The Golden Gayatri



A beautiful, well-dressed young woman with four lustrous braids, to whose words two celestial birds in a tree listen attentively… That’s how the old Sanskrit verse makes an elegant mind-picture of the Vedas:

chatush kaparda yuvati supesha
kruta prateeka vayanani vaste
tasya suparna vrushana nishedaduhu

The four braids of course denote the four Vedas, personified as adorning an eternally fresh and bright young woman, whose highly attractive wisdom wings through the ages for all time. Such a dazzling vision…how can one not like the ancients, at least for their apt ways with mind-pictures?

It’s like by their words shall you know them, isn’t it? The ancient Hindus left few other clues. They seem to have condensed their thoughts into riddles. It’s the stuff they leave unsaid that offers endless interpretative scope, just like a line of song in our classical dance which the singer repeats while the dancer uses it to tell many stories.

Yamini Krishnamurti charms anew on Monday in Delhi with her frank, humorous view of existence and her utter confidence as a divine diva. All the teens and 20-somethings gasped when they saw the videos of her dancing in her prime. (Photo by Jasjeet Plaha)

Past perfect: Yamini Krishnamurti charms anew on Monday in Delhi with her frank, humorous view of existence and her utter confidence as a divine diva. All the teens and 20-somethings gasped when they saw the videos of her dancing in her prime. (Photo by Jasjeet Plaha)

As to which, I had the incredible good fortune this Monday of hearing modern India’s greatest ever dancer (other dancers say it, too!), Yamini Krishnamurti, screen a couple of her old videos and answer questions in an open chat at the India Habitat Centre. The mood was beautiful with young dancers, critics and older people who remembered her glory days. Said Romi Chopra, a Delhi aesthete, “We in Delhi knew nothing about Bharata Natyam and Kuchipudi, but Yamini was our turning point. She took us right up to the gods and we were hooked to Indian classical dance.”

Writer RK Lakshman said after watching her dance “Lalite simhaasana-sthite” (“O Tender Goddess on Your Lion Throne”) about Devi that “It was as though Devi herself had descended.” I saw this note written in the early 70s, rootling around in one of Yaminiji’s old files.

That’s because I interviewed her for one whole year, dug around her papers and wrote her life story for her (Viking, 1993). It was their first artiste’s bio and it was at Khushwant Singh’s behest that we connected.

But we had a history already, besides her knowing my mother back in the year dot.

Though my mother had been a dancer and taught me my first steps, and I was taking Bharata Natyam lessons in Bombay then, Yamini was the first dancer I “saw” properly in my “conscious” life. It was as a little girl when she danced in Bombay, this blue flame moving with such smooth energy, those luminous arms moving like butter, lifting in perfect arcs. (I think it was the sheer beauty of her movement that overcame me. Like, I am not into cricket but I remember stopping despite that to watch oldtime spin bowler Waqar Yunus run up to bowl on TV in someone’s house because he ran with such grace).

Yamini K was the person who dusted the mud off Kuchipudi and put it on the national and international map from the 1960s. The Italians in particular loved its operatic nature.

Sringara in Kuchipudi: Yamini K was the person who dusted the mud off Kuchipudi and put it on the national and international map from the 1960s. The Italians in particular loved its operatic nature.

Watching Yamini, I believe I clawed my mother’s arm without realizing it for I was that mersmerised. And she bore it patiently like Karna bore the insect-bite because she saw that her daughter was in the total grip of magic and couldn’t bear to break the spell. I lost my mother some years later and consequently built a private shrine to Indian classical dance in my heart.

Knowing how catty the scene had become, I refused to write on dance for years, resisted critic Sunil Kothari’s offer to set me up as the Times of India’s dance critic in 1992 and even the offer by the late Mr Pattabhiraman, founder of the highly-esteemed “Sruti” magazine (Chennai) to write on dance from Delhi.

