Time’s short and the task daunting for UPA



The possibility of a mid-term poll in the country is remote— no matter who says what. I’ve held this view and even written about it in the aftermath of the poll results that shocked the Congress and had a sobering influence on the BJP.

While it might suit the BJP to keep the speculation alive, its objective primarily is be put the UPA off-balance and show it as a dysfunctional coalition. Short of a snap poll, the saffron parivar, which won Goa but fell short of expectations in UP, Punjab and Uttarakhand, will use every trick in the book to embarrass the ruling combine in the ongoing budget session of Parliament.

No, I’m not taking about cut motions on money bills that can bring down the regime. The BJP and other elements in the Opposition benches, especially the Akalis, will seek to stall policies and programmes that can resurrect the UPA’s failing image.

The schemes on the radar of UPA’s adversaries might include FDI in retail, the food security bill, the direct tax code, the proposed land acquisition and compensation law and the national counter terrorism centre. India is a Union of States and not a federation. But the Opposition wouldn’t be shy of presenting an exaggerated picture of the State’s federal features to put a finger in every pie the Centre cooks.

To ward-off the BJP led onslaught, the UPA will urgently need to place its house in order. How? Well, it must setup without further delay a coordination committee of coalition partners where such proposals are discussed in advance to avoid any public display of differences within the alliance.

And to make the arrangement work better, the Congress has to strengthen its numbers in the two Houses of Parliament by settling the terms of engagement with the BSP and if possible the Samajwadi Party.

The BSP should be amenable to reason. After the drubbing she got in UP, Mayawati’s natural impulse will be to be in power or at least on the right side of it at the Centre. Likewise, it suits Mamata Banerjee to use her clout to get a good financial package for the bankrupt West Bengal rather than risk a mid-term poll when her popularity is a notch or two down after the thumping victory in the assembly elections.

Mamata also knows the Left parties do not want early polls. They will be too happy to lend the UPA the numbers if the Trinamool chooses to walk out.

But the UPA’s real challenge will be to walk the tight rope while pushing reforms and pro-people programmes. Arrogance will have to be replaced with a sense of accommodation, riposte with reason and a lax, opaque administration with efficiency and transparency. Without these attributes, an honourable survival might elude the Congress-led political conglomerate. It must remember that there are battles to be fought in Delhi, Himachal, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat before the 2014 war for the next Lok Sabha. Time’s short and the task daunting.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (24 votes, average: 2.21 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Anonymous

    Vinodji

    Very well analysed. The following points are worth noting.

    A) The BJP and other elements in the Opposition benches, especially the Akalis, will seek to stall policies and programmes that can resurrect the UPA’s failing image.

    B) “The schemes on the radar of UPA’s adversaries might include FDI in retail, the food security bill, the direct tax code, the proposed land acquisition and compensation law and the national counter terrorism centre.

    India is a Union of States and not a federation.

    But the Opposition wouldn’t be shy of presenting an exaggerated picture of the State’s federal features to put a finger in every pie the Centre cooks”.

    C) The BSP should be amenable to reason. After the drubbing she got in UP, Mayawati’s natural impulse will be to be in power or at least on the right side of it at the Centre. Likewise, it suits Mamata Banerjee to use her clout to get a good financial package for the bankrupt West Bengal rather than risk a mid-term poll when her popularity is a notch or two down after the thumping victory in the assembly elections.

    Mamata also knows the Left parties do not want early polls. They will be too happy to lend the UPA the numbers if the Trinamool chooses to walk out.

    [Reply]

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_URSXATBEMZ7HUAB3OH36PLYWDM Ashok

    The fiscal situation calls for the food security bill to be put into the deep freeze and for the land acquisition bill to be reworked so that it becomes practical and affordable to industry.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    in Hindi it is called food screw-tee

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ Vinod Sharma

    Well we all k now that your loyalties lie with the Congress. Fine enough. But why get BJP into the picture when the Congress as wwell as the BJP are actually facing a challenge from the regional parties.

    I think Rahul Amul baba has been ill served by Digviansh Singh and has ended up shouting BJP BJP in UP when the real fight was with the SP which it did not even acknowledge.

    A good way of recovery for the Congress would be to adk Rahul to retire hurt and then get MMS out and remind all of us that this was the guy who rescued India. But to make this a success, Rahul and Digivinash should retire forever first.

    Dynastic succession in the Congress is so boring now.. The people dont buy it anymore, except in fake Congress surveys

    jo kewal… dil ko behelane ke liye khayal achche hai…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Did Advani or Rajnath Singh retire hurt after 2004 and 2009? Will Nitin Gadkari also retire after getting lesser number of seats in UP, Punjab and Uttarakhand?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think BJP changes presidents every few years. Furtheron they are ot selected on dynasty considerations.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    The stage is set for disruption of the Parliament proceedings. The BJP wants to set the agenda and the sequence of the same to be followed or else ………

    It will be no work, all pay once more for our MPs.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Vijay

    In the previous blog, you wrote

    “third fronts have always been dangerous. VP Songh, Chandrashekhar, IK Gujral, Dev Gowda… well a line of disasters…”

    Agree, but that does not prevent these small parties from dreaming up alliances, whenever the big parties have floundered.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    They are an obscene remider that national parties have a lot of work to do.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Another bouncer from Didi.

    PWD objects to toll collection for six-lane projects in West Bengal

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/PWD-objects-to-toll-collection-for-six-lane-projects-in-West-Bengal/articleshow/12237765.cms

    Excerpt

    “We are caught in a fix. The NHAI has allowed us to build the toll plaza. But with the state objecting to toll plaza and collection of toll fee from day one is making it impossible to convince lenders to finance the project,” said a spokesperson of DSC Ltd, which has bagged the project.

    Land acquisition and people’s objection to pay toll have emerged as the two biggest stumbling blocks for highway development on public private partnership in West Bengal.

    [Reply]

  • engrich

    ravi bhai , sanjay &mohan_t,

    Our Birth is our Opening Balance!
    Our Death is our Closing Balance!
    Our Prejudiced Views are our Liabilities.
    Our Creative Ideas are our Assets.
    Heart is our Current Asset.
    Soul is our Fixed Asset.
    Brain is our Fixed Deposit.
    Thinking is our Current Account.
    Achievements are our Capital.
    Character & Morals, our Stock-in-Trade.
    Friends are our General Reserves.
    Values & Behaviour are our Goodwill.
    Love is our Dividend.
    Children are our Bonus Issues..
    Education is Brands / Patents.
    Knowledge is our Investment.
    Experience is our Premium Account.
    The Aim is to Tally the Balance Sheet Accurately.
    The Goal is to get the Best Presented Accounts Award

    [Reply]

  • engrich

    rajeev s jee,

    i hope azam khan will next be the premier of india.this is the only way to makeindia prosper and strong.

    do u agree with me.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Sure..the day you will consume pork..

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    and u will consume co.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I already consume cow… :) not stuck like you in dogmatic religion.
    If you say once that you like munching ham burgers, I’ll support Azam.

  • engrich

    americans arekilling children for sport in afghanistan,they laugh when children cry,

    11 March 2012 murders in Kandahar. Back in 2010, four US soldiers killed unarmed civilians in this part of Kandahar. They were found gulty of forming a “kill team” that murdered Afghan civilians for sport.

    On 11 March 2012, a GROUP of American soldiers murdered 16 civilians, including nine children, in southern Kandahar province in Afghanist
    Witnesses said the American soldiers were laughing when they carried out the shootings.

    Child murdered in Kandahar on 11 March 2012. A GROUP of Americans carried out the murders.

    Witnesses told Reuters they saw a GROUP of U.S. soldiers arrive at their village in Kandahar’s Panjwayi district at around 2 am, enter homes and open fire.

    .

    The Mai Lai massacre carried out by US troops as part of Operation Phoenix killed 100 villagers mostly children and women.

    Afghan President Hamid Karzai described the Kandahar attack as “intentional murders”.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Well, a country of retards….. Didn’t Rahul Gandhi advocate that they should be left alone to do fatwah or whatever?

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Now-Deoband-issues-fatwa-on-body-scan/articleshow/12239669.cms

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Very interesting indeed..They are forgetting that these body scanners all due to nuts like them..I wish we could go back in pre-9/11 world when air travel was without hassles.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    american armies have committed biggest holocaust of human history,starting from korea to afghanistan,via latin america and iraq.
    they should be carefull for passenger safety.spt 11 was inside job,that is why no enquiry commission was set up to investigate truth.zoinist henry kissinger was appointed to head a cmmitte in this regard.but he even resigned after knowing facts.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Interesting article on income growth, “Gatsbys” in India — today’s NY Times

    http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/03/12/the-great-gatsby-comes-to-india/

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    My posts are getting deleted especially when I reply to Congressi-Jihadis..

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Rajeev,

    You have my sympathies. You and I have been targeted by the new censor of this blog. Lat week, a post on Rahul Gandhi got deleted repeatedly more than 10 times!

    I wrote to Vinodji personally, but it didn’t have any effect. Only in the last three days, most of my posts are getting published here.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Views of young liberal Pakistani on the conditions of hindus in pakistan..
    http://www.dawn.com/2012/03/12/an-infected-conversion.html

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    forced conversion is very rare.sometime it happens with girls.kidnapping is because ,hindus are very rich.in india also hindus are kidnapped and killed for te same reason.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Beautifull ! Nominated as the fake tale from Toa Bora for this blog !

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    force conversion is against islam.those who commit this crime should be charge for adultry according to sharia.

    Anonymous Reply:

    fake tales from a brain-washed, failed jihadi.

  • Anonymous

    Post-U.P., Congress and BJP in conciliatory mood in Parliament

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article2988812.ece?homepage=true

    Chastened by their drubbing in the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, both the Congress and the BJP appeared sombre and even conciliatory on the opening day of the budget session of Parliament.

    ————

    Read on.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    News Analysis: Why a Third Front is not possible

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article2988626.ece

    Excerpt

    Barring the Trinamool Congress, a UPA ally with 19 MPs, and the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD), a part of the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA), no party is keen to precipitate a mid-term election. For, if the Congress fared poorly in the recent round of Assembly elections, so did the 114-member strong BJP: its numbers fell both in Uttar Pradesh and Punjab, and even if it lost Uttarakhand narrowly, it only won Goa.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Power crisis: 60,000-MW plans run on empty

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/power-crisis-60-000mw-plans-run-on-empty/923045/0

    Across the power sector, alarm bells are ringing, threatening to short-circuit the already unravelling growth story. Manufacturing has pulled down to its lowest in three years, export growth is petering out, while rising input costs and a significant fall in capacity utilisation across sectors have stymied hiring and investment outlook further.

    At least five states have declared power holidays and another eight have load-shedding plans lined up.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Deliver us from legislation

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/deliver-us-from-legislation/922495/0

    Excerpts

    Once appointed, few government servants undergo any training. In fact, for the majority of government employees, there is simply no facility for any training anywhere. The government employees who undergo some form of training at the entry level seldom go through any other training program over the course of their long careers. All the learning takes place on the job, from seniors and from colleagues, and in this process, the status quo is reinforced.

    ————

    Every year, central and state governments enact several hundred laws, not because there is a need for all of those laws, but because it is easier to enact a law than to implement a program. Most often, laws are alibis for inaction. Of late, laws are being enacted at the prodding of civil society organisations with persistent backing from the media. We now have laws guaranteeing jobs, education and — soon — food, though everybody knows that an affected person would seldom go to court to demand his rights. But we continue to demand more laws on all possible subjects and hope that these will be implemented, however perfunctorily, by the same government servants.

    ===========

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Aditya Sinha: Kaun banayega Rashtrapati?

    http://www.dnaindia.com/analysis/column_aditya-sinha-kaun-banayega-rashtrapati_1660792

    The best thing to come out of the recent state elections is that our next President won’t be someone useless, someone blind to corrupt family members and someone whose only qualification is her comfort level with the leader of the coalition running India. With all due respect to the Constitutional post, the person occupying it is a travesty, and certainly no patch on the person who occupied it before her.

    ———–

    Read on

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The article also says

    According to urban legend, Dr Kalam did his duty to the nation by refusing to swear in a certain person as prime minister (there were, it is said, strong objections from the armed forces and the intelligence agencies) and so he had to swear in Dr Manmohan Singh instead. I’m not sure about that, but my own theory is that each individual has their one moment of greatness in their lifetime, and that’s it. And so Dr Kalam will not be returning to Rashtrapati Bhawan (he’s too dignified to do so)
    —————————————————–

    Neither will Hamid Ansari be selected just because the Congress feels that his Muslim credentials will help Rahul Gandhi become the Prime Minister.

    ———————————————

    I think it is a fair analysis. I wonder how the person Dr Kalam, refused to swear in was. Was it a lady….? .

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Looks like it must Sonia Gandhi.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay Kumar,

    Prabhat used to say, “file for a RTI reply”.
    But ever since that fateful day, many have reported Sonia Gandhi often “gun-gunaing” a particular song, of course in her own Italian style:

    हम थे जिनके सहारे, वो हुए ना हमारे
    डूबी जब दिल की नय्या, सामने थे किनारे
    हम थे जिनके सहारे …

    है सभी कुछ जहाँ में, दोस्ती है वफ़ा है
    अपनी ये कमनसीबी, हमको ना कुछ भी मिला है
    हमको ना कुछ भी मिला है
    हम थे जिनके सहारे …

    यूँ तो दुनिया बसेगी, तनहाई फिर भी डसेगी
    जो ज़िंदगी में कमी थी, वो कमी तो रहेगी
    वो कमी तो रहेगी
    हम थे जिनके सहारे …

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    I can’t believe Vinod Sharma worote this:
    But the UPA’s real challenge will be to walk the tight rope while pushing reforms and pro-people programmes. Arrogance will have to be replaced with a sense of accommodation, riposte with reason and a lax, opaque administration with efficiency and transparency. Without these attributes, an honourable survival might elude the Congress-led political conglomerate. It must remember that there are battles to be fought in Delhi, Himachal, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat before the 2014 war for the next Lok Sabha. Time’s short and the task daunting.

    This is what I make of this, line by line:
    1. All reforms are necessarily anti-people/ pro-people programmes are anti-reform.
    2. UPA currently is arrogant and not accommodative.
    3. Combative without purpose
    4. UPA runs a lax and opaque administration which is not efficient.

    If Vinod, who wears his love for Congress on his sleeve, can say this, what hope for Congress?
    Also, it would not have escaped anyone’s notice that all the states that Vinod mentions are not likely to provide good atmospherics for Congress in the run up to the 2014 general elections.
    By the way, Vinod, when you warn:”… an honourable survival might elude the Congress led political conglomerate..” I hope it is not taken as an invitation to plan for survival at any cost by Congress, dishonourable or not.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    good.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Aashish,

    Mr. Sharma has accepted that Congress had committed blunders and had been arrogant in dealing with its allies. He has now advised or should I say
    warned them to change as soon as possible or be ready to sit in opposition
    in 2014. Will these arrogant, sycophant the people who believe in appeasing
    policies change for the betterment of India ?
    This budget will give us a clue to their future approach . We have to wait and
    watch.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Something interesting
    ========

    In Sabarmati jail for fake encounters, Vanzara turns Guru Cool

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/in-sabarmati-jail-for-fake-encounters-vanzara-turns-guru-cool/923094/0

    Excerpts

    Both “Iron Man” Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and “Iron Lady” Indira Gandhi were “direct descendants of Chanakya”, former prime minister Atal Behari Vajpayee was “Ajatshatru” with no enemies, Nehru was innocent.

    ———-

    And this one transcends national boundaries. Rawalpindi must be freed from Pakistan and the Chinese must be shown their place, says Vanzara in his third book written during his long sojourn in jail, Ran Tankar (Battle Cry), a collection of 128 poems which was released on Saturday by former DGP Shabbir Khandwawala.

    ———

    Read on

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    did he wrote anything about fake encounters and using his position in money extracting bussines.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    For the sake of India that is Bharat
    Earlier you are proven Wrong Mr Vinod Sharma the better it is.
    Any Govt is going to be better than this lame duck Govt lead by Arrogant, Insane, Communal and Corrupt party that has betrayed Democracy and its People time and again and is only striving to defend the undefendable and shield the corrupt and communalize rule the nation with devide and rule theory one way or the other.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Does India provide healthy environment for conducting business ?

    Mr. Jim Rogers who partnered with famous financial guru Mr. George Soros
    and started a hedge fund in seventies and went on to make huge money.
    Mr. Rogers who retired at 37 and now at the age of 69 has this to say about India.

    ” If you can only visit one country in the world, visit India,” Rogers advises.

    “It is a complete assault on your senses. Amazing natural beauty, diverse peoples and cultures, wonderful buildings and temples. It is a complete sensory experience for sight, smells, tastes. But never, ever do business there. The Indians have taken British administration and red tape and moved it three levels higher. It is impossible to do business there because of the regulatory environment and protectionist rules.”

    India rules

    “Take agriculture for instance,” Rogers says, returning to his favourite topic. “In India, there are land ownership rules in place that limit land ownership to five hectares. If there are ten sons in a family and each have five hectares, how can 50 hectares of land be productive? That’s why India will never develop. The regulatory environment and protectionism needs to change.”

    He also offers advise of making money in future. Very interesting interview.

    http://gulfnews.com/business/features/the-world-according-to-investor-jim-rogers-1.993414

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    I am with him on blaming the “british administration and red tape”..
    It is high time we get rid of the IAS/IPS bureaucracy..
    the British system was designed for command and control by a central authority, with the numerous inspectors and inspectors over inspectors…all those are money eating bribe taking authorities now..

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————–
    ~~~ NOW MANI SILENCER WILL SILENCE CHIDAMABRAM ~~~~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————

    The Congress need not hunt for enemies. Its own son is determined to topple it totally. If we remember the CWG, it was Mani AIyar who failed as sports minister and then triggered the stories of ‘70,000 crores looted.”

    Well now he has draggged Chimdambaran into the mess. Read from NDTV:

    ———————————————————————————

    Senior Congress leader and former Sports Minister Mani Shankar Aiyar has stirred a fresh controversy by saying that it was then Finance Minister P Chidambaram who okayed the expenditure for the Commonwealth Games held in Delhi in October 2010. Speaking during the course of a debate with current Sports Minister Ajay Maken on NDTV’s Your Call, Mr Aiyar said that Mr Chidambaram sanctioned the release of the massive funds to Suresh Kalmadi, adding that the money was handed over sans an approved budget.

    Read more at: http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/news/chidambaram-cleared-spending-for-cwg-mani-shankar-aiyar/224824&cp

    ——————————————————————————–

    Since Mani SIlencer is from the St Stephens college and so are the anchors of some channels, we can now expect him to release his silencers on these English CHannels to finally topple Chidambran. In the process the three legged COngress will be crippled further.

    What fun !!

    Vinod Sharmaji … did I not warn you about your friend… 3 years back !! :)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Leader wohi hota hai jiske peeche koi followers ho.
    Therefore, NDTV calling him a senior leader of the congress party is a big joke.
    Mani Silencer was nominated to the Rajyasabha as a writer and he is busy writing the epitaph for the congress tombstone.
    The silencer, whenever he opens his mouth, only causes a lot of noise and stink.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Aiyar is going to be the winner of the Booker for creativity… Folk tales of a Congressi sycophant…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    To make sure that the Booker is his, he should title it:

    THE FOLK TALES OF A FUxxED UP FORMER DIPLOMAT TURNED FAILED POLITICIAN.

    Abu Ahmed Reply:

    Bureaucrats / technocrats from the state of Kerala are a problem; Mani Shankar, Shashi Tharoor (IPL), Madhavan Nair (ISRO) – you name it, they have sunk the ship. There’s something pathologically wrong with them – may be too much of misplaced pride or the food / drinks that they consume, whatever. Just observe Malyali babus and you can tell the difference. May be I am wrong, and I don’t mean any offence to any one, still….

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    cmon Abu

    U cant blame it on the state. It is the ego of the man– Shashi or Mani– who feel that their english and their persona can scare us natives.

    As for madhavan– he is a hero who made a slipup and that isit.

  • Abu Ahmed

    Raat baaki, baat baaki
    hona hai jo, ho jaaney do!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    रात ने क्या क्या ख्वाब दिखाये
    रंग भरे सौ जाल बिछाये
    आँखें खुली तो सपने टूटे
    रह गये ग़म के काले साये
    रात ने क्या क्या ख्वाब दिखाये1

    [Reply]

    Abu Ahmed Reply:

    In fact, this interim period is pregnant with numerous possibilities – exciting times ahead for the country in many ways.

    [Reply]

    Abu Ahmed Reply:

    In fact, this interim period is pregnant with numerous possibilities – exciting times ahead for the country in many ways.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Rift is emerging before even forming the government at Uttrakhand.

    http://www.samachar.com/Harish-Rawats-supporters-protest-over-making-Vijay-Bahuguna-Uttarakhand-CM-mdnmKPbjghc.html

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    That is the result of high command culture.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    I don’t know how many commands they have.
    High command – Sonia, Rahul, Vadhera
    Middle command – Chidambaram, Pranab da
    Low command – Digdryodha, Sibal, Khursheed,
    Lowest command – Manish Tiwari, Silencer

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    MOhan I think u should go on TV !! Replace Cyrus… really good !

    Anonymous Reply:

    In UP, there is no demand.

    Anonymous Reply:

    mohan-

    quite funny… and Manmohan Singh nowhere?

    AshishC Reply:

    Mohan, :)
    Where is the chain of command? Or are they all tied up in chains?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    Our PM the nice guy of Congress unfortunately cannot
    command anyone.
    I left out Manu Singhvi. He is a floater. He believes
    that he is part of Middle command but actually he is
    floating somewhere between low and lowest command.

    Anonymous Reply:

    There is only one – an insecure bunch of non-electable jycophants aka loyalists, who surround the family – the fault lies with the family for allowing to be fenced around by such jokers. One of the jokers is the Governor of Uttarakhand.

    In this case, as is the practice, the highcommandwalas (Azad and Co.) must have spoke to each legislature in private – no one else knows what was told. They go back to Delhi (along with a resolution passed by the newly elected members that Sonia Gandhi has been authorised to appoint the leader) and tell her that the consensus candidate is X. No way to verify the if it so. This X may be one of the close friends of the emissaries and not the choice of the majority. This is Congress ‘ishtyle’ and ‘paramparaa’. It never occurs to them, that having a poll to elect a leader would prevent a lot of heart burn. But then other parties also do the same – authorise the high command or the supremo to do so.

    If in this mess, the BJP manages to form the Government, it will be just desserts for the Congress. They never wish to learn from the disasters.

    Anonymous Reply:

    It simply is stupid in these times to move a sitting MP to CMship — potentially they will lose the assembly seat and parliament seat..

    (it looks like they think they are like Samajwadi party!!!! …

    Anonymous Reply:

    This govet will fall ! RSS or BJP hand behind?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ Mohan

    Sachin should retire now. This 100th century thing is becoming a joke and making people feel that he is playing for himslef. Go at the top… is the way to go…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,

    Problem is that media has made this 100th ton a joke. Even before the match starts
    all the TV channels start talking of this so called Maha shatak.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    yah shatakon ka shatak ban gaya hai yek joke
    Sachin dab gaya hai under this yoke
    lekin kya karen, kismat ne laga diya hai rok
    he may cry, with tears his hankey may soak,
    but now there’ll be no champagne, only coke.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    Very good one.

    Now to achieve this milestone he will have to recite few shloks.

    Anonymous Reply:

    He has overstayed his welcome.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    He WAS our best. Either he plays in top form and continues his wrld cup form or otherwise people will start questioning , which would be sad. Ie needs to remember that even the gr8 Kapil Dev was once booed… in his last match.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Instead of walking into the sunset with his head high (like Gavaskar and Dravid – just two examples), he will be told soon – enough is enough and dropped or told to announce his retirement. Some people never know when it is time to say goodbye.

    In my area, the frequency of snide remarks have increased since yesterday. Here is a sampling

    ‘ Sachin, ghar waapas aao, ab bahot ho gayaa”

    ‘ Sachin Bundlekar’

    ‘he will continue to play until his son gets selected to play for India’

  • Anonymous

    UPA should 1) prosecute the Mumbai diamond market and Delhi high court attacks within few months 2) put Afzal Guru to death (kasab, i m not sure – young man , was lured by money payment) 3)Work with Anna team to pass Lokpal 4) Start the river linkage project 5)Prosecute 2G on fasttrack 6)Prosecute Adarsh on fast track 7)Prosecute former Chief Justice Balkrishnan on fast track etcetc.. Although delays are parts of the system, common man considers it gaming of the system by the privileged. A few should be packed to jail for a long term.

    BJP should stop opposing everything. They are not considered a significantly better party than congress; yes, they are less corrupt; that is mainly because the corruption opportunities for them are less than for Congress.Gujrat is a great example; but for whatever reason they do not want to tout it because of the misplaced fear of Modi backlash. BJP should deal with the Madhyapradesh mining mafia – couple of police officers (including the young IPS officer ) were murdered in broad daylight by the agents of these mafiosi. Also they have to get Yedurappa out (work with congress to give him a governorship in exchange of supporting a bill);

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    ‘Also they have to get Yedurappa out (work with congress to give him a governorship in exchange of supporting a bill)’

    What a brilliant idea. Why didn’t Mohan Bhagwat or Nitin Gadkari think about it first?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Mayawati’s wealth doubled to Rs 111.64 crore during her term as chief minister

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Mayawatis-wealth-doubled-to-Rs-111-64-crore-during-her-term-as-chief-minister/articleshow/12249319.cms

    Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) president Mayawati’s assets doubled to Rs. 111.64 crores (approx. $22 million) during her term as chief minister of Uttar Pradesh.

    ————

    Should we surprised? Just before elections, she expelled ‘corrupt’(?) members of her party.

    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar

    The obvious question is why people like these are not investigated – and how/why these are not identified while the wealth is accumulated (like property, company shares etc)
    How can a person who did not have any assets when she became the CMat 38, can accumulate so much of wealth just on government salary?

    There was a report that Sonia Gandhi is worth $19 Billion.

    Are these people not investigated for the fear of losing jobs?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    They will be investigated only if permission/order is given. Who will
    take this responsibility? Perhaps one day Supreme court will take the charge and order an investigation.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    She will be not be investigated, not for the moment in any case. She will be used to neutralise the empress from the Kingdom of Poschim Bongo. Sword of damocles and that sort of thing.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    but Manohar

    She is openly declaring she is worth this much (she should be congratulated, unlike Pawar etc whose money is in swiss banks).

    Looks like she has paid the taxes.

    May be our existing laws let a person loose if he paid taxes??

    How can she have rs 100 crore plus? (granted some investments in property etc must have significantly increased in value).

    Who in our current structure is supposed to investigate situations like this (where she seems to have paid appropriate taxes, but the source of wealth obviously is questionable)

    Anonymous Reply:

    She has claimed that the bulk of the money is from her well wishers and supporters as gift on her ‘happy birthday to you, behenji’ celebrations (recall the garland made out of currency notes). I believe this is being contested in the courts. Who knows the kickbacks are routed this way. This is her declared income. How much money she has underground, only underground people will know.

    Anonymous Reply:

    but Manohar

    She is openly declaring she is worth this much (she should be congratulated, unlike Pawar etc whose money is in swiss banks).

    Looks like she has paid the taxes.

    May be our existing laws let a person loose if he paid taxes??

    How can she have rs 100 crore plus? (granted some investments in property etc must have significantly increased in value).

    Who in our current structure is supposed to investigate situations like this (where she seems to have paid appropriate taxes, but the source of wealth obviously is questionable)

  • Anonymous

    Another “Kurian” breaks patent cronyism, paves the way for affordable cancer drugs for millions of Indians.

    “Bullet Kurian” has done it again! But, he sure, has amassed lot of enemies.

    It gives us some hope – that there are dedicated ‘country first” civil servants like Kurian.
    I am particularly proud because he is a fellow Malayali (and Christian), although neither of those attributes have anything to do with his commitment and sense of service),

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Compulsory License (CL) is a “funny” thing. It is an involuntary contract between a willing buyer and unwilling seller imposed and enforced by the state. It is widely practiced across the world since 1830s.

    By granting the first CL in India, Mr. Kurian has helped millions of countrymen and of course Natco Pharma (against Bayer). The licence mandates Natco Pharma to sell the cancer drug at Rs 8800 for a monthly dose as opposed to about Rs 2.85 lakh charged by Bayer for their patented medicine Nexavar.

    Welcome decision. Thank you Gopi for letting us know about it.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopji,

    Great news. Such people help millions of Indians and bring glory for our
    country.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi,

    as you know, we South Indians are very good at inventing things, be they drugs, milk, or even stories.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Good move. However, how much quantity will disappear into the black market? The price differential is too huge Rs. 2.84 lacs to Rs 8880

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Well, .. one kurian is only one …we need honest bureaucrats and politicians like him…
    .

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    No. The chemists, the distributors and who knows who else will be there to laugh all the way. The drug if supplied directly to Tata Memorial Hospital for example and other genuine charitable hospitals would go to the right person and at the right price.

  • Anonymous

    Dear Shri Vinod,

    (I Hope this is your real name, unlike some plants here who come with fake IDs)

    You are right. Much of what Vinod Sharma writes is nothing earth-shaking.
    Nobody breaks into sweat after reading these blogs. But, we carry on regardless, whatever the subject and from whichever angle he writes.

    But we are grateful to him for tolerating some of us who pretend to be scribes.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    BREAKING NEWS——-BREAKING NEWS
    ============+++++++++================

    In keeping with the image of Didi as the friend of poor people, Dinesh Trivedi,

    1.the Rail Minister is proposing serving of free food and snacks to people who travel on roofs.
    The extra expenditure on this item is 1647crores.

