A breakdown of the Unbreakable



I met the newly-minted Padmashri, Carnatic singer Aruna Sairam, on Wednesday for the sole purpose of deconstructing the abhang, which she is noted for. It’s ‘a-bhang’, literally ‘the unbreakable’ in Sanskrit, Marathi and Hindi, meaning the Word of God. The abhang is the semi-classical devotional song form of the Bhakti saints of Maharashtra, using classical ragas but with its own happy mix-and-meld freedom. I thought Aruna, a Matunga girl from Amchi Mumbai, who has the hugest fan following in Carnatic and European circles would have interesting things to tell us about it.

Aruna was aglow in a pink silk sari after receiving the Padmabhushan the previous evening at Rashtrapati Bhavan.

Aruna, 55, has two daughters, both in the US. One is a software techie and married, the other works for the art dealers, Sotheby’s. Sairam, her engineer husband, recently quit his corporate job to locate with her in Chennai for the sake of her music. “He took premature voluntary retirement to support my career,” says Aruna gratefully.

The thing about Aruna is that she is a brave experimenter. She regularly draws flak from uptight purists about how she mixes compositions and shows bhava (feeling) with her body language – women singers ‘from good families’ are expected to sit trussed up tight. See her photo, left.

And yes, she DOES ‘play to the gallery’ sometimes! But when she’s singing at the Music Academy, Madras, that holy of holies, during the celebrated season of Maargazhi (the lunar calendar month of December-January) you can’t get room to stand on one leg. I’ve seen it myself. I mean, you can’t fool all the people all the time.

Aruna has made the abhang a part of regular Carnatic vocal concerts. It’s the rage in fact and other singers are picking up on it! Carnatic audiences now expect an abhang from Aruna at the end in the ‘small song’ section called ‘tukda’ … or, as Southies spell it, ‘thukkada’.

So how did Aruna tune in? It wasn’t terribly formal. She went to the JB Vachha High School in Bombay, growing up among Parsis, Maharashtrians and Gujaratis. The abhang came at her from the aab-o-hawa like a sweet drift of jasmine from a passing veni.

Importantly, Aruna listened.

During Tulasi Puja, for instance, the raamas, as workers are called locally, would gather in the alcove under the stairs and sing abhangs, keeping time with the chipla (clackers) and manjira (cymbals).

Or, while on the train from Dadar to VT, she’d hear porters of the Warkari persuasion (cult of Vithoba at Pandharpur) sing these songs.

Aruna’s Carnatic teacher, T. Brinda, a celebrated singer of devadasi descent, would come and stay two months a year in Bombay to teach Aruna.

“I grew up in the energy of Bombay and long after I was launched as a Carnatic singer, I sang an abhang at a concert in Madras…it was at the Narada Gana Sabha,” says Aruna.
(This hallowed old sabha or music society, btw, has an excellent canteen…so nice to pop out into for a kaapi, vadai-chutney or dosa when you need to refuel between long hours of listening).

The abhang Aruna sang was Pandit Bhimsen Joshi’s famous sign-off, ‘Teertha Vitthala, kshetra Vitthala’, still one of her favourites. And Madras was hooked!

Not that Madras didn’t know abhangs for the Marathas had ruled at Tanjore in Tamil Nadu and there had been much give-and take. Just as Carnatic music was influenced by the Marathi abhang, Marathi Natya Sangeet picked up several Carnatic ragas (Arabhi, Kiravani, Suddhasaveri, to name a few).

The abhang was the gift of Saint Dnyaneshwar to the world, to take the inaccessible but worthwhile message of Sanskrit scripture to the common people in simple, sincere words.

A long lineage of Maharashtrian Bhakti saints followed him, of all castes…. a beautiful free flow of thought and feeling: Namdev, Gora Kumbhar (a potter), Janabai, Bhanudasa, Saveta Maali…
The culmination of this spiritual-musical lineage was the enigmatic, intense Tukaram in the 17th century. See this website www.tukaram.com for more on this wonderful personage.