But there was no way I could resist doing the Yamini book. (And then the dance caught up with me finally as a journalist in The Indian Express, where I had to become Arts Editor, and again in the gigantic paper that is HT).

To see Yamini dance and delve into her amazingly focused life (she burnt herself like camphor for the dance) is to realise the real wealth of India. North India adored her through the 60s, 70s and 80s and openly acknowledged that it received a lost part of its soul back from her.

Her erudite father would introduce the dance thrillingly, her sister Jyotishmati would sing and Yamini would dance, with a well-synched team of musicians. She danced every year at the Ashoka Hotel in Delhi and only for her shows would the huge convention hall be thrown fully open and was packed from the first row to the last (otherwise its gigantic side spaces were partitioned off).

the Vedic seers described the dawn in the Rig Veda as a radiant, exquisite and unmatchable beauty...and Yamini was the first to dance to Vedic hymns.

As Usha, deity of dawn, in a 'Vedic Ballet': the Vedic seers described the dawn in the Rig Veda as a radiant, exquisite and unmatchable beauty...and Yamini was the first to dance to Vedic hymns.

Yamini made history as the first person to dance Vedic hymns and slokas and put them into the public domain for all to experience.

It tied in perfectly with their purpose as instruments of general good.

Take  the Gayatri Mantra. Its sadhana or practice is supposed to lift sorrow and benefit both the individual and society at large. Each syllable in it is a “palimpsest” – bunch of layers – of meaning.

So what are its benefits, according to that otherwise unlovely creature, Manu? He says that of all the mantras, there is none to match the Gayatri.

A person who recites this mantra regularly cannot be cowed down by any threat. Nor is this person scared of kings (those in power), asuras (those stronger), rakshasas (malefic forces), fire, water, air or snakes.

Manu also upholds that a person who makes the Gayatri part of his life (and we now add “her”) will become Brahma himself. The house in which the Gayatri is a habit will never catch fire and its children will never die. Let’s try to figure this out, knowing what we know about how our ancients think cryptically!

Yamini says she loved the tribhanga (three angles to the body) stance typical of this dance, it made her feel like a sculpture stepping off the walls of a temple and dancing for God!

Made dizzy by Odissi: Yamini says she loved the 'tribhanga' (three angles to the body) stance typical of this dance, it made her feel like a sculpture stepping off the walls of a temple and dancing for God!

Obviously, it’s daft to take these observations literally. Mere mortals do not become Lord Brahma. Nor is there any physical guarantee possible for either property or life. So what could Mr Manu possibly mean?

Let’s look at the Gayatri itself.

Tat savitur vareniyam bhargo devasya dhi mahi dhiyo yo na prachodayat

“That Sun, who inspires our minds to action, we mediate on that luminous creator.”

In modern words, surely it means our lives happen through our mental attitude? A positive attitude will help us transform “bad” luck into “good” luck. See the Pushkara Mahatmayam, the legend of Pushkar in Rajasthan, which is famous as North India’s only living temple to Brahma (the South has Uttara-Ramar-kovil).

In the Pushkara Mahatmyam, Brahma conducts a big yagnya or sacrifice for the world’s well-being. But several times, something goes wrong to mar its successful completion. But each time there’s a problem, Brahma uses the opportunity to create something else, including, by the way, the Gayatri. Thus, by positive thinking, our personalities (“houses”) will never be destroyed. Nor will our dreams (mind-born “children”) ever die. Isn’t that supposed to keep life fresh and interesting?

The Mahabharata, a war book, says that reciting Gayatri establishes peace in society. It figures. Chilled-out individuals don’t quarrel. They prefer conflict management and resolution.

Truly, there’s a coded lesson in there if we find it, in fact how else could the ancients pass on values except through stocking fabulous stories in mental libraries?

It was Brahma, by the way, who is said to have culled the essence of the four Vedas into the  “Natya Shastra” (Principles of Theatre) from which our classical dance comes, just as our classical music comes from the Sama Veda chants (the Saman is the Rig Veda set to music).

