul almost border what some might say – blind admiration.

    But,equally strongly,for the craft he engaged in I also have blind admiration for Mr Amitabh Bachchan.

    I am not hesitating to admit that on this issue,the stand of Congress and Congressmen as a party and as a set of individuals in squeamish and petty minded to say the least and that too in a most charitable manner.

    I fail to understand why Sonia and Rahul – or one of them cant issue a clarifying statement that they do not endorse what actually amounts to needless and highly objectionable witch hunting.

    I am highly disappointed by the fact that what is basically a matter of inter-personal or maybe inter-family compatibility – turned – incompatibility now seems to have become an orchestrated campaign.

    Public space in a country has enough space for dignity and basic regard for people of all shades of opinion.Mr Amitabh Bachchan – all right thinking Indians are with you as they were with Shah Rukh Khan earlier.

    Mr AB has every right to go wherever and be invited anywhere.If a persona like him is not invited to any function to which he could have been or should have been invited,it is the function and the organisers that show in a poor light.

    Congress party beware – do no take such liberties with right thinking people like me who respects Sonia as much as he respects AB.

    Afterall,the AB dialogue symbolises his place in the hearts of every Indian is – hum wo hai jahaa khade ho jaate hai line wahi se shuroo ho jaati hai.

    Rock on AB – we are all with you.

    It is so pathetic to see one after the other Congress leaders to blabber away incoherently on TV channels on this issue.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Ganesh S,
    I admire you for supporting AB despite your blind loyalty towards Sonia and Rahul.

    You must know that this family is known for dictatorial behaviour. You are going to be disappointed.

    [Reply]

    Sujata Anandan Reply:

    Actually even I am waiting for Sonia Gandhi to speak and make clear her position on the Bachchans. it would b interesting to know what she thinks — remember the time when Amitabh called himself the runk and her the raja, saying the ordinary are befreinded by kings and not the other way round. And that it was the Gandhis who had decided their freindship was at an end. Lots of rumours but would like to know what really went wrong between the two.

    [Reply]

  • A Fernandes

    It has been quite easy to think of Amitabh Bachan as a sincere guy. After all, in the past, barring some unsavoury situations, he has been seen to show character and righteousness and/or maybe his films have created this kind of magic. But of late, an increasing number of people, including the equally righteous,diehard sceptics,foolhardy critics and the one who know much, find many clouds before their eyes when judging him. Is Amitabh Bachan doing all that he is doing now and acting another role for a reason? There are quite a many, in fact! His MP wife is about to get consigned to historical oblivion for she is unlikely to be given another Rajya Sabha term by the SP or any other party when her term ends this year; in fact, her refusal to leave the SP along with Amar Singh who baptised her in politics, which would have put her on a higher moral pedestal, perhaps proves how desperate she has become. He cannot and will not take the risk of overtly joining the BJP for fear of alienating his large following of minority and secular people and by now he might have also made the calculation that the BJP has a very stiff chance of reviving its electoral fortunes. His film career is gradually but clearly going to be on the wane and his son’s and daughter-in-law’s future do not look so bright. Or having conquered so much and having reached a particular point in life, is he trying to transcend and reach another level on the national platform? So the questions to be asked are : is he working on an agenda to get ingratiated with the Congress for resurrecting the fortunes and future of himself and his family? Or is he trying to portray the Congress and particularly the Sonia Gandhi family in poor light and hope that a protracted campaign of antics, hyberbole and subterfuge might covertly pave the way for diminishing of the Congress’ image to help the electoral chances of some other party where he may get a centre-stage position? Or is he still that nice bloke who is doing these things on wrong assumptions and a lack of good judgement. Looking at everything, it sounds somewhat difficult to trust him altogether now?

    [Reply]

    Sujata Anandan Reply:

    In fact, what you say is what I have heard a lot of critics say, too. Difficult to deny the charge of opportunism. Also have a little bit of an issue over his endorsement of Gujarat — what does he mean by half-endorsing `only tourism’. That is sophistry bcause today Modi equates himself with the rest of gujarat. Amitabh shd have had the courage to say `no’, even if it meant not getting a tax exemption from either Kerala or Gujarat

    [Reply]

  • Gautam

    I take umbrage to one of your observations. You say “But somehow, now, all these years later, it is sad that he is being drawn into politics against his will”. ‘Against his will’???? This is so not true. the Big B was always in politics. He meddled with it, he hob-nobed with politicians and profited from them.