As their legacy, there are essentially three types of abhang:

  1. the total surrender to God or Sufi kind, full of adbhutam (wonder)
  2. the anecdotal kind, which tell stories or incidents from nature and scripture with a moral purpose
  3. the Gaulana, a lighter variation entirely devoted to Krishna lore. Hear Aruna sing one such abhang here: Brindavane…

What intrigued me most about the abhang was its lilting rhythm, a ‘sukhyasa tarang…Pandurang..Pandurang…’ as Tukaram put it: a ‘wave of well-being’ in saying God’s Name.

There’s usually a practical reason behind artistry, with form following function. In the abhang’s case, it’s meant to be a walking song, as Warkaris sing and walk for miles on pilgrimage to Pandharpur in Maharashtra, the centre of their cult.

So, says Aruna, the abhang is not sam on sam (with the word landing exactly on the beat of the taal) but ushi on ushi (the space between beats: the off-beat). Meaning, the entire rhythm of the abhang is off-beat even while it continuously follows the song!

Don’t you think this pattern of the ‘faithful beat’ is a fabulous metaphor for the devoted heart that beats for and towards God (Tuka calls it ‘Vitthalacha chhand’, ‘God’s metre’, a chhand is a Vedic metre).

I felt its echo in this verse by Janabai who worked as a maid in Namdev’s house and sang,

dalita kaandita tuzha gaayina ananta
na visamde kshanabhari tuzhe naamga’ murari

‘Pounding and grinding, whatever I do, my heart sings of You always; I don’t forget you even for a moment, Dear One.’

Try walking to an abhang in a steady, long-distance trot. Your feet will lift and you’ll want to dance, just like the pilgrims (I tried it at home, more like a caged beast though than a pilgrim).

And do see this moving old clip from 1936 of the film Sant Tukaram by Prabhat Films, starring Vishnupant Pagnis. It was a huge hit at home and got an award at the Venice Film Festival in 1937!

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (5 votes, average: 4.6 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Reshmi

    Hi Renuka. Things that can be discovered through you are amazing…Thanks!

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Thank you, Reshmi!

    [Reply]

  • Partho

    Hi Renuka,
    Abanga in Carnatic! I followed the link you gave and heard / saw all the other Abahgas that are loaded on youtube. It takes a bit of adjusting to listen to such a different intonation and rhythm. What one notices immediately in Smt Aruna Sairam’s rendition is the influence of North Indian techniques – for example the bol-taans used – so difrerent! I’m listening to Pandhari Nivasa as I write. Even the ‘ucchar’ of the notes is different. So one can see why ‘purists’ might fidget. lol
    Let them! Would we have seen Kuam Gandharva if the purists had had their way? So more power to Smt. Sairam, and other bravehearts of quality, I say!!!
    I love the timbre of her voice, and am captivated by the energy that she exudes. Thanks for bringing her to us all.

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Hi Partho!
    Yes indeed, interesting to think how the ‘purists’ got after Kumar Gandharva for singing Hindustani in a ‘Carnatic’ manner. The funniest thing about Southie purism is that it seems to have forgotten how new the present Carnatic concert format is.
    It was Ariyakudi Ramanuja Iyengar who rranged it 60 plus years ago. And the number of innovations in Carnatic music is amazing: Muthuswami Dikshitar’s brother introduced the Western violin into Carnatic music after hearing British bands play in Fort St George. M. Dikshitar himself spent years in Varanasi and came back with heaps of ‘HIndustani’ influences. He composed musical pieces called ‘note swaram’ (as in English musical notes!) I heard it recently after ages, played with great verve on the flute by the Sikkil Sisters and their daughter, Mala Chandrasekhar, at Thiruvaiyaru-on-Kaveri.
    And old Pattanam Subrahmanya Iyer (Pattanam means Town, meaning Madras) actually composed a skippety-hoppety raga called ‘Kathana-kuthu-kulam’ based on Western music. We’re taught a very sweet song in it (our equivalent of Carnatic 101) soon after we finish learning our scales and our First Song (to Ganesha). It’s to keep our interest going as kids before we draw a deep breath and start learning the big ragas like Todi, Kalyani, Mohanam, Shankarabharanam…damn, I sound like Gollum crooning “Precious!”

