Anna Hamare!



Anna Hazare’s campaign against corruption isn’t significant as much for the fact that he made the government bend. Its import  lies in registering the malaise in public consciousness like never before. The issue has acquired the potency of a slogan that could drive voters. It happened once before in 1989 when V P Singh put allegations of slush money in Bofors gun deal in public domain.

The term of the then Lok Sabha was nearing an end and the combined Opposition captured popular imagination way beyond their actual sacrifice by resigning en masse from the lower House. The situation now is different.

The 15th Lok Sabha is less than two years old and Hazare is spewing venom against the political class in one breath and praising a select few in another. The certificate he handed down to Narendra Modi — besides Bihar’s Nitish Kumar — was better avoided. Regardless of his relatively better record of governance, the Gujarat CM evokes extreme reactions that aren’t in the interest of a united fight against corruption sans caste, language, region or religion.

That the BJP strongman has done well to devolve powers to rural bodies and develop rural patches in a hugely urbanized state might well be true. But for some, it isn’t okay to celebrate rural reforms in the killing fields of 20O2. The assembly polls Modi won in the wake of the post-Godhra violence had seen men like Praveen Togadia calling the Mahatma names.

The CM did nothing about it. He was then a big patron of such elements and their communal agenda. Hazare has since sought to limit the damage by clarifying that his praise for Modi does not mean that he condoned the riots. I trust him. But he’d need to do more to get on his side a wider section of people including clean and saner political elements without whose support he’d have problems sustaining the anti-corruption crusade. I say this because respectable men like the SP’s Mohan Singh and the RJD’s Raghuvansh Prasad — both former socialists associated with Jayaprakash Narayan— have questioned his tactics while supporting the cause he’s espousing.

JP couldn’t have defeated Indira Gandhi’s Congress without the passion and integrity of socialists of varied hue and the logistical support of the cadre-based RSS. Hazare does not have one (socialists’ backing) and he cannot afford to overtly align with the other (the Sangh) as the torchbearer of the Mahatma’s values. The saffron brigade has in recent years acquired so much communal baggage that it’s companionship is a liability in social and political terms.

Rather than rejecting the political class lock, stock and barrel, Hazare must permit in his fold those willing to give up power to work for cleansing the system. He can of course evolve his own strict criterion (based on probity and past record) to sew up such alliances. These kind of tie-ups are essential because democracy is sustained by the poor, the below poverty line people, not by the vocal middle and upper middle classes given to conspicuous consumption and commodity fetish.

In the candle light vigils and hunger strikes Hazare’s marshaled is metros and million-plus cities had negligible participation from the real victims of corruption — moral, physical, social and financial. If he has to succeed, he’d have to wean such sections away from the Naxalites. More ironically, the media that rooted for Hazare hasn’t had much time for the weaker sections — tribals, dalits, peasants, small farmers and minorities — who take the brunt of the establishment’s corrupt ways and big businesses’ relentless profiteering and rape of natural resources.

The media is either a beneficiary or an adjunct of such vested interests. Its does stings on elected representatives but not the moneybags who buy them to manipulate the system. As the battle is perceptional, Hazare, while pursuing the Lok Pal Bill and its enactment by Parliament, must take steps for public audit and voluntary disclosures by his own self and those in his inner circle. This must include NGOs, Gurus and God men claiming authorship of the anti-graft movement Anna now presides over. It’s easier said than actually making these sections fall in line.

Streets were stirred and social networking sites activated in Hazare’s support by camp followers and worshippers of these so-called spiritual gurus who now must come clean on the empires they have built. Or else the movement against corruption will be a utopian dream. Charity as the cliché goes begins from home. The accountability debate can only be led by setting personal example.

Gandhi did not travel by choppers. He owned no palatial ashrams and television channels. He told us rich held the wealth as trustees of the poor: “I am inviting those people who consider themselves as owners today to act as trustees, i.e., owners, not in their own right, but owners in the right of those whom they have exploited.

Supposing I have come by a fair amount of wealth—either by way of legacy, or by means of trade and industry—I must know that all that wealth does not belong to me; what belongs to me is the right to an honourable livelihood, no better than that enjoyed by millions of others.

The rest of my wealth belongs to the community and must be used for the welfare of the community.” So it isn’t just about bribe takers. It is also about those who make money talk.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (29 votes, average: 1.79 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • http://www.rediff.com Paritosh

    @ Vinod

    there you with your anti BJP rant in the initial paragraphs.

    in the final paras , you seem to have made an indirect mention of Swami Ramdev.i dont get whats your damn problem who poses as a spiritual guru and aims to fend off corruption

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    typo – ” ……whats your damn problem with the one who is a spiritual guru and aims to fend off corruption”

    [Reply]

    PB Reply:

    @Vinod

    You are a educated person and you can’t see what currupt(congi) party has done to all country.

    you can just see Gujrat Riots. You cann’t see Bhopal Gas, Bofors, 84 Anti Sikh Riots these are

    only the few in my list if i will start writing currupt party history I will need atleast few months.

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @paritosh
    I have no problem with anybody who discloses his wealth before being accepted as a crusader against corruption.

    [Reply]

  • B.V.SHENOY

    Vinodji,

    It is really sad that you cannot resist the temptation of indulging in Modi bashing given the slightest pretext. For you, it is okay to celebrate urban development in the killing fields of Delhi, where Rajiv Gandhi had 4000 innocent Sikh men, women and even children massacred in the biggest pogrom in the history of India, yet you are very comfortable that the Sonia Gandhi government had rewarded his service for creating the killing fields, with the Bharat Ratna.

    You are so quiet about how Anna Hazare subjected Sharad Pawar to terrible humiliation by demanding his ouster from the GOM, even when he had no objection to the presence in the same GOM of other corrupt and morally bankrupt ministers like Oily Moily and Sickular Sibal. You didn’t find any dichotomy in this demand?

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @BV shenoy
    Two wrongs don’t make a right. Modi hasn’t even apologised for the 2002 bloodshed. What’s more, he let his cohorts vilify Gandhi to win elections.

    [Reply]

    vaibhav Reply:

    When has Congress (I) [read Gandhi pariwar] apologized for the Sikh massacre and even if it did in future an apology is nothing…..a massacre requires punishment not apology….if Modi is guilty punish him…otherwise an apology is an easy escape route

    You are against Sangh pariwar and I am against “Indira Gandhi” pariwar….there is hardly a meeting ground

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    but what about the Singh parivar?