    First the Gandhis, then the Samajvadis and now Modi. The latest rant of Amar Singh against Jaya Bachchan is an example of how opportunistic the Bachchans are. It is Amar Singh who stood by them in their most difficult hours and now in his most difficult hours, Jaya Bachchan has left him high and dry, hung on to her political seat and Amitabh Bachchan is courting Narendra Modi.

    Plus his association with Gujarat is not some love for the State or its people, it is simply a need for tax relief. He got in Gujarat, tried in Kerela and will act as mascot for every State, district, town and mofussil in India and outside if they give him a tax relief.

    [Reply]

    Sujata Anandan Reply:

    Perhaps, you are right.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Congress = Taliban
    Sonia = Mullah Omar
    Rahul = Mullah baradar

    [Reply]

    Trushar Reply:

    Why do you think he is right,can you explain me?????

    [Reply]

    Trushar Reply:

    Amitabh Bachchan doesn’t need any political support to get success…

    Relationship with Gandhi family was even before he was in Hindi film industry…

    I shouldn’t even justify but as you blame Amitabh Bachchan I am going to do so…

    Amitabh is promoting Gujarat not Modi…

    What is his self interest in that??? Promotion and box-office collection of movie Paa??

    Nuppp!!! Can’t be… The simple reason is Amitabh has offered endorsement of Gujarat tourism without a penny…Do you know how much is his singing amount top endorse one product…at 1000 times more than the potential collection he might have earned in state of Gujarat…

    He had relationship with Samajvadi Party before KBC, when he was passing through box-office fails…

    History is witness of this…that it is very easy to become politician for an actor…

    Politicians are going to come and go every five year…

    Amitabh Bachchan is in the hearts of millions since 41 years. One and we all should respect him and his respected family. he deserves definitely better than what you have written..

    Remember …“When you are blaming person who was nationally honored with Padmabhushan and Padmshri, you are insulting not only that person but the nation.”

    Being from a media here in United States I can assure you that no one reside in people’s mind as he does!!

    [Reply]

    Trushar Reply:

    You can even post this comment on http://www.big.bigadda.com too,If you need satisfied answer from Bachchan himself.

    [Reply]

    Trushar Reply:

    Correction: http://www.bigb.bigadda.com

    [Reply]

  • Anil

    A lesson for indian writers in general please resist from using words like
    MINION, SERVANT etc .. these are demeaning words use the euphemised versions of these please..

    [Reply]

  • Anil

    This all is happenign at behest of Sonia . So my advice to you don;t be more loyal than the queen.. tell it like it is. Ashok Chavan if left alone will anyday hobnob with Bachchan..

    NO Bachchan endorsing Gujarat has nothignt o do wiht politica no matter how hard you guys try to paint it that way..

    [Reply]

  • http://www.hindusantimes.com Sujata Anandan

    Suren, there are lots of others who think like you do. I didn’t want to say all that because it would a
    have been very uncharitable

    [Reply]

  • http://www.thekidsaidwhat.com/Moyieghes Kerry Ison

    You made great points there. I made a search on the topic and found most peoples will agree with your blog. These players have not become self-absorbed millionaires who care more about their image than their teams’ record.

    [Reply]

  • Mohil Patel

    Narendra Modi is a good politician with good record. He has been involved in few mess ups but have been given a clean chit. As a Prime minister, he could do a lot for the nation with his experience.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    NARENDRABHAI HAS WON THE HEARTS OF THE PEOPLE OF INDIA. IT IS ONLY THE SO CALLED SECULAR QUARTERS WHO ARE SUFFERING ACUTE STOMACH ACHES. THE MEDIA, AS ALWAYS SIDES ANYONE WHO PAYS. TODAY MODI IS THE MOST POPULAR LEADER OF THE COUNTRY.

    [Reply]

  • Krishna

    buchter of gujarat? really?

    [Reply]

  • Dr.G.Ghosh

    No doubt he will be our next PM and the CONGRESS (Corrupted Overall Nehru GandhiKhanIndira Rajiv’s Empowered Sonia’s Swiss) vote bank will be thrown into the Bay of Bengal and Indian Ocean in the 2014 election. God save Indian people from the corruption that was implemented by the CONGRESS and Mr Nehru.