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    I have to add, the first time I heard an abhang in Carnatic was the late MS Subbulakshmi singing ‘Bhara Panduranga…”. She sang in many languages from the Bhakti bandwidth, so that’s how lots of us pipsqueaks in plaits and tunics (or shorts) first heard anything by Narsi Mehta, Meera, Guru Nanak, Chaitanya Mahaprabhu, Tukaram, Kabir….and of course the glorious company of Southie saints…it was pizza with everything on it, a big fat feast.

    [Reply]

    Partho Reply:

    Hehehe, Gollum and his unmusical prreshsiyus!
    Of course MS! Doordarshan made it possible to hear her sing Bapu’s favs with that unique treatment to the notes that only MS could (Speaking of Bapu, my eternal favourite is ‘Abide with me’ at the end of Beating The Retreat. Ah! the magic!)

    Pandit Kumar Gandharva also made it startling use of grammar to bring out the nature of a Raaga – case in point, the Hamir recording (Baithak series) with the shifted vadi; and his turning the order on its head by ending with a madhyalaya.

    BTW, even someone like Parveen Sultana has introduced South Indian Raagas: for example Ambika Sarang.

    When I read about the Kathana-kuthu-kulam bit, I got reminded of the ‘Scoth-Bhupali’ by Rabindranath Tagore (I think for ‘aami chini go chini tomaare’). Is it possible to hear the skippety-hoppity thing?

    Nirguna Reply:

    Thanks for tuning me in to Aruna Sairam of the ” Bhakti bandwidth” . Good spin :)
    Indeed,the scope for entry into Brindavan is wide and unbounded .
    Have you heard MS Subhalaxmi’s Brindavaner Lila ?

  • renuka

    Will try to find Kathanakuthuks. The geetam is ‘Raghuvamshasudhaambudichandra Shri Rama…’ ‘Rama, the moon arisen from the ambrosial sea of Raghu’s race….’
    Some of my colleagues at HT kindly hummed ‘Aami chini go chini….’ for me just now and I was told it was written by The Poet for Victoria Ocampo….I fled when they asked if I wanted to know when , why and how…

    [Reply]

  • Partho

    Thanks Renuka. I’ll look around as well…the hint on the lyrics will help.
    It is intriguing to think of a ‘fusion’ of a raaga and a western ‘tune’ because really, the melodic line can be similar in both. One would imagine that the vertical nature of Western music is impossible to ‘use’ in Raagas. The Maihar Band and Ananda Shakar have shown us the futility.

    Personally speaking, I thought Satyajit Ray did the incredible fusion – picking the harmony and the melodic line effortlessly. In a mindboggling piece of composing [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCIxBJSBqao], after the werd combo of the nagada and sitar do the war roll, he has the first and second violins do the simple folk tune in a fugue-like progression between the song and has the dotara, the sarod, the piccolo-bansuri, the cymbals, all pluck out the melody to make it sound so very Indian. Yet the arrangement is so western, so vertical.

    As for the Ocampo bit from which you (wisely) fled, I really, really, really, really doubt if someone with as feminine a sensibility like Gurudev would have romantic inclinations to this very charming young lady. Methinks, Rabindrasangeet is almost totally feminine, despite what we Bongs like saying while listening to Debabrata Biswas and his ‘martial’ Rabindrasangeet. Have you seen people dance to these songs? Good Lord!!!

    Shiva, shiva, what sacreligious thoughts!!! I will be lynched with flowers and ripe figs!!

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Hmmm…what will befall you now? But I’ve always thought of ‘Ekla chalo re’ as a personal anthem. I agree, Abide With Me, the way they play it as the finale of Beating Retreat is one of the most moving experiences in modern India’s life.
    Would like to call attention to the opening theme of the film ‘Bombay’ by AR Rahman. It kind of fulfilled my fantasy about hearing a Carnatic raga played by a Western symphony orchestra..in this case, the beautifully apt ‘Raga Huseini’ since it was a Hindu-Muslim story. Fusion at many levels…HIndu-Muslim, Western-Indian, North-South India, classical-popular…brilliant. I think it’s the best piece of music he’s made, though Roja remains a heart-stealer.