He did so, says Bharata Muni, who put the Natya Shastra together, “For the upliftment and betterment of all people.” So Yamini and India were being true to themselves and their ancient rhythms when they put select Vedic shlokas out for all.

And Brahma seems to have invented the Gayatri bang in the midst of a serious yagna-breakdown at Pushkar just to give us this important lifecode:

“When life hands you lemons, make lemonade!”

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (8 votes, average: 4.75 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Anil

    A very nostalgic peice on Yamini an institution in itself. Digressing a bit from the blog with your reference to Mahabharatha, I am surprised that why these legends don’t portray Draupadi in their theme. I would rate Draupadi above Seetha or Savithri. She had the audacity to tick off Bhishmacharya when he was lying on his death bed (arrows) and that too scornfully. To think that Mahabharatha ended with Draupadi having a shampoo with Duryodhans blood !!

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    U r right…I hv to write my feelings about Draupadi and get everybody’s thoughts on her…she deserves some kind of Eternity Medal. She’s listed in the Pancha Vama, the five ideal women, along with Satyabhama, Savitri, Tara and Mandodari.
    I hv to confess I couldn’t help snickering when I saw rome really fat dancers trying to look oomphy as the ‘Paanch Kanya’. I thought it should’ve been ‘Paunch Kanya’, because, dash it all, the body IS the metier for dance.

    [Reply]

    Partho Reply:

    Would it be Kunti and not Satyabhama?

    [Reply]

    snigdha Reply:

    Aren’t Panch Kanyas Ahilya, Kunti, Draupadi,Mandodri and Tara ?

    renuka Reply:

    Yeah, there seem to be regional variations, like pizza topping.

    [Reply]

  • Anil

    I am sorry for the above digression. Delhi in sixties and early seveties had a very good Indian classical music and dance scene. One of the most popular one was the Vishnu Digamber Jayanti started by late Pt Vinay Chandra Mudgal. I was in my teens. At that point I don’t remember anyone including Yamini dancing only for one hour or one and half hours. It would be an insult if an artist was asked to sing raag bharavi after 45 minutes of performance. Most of her performances would peak only after 30 to 35 minutes of dancing. True with every artist. Her performances whether invitational or by tickets were house full. And to think that the news travelled by word of mouth. Best transportation was ‘eleven’ or ‘gyarah’ number bus. No one complained of traffic woes. Not difficult to sneak in Ashoka hotel too. Rightly put she introduced the southern form of classical music to north. Poineering work by her. a favourite of Pandit Nehru too.

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Eeks, just got a call from a cross cricket -crazy person. Though I went all the way to check with the Sports Dept I still managed to get it wrong: it’s Waqar Younis, not Younus, and he was a pace bowler, not a spin bowler. Me and cricket: taal mein nahin hain, kya karein?

    [Reply]

  • Samar Halarnkar

    Great blog as always. But I really like the effort you’re putting into getting photos in — makes a big difference.

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Thank you. Had to share Y’s lovely pix!

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted renuka

    Glad u have those memories. It was very touching on Monday evening to see young people crowding around her afterwards. Young Sharanya Chandran, a dancer herself, just out of LSR and accepted now in LSE, told me, “What a goddess!”

    [Reply]

    richa Reply:

    is there a good book where i can read all this? About hidden codes in various hindu religious stories?

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Not in one place, alas. I often hv to try my own code-cracking. Name a couple of things u r interested in and i’ll try to get you the answers.

    [Reply]

  • Tamizh Penn

    Hey Renuka
    Lovely post. The fact that Brahma created the Gayatri under these circumstances in Pushkar was a revelation. In the south, women don’t recite the Gayatri – any idea where that is written- perhaps our man Manu?- also, the Gayatri is supposed to be such a powerful, rahasya mantra that it is not supposed to be uttered aloud. A south indian man I know who came to Delhi after many years of living abroad was shocked to find the Gayatri blaring from grocery stores.