    [Reply]

  • Dr.G.Ghosh

    No doubt Mr Modi will be our next PM.

    [Reply]

  • DINESH H.PATEL(NRG)

    CONGRESS GOVERNMENT LOST THEIR REPUTATION NOT ONLY BECAUSE OF CORRUPTION BUT TOTAL FAILURE IN PROVIDING EFFICIENT LEADERSHIP IN NUMBER OF RECENT INCIDENTS PEOPLE OF INDIA HAVE FACED. OTHER SIDE NARENDRA MODI HAS PROVED HIS EFFICIENCY AS MATURED AND EFFECTIVE LEADERSHIP. SO FAR POLITICAL SITUATION IS CONCERNED INDIA REALLY NEED THE LEADER LIKE NARENDRA MODI.

    [Reply]

  • Gyan

    Narendra modi has won hearts of only Gujaratis no one else’s. I do not see any suitable candidate for thr top job in India.

    [Reply]

    Gaurang Vaishanv Reply:

    How do you know that he has not won hearts of others? May be you need to take off those colored, prejudiced glasses and study media reports all over.

    [Reply]

    JSW Reply:

    Media bik chuki hai, Porngress ke hatho me.

    [Reply]

  • Reema

    If Hindus shed their caste vulgarity and slavish mind about white skin, BJP under Modi will win hands down. Nitish Kumar is a non-entity, a very crude communalist. His mask is clearing up, people can see he is worse than Congress. But Hindus will keep divided as they have done for centuries and will accept 2nd class citizen instead.

    [Reply]

  • Bhatti

    Modi is the fitting candidate to take over the mantle from Advani, and for sure, he too is definitly going to be a PM in waiting till the end of his life- like Advani- his mentor.

    [Reply]

  • Rd1patel

    Mr.Narendra Modi is good administrater and has good vision as P.M
    In India most of top rank politicians are interested for the position of P.M
    I understand for such post all party may try their way and select candidate
    for P.M. To reach such position numbers of different stage are required to go
    and one of them to play very dirty politicas by creating lye alligation against his
    compitator and to please supporters at any extent without any athicas.
    This may be difficult for Mr.Modi like Mr.Moraji Desai

    [Reply]

  • Nagarnaru

    The priorities for the BJP now are as follows:
    [1]Preparations for the ensuing UP Assembly Election
    [2]Throwing their entire weight behind fighting the SCAMS.
    [3]Preparing Modi for the PRIME MINSISTERSHIP.

    Capturing UP is a key factor to capturing Delhi. The citizens of UP are disenchanted with both CONGRESS & BSP because of the phenomenal corruption. SP has almost lost its sheen. Unless BJP puts its act together & concentrates on winning the UP,it will make their road to DELHI also arduous.

    The entire nation is in a state of shock. Astronomical amounts have been swindled by the present Government. Unless the BJP focusses their attention in fighting the SCAMS&bringing back the BLACK MONEY, the citizens of India will view BJP also with suspicion – whether they are also partners in the scam!!!!

    If there is an INDEPEDENT, UNRIGGED OPINION POLL today asking the Indians who they want their Next PM as, not less than 1 Billion are likely to vote for Modi. So let BJP concentrate on this

    [Reply]

  • Nagarnaru

    The priorities for the BJP now are as follows:
    [1]Preparations for the ensuing UP Assembly Election
    [2]Throwing their entire weight behind fighting the SCAMS.
    [3]Preparing Modi for the PRIME MINSISTERSHIP.

    Capturing UP is a key factor to capturing Delhi. The citizens of UP are disenchanted with both CONGRESS & BSP because of the phenomenal corruption. SP has almost lost its sheen. Unless BJP puts its act together & concentrates on winning the UP,it will make their road to DELHI also arduous.

    The entire nation is in a state of shock. Astronomical amounts have been swindled by the present Government. Unless the BJP focusses their attention in fighting the SCAMS&bringing back the BLACK MONEY, the citizens of India will view BJP also with suspicion – whether they are also partners in the scam!!!!