    2. He is also providing for free life insurance to all these roof-travellers upto 1.2lac.
    The expenditure to be incurred is 1983 crores!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    u jokimg or is this real — quite possible she will do somethig like this…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    I knew she will be biased to other travelers. Nothing for passengers who
    travel in toilets of train compartments ? Not fair.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Am I drunk … or are you playing a joke :)

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    deffenetely it is posted by rahul baba, now he has become an unwanted fellow for congress stooges, so he now took up ghost writer job posting these kind of articles, the disgusted attitude of mr.sharma come out when he used words bjp and elements, his remarks are utter disregard for popularly elected mp.s

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    National Fight Championships
    ————————–
    Himachal MLAs turn Assembly into house of horrors

    http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Himachal-MLAs-turn-Assembly-into-house-of-horrors/923258/

    Excerpt

    Congress members, continuing to raise slogans from the well, moved towards the treasury benches and Randhir Sharma (BJP) and Rakesh Kalia (Congress) traded blows and after sometime Balbir Chwdhary (BJP) and Mukesh Agnihotri (Congress) tried to hit each other.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    National Fight Championships
    ————————–
    Himachal MLAs turn Assembly into house of horrors

    http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Himachal-MLAs-turn-Assembly-into-house-of-horrors/923258/

    Excerpt

    Congress members, continuing to raise slogans from the well, moved towards the treasury benches and Randhir Sharma (BJP) and Rakesh Kalia (Congress) traded blows and after sometime Balbir Chwdhary (BJP) and Mukesh Agnihotri (Congress) tried to hit each other.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Interesting op ed article on population /indias benefits…see the fifth and sixth para from bottom ..also that the population growth in South India is below sustainable levels while in the North it is significantly higher…

    http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/13/opinion/brooks-the-fertility-implosion.html

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Binoy

    I think the articel is a bit shallow. It does not take into account robotics which will replace manpower in a controlled way. HOWEVER yes, there is a big problem of ageing population in rusia , japan and Europe as familes have disappeared and individuals in search of pleasure dont find the need to burden themselves with children . On the flipside… hig population growth rates in UP and Bihar place the states as laggards in India.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Mamata Banerjee embarrasses Manmohan Singh, TMC leaders skip his dinner

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Mamata-Banerjee-embarrasses-Manmohan-Singh-TMC-leaders-skip-his-dinner/articleshow/12251126.cms

    Excerpts

    The dinner hosted by the Prime Minister was attended by party MP Ratna De Nag only, even though Trinamool has seven ministers and its total strength in Parliament is 25, including 19 in Lok Sabha.

    Where is civility? Will O’Brien or anyone from TMC answer that?

    ————–

    “Since we came to power in West Bengal, no financial assistance has been given to us by the Centre inspite of our demands. We have been demanding a moratorium for three years on the interest but to no effect as yet,” he said.

    He forgets that it takes two to play tango.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar

    Mamta is stupid! The skipping of dinner is really bad.

    Congress should drop Mamta — she is going to screw them up (in addition to all the screw ups they themselves do). Beg, borrow from others..As long as she is there, the next two years will be a nightmare and sure path to 2014 Lok Sabha failure.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think it is matter of days now for her to be told by the Congress – go take a walk. Tomorrow will be the first indication when the motion of thanks to the President is adopted – Congress will strike deals (if not done so already) with the SP (there are some corruption cases pending against Mulayam Singh and his family) and BSP. The Congress at the moment are not reacting to her shenanigans publicly.

    Then she will have no one else (not even Derek O’B'rien and Co.) to blame, but herself.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I am told she asked for and got an advance copy of the menu, which made her skip the dinner. The menu had two items: Italian pasta and South Indian Sambhar, to both of which she seems to have developed intense dislike.

    The dinner could have been saved if these two items were changed.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Civility and Mamata are not coterminus.. sadly, the political discourse in waste bengal is held hostage increasingly to such people.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Myawati’s assets have been discussed here. let me inform you her sardar patel road house which is basically five plots of 600 yds joined together alonge must be about 300 crores in that area.

    Other assets if actually stringed together would be…. about 20,000 crores …

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Why is nobody talking about murder of IPS officer in Morena MP?
    One IPS officer committed suicide today in MP due to over interference by superiors.

    What is happening in Madhya Pradesh? This Shivraj Chauhan seems to be a shady character.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    It is in the interest of BJP to investigate and prosecute the two cases fast. BJP will not win the state elections next year if they do not prosecute this.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Absolutely. I think all honest officers need our support and anybody who messes up their lives needs punishment.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    BJP must be much more proactive rather than only reacting to public pressure. Otherwise, what is the difference?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Ashish

    How has Amit Mitra – the finance minister – kept himself busy until now or has he been sent on a long vacation?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Amit Mitra is working his socks off to clean the economic mess left by the vermin party. If CPM lends it support to prop up the Govt , it will come as godsend to mamata , the congress in west bengal then will undergo its last rites

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    I know Amit Mitra must be working hard. It would help though, if he let us know, exactly at what.
    Are you aware of something that we – admittedly outsiders- are not?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    yes,

    since Amit Mitra greatly values Nirad Chaudhary, he has a hotline to our modern version of Nirad Babu.

    AshishC Reply:

    As his name suggests Amit Mitra (Amit – Limitless and Mitra- Friend), he has many friends. I am sure he will need them for therapy- and his next job. Poor chap. Perhaps, we will see him soon back in Delhi- buying fish in INA/ CR Park.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    And when he returns to Delhi, he will have a different meaning: A friend of the limitless.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Is Babu Moshai, the resturaunt,… in CR Park still rocking?

    U’ll ry spotting Dr Mitra there…

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Given that is down my alley , would you care to elaborate in detail. so far I am aware , after the GATT and WTO , INDIA CANNOT FLOUT INTERNATIONAL PATENTS. .Previously India got round this by recognising THE PATENT FOR THE CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS PATHWAY, BUT DID NOT RECOGNISE PATENT ON MOLECULES.
    It cannot do that anymore AND HAS FALLEN IN LINE WITH INTERNATIONAL PATENT LAWS.So I do not know what you are talking about.Give me some detail , i will separate the water from milk.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    A big worry for big pharma

    http://www.hindustantimes.com/editorial-views-on/Edits/A-big-worry-for-big-pharma/Article1-824967.aspx

    Excerpt

    The Trips agreement provides flexibility to governments to produce the patented product or process without the consent of the patent owner, for domestic consumption and at specified price. In this case, Bayer must license Nexavar, or sorafenib, to Natco Pharma. In exchange, Natco will pay Bayer a 6% royalty on its net sales and must sell the drug for Rs 8,800 a month, about 3% of the Rs 280,000 that Bayer charges for it in India.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous
  • Anonymous

    A great article on why some countries are well off, why people are the root of wealth, values in sharing etc based on 2 MIT economists’ study
    http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/18/magazine/why-countries-go-bust.html

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Binoy,

    Very good article. Thanks.

    “” If national institutions give even their poorest and least educated citizens some shot at improving their own lives — through property rights, a reliable judicial system or access to markets — those citizens will do what it takes to make themselves and their country richer. This suggests, among other things, that instead of supporting one-off programs promoting health or agricultural productivity, the international community should focus its aid efforts on deep political and economic change.”

    Here he is suggesting which is a long term policy. Problem is that political
    parties all over the world adopt only short term policies which will garner
    them votes.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    The end of the high command

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/the-end-of-the-high-command/923455/0

    Political scientist Francis Fukuyama, in his authoritative book The Origins of Political Order: From Prehuman Times to the French Revolution, boils it down to three essential components that modern nation-states need for sustained success: a strong state; its subordination to a rule of law; and the government’s accountability to its citizens.

    ————

    Read on.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    RSVP dharma

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/rsvp-dharma/923465/0

    West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee is sending her state cabinet colleague to attend the swearing-in of Parkash Singh Badal as Punjab chief minister in Chandigarh. It is telling that that statement should be seen as a trigger of insecurities, fraught with political charge, almost scandalous. But why should the attendance of a CM or her representative in the ceremonials held to usher in a leader of another state be seen as the stuff of political intrigue — and so what if both belong to regional parties that are members of two opposing coalitions?

    ———————–
    Read on

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Don’t work after 8pm, Gurgaon tells women

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/gurgaon/Dont-work-after-8pm-Gurgaon-tells-women/articleshow/12254740.cms

    A day after a 23-year-old woman was abducted and gangraped in the city, the Gurgaon administration on Monday passed an order virtually absolving its responsibility of ensuring women are safe. The administration has told all malls, commercial establishments and pub owners that they cannot have women employees working beyond 8pm.

    ———–

    What an retrograde step.
    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    very retrograde. The state has washed its hands of proetction of women. I am not cribbing but had this been Noida or Punjab… the same press would have linked it to the anti women policies of the opposition government.

    Sheila Dixit (ealrier) and now Hooda willg et away becasue of being Congress govets,

    Gurgaon is supposed to be India’s future city. This way it is becoming India’s past.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    As expected, you always try and give a political colour to everything and as usual blame the Congress if it is in power there and scoot if it happens to be BJP government. Remember, the attack on women in a Mangalore pub, whose government was it? In Bangalore the pubs were ordered to be shut by 11-30 PM. who was the chief minister? Under which government an attempt was made to ban girls from wearing jeans in Bhopal. Let me see, whether you will scoot from this thread or should I say again, you win, I lose?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Sharia looks better every day!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    Read a news just now about another rape in Gurgaon. Time is not mentioned,
    but if this was a day time incident then will administration order all women
    to stay indoors for ever?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    This idiotic rule, which I suppose, will be challenged soon. The saem logic prevails here in Bombay. Women are not allowed to work in bars after 9-30 PM, because it insults the sensibilities of the state’s home minister, R R Patil, a person from a one-bull-village from the far way interiors of Maharashtra. The case is pending in the high court. The state has not been able to answer one question – if the owner of a bar happens to be a woman, is she allowed to be there on the spot or not after 9-30 PM, mind you she is not a customer. The same question can be asked about Gurgaon ban – if the boutique owner happens to be a woman (in which many cases they are), then is she supposed to close shop at 8 or leave and let male employees (if any) manage the show. Moreover, why allow women to visit malls after 8 PM. Logic and reason have never been the strong point of the bureaucrats civil and police. If there is a problem, instead handling it the way one is supposed, they create another set of rules, hoping the problem will just vanish.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    “” Logic and reason have never been the strong point of the bureaucrats civil and police. “”

    This says it all. Agree with you.

  • Anonymous

    An idiotic move if there was one.
    ——————————————-

    AMU blocks Facebook, says it ‘hurts religious sentiments’

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/amu-blocks-facebook-says-it-hurts-religious-sentiments/923486/

    The Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) administration has blocked Facebook on the campus, claiming that the content posted on the social networking website could hurt religious sentiments.

    ———–
    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    They should just change of name from AMU to PMU – Pakistan Muslim University – than no one will object on banning anything.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    u are an brainless bania.u people bring poverty whereever u go.idi amin knew u people best.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Engrich

    Does facebook work in Tora Bora?

    engrich Reply:

    yes it works in nagpur.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Nagpur will not ban it. I was asking about Tora Bora.

    engrich Reply:

    nagpur will use this for communal riot.

    Anonymous Reply:

    engrich,

    please tell us kafirs whether Aligarh MU is authorised to issue the fatwa.

    Does it have to be ratified by the Wahabi council in Saudi?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ratification of the current true Muslim
    Mr. Salman Khursheed is enough.

    engrich Reply:

    ur questions are full of stupidities.but things like this i always expect from brainless members of rashtriya swam sevak sngh.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Engrich,

    Don’t know why you got angry? Did not Pakistan try to
    ban face book for this same reason ?

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Mohan

    Sadly Kapil Sibal and Digvinash SIngh also tried to peddle the asame reason for censoring facebook.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ok than change the name to
    CMU – Congress Muslim University.

    Everyone know what congress stands for.

    engrich Reply:

    congress stands for much higher principles as compare to thieves of parivar.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Ha!!!

    engrich Reply:

    yes even many literature is banned in europe nad america.

    hum aisee sab kitabein qabile zapti samajhtein hain,

    ki jinko padh ke bete baap ko khaptee damajhte hain.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Since when face book became literature?

    engrich Reply:

    action is in right direction.zoinists wants to rob middle east so are using anti-islam compaign.they did same with christianity in europe.now hinduism has also come on target as destroy india compaign is in full swing.
    in the name of freedom of action u cannot start sleeping with ur daughters.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    ——————————————————————————————————————————~~~~ THREE MUSKETEERS ~~~ VS ~~~ THE THREE FAILURES !! ~~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————-

    The three musketeers was an entertaining story and has been picturised many a time by Hollywood.

    The THREE FAILURES– amul baba, Digviansh Singha and Salman the communalist — is not such an entertaining story but more a case of a scoialogical study on how communalists try to divide India.

    Where is the trio of the Three Failures hiding ?

    Sanjayji/Prahladji/ Vinod ji… since u guys have an ear on the door of 10 Janpath, can you please guide us, the less informed?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    It looks like US military will accelerate its departure from Afghanistan following the killings of 16 people (may of them children) by the deranged American soldier.

    India will have to thnik through what role to play/how to play

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    The reaction of some American soldiers on duty in Afghanistan is showing
    the effect of War syndrome/War illness. Withdrawal now seems imminent
    and this may also help Obama in forth coming elections this year.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The US probably will leave a mess behind. India may have to battle a resurgent Taliban and ISI.

    Time to divide Pakistan so that the internal fissures take care of its aggressiveness towards India. Sadly the US woke up too late and its Baluchistan resolution has just come in.

    For 10 years it could not detect that the problem was Pakistan.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I believe US will keep some solid infrastructure in Afghanistan precisely to monitor Pakistan. US now knows about the dangers of Paksiatan.

    Anonymous Reply:

    America should think through about soft power/hard power balance especially these days when they are squeezed by too many issues beyond their control.

    Actuallly, with all the sophisticated gadgetry and technology, all the wars they have fought since the second world war have been expensive with no results to be shown , no victory in the traditional sense – Korea, vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan…

    The war group there is pushing for bombing Iran. Obama may be forced to drop bombs based on the poll situation in September.

    Another “weapons of mass destruction” story

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji/Vijay,

    US have always done this since WW2. They start the war
    and after few years leave them in mess without completing
    their job and withdraw. Is that their policy ? Not sure.

    engrich Reply:

    if muslim do same u will say something else.what a double standard.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Brookings Institution write-up on Jayalalitha’s comeback, governance…

    http://www.brookings.edu/opinions/2012/0224_tamil_nadu_antholis.aspx

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    I have read many times Westerners analysing Indian election, political personalties and many other things happening in India. Recently Greg Chappell
    commented that India cannot produce leaders. Many cricketers from England
    and Australia regularly advice Indian players what should they do. Recently almost everyone is advising Sachin to retire. I do not see Indian doing this
    to Western countries or their people. We don’t normally analyse or advice them. Whatever they say about us, most of the time we take that seriously.
    Why it is like this ? Do we feel inferior to them and do they also believe that
    they are superior to us ?

    [Reply]

    Ravi Reply:

    Mohan

    West’s fascination with India and things Indian is nothing new.

    West views India as being very advanced in certain aspects of human endeavour and quite backward in others.

    The advise offered is from the POV of making someting that is good better rather than as an outright criticism of our society.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ravi,

    It is fine if it is because of fascination, but most of the times IMO, I find it patronizing.

  • Anonymous

    Just finishing watching the presentation of the Railway budget.

    First impressions, a sensible, non-populist and impartial budget after more than 12/13 years. No pandering to one’s own home state and no Didi’s stamp.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Mamta Di angry at increase in rail fares announced in this budget. Did Mr. Trivedi
    not inform his boss before presenting the budget ? Will he have to resign ?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    This is not railway budget.
    It is “haasyaaspad budget”

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    He has said that he did not discuss it with her (as a minister, he is not supposed to discuss it outside the cabinet). He may resign and would be asked to quit TMC.

    Look at this way, he must have been embarrassed by the ludicrousness of and the total confrontational approach by Mamata. This must be his way (increase the rail fares) to part ways with her. If he is expelled from the party, he still gets to keep his Rajya Sabha seat. Congress would not mind having him on board, as an independent supporting member and he may still continue as a Railway Minister.

    Can any right thinking person can tolerate Mamta?

    —————–

    Real time quotes

    I have not consulted anybody but the common man: Trivedi

    I can’t guarantee safety if I don’t have money: railway minister

    Bhagat Singh lost his life, I don’t mind losing my job: Trivedi

    People can afford little fare hike: Dinesh Trivedi

    Did not consult Mamata or my party on rail budget: Dinesh Trivedi

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Trinamool demands rollback of rail fare hike

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article2994333.ece?homepage=true

    Excerpt

    When pointed out that Mr. Trivedi was a member of the Trinamool Congress, he said the Railway Minister has performed his “Constitutional duty” by presenting the Budget.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Some comments from the net re: demand for roll back.

    ‘This over populist and left characteristic of west bengal parties has already sunken the mighty WB state and now they are planning to do the same with Indian Railways’.

    “Mamata Banerjee: why not reduce the prices and salaries of everybody in West Bengal to 1980’s level. Avg Annual salary: 200 bucks, railway fare from kolkata to delhi: 20 bucks”.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Ha!!

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ask Mr. Sinha – Is the increase in salaries and perquisites of MPs (as passed last year) not a burden on the common man?

    No – I don’t have to directly pay the increased salary of the MPs but I would have to definitely pay the increased fare, should I wish to use the Indian Railways to travel.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Direct or indirect – does it matter?

    Anonymous Reply:

    I am sure you understand the difference between the two. The MPs would get their increased salary irrespective of the fare the railways would charge.

    I’d rather have honest MPs with a higher salary than corrupt ones on a low salary.

    Anyways, I let you win this arguement.

    Anonymous Reply:

    I am not against the hike in MPs salaries. The point was Mr. Sinha was objecting to fare hike (looks like for the sake of it).

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar

    She is living in some other planet lightyears back!

    She has this notion that people will revolt at a nominal rise in ticket price. She has miscalculated that CPM will take and run with the price rise eating into her base.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The scenario I described above may as well have been scripted by the Congress and DInesh Trivedi. Now the onus is on Mamta Bannrjee – damn if she acts against the Railway Minister, damn if she does not.

    The Empire Strikes Back!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Anonymous

    Mohan, Vijay Kumar, Gopi, Ishwar,

    Here is one for all of you:

    Wife: Where the hell r u?

    Hubby: Darling you remember that jewellery shop where u saw necklace & totally fell in love with it & i didn’t have money that time & said ” Baby it will be yours one day ”
    Wife: Yeh i remember my love !! :)
    Hubby: I am in the pub just next to that shop … :

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    great!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    I would like to meet this man. Very good one.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Mohan, just look in the mirror :P

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    (: (:

    Anonymous Reply:

    ☺☺☺

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Now that has to be me…. :)

    On some future day…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    One of the advantage of drinking.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Here is a fine example of Indian secularism, practised by some of the most fundamentalist Muslims: speech by a MQM MLA:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nvjsgp8Mx-I&feature=share

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy-

    The Owaisi family has been getting a free ride, they control the goondagiri in Hyderabad. Akbar’s brother has been an MP for a long time.

    With 7 MLAs, the present Congress govt relies on their support now that Jjagan Reddy has formed his own party.

    It is really sad they always win elections insulting Hindus and blasphemising Hindu worship/Gods.

    It is even sadder that Congress does not have shame in requesting their support.
    This fellow, Akbaruddin, was shot by another Muslim youngster of his party in a land grab incident (well, at the end of the day, there are no rabid Muslim or Congress or BJP politicians, all want to grab land in the evening!)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    shenoy-

    It is not MQM, but MEM.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shoeb,

    Thanks for our response.

    Yes, these are the most rabid amongst the fundamentalists, and the saving grace is that they still constitute a small minority.

    My wish is that just like Hindus reject the extreme among them, the Muslim society too does likewise.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy/Shoeb,

    I have heard worst than this also. Such idiots should be ignored only.

    engrich Reply:

    hidu fascists and muslim communalist feed each other.AYODHYA KA MUDDA HINDUS KO DESTROY KARNE KE LIYE RSS(ZOINISTS)NE UTHAYA THA.they succeeded in their game.ayodhya has become stagnant and depressed city since this anti-national movement.

    engrich Reply:

    what he is saying is absolute right.hindu fascists and muslim communalist feed each other.owaisi has done lot of positive works for the people of that area especially for muslims.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    ram temple movement was based on fraud and liesayodhya was budhhdist city .ram was never born even in india.before 16th century nobody knew even the name of ram in ayodhya till ramanand tiwari introduced rama cult.plan was to ignite war between shivbhakts and vishnubhakt.brhmns engineered this game.ravan was brhmn i never saw any brhmn going to ramlila.ramlila was started by nawab wajid ali shah from baradari lucknow.
    brhmnst wanted to use this to perpetuate bloodbath in the area.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    he is right.noyorious brhmns hurted the common man a lot in name of ram.
    holy people of ayodhya has banned their entry in ayodhya.inka hukka pani bhi bandh hai.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    May be India should repatriate the Pakistani Hindus to India if there is a systematic killing/elimination of them

    http://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/Pakistan/Hindu-doctors-gunned-down-in-Pakistan/Article1-766292.aspx

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The MNA (equivalent of MP) from PPP got hindu girl Rinkal Kumari abducted and forcibly converted to Islam before getting her married to his nephew.
    They even took out a massive JULOOS claiming victory over infidel Hindus.

    On record PPP is secular socialist party..

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y2Fgh0dR-pw

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Rajeev,

    Horrible. Looks like whole country is brain washed.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    this video is prepared by rss to incite hindus.some stupids are there on both sides.regarding conversion,AS PER UR HOLY SCRIPTURES ,HINDU WOMEN HAS NO RELIGION.SHE HAS FOLLOW THE RELIGION OF HER HUSBAND.

    girl should be brought before sharia court.if she confirms her kidnapping,boy will be stoned to death.this will be good punishment.

    ground reality is,thousands of muslim girls are marrying non-muslims and vica versa.

    in ghettoos i know many hindu girl who converted to islam after knowing their lower position in their religion.they are classified between shudras and chandals,whose killing is not sin.

  • engrich

    gopi,there is nothing like this in pakistan. pakistan has passed through worst period but there was no mass exodus.few cases here and there happens even in india.u are quoting old report to cange dicussion.triputi has biggest brothel of the world.brothel in cosmopolitan cities are spreade in .miles and miles employing lacs and lacs of innocent girls..first correct them.

    hindus are kidnapped because they are rich.in india rich are kidnapped for same reason.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Old report ? Gopiji has posted four months old news. Do you mean to say
    that Pakistan has become PAK in four months.
    And what about one week old video which Rajeev has posted.?

    Don’t try to defend indefensible.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    roz tumahari jati ke baniye ghaziabad mei aur faridabad mein kidnap hote hain.reason is same.they are rich.guru bhi gharoon mein ghus ke inhi ko lootte hain.for money.thousands of muslim pakistanis are also kidnapped.gopi is an rss paid propagandist.twist the things.

    And what about one week old video which Rajeev has posted.?

    regarding what.this also people like zaid hamid are rediculed and ignored by mainstream of pakistan.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    pankaj jee,It is good to visit & countries with good karma.

    Which factors might produce bad karma?

    A. Materialism. Think of people who worship money and possessions.

    B. Greed. Think of a small group controlling most of the wealth.

    C. Lust. Think of Pattaya, Pompeii or Las Vegas.

    D. Violence. Think of army generals carrying out acts of false flag terrorism, to justify endless wars

    Anonymous Reply:

    What difference does it makes what other people do.
    Just ignore them. Trust me you will be a very happy
    person if you just learn to ignore the things which you
    ‘think’ are hurting you.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Engrich;
    A. Materialism: It is not correct to criticize materialism, when one is not in a position to have it. After being in a position to have wealth and power and not falling victim to it is best.
    B. Greed: A bad trait but not haram, if not halal. enough in world foreveryone’s need but not enough for even one person’s greed.
    C. Visited pattaya, beautiful town, approached by very good looking girl, did not fall to her charms, my decision. girl may be trying to meet both ends meet( a phrase only)
    D. violence: Feel you are shielding violence of your people and highlighting violence in other places. This is double standard.

    engrich Reply:

    pankaj jee,It is good to visit & live in countries with good karma.

    Anonymous Reply:

    A. Materialism – Is it bad? Even your Mohammad was a trader who married his employer.
    B. Greed – Mohammad indulged in looting non-muslims.
    C. Lust – Mohammad married 6 year old Ayesha.
    D. Violence – Mohammad personally killed many jews.

    Think before you post..Are you alleging that Mohammad indulged in bad karma?

    engrich Reply:

    bullshit.no problem hillay ande kee paidaish ho.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Engrich

    If you win the fake tales of Tora Bora booker prize, will you include this dialogue in the jehadi folk tale book?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    My posts are again getting deleted..Where is Dhawan? In Ravi’s manhole or Sharma’s.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Reading your post remind me, what I see here on Bus stand benches: You just now proved that Bench advertizing works”. Reading post above shows, you are not banned here as yet. Godforbid if that happens.

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    Rajeev;
    A friendly request. please avoid use of these words, it vitiates the atmosphere of blog. You sometime bring refreshing ideas and facts about which I am unaware. You are also combatative in your unique way but you may avoid direct or indirect use of vulgar words. Request only.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    hillay ande kee paidaish hai.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,
    These words come out of me in frustration. The atmosphere on this forum is very suffocating and hypocritical. The Congressis give spin to everything with some backing from forum moderator. Enrich has free run here and same with Ravi. The opinions are so polarized here all the time. I find it very difficult to accept how human rights of non-muslims are any less than muslims. The views of Congressi-Jihadis keep reinforcing that muslims have first right to Human rights.

    Ravi finds unique ways to defend Rajiv Gandhi for 1984 going to the extent of calling murder of Rajiv Gandhi as closure to that riot. He subtly suggested same in case of Modi but spin doctors bombarded this forum with heaps of garbage and deleted all the counter-posts. Is this the way to debate?

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Rajeev;
    Agree with you. My general tone and tenor is always against this trend and we as a group always try to struggle against it. I like to go with these words, an Indian Army Motto: when the going get tough, toughs get going. You can also share your frustration in a way, most of us bloggers use, that way it becomes more forceful. That is what, I feel.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Totally agree..will follow your suggestion.

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think Ravi has been stamped out like a snake so that all the poison inside him goes into the drain. Frankly we should let him remain in the manhole as balwinder revealed his whereabouts.

    His shallow quotations from Wendy Donger reflected a lack of depth an intelligence. His claim to fame was having read Wendy DOniger. Doniger is a trained psychoanalyst much in the Freudian mold without a medical background psychiatrists have. Having read two books by her, I could only conclude that she belongs to a school where everything is analysed from a sexual angle.– a minar is viewd as a penis, a burqa clad woman in her book is has a mouth which is a vagina, etc etc.

    Unfotunately Ravi probably got excited having read a line or two from her book on Hindus and suddenly pretended or even beleived that he was an intellectual. He lacks the depth to understand that at the end of the day Doniger was reflecting her prejudices as well as he desire to sell a thesis.

    As balwinder revealed he is a damaged man and needs help. I hope his self pemance would make him a better human being, father and husband.

    We need to treat Engrich like Zakir Hussain lakhvi, the jehad master of kasab. Maybe Engrich even beleives the shit he writes. Funny is’nt it?

    That is life.

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    Engrich;
    Agian a friendly advise. Do you hear Quawwalis? yesterday, while sipping bear, I was hearing ” Jhoom barabar Jhoom” of Aziz nazan, and “Hamain to loot liya” of Habib Painter. try this therapy for some time, I will tell you next step. By the way I am more Muslim than you and More Dalit friendly than you and your friend. We can discuss any aspect of these two observations any time of your choice. Very busy but you are again getting very toxic.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,

    Aashish said that he is a misguided friend and even I believe that, but whatever
    we try yeh banda change hone ka naam hi nahin leta. He keeps on posting
    same things again and again. Gopiji and Rajeev posted something about
    Pakistan and he took upon himself to defend that country and in process
    posted about a dozen of his usual garbage.
    Kya karein is bande ka ?

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Mohan;
    Since now you are an honourable member of club, invitation to visit Atlanta or Vagas, all inclusive, except airfare and chips, (plastic ones). I know you like Casinos.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,

    Thanks. Yes I do like casinos and my wife more than me. I have twice been
    to Atlantic city and Vegas. Next year again planning a trip there.

    Anonymous Reply:

    MOhan

    On this blog engrich has declared that India should be fragmented and more countries like Bangladesh be formed. Do you really think we can reform his occiput? We ca only study it to see what brainwashes him and how his brainworks…

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    i did not say that india should be fragmanted.states shoul be given powere to work for betterment of their people.bangladesh can be example.neverthless anything which will come in the way of prosperity and progress will be destroyed by common man.for this also bangladesh can be an example.

    Anonymous Reply:

    read ur post which says India should be fragmented.

    Anonymous Reply:

    I was surpised that u said it. U only spoil the name of Musliims. U shud stop ir communal talk as everyone has seen ur game and c u as a jehadi joker.

    engrich Reply:

    my awnser is shut up.

    Anonymous Reply:

    My answer is U Y

    engrich Reply:

    read it is fragmentation under indian flag for betterment of people.ultimately it is people who matter most.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,

    Yes I had read that post. May be we all together can reverse brain wash him.
    Am I hoping for a miracle ?

    Anonymous Reply:

    True… If we do… I’ll send you a hamper of royal Salute while you ca semd me a dozen bottles of Chivas regal.

    engrich Reply:

    banda change hone ka naam hi nahin leta

    change for what.i should clap ur stupidities.what u call garbage is awnser to ur false claims.u dont awnser as u have no awnser.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    pankaj bhai,

    discussions always bring good result.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Shocking video .

    I think we should raise this in the United nations. Instead our FM is a wimp who will pretend this has not happened.

    Engrich and his lover will probably justify this saying that the girl has been rescued from Brhmns /zionism

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,

    US have already taken this incident very seriously and are in talk with
    Pakistan government regarding this.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    usa has already taken this incident,

    The United States has very bad karma.

    New York means materialism and greed, Los Angeles means lust and the USA in general means violence.

    Think of the Pentagon’s involvement in false flag terrorism – Operation Northwoods and Operation Gladio.

    Think of the CIA’s kidnapping and torture of children – MK ULTRA.

    Think of the CIA mercenaries known as al Qaeda.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Hi Everyone!

    Been busy with exams. Feels funy to be in text books when whole HIndustan is debating the probable collapse of this government.

    The resolt of the UP polls seems to have srprised everyone, though not too much to me. However I fervently pray– to allah and ram –that SP does not go back to its goonda past of the mifd ninties when criminals manned policestations and people were routinely shot for 100 bucks or just becasue he stared at your sister. Akhilesh does seem more sensible than his father and I hope he will not auction policestations or ban English. The Gandhi factor is waning in charisma and UPiites think Australia returned Alhiesh is as charismatic, The bad un for me was Khurshid, who had reduced his campaign to communal stunts.

    Muslims and all of UP need a national agenda which iis pure 21st century. No party– Cngress, BSP, BJP or SP had it. They have voted fo9r the best among the worst.

    Quite frankly the divide between Muslims and others has only grown after this election. Will the parties go further on this road in the next?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    In my rather frquent visits into western UP i could make out that SP was going to do wel. but not this well !

    Boss, UP is too big for a state government to really do anything . Private enterprise will go soe distance but in the end a dedicated government has to build education and infrastructure, Akhilesh seems a Good guy.

    The party…

    No comments.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Well no comments… is also a comment !