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Hey Tamizh Penn! Cool name (it means ‘Tamil Girl’, guys, in Tamil of course, haha).
    Traditionally women stopped reciting the Gayatri, though it’s a female personification.. Hv u ever heard of such a foolish thing as not letting the women say it? Now they do. Yes it was a secret mantra and it’s still whispered under the cloth into an initiate’s ear when he gets to wear a sacred thread.

    I think the last laydiss to get a sacred thread in ancient India was the hot Rishini Gargi, who had a big public spat with that bully Rishi Yajnavalkya in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad.
    .
    At one level i’m glad the Gayatri’s out in the open (thanks to Swami Dayanand Saraswati and the Arya Samaj). But I hv to say it sounds very tacky if some high-pitched sugary sweet female voice sings it in a filmi way. Gayatri is pure class. Wish they’d keep her that way, though again, everybody’s got to get to their own understanding of Gayatri.

    btw, it’s also the name of an ancient Vedic chhand (poetic meter), like Tristhup, Anusthup, Jagati…. The very first sukta (hymn) in the Rig Veda is in the Gayatri chhand:
    Agnim eeley purohitaam…addressed to Agni. So fascinating that agni is cognate with Latin ‘ignis’, from which we get words like ignite, ignition…
    Anyway, Rig Veda 1:1 (Agnim eeley purohtiam…) was composed by Rishi Madhuchhandas (Sweet Meter), sounds like ‘Dance With Wolves’ or ‘Laughing Water’ , no?

    [Reply]

    Anil Reply:

    In Pune there is a society where all women priests are there. There are more than two to three hundred women priests performing all vedic rites. They are performing all ceremonies from thread ceremony to marriage and even last rites. This was inspite of vehement opposition from the Shankaracharyas of all four peeths. You are absolutely right that they have to be recited in proper vedic chhand. These priestess are doing exactly that way. The beauty is that they are keeping the rituals short and sweet. For the benefits of some one who doesn’t know sanskrit there is some one to translate it for you in English !

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Yes indeed, you can be trained as a woman priest in Coimbatore and Nagpur. Guess who first told me about it though, with total approval? Sri Jayendra Saraswati, Shankaracharya of Kanchipuram!

  • angad lamba

    well done Renuka
    keep it up

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Tks, Angad. You hv a fabulous name, ‘Guru Angad’.

    [Reply]

  • Tamizh Penn

    Everyone, read this article in Mint on the Pune women purohits.

    http://blogs.livemint.com/blogs/from_the_beat/archive/2009/03/08/women-god-and-a-job.aspx

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Lovely story by Sudha. Missed it, I was revving to go south. Tks for sharing, Tamizh Penn, it makes me want to take a sabbatical and go to Pune.

    [Reply]

    Anil Reply:

    Whenever you plan to go to Pune I suggsest do visit Cafe Good Luck at Deccan Gymkhana. Nothing new for people who have lived in Mumbai, Surat or Ahmadabad. It is the only Irani restaurant running in Pune. Almost hundred years old. A masala chai with Boon Maska and double omelttte (optional). A portion is still having old furniture, almost heritage value. Sabbatical is much easier when the digestive juices have been taken care off. Another tip. Sadashiv Peth where this movement started, is full of ‘Cobras’. (Cocanasth Brahmins). you may get some spritiual tips but I would consider you lucky if you are offered a glass of water !