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    @Vinod Sharma ji

    Sir,
    Gandhis (Mrs. Sonia) is not a holy cow after all. She started the vilification process by calling him “Maut ke saudagar’ and got an immediate response. Why to complain? After all, politics is a ruthless game and one has to be prepared for all actions and reactions. After all, it is not a one sided show.
    BNA

    [Reply]

    payal Reply:

    yeah sharma two wrongs do not make a right……especially if the second wrong is an alleged bjp one and the first wrong is a proven congress one…

    infact only congress wrongs make a right evn if there a million such wrongs in 60 years starting with half amillion dead under nehru gandhi in 1947…modi’s 2002 are a picnic in comparison to that and ocngress 1969,1985 and other riots in gujarat when peolelike u were
    dancing unedr a congress trance like u do for sikh riots and godhra train etc…

    yeah congress wrongs r fine..no wonder u nevr reproted congress scamsi in last 3 yrs let alone before…and were shamlessely smiling away on tv…but were so angry with the supreme court
    for slamming ur congress govt for corruption..

    yeah sharma we belive ur wagging tongue when usay ur r aginst corruption…only of the pocket thief yeddy kind..but not the quatrochi italian kind eh

    looting apoor country is no wrong for u because u were a congress lapdog for all these yaers…
    with so called loot fed media like this…no wonder india is so poor

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Payal
    Your opening lines are a giveaway. They don’t sound like payal. They sound like paid news :) )

  • akul

    I was sure that the moment Anna Hazare captured the imagination of the people, these part time journalists would start digging dirt.I have seen this man sharma on television and he looks so undignified and biased. Wish he could borrow a chapter from Swapan Dasgupta. There is a limit to being biased. the worst thing is that these HT journos have no shame. They take it as a badge of honor and dub everyone as trolls. only Kumkum Chadha is a bit dignified.

    [Reply]

  • M.Srinath

    Sharmaji, Anna has a simple world view which may not be as ‘cerebral’ as yours. He is as secular as any Gandhian can be. His ‘certificate’ to Modi was on rural development and it should be considered for just that. When persons of unimpeachable integrity launch a crusade for a noble cause, nitpicking from the political and intellectual class becomes inevitable perhaps fearing the rumble under their feet. All i can say to those who are indirectly championing the cause of the corrupt is : Thum katl karthey ho tho churcha naheen hotha. Hum aah barthey hein tho badnam hothey hain.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    Mr Sharma’s proclivity to see everything through the ‘Congress prism’ and use of such baseless, callous and thuggish, provocative and juvenile language like ‘killing fields of Gujrat’ ( Mr Sharma should have been made to spend a few hours under the pol-pot regime in Cambodia ) , renders his views meaningless jibberish.

    [Reply]

    b l pandita Reply:

    BUT Mr sharma why have you not said a word about killings of 4 thousand KPs/sikhs and hounding out 4 lac ancestrial residents at kashmir HOW is Farooq Abdullah , omer heading central and state GOVERNMENTS .Why there is no aplogy from any one .Why only Mr MODI BASHING .What was the basis of killing at delhi and Kashmir ?

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @mukesh
    Pl show the tolerance towards other people’s views. Insinuations are no substitute for good argument. Thanx

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @rajiv
    I covered the 2002 riots as also the 1984 anti sikh riots. Can’t forget.Can’t forgive those those perpetrated them.

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Vinod Sharma,

    Then why do you forgive the guy who said… jab ek bada ped girta hai toh dharit hilti hai??? :D

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    Dear Vinod
    1. Godhra and Gujrat, terrible tragedies, but time to move on. If I remember correctly, 100 policemen died during the riots testifying to the widespread fury and of a situation totally out of control.
    2. Let the law take its course, and if Modi is guilty, punish him
    3. But sometimes healing comes with progress, with commerce, with the realisation that individuals and communities are interdependent and integrated. And people need to interact and empathise with each others pain.
    4. Yes, Anna Hazare treads a minefield if he leaves this middle of the road path and veers to any party. Looking at Kapil Sibal’s ghastly comments and the silence of ‘heir aparent’ Rahul, I am disappointed that the Congress party is going into this Lokpal bill with lack of enthusiasm.

    Journalists like you have a duty today to attack this devious go slow by the Congress to make sure that the Indians have a Lokpal WITH TEETH. Nothing less.
    Dr Mishra, Yorkshire

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Dr Mishra
    fight against corruption is non-negotiable sir. we’ll have to fight whoever comes in the way— this government or any future government.

    [Reply]

  • Gianinder

    Dear Vinod,

    Please move on in Life lest you are dumped in the dustbin of history as another archiac tainted journalist. The problem with you is not your congress leaning but rather your desperate attempts to hide it all the time to project yourself as a neutral Journalist with High integrity. There are Chandan Mitra’s and others who openly flont their party affiliations along with being in Journalism so when one reads them one knows where they are coming from. What makes you a sinner is that you practice the a high value profession like Journalism and project yourself as someone that you definetly are not. Come out in the open and along with appointment to Minority council and other largesses ,your party and first family will get more genereous in throwing some benefits towards you. Be a man and stand up for what you believe in…..stop this farce, it’s getting so repetitive.One last word”FOR HEAVENS SAKE STOP SMILING ON TV…..IT’s not such a great smile as your cronies would like you to believe”.

    [Reply]

  • Vineet

    Being an Indian and a Journalist, dont you guys have a moral responsibilty to support this man?
    Instead of being a spactator and writing article to analyze the situtaion and tell Anna that dont do this dont do that. Why dont you become an Actor and support him for the good cause. It would have been better If you write articles to defend Anna Hajare from politicle people who can try to take his statements in the ohter way.

    [Reply]

  • Vivek Balasubramaniam

    “But for some, it isn’t okay to celebrate rural reforms in the killing fields of 20O2″

    I am not able to understand what you exactly want. If he doesn’t develop rural Gujarat, and if he does, you don’t give him the credit. And why aren’t you commenting on the shameful obstinacy of the UPA? And Rahul baba?

    [Reply]

  • Mukesh

    Sharmaji, it has become your dharma to bash Modi on any or every pretext. Do you know what “killing fields” are or you are just parroting what 10 Janpath directs you to write? Have you ever written about the ‘killing fields’ of Kashmir or Assam or Bangladesh? You have become rather obnoxious with your one-track mindset and you and your bias stand xposed at a chauraha. Please sometimes try to use some common sense and not conman sense.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Mukesh,

    as I understand the term, “The Killing Fields are a number of sites in Cambodia where large numbers of people were killed and buried by the Khmer Rouge regime, during its rule of the country from 1975 to 1979, immediately after the end of the Vietnam War.”