    If there is an INDEPEDENT, UNRIGGED OPINION POLL today asking the Indians who they want their Next PM as, not less than 1 Billion are likely to vote for Modi. So let BJP concentrate on this

    [Reply]

  • Candor

    Almost all BJP CMs have shown good appetite for development. May it be Gujarat, MP, Chattisgarh, Uttrakhand, HP, Punjab (in coalition), Karnataka, Goa. Should not forget it was NDA government who had brought the thaw in Indo-US relations throwing vast business and employment opportunities for India. India should be ruled by pro-development BJP.

    [Reply]

  • sanjay

    who so ever will be the PM he must have a quality of narendra modi– a best administrator in country

    [Reply]

  • sanjay

    who so ever will be the PM he must have a quality of narendra modi– a best administrator in country

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    everything depends on up elections in 2012. if the bjp can put up a decent show then they have hopes of even going it alone in 2014 –in that case modi can become the prime minister easily .
    it all depends at the situation in 2012 or after that . We know the politicians –they will gravitate to a partY or person who has chances to come to power
    another thing which is important is the stress we are giving to muslim vote –this should be marginalised .
    Political pundits are wrong in their assesment as they see the coming to power of upa 1 as the reaction of the aam admi to the bjp rule —frankly bjp rule was not bad , better than the congress but there was one difference which perhaps cost them the election POLITICAL. PUNDITS MAY HAVE THEIR OWN FANCY THEORIES BUT MY FATHER 1 YEAR BEFORE THE BJP LOSS HAD PREDICTED THIS LOSS–THE REASON , AS HE SAID THT THEY SHOULD HAVE DONE SOMETHING DIFFERENT FOR THE HINDUS WHICH ALL WHO VOTED FOR THEM EXPECTED . AS HE SAID THEY DID NOTHING FOR THE HINDU CONSTITUENCY AS PEOPLE EXPECTED—– THE ENTHUSIASM OF THE HINDUS WHO VOTED FOR THEM WANED AS HE HAD PREDICTED . THE VOTE BANK OF BJP IS NOT MUSLIM BUT HINDUS –THEY SHOULD NURTURE THIS IF THEY WANT TO WIN . aFTER ALL 85 PERCENT IS DEFINETLY MORE THAN 15 PERCENT—-SOLIDFY , UNITE THIS VOTE BANK

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    everything depends on up elections in 2012. if the bjp can put up a decent show then they have hopes of even going it alone in 2014 –in that case modi can become the prime minister easily .
    it all depends at the situation in 2012 or after that . We know the politicians –they will gravitate to a partY or person who has chances to come to power
    another thing which is important is the stress we are giving to muslim vote –this should be marginalised .
    Political pundits are wrong in their assesment as they see the coming to power of upa 1 as the reaction of the aam admi to the bjp rule —frankly bjp rule was not bad , better than the congress but there was one difference which perhaps cost them the election POLITICAL. PUNDITS MAY HAVE THEIR OWN FANCY THEORIES BUT MY FATHER 1 YEAR BEFORE THE BJP LOSS HAD PREDICTED THIS LOSS–THE REASON , AS HE SAID THT THEY SHOULD HAVE DONE SOMETHING DIFFERENT FOR THE HINDUS WHICH ALL WHO VOTED FOR THEM EXPECTED . AS HE SAID THEY DID NOTHING FOR THE HINDU CONSTITUENCY AS PEOPLE EXPECTED—– THE ENTHUSIASM OF THE HINDUS WHO VOTED FOR THEM WANED AS HE HAD PREDICTED . THE VOTE BANK OF BJP IS NOT MUSLIM BUT HINDUS –THEY SHOULD NURTURE THIS IF THEY WANT TO WIN . aFTER ALL 85 PERCENT IS DEFINETLY MORE THAN 15 PERCENT—-SOLIDFY , UNITE THIS VOTE BANK

    [Reply]

  • mohd anaskhan

    Million Dollar question is that when Modi has failed to manage 6 Cr Gujarati How he will manage 120 Cr Indians.

    [Reply]

    vinod Reply:

    Million pound answer is he is not their to manage the people , he is there for serving the 6 crore gujrati , & for your information he has taken the clear & clean steps which is followe by the people working in the state government & same will happened while ruling india as P.M

    [Reply]

    vinod Reply:

    Million pound answer is he is not their to manage the people , he is there for serving the 6 crore gujrati , & for your information he has taken the clear & clean steps which is followe by the people working in the state government & same will happened while ruling india as P.M

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Rajiv Gandhi failed to manage 5 million Delhites so how did he manage 800 million people in 1984?
    I know muslims are communal 99% of the time but it looks like you are communal 100% of the time.