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    And I’m so glad someone else – a Bong, at that! – wasn’t thrilled by poor Ananda Shankar. I thought that kind of ’school pageant’ dance quite wimpy but when I ventured an opinion way back, a number of bhaari hastis jumped on my head and said I was a “Carnatic snob” which I so am not. .I mean, it was just a regular reaction and I am in fact persona non grata with half the dancers around for saying that the emperor has no clothes….wotthehell

    [Reply]

    scio amo Reply:

    lololol good point, partho ……inspite of so many boudi rumors etc, tagore’s s most moving songs all seem to be addressed to a male beloved, and not to charming young ladies…
    ahem…r u thinking what i am thinking? ahemmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm lol

    [Reply]

  • Anil

    Thanks for the fantastic link. I was reading the comments on the rendition by Aruna. One such comment said that the abhang is pur maratti. This reminded me of one such inconsequential heated discussion whether ‘Vittal’ was a Kannadiga, Maratti or Telegu. Such meaningless discussions can occur only in Pune. It followed a fantastic rendition of ‘Kanada Vittalu’ abhang by none other than Pt Bhimsen Joshi. But I must say there are battery of Carnatic Musicians who give some very soul full bhajans and abhangs. Besides incomparable MS, Balamuralikrishana is one such great artist.
    I would also like you to have dekho at two fantastic young artists, Prathamesh Laghate of Ratnagiri and Kartiki Gaekwad of Alandi on youtube (SRGMP lil champs edition). Both of them are not even 12 years of age They can’t speak proper hindi or english and I am not sure whether they understand the soul of these stanzas. Their rendition of these abhangs is amazing. You may dance like a beast, but you know when you listen to these abhangs you have experienced something which cannot be described by words.

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    As a comment on one of the Tukaram song links went, “Tears in my eyes… Jai Panduranga!” It gives me a great sense of rightness to hear an abhang because it is so democratic and yet so personal, so community and so individual. But philosophical and political heaven apart, it’s just lovely music and words. Will hear Prathamesh and Kartiki, thanks.

    [Reply]

  • lathasridar

    Dear Renuka,
    Thanks for all this information. I think it was in the 1990s when most of my friends who had finished their basic Carnatic training decided to learn abhangas for advanced music training. But Abhangas were always a part of the Bhajan Paddati . My father’s grandfather had started a Bhajana Mandal in a village in Palghat and as a child my father would sing me one Bhajan , it went Dhimmikit Dhimmikit Nache Mridunga Brahma Naach Kari Gajanana…..

    And just this year during the Tamil month of Marghazhi we had a Bhajan Utsav near home and I heard someone sing this Abhang. But to hear Abhangs you must go to a village in Maharashtra and hear the villagers sing in their rustic voice. That shruti range and feeling can not be reached by any professional. I had this experience when we went to a beach resort near Kihim and we went to the local temple. It was a typical small village temple made of stone and their Bhajan rendition was out of this world. I wish to go to Pandharpur once to hear the Varkaris sing Abhangs before the Lord

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Hi Nirguna, no I haven’t! Or if I have, I don’t recall it…tks, will hunt it up.
    Partho mentioned Parveen Sultana….
    I cherish her ‘Bhavani Dayaani,,,’ as one of the best things I’ve heard in my life. If bestows darshan of Devi the way she sings it, with such skill and such bhava…too beautiful…..do hear it if u haven’t, everyone…

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Hi Latha.
    What if buildings and colonies revived Bhajan Utsavs maybe on Independence Day and Rebulic Day or just any non-denominational day, where all religions could participate in any language,,,Christian hymns, Gurbani, Sufiana…Quranic recitations of select suras,,,there are seven ways to recite the Holy Quran and three ragas are distinctly present in it….Bhairavi, Bhairav and Kalaangra (the ‘Arabic Bhairavi’)…and of course the rest of the God gang…wouldn’t it be lovely?
    ‘Bhajan’ merely means ‘a song that seeks God’, right? So nobody neeed worry that they are being shirk or blasphemous by joining in.
    musicians don’t anyway, but it would be nice to work it at our everyday level today…