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Tks for the nice tips..I remember those lovely Shrewsbury biscuits from Kayani’s that friends would bring.. I used to like Irani cafes, their elegant, thin-crust samosas that I ate in Pyrke’s, was it, in Bombay. And guess where I found them again? In the town of Arcot, three years ago, when I was on the way from Chennai to Kalavai (past the turn to Kanchipuram) deep in the countryside, to catch up with the Shankaracharyas. Oh dear. Feeling hungry suddenly for a Britannia ‘Iranian Berry Pulao’ at Fort, Bombay.
    Cobras? Konkanastha Brahmins? Goodness. The few I’ve met seemed quite cuddly. Never been to Sadashiv Peth, tsala, baghu…

    lathasridar Reply:

    Dear Renuka,

    Thank you everyone for jogging my memory but the dancer I had in mind was Chitra Visweswaran and her husband. I remember the song was Krishna Nee Begane Baro (which means Krishna please come fast). Renuka as a child I would feel the grand Upanayana was a waste because most of my cousins would not do their Sandhyas. But now I know it is not just a caste symbol but the mantras have a much deeper meaning. My son is spiritually inclined having watched his grandfather do his Siva pooja. At 3 he could recite the Siva Manasa pooja without being specifically taught. So I thought if I perform his Upanayana it will further his spiritual pursuits. More so I have heard with regular practice the practitioner becomes more confident. He is now 9 when he was 6 he was down with Guillan Barre . Through sheer will power he has totally recovered, but a little negative criticism from his peers and he gets upset. Sometime back I had talked to you about Sirkali Chattanathan Swamy. Well both of us had during this phase prayed to him. I hope the Lord gives him emotional strength also the way he gave him the will power to get on his feet.

  • AKGURTOO

    WHY? INDEED Y???
    B’CAUSE SHE IS A ( I BELEIVE) A HINDU??? OR IS SHE!!! & IN HINDU-STHAN THAT IS INDIA!!!

    [Reply]

  • anurag dutt

    Hi Renuka,
    Congrats for another great post.

    You rightly mentioned that Gayatri is such a powerful Mantra that reciting the mantra is supposed keep off every trouble .Even the starting Word “OM” is such a powerful word that it gives you a ceratin amout of possitiveness when you feel like that you are in trouble and you tend to start some work.I dont know if i am wrong or right but it is said that even “OM” word in the starting of the Mantra has got many layers of meaning.

    As you mentioned about Yamini in the post i was thinking about how we are forced with n number of Dancing shows in TV and the wastage of time .

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Tks Anurag.
    I agree about TV dance coverage. I think DD has been singlehandedly responsible for killing off the interest of an entire Indian gen with its tacky shows. Lots of undeserving people got onto the National Programme thru pull or ‘jack’ as Delhi slang calls it. Also, the magic league is in short supply. You hv lots of dancers but they have to feel things deeply inside first to be able to reach out and touch us, yank us by the scruff of our neck into the forcefield they are meant to create as soloists (it’s called Ekahaarya).
    You can’t fool the public. My fave true incident is when the Germans were dancing a bit from the ballet Swan Lake in Siri Fort Audi, Delhi. Their precision was perfect but they had zero feeling. Suddenly I heard a big Sardarji say scornfully, “O yaar, Russian kinne changge sigge!” – How good the Russians were!
    He’d obviously seen the fabulous Kirov Ballet earlier that year in Delhi, the lyrical Russian movements..we, as I always say, are a singing, dancing nation. We don’t need to understand every word and movement, but we can relate to even an unfamiliar thing if it’s sincere, we can tell quality, when someone is doing something jaan lagaa ke. That’s why Yaminiji triumphed. And she attacked her audiences with hardcore classicism at that! Do go see Sujata Mahapatra and Bijayini Satpathy in Odissi, they’re in super form!
    Let’s see what our dance destiny has in store… our classical music scene is fantastic, lots of young, brilliant singers especially…if we’re lucky, we have years of great listening ahead.

    [Reply]

  • lathasridar

    Dear Renuka,

    My exposure to dance has been some shows at Shanmukhananda Hall ,Mumbai . It was in the 1990s. None of the dancers then are seen now, there was this dancer couple the husband would sing and the wife dance. He was such a soulful singer. I can’t get their name. Unfortunately I have not learnt dancing so I couldn’t fully appreciate the technicalities but I enjoyed the bhavas expressed. I still remember my friend Aparna at school who had decided at 13 that she would go to Rukmini Arundale’s school at Chennai to learn dance. I still remember that she would walk gracefully like a dancer and she would always stand in a Tribhanga pose.