    [Reply]

    Rameshagarwal36 Reply:

    BEING A CONSERVATIVE AND RADICAL MUSLIM NOTHING BETTER CAN BE EXPECTED FROM YOU IF HE HAS NOT WON HEART OF PEOPLE HOW HE WON ELECTION?EVEN USA HAS DESCRIBE HIM AS EST CM OF INDIIA.YOU LIVE IN INDIA AND THINK ABOUT TALIWAN.

    [Reply]

    Gaurang Vaishanv Reply:

    Congress “manages”, nay, manipulates people, mostly Muslims whom it has kept poor and uneducated for six decades. Modi does not manage, he inspires and enthuses. Results are for all to see there, if they have eyes to see.

    [Reply]

  • mohd anaskhan

    Million Dollar question is that when Modi has failed to manage 6 Cr Gujarati How he will manage 120 Cr Indians.

    [Reply]

  • Ananthanarayan Na

    It’s a foolish write up and justify that muslims will vote for congress, as Narendra Modi is getting projected as PM , but of late muslims have also realised that sitting with congress for these many years has done no good and congress is considered as STUS QUO party.

    [Reply]

  • Famouspankaj

    it shall be blessing of God that modi shall become prime mnister of india -pankaj

    [Reply]

  • Famouspankaj

    it shall be blessing of God that modi shall become prime mnister of india -pankaj

    [Reply]

  • Mehta Snajay22

    NarinderJi is a fantastic personality. The man is full of moral character, ethics and having the spontaneous caliber to adminstrate and lead not only Gujrat, but India and its my conviction that India would be the Pioneer in world under his Premiership. I wish long life to NarinderJi as well as to attain his goal to lead the country for the well being of country.

    [Reply]

  • anirudh

    Before debating over the issue, think – who is there to compete with Modi – Rahul Ganghi?
    Wont it be a contest between ability and inability?
    The fact that Modi is the most able administrator and Rahul Ganghi is unable to do anything right, is not a secret. (So far only the Indians knew about it, now even the Americans do). In spite of this if Rahul Gandhi becomes the PM, wont it raise questions on the intelligence of the Indian voter?
    Shouldnt there be a reasonable criterion for the top job? The developmental work of Modi is for all to see (those who can not, should consult an eye specialist). But think – what can Rahul claim about, what did he do to deserve the post?
    Please think reasonably.

    [Reply]

  • Rameshagarwal36

    NARENDRA MODI HAS WON THE HEARTS OF NOT ONLY GUJRATIES BUT SENSIBLE INDIANS TOO FOR HIS GVERNANCE/DEVELOPMENT.HE IS OPPOSED BY POLITICIANS VYING FOR MUSLIM VOTES.BESIDE POL.A SECTION OF MEDIA UNDER INFLUENCE FROM UPA IARE TARGETTING MODI WITHOUT ANY BASIS.INSPITE OF MANY ENQUARIES NO SINGLE EVIDENCE HAS BEEN FOUND IMPLICATING HIM IN RIOTS.WHY POL./MEDIA IS QUIET ON ATTROCITIES ON HINDUS AT VALLEY AND ANTI SIKH RIOTS.INSPITE OF OPPOSITION FROM A LARGE SECTION OF PEOPLE FROM INDIA HE WORKED TIRELESSLY AND WON THE HEART OF MILLIONS OF COUNTRYMEN AND EVEN COUNTRY LIKE USA HAS ADJUSTED HIM AS BEST PM.CONGRESS WILL PROJECT RAHUL GANDHI WHO HAS NO EXPERIENCE AND VERY BAD RECORD AS CAN BE SEEN FROM UTUBE.HOW LONG DYNASTY RULE CONTINUE IN INDIA?CONGRESS HAS BECOME UNPOPULAR DUE TO CIRRUPTION/SCAMS/INFLATION/UNEVEN DEVELOPMENT AND FAILURE TO CONTAIN TERRORISM.YES IT IS TRUE THAT NITISH AND JD(U)WILL OPPOSE MODI DUE TO MUSLIM VOTES,NITISH IS ALSO VERY ARROGANT AND HIS PARTY DOES NOT KNOW THE DHARM OF ALLIANCE.HE IS POWER HUNGRY.IF THERE IS UNANIMITY IN BJP THEN MODI WILL BE BEST CHOICE FOR PM.AND TO THE INTEREST OF NATION.