    [Reply]

  • V.B.N.Ram

    Aruna Sairam’s voice carries divine vibrations from the core of her heart.
    As regards the two systems , namely Karnataka and Hindustani , Vani Bai Ram ( my late mother , writing in her seminal treatise ” The Giimpses of Indian Music ” states ” Till the 13th century AD, we find there was only a single system. There was no literature as Hindustani music. Then came into force the Persians and Afghans and they began to persue along new channels, which later came to be known as the Hindustani system. The ancient music which was current then ( in the North ) had almost vanished and in its place, this high class mixture of Persian and other external styles introduced. Further more the Moghul rule provided state patronage to this music form ” This view coincides with scholars such as the late Pandit Ratanjhankar of the Morris College of Music Lucknow. ( one of Vani’s guru ) and the late Dr. P. Sambamoorthy ( formerly Professor and Head of the Music department of Madras University ) and M Ananthasayanam Ayyangar ( an acknowledged authority on the subject )
    How ever Vani Bai Ram was one of the first strong advocates of bringing about a fusion among the two systems of music, as she always was between any systems of music , which lent themselves to such fusion. With her vast knowledge of not only the above two systems, but also western music, she was quite competent to make such an asessment

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted renuka

    Please share the details of her book (title, publisher, year, etc)?

    I’ve seen the books by Pt Ratanjankar and Prof. Sambamoorthy. But the only Anantasayanam Ayyangar I’ve heard of was the Speaker of the first Lok Sabha (I think!). So pls tell more? Tks

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted renuka

    PS! Somebody just called to ask about the abhang influence on Carnatic music. Two examples that Aruna feels might answer, both by no less than Saint Thyagaraja, composed in Telugu:

    1. Teliyaleru Rama bhaktimargamunu…in Raga Dhenuka, set to Deshaadi tala
    2.Girirajasuta tanaya sadaya… (to Ganesha) in Raga Bangaala (from old Shankarabharanam) …also in Deshaadi

    The names ‘Bangaala’ and ‘Deshaadi’ are interesting clues, aren’t they, to the cross-regional and folk-classical give and take?
    For those who heard TM Krishna in Nehru Park in Delhi recently in Bhakti Utsav: remember, ‘Teliyaleru Rama’ was what he began with?
    And in all this about the Bhajana Sampradaya (tradition of bhajans) , let’s not forget to kowtow to the Big Daddy, Saint Purandaradasa, of what is now Karnataka: he’s up there as the ‘Karnataka Sangita Pitamaha’ and did lots for the Bhajana Sampradaya..

    [Reply]

  • V.B.N.Ram

    Renuka ji, the details you wanted to know are given below:
    The book ” Glimpses of Indian Music ” was written and published by Kitab Mehal Private Limited Allahabad in 1961. It continued to be published for a few editions, till the time the publishers closed down. The introduction to the book has been given by M Ananthasayanam Ayyangar ( the then Lok Sabha Speaker, as correctly mentioned by you ) The forward was given by Mr.B.V.Keskar , the then Minister for Information and Broadcasting. Prof P. Sambamoorthy , has also offered his comments.
    There are two gold medals , which the University of Delhi has instituted in memory of the author. These two are given to the most outstanding student of M.A. in Hindustani Music, as also the most outstanding student of Karnatak Music in MA. For a long time , the referred book was also being given along with the medals. For Vani Bai Ram , music was a passion. She had a melodious voice and taught the subject. For several decades she was with the All India Radio, and conceptualised the Bhaktti Sangeet ka karikran ” Vandana ” Some of her most popular songs, including Tyagaraja Kritis have been preserved by the archives of the All India Radio. As a matter of interest, the late Sarojini Naidu, who was a family friend, used to get enthralled by her soul stirring music.

    [Reply]

  • V.B.N.Ram

    The first sentence above should read , the book was written by Vani Bai Ram and published by…….
    Sorry for the oversight

    [Reply]