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pervez,

    Akhilesh looks like a decent chap. I think we will see a positive change in UP during his
    tenure.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I hope +ve change happens. I would agree with Vijay that UP is too big or diverse to be centrally ruled.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Parvez

    Hope you did well in your exams. we missed you.

    My gut feel is that Akhilesh will do good for all UPites, whatever the election stunt may have been. He comes across as an earnest guy.

    Congress, as usual, is trying 20th century tactics in 22nd century!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Gopi sir

    Thx I need ur wishes ! I think the COngress was badly out of synch. Rahul Gandhi sounded a bit like Mulayam of 1995 while Akhilesh sounded like Rajiv Gandhi.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Parvez,

    Nobaody takes this dunce seriously except his partner-in-his-arms. Neither do we take his views to reflect that of Indian Muslims.

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    Manohar/ Gopi:
    On Mamata: I wrote in July 2009; posting excerpts

    Many have celebrated Mamata’s ascendancy and indeed have watched with glee over the last few years how political opportunism mixed with total irresponsibility has become respectable, even mainstream in the state of West Bengal and have not blinked, because, the fire was burning elsewhere.

    As Mamata free-wheeled through alliance-making; frst the BJP, then the SUCI and Naxals and then with Congress, our political commentators were silent. It was all kosher; everything was fair game, we were told, if the Marxists can be removed from power in West Bengal.

    ……

    My fellow Indians, now our time has come. Now, we will pay the price for Mamata, as a nation. And, it will no longer be possible to ignore her.

    I refer to the “Land Bill”, which was being brought in to replace a century old Colonial law which recognised only the role of the State in acquiring land for “public purpose”.

    Mamata does not want this bill; every other political party is okay with it. Why? Because, this will be against the emotive, nihilistic and yet, electorally expedient stance she took in Singur and Nandigram.

    So, what is the solution? After all, as Nirad Chaudhuri never tired of pointing out, Bengal loves going against the tide in the rest of the country; so what if such a stance is detrimental to progress.

    There is a precedence. The Industrial Disputes Act of 1955 has specific sections which apply only to West Bengal. Perhaps, we can have the Land-Bill in the rest of the country, and have a “Mamata section” in the bill for West Bengal?

    After all, why should the rest of India pay for the inability of the West Bengal voters to know what is good for them?

    Will it stop at the Land Bill? My fear is, it will not.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish,

    Sound very ominous. I have seen her many times on TV and noticed her comments
    she makes, from all these she does not seem like an intelligent person . She only comes
    out as a very street smart person. Is there any powerful force behind her who have a
    different agenda which they believe can be achieved through her?

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    You should have watched Derek O’Brien today- on Times Now and on NDTV explain how train fare hike is against the very DNA of TMC- he used the word DNA at least 30 times. Hilarious..
    The conspiracy theory is that Mr Trivedi will continue being Railways Minister; but as a member of Congress.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I too heard that DNA theory, but then what else can you expect from Derek O’Brien.

    As per latest news, there may not be any conspiracy, Mamta Bannerjee wins, UPA loses. The fig leaf of the UPA is getting smaller and smaller and soon they have will have nothing to hide their …………..

    It seems, Kolkatta has become the capital of India till such time the general elections are held. The people of Poschim Bongo must rejoice.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Ashish

    The time is now ripe for the COngress or BJP to grab Paschim Banga and get it back into the national mainstream. Mamta can only be an eccentric catalyst for change.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    The trouble is that this is not about Mamata or CPM; it is about the nihilistic nature of the people of West Bengal. Mamata is pushing the state further down the path of CPM.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Ashish

    I think this is a lot to do with romance !!

    In the few months I lived in Cal, I discovered that the bongs (urban) at least, loved all the things they hated. They hated the British who had gone 50 yrs back… but all wanted to be the suited booted burra sahibs… One Mr C/S on this blog has actually become a pretender to be a burra Sahab.

    They loved the Communists (then) but would never have worked in the communes of mao and Stalin….

    A joint family culture which believes that Jyotida was the head of the grand Bengali family and today mamta didi is.

    HOnestly bengal needs entreprenuership success stories to fire the imagination. Prannoy can be one. Subroto Roy can be another. Kiran mazumdar another.They have to find the succes there, not outside.

    Till now all the success stories are about rebels against tyranny of the system. Never about a guy who makes the system work.

    engrich Reply:

    They loved the Communists (then) but would never have worked in the communes of mao and Stalin….

    mao and stalin both were great.bhadralok used them to hang in power.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Ashish

    I think this is a lot to do with romance !!

    In the few months I lived in Cal, I discovered that the bongs (urban) at least, loved all the things they hated. They hated the British who had gone 50 yrs back… but all wanted to be the suited booted burra sahibs… One Mr C/S on this blog has actually become a pretender to be a burra Sahab.

    They loved the Communists (then) but would never have worked in the communes of mao and Stalin….

    A joint family culture which believes that Jyotida was the head of the grand Bengali family and today mamta didi is.

    HOnestly bengal needs entreprenuership success stories to fire the imagination. Prannoy can be one. Subroto Roy can be another. Kiran mazumdar another.They have to find the succes there, not outside.

    Till now all the success stories are about rebels against tyranny of the system. Never about a guy who makes the system work.

    engrich Reply:

    ashish this is brhmnsm.always talking of war and voilence.with zero result.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Did you see a brhmns zionist conspiracy when Shuja Pasha tripped on his shoelace and fell on Kiyani’s bh_ _ _ ?

    engrich Reply:

    shuja is out and army under control.peoples power.before it was all conspiracy.

    AshishC Reply:

    The trouble is that this is not about Mamata or CPM; it is about the nihilistic nature of the people of West Bengal. Mamata is pushing the state further down the path of CPM.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,
    I really like your optimism but the fact is that people of Poschim Bonga are deeply in love with Communists and now with Mamata. After all these two favorite parties provide them with ultimate entertainment of Dharna, Hartal, Tala-Bandi..

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Rajeev

    I have become an optimist in life after being knocked around for beign a pessimist for too long !

    i think it is best to be transparent and blunt to the people. mamta or someone stand on stage and announces to the people

    Revenue collection = X
    Expenses = 2X

    People of bengal, tell me what to do?

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Rajeev

    I have become an optimist in life after being knocked around for beign a pessimist for too long !

    i think it is best to be transparent and blunt to the people. mamta or someone stand on stage and announces to the people

    Revenue collection = X
    Expenses = 2X

    People of bengal, tell me what to do?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish and others

    What we are witnessing since the presentation of the railway budget is the theatre of the absurd, unless the Congress comes up with some master stroke in a day or two. I not so hopeful though.

    How long this Government can keep getting insulted / browbeaten by Mamta Bannerjee. Any self-respecting person or a government by now would have said enough is enough, even if the Government fell

    Is there no shame left? Is clinging to power is so paramount that dignity and self respect be thrown to the winds? The statement that they have the numbers (minus the TMC) must a case of whistling in the dark – they do not have the numbers – the SP and the BSP are not playing ball.

    Disgusting to say the least.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Then we need to remember Vajpayee who refused to condone the corruption of Jayalalitha and did NOT let his governmnet survive.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    In fact the NDA was far cleaner and even kept mamta on a tight leash. Out here the UPA just leverages the CBI to retain power. They now have the CBI danda against Mayawato to get a majoirty on Uttrakhand and retain the Lok Sabha,

    Anonymous Reply:

    Self-respect and Manmohan..are like Day and Night.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Congress should pay the price to somebody else (Maulayam?) and get rid of Mamta ..let her go down

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mulayam, as his name suggest, will turn out to be a slippery customer too. The UPA has been caught in a cleft stick.

    I wish there is a general election now – this is pathetic.

  • Anonymous

    My 2 posts were deleted in last 1 hour.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Well I did see one Kapil Sibal dancing waltz with Digviansh Singh at India gate…

    Both hqd scissors in their hands. Amul baba had given them a mandate to stop all bad news…

    [Reply]

  • engrich

    what he is saying is right.u people kept india paralysed for 10 years.all ur claims were based on lies and fraud.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Well my last posting…

    Just finished three strong ones of RC and plan to crash into bed…

    WHAT WILL HAPPEN IN CASE A CHANDRABABU NAIDU or a MODI get power in paschim Banga and get in corporate culture??????????????/

    [Reply]

    Ravi Reply:

    Good night
    Sleep tight
    hope snake
    wo’nt bite

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Thx for the wishes. Wendy Doniger is writing a porno based on Freudian psychoanalusus of a sex life of a mosquito. Read it and quote tomorrow. :)

    [Reply]

    Ravi Reply:

    She already has, you are the mosqi

    Anonymous Reply:

    No I am the stamper of the snake… and u r deluded ! :)

    Dr Mishra Reply:

    wow brilliant Vijay haha

    Anonymous Reply:

    Thx Doc sahab !
    !
    I think the royal challenge inside me (dont know how many ml !) moved the keyboard…

  • Anonymous

    @ Mohan and rajeev

    Well u may wonder what keeps me an optimist. Let me throw a mysterious one. Like I said I am part of a research program– apart form my regular work in construction.

    The question we are asking is “Is it possible to have a mechanism or a machine… jo aadmi ki khopdi tune kar de… that he does not develop heart blockages, vision problems (spectacles), hypertension, sugar, diabetes, cancer … etc etc.

    Now u need to be a f_ _ _ _ _ _ to beleive that it can be done….

    Mohan I hope u have a joke ready for me 2 moro… !

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,

    I have posted a joke, but that is for intelligent men only and fortunately you
    have not yet reached that level. Lucky guy you are.

    By thy way good luck on your research program. I hope it will bring a
    revolution in medical world.

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra

    How authentic is this ? ”””””””””””””””

    SONIA GANDHI IS WORTH £ 2 BILLION PLUS
    http://www.worlds-luxury-guide.com/Luxury-News/433294/Worlds-Richest-Politicians

    anyone know, thought Indian MPs had to declare their assets and income

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra

    Parvez welcome back”””””””””’

    Akhilesh will be better than Mulayam- yes- that is a given, but then anyone will be better tahn Mulayam !!
    Dont know if you read my post last week- our extended family back in UP which was in political wilderness after the passing of Brahm Dutt, has seen the sudden emergence of a distant nephew ABHISHEKH MISHRA.
    He is very close to Akhilesh Y and is actually ex IIM. If allowed to, he can get SP moving in right direction. But you know what Parvez, I am so pessimistic about UP- so much dirt and poverty, even in Agra which – being a world calss tourist destination- desrves to be clean but is such an eyesore.
    Only Kolkata depresses me more

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    All;
    Felt so bad. Writing many a times wrong spelling of words. believe it is hurry/ pressure and no time to recheck. No excuse. Industry has taught me to own mistake. HIDING MISTAKE IS SERIOUS, ADMITTING MISTAKE IS OK. HOPE PEOPLE IN REAL LIFE ALSO FOLLOW THIS.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,

    An intelligent way to pass on a good message. I hope people will understand.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    If a 36 year old sub collector can amass Rs 115 crores…..
    I want Sharia…
    http://www.deccanherald.com/content/234409/maha-dy-collector-allegedly-worth.html

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    i hope uwill ask for sharia for following also,

    An Indian American physician in Chicago has been convicted of a health care fraud by a federal grand jury, the US Justice Department said.

    Dr Jaswinder Rai Chhibber, 43, faces a maximum penalty of 70 years of imprisonment, and a fine of $2,250,000 for being found guilty of five counts of healthcare fraud and four counts of making false statements involving a health care benefits programme between 2007 and July 2010.

    After less than two full days of deliberations following a week-long trial in US District Court, in Chicago, the jury found him not guilty of seven additional counts.

    Chhibber, who operated the former Cottage Grove Community Medical Clinic in Chicago, was convicted on Tuesday of defrauding Medicare and Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois by submitting false insurance claims for medically unnecessary tests and using false diagnosis codes to justify the tests he had ordered.

    According to the Justice Department, the evidence at trial showed that Chhibber ordered medically unnecessary tests, falsified patients’ medical records, and used false diagnosis codes on insurance claim forms in various fashions for at least five patients who testified at trial, including two undercover federal agents who posed as patients.

    Evidence also showed that Chhibber administered echocardiograms (Echo), electrocardiograms (ECG), nerve conduction studies, and carotid doppler and abdominal ultrasounds for an unusually high percentage of his Medicare and Blue Cross patients, it said

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    One deputy collector in one district of the country amasses Rs. 115 crores
    in just 12 years. It is beyond my imagination how big is the corruption in our
    country. How much the people who bribe these government official would
    be making through their dubious deals. India is such a rich country, if properly
    governed, we can do miracles, but alas …….

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    in terms of Sibbalian philosophy, in the end it is all zeroes.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Ashish

    Mamta’s Land Bill is terrible; it will freeze the state..

    Regarding your observation about whether the WB problem is due to Marxists or the inherent nihilistic nature of the populace — I tend to agree with your conclusion. The Marxists ruled Kerala for a long time, although not continuous like West Bengal; however, it was not a totally regressive one, and there were several developmental initiatives all along, especially in the last Achuthanandan minstry. So, it may not be reasonable to categorize the problem there in WB strictly as a Marxist related problem.

    Mamta should be packed off, otherwise the state is going to end up worse. I thought Mitra would do some magic; may be Mamta’s bleeding heart must be pulling him back.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Gopi,
    the problem of West Bengal is NOT a Marxist related problem. It is a unique problem more to do with the state and its citizens than with who governs them.
    It is instructive to study the timing of CPM being voted out of power:
    1. Buddhadev, after years of industrial stangnation and pathetic reputation as an investment destination- tries course correction.
    - now what led to the pathetic reputation? Militant trade unionism, poor government policies, general apathetic populace- they all had a role. You can rein in the TUs- anyway, it is difficult to continue to struggle on an empty stomach, you can change government policies but what will you do about a general populace which is happy to while away their time waiting for government schemes?
    2. Congress and Trinamool finally fight an election together. It is simple arithmetic; the combined voteshare has always been more than that of left front. Much as the INC and TMC shout in public, they will not survive in an election should they decide to fight the WB elections separately.

    Lessons from this:
    Unless the electorate in WB gets fed up of this devil and deep sea choice, and more importantly someone who is as charismatic as BC Roy or Jyoti Basu and with the right socio-economic vision emerges who can rally the electorate, I see no hope for West Bengal.

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    All;
    Trivedi resigns.
    Tail is ferociously wagging the dog.
    Not funny but pathetic.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I watched Trivedi’s interview..Pretty impressive. I think if Mamata pulls out of UPA, Trivedi will be inducted in Congress.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Will not mind if Trivedi joins Congress. At least this guy showed some ethics and was ready to sacrifice his chair.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    It is even worse than pathetic.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Manohar;
    I had to be somewhat charitable. it hurts to hurt again a self defeated UPI.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Yeh hai hamara maha shaktishaali sarkar ka badh-haal

    By its tail the dog is wagging
    its legs are wobbling
    other dogs are, in delight, howling
    Its confidence is crumbling
    with policies, it is fumbling.
    while, within itself, it is brawling,
    In front of allies, it is crawling.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    In short all our politicians are DOGS.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Thanks Shenoy Sahab.
    Yes, anybody can see this pitiable condition.

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    Vijay,
    your post to Rajeev:
    ====
    i think it is best to be transparent and blunt to the people. mamta or someone stand on stage and announces to the people

    Revenue collection = X
    Expenses = 2X

    People of bengal, tell me what to do?
    ====
    People of Bengal: “Didi, please do this:
    1. Ask the centre for a bailout.
    2. Give us doles
    3. Paint the city blue
    4. Rename metro stations
    5. Kill some CPM “harmaads”
    6. Appoint some “intellectuals” to the cultural committee of Indian Railways.
    …..
    and, if all fails, do a padyatra thru central calcutta in peak office hour- all will be well.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish

    Looking ahead, would this one and only opportunity for Mamta Bannerjee to preside over Bengal or the people will not learn and elect her again? Are they walking around with their heads held high and thumping their chests given the fact one of their own is holding the Government at the centre (and also the rest of the country) to ransom?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Aashish,

    Superb. If this is what people of Bengal are then they do not deserve anything
    better then what they have.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    .Very apt and very telling !

    I hope Dr Mitra does make some blunt announcemnets before he resigns…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    .
    Dinesh Trivedi should talk to our Dr.Mishra about swabhimaan and resign with dignity.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Another feather in the cap of Mr. Nitish Kumar.

    World record in potato production.

    http://gulfnews.com/news/world/india/indian-farmer-eyes-record-with-potato-crop-1.994750

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Great. Let it be replicated all over the country.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Amen.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Ek fakir tha. Bheek manganae ke liye wah ek masjid ke samne baitha tha. Namaz hone ke baad log bahar aane lage aur chale gaye . Lekin kisine bhi usko beek nahin dali. Nirash hoker wah ek mandir ke saamne baitha. Udher bhi kiseene usko bheek nahin dali.

    Wah utkar church, aur uske baad gurudwara ke bahar baitke bheek mangne laga. Kahin bhi usko logone kuch nahi diya.

    Akhir wah ek baar ke saamne baita. Udhar har aadmi usko dekh ke paise dalne lage. Uski katori noton se bhar gayi.

    Wah uper dekh ke bola, “hey malik, Rehte kahin ho, aur patha kahin ka dete ho”

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    One of the best.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    when he got the cycle, he should have shown some cleverness and prayed God,,,,” Hay Bhagwan, mujhe aise hi ek motor byke dilade, mein sau rupaye ka prasad chadaavoonga”.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    has cleaed my hangover !

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    Not as good as this one, but similar to this.

    A man who used to walk to his work place daily, saved enough money and
    bought a bi-cycle. Next morning he rode on cycle to his office. In the evening
    because of his regular habit he walked back home leaving his cycle behind.
    When he realized he prayed ” Oh god if my cycle is not stolen, I will offer
    Rs. 10 parsad at your temple “. Luckily he found his cycle where he had left.
    He took his cycle and immidiately he went to the temple and offered Rs.10 parsad and came out of the temple.

    His cycle was missing.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Derail Budget

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/derail-budget/923760/0

    Such Railway budgets happen rarely. Once in 10 years, literally. For Railway Minister Dinesh Trivedi of the Trinamool Congress, to muster courage and hike aam admi fares by up to 20 per cent, must have been a leap of faith. Because in India, general class passengers account for 95 per cent of total traffic. The balance 5 per cent is made up by those travelling in air conditioned coaches. The expert group for modernisation of Railways chaired by the prime minister’s adviser Sam Pitroda had recommended a one-time 25 per cent increase in fares to raise Rs 37,500 crore. Trivedi did not exactly do that but with an across-the-board passenger fare hike and a modest 5 per cent growth in traffic, the Railways projected earnings to go up by about Rs 7,000 crore in next year, 25 per cent more than the expected earnings in 2011-12.

    ==========

    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Congress should get the support of Samajwadi party – Akhilesh will sure welcome some central projects in his overall development scheme. This lady is total nonsense and embarrassment

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji/Manohar

    And she is a lady. Stree-hatt. No way she will listen to any reasoning.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    ONLY INTELLIGENT MEN SHOULD READ THIS.
    ————————————————————————

    Whenever an intelligent man has to make any important decision, he closes his eyes,
    thinks a lot, listens to his heart, uses his head and finally does what his wife says.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ MOhan

    Bachelors rock!!

    By the way getting knocked around by unmarried women is also a lesson in life. Seems MMS and Pranabda never learnt it and they are getting knocked around now.

    Atalji, with his towering personality was probably far more adept with women and handled Mamta ably!!

    Maybe Modi should give Mamta didi a call… or Nitish, who is currenlty single….

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    I am pretty optimistic for UP with Akhilesh as its leader. He has handled himself well so far. I get the impression that he has a sense of destiny, and is motivated beyond the norm of greed and power.

    With Nitin next door and Akhilesh in Lucknow, may be the two perennial laggards of Indian State will finally usher into the new era.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————-
    ~~~ ANOTHER CONGRESS CORRUPTION ~ under the garb of women’s rights ~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————-

    When, some months back I had compared the intellectual capacity of APJ Abdul kalam with Pratibha Patil, whose only claim to fame had been cleaning utensils for Indira Gandhi, Prahlad ji had howled in protest claiming that I was insulting women in general and Pratibha in particular by denying them “rights”

    Well India today had revealed another scandal from the Pratibha cupboard. After the implication of her husband then son in the cash seized, it is land grab now !

    Wah re Congress !! Kahan gaye woh Mahatma Gandhi aur Sardar Patel wale asool….

    Excerpts:
    —————————————————————- Son exploits President Pratibha’s name

    President Pratibha Patil’s son used his status to further his business and political interests

    Rajendra Shekhawat, the MLA son of President Pratibha Patil from Amravati, courted controversy on February 15 when local police seized unaccounted cash of Rs.1 crore from a car headed for his home, two days before the city voted for the municipal corporation. This is not the first time his name has cropped up for the wrong reasons. The high-profile Shekhawat, 45, allegedly used his status as President’s son to acquire a 532 sq m plot of land worth Rs.1.50 crore and in possession of the National Cadet Corps (NCC), for a college run by Vidya Bharati Education Society (VBES), a charitable body, while he was the organisation’s chairman. VBES runs 21 educational institutes including colleges and schools in Amravati. India Today is in possession of documents which show that land, which was previously with the NCC, was transferred to VBES.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    As usual, nothing will happen.

    I want my friend Egrich’s Sharia law imposed here for politicians and bureaucrats.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Gopi

    Well Sharia is certainly not possible here… but we can surely go back to the jury system as it gets us justice in a matter of weeks.

    Video tabulation, jury system, judges going to the place of the crime to see things, instant seizure of cash… so many possibilites which our lawmakers will not look at.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji/Vijay

    Something serious should be done to fast track such cases.
    They linger on for many years and by then in almost all the
    cases witnesses turn hostile by bribes/threats. There is a huge
    incentive to commit such crimes as one is almost sure of
    not getting punished.

    Anonymous Reply:

    But, first of all we must fast-track this engrich case.
    He is going off-track so fast and so often, we have to recall Sanjayn Dhawan and/or Prahlad Sir to make sense of his posts.

    Anonymous Reply:

    MOhan, it requires a governmen with Balls.

    Egver since the Dunce prince appeared and Digroydhan SIngh took charge, the government is suffering from erctile dysfunction.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,

    They have reached at such a stage that even Viagra won’t help them.

    Anonymous Reply:

    shariah is not needed.
    shaurya is what we need.

    engrich Reply:

    shaurya is what we need

    shaurya is what we need

    pundit bania dono dosron ko shaurya ke kahte hain but themselve they are very coward.dont want to die or get heart.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    Who has Shaurya in UPA.

    Sonia : Her shaurya is in crying for Batla house victims.
    Rahul : Still a Kid
    Digdrodhan : ‘ Rahulji is our only Shauryawan purush,
    wait till only 2050, he will prove it ‘
    Sibal : Zero Shaurya.
    Pranab da : Busy removing bugs from his office.
    Chidambaran : He used all his shaurya to prove that
    he was not involved in 2G.
    Manish Tiwari : Barkha Dutt asked him about his shaurya, he said ‘ Advani does not have shaurya, Vajpayee is a shauryaless person and in fact
    none of the BJP leaders have any shaurya’
    Barkha clapped when she heard this intelligent reply.

    Only shaurya, I have seen in recent times is in

    Anna and his team.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Wah ! Really gr8! Cyrus would be proud !

    Anonymous Reply:

    that is a good one….

    engrich Reply:

    it is not my law.it is law of god.best law.in nigeria and emirates even christian prefer to go islamic court and use interest free islamic banking system.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Interest free Islamic banking system ?

    engrich Reply:

    yes in uae most of the christian contractors go for this as liability is known.interest banking is another name of slavery.one of the main reason zoinists supported arab spring was to finish islamic banking system which was getting popular in middle east and africa.

  • Anonymous

    Imran Khan has pulled out of speaking at India Today conclave because of
    Salman Rushdie. Mushraff had rightly said ” Imran Khan is a Taliban without beard.”

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    Imran Khan has pulled out of speaking at India Today conclave because of
    Salman Rushdie

    and we say that we are democratic society with freedom to speech.truth is ,we want to hear what we like.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ Gopi

    Akhilesh may seem a well intetioned guy. But his cabinet has Shivpal yadav as PWD Minister which takes care of all contracts and also land for builders.

    Raja Bhaiyya his Minister was running his own private state with his army.

    I dnot think he will break away easily from the past.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I hope it is a strategy! (to get them under his purview, and then deal with it )

    I was disappointed in some of the selections; but again, I hope he did it with some endgame in mind.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Viju

    Raj Bhaiyya, as I understand, contested as an “independent”. So, the motivation of inclusion of him in the ministry may be fear or, as I hope a “strategy” to contain him. Time w ill tell.

    There is another side of me saying if one is elected, one should be considered to be in the ministry or whatever.

    We cannot have a system that willynelly lets murderers and thugs contest election. Will our honoured parliamentarians and the hallowed parliament (Manohar considers that institution as the jewel) pass a law disallowing anybody who has a criminal/civil complaint against him from contesting elctions. (of course the excuse will be that enemies will file frivolous cases)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar considers that institution as the jewel
    ———–

    You are right. If a criminal enters a holy temple, does the temple becomes less holy?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Well, we will have to enter like what we did at golden temple

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar

    On a serious note, like anything else 1) we should prevent known bad elements getting in nd 2) safeguard the state by making the ‘ggod ones” accountable once the rest gets in.

    Preventing the bad guys getting in seems to eb an easier chore. The second one as to monitoring, is more difficult, because the prosecuting organizations are under political control and bringing ion LokPal etc is tough as shown in the last years struggle.

    How can EC approve somebody like RajBhaiya contest – given the power I am confident EC will do a god job..

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi

    That would be an ideal situation. The problem is that we asking the lawmakers to enact a law that will eliminate their chances of winning more seats. No party is above board, hence the reluctance to bring in such a law.

    The EC cannot go beyond the laws that are in place. Once the law (to bar candidates with questionable credentials) is in place, of course the EC will do a good job.

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————
    ~~~~~ UNITED IN PORN ~~~~~~~~~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————

    It is coming out that 10 MLA’s watched porn in the Karnataka assembly including three for the JD and 3 from the COngress.

    I hope all the morally outraged will now throw barbs at all the 3 parties.

    Hindustan TImes which was leading the charge by naming BJP and NDTV too, in main news… should balance everything.

    Or will they now pretend that the MLA’s were following practivals of family planning classes?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Hamam mein sab nange hain.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    nange logon ko Hamam hi kyon pasand hai? Lux, Rexona, Lifebouy, so many other soaps are available.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shhhhhhhhhhhh !! Ab congressi bhi hamam mein mil gaye toh jaldi subject change karo ! Vinod Sharma and Prahlad ko achcha nahi lag raha…

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,
    This is serious matter..and current deafening silence of Congress supporters show how serious they are about anything they raise. Their only aim is to bash BJP and hindus.

    Anonymous Reply:

    The issue will now get obfuscated. TV channels will also lose interest.

  • Anonymous

    As of now, it seems, the Congress/UPA is set to call Mamta’s bluff, but then no one knows what will happen in the next one hour/day/week or so.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Team Anna behaving like Naxalites: Swamy

    http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Team-Anna-behaving-like-Naxalites-Swamy/924121/

    Janata Party President Subramanian Swamy today said Team Anna was behaving like “Naxalites” as they were “not keen on solutions” and instead bent on dragging the issue of corruption.

    “Though Anna Hazare is spreading the anti-corruption movement and wants a strong Jan Lok Pal bill to tackle the menace, his team members are behaving like Naxalites,” Swamy told newsmen, here today.

    ———-

    Read on.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Raghuraj Pratap Singh alias Raja Bhaiyya alias ‘KUNDA KA GUNDA’ is now a minister in Akhilesh’s Cabinet.

    Read the profile of Kunda ka Gunda…
    http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?218953

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ rajeev

    UP is doomed to be a dark place untli it is made smaller. Raja Bhaiya has literally been made a hero. At one point many human bodies were fished out of his lake.

    Well… do you honeslty believe UP would really change? This SP victory can probably make Mulyam the PM….

    India will then ban English and computers !

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Raja Bhaiya is not the only one in the cabinet – there are other people with criminal backgrounds too. Looks like it is payback time for Mulayam Singh Yadav and family.

    Imagine the police forced to protect people, who they are supposed to prosecute and if found guilty send behind bars.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    It is only the proximity to Delhi which makes western UP move. Go deep inside the movement is much slower than the potential . Tourism, exports, manufacturing are all victims of lax adminstration, callous po;itcians, tabad tod corruption, casteism, religious animosity….

  • Anonymous

    Sushama Swaraj and co are totally clueless and in some other planet if they believe they can win next elections by clamouring about the lack of sufficient numbers for UPA in Lok Sabha or by criticizing the railway budget as anti-people.

    UP elections have shown that these types of arguments are yesterday’s.

    BJP better have a complete overhaul of its leadership positions sooner if they want to garner a majority in the next election.

    At least do not yak when karnataka is upside down, HP assembly retention is uncertain etc..

    Get the house in order and attack from a position of strength, and attack only on items that need to be dissected – such as religious reservation, priority of FDI in retail or should it be in some other sector etc

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    That is what one has been crying hoarse about for a long time.

    Get a new set of leaders and set a new road map with a creditable agenda and push it.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    How Congress can come back

    a) Compulsory retierement to Chotta ababa, Slaman and Digvinash

    b) joining hands with Anna for removing corrpution

    c) getting some humour into life by appointinting Mohan as joke Minister.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I did not know that the Congress has gone some place. Where? You should be happy that Congress has gone and it is sliding down day by day, it ‘opens’ the floodgates for the BJP to romp home. Why do you wish to create/resurrect hurdles or you feel that no matter what the BJP has no chance? What say?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Gopi and Manohar’

    HOnestly I am not a BJP guy. Just believe that a centre right, nationalist government rules us. A disciplined party which gets discpline in daily life without being corrupt or moralisitc.

    I have met aa few netas in real life. Some work for which my small company bids for falls into the MP funds category. I know for sure… that sab ek thali ke chatte batte hai. However I know for sure that BJP is MUCH less corrupt.

    At this point with the advent of Rahul, the Congress has scored a self goal. It has ended up portraying MMS as weak and maun, with its shouting brigade maintianing that Rahul would be a better PM, even though we know for sure that he has not worked as even a peon till now.

    I the public perception now, if Rahul, without experience can be a better PM, than probably MMS is a bad PM. Further on Rahul’s shallow take on terror, Batla house, LeT shows that his word view is poor.

    Pervez made a fantastic observation. That Rahul sounded like Mulayam SIngh Yadav, while Akhilesh talked about a vision of the Rajiv Gandhi of ealry years…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Good.