    [Reply]

  • Gaurav

    Just like there were people …even Indians… opposed to Mahatma Gandhi and his good work… some people today are opposed to Mahatma Modi ji. :)

    [Reply]

    chlm Reply:

    Sharma ji – You should stop your journalism and join the Congress party – Show me one state under Congress which is as progressive asGujarat !.

    [Reply]

  • Rakesh Chitkara

    Perhaps time has come for Anna Hazare to a adopt a low profile, and restrict his access to media. He will do more harm to his image than enhance it. More he speaks, greater are the chances of his being trapped unwittingly by some mediahound who specialise in generating controversial sound bytes.

    Goodwill should not be allowed to wither away. His close advisors must put it to him firmly. Leave the talking and briefing to the nominated persons in his group. He must accept that he is not a seasoned politician, and that knives are out to cut the halo around him.

    [Reply]

  • http://natureparkindia.blogspot.com Sharat Sindhwani

    We will turn the saying around
    “MERA BAHRAT MAHAAN JIS MEIN DUS MEIN NAU HAIN BE-IMAAN”
    into
    “MERA BHARAT MAHAAN: IS MEIN SIRF RAJNEETIGYA AUR KUCH SARKARI HAIN BE-IMAAN”.

    We can clearly see the solution lies in
    15th August ko “SANSAD GHERAO”
    and ostracise the politician
    BOYCOTT ELECTIONS
    form a
    “NATIONAL MANAGEMENT GROUP” TO MANAGE INDIA INC.

    “WE THE PEOPLE” ARE SHARE HOLDERS. EACH ONE HAS A VOTE. WE SHALL CHOOSE OUR OWN CORPORATE HEADS AND BRANCH VICE PRESIDENTS & MANAGERS BY NOMINATION ON THE BASIS OF QUALIFICATIONS NOT UNIVERSITY DEGREES BUT SCHOOLING, CHARACTER AND SOCIAL PERFOMANCE.

    Anyone who talks nonsense can be sacked. Performance will speak for itself.
    Anna Hazare is the true representative of the common man of India. Watching debates on TV on JLP (JanLOKPAL BILL) sounded like attending a fish market.Politicians have forgotton the common man somewhere. Each man is busy inventing a new method of dividing Anna Hazare’s campaigners. From inducing fears of “Power Corrupts” to “Anna as dictator of India”. Basically these corrupt politians are shivering in their pants as they will not get a chance to fool the common man anymore.India Against Corruption IAC is “non political” it talks of the needs of the common man. “Mean and selfish” politians gave rise to lose talks like “non secular forces” and ” reservations for jatiwaad”. No Indian Hindu hates any Indian Muslim or the Christian or the Sikh. The common man knows that each religion teaches the same thing and has the same essential cons****uents. Its like going to attend St. Joseph’s Academy or the Doon School. The subject of Physics or Chemistry remains the same. The same formula “Caustic soda plus oil” makes soap!! When our politicians talk of non-issues like Babri Masjid for decades they think the common man can be fooled and made to go hungry with increased food prices.
    Sorry dear politicians you have had your innings. Now it’s the common man’s innings.

    [Reply]

  • M Aziz

    Dear Anna Ji,
    Why you did it to us?? Why you misguided us? Why you wear the mask of RSS, who was/are always against the principle of Mahatma Gandhi? We were thinking you are working like Mahatma Gandhi but…………………this is big but. Our heart are weeping and please never do that again, we are innocent and poor citizens of this great country, India. Please please don’t do it with us again. We trusted you but you misguided us. Sorry to say you are not our leader like Mahatma Gandhi. Thanks.

    [Reply]

  • G Vishwanathan

    It has become a practice to indulge in MOdi bashing by these Pseduo Secularists. Rajiv Gandhi & family can be gorgiven for the 1984 riots & we will still honur them. It is only due to so called jounalists like Vinod Sharma who have no qualms about selling his soul to the Devil, thet Congress gets away with this kind of arrogance & duplicity.

    [Reply]

  • Bhaaratiya

    Indian political system lacks transparency like all other systems. Anna has initiated bringing transparency by proposing this move. We all, from the deep of our heart, thoughts and deeds, support Anna’s foresightedness, which one fine day will eventually bring transparency in our day to day life and make Bharat the Golden Bird of Yesteryears. Kudos to Anna and his Team…

    Down with cover-ups. Down with pople still following Britsh Raj policies.. like Dived and rule..

    This is not Britsh India.. This is new age Bhaarat..our Hindustaan.. Let us change..remove the masks of British era.

    Change to Bhaarat.. Mera Bhaarat.. Hamaara Bhaarat.. Jai Bharat!!! Jai Ho.

    ‘United We stand..United We Win’ and everyone will see WE ARE ONE and unity is going to unfold Pure, Flowering, Peaceful, Strong and Prosperous Bhaarat Maata..Our ‘Loving Motherland’ for us..

    We The Bhaartiyas..Hum HINDUSTAANI..

    [Reply]

    harish Reply:

    these guys are typical specimen of intellectual dishonesty and they are unnerved when others dont follow their convoluted thoughts.
    the issue right now is corruption and the same Anna saheb is taking up tot he exclusion of other issues.
    if somebody is seen to have done rural empowerment without corruption, he has been singled out. if vinod sharma is wont to check the political colour of the person before singling or in this case doubling him out, he cant expect a person of ANNA SAHEB’s rectitude to folow suit

    [Reply]

    Jami Reply:

    Excellent analysis. The trouble is that we cannot handle truth and the truth is that Modi was directly responsible for killing of all innocents. It was his pogram that directly targeted minorities after a minor incident at godhra. He is responsible for continuing to inflame exremists hindoos against minorities whether it is gujrat assam or kashmir or kerela.
    keep up the good work vinodji and it is because of journos like you this country has not become a banana country. Let barking dogs bark because they seldom bite

    [Reply]

    G Vishwanathan Reply:

    It is laughable if it is not so tragic. Minor incident at Godhra!!!. People ike you are already syaing it is an accident. We will agree that the media is fair & unbiased if they look a everyone in the same way One law for the Gandhi family.(Rajiv, Sonia, etcc. ) & one rule for the rest. If what Modi did was wrong, then what Rajiv did was equally wrong after Indira’s death.

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Jami,

    you are right.

    Godhra, where 79 Ram bhakts were burned alive was a minor incident.
    In fact it was so minor, that according to Banerji commission, it almost didn’t happen.
    The only reason why it happened was because the Ram bhakts were, all of them, suicidal and set themselves on fire in a mass frenzy and killed themselves.