    Could you tell us some more about the Gayatri mantra. I have seen the Gayatri devi photos. Is there a legend ? I am planning my son’s Upanayana next month so I searched the net for the meaning of Upanayana ceremony. There are people performing the Upanayana for their daughters. As a child I remember being annoyed by the huge amount of money spent on Upanayanas for my cousins and obviously none of them perform their Sandhyas. I hope I can motivate my son enough to do his Sandhyas.

    [Reply]

    Partho Reply:

    Hi lathasridar,
    It could have been Sanjukta and Raghunath Panigrahi. They were divine.

    I actually have very fond memories of Doordarshan and the National program of Dance and Music. The early grounding that I have had for our musical heritage has been in a large way moulded by Doordarshan (and also by being in Maharashtra). I remember watching Yaminiji and later Mallika Sarukkai. It was the only place that I’ve ever seen Mohiniattam, Manipuri and Pung Cholam. How I wish we could again see these on a weekly basis! The youngsters nowadays are brimming with confidence and would take to the brilliance in our culture with even more enthusiasm if they get to see and hear them more often.

    I agree with Renuka’s assertion that the future of classical music is indeed rosy. Often one hears how things are going from bad to worse and that the youth nowadays are ‘bhasht’. Au contraire! I believe that this generation is brilliant – confident, unapologetic, communicative and not afraid of failure.

    [Reply]

    renuka Reply:

    Panigrahis, I’m sure, if it was Odissi. It’s indeed interesting to see what dancers like Alarmel Valli, Malavika Sarukkai, Leela Samson and Priyadarshini Govind do in Bharata Natyam. I don’t always ‘agree’ but it’s interesting nevertheless, keeps the flow moving…there are lovely moments often, like a gift.
    I’ve noticed we have a tendency to ‘rank’ dancers and musicians, like right now you hear loyalists of TM Krishna and Sanjay Subrahmaniam (both Carnatic vocal) say this and that.
    My own feeling is that it’s like apples and oranges, each person has something to them that we enjoy, we can enjoy experiencing all of them as our rightful variety…and rightfully react if it’s not happening for us…
    of course, when someone like Yaminiji made a quantum leap it put them self-evidently ‘up there’…and Swapnasundari for instance was amazing to watch when she first burst upon the Kuchipudi scene back then, so beautiful and intelligent and with such a strong sense of music. I guess we have to see who leaps into the magic league of this millennium

    [Reply]

    Partho Reply:

    Malavika, of course!! Thanks Renuka. I must have morphed Sarabhai with Sarukkai in my mind. Sacrilege!
    Swapnasundari – the first time I saw her dance, the annoying announcer was reading off stuff and then said, ‘Swapnasundari’. I couldn’t help chuckling; who could have a name like that? But then I saw her – no name could have been more apt. There was something bewitching about her in those early years

    Renuka, what is your take on Chandralekha’s contribution to dance?

    renuka Reply:

    Latha, I will give Dikshitar a call. I have mixed feelings about the thread ceremony. Wish it were not limited to three castes and only to men, wish it could be modernised for those who would like to keep the philosophical meaning but don’t want an empty ritual. Our cousins, the Parsis, do the navjot (their upanayanam) for both sons and daughters and they really seem to value it. A Parsi friend would swear by his ‘kusti’ (sacred thread) and say ‘kusti promise!’ to me if I disbelieved something he said.