    Now suggest ways as to how the BJP can become that great centre-right nationalist party that no one should have any objection to if it comes to power

    Anonymous Reply:

    Viju

    No amount of window dressing is going to help Congress.

    The only way Congress will be able to retain next Lok Sabha is by the total foolishness of NDA or the infightings of the potential third front. And my prediction is that NDA will work overtime to promote one stupidity after another, and the infightings will prevent the third front to get any meaningful numbers.. So, better get used to the fate — democracy, what a beautiful term!

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Breaking News

    2 year Falak ( the battered baby) has died. Very sad indeed.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Very sad indeed..I applaud the efforts by doctors to save her.

    Now it is time to punish parents for Child abuse.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Mamata govt receives Rs 80,000 cr investment proposals

    http://www.hindustantimes.com/business-news/WorldEconomy/Mamata-govt-receives-Rs-80-000-cr-investment-proposals/Article1-825953.aspx

    Chief minister Mamata Banerjee’s West Bengal government has received investment proposals of around Rs 80,000 crore in the first nine months of its tenure, Governor MK Narayanan told the state assembly on Thursday.

    ————-

    ????????????

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    this is like those scores from Harvard and MIT lining up to teach at Presi- Cal

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    1) Trinamool state minister dubs Dinesh Trivedi a ‘traitor’

    http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_trinamool-state-minister-dubs-dinesh-trivedi-a-traitor_1662869

    Now read this statement

    “Hakim said that by saying he had taken the Railways out of ICU, Trivedi had insulted party chief Mamata Banerjee”.

    ————

    Insulted? Phew!

    2) Dinesh Trivedi finds support in Trinamool MP Kabir Suman

    http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_dinesh-trivedi-finds-support-in-trinamool-mp-kabir-suman_1662857

    As the Trinamool Congress leadership seemed to be inching toward putting a full stop to Dinesh Trivedi’s stint as railway minister, he found a supporter in party MP Kabir Suman, who not only supported the rail fare hikes but also asserted that the railway minister was not the party’s property.

    ——–

    Interesting. How true – Railway ministry was not the party’s property.
    Read on.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Here is an interesting comment from the net.

    One thing to learn… UP was ruled by Mayawati… trouble… TN ruled by Jayalalita.. more trouble… WB rules by Mamata … further trouble.. this Government ruled by Sonia.. also trouble.. guess its time to give rest to the ladies and let some real men rule the country… let trivedi be the railway minister.. let him hike the prices.. atleast its direct hike and will go to railways.. not indirect income.. i support the railway budget..

    ——-

    Is the commentator a MCP or telling the truth?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Jayalalitha is doing a great job. She is now going for legacy.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Not necessarily. We will have to wait and see. For example, why is she opposing the Nuclear plant, when it is about to go critical, at a time when her own state TN faces a power shortage of 7000 MW units? Where was she earlier? She is like any other politician.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    manohar;
    This writer is seconding my thoughts or in reality, I am seconding his thoughts.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    All;
    Some time I find it disturbing. Most of us are highly educated and politically sensitive people. But a general trend, even amongst us is biased by regional preferences. May be it is natural or in other words, people know more about the places, where they live and surrounding area. But I feel, we should always think at a national level at least, if not in global terms. Please correct me, if I am wrong.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,
    Except for one person based in UK, everyone here including Congressi-Jihadis have national outlook. This is something very positive about this blog.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Rajeev;
    I am very happy to see this positive comment from you. No pun intended. Yes, our approach may differ but in heart of our hearts, we wish well for India. I am speaking about regional pride and prejudice( pun intended). While, Manohar and Mahesh will root for Maharashtra, Shenoy and Gopi for southern states, though, Shenoy less so, no let me correct myself, Shenoy speaks at National level. Mohan, though Gujrati, speaks at national level, Ashish, though Bengali but self admitted honorary member of North Indian society, also a national champion, Shan is Bengali champion, Vijay, may be slightly, North India biased.
    Hey friends, do not take it seriously, it is boring time here as weekend is fast approaching.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,

    I am from Gujarat but I am not a Gujarati.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    My apologies.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj ji,

    when people don’t take offence when the engrich kind spatter the blog with jihadi and anti-Hindu lava, where is the possibility of anybody taking offence to your well considered remarks couched in humorous words?

    But, let me correct you. Shan, the chingulate, is highly parochial and utterly narrow minded. Most of the time he is anti-India to.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Pankaj

    I write more about North India, only becasue I am based here. I am not biased towards anybody except…Madhuri dixit– who happens to be West :) Indian….

    engrich Reply:

    dixit are originally brhmns from from unnao u.p.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Ha!!!

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj ji,

    the “writer” conveniently forgot to emntion the biggest fraud on the electorate, Sheila Dixit.

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    Congress said that decision on Trivedi will be taken only after March break. At least some straigtening of spine by congress. Glad for it.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj

    Do not bet on it as yet. One has to wait and see by tomorrow after the budget speech – the deadline set by the Empress. Then we will know whether there is straightening or more bending.

    [Reply]

  • engrich

    Friday, March 09, 2012
    MULTI MILLIONAIRE GENERALS AND POLITICIANS& POOR PAKISTANIS

    It is often said ‘Other countries have armies. In Pakistan’s case, it is an army that has a country.’

    The Pakistani army has become the largest land owner and the biggest corporate entity in Pakistan.

    In cities, they own the prime real estate (they simply ‘conquer’ it) and you will have trouble finding an officer (Major and above) who is not also into real estate

    According to the book Military, Inc., a brigadier on average is worth a cool $50 Million.

    But that book came out in 2007 and today the armies assets have more than doubled/quadrupled

    They are also busy conquering territory in the North West, claiming civilians invited them for security.

    Of course Kayani has the nerve to claim “No military operation is going on in Balochistan”.

    On the civilian front, the economic warfare is in full swing, with the crooks at the top are busy destroying every public asset.

    Some Big examples:

    1. The national airline has been destroyed financially

    2. Pakistan Railways has been destroyed

    3. Pakistan Steel has been robbed completely

    4. Other major profitable assets like Pakistan Telecom has been sold off for a SINGLE DOLLAR (no kidding)

    5. In the last four years, more loans have been taken out under this “democratic” government than in the 60 years previous.

    6. REAL Rate of inflation is close to about 25% and increasing…Remember too that the rupee has lost 50 percent of it’s value in the same four year period.

    7. Electricity production has been turned off intentionally for up to 12 hours a day to destroy the industry (in rural areas, it is off for up to 22 hours a day)

    8. Banks are almost bankrupt

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Engrich

    That is the spirit. You should go back to Pakisitan and stop all tis from happening there. Your friend sitting in your manhole should stop reading fake conspriacy theories of pills being made to eradicate Muslims and Dalits.

    Rather both of you can contribute to humanity by working in nursery schools to teach kids ABCD and K Kh Ga instead of A=AK 47, b=bomb, c= car bomb,

    Engirch and your pal in ur manhole, love all religions and countries.

    Zindagi na mile doobara…
    Why waste it in jehad, murder, lies and fanatcism/whabbism ?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay Kumar,

    I repeat my offer of bearing 10% of the railway fare (one way) for engrich and pray for his safe delivery at Lahore, to join his fellow guttermates. I will even pray for his long stay in the gutter undisturbed and unharmed by Imran Khan’s DDT squad..

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I will pay 110% fare. 10% for Mr 10% for keeping him there

    engrich Reply:

    again no awnser.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Purchase with real Pakistani rupees or fake Indian printed in Muridke?
    ~~~

    engrich Reply:

    fake printed in jallandhar.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Has ISI started a fake dhandha thru its agents in Jallandhar also?

    You should join RAW and give all details… asn atone for the past. :)

    engrich Reply:

    fake printed in jallandhar.

    engrich Reply:

    i can purchase both of you.

    engrich Reply:

    imran khan is far better than most of our stupid politicians.the way u behaved with him shows our narrow mindednes and intolerant nature.talibans good or bad never hurt any indian or india.

    engrich Reply:

    vijay it is very difficullt to correct punjabis.they are like this.my friend is sitting on ur manhole,when he goes to shenoyv manhole.dont try to be a mahatama.u both are bunch of idiots.try to make jokes when u dont know even abcd of this.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Railway budget, MORE THAN WHAT MEETS THE EYE.
    I know dinesh Trivedi , more than what BV shenoy knows about MohanR.
    Trivedi has a MASSIVE FLAT just next to automobile association of eastern india(AAEI) head officeThe name of that complex is VIVEK VIHAR.In fact the entire TOP FLOOR of a multistoried apartment , floor space of about 3000 sq ft.belongs to him.
    A flat in that coveted area will fetch ONE CRORE.
    He graduated from HARTLEY SCHOOL , which is feeder school to St Xavier;s school.
    His father had a TRAVEL AGENCY BUSINESS which did not do a great deal of business. His METEORIC rise came when VP Singh got him elected from Gujrat(he is Gujrati but born at calcutta , probably so was his dad.
    THE WHOLE POINT OF THIS BUDGET IS TO INDUCT THIS RAILWAY SAFETY TECHNOLOGY,now this WONT BE IN HOUSE , IT WILL BE ON A GLOBAL TENDER.
    Apparently it will surpass the RAFALE deal,
    Now draw your own conclusions.
    He while being a member (all parents are) of Calcutta international School society , TOOK OVER the management by sheer canvassing and entering into understanding with”like minded” parents. Once he got control of the management , SOLD OF THE SCHOOL building and land to a property devoloper and moved the school into the hinterland of salt lake. The School is situated at the canaught circus of calcutta.
    AGAIN DRAW YOUR OWN CONCLUSIONS
    As they say Morning shows the day ………

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    If Dinesh Trivedi was so bad, then why did Mamta didi give him a ticket and get him a Ministry?

    Very bad…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I always thought he was a conduit through which marwaris funnel money into trinamool congress

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    How an the TMC call him bad when they make money thru him and come to power based on that money?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Chingulate,

    what little I know of Mohan, has made me a better person, even if slightly.
    what a lot you know about Dinesh Trivedi has made you look like a fool.

    The Railway budget presented by him looks unexceptional.
    If there is going to be corruption in the deal, there is always Anna Hazare to take care of that.

    The news is that Dinesh is the Shikhandi behind whom Pranab Da is shooting his arrows at Mamta Di.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    GOPI, PL U EXPLAIN
    Just read that while u want Afzal Guru hanged you wanted leniency on Kasab cos of his age and brainwashing etc.
    I am totally shoked, it is precisely this woolly thinking that has our country in deep doodoo. That is why Raja Bhayia kills and gets away with it , cos he can.
    Justice should be swift and mercyless for big crime. Gopi you started speaking like Ravi here, pl dont mind.
    btw where is Ravi. Which manhole he hides under reading WendyZaidHamid? Blog misses its favourite spanking ***

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    In UK they went overboard wben they punished rioteers in London. Ppl got 3 months prison for stealing 100 pounds worth goods. And in india they say, let kadab go. He is baby
    Let kanimozhi go. She is mother

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    jaan kee aman paoon to pochon,afzal guru has not killed anybody why he should be hang.only charge on him was supplying cycles to terrorists in srinagar.high court rejected these charges as cbi could not prove even this in court.providing defence lawyer to accused is mandatory,he was not provided with lawyer to defend himself.then why he should be hang.bank account of sbarwal should be checked.

    the boy who was shooting at cst station had hindu holy thread kalwa in his hand.kasab cannot wear it.to kill king of nepal 3 masks were brought by cia and brother.

    i would keen to have ur reply.if kanoon should be merciless why modi i not in jail so far.,

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think you are very high on Hashish, Bhang and Afeem…Get sober.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    on afzal guru u can check.death sentece is past on actual killers.kasab photos are available on internet.from where he got kalwa.

    Anonymous Reply:

    He is mad at the continued absence of his jihadi partner, fake Ravi.

    As usual, engrich’s Islamic out-pourings continue to entertain this blog.

    engrich Reply:

    better to give awnser.correct if i am wrong.otherwise ur vulgar language can not win ardument.this shows how much empty headed u and vijay are.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Balwinder

    I dotnt think Gopi really meant that seriously. We need to hang all the kasabs, afzal gurus– end of the matter.

    As for Ravi, I think he is undergoing a healing process where he is doing some sort of penance. His theory that US + CIA + Isreal + BJP were going to make some anti Muslim pill was not only funny but really made me doubt his state of mind.

    However thru penance I hope he will emerge a bettter man. a better husband, a better Indian… or a non Fundamantalist pakistani ( if he is pakistani_)

    My advice to the duo has been:

    Engirch and your pal in ur manhole, love all religions and countries.

    Zindagi na mile doobara…
    Why waste it in jehad, murder, lies and fanatcism/whabbism ?

    [Reply]

  • engrich

    US threatens sanctions against India over Iran oil

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Akhilesh’s cabinet, but Mulayam’s men

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Akhileshs-cabinet-but-Mulayams-men/articleshow/12283102.cms

    Excerpt

    Doubts were being raised on the Samajwadi Party’s intentions to check crime and criminals as 28 out of 47 ministers have criminal cases against them, even though a number of these cases could be political in nature.

    ————

    28 out of 47 . (59.57%)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Uncle Mulayam will pitch for the PM’s seat. Criminals will rule, English amd computers banned. Kasab will be freed.

    The dawn of new India.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    he ramachandra keh gaye siyase aisa kal yug aayega
    hansa chugega dana dunka kauva motee khayega

    siyane puchha, kala jug mein dharam karam ko koyee nahee manega
    toh prabhu bole
    dharam bhee hoga karam bhee hoga, parantu sharam nahee hogee
    bata bata par mata pitako, ladka aankh dikhayega
    raja aur praja dono iname, hogee nisdin khinchatanee
    kadam kadam par karenge, dono apnee apnee mann manee
    jiske hath me hogee lathee, bhainsa wahee le jayega
    suno siya kal jug mein kala dhan aur kale mann honge
    chor uchakke nagar seth, aur prabhu bhakta nirdhan honge
    jo hoga lobhee aur bhogee woh jogee kehlayega
    mandir suna suna hoga, bharee rahengee madhushala
    pitake sang sang bharee sabhame nachegee ghar kee bala
    kaisa kanyadan bidahee kanyaka dhan khayega

    murakh kee prit buree jueki jita buree
    bure sang baitha baitha bhage hee bhage
    kajal kee kotharee me kaise hee jatana karo
    kajal kaa dag bhai lage hee lage
    kitna jatee ho koyee kitna satee ho koyee
    kamanee ke sang kam jage hee jage
    suno kahe gopirama jiska hai ramadhama
    uska toh phanda gale lage hee lage

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ab kal yug… mod par khada hai..!

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Vijay;
    I remember, Lalu prasad insisting on Taslimuddin, as union home minister. Can you beat it. Taslimuddin is still a big time don of Kishenganj, Bihar, with murder cases against him. If this is democracy, then to hell with it.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Say no to the bully

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/say-no-to-the-bully/924335/0

    Prime Minister should have the courage to tell Mamata there’s a door out of the coalition

    ————-

    Read on.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    UPA-2: With allies like these, who needs an Opposition?
    Minhaz Merchant

    http://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/headon/entry/upa-2-with-allies-like-these-who-needs-an-opposition

    Excerpt

    As for the high command itself, it cares for little else but staying on in power which keeps the financial pipeline of corporate donations flowing. Any self-respecting political party that heads a coalition government should have dissolved parliament and sought a fresh mandate from the people rather than cravenly accept bullying by a 19-MP party like the Trinamool Congress which constitutes barely 3.5% of the Lok Sabha’s total strength.

    ———-

    A telling comment, but then self-respect, what is that, as far politicians are concerned?

    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I doubt whther Yedurappa was alone responsible for the mining mafia. They were there since 10years. Yeddy just came in 3 years back. Before that the Congress and Kumraswami were mining mafia for 7 years

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    “Good defence’. The BJP follows others and not the other way around. You example is a good one, so also the MP example above (read the whole article).

    We need a party that leads and not follows.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ manohar

    I am talking facts. All governments make money thru mining mafias. The BJP joined the party only lately as it has come to power only now. Goa mining was solely done with a connivace of the COngress. .Come to Aravali hills Haryana and I’ll show u what is happening. The Supreme court has banned mining here for the past 15 years. It goes on round the clock These are stone quarrys for building material.

    All the governments have been Congress since 86— Bhajan Lal, Bansi lal, Hooda, Except for a short interlude of Chautala.

    The Congrss MLA from the district — who is also the mining king–gave 125 maruti Zens to baratis during the marriage cermeony of his daughter. The groom came by helicopter. It was gr8 fun… I saw it from close … though I did not get a car.

    Mining is required for getting minerals and ore. Sand and grit. It becomes illegal in case no royalty is paid to the state for extracting these. Or excess is mined without showing it on record.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Even I am talking facts.

    I feel sorry for the BJP for not getting the chance to loot Haryana since 1986 (28 years is a very long time to be in the wilderness) , as a result I also feel sorry for you – if the BJP had a chance to rule, who knows, a BJP MLA would have gifted you a Skoda or a Honda car for some wedding in his family. Very ’sad’ indeed.

    The wedding description also reminds me of the wedding of Nitin Gadkari’s son in Nagpur. Details should be available on the net.

    Nobody is denying mining is required, but not illegally – whether it is the Congress or the BJP government. In case of MP, granted illegal mining was started under the Congress regime (shame on them), but why has the BJP government in power for the last 10 years, which keeps talking of good governance aka suraaj, not put an end to it and also not prosecuted the culprits indulging in the illegality under the previous regime? The same question applies to the BJP governments in Karnataka and Uttarakhand.

    I look forward to further ‘justifications’ by a person who claims he is not a BJP guy.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay does not support BJP = Manohar does not support Congress and Islamists

    I believe that.. :)

    Anonymous Reply:

    Equation balanced !

    Anonymous Reply:

    Great. You got help to get hold of ‘fig leaf’ to hide, which is the same thing as scooting. Good luck.

    I wasn’t expecting any answers to my queries above, going by your track record. Having a nerve requires courage or having courage requires nerve – take your pick.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Minhas is right about his prognosis on BJP. The broad daylight murder of the two police officers is anothere xample of the bad law nd oredr/mafia rule situation in MP.

    Modi has to be unshackled. I do not think either (a) or (b) is an issue. On (a), the press and the “ferocious cottage industry” will continue to drum up, he should ignore, as has been shown in UP elections, people vote on aspirations and who can fulfill the promise. Obviously, as a smart politician, he should decide where/when to campaign etc.

    On (b), based on what I see as the total lack of discipline and the prevalent land/mining/other mafia corruption in their states, I do not think there is much RSS influence on governing. I just cannot imagine RSS tolerating BSY tantrums or letting the mafia connected politicians continue in power.

    Modi’s consistent 12% growth should be touted – roads, 24 x7 power, etc etc.
    What India wants is that type of growth uplifting all across

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi

    I have said it before, the RSS/BJP is responsible for keeping Modi pinned down in Gujarat (of course they never tire of praising him, but have not put their money where their mouths are) and not the ’sickular’ brigade.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar

    BJP is suppressing him….
    Based on what I see in BJP states, my take is that RSS does not care a hoot as to candidates, election, governance etc — because there will not be this total lack of coherence, the level of land/mining mafia involvement , if RSS is really involved..whatever are the attributed negatives on RSS, they are pretty good on discipline, structure, execution etc.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi

    BJP is suppressing him….

    If not, how else do you explain his confinement to Gujarat and this is 2012?

  • engrich

    mera bharat mahan,

    एक सुबह 6 बजे माँ ने जोर से आवाज लगायी , बेटा जल्दी ऊपर आ जल्दी , मै डर गया की आखिर हुआ क्या ? इतनी सुबह वो क्यों मुझे बुला रही है , मै भाग के ऊपर उनके कमरे में पहुंचा , टीवी चल रहा था , माँ ने कहा बेटा बाबा के दर्शन कर ले , और बाबा कृपा बाँट रहे है , तू भी अपने लिए कुछ मांग ले , मेरा दिमाग चकरा गया , आखिर ये कौन सा खेल चल रहा है ? क्या टीवी पर देख कर अपना पर्स खोलने से पैसों की बरसात होने लगेगी ? क्या बिना कुछ किए सिर्फ बाबा के आशीर्वाद से सब काम हो जायेंगे ?

    और कल अचानक ही मैंने फेसबुक पर बाबा को लेकर बड़े आप्पत्तिजनक लेख पढ़े , तो सोचा बाबा और इस श्रद्धा / अन्धविश्वास पर आप लोगो की राय भी ली जाए :)

    फेसबुक पर युवराज सिंह की बीमारी को लेकर टिपण्णी की गयी थी , उसमे बताया गया था की कैसे बाबा ने युवराज की माँ शबनम सिंह से बीस लाख ठग लिए , युवराज की बीमारी को दूर करने के नाम पर , और अंत में युवराज के पापा ने बाबा का साथ छोड़ कर युवराज को डॉक्टर को दिखाया और उस का इलाज कराया , युवराज के पापा ने बताया की ढोंगी बाबा ने इलाज के नाम पर हर बार २० हजार रुपये फीस ली| और अंत तक रुपये बीस लाख उड़ गये उनके , जब उन्हें इस बात का पता चला तब तक बड़ी देर हो चुकी थी |

    युवराज सिंह के लुटते ही , हजारों जबान बाबा के विरूद्ध बोलने लगी , लेकिन इससे पहले बाबा ने ना जाने, कितने भक्तों को लूटा है , क्यूंकि बाबा का ये दरबार कई सालों से चलता आ रहा है , और आज निर्मल बाबा का “कारोबार” देश के हर हिस्से में अपना जाल बिछा चुका है , लोग झोली फैला कर खडें है , और अपनी मेहनत की कमाई बाबा की झोली में ड़ाल रहें है, लेकिन किसी ने बाबा का सच जान ने की कोशिश नहीं की |

    ये इस देश की परम्परा रही है , यहाँ लोग जल्दी से बाबाओं की बातों में आ जाते है , और बड़ी से बड़ी अपनी समस्या का इलाज वो उनसे करना चाहतें है , इस देश के लोगो को मुर्ख बनाना बेहद ही आसन है , और जब से मिडिया का दखल बड़ा है, इनके झांसे में बड़े बड़े विद्वान , पढ़े लिखे लोग भी आने लगे है | आज कल लगभग हर चेनल पर बाबाओं का दौर चल रहा है , हर चेनल अन्धविश्वास को बढ़ावा दे रहा है , कहने को तो हम विकसित देश बनने की और कदम बढ़ा रहें है , लेकिन आज भी हम उसी रुढ़िवादी मानसिकता में जी रहें है , जहां आज भी कैंसर , एड्स का इलाज झाडे फूकें से होता है , आज भी लड़के लड़की की शादी कुंडली , गुण मिला कर की जाती है , और फिर भी शादियाँ कितनी सफल होती है वो भगवान या बाबा ही जाने :)

    लोग अपना भविष्य जाने के लिए , अपना हाथ लिए खड़े रहेते है , घंटों लाइनों में , कुछ हमारी मानसिकता ऐसी हो गयी है , की हमे सब कुछ चाहिये , लेकिन हम करना कुछ नहीं चाहते | ना जाने इस देश में कितने बाबा आयें लोगो की आस्था से खेलें और चलें गयें , कुछ दिन भक्त उदास होतें है , और फिर कोई बाबा आता है उन्हें पुचकारता है और छल कर चला जाता है , और ये आस्था अन्धविश्वास का दौर चलता रहता है |

    मुझे निर्मल बाबा से कोई ऐतराज नहीं है , लेकिन मै चाहता हूँ की बाबा अपनी कमाई का ब्यौरा सार्वजानिक करें , यदि वो जनता की भलाई का कार्य कर रहें है , तो गरीबों को सही दिशा दिखाएँ , और अपने कमाए गये रुपयों से जनता का भला करें ना की उस पैसों को अपने ऐशो आराम पर या अपने भक्तों की भोग विलासिता पर खर्च करें | आप यदि जन सेवा की भावना ले कर चल पड़े है तो फिर आप को पैसों की इतनी लालसा क्यूँ है?

    यदि आप किसी का भला कर सकतें है , ऐसी को दिव्यशक्ति आप के पास है तो क्यूँ ना खुले दिल से और खुले मन से खुले प्रागण में और एक दम परिदार्श्किता के साथ काम करें ? ना की अपने भक्तों को टोपी पहनाने का काम |

    मुझे गीता का शलोक याद आता है “कर्म करे जा फल की इच्छा ना कर रे इंसान” , और “जो भी होता है अच्छे के लिए होता है , तो यदि आप लोगो के साथ कुछ बुरा भी हो रहा है तो उसके पीछे कुछ कारण होगा , किसी बाबा के कहने या करने से आप के दिन बदल नहीं जायेंगे , जो लिखा है वो भोगना ही होगा | सो कृपया आँखें खुली रखें और अपने आप को ठगने ना दें | श्रद्धा को अन्धविश्वास का रूप ना लेने दे |

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Budget is a bit confusing and boring today. Nothings gone down in prices…

    Big quesiton. Will Sachin get it today?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    CPM says the budget “will increase the financial burden on common man”

    BJP says “betrays the trust of common man”

    Obviously the budget has to be good if CPM and BJP has the same point.

    BJP has to stop drowning in its own ……….

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    While going by Opposition-speak is hazardous on the budget- in my view, Pranabda commits one cardinal sin – increases indirect taxes while giving exemption on direct taxes (howsoever low).
    INFLATIONARY.
    Secondly, it is the most boring budget I have seen in years- absolutely zilch in vision, initiatives.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish

    Agree. And BJP, instead of mimicking CPM’s “common man” theme, should have attacked on the grounds such as the ones you have pointed out.

    Anonymous Reply:

    The cardinal sins are needed for prudent financial management. The goodies will be there in 2013-14 budget, a year before the general elections, provided the government lasts till then.

    Who says the budget speeches are supposed to be entertaining?

    Vision and initiatives – the problem is the ‘Eastern Empress’ has put the Congress Party in a dark room without any windows.

    Anonymous Reply:

    The cardinal sins are needed for prudent financial management. The goodies will be there in 2013-14 budget, a year before the general elections, provided the government lasts till then.

    Who says the budget speeches are supposed to be entertaining?

    Vision and initiatives – the problem is the ‘Eastern Empress’ has put the Congress Party in a dark room without any windows.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish

    Now where is the famous Bong creativity in Pranabda? :)

    I think if Chidambaran and MMS were able to create euphoria with their budgets, it was becasue they were able to prokect somthing that the common man or the corporates would directly get.

    Maybe Pranab acted like a school headmaster, rather than the music teacher. He could have given sme rhetorical flourishes or even added some emphasis on one new sector to add sex appeal. It could have been solar Energy, water harvesting (to address India;s water woes) or Maybe some grand emphasis on education which gave the budget a face.

    Right now it was just a chartered accountants budget !

    PS : Vinoo dont kill me for this. I swear my CA is an interesting person… as long as he doesnt hike his fee.

    Anonymous Reply:

    All my taxed, worried, and confused blog mates,

    “I contend that for a nation to try to tax itself into prosperity is like a man standing in a bucket and trying to lift himself up by the handle”.

    — Winston Churchill

  • Anonymous
  • Anonymous

    Raghuraj Pratap Singh ‘Raja Bhaiyya’ is no ordinary criminal. He is comparable to Syed Shahbuddin (currently jailed) of Sivan, Bihar.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Rajeev

    15 human skeltons were found from a lake were he was supposed have disposed bodies of people who went agianst his writ in Kunda. This is as pwr the enquiry done by Mayawati.

    However Amar Singh Dahla thought he was the face of Thakur pride in UP. SP which wants UP mire in caste and communal occassions used him for Thakur votes.

    @ Dr Mishra

    Hope Abhishek can shake the SP out of its past by getting a radical new agenda and a bag full of ideas on how to welcome the future.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Rajeev;
    I had seen a movie: Phans gaye re Obama: a gem of a comedy. The top don in it resembles Raja Bhaiyya, immensely. He had also a lake/ Big water tank, filled with acid to throw people, who did not pay ransom money. And he was a minister a minister as well, aspiring to be CM. What an uncanny resemblence.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,

    A very fine movie. Rumors were that it was deliberate attempt to show this character
    as Raja Bhaiya.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    It’s official, the UPA is all at sea
    Siddharth Varadarajan

    http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/columns/siddharth-varadarajan/article2999595.ece?homepage=true

    Remember the old Ajit joke in which the greatest Bollywood villain of all time asks his henchmen to use “liquid oxygen” against the hero? “The liquid won’t let him live and the oxygen won’t let him die,” he explains. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh can be forgiven for feeling a bit like he’s caught in the middle of a forgettable 1970s movie. The United Progressive Alliance government he runs is all at sea and each week seems to push him further away from the shoreline. But even as ill winds buffet him from all sides — the latest tempest emanating from somewhere in West Bengal — none of the political forces ranged against him really wants to see his rickety boat capsize. Just when he is about to be swallowed up by all the liquid around him, he gets a tiny bit of oxygen.

    ———–

    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The fall in standards came only when Digivijay and Arjun Singh before him asked Manmohan Singh to make way for rahul. It was like telling the Indian public that the second best rules you right now and the real guy you deserve is Rahul.

    The low level antics of the Congress removed the moral halo the hard working, image which silent Manmohan Singh had got them.

    The UPA started tottering when to hide the corruption of 2G it started shouting BJP– something which even our own Vinod Sharma did very often on TV.

    When Digivijay chose to call 26/11 a RSS ki saazish and made fun of MC Sharma’s martyrdom at Batla house, the Congress lowered its standards to that of Lalu’s RJD and Mulayam’s SP

    It can still get back credibility if Salman Khurshid apologixes for peddling his wife’s conversion. If Rahul remounces politcs and deries dynatic succesion.

    Remember, even Priyanka’s impeccable looks and charisma could not get the Congress’ votes.

    Only trie reform and penance can.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Be careful. The record you keep playing constantly is starting to sound scratchy and there is only one.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The sun comes out of the east… the sun comes out of the east… the sun comes out of the east…

    Even if it sounds scratchy… it still remains the truth :)

    Anonymous Reply:

    I cannot argue with the fact of nature that sun rises in the east, but then we are talking about something more complex where humans are concerned and where what is truth and what is not can be very subjective. So be careful.

    engrich Reply:

    . Election is not synonym of democracy.this is game.