    In fact, even the 1984 anti-Sikh pogrom never happened, if we are to believe Vinod Sharma and other “seculars”. Here too the Sikhs set upon themselves in a minor incident and killed 4000 of themselves.

    Like you, Jami, I too commend Vinod Sharma for saving our country from becoming a kela-desh (banana republic for the ignorant).

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    :) @ Shenoy…. kela desh !! ~~~ masterpiece !

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Unke hain Lambe kesh
    Pehna hai vairagya ka vesh
    dil me basaa ke paap ka shesh
    wo karte hain pesh
    duniya ke saamne
    Bharat ko kela desh

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Shenoy saab ka to jawab nahin

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Shenoy Sahab,
    Kela desh, man khush kar ditta. Wah janab wah.

    Mohan Ramchandani Reply:

    Very nice Shenoy Saab. keep it up.

    jimmy Reply:

    by the way shenoy whom are u describing here..

    i treid to solve the riddle but couldnt

    tajender Reply:

    shenoy compartment was ignited by agents of parivar to provide reason for riot,which was preplanned.actually since 1969 rss was perpetuating brutal riot every year to take control of gujrat.2002 riots got more publicity because of advance electronic media.who locked the doors of compartment.train was almost under full control of vhp goons.compartment was reserve all of them are alive.why bogey was sold so quickly.

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Come on Mr. Jami, you call burning of 70 odd human beings a minor incident.. Is it all this much conscience you have blessed with?
    BNA

    tajender Reply:

    can u furnish me the list of name of those who died.

    zhoot kee tahni kabhi phalti nahin

    nav kagaz kee kabhi chati nahin.

    vhp goons ignited the bogey.

    as per fir pumps to extinguish the fire wer brought by muslims.

    james Reply:

    i was watching tv MUTE and I saw a very stern looking sharma….just days ago he was smiling away like a doting father when congress corruption was being talked about…

    so I turnd the volume on

    sharma was saying sternly that nitish was quiet but modi wasnt…regarding anna’s praise

    wait a minute mr. awesome genius….does nitish get vilified by media for a decade like modi…?

    does modi have a right to react and defend??mr genius that is the difference between whathappened to modi yesterday when anna spoke…

    even with anna who honestly spoke his mind..like a kid would know and say sachin is agreat batsman…the media showd its evil…they brought up 2002…

    so here are the genius rules…they will attack modi even when someone praises him honestly…even when the country knows modi is honest unlike quatrochi rajiv

    this from the same tribe who hides godhra train,kashmir and sikhs 84 and worship corrupt dynasty

    I almost fell off the floor in laughter at sharma’s stern face …

    and I am sure this man has fans on this board like pankaj who will not be affected by such despicability and abuse of patriot modi who tirelessly works for poor…..but will tell bloggers to not react or else it is abuse as judge by this evil sharma bootlicker

    u cannot be a congress stooge and oppose corruption u cannot be against modi and be against corruption…so sharma keep making us laugh with that ridiculous stern expression against congress enemies like the supreme court for exposing corruption
    and the loving smiles for congress achivement of swissbanks..

    and there r evil fans like pankaj who worship u..

    and will call this abuse…wow what a country

    [Reply]

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Yesterday I read a commentary by an expert that if the Jan Lok Pal Bill becomes a reality , it will have far reaching consequences not just for the political- bureaucratic class but also the corporate sector where many companies , in some sectors like real estate and telecom etc who have been direct beneficiaries of this corruption may even implode. Top politicians are hidden partners in some such companies.
    So now we should realize how daunting the task is going to be and to what extent the vested interests shall resist. About the media , Mr Vinod has already said ” The media is either a beneficiary or an adjunct of such vested interests.” Kapil Sibbal and Pranab Mukerjea have given an indication of what is on the mind of the Congress Party. About the doormat PM the less said the better. Sometimes I wonder should we even think of him as someone having a role to play.
    BJP is already on record that it shall support the Bill. So we may have some hope from it . The SP , NCP and the RJD representatives have opposed Anna . Such statements coming from such scamsters is no surprise. It is now a question of their political survival . Laloo and Mulayam carefully chose Raghuvansh Prasad and Mohan Singh to be their mouthpieces .
    So let us not fall into the trap and there shall be more than one, to get the movement derailed.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Praveen Saxenaji,

    have you observed, the congress party is so scared, it has loaded the committee with all lawyers and all of them congressmen? When it comes to making the law against corruption, the congress party doesn’t trust even a single alliance MP!

    It is now opposed to videographing the proceedings because there is, the certainty that the issue of foreign bank accounts and illegal hoarding in those accounts will be raised by the civil society reps, which will most certainly expose the queen mother and the clown prince, the new Amul Baby of the party. I believe in the US, all congressional hearings are invariably televised. When the parliament proceedings themselves are telecast daily, why oppose the videographing of the proceedings of this minor committee?

    awakend Reply:

    Mr. shenoy,
    I don’t know what your age is but your writing suggests you are still left with verve of twenties in you. I have read all comments (either direct or reply to another comment) and I will share my views with you on all. You are right in saying that the corruption is rampant amongst the congressman. There is no denying this fact. But video-recording of the proceeding has genuine flaw in it. An edited broadcast would not satisfy the critics and un-edited may not be interest of the society at large. I will get back to why and how part of it but for now I want to draw your attention to the fact that debates in parliament (known by other name in other country) is quite different from that of the deliberations in the standing committee or expert committee in charge. See this private part of the deliberation has always been an integral element of negotiations and believe me it will be till the time this world lasts and this phenomenon is not specific to any society or belief system. Just for the sake of example I would draw your attention to the fact that in trying to get the “health bill” passed by the congressman by ensuring bipartisan support, Mr. Obama had to made concessions to the Republican; in quite contrast to the plank with which he was voted in power. Now let’s turn to why and how of the possible disservice caused by un-edited broadcast of the proceedings. Members attending the meeting are also human being and therefore can’t be subjected to the rigours of writing examination paper for the period of attending the meeting. In a meeting there are many off the cuff remarks not meant to influence of the outcome of the meeting but to relax…… Yes, sometimes off the cuff remarks of intellectual divergence is a great elixir and allows you to unwind the exhaustion. What happen if the remarksares about the role of CII, FICCI, ASSOCHAM. If it proves to be favourable to them they make use of the every loophole that is talked about by the members. If it proves unfavourable to them, they get scared and investment freezes. What happens then, an economic imbalance. So my request is: look into the issue bit dispassionately and you may get the moderate inference out of your own study. I think this screed addresses your concern. Thanks.