    As for Gayatri’s picture, I believe my great-grandfather, TS Narayana Shastri was the first to commission a Tanjore-style painting of Gayatri according to his specifications in the late 19th century. Our family broke up and many precious things I’m told, went here and there. I was taken to see this painting one summer in somebody’s puja room in the grounds of the Theosophical Society, Madras. Can’t even recall who now and the great-aunts and aunts who knew these things are dead. I’m wondering, myself…just have this blur in my head of a large splendid painting and many rings, I think, around ‘Gayatri Devi’, I do recall she had a lovely face.
    It was considered a big thing that old gramps had this ecstatic ‘vision’ of Gayatri and rushed to have it painted with goldleaf and gesso work for his puja room.
    But I was too young and stupid to realise what I was seeing!
    So what, let someone today make a wonderful new picture, the mantra is the thing.

    [Reply]

  • Mukesh

    Thanks Renukaji for the lovely post. I can’t seem to have enough of your blogs and articles. Yesterday’s faithscape was also great. Kudos to other commentators for enriching the piece.. it is developing like our ‘dharohar’…

    [Reply]

  • renuka

    Thanks so much…dharohar..amaanat.. such lovely words.
    Chandralekha? I liked her boldness as an attitude, in trying to ‘deconstruct’ Bharata Natyam. It was very refreshing initially, an antidote to fat, smug conventional dancers (of whom there were/are many).
    I liked her geometric sweeps of group choreography using Bharata Natyam adavus (sequences of steps).
    But the dance is constructed as a vehicle for ‘narrative’, the jathis ( the pure dance ‘paragraphs’ punctuating a varnam, for example) are like in-built ‘item numbers’ if I can put it that way.
    so when C did away with ‘narrative’ , I feel the dance didn’t support her. It got pretty boring and repetitive. ‘Leelavathi’ (on Bhaskarachary’s Beeja Ganita was her nicest, I thought, because it had the most story-telling).
    Also, the fell influence of German choreographer PIna Bausch on C’s work: Ayyo! Ayyayyo! That grimness. Like taking the anklets off dancing feet and putting lead boots on them. We don’t have Holocaust guilt, our dance is coming from a different place, it just didn’t work, for me at any rate.
    .
    I think she was right to experiment and people should go on experimenting, but there’s so much to learn and tell from the regular stuff or margam anyway, that experimenting should go on alongside in case it strikes gold, it can’t be a ’substitute’ …it’s nowhere near that solidity and subtlety. Mostly it’s been cut-and-paste from regular B’Nat.

    btw, wish somebody would write more modern padams and javalis (love songs), it’s really hard to relate to some of those feeble heroines, always ‘going for the burn’ with ‘virahagni’ (the fires of separation)! I find myself muttering, “Get a life, girl”
    And a good, toned bod is a must….it’s DANCE. Who can bear to see a fat (or anorexic) dancer unless somehow, she’s got some amazing mystique that transcends disproportion? Don’t know anybody like that today. Do you?

    [Reply]

    Partho Reply:

    Unfortunately none that I can remember except for the excellent newcomers in the Odissi scene. Apparently there are schools in Canada and the US churning out skilled performers. The two reports (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/21/arts/dance/21batt.html?pagewanted=1&sq=indian%20dance&st=cse&scp=21) (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/25/arts/dance/25batt.html?_r=1&pagewanted=1&sq=indian%20dance&st=cse&scp=26) attached here seem to indicate that.

    Another point: One notices many more male dancers nowadays, something that is obliquely hinted at in these reports. I wonder why? Maybe there is finally some acceptance in defining and communicating sexuality. One is not suggesting that all male dancers are gay. However, if they are, they now seem unafraid to be the focus. Do you think we are seeing a revolution there? I think we have reached the tipping point as far as expressing womanhood is concerned – the pink chaddi campaign is a small but valuable indicator to public expectations. I guess we are not quite there with sexuality yet…

    But we digress. The point I wanted to make was: despite the considerable expertise shown by the male dancers, somehow they seem contrived when doing B’natyam or Odissi or Kuchipudi (Raja & Radha Reddy exempted!). Half the time they impersonate women. Or maybe our nrittya is loaded in favour of the laasya? It looks odd. It does not fit. On the other hand, it fits when men dance to Chhau and Pung Cholam and Kathakali. Am I being biased?