    Election is synonymous with democracy is a myth. The goal is to denigrate or demonize other systems and prevent a discussion of political and electoral systems where leaders are determined through non-bourgeois elections, for example, on the virtue of age, experience, or popularity of candidates. In fact, it is the capitalist system that manipulates and bribes, where a vote is a conditional term, and election is only a formal act. The mere fact that the elections are always won by representatives of the bourgeois minority makes them unrepresentative. The myth that bourgeois elections guarantee presence of democracy is one of the most entrenched, and even some left-wing parties and forces also believe in it.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Who wrote this for you ? This is not written by our friend Engrich we know.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    dono jahil tan aur man mein ek hai.. :)

    I have always maintained that guru and chela are one.

    Maybe one is sitting in the manhole just like a kangroo’s baby in the pouch.

    Anonymous Reply:

    guru and chela !!!!!!!!

    Now where did I hear that before?

    engrich Reply:

    reply if u have any.accept if it is right.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Democracy does not mean elections alone. It is one of the important pillars.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————–
    ~~~ HOW THE SELFISH & dynastic CONGRESS ~~ killed the UPA ~~~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————-

    MOst of us on this blog have done or doing jobs. And most of us know that a weak, insecure boss, plays the policy of divide and rule to undermine you, especially when he feels that your shine is greater than his.

    That is what Sonia, Rahul, Digivinash and co did to MMS and Chidambaran– and in the end the tattered UPA 2 is a joke tottering on the brink

    Yeh hai India ki Kahani… Vijay Kumar ki zubaani.. .. Here it goes.
    ======================================

    The year 2009. India was shining. The economy was booming and Indians were moving all over the world. New ideas were being talked about, the media only had success stories. Rural India too was joining the fun… and even our courts were delivering justice !

    We had a PM called Manmohan Singh, who was a professor by style– yet he delivered through his silence. Most of us believed that he was like Rahul Dravid, not spectacular, but the spine of a team, the hard working boy…

    Even when the evil ISI attacked India on 26/11, the whole country stood together, Except of course Congressis like Antulay — whom we anyway knew to be corrupt and communal.

    And then one fine day Sonia, Digvijay and the Congress probably atarted feeling insecure.

    WHAT IF MANMOHAN SINGH GETS ALL THE CREDIT ALL THE TIME?

    He was supposed to keep the seat warm for Rahul. What if he becomes independent? What if he puts up his hand for 2014? How can Rahul ever compete with a towering figure like MMS.

    From that day Digivjay SIngh , who was Rahul’s mentor, started undercutting, undermining and ridiculing Manmohan SIngh and Chidmabaran — who too could pose problems for Rahul or the Congress in case they became too “independent.”

    From that day… it has been a downward spiral each day.. each hour… each second..

    The supplicant media which survives on handouts from the Gandy’s is a major player in this game…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    About a weak, insecure boss:

    About the sorry plight of Manmohan Singh and his big boss:

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think insecure bosses are willing to destroy an organisation… just to get the shine on themselves!

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    myth of of advanis shining india was burst by people of india in election.
    on 26/11 india was attacked by sacred brhmns of IB not by isi.these people own india like pak army own pakistan.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Did the ISI tell you this or OSama in tora bora? Jish desh ka khaate hu, usko bhi salaam karo…

    Osama ke talwe chaat kar or Kasab ki puja Kar kar kewal jahunumm milega aur suar ka gosht… :)

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    i am not with osama or kasab.what i say is truth.

    Anonymous Reply:

    For the good health of our democracy, we need an equally good party to be in opposition. Given the critical mass the BJP has, can you suggest measures and the road map for it to be a good opposition party? I say opposition party, because the measures suggested by you for the Congress (if implemented) will make it unbeatable and the BJP will have no chance. What say?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I am not thee BJP’s durban, member or propgandist.

    I believe that it should

    a) ensure that it never become a dynasty party

    b)keeps its doors welcoing to Muslims to remove misivings

    c) gives 25% tickets to eminent people like Dr Kalam,

    d) Makes new members and has internal elections in each district every two years with transparency so that it becomes an exciting plac of debate and progress.

    e) Keeps up the fihgt for strong anti corruption laws

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Fine. IMO, the present leadership does not seem to capable of doing that. Who in the BJP should be told to take ’sanyas’ in the true sense of Hinduism?

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think u r wrong here

    a) The BJP gave a ticket to kalam

    b) It soes not support the synsty princple

    c) It has to improve on getting more Muslims in . however it maintained moral rectitude and pricnples by not succumbing to the idea of reseravtions on communal lines

    Anonymous Reply:

    1) Ticket to Dr. Kalam?

    For you information, Dr. Kalam was not the first choice of the BJP, it was the late Bhairon Singh Shekawat (no problem with that per se). When it was found that there were not enough takers mostly among its allies, they settled for Dr. Kalam. So do not make a virtue out of a compulsion.

    2) Does not support dynasty principle?

    A few months back I had given a long list of dynasties in the BJP – if you care to remember and not use selective amnesia.

    3) It has to improve on getting more Muslims in

    Improve, but how? You have to spell that out in detail. Like who are the leaders, because of whom the Muslims are not ready to play ball.

    Anonymous Reply:

    The BJP NOMINATED a kalam for the presidentship It could have been a ticket, had the Congress gone ahead with pushing its own candiate. Compare this with Cognressis giving it only to Congressmen, inculding questioanbale choices like Pratibah Patil. Of course you wont notice the difference in intellect between kalam and Patil

    If you call BJP a dynasty party it is a joke !! A dynasty party is one which keeps the top job only for the dynasty.

    In case Rahul remained just a samll worker or maybe just an MP , I would not call it dynasty. or incase Mrs Gandhi had restricted Sanjay and Rajiv to be just MP’s it would just have been a political family.

    Even a non rocket science student will note the differn

    Anonymous Reply:

    The BJP was ‘forced’ to nominate Dr. Kalam (no questions about his suitability and credentials, he was a great President). You can continue to make a virtue out of a compulsion, I have no problem with that.

    I have noted the ‘finer’ distinctions you have made in your arguments, depending upon .at what you are looking at and which side of the fence.

    Anonymous Reply:

    When the Congress was NOT compelled to chose between MMS and Rahul… it still chose the dynasty.

    Can you see the difference in approach?

    Anonymous Reply:

    I am not making a virtue out of Congress’ ways. They are like that only.

    The question was you trying to make a virtue out of

  • Anonymous

    Sachin has done us, all Indians, proud.

    He has silenced all the nay-sayers, doubting Thomases and antsy aunties.

    A VITAL QUESTION: WHY HE TOOK SO LONG TO REACH THERE?

    SEE THE IMAGE
    —————————–

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    One more century by Sachin and one more loss by India. Our bowlers some how
    make sure to lose the match whenever Sachin score a century. No matter who
    are the opponents.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I lpved Sachin’s century. But I know he took 30 balls extra for it. With 5 wickets stqanding we could have got 30 extra runs… and the match.

    The bowling is pathetic. This new coach is bad

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Against Bangladesh this score could have been easily defended. India took Bangladesh
    for granted. Anyway it was good to see Sachin among runs after a lean patch.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Narendra Modi on Time’s cover page

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Narendra-Modi-on-Times-cover-page/articleshow/12296366.cms

    Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi figures on the cover of the forthcoming issue of Time magazine which praises him in an article for development of the state he has been ruling for over a decade but wonders if he can become the Prime Minister.

    The cover of the Time magazine’s March 26 issue features Modi, with the caption: “Modi means business but can he lead India”.

    ————–

    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The US probably senses that Congress is no loger in a position to push reforms and free enterprise as it is tottering under corruption and dynasty hangups. the baisc premise fo the US is meritocracy. Despite all its flaws the Ameircan dream was always from Log cabin to White house.

    The Congress in its current acatar and the dynastic constupation it suffers from is very different from the American dream…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    Very soon we will hear that US granting him a visa.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    If I am on a Newsweek cover, can I get an USA visa?

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    More likely than not.

    Anonymous Reply:

    One of the greatest men ever walked on this earth, a small frail man from Gujrat, MohanDas Gandhi, stated once that “poverty, bu is the worst violence”.

    It indeed is heartening that another son of that region is doing all he can to alleviate poverty through incredible growth. A consistent 11-12% growth over all these years is a huge feat (ya, one man doesnt do it by himself, the platform was built and handed over to him, Gujratis are entreprenurial, so a tree could have had the same results………go on)

    I have not computed what india’s growth will be (from the current 6.5 or so) if Gujrat grew only at 6%.

    India has wretched poverty in many regions; I hope he becomes the PM and ushers in 11% growth , reducing poverty.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Good luck to you and Modi.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @Gopi Thomas , THE ILLUSION CALLED PERCENTAGE GROWTH
    ew Delhi: In a study done by Abusaleh Shariff, chief economist at the National Council for Applied Economic Research (NCAER), Gujarat surprisingly emerges as a State with high levels of hunger, while simultaneously boasting high per capita income and consistent income stability.

    The hunger levels in Gujarat are higher than in Tamil Nadu and West Bengal, and surprisingly even higher than in Uttar Pradesh, according to the study, which is based on statistics compiled from a variety of sources: 61st round of the National Sample Survey; the Human Development Survey of the NCAER, deprivation data presented by the Sachar committee and the annual reports of the Reserve Bank of India.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Must be bunkum

    i have yet to see a gujrati beggar … or a Sikh beggar..

    Anonymous Reply:

    “I have yet to see a gujrati beggar”

    You must be surely living on a different planet. Can we have its name?

    Anonymous Reply:

    I dont see them in Delhi… where beggars form all states accumalate. And hoestly I have not seen a Sikh beggar all over the world.

    Anonymous Reply:

    ‘I dont see them in Delhi’.

    Therefore, can we conclude that what you do not see in Delhi does not exist? By your logic, Taj Mahal does not exist. Hai naa?

    Anonymous Reply:

    They are beggars from many states near the Taj Mahal. Just to pass time,,, I spoke in Punjabi and found NOT a single beggar from Punjab.

    engrich Reply:

    they are overrepresented in brothels.

    Anonymous Reply:

    shame on you for exploiting women in brothels. Kya yehi seekha hai mazhab se?

    Anonymous Reply:

    shame on you for exploiting women in brothels. Kya yehi seekha hai mazhab se?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Either the someone moved the Taj Mahal lock, stock, barrel & beggars to Delhi or you stood on top of the Qutub Minar, saw and spoke to the beggars on their cellphones to check their antecedents.

    Your defence of Modi is without ‘parallel’ and very ‘admirable’.

    Fan(atic) ho to aisaa.

    Anonymous Reply:

    I have never deffended Modi ever !!

    Well yes… you go out of the way to defend dynastic succession… like a sycophant..

    Now dont call this abuse. You call me a fantatic when I defend India and dont want its democracy destroyed by sycophants and fuedal slaves who want to live life as domestic servants :)

    Anonymous Reply:

    You can assume anything about me and which you do without ever reading my posts and links.

    I cannot and do not wish to change your mindset and ludicrous thought process. Reveal in your own make believe world.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Khapodia , I will write about china in coming days . However given your INCLINATIONS which are DHANDHBAJI supercedes RATIONALITY, here is something I saw in a A Tv documentary about china.
    THIS HOW CHINESE DO IT , WILL COME IN HANDY IN YOUR TRADE.
    When Chinese want to bribe a bureaucrat , they dont just carry a suitcase full of notes to the house.
    The BUILDER’S wife or mistress invites the bureaucrat’s wife to a game of MA JONG .The wife mistress WILFULLY loses passing on the intended cash

    engrich Reply:

    sikh is small community.their collaboration with british invading robbers gave some relief to their
    community.during british days they almost had reservation on some jobs.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Delhi should be called national begging capital.

    engrich Reply:

    best prostitutes and dancers in india have gujrat their origin.

    ahmadabad built by sultan ahmad shah was most beautiful city of world in 16th century with running water and street lights,when london and paris had houses of clay without any facilities.

    AshishC Reply:

    I object to dancers and prostitutes being mentioned in the same sentence-
    some of these sentences are a dead giveaway and speak volumes about who you are and what you represent.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Ashish

    We all know who the remote control, sitting in his manhole is :)

    Anonymous Reply:

    Now Shan, you are not ‘allowed’ to do that. Why taint a ‘good’ painting? In the bargain, you may be spoiling his chances of taking a shot at the top political office.

    You cannot ‘connect’

    1) progress and development – 6/8 lane highways and roads, spanking new malls, auto factories, uninterrupted power supply, etc. (all very well, remarkable and required)

    and

    2) human development indices, justice not delivered, a section of people ‘dumped’ within the breathing distance of Ahmedabad’s biggest garbage dump as part of rehabilitation, etc., etc.

    Anonymous Reply:

    The cover.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Will support govt even if TMC quits: SP

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/will-support-govt-even-if-tmc-quits-sp/924638/

    Excerpt

    “If Trinamool pulls out, our outside support will continue to the government,” Samajwadi Party MP Shailendra Kumar said.

    He dismissed speculation that the Samajwadi Party will be part of the Union Cabinet, saying, “There is no such thing.”

    ————–

    Is this a message to tell Mamta that it is the end of her Didigiri?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    MMS and Sonya should meet with Akhilesh and his father, give some major projects to UP so the son can show some immediate accomplishments, and get an iron clad support agreement from them.

    Mamta has done too much damage

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi

    It looks like that has already happened and the CBI will also take a very long rest in pursuing the cases against them.

    Dinesh Trivedi is still the Railway Minister.

    ————

    BTW, what do you think the BJP will do re: hike in rail fares? Will it support it or side with Mamta Bannerjee to roll them back?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Akhilesh sacks his people for vandalism.

    http://www.rediff.com/news/report/akhilesh-sacks-ten-for-vandalism-at-swearing-in-ceremony/20120316.htm

    This man may make a difference.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    With 60% of his cabinet filled with criminals, do you still think so. He has taken action against insignificant section of his party – who can be dispensed with.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Small steps ! But let me tell you a true incident. Today afternoon in greater Noida… an extortionist from factories who had hidden during mayawati’s time was checking out whether business would begin again.

    Builders too are being given the signal that their rpojects wont suffer— i.e alotments given by mayawait for money– provided they do the needfull. Hopefully Akhilesh does not know about this. But the whole thing is too big for those gurgaas to do all this without some signal from the top…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan,
    Akhilesh is only a puppet..Mulayam has the remote control. It looks like Mulayam has decided Sonia style of governing the state.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————–
    ~~~~ TRUE COMEDY FOR THE NIGHT ~~~ why UP can’t change easily ~~~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————–

    @ Mohan and Rajeev

    here is true comedy of real life.

    UP has had a SP and BSP government like Ying and Yang. Now I wont name when it happened.

    ———————————————————————

    Some years back I was travelling inside UP and had to meet a person in the engineering division, Now when I went there, there were a row of gypises and white Ambassadors outside his office. Apparently there was a CID raid on…

    Is this the right time to meet him ? I wondered and decided against.

    But his peon saw me and said, : No problem… sahab is waiting…”

    I went inside his room. The CID was waiting there. Now I had only come to meet him to deliver to him a gift packet my brother had been given by his son in London. Still I felt uneasy seeing the CID…

    Ang now beigns the comedy.

    My apprehension and the CID! I have seen CID in films… Dev Anand to Akshay Kumar. But UP CID was a class apart. Pot bellied, smoking bidi and cigarettes pointing at the cieling and repeating BC and MC in each sentence… ( BC not being before Christ but… behen… and MC u can guess ! )

    On the officer’s tabnle were zonal plans of the devekpoment of the city and account balance sheets…

    Funnier was their mission. A real hoot. They had come to check out the corruption in the office…

    Not to root it…

    But to ensure that at least 70% of the money collected reached the CM !!!

    Wah WAh Wah !!!

    Can UP really change ????/

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,

    What you described is real India. A neighbour business premises was raided by IT
    department about three years ago. After about a week I ake him about this. He told
    me that he had to pay 30 Lakhs in bribe to get clearance and he was taught different
    novel ways by those IT officials how to manipulate the books to make much more
    than he had paid in bribe.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Just shows why we need a serious anti corruption body !! All this is a black comedy… a theatre of teh absurd

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Mamata Banerjee AN APRAISAL
    First the BACKDROP.
    Luck , fate , chance plays a role sometimes big in an individuals life. It similarly plays even bigger role in a nation’s life.
    If CPM rule was like Plague, the worst part was bengal instead of getting antibiotics or rat killing poison, was saddled withCONgress , aptly named the B team of CPM.
    So BENGAL DID NOT HAVE ANY OPPOSITION FOR 35 YRS , till the advent of Mamata banerjee. That congress was in cahoots with CPM was loudly and unhesitantly stated by no other than Jyoti Basu.
    When CONgress MLA’s were goading Jyoti Basu for his BLIND SPOT regarding the shenanigans of his IMBECILE son Chandan Basu , he retorted”You people I am told go and party with him all through the night with loud music ”
    So support for Mamta Banerjee was like A DROWNING MAN CATCHING TO A STRAW.
    Now MAMTA’S BACKGOUND
    She is from a RURAL PEASANT BACKGROUND BUT FROM WEST BENGAL , most of the leaders of CPM are refugees from East Bengal(Bangladesh)
    Her parents left RURAL BIRBHUM for calcutta , and his dad ran VERY SMALL kinara shop , in bengal known as mudir dokan. These shops are equivalent to SUBSISTANCE FARMING.She graduated from a NON DESCRIPT girl’s college , a measure of its stature can be ascertained from the fact that it operates only from the hours 0800 to 1200 hrs OUT OF A PROPER DAY COLLEGE.
    She did BA in History , but knowing Indian education , this was ROTE , also most likely answers written in bengali , thus the vista limited. She also did MA in ISLAMIC HISTORY , again this is ROTE .I have read the answer paper of a relative who got FIRST CLASS FIRST from an University in Bihar.It was COPY AND PASTE from a couple of textbooks.Mamata most probably just scraped through.
    SO THE SUM TOTAL IS , SHE IS INTELLECTUALLY very limited.
    As to her STREET POLITICS and HISTRIONICS one has to keep in mind SHE HAS TO CONTEND WITH THE VERMIN PARTY, thus a highly intellectual guy will commit
    Suicide, if he sticks to his taste and manners.A POLICEMAN DEALING WITH RAPISTS WILL SPEAK THE LANGUAGE OF RAPISTS.
    And there is another thing about her being a SPINSTER, woman with ZERO SEX APPEAL.Woman have limitation NOT JUST FIVE DAYS IN A MONTH, if it very difficult for them to be RATIONAL AND ADMIT MISTAKE.
    Yet if she wanted she could have had Economic advisers that will give WHITE HOUSE run for its money , here are some names Prof Pranab Bardhan of Berkley, Prof amartya sen , Kaushik Basu of Columbia , Debraj Roy (now lapped up as prof in Newyork university) .In fact out of ten members in Govt of Indis’s Economic Advisory Committe five are bengalees. ARJUN SENGUPTA , and AMITABH something , and HOST OF INTELLECTUALS STILL LOCKED IN INDIAN INSTITUTE OF STATISTICS and other institutions in calcutta.
    YET SHE CHOSE FADED stars of Tollywood.
    Actually i am not sure if she has a council of advisors.
    HER EVERY ACTION IS A KNEE JERK REACTION, hope she learns fast HOW TO SPEAK LIKE A TRUE POLITICIAN , where you essentially dont give way anything and just waffle your way through , rather than taking BLACK AND WHITE PSITIONS.
    Rajiv Gandhi is an example of how not to speak while in politics

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    There is a flip side. Whether the economic advisers and other professionals you have mentioned were/are ready to associate themselves with Mamta Bannerjee? She had given indications of her unpredictable ways and knee jerk reactions, when she was with the NDA 12 years earlier.

    IMO, she will remain a street fighter. Administration is not her dish of ‘Machher Jhol’.

    BTW, Mr. Kaushik Basu is the Chief Economic Adviser – Ministry of Finance, Government of India.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Nirodh babu

    U sound confused as ever. The problem is Mamta’s hysteria which your posts often reflect. Take a cold water bath and post something in logical sequence.

    Because of her low education and small world view, I should forgive her?

    She painted the trains in what at best can be called a tribute to the aethetically challenged. Every day she lowers the level of political discourse by stalling the entire country. She has had her moment of glory. History should bypass her now :)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Khapodia , you need not forgive her BUT SO HANG THE PORTRAIT OF YOUR GUIDING LIGHTS FROM YOUR STATE , BANSI LAL , BHAJAN LAL AND TAUJI

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Nirodh babu

    My state is India… my heart is India… My love is India…

    In sharp contrast to u

    Nirodh babu’s love is being a wog

    Nirodh babu’s heart is parochial Bengal but heart attacks are
    Goras

    Nirodh babu’s state is… a confused abusive state of mind !!
    :) :) :)

    Cheers !

    Anonymous Reply:

    Khapodia , your state is GORA DHANDHA, YOUR LOVE IS SOHO AND GORA BRAND WHISKY,
    and your heart ….. well that is sadly MISSING, or sold to the devil (read backhanders)
    Chao

    AshishC Reply:

    Oh, Vijay…. c’mon..
    forgive her, because she truly does not know what she does :D
    Under IPC, insanity is a defence; juveniles get a long rope too.
    That is what Shan is arguing for- as her defence lawyer, he is pleading insanity.
    Or immaturity..
    But, you must give Shan credit for such a wonderfully confused pen-potrait of Mamata- his description matches the subject- both are all over the map.
    I kept reading and knew Shan would bring in sex deprivation somewhere.. he did not disappoint. :)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The difference between a marketing guy and a FRCS surgeon ,is like between a peasant and an plant biologist.A doctor is the next best thing after god when it comes to matters relating to his creation

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    You are full of surprises. Sometime your posts are
    full of knowledge — though your arrogance is also
    visible from those posts, but I am ok with that – and if I
    compare this post of yours with other posts, it leaves me stupefied. What is the relation of this post with
    the topic ?
    One of my very close relative is a Doctor, and an extremely good surgeon.

    He beats his wife regularly. Should I call him god too ?
    I did not know that profession makes a person
    perfect or imperfect, good or bad.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan,

    your relative surgeon may be beating his wife.
    But God alone knows how many patients Nirodh Babu has put to permanent sleep.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Really really funny!!

    Anonymous Reply:

    God alone knows how many people’s loan were blocked because the konkan ex bank manager would not release them without a CUT

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish, I like the bit about Shan being a defence lawyer.

    Here are a few howlers which defence lawyers must read:

    Most lawyers try to make monkeys out of witnesses, by brow-beating, badgering, hectoring, and/or confusing them.

    But here, we have, the reverse; court records, word for word, show lawyers tooare sometimes made to look idiotic, stupid and/or plain confused by witnesses:

    ATTORNEY: Now doctor, isn’t it true that when a person dies in his sleep, he doesn’t know about it until the next morning?
    WITNESS: Did you actually pass the bar exam?
    ____________ _________ _________ ______
    ATTORNEY: The youngest son, the twenty-year- old, how old is he?
    WITNESS: He’s twenty, much like your IQ.
    ____________ _________ _________ _________ ____
    ATTORNEY: Were you present when your picture was taken?
    WITNESS: Are you shitting me?
    ____________ _________ _________ _________ __
    ATTORNEY: She had three children, right?
    WITNESS: Yes.
    ATTORNEY: How many were boys?
    WITNESS: None.
    ATTORNEY: Were there any girls?
    WITNESS: Your Honor, I think I need a different attorney. Can I get a new attorney?
    ____________ _________ _________ _________ _____
    ATTORNEY: How was your first marriage terminated?
    WITNESS: By death.
    ATTORNEY: And by whose death was it terminated?
    WITNESS: Take a guess.
    ____________ _________ _________ _________ _____
    ATTORNEY: Can you describe the individual?
    WITNESS: He was about medium height and had a beard.
    ATTORNEY: Was this a male or a female?
    WITNESS: Unless the Circus was in town I’m going with male.
    ____________ _________ _________ ________
    ATTORNEY: Doctor, how many of your autopsies have you performed on dead people?
    WITNESS: All of them. The live ones put up too much of a fight.
    ____________ _________ _________ _________ __
    ATTORNEY: ALL your responses MUST be oral, OK? What school did you go to?
    WITNESS: Oral.
    ____________ _________ _________ _________ __
    ATTORNEY: Do you recall the time that you examined the body?
    WITNESS: The autopsy started around 8:30 p.m.
    ATTORNEY: And Mr. Denton was dead at the time?
    WITNESS: If not, he was by the time I finished.
    ____________ _________ _________ _________ _____
    ATTORNEY: Doctor, before you performed the autopsy, did you check for a pulse?
    WITNESS: No.
    ATTORNEY: Did you check for blood pressure?
    WITNESS: No.
    ATTORNEY: Did you check for breathing?
    WITNESS: No.
    ATTORNEY: So, then it is possible that the patient was alive when you began the autopsy?
    WITNESS: No.
    ATTORNEY: How can you be so sure, Doctor?
    WITNESS: Because his brain was sitting on my desk in a jar.
    ATTORNEY: I see, but could the patient have still been alive, nevertheless?
    WITNESS: Yes, it is possible that he could have been alive and practicing law.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    Very funny.

    And this one:

    Attorney : You and your brother are the only two
    children of your parents.
    Witness: yes
    Attorney : One of you was killed in an accident?
    Witness : Yes
    Attorney : Which one was killed ?
    Witness: I wish it was you

    Anonymous Reply:

    Both u guys should be joke Minsters in the UPA to get the smile back on MMS’ face…

    Anonymous Reply:

    Unfortunately, nobody can be certain that MMS is smiling. Look at this image

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Ashish

    I think Shri Shan… remains a bit too pareshaan.
    Quite incoherent reactions like that of Mamta…

  • Pankaj#1

    All;
    One way to remove tag of being communal party, BJP may induct as many as 10% members from Muslim community. But they should be people of high caliber and impeccable credentials. They must not admit rabble rouser and people with hidden communal agenda. All the progressives amongst them should have a chance to join any party of their choice.
    I remember, Najma Hepatullah had joined BJP. Bashir Badar from Meeruth, a highly respected Urdu poet had supported BJP and scores others I know and do not know. This step may galvanize party, remove the tag of of being communal and only people like Shoeb, Rizwan and their ilk should be admitted. Not Taslimuddin or Shahabuddin variety.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Good suggestions.

    Najma Heptullah joined the BJP on the rebound when she was denied renomination to the Rajya Sabha (after 4 terms) by the Congress Party in 2004.

    She was fielded by the BJP as a candidate for the post Vice-President in 2007 and lost.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    najmaheptullah or bashir badar are not representative of muslim community.muslim leaders should come from slums of mumbai,delhi and gujrat.who knows the pain of community use their position to uplift community.azam khan is an example.he is from very very poor family.was a fighter from begining.did so much for rampur that all commuities supported him and won election with record margin of 63000 votes.that amarsingh,jai pradha and others were camping in rampur to see him defeated.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Muslim leaders don’t live in slums.

    Anonymous Reply:

    najmaheptullah or bashir badar are not representative of muslim community

    Why not and who says?

    engrich Reply:

    Not Taslimuddin or Shahabuddin variety.

    add vanjara amit shah and narendra modi also.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Zionst Brhmnst magazine, Time is featuring Modi on its cover.

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra

    DID AZIM PREMJI REALLY SAY THIS ””””””””””””””

    this came to me in an email- dont know if it is true-


    Wipro chairman Mr. Azim prem ji’s comment on reservation:

    * I think we should have job reservations in all the fields.
    I completely support the PM and all the politicians for promoting this.
    Let’s start the reservation with our cricket team.
    We should have 10 percent reservation for Muslims.
    30 percent for OBC, SC /ST like that. Cricket rules should be modified accordingly.
    The four hit by an SC/ST/OBC player should be considered
    as a six and a six …

    Bowlers should bowl maximum speed of 80 kilometer per hour to an SC/ST/OBC
    player. Any delivery above this speed should be made illegal.
    ….
    Let’s recruit SC/ST and OBC pilots for aircrafts which are
    carrying the ministers and politicians (that can really help the country)
    Ensure that only SC/ST and OBC doctors do the operations for the ministers
    and other politicians. (Another way of saving the country..)…

    [Reply]

    Dr Mishra Reply:

    another cheeky email came thru-
    ‘ Glad didi,bhenji and Amma do not have children…..’

    [Reply]

    Dr Mishra Reply:

    AND THIS CAME THRU- IS IT TRUE-
    ‘ religion-based scholarship, INR 30000 to every 10th pass Muslim girl- Way to Akhilesh – you’ve to beat Mulla-yam Singh after all! ‘

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    mishrajee,

    jis samaj mein bhai bhateejawad duty hai wahan reservation is must.post of patwari or lekhpal,no special education is needed,in up muslims are about 20%,while muslims hold only .6%(less than 1%) .same in other departments.
    department is must otherwise bharat mata will look deformed.

    [Reply]

    engrich Reply:

    we have policy of grabbing the cake instead of increasing it.cash from swiss banks,ashrams,dargahs and temples must be confiscated and brought back into economy.economy will double no need of resevation.muslims are hardworking,intellegent race.every city of up is known with their skill.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    dargahs and mosques, even the most dilapidated, are secularism-protected. Nobody can touch them.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Level playing field literally got a whole new meaning!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Dr. Mishra,

    This E mail is making rounds since few years. Take this as a joke only.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Gnight everyne.. Its almost 3 India time. I am not sure whether the human brain can read gravity and light as a single signal.

    Worth exploring 2 moro..

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    An Advice to Mamata (for whatever it’s worth)
    Next time a woman in raped in plague ravaged west bengal , dont get riled .Just say it is a shameful day for west bengal , my govt will do everything to nab the rapist ,we are a govt only 9 months in office, but our resolve should not be underestimated.
    PEOPLE SHOULD KNOW THOSE DAYS WHEN THE RAPIST DUE TO THEIR CONNECTION WITH CPM LEADERS USED TO MOCK THE POLICE ARE OVER.
    Similarly EVERY little incidents , just say we are WITH THE PEOPLE , WE ARE WITH THE VICTIM , give us time we will turn it around . 35yrs pent up garbage will take time .
    FORM A COUNCIL OF ADVISORS, from ACADEMICS , and their words should guide the future policy.
    On a small note , please refer to an Email sent to trinamool’s office by yours truly, which is packed with ideas to transform bengal

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Again the same.

    Who in his sane state of mind wants to associate with a hysterical personality?

    There has to be a method in one’s madness, even that is missing in the DNA (courtesy Derek O’Brien) of the Didi and the TMC, as demonstrated time and again for the last 10 months.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    On a small note , please refer to an Email sent to trinamool’s office by yours truly, which is packed with ideas to transform bengal
    - blind leading the blind?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Blind leading the blind
    Bengali CRAB in action

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Blind misleading the already misled blind.

    Anonymous Reply:

    :) Good one~!

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    My 3 posts were deleted today.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Rajeev,

    Try changing your ID.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I won’t do that because I hate deception. Thanks for suggestion anyway.
    I’ll keep shaming the coward who parachuted and then vanished.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Rajeev,

    I did not mean that. Try changing only spelling of your name .