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    It should make no difference to most people either way. But, having Kapil Sibal on the committee makes the whole thing different. He is wily, he is crooked and he is also an arrogant ji-huzoor-e-wala. He has the media eating out of his hand and he is quite likely to present things quite differently from what they actually would be. From that point of view, I would say videograph the whole thing or have Kapil Sibal sit out.

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    I am sixty seven and I eat only Amul cheese
    I am no baby but my cheeks are baby like, please.

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Shenoy Saab

    Even the apologists of the Congress Party , in their hearts would be knowing that when the issue is ill-gotten wealth, none can surpass the Congress Party and the people who run it. They would also be knowing that it will do its best to retain the status -quo. The trick which they will use the most is the old ” secular vs communal ” card . And they have already started it , to confuse and obfuscate and divide the people behind this movement. Other dirty tricks shall also be attempted. Remember Kapil Sibal’s poser , how is the Lokpal going to benefit the hungry child ?
    The essence is not to fall in that trap. So howsoever Mr Vinod may try to revive Gujarat , Modi , 2002 , Amit Shah Amit Shah , let us not fall for that bait . “Arjun ki Nigaah sirf Machli ki aankh par honi chahiye.”

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Praveen Saxenaji,

    “Arjun ki Nigaah sirf Machli ki aankh par honi chahiye.”

    Lekin congressi log aur media walon ki nazar sirf Soniaji-mataji ki taraf hai aur unka ek, ek baan bhi phoolon se banaa hua hai.

    Wey unki ek “kripa kataksh” ke liye taras te hain.

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    ~~~ :D :D ~~~ CORRUPTION KE ASLI MUKHOTA ~~~ :D :D ~~~

    Raghuvansh Prasad and Mohan Singh are the frontmen of two of the most corrupt men in Indian politics– Lalu and Mulayam. Both must be shiverning in their Latha kachchas if the Lok Pal starts probing their crimes. Since those guys cannot attack Hazare directly, they are using the mukhotas !! :D :D

    Similarly a scared Congress saw an avalanche build up. It is going to use every trick in the book like RSS, Narendra Modi, Godmen etc etc to defame the movement. Unfortunately for it– foot in the mouth Sibal leaked its intentions to the public.

    Hai ram !! Hai Allah… !! ab kaise shakal chupayogi Congress???

    it will use trick no 2… its loyal chamchas in the press and media in an attempt to defame Anna and Ramdev.

    ~~~ :D :D ~~ I SINCERLEY HOPE OUR DEAR OLD CHAP– VINOD SHARMA, DOES NOT ACCIDENTLY BECOME A HAND TOOL IN THE HANDS OF LARGER CORRUPT FORCES LIKE SATISH SHARMA AND AMAR SINGH TO DEFAME THIS FLOWER OF HONESTY WHICH ANNA HAZARE REPRESENTS ~~~ :D :D ~~~

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Vijay Kumar, your fears are not unfounded. The congress party has worked overtime these last three days and look what is being cooked for Anna Hazare to eat:

    “Gandhians, activists want Anna Hazare to rethink Modi praise”-healine in today’s Indian Express. It says:

    Veteran Gandhians and activists have written to Anna Hazare, saying claims of rural development made by Gujarat under Chief Minister Narendra Modi were false and the noted anti-corruption crusader needs to correct his statement about the BJP leader.

    “We would like to add here that your statement regarding development in rural area requires a thorough correction.”

    Put in plain Hindi, it means, “aap bakwas kar rahe hain”.

    The development crazy Narendra Modi has done great harm to the rural area,” veteran Gandhian Chunibhai Vaidya and other activists, including Prakash Shah, Ilabahen Pathak and Indukumar Jani, said in a letter to Hazare.

    “He (Modi) is responsible for the desertion of the villages by more than 10 per cent of the population which includes mainly youth; this we say from the statistics of the Census recently concluded,” Vaidya added.

    Meanwhile, noted danseuse Mallika Sarabhai wrote an email to Hazare, expressing shock at the veteran social activist’s endorsement of Modi on the rural development front.

    “There has been little or no rural development in this state. In fact, grazing and irrigated farmlands have been stealthily taken by the government and sold off at ridiculous prices to a small club of industrialists,” she said.

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Mallika Sarabhai says, “The state is in terrible debt because of his (Modi) largesse to industry, while 21 lakh farmers wait for compensation. Your endorsement is appalling and we will be forced to distance ourselves from the Lokpal movement unless it is irrevocably retracted,” she said.

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Mr. James
    (Hadley Chase or Bond?) My name is Bond- James Bond fame.
    You are awesome, labeling me as evil, sharma fan. Either you have joined this blog late or do not come to it regularly, otherwise, you would have known my views on congress, Vinod, Narendra and so many people/situations.
    People like you, who are constantly straining to turn me into a Vinod fan, will not succeed, either by design or by mistake.

    [Reply]

  • harish

    he cant make up his mind on what to say

    [Reply]

  • http://htblogs reality bites

    could not get myself to read beyond the first few lines. sick yellow putrid journo!! his first few catch words are, “government bend”, “potency of a slogan that could drive voters” and to top it all..,” Regardless of his relatively better record of governance”, so he disregards the fact that hundreds and millions will come out of poverty and live better lives, wow! Such journalists with the RAJ mindset should be part of Hazare’s campaign to be eradicated first! Sloganeering and vote bank politics, they have just been bred on this diet, they cannot look beyond that

    [Reply]

  • Satish Haldankar

    Dear Vinodji

    A very good analysis. However, there are certain things need to be pointed out.

    Having gained the moral superiority over the establishment and gained a momentum to put in place an effective watchdog within the framework of the constitution, some of the the events since Saturday have put a dampener. It is unfortunate that Anna Hazare is getting himself into needless controversies. His attempts to dictate terms (possibly at the behest of his advisers, who seem to have tasted blood and wish to go for the kill) – videograph the proceedings, telling Kapil Sibal to quit, retractions and clarifications after unwarranted statements. The daily confrontations with the elected government – parliament and by extension the executive – is going to make the process to achieve the goal so much more difficult. One fine day the establishment might just tell them “Enough is enough. Leave it us to get the job done and in any case it is our responsibility to do so. You can carry on with your protests”.

    The setting up of the institution of the Lok Pal (whatever the form and whatever the powers and authority vested in it) will only marginally help in reducing corruption.