    The last point you make about the good toned bod – well maybe both men and women dancers need to remember this! Alas!

    [Reply]

  • V.B.N.Ram

    Yamini enthralls her audiences. I am not much drawn to many classical dance forms, save Kuchupudi, Odissi and to a lesser extent Kathak. I was almost cajoled on many occasions, by my late mother ( formerly the Deputy Chief Producer of Music AIR handling both the north Indian as well as the Karnatic systems ) to accompany her for Yamini performances, I would almost always oblige her -to remain her good son. I however, never regretted having done so , since I could delve deep into Indian culture, as well enjoy the melodious accompanying music

    [Reply]

  • Anil

    What is your opinion about Sonal Mansingh. What grace, elegance. What a come back after such a horrible autobahn accident at Munich. Her gorgeous eyes, swan like movements, those bhavs and mudras. She just walks into your heart through her dance. Jaya and Vanashree Rama Rao is another cute couple.Raja Radha Reddys. Madhavi Mudgal is one very under rated dansue. Controversisial late Protima Bedi. List is endless. The credit however of introducing southern classical dance to north Indians goes to Yamini alone. The only other exposure to southern classical dance was through the Bollywood movies (Ragini Padmini sisters and Vyajanthi Mala) Great dancers. But filmy exposure. I would go the extent of saying that the north Indian kathak got respectabilty simultaneously, which otherwise was confined to royal courts of Avadh. But that’s another story.

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted renuka

    You sound like a very committed and focused family. Parenting is total heartbreak I think if even a little thing goes wrong with a child. But you’re right, the mantras flood you with energy if you approach them with respect. It’s an anugraham or inayat to be able to tune in and if your boy is able to do that already, he sounds blessed. Every good wish and prayer, Latha, that he will be fine and so will you. Please look after yourself nicely.

    [Reply]

  • pradeep rao

    My closest friend had lost his father, after a prolonged illness. We went for the funeral and all his village had come. They are a community of rajputs, land-owners of Delhi, desendants of the Chauhans and Tomars ( Tanvars) the dynasty that ruled Delhi before the Turkish conquest. Tall, square-jawed men with muscular arms, farmers and soldiers, they are not a flabby puja-paath community like the south of vindhyan one I belong too – yet as they performed the final rites around the flames, the whole community recited what connects us sons of manu so viscerally – the most sacred mantra in Hinduism, the Golden Gayatri as you so rightly phrase it . It was very moving.

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted renuka

    sons of manu! I don’t mean to sound rude about anybody’s father’s funeral. I respect that. And I love the Gayatri or I wouldn’t have written a paean about this mantra.
    But when you say ’sons of manu’ in that nostalgic way, I, as a woman, say, ‘Tilak, taraaju aur talwar, unko maaro joota char.’ Ye olde patriarchy makes me want to barf.

    [Reply]

  • pradeep rao

    I think Renukaji, with due respect that this is your liberal guilt speaking. Sociologists have a more prosaic term for us ’sons of manu’ – HUM – Hindu Uppercaste Males and genetic studies across India have confirmed that HUMs are ethnically somewhat distinct in all populations with a higher proportion of the R1a1 Y-Chromosome, (known to be common among Uzbegs and Ukranians of the steppes) which is identified by some experts as the Indo-aryan gene marker. Just because I noted a cultural-spritual connection between a Hindustani Rajput and a Deccani Brahman does not mean I am in any way a practising casteist or that I am against social & economic upliftment of all disadvantged sections or that I am not personally committed to the values enshrined in our constitution including postive discrimination. Phew!

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted renuka

    Phew to you! You can sing whole litanies of DNA and morph into a double helix. What’s not right is not right.

    [Reply]