    Anonymous Reply:

    Clunky Lad! Don’t be a rondu !

    Anonymous Reply:

    Coward..stop hiding..Your kind of scums need kick..

    Anonymous Reply:

    Clunky lad ! You definitely had a problem with your education. Stop jumping to conclusions.

    Anonymous Reply:

    a few more ‘e’ s may help beat the censor, Sanjay Dhawan.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Sanjay Dhawan has no time for eeeeeeeee’s !

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Rajeev

    I think ur name must have been sent to the censor. As Mohan suggested that why dont u change ur initials or just an alphabet. Now dont let the censor intimidate you… Your presence here is ur choice and your relationship with the people here. Not because of the censor.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Another must read.

    National interest: The Trivedi Tutorial
    Shekhar Gupta

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/national-interest-the-trivedi-tutorial/924740/0

    Excerpts

    His (Dinesh Trivedi) fate will also be a black mark on the CVs of the reformers of 1991 who continue to lead this government. There is no alibi in compulsions of coalition politics. The rail budget was a collective, cabinet decision. And having “bitten the bullet”, the cabinet should have collectively risen to defend a minister who only followed its agenda. So, why did they not do it in 2012, when the very same people had put their heads on the line in 1991? Why does the UPA think its risks are higher today? Or that it has more to lose, than even in 1991 when it was a minority government? Has the reformers’ will weakened? Has the economic success of these two heady decades made us lazy, and smug? Or, most worrying of all, have we become cowardly?

    What Dinesh Trivedi’s fate tells you is not about the Indian Railways, about how such a crucial — and once marvellous — element in our national infrastructure has been destroyed under serial populists. Or about the fate of one man who tried to pull it back, literally from its excreta-laden tracks, to some kind of dignity.

    —————

    Dinesh Trivedi is merely a pawn. He got caught in this chaotic retreat from reform economics by the champions of 1991. He has blundered in taking them at their word, and in relying on their reputations. But if he is martyred now, he will be hailed as the first Indian who sacrificed his job for his commitment to reform so virtuous even his unions are backing it. He is a political lightweight for sure.

    ————

    The most pathetic thing now is the way the leaders of the UPA are running from the issue.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    IMO the difference between 1991 and now is the leadership of congress. In 1991
    people like Narsimha Rao and Kesri were easily accessible and most of the prominent
    leaders would meet and arrive at a collective decision. The scenario is different now,
    everyone waits for high command to tell them what to do/say, which creates confusion
    and indecision.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    There is truth in what you say. Shekhar Gupta is bang on target.

    One only hopes that the Congress Party takes cognizance of it and not leave Dinesh Trivedi in the lurch – he is already a persona-non-grata in the TMC. Does Congress High command really care? I do not think so.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan,

    There is a saying, “familiarity breeds contempt”. Sitaram Kesari was so familiar and accessible as congress president, thery removed his chair and gave it to a green horn apolitical Nehru family successor when Kesari was in the toilet!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @Manohar T , given your background is maths and physics , one would have expected better.
    DO YOU HAVE A SCIENTIFIC APPROACH TO ANANLYSING MATTERS , or are you one of those “marketing guys” who graduated in science or engineering , but had the aptitude of a bollywood comedian.WHEN IT COMES TO SCIENCE.
    Sekhar Gupta is another guy FULL OF GENERALISATION .Lets join the BANDWAGON.
    Now I SUPPORT FARE HIKE, but with a caveat.
    The fare hike may look only 2 paisa /km for the suburban and 2nd class tickets , BUT IF YOU READ THE FINE PRINT, apparently after 5Rs there is a MULTIPLE , and that in effect can raise fares by Rs 40 , which is high IN A COUNTRY WHERE 50% GO HUNGRY EVERY NIGHT.
    Barring that FARE HIKE IS FINE.
    But it is not FARE HIKE,that is important , which plays a small part , IT IS ONLY GOOD AS A WAY TO REDUCE DEMAND. To INCREASE YOUR INVESTMENT IN ANY BUSINESS you dont rely on your revenue , for they are PITTANCE , you TAKE LOANS. Nobody does business with their own money . It isalways through loan , and there are hundreed modality to secure them , conventional as well as non conventional. Only thing to keep in mind is the INTEREST PAYMENT , which can be deferred by issuing BONDS etc.
    NOW INDIA NEEDS MASSIVE INVESTMENT IN MODERN FUEL EFFICIENT ENGINES AND SLEEK AERODYNAMIC COACHES as well as MASSIVE RESEARCH FUNDING into HIGH SPEED RAIL and small amount for MAGLEV technology. Massive Investments TO TURN BIG RALIWAY STATIONS INTO A STATION AS WELL AS A SHOPPING MALL(like in Uk)
    Rather than concentrating onFINISHING THE HUNDREEDS of projects which lie half finished TRIVEDI EMBARKS ON GLOBAL TENDER FOR EURO STANDARD ANTI COLLISION SYSTEM.
    If Mamata couldn’t have brought down the Govt ANOTHER BOFOR IN THE MAKING WOULD SURELY HAVE DONE

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Your reading about me is simply incorrect. Let it pass, as it does not matter.

    As I keep saying, there is no such thing as a free lunch nor a cheap one either. What Dinesh Trivedi has done is to make a beginning, no body lends funds to an enterprise going sick (look at Air India, it has been worked to the ground, I am not blaming Mamata for it). Before they do one has to put one’s own money where one’s mouth is. Then the Railways can go around seek those massive funds.

    Fares have not been hiked for 10 years by serial offenders – read railway ministers to score cheap political points and pander to their own constituency, thus jeopardizing the health of the railways, as if it is ‘baap ki jaagir’. Other than the TMC and the comrades, no one else seems to have a problem with the fare hike, especially the people and even the railway unions.

    Bofors?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    ‘baap ki jaagir’ reminds me of the Farmer’s loan waiver

    Anonymous Reply:

    ACS and New Signalling system are pending since 2008. It was sort planned during early days of UPA II. But lalu’s effort to create a pressure group of Yadavs inside UPA misfired. Mamta did not do much of work for the revenue generation. Infact she reduced the budget for the safety and tried to balance.

    I noticed you are a bit touchy about Mamta. If you think she should be given some relief for being first time CM, then she should have worked doggedly in last few months and not give silly comments on everything.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Is it okay for private enterprises to charge more for their goods and services, indexed to inflation and input costs (or not) but, not okay for the government undertakings?
    That said,
    But it is not FARE HIKE,that is important , which plays a small part , IT IS ONLY GOOD AS A WAY TO REDUCE DEMAND. To INCREASE YOUR INVESTMENT IN ANY BUSINESS you dont rely on your revenue , for they are PITTANCE , you TAKE LOANS. Nobody does business with their own money . It isalways through loan , and there are hundreed modality to secure them , conventional as well as non conventional. Only thing to keep in mind is the INTEREST PAYMENT , which can be deferred by issuing BONDS etc.
    Shan, have you ever run a business in your life? Evidently not. But, do you even know how to read a balance sheet or p&l?
    Hundreds of modalities of securing loans- really? Only a small matter of paying interest, which also can be deferred by issuing bonds?
    What is this? Cuckoo-nomics?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Complete and utter BOLLOCKS. Some price hike are inevitable. Like if the INPUT price goes up , like increase in fuel price , etc , IT WILL BE PASSED ON TO THE CONSUMER.That is NOT A TRUE PRICE RISE. Inflation on its own DOES NOT INCREASE PRICE ACROSS THE BOARD, there is a SMALL THING ABOUT DEMAND AND SUPPLY ASWELL.
    Railway IS A PUBLIC SERVICE , it is not a business.
    In UK fares in SOUTHEAST of England (which has highest per capita income) are FIVE TIMES HIGH.This is used to SUBSIDISE fares in NORTH where the per capita income is low and population sparse.
    As for LOANS , haven’t you heard of loan recycling , loan securitisation , debt recycling(take another loan to pay off the previous loan), and there is BONDS.
    Obviously MOST IMPORTANT is DEBT/ASSET ratio . When it approaches 100% you are theoretically bankrupt if your interest payment is more than your income
    Hope this clears the matter

    AshishC Reply:

    It certainly clarifies once for all, for me that discussing economics with you is a waste of time.
    Stick to biology.
    Inflation is nothing but having to pay more for goods and services- price rise. Anyway, like I said, utter waste of my time..

    Anonymous Reply:

    Stick to your “liberal arts” .Economics is not arts any more it is SCIENCE. I was not giving a definition of Inflation , for which you do not need to consult a book on economics , a DICTIONARY will do.
    Price of salt hardly increases BECAUSE THERE IS NO DEARTH OF IT , apart from the transport cost.
    On the other hand even when GENERAL inflation is low , CERTAIN commodity may experience a price rise BECAUSE THERE ARE TOO MANY PEOPLE CHASING TO FEW GOODS AVAILABLE.

    AshishC Reply:

    Shan,
    as has been pointed out many times, one needs to have some basic appreciation of mathematics to understand economics- which sadly you do not. Please do not quote random, well known cliches; they do not contribute to any understanding of the subject.
    If you wish to really understand economics basics, I can recommend some text books- with a minimum of maths. Even Samuelson will be too heavy for you. You might try Galbraith. And till you do, stay away from reading popular literature on economics. You are just too confused.

  • Anonymous

    Now this is interesting
    ——————————

    I will resign in a day or 2: Dinesh Trivedi

    http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_i-will-resign-in-a-day-or-2-dinesh-trivedi_1663555

    Dinesh Trivedi on Saturday said that he will resign in a day or two from the post of railway minister.

    Mentioning that Trinamool Congress MP Kalyan Banerjee has asked him to quit, he said that he wanted Mamata Banerjee to give him in writing that she wanted him to resign.

    ————–

    With SP playing footsie with the UPA, will Mamta bite the bullet and put in writing.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    It seems congress in firing using Trivedi’s shoulders. Poor guy by asking
    Mamta to put in writing may incur more wrath from her in future.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    His association with the TMC is over, so her wrath does not matter. He must not have asked for the letter otherwise. It is now for the Congress to look after him. The question will they?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    In near term, Congress may not really look after Trivedi for the obvious reason. But by next election, he may find favour with the Congress.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Because Mamta di can’t write saala!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    gr8 one !

  • Anonymous

    SHAN BASHING
    ++++++++++++++++++++

    I try to stay away from this blog but sometime the cheeky posts just make me smile-

    cingulated shan Dr- “On a small note , please refer to an Email sent to trinamool’s office by yours truly, which is packed with ideas to transform bengal”

    Ashish- “blind leading the blind?”

    ouchhhhhhhhh

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I liked it too.

    Anything that punctures the fake intellectual’s bloated ego is good reading.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    This says all about you
    Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity.”

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Nirodh Babu,

    so many people here have so adequately exposed you and your malicious humbug.

    Anonymous Reply:

    one more addition to those exposures
    Ravi in New York City Reply:
    July 26th, 2010 at 8:03 am

    Shan, wherever you are, you are a smart person. Keep up the good work.

    Anonymous Reply:

    feeling childishly happy about stale lollypops, chingulate?

    Anonymous Reply:

    actually I had read Shan’s letter. it was cute- typical Shanno style, full of rambling nonsense.
    Also Mishra doc, that email from Premji is fake- its just not his style to talk like that. But I say again- and this is for Vijay, Pervez, Shoeb, Shenoy- desperately poor of ALL religions and castes need reservation.

    One of our ex employees Sharma- when he died his widow fell on hard times. Seems every neighbour and relative of hers tried to help her and they wanted to have sex with her !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My abbu saved her, we employ her even though we dont need to.
    after school her son and daughter come to our noisy factory to do homework while mum works. mrs sharma says otherwise someone will rape her 11 year old daughter if she went back to the flat which is in a disgusting area
    i think lot of people here skim over the underbelly of indian life- we are too much drunk on mera bhaarat mahaan or there own intellectual greatness

    sorry reading shan’s silly posts makes me realise why india does not tick- every man is a sahabzaada Salim

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    U r quiet right here. Subsidies and reservations need to be targetted at the real needy. The way to identify them should go beyond sweeping class and religious lines which bureaucrats and politicians want.

    I think the way you people are helping the lady is inspiring and individual efforts really add up to what societies can achieve.

    In my small humble way I do try to do things. One effort which has been good is to collect used clothes from relatives and friends to distribute among the children and adults at construction sites. It is always gr8 to see my Rockport shirt being worn by my mason and my nephews bennetton T Shirts on the children at my site.

    Another effort which has really been very satisfying has been to

    a) Donate a few computers to children in the workers colony. My Mason’s son can now cut a CD faster than me. When he somtimes comes to site as an electircian he now has a walkman plugged in and can be singing Kolaveri Di

    b) Organising a cricket/ football game for less priveleged kids by also giving cricket bats/ footballs etc. Gr8 Talent we have there !

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Now why did u stop comimg to this blog?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I stay away from the blog
    Can we read as “I am keeping low, as INSTRUCTIONS from otherside of the border asked me to do so”. Apparently vans with special gadgets to monitor conversation in our mohalla are making rounds ..As you know to us QUOM comes first .
    Chichichichichichichi

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    If this post of yours was addressed to Engrich, than it would have deemed perfect. Rizwan does not belong to that category.
    Wrong choice.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Nirodh babu that is a petulant , false, racist, communal, parochial charge… which only a termite in a perpetual state of hysteria would scream out…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Iss Nirodh ka virodh karna chahiye.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Dear Rizwan

    How is your gf in Lahore?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    A priest can be a paedophile , but a paedophile cannot be a priest.
    An engineering graduate spends his life in MARKETING is hardly an engineer,
    I am talking about anyone who has DELVED into the mystery of his creation and not a technician

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The above was addressed to MohanR

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    A paedophile can certainly be a priest, doctor, teacher or anything else.
    His characteristic comes to the fore only when the victims manage to expose him.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    A paedophile becomes a priest which enables him to hide his horrible act.

    Though sometimes few of them are caught.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Here is something for the new found admirers of Akhilesh Yadav

    ================

    New UP govt’s first embarrassment: Bid to extend Lokayukta term fails

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/new-up-govts-first-embarrassment-bid-to-extend-lokayukta-term-fails/924949/

    An ordinance, extending the tenure of the Lokayukta from six to eight years by amending the Uttar Pradesh Lokayukta and Up-Lokayukta Act 1975, was approved at the very first meeting of the new cabinet Thursday evening. Later, it was sent to the Raj Bhavan, well after office hours.

    By then, Governor B L Joshi had left for Delhi and Mehrotra’s term had officially ended. Also, the ordinance, drafted in unseemly haste, suffered from serious legal lacunae, sources said.

    ————

    One must they are trying to extend the Lokayukt’s term.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————
    ~~~ INDIANS DONT KNOW WHEN TO RETIRE….. ~~~ is’nt it ? ~~~~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————

    Now this post is not about all the fine bloggers out here who have retired from their company but are actively involved in a higher work– Blogging !

    I am talking about some people in public life and sport who need to retire to maintain the public respect for their legacy :

    a) Saurav ganguly: Was a gr8888888 captain. But should now stop dreaming of playing bengal or IPL as his failures now, smudge his cricketing glories.

    b) Sachin : NDTV reports that he is NOT considering retirement. Well we all know that he was the greatest name in the world once. Our pride. Maybe he should learn from Sunil Gavaskar that it is important to walk out when people ask, “Why?” rather then people snidely commenting “why not?”

    These were the successfull people. Now let us talk about the failures.

    c) Digvijay Singh: A total failure as a CM, he is now hanging on ruining the COngress’ chances everywhere as well as reducing the standard of ur thinking to that of selfishness, communalism and cheapness

    d) Rahulji : Well Rahulji is not really cut for politics and adminstration. In case he retires and announces that from now on he would work against the princples of synastic succession which have no place in a democracy, he would win widesprad respect. he can also do some actual job to learn what life is all about, rather than living of the royalites of books gr8gr8 grandpop wrote.

    I better rush now… !!

    To a construction site and do actual work… before my partners retire me off…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Seems everyone has rushed to work… before their partners/spouses ask them to retire…

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Sorry Guys ! I have been travelling. I promised myself not to use my Tablet for the blog. Then there will be no time for the work !

    I had my first interaction with an IIM Prof – politician in UP. Yes, he is good. Come to think of it, he has his fingers on the real politic ! Why else he would join a party like SP ? But then who else had a chance in UP ? Imagine he beat Lalji Tandon’s son in Lucknow North. Infact, Dr Neeraj Bora of the Congress was too a good cadidate. Guess, it would make Dr Mishra proud.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Sanjay

    Did you have on occasion to interact with Akhilesh? He seems to be earnest, head screwed right, committed to get things done.
    He has some goondas such as Raj Bhaiyya in the cabinet. My guess (and hope) is that he included them as a part of a grand strategy so he can keep a close tag, and ‘deal” with them appropriately later.

    Finally it looks like, imo, there is light at the end of the tunnel in UP.

    Your observations will be appreciated -

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    THE REAL INTENTION OF TRIVEDI FOR INVITING GLOBAL TENDERS FOR ANTI COLLISION DEVICE(draw your own conclusions)
    However SORRY TO SPOIL THE PARTY
    Mamata nod to introduce ACD in 8 railway zones
    Kumod Verma, TNN Mar 14, 2011, 03.05am IST

    PATNA: Railway minister Mamata Banerjee has approved an ambitious safety plan to introduce anti-collision device (ACD) across the country in 2011. Out of 17 zones of the railways, it would be introduced in eight zones including East Central Railway (ECR).

    According to a Railway Board official, the railway ministry has taken the decision to introduce ACD after its successful trial conducted under Southern Railway in Tamil Nadu recently. It was the second trial of the ACD which proved successful. Though the Konkan Railway has designed and developed the ACD, railways has made slight modifications in its design and structure for its implementation, the official said.
    SOME MORE SPANNER IN THE WORKS
    speaking about railway accidents, she said that human error was responsible for some of them, but they were less in comparison to road accidents.

    “Road accidents take a toll of 1.40 lakh lives in India each year, while 1,000 persons die in rail accidents,” she said.
    Sanjay Dhawan , wishing you a SAFE travel

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Konkan’s ACD has been around for a long time. Though cost effective, it was always a suspect in terms of integration with the full system. The railway is in the middle of a leap jump to take care of the future need. It’s not the marginal need. Like power, the railway needs a massive restructuring.The advanced signalling system has been pending for years. If you are thinking to be on the track with China, we need futuristic technologies, not some marginal ones. Forget about these big stuff, they have not even finalised the train simulators in last 3 years ! Laloo atleast used to come to Delhi every Friday to work over the weekend. Didi never even did that !

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    If Didi was so bad all along… why did the Congress support here and used her support. Now with the Congress Bureau of Investigation, having cornered Mayawati, I am sure she would be seen a worthy partner…. :)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Perhaps you think spending BILLIONS to save 1000 lives IS MORE IMPORTANT than using the SCANT RESOURCES to overhaul the antiquated railways.ANYWAY THE REAL REASON FOR FOREIGN TENDERS ARE………….cowbelt ethics overrides patriotism
    Here is a copy and paste
    Officials say the ACD, designed and developed by former Konkan Railway managing director B. Rajaram, has a success rate of 99.9 percent in preventing collisions after it was commissioned by the Konkan Railway and the Northeast Frontier Railway.

    Incidentally, it also had the support of Railway Minister Mamata Banerjee in her earlier stint at Rail Bhavan here.

    “Its implementation is being delayed over the years by successive revision of norms by the Railway Board even though the technology met the conditions successfully in every instance,” Rajaram, an alumnus of the Indian Institute of Technology at Kharagpur, told IANS.

    Rajaram raised this issue with Banerjee in a letter written April 5 this year, drawing her attention to the money earmarked for the Research Design and Standards Organisation (RDSO), the ministry’s apex research body.

    “Indian Railway never produced a world class technology since independence. We spend so much of funds on RDSO, but we have nothing innovative of world class to export from RDSO or even to be used on Indian Railways,” he said.

    “We just import. RDSO is used to assist to import.”

    The letter said the device named “Raksha Kavach” was developed indigenously and was even singled out from the millions of global patents and praised as a unique safety system by the World Intellectual Property Office in Geneva.

    “But the multinational companies which have much to lose if ACD comes in operation, have consistenly been fighting a proxy technology war using our own retired and even working railway officers.”

    He went on to say that at every stage of development, hurdles were raised and said its implementation in the Northeast Frontier Railway would have been blocked but for former railway minister and present Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Trivedi digs his heels, says ‘duty to pilot Rail Budget debate’

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/trivedi-digs-his-heels-says-duty-to-pilot-rail-budget-debate/925042/

    Trivedi’s defiance puts the Prime Minister and the Congress leadership in a bind in which they have to decide on the removal of the Railway Minister or allow his continuance at the risk of possible threat of withdrawal of support by Mamata Banerjee’s Trinamool Congress.

    —————

    Is this all scripted by the Congress to call Mamta’s bluff or ….?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Video

    ‘Not good at reading Mamata’s mind’

    http://indiatoday.intoday.in/video/india-today-conclave-2012-dinesh-trivedi-mj-akbar-rail-budget/1/178181.html

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ Sanjay Dhawan

    Welcome back ot the blog. A fortnight is a long time in pollitcs and you would have seen that Congress with its hate agenda of dividing Hindus and Muslims has been trounced :)

    If you are moving around UP to check out why Digvinashji could spread his communal ‘vish’ and still not win and why Rahul despite the fawning media giving him all publicity, lost, here are a few facts:

    a) Somebody noted here that rahul ji sounded more like Mulayam SIngh yadav and Lalu Yadav with his casteist and communal agenda while Akhilesh sounded like the early Rajiv Gandhi– sincere, simple, promising a bright future

    b) Create all the spin to propel a non performing machine.. well … it wont fly. Only the spin doctors will make a living. :)

    c) The Congress should honestly worry that the Priyanka factor too failed. The politics of charisma is over.

    Frankly with the advent of the electronic media, the days of dark Indians in tattered clothes beding before fairer kings and queens is over. There are a thousand heroes and heroines around now.

    Priyanka sounda like a nice sensible girl, She should immerse herself in social work — like children;s nutrition or education. She should be careful that her husband does not use her name to popel himself further. As we know, from rickshaw travelling in Moradabad in 1998 to owning the Aman Hotel and partnering DLF to buy Taj and other boutique hotels, he is the epitome of a starry rise…

    d) I asked the parking Lot guy inNoida sec 18, two hrs back, on which party he voted. SP was his answer. Reason– the mayawati supporters have had a good time for five years, now we got to give it back to them.

    So Akhilesh better watch out as his voters have a different take….

    He did not have any connect with Rahul and … Priyanaka….

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ shan cingulate, I called your thoughts infantile, most do. In return you called me Pakistani!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! wtf, r u confirming yr infantile status?

    @gopi, she was never my gf. Just met her last year when I went to see the match in Chandigarh, we skyped for a while but it fizzled out. Ammi was very troubled about my dating a girl from Lahore. to be brutally honest, our roots are in MP and my family is anti-punjabis. sorry viju and Balwinder uncle- just saying it as it is lolzz

    @ viju you ducked the main thrust of my post dude- the underbelly of India. My comment that working parents try not to leave their young girls at home because they could be raped. This blog never addresses the terrible crime situation in India, everyone here just bangs on about GROWTH as if mentioning the 9 % figure again and again will somehow mask the hunger, disease and violence

    and the fact that mrs Sharma on being widowed had to contend with all the male predators, she once told Abbu that the first pass was made on her the day after her husbands funeral!!!!!!!!! mera bhaarat mahaan

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Rizwan,

    About Mrs. Sharma. This has nothing to do with India, it is a basic nature
    of an animal called man. Young widow is considered by many men as a sex starved available person and they try their worst to ‘help’ such ladies.
    I do not have any suitable adjective to address such men, but you will find
    such people all over the world.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    This is why I propose my friend Egrich’s Sharia law for certain cases

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    I understand why you are proposing this law. The sheer
    frustration you feel because criminals are not being punished
    for such horrible crimes. But, is Sharia the solution ?
    Here I tend to agree with Mahesh, who had said something like
    ” severity of punishment does not reduces the crime rate”.
    There are many animals in the guise of human roaming around
    the world, who will commit such heinous crime without any
    remorse, Sharia or no Sharia.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    I believe swift and severe punishment will in general reduce crimes, except the crimes of passion or extreme anger/despair.

    I am for a modified Sharia for many violations …

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi

    Let us pray we dont get Sharia. Our corrupt police and lawyers will use it vidictively against innocents.

    Instead we can have speedy justice by getting in the jury system and also by referring cases of property and marital disputes– which take ip 70% of the court cases– to binding tribunals.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    Swift punishment is very important and that
    will definitely work as a deterrent.
    For this the whole structure of working of
    police departments and courts have to change.
    Who will take this initiative ?

    Anna and his team ?

    Anonymous Reply:

    MohanR , Mrs Sharma , may be ONE hapless individual , this is from the land of that dickhead’s coreligionist
    The abduction and forced conversion to Islam of Christian girls who are then married against their will to their captors is a disturbing and growing trend in Pakistan; it is estimated that there are over 700 cases every year, according to the Barnabas Fund – a Christian advocacy group based in the UK.

    One of the latest incidents involved a 14-year-old girl, Mehek Rashid, who was kidnapped at gunpoint from her home in Shisharwali, Gujranwala, by a gang of five armed Muslim men. One of her abductors yelled that he would purify Mehek by converting her to Islam before marrying her. The local authorities are refusing to investigate the case, apparently because the assailants are from a prominent Muslim family.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Cingulate

    I think you should inculcate ahabit of seeing the difference and not going in the hysterical mode all the time.

    Rizwan is decent, well edicated and the direct opposite of a fanatic like say Engrich or his partner in hate. You cannot lay the blame of a fanatic on the door of a liberal.

    How would you lay the blame of Mehak’s conversion to Rizwan, who would condemn it as much as I do?

    If this is the level of your scientific, rational thinking, then sadly you have learnt science and rationality from wrong teachers.

    Anonymous Reply:

    How could he use one ISOLATED CASE TO PASS JUDGEMENT on aryavarta.
    My instinct tells me this geezer is engrich without the skull cap and long beard.
    Ask his opinion on eating BACON SARNIE

    Anonymous Reply:

    I dont think eating Bacon Sarnie confers anybody a knighthood. The choice of meat is a matter of preferance and religious taboo.

    Hindus dont eat beef

    Muslims dont touch pork

    Anglos Saxons detest dog meat which koreans and chinese love.

    Veggies hate all meat.

    Individual experiences give an insight. Of course you cannot generalise on that basis.

    There is no way you can compare decent guys like Shoeb, Pervex, Usman, Rizwan with Engrich.

    The only person who qualifies for that is Engrich’s gr8 thick pal and partner.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Hindus don’t eat beef

    Who says?

    AshishC Reply:

    Manohar,
    of the entire post of Vijay, the only line that got your goat was this one: Hindus don’t eat beef…
    Why not some of the other, equally “general” comments Vijay used to make a very good point?
    If dietary taboos would define (defile?) a man, then, as Vijay says, you would have to agree that Anglo-Saxons are narrow minded for not liking dog-meat or indeed most of humanity for not liking “screaming monkey brain” (Taiwan).

    Anonymous Reply:

    For the last two days, he has left behind rationality and logic. (navigate and see for yourself).

    Re: No Gujarati beggars – see how increasingly illogical and irrational he becomes as he goes along and ties himself in knots – just to justify what he started off with.

    Re: his declaration – Hindus don’t eat beef – is very far removed from reality.

    Only if he had said that most or many Hindus do not eat beef – then it would make sense. Unless his theory is that only those who do not eat beef can be called Hindus.

    I may or may not have any issues about his other declarations.

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think u r pretty wide of the mark in trying to prove a wrong statement.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish, Vijay Kumar,

    this congressi troll seems to consider your statement that ‘Hindus don’t eat beef’ something akin to sacrilege. He doesn’t mind the Chinese eating (and loving it) dog meat, but how can anyone say Hindus don’t eat beef?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vinoo

    If what Vijay has been posting makes sense (to me it does not), then good luck to you.

    Anonymous Reply:

    I’ll reverse the question and ask you… what have u been drinling and smoking…

    Now dont start crying abuse abuse :)

    Cmon why dont you try to start a chain of “Hindu beef shops” and see the reactions?

    Most Hindus dont eat beef. Like Most Muslims dont eat pork and most anglos dont eat dog meat.

    As for beggars… show me a Punjabi beggar all over India, I’ll shave of my head.

    And as for Gujrati beggars you wont see them in Delhi and North at least.

    All because of the enterprise of the two communities.

    You wont notice of course !! As you are too busy saluting dynastic succession and would never ever see a mass murderer like Sajjan Kumar who would have actually personally LIT THE FIRE ON LIVE INNOCENTS. Of course he to is a Congressi dynasty sycophant and it is just enough to say very bad… very bad… and then give him a ticket :)

    Anonymous Reply:

    I have been drinking water and smoking branded cigarettes.

    Keep tying yourself in knots re: Gujarati beggars.

    Congress dynasty and Gujarati beggars. Wow, what an connection? You can further connect whatever takes your fancy and revel.

    I will spare you the embarrassment and I will save a lot of time, which I can use productively elsewhere. have a nice day.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Manohar,
    Just out of curiosity, what is the region, where hindus openly eat beef? Not chori Chhupe or because of poverty.

    Anonymous Reply:

    In the cities, it is no more a taboo. To cite one example, there is a kabab corner near my residence, which basically serves only beef delicacies and 90%+ of its clientele are Hindus.

    In rural Maharashtra, the farm workers as part of their nutrition (needed for the hard work in the sun), beef is one of the staple foods on account of its price.

    In 1995, one of the first acts of the BJP/SS when it came to power in Maharashtra, was ot ban cow slaughter, in the great tradition and culture of …….
    They had to beat a hasty retreat, when their was an uproar.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Manohar,
    Just out of curiosity, what is the region, where hindus openly eat beef? Not chori Chhupe or because of poverty.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    Yes, I have heard and read many such stories. The people who commit these
    crimes are brainwashed and they actually believe this silly notion that their
    act is for the good of Islam. In the process of doing something ‘good for Islam’
    they commit such horrible acts of torture, killing and rape.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Rizwan

    Dont take too much notice of cingulate.
    If he calls you Pakistan… he is duplicate !

    Thx for being anti Punjabi !! I am also anti Punjabi, whenever my mom lines up a lush babe form the wheat fields of Ludhiana for marriage… I am a Delhi boy now and have eyes for the Delhi gals !

    By the way Punjabis are the only community left who can enjoy a barb at themselves… !