    I wish Anna Hazare had pressed the establishment to clean ups its acts of commission and omissions, instead of demanding enactment of the Lok Pal Bill (the civil society’s draft will not stand scrutiny by the Supreme Court). He should have demanded that

    1) the political parties clean up their own act. No more candidates with suspect and undesirable credentials. Currently, we are faced with Hobson’s choice in most of the constituencies – one candidate worse than the other.

    2) state funding of electoral expenses.

    3) total revamp and speeding up of the Criminal-Justice system, which has almost collapsed

    4) police reforms, so that political and other nefarious influences do not come into play in their working.

    [Reply]

  • rekha

    Wish you could be APOLITICAL in your views too !!! Not a Modi fan but would just like to point out that a. the political system that you want to preserve could do NOTHING to Modi in all these yrs. Surely that calls for a CHANGE in the system. And
    b. Praising one aspect of Modi does not necessarily mean endorsing EVERYTHING he has done.

    You appeared as such a BIASED, nitpicking agent of some party yesterday on tv.

    [Reply]

  • shikha

    I am quite amused to see how the smear campaign against Anna Hazare has begun. It almost makes me feel that we are waiting hawk eyed ..hoping that there is some division and Anna Hazare’s team falls apart and the govt (of our favorite political party) wins. But wait.. I do not want to blackmail people into supporting Anna. We shouldn’t be so closed minded to say.. “If you do not support Anna, you’re anti Indian”.. Or if you support Modi you are anti muslim. People are entitled to have serious differences . If the differences are a principled one.. fine. If the differences are based upon your political leanings, it is wrong. Nation is above petty politics.

    [Reply]

  • amit

    in all tv debates vinod sharma espcially on times now is called as a congress representative and BJP/arnab even makes it clear who he is representing..so, no one get surprised whn mr. sharma indulges into modi/bjp bashing and at the same time claim every time dat he is speaking as an independent journalist..dat sounds so funny..he sud atlest take sme lessons from swapan das gupta who nver evn tries to hide the fact that he supports BJP but at d same time he is far more obejective in his analysis..v hav seen d loonism of mr. sharam while supporting corruts like PJ thomas n now he is takeng abt fighting corrution..wel, indian hav short memory bt not short enugh 2 know antics of sharma/sanghvi n whose beshest dey write..he sud also disclose dat he is being appointed by his masters as memebr of minority commision if he dont want to disclose payment per article/debate

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    @ VInod Sharma,

    Sir, the COngress today partners the Muslim league in Kerala and even Andhra. DO you see the league– which clearly has an Islamic agenda– as a torchbearer of Congress tyled secularism??

    Just want an honest answer…

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar
    The subject of this blog is ANNA and his anti-corruption crusade. We can discuss IUML and its tieup with the Congress separately. Anyway, your argument equates Anna with the Congress.

    [Reply]

    vaibhav Reply:

    Mr Sharma,
    This was a pointed question and you gave him a lesson in obfuscation. Congress is also hobnobbing with Islamist elements in Assam elections may be add that too whenever you get a chance

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Vaibhav and Vinod Sharma

    We all know that the Congress right from the time of Indira Gandhi, who approached the Shai Imam for votes, has double standards of secularism.

    When it denies marital rights to Muslim women… its chamchas say… “wah wah… this is Congress secularism ! :D

    When it ties up with religious parties with fundmantalist agendas… its yes men say… “Wah wah Secularism ji secularism !! ” :D :D

    And when it is caught on the wrong foot… as in 2G and Anna Hazare, it will shout out Modi… Modi… modi… rape rape… !! :D

    When the clown prince says VS is old … its chamchas say wah… sahab, wah… what an observation. And when the CM of Kerala points out that the Yuvraj is mentally an Amul baby,,, they start crying that the youth icon, and the youth of India has been insulted !!:D :D

    Well the Yuvraj maybe a youthful at forty two to Congress toadies and maybe by saying that the youth of Indi has been insulted they mean that it is back to “India is Indira days~”

    But to many an unmarried man of forty two claiming to be the “youth of India’ and dismissing the LeT as inconsequential, is more than a clown or an Amul baby.

    He is an intellectually challenged ant who can be a danger to India….

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Vijay
    Good one .You have brought out the hypocricy of the Congress quite succinctly.

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Praveen

    Thanks !

  • Gajendra P. Singh

    Mr. Vinod Sharma,

    You are either cynic or part of corrupt and unholy nexus of corrupt politicians and corrupt journalists.

    You are the best to answer which side are you in.

    May God give you the strength to introspect and give you the courage to throw out the weight of corruption from your soul.

    Sincerely,
    Gajendra

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    @ Vinod Sharma

    Yes the blog is about Anna. And let us all congratulate him and Ramdev for forcing the government to take action on LokPal. We need to thatnk these real candle bearers at India gate, who unlike the fake candle holders at Wagah, are the heroes of new India.

    I got IUML into the picture to make you and COngressis realise that the people who are linked to IUML ( a name similar to Jinnah’s party) can never be secular. They are just communal … COmmunal and COMMUNAL with a a capital C :D

    Jinke ghar sheeshe ke hai…
    woh kyon public ke saamne

    Kapde badal rahe hai ??? :D

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Jinhone pehne ho kaale chashme
    aur rehten ho andhere kamre me
    Wo bhala kya dekhenge
    kaali billi secularism ke karishme?

    [Reply]

  • B.V.SHENOY

    @BV shenoy
    Two wrongs don’t make a right. Modi hasn’t even apologised for the 2002 bloodshed. What’s more, he let his cohorts vilify Gandhi to win elections.”

    Vinodji,

    Has the congress party “apologised” to the Sikh community? Has SOnia Gandhi ever admitted that her husband was wrong in taking revenge on the Sikhs for the assassination of his mother by ordering a pogromagainst them? Has she apolofised to the nation?

    As for vilifying the Mahatma, most congressmen, including Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi have readily exonerated Joseph Lelyweld who has called Gandhiji a kinky bi-sexual and a racist .

    In your own paper, Karan Thapar wrote that Gandhiji praised and supported Hitler, that he had no objection to the extermination programme he carried out against the Jews. But I don’t know whether HT has asked him to apologise to the nation, nor has HT removed him like it did to Vir Sanghvi. Then, why single out Modi’s response to people who “vilify” Gandhiji?