    [Reply]

  • Chinubhai Mehta

    - MR. MODI HAS A LONG VISION -NO DOUBT ABOUT IT. HE IS AN EXCELLENT PLANNER. IN HIS YOUNG AGE, HE COMMITED MANY UNCONSTITUTIONAL ERRORS FOR WHICH HE ISI SUFFERING .
    ONE WHEN TAKES UP RESPONSIBILITY OF A STATE HEAD, HE HAS TO TOTALLY DISCHARGE HIS CONSTITUTIONAL OBLIGATIONS.IN OUR HONEST VIEW , IT WOULD HAVE MORE APPROPIATE FOR HIM NOT TO FORGET THIS BASIC PRINCIPLE.ANY WAY WHAT HAS HAPPENED CAN NOT BE UNDONE.
    BUT HAD HE STARTED HIS THREE DAYS FASTS EITHER IN JUHAPURA OR IN ANY MUSLIM BIG AREA ,WHERE MUSLIMS WERE KILLED, COULD, IN MY OPINION , WON THE HEARTS OF LACS OF MUSLIMS OR THEIR CERTAIN BAD FEELINGS COULD HAVE BEEN WIPED OFF TO CERTAIN EXTENT..
    BUT FROM SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS , PROBABLY, THIS WAS NOT DONE. NOW, MR. MODI SHALL HAVE TO DO SOME POSITIVE TO WIN MUSLIM HEARTS.

    [Reply]

    Gaurang Vaishanv Reply:

    What you are suggesting is typical Congress theory of appeasement of minorities. Modi has done noting wrong, no court has charge-sheeted him nine years after riots that were in reaction to burning alive 59 innocent Hindus by Muslims. He does not owe anything special to the Muslims and will not do what you are asking.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/roshiley Roshan Shah

    2003 first Vibrant Gujarat – 66 Thousand Crores investment MoUs (Rs. 4,000 debt per Gujarati)
    ….
    ….
    2011 fifth Vibrant Gujarat – 20.83 LAKH Crores invesment MoUs – (Rs. 40,000 debt per Gujarati) – hardships in life increasing.

    [ From 2003 to 2011, there has been 31.56x multiple in investment in Gujarat - or say i.e at least doubling every event i.e 2x2x2x2x2 ]
    ….
    ….
    Come 2013, we have 4 times bigger venue and see the article that participants and visitors in 2011 nearly doubled from 2009 summit.
    ….
    ….
    So 2013 may look like – 50 Lakh crore investment [ USD $1.25 Trillion or 60% of India's 2013 projected GDP of USD 2.06 Trillion]
    and growing at the same rate (if Modi does not become PM in 2014 because Gujaratis love this growth numbers)
    ….
    ….
    2015 will be 100 Lakh Crore+ [USD $2.5 Trillion or 100% of India's 2015 projected GDP of USD 2.5 Trillion]

    [Reply]

    Roshan Shah Reply:

    these are cooked up numbers slapped on people’s faces. Major (almost all) MoU’s are by Indian Business Houses. There was Canadian and US delegation in VGIS 2011 but you know what? They were more luring VGIS investors to invest in US and Canada – ha ha! I am sure those who attended VGIS 2011 will second this.

    [Reply]

    JSW Reply:

    are you idiot, I think you dont love india, that is why you hate modi, please support him to grow india, but if you will not support him, other people will, and he will become PM, please allow india to grow.

    [Reply]

    Roshan Shah Reply:

    A person who does not care for his Political Father – Keshubhai, Wife – Jashodaben Modi, Friend – Haren Pandya, High Court rulings, Governor and many BJP workers..do you think he has character to even serve common citizen…

    Think.. Think.. Look at him – he is just a PR Machinery – nothing else. He is running a tiger.. the moment he steps or gets pulled down, he is going to be eaten alive..his end is going to be worst.

    Let other people support him.. I don’t like any Vibrant Gujarat over hate, murders and illegal wealth. Let him at least show transparency by mandating his ministers to declare assets of themselves and their family members, children, brother/sister and their spouses.

