Good cops, bad cops
Like my colleague Kushalrani Gulab, I am all set for the monsoon, too – but the rains just haven’t come.
Monsoon in Mumbai always puts me in a benign mood about the city’s cops – no, don’t laugh. They are a much maligned lot but where would we be, or rather where would I have been one really rainy day — make that two – had it not been for the humble havaldar?Before coming across these saviours I, too, had painted all the cops black – particularly since after a hard day’s work, as I was making it back home (on foot) to Colaba from Nariman Point one night, I was accosted by one who wanted to know the way to the Gateway of India. As it was close to midnight and the streets in this business district almost deserted, I thought I had had it.
But then not for nothing was I a reporter – and very thankful that my Chief Reporter had insisted that I do the crime beat for a while. So I threw names at this cop on the prowl, startled him by reaching for his buckle (for the number), guessed rightly that he was probably posted at the close-by police station and threatened to report him not just to his DCP but also the Police Commissioner (by their names).
“If nothing else, you should be suspended for sheer incompetence,” I told him. “You are a beat cop in Colaba and you don’t even know where the Gateway of India is?”
I have still not gotten over the look of sheer horror that came over his face, mixed with an emotion that looked akin to that of a hunted rabbit. He had scurried away and, before I could turn the corner, quite disappeared out of sight.
Of course, I let it go at that and did not lodge any complaint. So it came as a pleasant surprise one pouring afternoon some months later when some cops flagged down my taxi (for reasons of their own) but made sure that their work did not interfere with my travel. They were checking for pollution control and, unfortunately, my cabbie proved to be a culprit.
One constable then poked his head into the window and said, “Unfortunately, you will have to leave this cab, Ma’am. We need to take him in for action.”
I despaired at finding another cab in the rain and hated the thought of getting all wet, when the same thought occurred to him. “Hang on a minute,” he said. “I will find you another cab or else you will be left standing and soaking for no one might stop for you.” What’s more, he even held his huge police umbrella over my head, until I had got into the cab he had whistled down to a halt.
Of course, my friends did not believe that any Bombay cop could be so helpful. “You must have been dreaming,” one of my colleagues said with finality, convincing himself that that was why I had come up with such a `bizarre’ story.
He would have found the next one even more bizarre – and thought I would have had to be positively in a state of the deepest slumber, or hallucinating at the least, to have encountered another good cop.
This time, it was raining cats and dogs as I landed at the airport from New Delhi – visibility was virtually nil even at a few metres. And since Delhi had been dry as dust when I left, I, of course, had no rain gear. I was soaked by the time I got into the cab – I needed to go to Churchgate, which is nearly as far as the city goes from the airport. But this cabbie had other things on mind. Like making hay while the sun did not shine.
So he told me he did not know where Churchgate was. I was speechless.
“You will have to get out and hail another cab,” he said, in a Smart Alec-y fashion, judging my already cold misery well. I guess he expected me to double his fare for doing me the favour not turfing me out in the downpour but before I could get my tongue round the words, I had a cop knocking at the window to see why the taxi had stalled.
When I told him why, prompt was his response. “Churchgate kuthe ahe, mahit nahi ka tula? (You don’t know where Churchgate is?),” he raged at the cabbie, a North Indian, in Marathi. “Boot kadhu ka mee ata (Shall I remove my boot)?” To connect with his head, obviously!
As the by-now surly but chastened taxi driver revved up to take off, the cop banged on the door again and asked me to lower the window. He handed me his number, saying now in Hindi, “If he decides to stop anywhere but Churchgate, you call me. I will radio the nearest police station. They will come and get him.”
Needless to say, the cabbie understood. Perfectly. I got home as fast as the wet roads would allow. And he settled for just the metered fare.
It was a small thing to do in a silly matter but I thought that cop had done more than just his duty — in fact, gone out of his way to be helpful. I like to think that there are many more like him around, and doing bigger things in more crucial matters. Or so many of them would not have been laying their lives down for us on 26/11 – both officers and men.
Hindustan Times


(4.75 out of 5)
Ahh..This is quite refreshing..its quite rare that you hear that Delhi cops are helpful, more often than not women in Delhi are more scared of cops that won’t walk the street
[Reply]
Sujata Anandan Reply:
June 22nd, 2009 at 1:40 pm
When I started out as a journalist, I had a choice — to work in either Delhi or Bombay. I chose Bombay. I have lived to not regret that choice!
[Reply]
Sujata, there are many many nice things I have to say about city cops - and city cabbies and auto drivers and bus conductors and random people as well. The good definitely balances the bad. DEFINITELY.
[Reply]
Sujata Anandan Reply:
June 22nd, 2009 at 1:42 pm
Absolutely. That’s why I related these stories. We tend to look upon them as villains when many of them could b heroes
[Reply]
Thanks Sujata. When most reports these days bring out the ‘not-so-nice’ role played by the police, your blog reconfirms my belief in the force. I too have been helped by cops, as I returned home from work late one night. Its sad, a few bad ones give the department a negative image.
[Reply]
Sujata Anandan Reply:
June 24th, 2009 at 3:27 pm
Yes, that’s true.That’s why its necessary to relate as many good stories as possible — it should not all always be about rogues in society
[Reply]
Sujata, it is indeed very considerate of you to talk of the good side of our cops. Agree that the cops in New Delhi are no match for ours and I think it’s a lot to do with their mind-set about women per se.
Once, my sister-in-law and I had a rather nasty experience of being eve-teased by cops in south Delhi (!). Well, my sister-in-law who was a cracker of a girl, stared down their faces till heaven come!
[Reply]
Sujata Anandan Reply:
June 26th, 2009 at 4:52 pm
Am I most thankful that life decreed that I live in a better part of the world, a better part of the countryI It is indeed the mindsets that make the difference — and more power to your sis-in-law. We should never allow them to get away wih anything if we can help it!
[Reply]
This is indeed quite a nice story. and its so clear why this is refreshing. Because, its a rare occurrence. However, its not really their fault. We should realize that after all they are human. we expect too much out of our police. For example, wouldn’t we be snappy and rude if we are put on bandobast duty for more than 12 hours, leaves canceled at the last minute, asked to face an ak-56 with a jacket that resembles a cardboard cutout of a school kid project. Just like a kindergarten school teacher cant be expected to coochie coo the kids all the time just coz they are small, the police need to be the way they are for criminals who wont take no for answers.
http://mywriterkeeda.wordpress.com
[Reply]