    [Reply]

  • (Dr.) B.N.Anand

    @Vinod Sharma ji

    Sir, whatever the credentials of Anna Hazare may be, can you throw some light as to why the government came to its knees in just four days on an issue which it had been postponing for 42 years.? I have never seen the full govt. crumbling on any issue under people pressure in just four days? Was it the nightmare of Tahir square in Eqypt which haunted the UPA govt. and panicked to yield to every demand of Anne Hazare or was it the fear of the adverse reaction on the outcome of five state elections in the country?
    There were all symptoms that the people were highly charged. The media just jumped in to the bandwagon just to promote their business. I understand the govt. called a meeting of the anchors of all the leading tv channels and briefed it some thing. Only then accusations and counter accusation started appearing..
    Well I really feel pity for Kapil Sibal who immediately back tracked from his statement as soon as Hazare challenged him to resign from the committe if he is so skeptic about the outcome of the committee formed for drafting the Lokpal bill.

    Sharma saheb, people are so frustrated that they were simply looking for apolitical leader to lead and to vent off their frustrations in the form of associating with Anne Hazare.. People have tasted blood and please be watchful. now for the future. Do not bring in any politician. The RJD and SP leaders you mentioned have been the ministers and they were and are witness to all the corrupt practices.The gathering at Jantar Mantar just scared away any politician who dared to visit the site of fasting.

    The killing fields in Gujarat are no different from the killing fields of Delhi.. People know this and your continuous efforts at only selectively Modi bashing is simply going to boomerang on you. Mr. Hazare honestly praised Modi and Nitish Kumar for their work at rural level but still that was not acceptable to you.
    Please be rather more pragmatic.
    Regards
    BNA

    [Reply]

    HPN Reply:

    The best of all posts on this topic so far, which aptly describes the feelings of the people at large. Thank you, Mr Anand. And for Mr Vinod Sharma, sir, please be with the people, for a change, rather than bringing in communalism into every topic. The “de facto ruling class” has timely sensed the mood in the country. It was a matter of a few more days before the country would have gone into turmoil and since people don’t see elections soon enough to throw them out through ballot, they would certainly have forced them to shun political power. They have only bought some time. Howsoever hard they may try their tricks, they will not succeed. The writing is on the wall.

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Thanks, Mr. HPN
    BNA

    [Reply]

  • ishwar

    Why can’t Anna Hazare contest an election and then change the laws?

    I thought this is how our country was supposed to be run. I am no fan of Gandhi and I don’t like people blackmailing the govt. of the day using the tool of “hunger-strike”. If you think you have integrity and are fighting for a worthy cause – prove it – by winning an election.

    Else, why do we have democracy?

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Ishwar

    Sir, it is not as simple as you have put it. Even our PM does not want to fight elections, he was defeated in the only Lok Sabha election he fought. Mr. Hazare has rightly said that majority of the people in the country are not aware of the strength and power of their votes. The bulk of the voters in colonies or slums simply barter it for 100rupee note of for a bottle of whiskey. No one ever came to our university campus for canvassing but in the adjoining colonies, there is always a festival like atmosphere during elections. I hope you are aware how brazenly in Tamil Nadu, people are being showered with TV sets, grinders, laptops and cable connections in exchange for their votes. No govt. at any time took any step towards electoral reforms. I think this govt. saw the writings on the wall and succumbed to all the demands in just four days. What the political system could not achieve in 42 years could be achieved in just four days.
    Yes, no one is against Parliamentary democracy but then the it has to be a system which should be reformed time and again according to need of the hour. Mr. Hazare has rightly and honestly accepted that he is sure to lose his security if he fights elections according to the present circumstances.
    BNA

    [Reply]

    ishwar Reply:

    Dear Dr. Ananad,

    Thanks for your response.

    I do appreciate the fact that it is not an easy task to win in election in our country where money and muscle power rules. Illiteracy and apathy towards politicians only makes the situation worse. However, if we have another Anna Hazare going on “fast-unto-death” for a different cause, how would the govt. of the day react. It is not setting a good precedence, in my opinion. Legislation is the job of the executive (parliament and its MPs) and it is best left to them.

    The cause Mr. Hazare is standing for is great, however; I am skeptical that his proposed solution is the right way. As per my limited understanding of the proposed bill, it might go the widely misused IPC 498-a way.

    (Disclaimer: I am a BJP supporter)

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    Dear Vinod, I posted this above-
    ————————
    Dear Vinod
    1. Godhra and Gujrat, terrible tragedies, but time to move on. If I remember correctly, 100 policemen died during the riots testifying to the widespread fury and of a situation totally out of control.
    2. Let the law take its course, and if Modi is guilty, punish him
    3. But sometimes healing comes with progress, with commerce, with the realisation that individuals and communities are interdependent and integrated. And people need to interact and empathise with each others pain.
    4. Yes, Anna Hazare treads a minefield if he leaves this middle of the road path and veers to any party. Looking at Kapil Sibal’s ghastly comments and the silence of ‘heir aparent’ Rahul, I am disappointed that the Congress party is going into this Lokpal bill with lack of enthusiasm.

    Journalists like you have a duty today to attack this devious go slow by the Congress to make sure that the Indians have a Lokpal WITH TEETH. Nothing less.
    Dr Mishra, Yorkshire
    ——————————-
    Your reply Sir was very brief and unsatisafctory-
    ——————————————

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Dr Mishra
    fight against corruption is non-negotiable sir. we’ll have to fight whoever comes in the way— this government or any future government.
    ——————————————-
    Sorry Vinod, I was looking for a strong reply particularly to allowing Modi some praise for his development work, and also condemning the ghastly Kapil Sibal, a committe member, for denigrating THE STRONGEST ANTI CORRUPTION BILL the country has ever known.
    Dont you think Kapil should resign?
    Your detailed answer pl
    DR MISHRA, YORKSHIRE, but heart in Jantar Mantar

    [Reply]

    Manohar Reply:

    I am rather amused that Modi and his supporters are always so desperate for showers for praise, encomiums and certificates of approval for him from any quarter. One wonders, why? Is there some deficit somewhere?

    After WIkiLeak’s cable saying he is incorruptible, Modi went to town that he got a certificate from Uncle Sam and now after this pat on the back by Anna Hazare (which he had to qualify it later), he again has gone to town. The less said about his die hard supporters painting the town red on receipts of certificates of being a good boy.

    No self-respecting and humble person would hanker after such compliments and make a make song and dance about them, if such compliments came one’s way. One would take the bouquets and brickbats in one’s stride and get on. To cite two names, Mahatma Gandhi and Sardar Patel. On the contrary, they surely must have been embarrassed by such adulation.

    In my humble opinion, the situation Modi find himself today is on account of his own doings.