    Well the underbelly of India is dirty simply because our criminal justice system has been hijacked by lawyers who want money and not justice. And politicans and police who couldn’t care less.

    I have seen men in colony parks… who want to touch a girl all over, while they keep mumbling, “beti… beti..”

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    time to test whether Delhi girls have eyes for you.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I am a gr8 practitioner of one sided love … :)

    Uska bhi koi alag mazaa hai…

    Anonymous Reply:

    Rizwan

    I read about the fear Mrs Sharma had for her 11 year old daughter. In a way she is blessed because your family took her under their wings.

    There was a news today about a woman’s headless body found in a Delhi garbage dump — the body was cut in 7 pieces and put in several bags.

    A few days ago, as you may have read, a young woman was raped by several men in Gurgaon.

    A few months ago, one Usha died in the streets of kolkotta, the Marxian utopia, while giving birth to twins – the death happened in front of a hospital that refused to take her in.

    It really is heart breaking these things happen, and in most cases, no authority will care in our flawed system.

    If you really want to feel even worse, I recommend you to read “Behind the Beautiful Forevers – Life, Death, and Hope in Mumbai Undercity” by Katherine Boo, of New Yorker magazine. She lived in the slums for three years and covered the lives of many. Abdul, Sunil, and Chitra could be my children, your siblings…..

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    it confirms you are an abba ka tukre me palla hua , FALTU.Try to earn a few paisa on your own kamiyee

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    More and more citizens are exercising their voting franchise..

    We had a by-election here today in “Piravom” constituency..

    86.3% of the voters voted! (the polling percentage in that constituency in the last year’s election was 79.1%)

    UPA will maintain the statusquo (2 seat majority) if their guy wins; CPM will gain one seat if their man wins. Both contestants have the same name – Jacob (so also the deceased MLA).. so it is quite possible votes meant for one goes to the other…

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Congress MP Sajjan Singh has served a privilege notice against kejerwall for calling the MPs “rapists, looters, and murderers”..

    Sajjan Singh must be thinking he is an MP in Luxomburg or US Congress!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    To punish Mr. Kejriwal, a new law has to passed in India.

    SPEAKING TRUTH IS A CRIME.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    yes!

    But the way the legal system works, truth will be labelled lie.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Sajjan Kumar the MP of a proud Congress is responsible for a 100 murders -AT LEAST- in the 1984 riots

    Of course the moment this truth is spoken trolls will shout– Modi Modi rape rape ….

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    He is Sajjan only in name.

    He might have committed more murders than Sajjan Kumar, for all we know.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    The following was sent to me by a friend. Can anyone authenticate it.
    ————

    HMV Company had once published a pamphlet giving the history of
    gramophone record. Gramophone was invented by Thomas Alva Edison in the
    19th century. Edison, who had invented many other gadgets like electric
    light and the motion picture camera, had become a legend even in his
    own time.

    When He invented the gramophone record, which could record human voice
    for posterity, he wanted to record the voice of an eminent scholar
    on his first piece. For that he chose Prof. Max Muller of Germany,
    another great personality of the 19th century. He wrote to Max Muller
    saying, “I want to meet you and record your voice. When should I come?”
    Max Muller who had great respect for Edison asked him to come on a
    suitable time when most of the scholars of the Europe would be
    gathering in England.

    Accordingly, Edison took a ship and went to England. He was introduced
    to the audience. All cheered Edison’s presence. Later at the request of
    Edison, Max Muller came on the stage and spoke in front of the
    instrument. Then Edison went back to his laboratory and by afternoon
    came back with a disc. He played the gramophone disc from his
    instrument. The audience was thrilled to hear the voice of Max Muller
    from the instrument. They were glad that voices of great persons like
    Max Muller could be stored for the benefit of posterity.

    After several rounds of applause and congratulations to Thomas
    Alva Edison, Max Muller came to the stage and addressed the scholars
    and asked them, “You heard my original voice in the morning. Then
    you heard the same voice coming out from this instrument in
    the afternoon. Did you understand what I said in the morning or what
    you heard this afternoon?”

    The audience fell silent because they could not understand the language
    in which Max Muller had spoken. It was `Greek and Latin’ to them as
    they say. But had it been Greek or Latin, they would have definitely
    understood because they were from various parts of Europe. It was in a
    language which the European scholars had never heard.

    Max Muller then explained what he had spoken. He said that the language
    he spoke was Sanskrit and it was the first sloka of Rig Veda, which
    says “Agni Meele Purohitam.” This was the first recorded public version
    on the gramophone plate.

    Why did Max Muller choose this? Addressing the audience he said, “Vedas
    are the oldest text of the human race. And Agni Meele Purohitam is the
    first verse of Rig Veda. In the most primordial time, when the people
    did not know how even to cover their bodies and lived by hunting and
    housed in caves, Indians had attained high civilization and they gave
    the world universal philosophies in the form of the Vedas.”

    Such is the illustrious legacy of our country!

    When “Agni Meele Purohitam” was replayed the entire audience stood up
    in silence as a mark of respect for the ancient Hindu sages.

    This verse means:

    “Oh Agni, You who gleam in the darkness, To You we come day by day,
    with devotion and bearing homage. So be of easy access to us, Agni, as
    a father to his son, abide with us for our well being.”

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    You are right. Max Muller was the person who coined the term ARYAN RACE.
    Apparently there were rich hindus in calcutta who were his patron , and provided him with a stipend.It maybe rajendra mullick who built the MARBLE HOUSE which has india’s only private collection of european art

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    “Apparently there were rich Hindus in Calcutta who were his patron, and provided him with a stipend”.

    Did he need any stipend from people in India? The following makes no such mention and neither did he ever visit India.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_M%C3%BCller

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Holy Maccaroni he did visit and stayed in calcutta , just give some time , there are two biographies of max muller

    Anonymous Reply:

    Look forward to know more.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar/Shan,

    Max Muller not only coined the term Aryans but also according to him Aryans migrated
    to India from Europe. Many Indian historians who believe that Aryans were indigenous
    reject this claim of Aryan migration. Some people even claim that Max Muller translated
    Vedas in a way which will demean Hindus.
    Who is right? Depends upon what anybody wants to believe.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    Is there any anthropological evidence to suggest the indigenous people evolved in India and were not Aryans?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    Frankly no idea. Different people different version. You believe what you want to
    believe.

    Anonymous Reply:

    What do mean, believe what one wants to?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    Some people believe Aryans migrated to Indian sub continent, some believe that there
    was no migration.

    AshishC Reply:

    Manohar,
    http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/living/the-story-of-our-origins
    Read this at your leisure. Will need time.. but, there is Sunday coming up :)
    BTW, here’s a line from the article:
    The second part of their conclusions rests on the fact that the proportion of R1a1 in some Brahmin groups such as those of West Bengal is as high as 72 per cent. This indicates that the origins of Brahmins as a caste may well lie in the R1a1 haplogroup. But since the antiquity of the Ra1a haplogroup in tribals such as Central India’s Sahariyas is older than it is among Brahmins, it is reasonable to believe that Brahmins may not be entrants from outside but may have originated as a caste from the tribal population of this country.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Thanks. Will read later. Time now to hit the bed. Good night.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish,

    Thanks. Will go through this.
    .

    Anonymous Reply:

    Very inconclusive, as far as my reading and understanding goes.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @Mohan R , It is now proven beyond doubt that migration did take place from STEPPES. Russian Indologist have shown that all European languages have their roots in Sanskrit. Like Matri , becomes matre , mother, pitri becomes fatre , father.
    Also russian archaeologist have found evidence of the fabled SOMRUS at the STEPPES. It is not wine , but a chemical from a plant related to ephedrine , a stimulant

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    Not sure what to believe. Why it cannot be other way around that Aryans from Indian
    Sub-continent went to Steppes and other parts of Europe.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Because the other branch went to Iran. Thus Parsi or Zoorasterian god or even before that the gog is named Anahita and Mitra.And this FIRE worship is common ritual of ancient Persians and modern parsis and Vedic Indians , thus the theory
    I have a theory where this facsination for fire came from. I saw a TV programme in BBC sometimes ago. It is about the area around Baku and central asia. There still stands a HINDU temple there.
    Now the mind boggling thing about that place is , fire seems to spout from under theground and if you are not careful , a sudden blast of fire lasting few seconds may burn you. This is because of massive amount of very superficial subterranean oil. The hindu temple is just a PERPETUALLY burning fire

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar

    “Agnimelee Purohitham
    Yajnasya Deva Mritujam
    Hotaram Raatna Dhtaman”

    This first verse of Rigveda is light (fire) as a witness, light as a vehicle, light as a protector…
    Max Mueller was a deep scholar of Sanskrit, deep into Vedas and Upanishads, translating a lot to German. He was connected with BrahmoSamaj , was a disciple of Ramakrishna Paramahamsa. He had his own theory of Indo European languages, population migration etc.. The Max Muller Bhavans (previously Goethe Institutes) in India are named after his honour.

    I am not aware of any documented record about the first words recorded. Assuming Edison connected with Max Muller (both were contemporaries and both were in England at the same time), it is quite possible that Max Muller recited the first verse of RigVeda, because of his deep admiration for the book and because he was in the process of translating RigVeda at the time.

    Regarding documented record related to eminent scientists quoting “meaningful” stuff from ancient Indian treasures of knowledge, I think the most recent may be the quotes Openheimer recited when he witnessed the first test explosion of the atom bomb in the “trinity” island (code named by US) on July 16, 1945 before they did the live one in Japan.

    Openheimer just could not believe what he and his team had created – On that day in july 1945, he saw the magnitude of light, heat, power that his mathematical equations resulted in. Seeing the explosion, its light, the measurement of its heat , he uttered:

    on the unvbelievable light

    ” Divi Suryasahasram Bhavethu Yugapathrudhita
    Yadi bha Sadrushi sa Sayathsi sa Bhastasta Mahathman ”

    (Bhagavad Gita 11-12

    ” if the radiance of thousand suns are to burst at once into the sky that would be like the splendour of the exalted one”

    and on the heat

    “Kaal aasmi lok kshayakrith prabhudha
    Lokan samahrutham eha pravirtha
    Srathipi swam na bhavishyanti sarvem
    Ye avasyatha prasthaneshu yodha ‘ Bhagavad Gita 11 -32

    “I am become death, the destroyer of the world, even without you, every warrior in the enemy camp will cease to be”

    This all relates to the Lord’s “Vishwa Roopa” , the one He gave Arjuna special sense to see, while he was explaining life, death, rules of life, dadadad …..

    Openheimer recited these in Sanskrit.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    A nice lesson in history. Thanks.
    What is your views on Aryan migration theory ?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The first known recording of a human voice, from April 9th, 1860. (Phonautograph Etching)

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBL7V3zGMUA

    ——————
    Thomas Edison and the First Phonograph
    August 12, 1877

    http://www.americaslibrary.gov/jb/recon/jb_recon_phongrph_1.html

    To Edison’s surprise, the cylinder recorded his message, “Mary had a little lamb.” People had a hard time believing his discovery at first, but soon doubt turned into awe as Edison became known as “The Wizard of Menlo Park,” after the name of the city in New Jersey where he did his work. Sound recording was rapidly becoming an American industry.

    ————-

    Therefore, Max Muller voice was not the first recorded by Edison !!!

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    I have not heard of this.. I doubt this is authentic.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    On googling, this claim is being made by Indians. Does it tell you a tale?

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Yeah, seems like it came from a cousin of PN Oak :) of the Tajmahal was a Shiv Temple fame

  • AshishC

    That may well be true.
    But to equate dancers and prostitutes is depravity. I do not wish to debate this anymore.

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    That may well be true.
    But to equate dancers and prostitutes is depravity. I do not wish to debate this anymore.

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    SHENOYBV
    Because Mamta di can’t write saala!
    12 hours ago in reply to mohanrr
    Shenoy,
    you are simply wrong. How dare you?
    I mean, wtphuck?
    Do you know, after BC Roy we are so proud to have our first doctor Chief Min?
    Only BC Roy was a medicine man, and our dear Mamata di is a doctorate from an Amrikaan univ called East Georgia?
    Heard of it?
    She can write, she can read … she can talk.. mind it! She even printed a doctorate as proof.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish,

    you definitely are an artist, who can speak even while keeping the tongue in the cheek.

    Yes, B.C.Roy was a doctor, both MRCP and FRCS,who strayed into politics, leaving medicine behind. For his doing good for WB, he was awarded Bharat Ratna.

    Here we have a modern version of Dr.Roy, who is a fake doctor, but real politician. And she dispenses bitter medicine for both the congress and the commies in large, and if everything goes well, in lethal doses.

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    All;
    In my humble opinion, Aryans migrated from North – near caucasus region and moving through middle east, Iran, Afghanistan settled in India. Apart from genetic studies, which shows similarity of Brahmins and european genetic has as much similarity, upto 98%, as Brahmins had least intercaste or mixed marriages. Apart from this, if Aryans were indigenous, then what about our tribals, their body structure, facials, colour etc is so different from Aryans. Even now, apart from white skin, many Brahmins have blue or green eyes.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj & Mohan

    Mohan, you asked ‘Why it cannot be other way around that Aryans from Indian Sub-continent went to Steppes and other parts of Europe’.

    Pankaj has provided one answer. The following may be useful.

    Dravidian people

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dravidian_people

    Because of admixture between Caucasoid, Mongoloid and Australoid racial groups, one cannot speak of a biologically separate “Dravidian race” distinct from non-Dravidians on the Indian subcontinent. However, northern Indians have more in common genetically with Central Asian/West Eurasian populations than southern Indian or Dravidian populations, who are more similar to East Asians, further demonstrating that there still exist significant genetic differences between Indo-European- and Dravidian-speaking populations.

    ————

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    All;
    had a nice round of : The Strip: in Las Vegas, where all the big Casinos are located. Circus de sole, arguably, best circus/ Gymnastic troup, is permanently located here on the payment of $ 500 million. This is an institution it self, originatinfg from Montreal, where, this art is practiced by practically every young girl and boy. Amazing.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj ji,

    my younger brother is working for one of the big hotels in Las Vegas.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Shenoy

    I hope he can help me in poker and roulette when I am there…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shenoy,

    Give me his number, next year I am planning to go there.
    I am sure he can teach me some tricks of winning.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Pankaj

    The strip… sounds pretty descriptive. I hope you did nto lose your way there.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    is it not called Cirque De soleul. It has originated in france and comes to UK every year. Montreal being FRENCH CANANDA , thus you get it from there.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Shan;
    You are right. Did not think that somebody can pick up this.
    Thanks

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Artists and performers in PAksitan!

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Faith-fear-silence-Pakistans-singers/articleshow/12310080.cms

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    Things are changing in Pakistan at alarming pace. Stronghold of extreme fundamentalist is increasing ever day. If not controlled in next 20-30 years
    Pakistan may become another Taliban.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Rushdie speech–

    I felt Rushdie took a cheap shot at Rahul Gandhi….

    I am not a fan of Rahul, but Rushdie crossed the mark..

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi

    Cheap shot or no, but there is truth in it. The Congress did play dirty re: Jaipur festival, given its high-pitched campaign for reservations and sops for the Muslims in UP at that time.

    The point to note – no one has a problem with his current visit.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi,

    I too saw and heard Rushdie, and he came across as an uninteresting, rambling speaker. There were a few laughs, but all of them appeared forced, as a concession to the VIP speaker than for genuine humour.

    He has, however, mastered the art of saying nothing even in a long speech.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Gopi

    Not really. remember nobody in our fawingin media is willing to say anything against Rahhul Gandhi as they lust for Rajya Sabha seats and advertisiments from public sector. It was right of Rushide to excercise this right as a person of Indian origin.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    In one of my earlier posts here, I had said that Dinesh Trivedi is being used as a Shikhandi by the congress to break Mamta Didi’s Trinamool.

    I am glad that I have been proved right.

    I read in today’s papers that Sam Pitroda is a house guest of Trivedi for the last three months and that he and Montek Singh Ahluwalia together drafted the entire rail budget!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    If this is true it just proves that cingulate’s thesis of an international conspiracy behind the Trivedi budget is typical conspiracy theorising.

    Sam Pitroda, is a Made-in -India man. He had faced the wrath of the multinationals when he headed C-DOT. He would be the last person to sacrifice Indian tech for videshi, needlessly.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Mulayam’s cousin set to become RS dy chairman

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/mulayams-cousin-set-to-become-rs-dy-chairman/925127/

    Amid the changed power equations at the Centre, the Samajwadi Party (SP) is all set to get the post of deputy chairman of the Rajya Sabha. Mulayam Singh Yadav’s cousin Ramgopal Yadav is likely to succeed K Rehman Khan, who retires in April.

    ————–

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————-
    ~~~ SAMAJWAD COMES TO UP ~~~ cheating in school exams fully allowed ~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————-

    @ Gopi

    I think you are pinning too much hope in Akhilesh. The party and the past wont let him too much beyond a point. The selection of ministeras has already indicated that corruption, casteism and freeing criminals on basis of caste and minority status will be the hallmark of Samajwadi rule.

    Today’s Indian Express reports that the board exams in UP have now since yesterday de- activated the control room which moniotrs cheating and condict of examinations. Examiners have given up as they fear a bullet in case they object.

    Two groups helping students cheat had a gunfight in which one person died.

    This is of course in tune with Mulayam’s early pollicy in which he wooed students with a “right to cheat’ policy .

    This has been discnitued immediately after Kalyan Singh took over.

    Maywati for all her corruption, had a school teacher background and at hindight, was pretty strict on student discipline and created schools and colleges.

    Mulayam will of course be Mulyam in all aspects of law breaking as long as he gets votes.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    I also saw the TV programme last night where Sreenivasan Jain interviews those queung up for unemployement allowance of Rs 1000; most queing up were openly saying they aready have a job or anyway have no intention to work, like hosewives- and wanted this 1000 Rs – free fokat ka.
    I am already yearning for the happy days of Maywati. AT least law and order was largely maintained.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Lucknow DIG who ‘beat up’ SP leader transferred to training centre

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/lucknow-dig-who-beat-up-sp-leader-transferred-to-training-centre/925255/

    Two days after coming to power, the Samajwadi Party (SP) government today transferred Lucknow Deputy Inspector General D K Thakur to Regional Training Centre (RTC), Chunar, in the same capacity.

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    also a brahminist…

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ Ashish and Vijay

    These are very very retrograde steps by the SP. UP has to move forward. Being from the state, my heart cries when I see the quality of adminstation and political debate

    SP in its earlier avatar was an assembly lines of goondas, crooks and at times, murderers. Extortionists and kidnappers like Mafan Bhaiyya and DP Yadav were its fund collectors.

    It would be indeed astonishing and shameful incase the SP takes us back to those days.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vinoo, Ashish, Mohan, Vijay Kumar,

    crime always pays and ruling parties these days need huge amounts of money to kep themselves in business.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Vijay/Ashish/Vinoo

    The problem is whenever such schemes or policies of free distribution of money
    are launched, human nature is not taken into account. All such schemes will never
    bring any benefit to nation or its people. Such schemes put dent on the
    government coffers, make people lazy and also create inflation.
    There should be some to law to stop this. How can any political party be allowed
    to distribute heard earned tax paid by honest citizens to be distributed freely just
    to get into/remain in power.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    How can you incentivize berojgari? Beyond me..

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think India will fail… if the SP and its clones seize power.

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    All (Shenoy/ Vijay/ Manohar): on the subject of Hindus being beef-eaters and the more subtle point::
    I wanted to just add a bit more academic rigour to the discussion on beef eating among Hindus.
    A few points of fact first:
    1. Beef eating, drinking alcohol, polygamy etc were all repvalent social customs in the vedic times. The priest class- brahmins definitely ate beef.
    2. Over a period of time- and there are disputes about what caused it- eating of beef became taboo among the higher castes of Hindus, especially brahmins. In fact barring a few notable exceptions (including Bengali brahmins :) ) vegetarianism itself became the norm and violation was taboo.
    A prominest sociologist- perhaps the greatest India has produced- MN Srinivas, introduced the concept of Brahminization, Westernization and Sanskritization to explain Indian society in flux.
    The essential points are:
    1. A society and its mores are not static- technology, industrialization, urbanization, mobility- they all impact the way a society evolves.
    2. In any modern and rule bound and hierarchial society, those at the top of the hierarchy define the accepted societal mores. Over a period of time, there develop accepted social mores for all castes- with the aspirational ones being those practiced by the brahmins.
    3. So, even though beef-eating was not taboo for non-brahmins, it was aspirational and thus became taboo for a large number of Hindus. This process was described by Srinivas as Braminization and later Sanskritization.
    4. This is not to suggest a one way process- there is an inverse process called de-sanskritization – which happens among modern brahmins- who neither wear the janeu, nor do they observe any taboo related to food or drinks.
    5. Finally, all of us- and perhaps most if not all we meet- are products of “westernization” a later term also introduced by Srinivas- our mores have changed as well- we are de-sanskritized, inspired by western humanist ideals and so on. And, yes, many of us do eat beef. I certainly do- though avoid it these days, as I do red meat generally.

    Now, to Manohar: (and I have now read thru the background posts)
    Vijay’s point was simple- food habits can’t define your liberal views or otherwise.
    I mean Hitler was a vegetarian.
    Vijay’s supporting point was about taboos being practiced by communities in general. I know Muslims who eat pork too. His main point was well made.
    In the context of your overall interaction with him, I understand your reaction but, his point- made to Shan (was it??) was unexceptionable.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashsih,

    Whenever I contemplate of becoming vegetarian, Hitler comes to my mind.
    Otherwise I would have become a vegetarian long time ago.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Similarly, all kidnappers and rapists should remember Ravan (not, of course, Shah Rukh Khan), who kidnapped Sita but didn’t,,,,,,,,,,,,

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    mohan — good one!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Thx Ashish,

    You said it more lucidly than I can !

    On a lighter note, I do know that many Bongs consider fish as vegetarians and this is a plasma zone.

    One known Bong journo (she is a known TV face) and her husband,a Jain ,are friends of mine. Whenever we dine out, both insist they are vegetarians.

    ” I eat fish… and fish is jal- tori (?) ,” she insists…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish
    There is a theory that Adi Sankaracharya, in his process of criss-crossing the land south to north and east to west, engaged in philosophical arguments persuading Budhists to come back to Vedic religion. Budhists ate meat, and renouncing meat was a part of the “coming back home” process ..A theory as articulated to me by a learned Brahmin friend in one of our discussions…

    Anyway, fast forward to today. An interesting thing I have observed /am observing among my Hindu friends here in kerala is a “reverse inverse process” ( piggybacking on the ” inverse process” you referred to) …There is a tendency among all lower caste Hindus to follow the wedding customs, eating habits, other customs/celebrations, dress habits on special ocacsions etc followed once only by the “higher caste” Brahmins/nairs… I thought that was quite interesting……especially when many of the customs are/were on the decline among the higher caste. I wonder whether this is happening in other regions.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Very interesting.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I remember reading r an article by Nirad Choudhuri ..He was writing about the period when Young Bengal movement was in full swing.
    Apparently frequenting brothels was a favourite pastime of young bengal.Some even bunked classes. IT turned out that BEEF served at the kothas was as much an attraction as the nautch girls.
    One worried dad , then told his son , he need not take all that trouble , beef is available at home albeit on the sly. he gets it delivered in a packaged box camouflaged as an ordinary gift

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Gopi,
    what you describe: “all lower caste Hindus to follow the wedding customs, eating habits, other customs/celebrations, dress habits on special ocacsions etc followed once only by the “higher caste” Brahmins/nairs.” is a textbook case of Sanskritization.
    It is intersting that Srinivas first called it Brahminizatrion but, later on modified it to Sanskritization. The reason was a few renegade brahmins (like Bengali Brahmins!) who ate non-vegetarian food. So, he coined the word Sanskritization.
    And, the other trend that you observe among the Brahmins and Nairs- of earlier rituals not being followed- could be either due to de-sanskritization or westernization. Westernization is one of the most contentious postulates of Srinivas- it has been attacked by many as the one among his theories with the least universal applicability. Westernization, the way Srinivas saw it was an omnibus concept of industrialization, urbanization etc- but different from western culture. Quite interesting.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    well, the interesting thing is that these trends are fairly recent here – say last 20 years with economic progress. I remember going for the wedding of my classmate… and five years ago I went for the wedding of his daughter — everything was different including food items (ie for his wedding there was fish and meat curry, but now, for his daughter’ wedding it was all vegetarian, as the custom among nairs)…

    AshishC Reply:

    Sanskritization is an ongoing process. Seriously.
    It has been used widely to study communities, very diverse in location and composition.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish,
    While I agree with you in general terms on this posting , please allow me to point out that we may have missed an important point about necessity of preserving cattle for agricultural society / economy (notice the deliberate interchangeable use of words society and economy here).

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Raising cattle for meat is agriculture as well.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    except, as the water conservationists indicate these days that one kilo of meat is equal to 100 kilo (ratio may be off) of corn which equals xxxx gallons of water.

    So, is it possible that our ancestors intuitively knew about eco-balance

    Anonymous Reply:

    “So, is it possible that our ancestors intuitively knew about eco-balance”

    Of course, they did and to say the obvious, a society’s primary nutritional requirements are dependent on the food that is available locally at affordable prices.

    AshishC Reply:

    Interesting thought.
    Next time I am in Cochin and strolling out for my fix of beef curry and parotta on the roadside, I won’t let it stop me though!

    Anonymous Reply:

    Wonderful !!!
    You could’ve as well argued Cattle not being part of agrarian activity related to Crop cultivation.
    Now , my question – what prompted such a careless response ?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Allow a biologist to step in. Apparently you need something like this , here is a copy and paste
    This depends on your location and pasture conditions, the size and rate of intake of the animal, as well as
    how long the animal is on pasture for. Most stocking rates are based on a per day or per month basis, and can range from 1 acre per day or 2 acres per month to 6 acres per day or 12 acres per month per animal unit (1 AU = 1 x 1000 lb cow w/ or w/o a calf that consumes 25 lb of forage per day). Check with your local county extension agent for more accurate stocking rate numbers for your area.
    THUS CATTLE REARING USES MASSIVE AMOUNT OF LAND.
    i had a patient in Wales (most are farmers) , he had 200 beef cattle, HE ALSO GREW OATS(kind of cereal, which I have for breakfast as oat porridge) in adjacent30acreland

    AshishC Reply:

    Mahesh,
    My response was not careless.
    As Pankaj tries to point out, there could well be an economic value of cow’s milk and using bullocks for tilling the farm; which prompted the start of the taboo.
    But, if that is true, then if in future, the economic value of rearing cattle for beef (like in western countries) would outweigh the benefit of using them for tilling the land- then the taboo could start disappearing. Won’t happen in 10 yesr or even 100. If the farms became larger, more amenable to mechanization- why not?
    Now that I have tried to explain myself, could you do me the twin favour of-
    1. Explain why you thought I could well have argued “Cattle not being part of agrarian activity related to Crop cultivation.”
    2. Can you be upfront about your question? What exactly were you alluding to/ insinuating?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ashish,
    At the outset sorry for a rather harsh choice of word.
    Back to the topic….
    Was essentially saying the same thing Pankaj stated differently. Just like all other things taboos evolved too – and in this case the reasoning could perhaps be traced to use of cattle in tilling.
    “But, if that is true, then if in future, the economic value of rearing cattle for beef (like in western countries) would outweigh the benefit of using them for tilling the land- then the taboo could start disappearing. Won’t happen in 10 yesr or even 100. If the farms became larger, more amenable to mechanization- why not?”
    Agreed – with all the attendant risks of predicting the future.
    ” Explain why you thought I could well have argued “Cattle not being part of agrarian activity related to Crop cultivation.”"
    Your terse response somehow lead me into thinking that you might actually have “glossed over” over the underlying economic causes.

    AshishC Reply:

    Peace :)
    I am more likely to take recourse to economics than in religion, anyway. I know little of either but, it is less easy to offend people with economics than with religion!
    On a lighter vein- if only it was reverse, would we have had less or more conflict in the world?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pure Non-veg reply.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Ashish,
    One of the best post I have read in last couple of weeks. Very comprehensive and convincing. I have few more suggestions, here. Many of the hindu religious practices have something to do with economy. Cow eating could have been proscribed as economic value of Cow, and ox for agriculture was immense. It also brings Holi to my mind, where bon fire will encourage, clearing of jungles for wood and hence more land for agericulture.

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Pankaj,
    thanks. Sometimes it is fun to revisit what we learnt in school/ college.
    I have heard the economic value argument for how the ban on cow slaughter came about- though there are other reasons like Budhdhism etc that have been cited. Really don’t know.
    Chhoti Holi bonfire- yes, certainly.
    On a related note, in many western cultures, folks are opting for cremation of the dead rather than burial which is as per christian practice- often because of economic pressure; burial land is so expensive.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Cremation is the norm in UK , very very few burials, land is exhorbitant , THOUGH MUSLIMS IN UK 100% BURIAL , THEY HAVE THEIR OWN LAND.Sometimes old burial site is used , with the head stone from previous burial standing side by side

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Ashish

    I think Manohar’s basic irritation arose from his support for dynasitc succession in the COngress which I ridicule. Perfect diagnosis !

    [Reply]

  • AshishC

    Where is Ravi? Seems to be away.
    Is this vacation time in UK?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    No it is not vacation time , vacation times applies to people with young kids , when the school are closed, doesn’t apply to Ravi a grandad..
    However Easter holiday is coming soon, that will be friday 6th and monday 9th , so people get a long weekend.Summer Holiday is around August/september for one month , but only applies to schools and colleges.
    Holidays are much much much less than in India .You get two and a half days for every thirty days you work. There is no moronic Casual leave or whatever.
    The country with LEAST holidays is USA. The one with MOST RELAXED approach to work is France.The ENTIRE france comes to a STANDSTILL between 1300 to 1400hrs. IT IS LUNCH TIME. French lunch is not Big Mac and fries or Sandwich , IT IS PROPER THREE COURSE MEAL WITH WINE.
    Given all that France’s productivity is one of the highest in the world.
    Oh on a small note EVERY ONE ARRIVES AT OFFICE AT 0900 HRS

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Diwali Pasta.

    Sri Lankan’s enjoy maximum holidays. Every full moon day is a holiday
    there. Worst part is that even casinos are closed on full moon day.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan

    That is interesting about full moon days in Sri Lanka….
    Is there any historical reason behind this? (such as Budhists special prayer day, or something like that)

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopiji,

    It has something to do Budhism. I was there last year for three days and one those
    day was a full moon day. Almost whole Colombo was closed barring few small
    shops. Casino opened at 12 mid night.