    He is a land mafia and cleverly playing games.

    He might not have done an MoU but now Vibrant Gujarat offers free Gynec in Hospital with Mayaben Kodnani sentenced for 28 years.

    Roshan Shah Reply:

    you will laugh reading this statement of 15th August in Nadiad.. God knows where he gets all this data from!!! he he..

    “According to Modi, Gujarat alone had a share of 59 per cent of the entire job opportunities created in the country while all other States together had the share of the remaining 41 per cent.”

    6 out of every 10 Indians packing bags and moving to Gujarat to work!!!

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/states/other-states/article2359082.ece

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/roshiley Roshan Shah

    less then 5 months ago Modi who stays in Gandhinagar, Works in Gandhinagar, and mobilized entire BJP to campaign but lost Municipal elections .. http://www.indianexpress.com/news/in-reverse-swing-congress-takes-gandhinagar/779697/

    Forget 6 crore Gujaratis – talk to anyone in Sachivalay – people know what he is doing.. he is more talked about his crimes, affairs, leaving wife, autocratic rule, suppression, showing off his hoardings everywhere (govt officers obey his orders but laugh at him), talking about how he broke BJP, land scams, affinity to Adani and most importantly having uncontested bragging rights…

    The biggest mistake Modi is making is thinking people of Gujarat are stupid. Gandhinagar is just the beginning. As you said – it is a mess and yes it is a mess and once people open up their closed doors of brain washed thought process, they will know the reality that you will have to find money to pay your debts.. it is not coming from Modi’s pockets.. not questioning him will be a gross mistake.

    [Reply]

    Gaurang Vaishanv Reply:

    By any chance are you related to Shaktising Gohil or Arjun Modhwadia? If not, you should apply as their spokesperson. They have been weaving the same fantastic yarn for 10 years but without any success. So either people of Guajrat are stupid idiots who cannot see through Modi’s lies or you are a frustrated Congressi.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/roshiley Roshan Shah

    we need to come out of party politics and ideally should have new young blood.. and if we really want to elect someone – we need simple, honest, transparent, judiciary friendly leader. And Gujarat does need change – for last 20 years BJP is there – even if someone else comes for few years, we need a change – then only someone will be able to get under the hood and bring out reality of all false promises and wrong data Modi is presenting.. Till he is in office, people will be continued to be shown ‘HORSE’ for a ‘DONKEY’ and when told repeatedly number of times, everyone will start clapping and dancing and then ‘DONKEY’ will become ‘HORSE’.. This is Modi’s style!

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/roshiley Roshan Shah

    Don’t talk about my 55 crore spend on Sadbhavna, I am stuffing your mouth with Rs. 2 Cr Grant.! http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_gujarat-university-gets-rs2-05-crore-grant_1590366

    [Reply]

  • RAMACHANDRAN

    Any patriotic Indian will pray Modi rto become Pm of India. Only pro western media and power hungry dynastic parties oppose him.

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    Narendra Modi the next prime minister of india

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Advani’s Rathyatra is as selfless as Sonia declining PM post… :)

    [Reply]

  • Abu Ahmed

    There’s something known as retiring gracefully; however, for a poltician of any hue, this attribute never suits. However, I admire his stamina and will to go on with a never-say-die spirit.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.sharetipsinfo.com sharetipsinfo

    Commodity trading is gaining lot of popularity in India. MCX and NCDEX are most popular commodity exchanges of India. MCX and NCDEX both offers hi tech platform for commodity trading. Commodity trading should have clear picture like how they can earn money from ncdex or mcx trading and for that they need to track various listed commodities and should rely on research rather than speculation.

    [Reply]

  • Suman Rao

    Mr. Vinod Yadav will be the next Prime Minister of India in 2014

    [Reply]

  • Suman Rao

    Mr. Vinod Yadav will be the next Prime Minister of India in 2014

    [Reply]

  • rammann

    most abused for personal good than used for national welfare

    [Reply]

    Shazzam Reply:

    Doesnt mean that the RTI act be truncated to the advantage of corrupt political parties.
    The people who abuse blackmail the parties/bureaucrats only who got the skeletons to hide. So in the end the ruling class is the one who is getting the stick. People def need to be checked on this and its govt’s failure not to bring such ppl to light cuz they themselves will get exposed.

    [Reply]