    Anonymous Reply:

    In countries from Portugal to Oman (through the Mediterranean sea) , the lunch break is generally from 1 PM to 4 PM (given the extreme summer temperatures and having proper meals). There may be other countries with similar or even longer lunch breaks.

    Here in India, shopkeepers in Pune, also take long lunch breaks – generally 1 PM to 3 PM. At least they used to, not sure currently, though still possible in old quarters of the city.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    We work two shifts here. 1.30 to 4 PM is a lunch break. Banks, government offices
    and some Multinational companies work single shift.

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Ashish

    I think Ravi has gone in for penance and would emerge as a better man.

    His postings had tended to go beyond just conspiracy theories. In one he was hinting at a terrible attack of BJP+ RSS + Isreal+ US + Republicans to make an anti Dalit and anti_Muslim pill to eradicate them “racially.” Well it would require sheer genius to conclude Dalits and Muslims are races and sheer .

    The idea of the pill was surely out of Gotham city — where batman and Robin fight such villians Or out of Muridke, where Hafeez Saeed trains his believers to attack the world conspiring against themm using such creative folk tales.

    I have suggested to him to stick to subjects close to London which would be more informative to us as he is clearly out of depth on India and tends to get in Modi, RSS and rape even if the subject happens to be Dev Anand.

    Further my honest suggestion is to him is to read more. Osama may have studied engineering in US, but it does not mean that Americans should now look at themselves though the eyes of Osama.

    One stupid women called Wendy Doniger cannot be the touchstone of what we indians are. Now just because she sees everything sexual in a minaret (a penis) , the mouth of a burka coverd woman (a vagina) , cannot make this the truth. Only a dunce or someone who suffers from such fantasies would see this as the truth.

    Funny part is I work with psychiatrists and psychologists and even have a lengthy meeting lined up today evening. We have deliberatley now sidelined Freudian psychoalaysts from this project, for their INABILTY to see beyond rambling intrepretation of what the mind is. Jung , who was Freud’s junior and beleived in scietific experiments which integrated psychology with medical facts has won…

    The message to Ravi is not everything is what a Gora/gori psychoanalyst says iit s

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    In historic speech, Zardari portrays a Pakistan few recognise

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/international/article3006417.ece

    Excerpt

    Amid slogan shouting by the opposition parties, the President — who has been the target of a ‘go Zardari go’ campaign — sought to paint a picture of Pakistan that is in contrast with the general perception of the state of the nation, drawing ridicule from Leader of the Opposition Nisar Ali Khan who pondered aloud as to “which Pakistan is he talking about”.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I thought it was a reasonable speech

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra

    BEEF eating”””””””””’

    Engerich, I am never far away, i am reading this blog quietly. Now and then I get fired up and come and fire a salvo. Like when I bored you all with my treatise on Hindu civilisations greatness, its interaction with Greeks, Arabs and most imp- Chinese- two of the most advanced civilisations saying hello to each other across the himalayas.

    It proved too much for our India hater Ravi who is in a hosp somewhere getting treatment for a nervous breakdown haha.

    Agree with Ashish’s observations on Sanskritization in general. Only 2 points-

    1. Just because my ancestors did something 2000 years ago, does not mean I have to do it now. Ref- beef eating, rampant sexuality a la Kamasutra style. Individuals evolve, societies evolve.

    2. I was non veg for a few years, but ultimately my love for animals could not get over the cruelty of slaughter- PERIOD. And I am very proud that the hindu civilisation way back in 300 BC was perhaps the first in the world to look at the moral aspect of this slaughter.

    I do belive that in the next 200-500 years the whole world will be vegetarian.

    [Reply]

    Dr Mishra Reply:

    watch this horrible halal slaughter- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PkAWGgE0-oQ

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Typical COWBELT islamophobia, as much I loathe halal slaughter , I cannot single out Muslims .Jewish KOSHER predates islam by 1000yrs.
    Animal breeders and geneticist are working out a breed which will produce animals with the part responsible for pain perception in brain undevoloped.Thus no pain during slaughter.
    JC BOSE proved thatPLANTS ALSO HAVE FEELING LIKE ANIMALS AND RESPOND POSITIVLEY TO MUSLIC AND NEGATIVELY TO NOXIOUS STIMULII

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Shan

    You dispalyed Islamophobia while reacting to Rizwan’s post. Dr mishra’s os just a viewpoiint which you may or may not agree to

    Anonymous Reply:

    VERY CRUEL, BRUTAL AND MERCILESS.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    That means there will be no islam , DREAM ON , or better time for more smorkelling

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Baisakhi spaghetti…. That means all Muslims will become vegetarian

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Shan,

    Thoroughly inappriate reaction. Dr mishra was talking about vegetarianism getting more and more popular. Medically too, Dr Dean Ornish has proved that vegetarians have less heartm lung, kidney and cancer problems.

    Wish you should understand the other person before launching a hysterical tirade.

    PS : Remember I have not used the words Nirodh babu in this posting.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I think the key to good health for the non-vegetarians is to reduce the intake of meat and increase nutritious vegtables and leaves. More of fish too would be more healthy.

    For the vegetarians, go for more proteins and other nutrients.

    All should intake more than adequate quantity of curds/yogurt.

    LONG LIVE A HEALTHY BHARAT.

  • Anonymous

    Mamta’s time…. over?

    With the SP set to join the UPA, it is goodbye for mamta. Suddenly you will see a toned down version of her.

    Danger zone: Mulayam will find it easier to putch for the PM’s seat in case UPA collapses or a third front type becomes the government in 2014.

    Time to say bye to all the goodwork done since 1991

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Riswan puttar, pl u ignore cingular shrill dr shan, when he calls you pakistani he is like Gali ka nikamma who finds his own abuse exhilrating. I liked your HARD HITTING points about Indian underbelly.
    Your story about Mrs Sharma being lechered by male relatives had a very sad touch to it. Bet you her molester would have been a Dr.shan type charaterless man. Your family will get your reward in this life and next, you bring tears to my eyes.
    And even in Punjab I have seen myself farm labour eomen carying even 5 yest old girls to work otherwise some lecher can do unforgivable act. And that is fact puttar. Mera bhaarat mahaan , not now.
    ps Gopi one of best posts on rigvedas. It took me 5 months to finish Ed Luce In spite of Gods and now I shall buy vedas book. Any suggestion on small book anyone, I read slowly

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Gambir is not playing with gambhirta.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    EC gives green signal to new auditing norms for political parties

    http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_ec-gives-green-signal-to-new-auditing-norms-for-political-parties_1664016

    In a step that will bring in transparency and help curb black money in the poll process, the Election Commission has given its nod to new auditing and accounting norms for political parties in the country.

    The norms and guidelines, prepared by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), will soon be notified to the political parties by the EC and financial enforcement agencies like the Income Tax department and the RBI.

    ———–

    Read on.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Saina reaches finals of Swiss Open

    http://www.thehindu.com/sport/other-sports/article3009275.ece

    Defending champion Saina Nehwal reached her second consecutive final of the Swiss Open Grand Prix Gold with a straight—game victory over Japan’s Minatsu Mitani in the semifinals in Basel, Switzerland.

    ———

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    She won the the final too. Congrats.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Congrats. Great news.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Now railway unions threaten agitation if fare hike is rolled back.
    How will Mamta di react ?

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Railway-unions-threaten-agitation-against-any-rollback-in-fares/articleshow/12315214.cms

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Let us wait and watch.

    Whether
    1) Mamta refuses to budge from the rollback.
    and
    2) the opposition also supports the roll back. They are on test.

    If both are affirmative, then God save the Railways, or perhaps once Manta is neutralised, then after a few months the fares may be hiked.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    A good win by India. Congrats.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Great one ! I missed most of the match… but what I saw made me feel that Virat is the next Sachin

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Surprisingly no one is commenting about VDIS – Voluntary Disclosure of Income Scheme- proposed in this budget.

    Unexplained money, credits and investments would attract the highest tax rate of 30 per cent irrespective of the income slab of the person possessing these assets.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Alsistar MacAuley’s review of Indian/Odissi dance/Nrityagram in today’s NY Times. He is NYT’s main art critic – some amazing observations about movement, rhythm, sound..

    http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/18/arts/dance/nrityagram-dance-ensemble-at-joyce-theater.html

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Interestring article. Sometimes an outsider can see things we cannot.

    Was surprised to know that Protima Bedi had a serious side to her.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    —————————————————————————————————————————–
    ~~~~ WHICH ROAD SHOULD WE TAKE ????? ~~~
    —————————————————————————————————————————-

    here are two roads which different groups of nations are following

    Road no 1 followed by

    1) Australia– New zealand — USA — Canada — UK — Japan — CHina — France
    Russia — Turkey — Malaysia — Italy — Mexico — Brazil — Sweden — Switzerland — Sri Lanlka — Norway — South Korea —

    Road no 2 followed by

    Pakistan- Bangladesh – Cuba – North Korea — erstwhile Libya — Erstwhile Iraq — Syria — Saudi Arabia– somalia– ethopia

    Which road should we follow ??????

    By the way Road no 1 is of democracies where dynasitc succession does not matter.

    Road no 2 is followed by countries where warped democracy or dictatorships based on family and dynasty succession rulers grab power.

    Choice is ours. We should have been leading the world. Now we have to folllow the world and choose a road…

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Vijay

    A very pertinent issue. When I I started following news from 1977 onwards, India was one of the few nations which was democractic. Now we have become a lax democracy.

    If we give up this fantasy for families– royal families. I would call them– we can graduate to the next level

    I am not happy with this baton passing of son to daughter using black money which normal people dont have. This is family-cracy not democracy.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Frankly only weak people fall for family rule. It shows that they dont have confidence in themselves to lead and believe that only a few families have that.

    I audit accounts of many companies, many of which are family owned. in family companies, the lala thinks it his jagir– right from the chair to the bank account. I think many of our political parites like Congress, SP, DMK are only family jagirs.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @ Vinoo

    Fantastically well said !! Only the weak support family rule as they want to live lives as domestic servants.

    The DMK and SP or the Biju Janta Dal are the creation of a family and will always be a pvt ltd company. The corruption in 2g shows how these pvt ltd screw Indians of 17600000 crores.

    But eh Indian National COnress is a party of Sardar Patel., Tagore, nehru and Subhash Bose…. and GANDHI.

    it cannot be made a pvt ltd of Quotrochchi …

  • Anonymous

    Who killed Baby Falak?

    http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/article3009764.ece?homepage=true

    Excerpts

    A child died and we collectively mourn. She was just two years old. And she fought bravely, but the tubes and wires connecting her to life support in the AIIMS Trauma Centre were no match for the systemic failures that carried this baby to her death. For the truth is that Falak never really stood a chance.

    ———-

    And what of the young 15-year-old teenager who first battered and then tried to save Falak? A run-away from the slums of Sangam Vihar, right in the heart of the capital. Her mother died and her father abused her, and so she ran for security to her would-be pimps. They prostituted and raped her, again and again. And yet this frightened young girl did not reach out to any system for help.

    Should she have gone to the police? Could she have? Rape, it seems now, is such an everyday occurrence, and justice so elusive, it may have made little sense. For where would she go from the police station after lodging her FIR, with no family backing, no one to take her in? Where does she stay, how does she live as she fights a rape case? No support before, during or after. We offered her nothing but rape laws and a gender blind criminal justice system.

    ———-

    Falak’s mother Munni was apparently sold and trafficked across two State borders from Bihar to Delhi to Rajasthan.

    ———-

    And as for Baby Falak — child abuse remains among the most rampant and hidden forms of everyday violence in Indian homes. Systematic data, information and services on child protection are still not easily available. The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights set up in March 2007 is a beginning.

    [Reply]

    Dr Mishra Reply:

    yes, as Rizwan and Balwinder pointed out, sexual violence against children and vulnerable women is a blot on our society. And they are right, it needs airing- not in the Ravi type sensationalisation, but in solemn analysis.
    In families.
    In communities.
    And in the nation.

    But that takes me back to my favourite gripe- POPULATION EXPLOSION- with limited resources, such cases are bound to happen. Compared with here in UK, social security net in India is pathetically rudimentary.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Due to large population, perhaps there is no value and respect for life, especially of women, girls and children.

    Though we have very good laws in place, their implementation and policing is zilch, and that is the tragedy.

    Crimes against children must attract the most severe punishment.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,
    One important aspect here is almost total absence of state as one would expect it to function in modern democratic society.
    What we are seeing here are just manifestations – the bigger underlyiing story is our failure in building and sustaining the insitutions in its various forms.
    It gets even more depressing when one thinks more about it – will we ever be able to do it ?
    p.s. : On a related note another anecdote comes to my mind.
    Sony channel broadcasts enacted dramatisation of selected crime events in one of its shows. One ghastly incident depicted the story of a girl from Dahisar (suburb in Mumbai) working in garment factory who was trying to get her ration card with the help of local politican (perhaps a corporator). Sensing her weakness – the politican pressures her into turning over her younger sister to him. What happens after that is even more interesting. The girl narrates this to her co-workers who talk the politican into having a drink together and subsequently murder him. Notice here – the act of murder is committed by ordinary folks without any criminal record. Notice also the choice exercised by this girl and those who committed the act of murder – it wasn’t approaching the state.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mahesh

    Two of the key elements of our democracy (for that matter true for any civilised society) is the maintenance of law and order and criminal justice system. Both of them have allowed to go to the seed and almost defunct – the reasons and the cure are too well known. Trumpeting that our electoral process (only a first baby step) is near perfection and efficient is no comfort at all.

    There are no words to condemn crimes against the defenceless – tiny tots, minors and women and elderly).

    Regarding the incident in Dahisar – it is the manifestation of the rotten state of affairs – didn’t we witness the spectacle repeated time in the 70s/80s/90s and again on the screens, where the law was taken into one’s own hand by brigade led by AB to deliver or get justice. Did the politician get the punishment he deserved – never mind who delivered it?

    In Maharashtra, we have a Home Minister (for almost 8 years now), who has taken the easy way out to show he is doing justice to his work by wearing the mantle of chief moral policeman.

    Police reforms are being opposed on the grounds that it is against the federal (which we are not) structure of the country and the states are loathed to carry out the reforms themselves.

    The more frightening thought is where do we go from here.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Boy you can turn the analysis of a david dhawan’s film into an cerebral exercise of highest order.
    To look at it simply , she knew the POLITICIAN , is the STATE , thus she had to bypass the state.
    Only people who would have made the difference at least in west Bengal is MEDIA and the Opposition Party.
    I know a case where a woman from JHUGGI raped by a constable after being hauled up to the thana without any rhyme or reason.
    The opposition (TMC) and the media saw that guy was eventually sentenced to life imprisonment.
    Recent rape cases in calcutta also got the swift action because of media and opposition pressures

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    A) Govt milks its PSUs to fund metro rail project

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/govt-milks-its-psus-to-fund-metro-rail-project/925245/0

    To fund its ambitious metro rail project to link Ahmedabad and Gandhinagar, the state government has asked the already cash-strapped public sector undertakings (PSUs) owned by it to shell out Rs 500 crore by purchasing equity shares in the MEGA (Metro-Link Express for Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad), the special purpose vehicle that is executing the project.

    B) State PSUs lost Rs 4,200 cr in 3 yrs: CAG

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/state-psus-lost-rs-4-200-cr-in-3-yrs-cag/925246/0

    “Lack of professionalism and accountability” and deficiencies in functioning seem to be taking a toll on the 60-odd public sector undertakings (PSUs) in Gujarat, which have suffered a loss of over Rs 4,200 crore in the last three years, the CAG has observed in its report.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    The ’superfast’ Modi Shatabdi Express skipped this station.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Jim Yardley’s article about Akhilesh Yadav in yesterday’s NY Times

    http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/03/17/surprise-at-indias-polls-reveals-a-new-kind-of-leader/

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ MOhan

    My last posting and I need a smile to crash into bed. What better than your hearthrob, Sonam Kapoor?

    She’s is dancing on my TV— is she dancing to mashankali on your TV on SOny Mix?

    By the way there is a pigeon sitting on her head.

    All the pigeons I had as pets… would shit at odd moments– including a grey pigeon I resuced from the lift pit of my office building..

    Now how come SOnam is safe??????????

    [Reply]

    AshishC Reply:

    Pigeons only shit on statues..evidently Sonam was not one!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mahatma Gandhi statues get maximum shit.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    isnt that a truth!

    Anonymous Reply:

    I wonder how mayawati will protect her own statues…

    I hope she did not employ an army of UP police for pigeon shit cleaning..

    Anonymous Reply:

    :) … yes she must have had pigeon love :)

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Vijay,

    Sonam Kapoor my heart throb ? I did not knew that. I have only seen her twice
    in Mausam and the movie you mentioned. Not very impressed by her.
    Sonakshi Sinha – that is another matter al to gather.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    sorry… wrong number dialled then

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Folks , I woke up to an experience called CHINA. Just as you know their language is unique , they do not have ALPHABETS , like rest of the world .They have characters.Also they write in vertical columns rather than transversely.The fact that they dont have a democracy may seem as alien to rest of world , just like their language which HAS 700000 CHARACTERS, but for chinese it is natural FOR THEY VALUE CONFUCIANISM , WHICH PUTS ORDER (which chinese like to call SOCIAL HARMONY) above everything else.Thus Prof Niall Ferguson commented “It is a bit like coming from Moon with zero gravity and then experiencing gravity. To we mortals at earth tthat is quite normal , but some body from zero gravity must feel odd.
    Also CORRUPTION IN CHINA is as old as china itself.One of the first MANDARIN in emperor Chin’s court amassed so much wealth , reckoned to be around 1.2 billion in current value.According to Official chinese version , HE WAS VERY HANDSOME SO WOMEN SHOWERED HIM WITH GIFTS.
    Prof Fergusson quotes China Daily which says 280 CHINESE BUREAUCRAT AND CEO’S OF COMPANY SIMPLY VANISHED FROM CHINA TAKING WITH THEM A STAGGERING 780 BILLION(Yes you are reading it correct) yuan , that 120 billion dollar.
    A small price to pay for a CLOSED SOCIETY RULED BY NINE PEOPLE

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    I started my China office in 2006. A Chinese boy worked for my company for four
    years and left in 2010. He started his own small factory of the same goods which
    my company buys from there. Now even I have become his one of the customers.
    Should I wonder from where he made all this money to start his own manufacturing.?

    People are same around the world.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @MohanR , One question I have been itching to ask . Why do you need to source your goods from CHINA and Malaysia , WHY NOT INDIA.
    Post bin detail , on the top it will UNLOCK the mystery of india’s UNDERACHEIVEMENT.
    Hopefully someone from Planning Commissiomn will read your comment and then use their philbut and act accordingly

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    I have 2 branches in Bombay, for there also I source my goods from Malaysia and
    China. In Dubai where I have a much bigger operation I get my goods from
    other countries also, all from Far East. Korea, Vietnam, Taiwan and Indonesia
    though about 80 pct is from China and Malaysia.

    The quality, finishishing and price which I want for me to sustain in this business
    is not possible in India. Another problem is the time, an Indian manufacturer takes almost double the amount of time to produce the same quantity of goods what any
    Far eastern manufacturer would take. The usual problem which everybody knows is
    that – depends on different manufacturers – they ask somewhere between 15-40pct
    money by un official channels.

    I don’t know about other countries but if I compare doing business in India and Dubai
    than doing business in Dubai is much easier, smoother without any hassles.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Well you are absolutely correct however painful that may be.
    Not surprising in a country with KHAP PANCHAYAT , Thackarey scums and the CPM bums.
    Incredible despite all this India has manged to come this long.
    What we need is an INSPIRATIONAL LEADER
    and 100% COMPULSORY QUALITY EDUCATION , this will take care of skill shortage and corruption.
    Perhaps it will take another couple of generation

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    What I told you was about my line of business. My brother and my brother in
    law they both are in textile business. They mainly import from India and are doing quite well.
    Yes, India has to yet catch up in many fields. The most annoying thing I find
    in India is the working style of labour. Out of about 10 hours they don’t work seriously
    for than 4 hours. It is very difficult to make them work upto their full potential.
    May be big organizations are able to manage them properly but for small companies, it is very difficult.

  • Anonymous

    @Pankaj#1, Vijay Khanna , and Ravi.
    Punjabi folks , I watched a pakistani film called BOL.The setting of the film is a house in Lahore, previously owned by Lala Ram chander, now occupied by some khan from Delhi.
    What struck me was the decoration inside the house. The entire walls were covered with filigree and painting showing Lord Krishna and Radha .
    Please confirm are hindu punjabi houses always had this kind of decoration

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Shan;
    No inkling about this but film Bol has been highly recommended by my friends. Will certainly see it.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,
    Bol is a must watch..Pakistanis can definitely make good cinema.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Shan,

    I saw this movie about six months ago.one of the best I have seen.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    have not seen bol. But saw Khuda ke liye, which I liked…

    But….

    I was very very disappointed to know that it was funded by the ISI/

    Nadeem Pracha reveals tthat this was in the Musharraf period when moderate Taliban was gud. Engirch type hardline Taliban was bad,

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    Vinoo;
    Would have loved to get lost in Vagas, temptation was great. But this was possible only 20 years back and I had little money. Ha.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Crisis in Karnataka BJP, Yeddyurappa whisks away 55 MLAs to resort

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bangalore/Crisis-in-Karnataka-BJP-Yeddyurappa-whisks-away-55-MLAs-to-resort/articleshow/12321078.cms

    The DV Sadananda Gowda-led BJP government in Karnataka was on the brink of a crisis with BS Yeddyurappa shepherding 55 loyalist-MLAs to a resort in the outskirts of the city late on Sunday, setting a 48-hour deadline for the party high command to reinstate him as chief minister.

    ———-

    Read on.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    BJP should suspend Yedurappa, let the chips fall..These guys believe it is their right to be CM?????

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi

    IMO, the BJP will do no such thing, as any other party would not either. Look at the UPA, it has been subjected to a non-stop humiliation by the TMC for the last 10 months and no nerve to call the bluff. The presiding deity is ‘power at all costs’.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Manohar,

    Power at all costs. That is what is happening. No one cares about the nation or it’s
    people. They will suffer any humiliation just to remain in power. These politicians suck.

    Anonymous Reply:

    See from the other side. Stay on the crease if you want to score. You have to deal with these situations. These are hard realities.I do not think it’s very different in business.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Sanjay

    However, any self-respecting individual / party would have the courage and say enough is enough, let the Government fall and followed by new elections. As of now, there is almost total policy paralysis, which is not acceptable.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Just that the thresholds are different for us and the politicians.

    Anonymous Reply:

    The question is not about threshold levels, it is policy paralysis that one needs to worry about.

    Anonymous Reply:

    There are many reasons for policy paralysis. Being questioned about the intent is the biggest fear.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Sanjay,

    Let them than openly declare that this a business and they are in this for personal
    benefit only.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Don’t they conduct business in the house ?

    Anonymous Reply:

    Good reply, or should I say good joke.

    Anonymous Reply:

    Learning from you.

    AshishC Reply:

    No one (least of all, in BJP) ever listens to me :P
    Toxic waste needs to be buried in specially reinforced concrete enclosure 20 feet under.

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    Shenoy Sahab;
    Please send his number through other means. I will certainly meet him. My friend has a huge property near this Strip and I frequently visit him.
    BTW Vegas resembles latin word Vagus, a la vagus nerve,which means a wanderer or AWARA. I am doing some awargardi here. Shan/ Dr. Mishra can confirm this.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Yes that is true , a related word is vagabond

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Pankaj,

    When in Vegas try playing more Black Jack than Poker. There arge more chances of
    winning at black jack tables than at poker.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    BJP is digging further — Now they are nominating Ajay Sancheti (of Adarsh fame) to Rajya Sabha…

    And Yedurappa is on a vengence trip– he will bring down the Karnataka govt!

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    A) SP ‘workers’ kill teen, relatives say political rivalry

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/samajwadi-party-workers-kill-teen-kin-say-political-rivalry/925495/

    The family of Salman (18) said he was a supporter of the BSP and was killed because of political rivalry. Police, however, denied the allegation and said Salman, a student, was killed over a trivial issue. Among those arrested were police constable Mohammad Fareed, his two sons Pervez and Javed, and their relative Jiyauddin alias Baccha. Police said Mohammad Fareed had not attended duty since 2010. The vehicle in which they were trying to escape has been seized.

    B) CM Akhilesh to head 50 departments

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/cm-akhilesh-to-head-50-departments/925485/0

    Interestingly, Raghuraj Pratap Singh alias Raja Bhaiya has been made jail minister besides giving him the portfolio of civil supplies and food department.

    C) Kushwaha report card in BJP: 2/10

    Of the 10 seats in which the BJP fielded Kushwaha candidates, the party won only two. On four, the BSP candidates won in spite of Kushwaha’s campaigning against them, on three the Samajwadi Party won and on one the Ittehad-e-Millait Council.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Samajwadis did not require any support of anybody else; they had absolute majority. So, I do not understand why Akhileshwar had to include Raj Bhaiya, even if the relationship between Sp and Bhaiya are deep.. Is it more like a payback for services rendered???

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Yes. It’s the payback time !

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    All;
    Modi on Times cover page.
    Kamar 40, Chhati43, phoola ke 44. I am happy.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    A purge with no losers

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/a-purge-with-no-losers/925322/0

    One of the more significant of these acts, with far-reaching effect, was what came to be known as the Kamaraj Plan, aimed at revitalising the Congress organisation and the governmental administration so that they could meet head-on the mounting criticism of the entire opposition of the debacle in the high Himalayas.

    K. Kamaraj was the chief minister of Tamil Nadu (then called the state of Madras) and generally admired for his competence, probity and spartan lifestyle. At that time he was greatly troubled by the rapid rise in his home state of the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), a regional party that had at one time stood for secession from India but later joined the political mainstream. Consequently, Kamaraj was toying with the idea of giving up the office of chief minister and heading the state party to counter the DMK.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    If history took another course, and if the leftists in Congress did not stand in the way of Morarji, India would have been like Taiwan or South korea today — rich democratic countries…Lot of “ifs”, but having lived through and seen the socialistic arguments from then and through Shirimathi Indira Priyadarshini Gandhi..

    btw the ‘no no no” of Kamraj he refers in the article refers to Kamraj’s often used word “parkalam”… a Tamil word for “later” “lets see”..

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @ Gopi

    Dont have any illusions of what our politicians are and how they operate. It requires a Lok Pal type of anti corruption movement to throw the scare.

    Today morning I got a call from a guy who had won the election on a SP ticket. He had earlier purchased a small office in a complex which I had designed in Delhi. He hinted that he can now get any work done in UP… including settling land disputes through “power”

    I profusely thanked hm for the offer… and said good bye !

    But then there are many people who would use such offers to settle scores… and make money…

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    @Gopi

    I did not have any interaction with Akhilesh. Now that he has few portfolio of my interest, I may have to approach him. Just that things are getting difficult in last two days.

    I was sad to see SP supporters behaving badly on the street, though understandable. They were not expecting such a landslide victory, hence the euphoria. Similar incidents were reported from Kolkata after TMC’s victory. I was hoping that “3 days” of free-for-all euphoria would die down soon. But it’s kind of getting extended.

    Please don’t go by the top level sophistication of SP. The underbelly of UP politics is very dirty. Only a good writer can write a realistic screenplay of Raja Bhaiya and the politics in UP. It’s only in Hindi films we see a dreaded criminal in prison getting elected and then becoming a minister for the prison. Now all the jail authorities have to openly salute him !

    Perhaps, Prof Mishra is one of the very few sane voice around there. I am disappointed that he was not offered the educational portfolio ! May be later, once Akhilesh gets over pleasing the hard core politicians !

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    I have a feeling that Raja Bhaiyya will first take revenge against all the jail officers who may not have been friendly to him.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Interesting plot for your best seller. Could be intense than Vikram Chandra’s.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Thanx !!

    But some where real life turns out to be stranger than fiction in UP. I have seen killers– exactly 5-1″ who dont resemble james Bond or Agent Vinod or Gabbar SIngh or Gulshan Grover.

    They would blow away in case you sneeze.

    But I have seen them extracting cash from Brick Kiln owners in Loni, Ghaziabad. Reason– they have shot people, got away because of political connections…

    Or maybe becasue the politcos send them for collection.

  • Anonymous

    Can I post this now or do I have to wait till late night. Will do it now only.

    Bhid wali bus mein ke ladki apne peeche chipke khade ladke se boli
    ‘ bus me hum dono ke liye theek se khade hone ki jagah nahi hai
    aur tum ho ki teesre ko khada kar rahe ho’

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    How can someone defend this?

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/retrospective-retrograde/925362/

    If the SC has ruled in favour of Vodafone, how can the govt. change the law retrospectively and ask for the taxes from the company?

    On the flip side, was any tax paid on this transaction in any country?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ishwar,

    I read about this few days ago and was surprised by this news.
    Laws changing retrospectively can create problems for some and can also
    bring huge financial gain for some people. Is India unique in such cases ?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Mohan,

    I am against this principle of making laws retrospectively, however, it is within the power of the state and I am glad that Mr. Mukherjee has gone ahead with this. The big corporate houses are finding innovative ways of avoiding taxes on huge financial transactions. If it takes something as drastic as this to get them, so be it.

    Interesting: I pay (service) tax on my mobile phone bill but if someone buys the whole company operating in this country, no tax is due!!

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Ishwar

    What is your opinion about the impact on FDI, especially with this going retroactively back to 1960s?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    Gopi,

    Well, the honest businessman (an oxymoron!!) would continue to invest and bring in money. Our country’s economy is growing and even if it grows at 7%, it would still be higher than many developed countries.

    The manipulators of the laws needed to be sent a signal. You are welcome to invest and make profit by innovation in your product/service/technology, however, you can’t hope to make profit out of a loophole in the law – it would catch up one day. “Shathe shathyam samacharet”.

    In an ideal world, there should be no such thing as a law with rospective effect, but, Vodafone tried to be too clever by a half and was eventually caught.

    Cancellation of 2G licences by the SC is another example. There was manipulation by a few foreign companies in collaboration with their Indian counterparts and politicians and eventually it didn’t pay off.

    By the way, Mr. Sharma’s new blog is now live.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Yeddyurappa ups ante, fields rebel candidate in RS polls from K’taka

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/yeddyurappa-ups-ante-fields-rebel-candidate-in-rs-polls-from-ktaka/925631/

    B J Puttaswamy, who served as political secretary to chief minister when Yeddyurappa was at the helm and continued in his post under his successor D V Sadananda Gowda, filed his nomination papers.

    “I have filed nomination as a third candidate (of the BJP)”, he said.

    ======

    [Reply]

  • Poirot

    It really leaves a lot to be said…when mainstream papers such as TOI & HT editors don’t bother to proof read and glaring typos keep staring at the readers..

    [Reply]