    [Reply]

    jimmy Reply:

    modi did not ask eever for compliments just like sachin doesnt …peole compliment them

    all modi said was thanks to anna like a gracious person and warned him about vilification..

    which turned out to be true as can be seen by sharma’s blog..

    manohar do urself a favor get a brain transplant done…

    i dont want to keep pitying you…u do not even know u come acrosslike a idiot

    weak on logic and worse evn understanding basic common sense….

    [Reply]

    Manohar Reply:

    If you think I am idiot, weak on logic and not understanding basic common sense, so be it I cannot and do not wish to waste my time in trying to convince you otherwise, be happy. I gove a damn.

    However, do not be a bigger idiot in responding to my comments, as it seems it is beyond your intelligence as to what I am saying – I am talking about self-respecting and humble persons.

    jimmy Reply:

    MANOHAR

    u r answer is all words no logic or facts..

    idiot modi was only thanking and talkning about vilification…he was defendning himself against blooggers like these…but u will not consider any of this factual evidence because u r brain dead…

    u seriously need a brain transplant…

    ur opinions of self respecting humble are urs….just put them in your empty skull

    crores supprt modi….idiot….what about u who r u to judge him…people call u an idiot
    for disrespecting modi and u talk of respect..

    yeah u will be happy if rahul and sonia are praised by modi by their bribed media…
    and then u will call them humble..

    atleast modi does not need to buy false praise like dynasty..

    crores adore him and this is anna’s praise which is honest and free..

    no wonder u do not criticize this blogger when he disrespects modi and bashes him
    for congress gifts….

    maybe a donkey’s brain willl help u understand something

    good luck…pity u .at least .thank the donkey after u get his brain

    u talking about modi is raja barking about honesty..ur braying will be better…than ur opinions

    Mohan Ramchandani Reply:

    Manohar,

    This is what all poiticians do. They will always highlight their achievements.
    They are in politics and this is one way of garnering votes. All the politcians
    around the world do this. There is nothing wrong in this. You cant blame
    Modi for this. As for his being involved in riots , let the court decide. If he is
    found guilty – HANG HIM . And meanwhile if he has done something good
    for his state atleast admit it if you dont want to appreciate that.

    [Reply]

    Manohar Reply:

    This is what all politicians do.
    —————————————

    I would suggest that you do not make such sweeping generalisations and brush everybody under the carpet with the same brush..

    Having done so, can you be very specific and tell me when (dates and times) and in which context have the following ever blown their own trumpets.

    Atal Bihari Vajpayee, L K Advani, Sushma Swaraj and Nitish Kumar

    Rest of comment has been on the forums/blogs countless times already and has been debunked, hence I will not waste my time in debunking it again. If you think I have no argument to counter it, you are welcome to feel satisfied.

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Mohan,

    The fear of these pseudo seculars is that the Supreme Court, after getting the SIT report will let Modi out baa izzat. Already serious aspersions are being cast on the integrity of the SIT.

    Manohar Reply:

    Blah, blah, blah from Jimmy or whatever, who seems to have lost his cool. What else is new?

    An ice-cold nimbu-paani should go a long way in reducing your temperature.

    [Reply]

    jimmy Reply:

    jimmy as usuaul u show ur empty brain..

    just writing some characters is no use….nimbu pani…sharbat etc ..can they replace logic and facts…looks like u cant even read….forget logic…..u may need an eye transplant too
    or may be it is just that empty skull effect

    anna praises modi

    modi thanks him and warns of vilfication which turns out to be true immediately…

    brays will be better than ur inanity like nimbu pani..chaii coffee whatever

    media as usual screams for money because it gets hits and trps from modi ….and also
    impresses congress masters..did modi had any thing to do with media headlines..

    even donkey will say no…

    but manohar genius concludes….modi is not humble but proud and arrogant and modi admirers look to praise him…idiot…modi admirers have aright to react to evil media and so does modi…

    u can give it but not take it…even a kid knows rules rthe same in a game but not u..

    genius where is the lack of humility…..the only conclusion here is u have no ability to raed facts and logically make inferences…

    and u r a typical anti-national modi hater….who feels a stomach ache if people get fed and live better under modi…..u love congress looting india for 60 years and switzerland banks
    growing…

    even the donkeys will refuse to give u a brain….unka bhi standard hoga…

    jimmy Reply:

    manohar as usuaul u show ur empty brain..

    just writing some characters is no use….nimbu pani…sharbat etc ..can they replace logic and facts…looks like u cant even read….forget logic…..u may need an eye transplant too
    or may be it is just that empty skull effect

    anna praises modi

    modi thanks him and warns of vilfication which turns out to be true immediately

    Manohar Reply:

    Jimmy or whatever

    You wrote
    “jimmy as usuaul u show ur empty brain.. ” then blah blah blah

    Kyaa baat hai! See one cannot hide the truth for very longm however hard one may try. I must compliment you for being sooooooo .. honest with yourself for once at least. Wish your fellow travellers were as honest as you.

  • Vinay

    Any revolution would usually be met with high expectation from optimists and speculations from others. With all our concerns whether India becomes corruption free just after this bill is passed, we still need to welcome the first step towards it. I felt, the article lacked the enthusiasm towards this step, instead totally focused on the faults in the movement. Yes, we all know there are faults in it. It raised out of blue, without planning and organising. There is bound to be. Yes, we know we are expecting too much from this man. But still there is a sense of breathing fresh air. Article has not attempted to capture the mood of common man. Anna Hazare’s comment was only towards development in Gujarat/Bihar. He never justified the riots. But bringing in riots in an article which was supposed to be on a movement against corruption, the article has deviated from its main theme. Is the intention of the article is to promote the movement or …?

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    Manohar, good point. All I can say is-
    But sometimes healing comes with progress, with commerce, with the realisation that individuals and communities are interdependent and integrated. And people need to interact and empathise with each others pain.

    In a nation of some mega corrupt leaders ( we are talking of billions of dollars stashed away abroad) it copmes as a breath of fresh air to have some honest incorruptibles like Anna Hazare, Modi (flinch), and ? Nitish Kumar (dont know much), Advani …..and who else?

    I am stuck, Manohar, pl help expand this list. Anyone else, pl help also

    [Reply]

    Manohar Reply:

    I am not sure whether you are a medical practitioner or hold a doctorate in some other field, but I am surprised at your views in the first paragraph.

    Plastic surgery (progress with commerce) is no elixir, when internal haemorrhage has been left unattended, in other words, progress and development without justice is just not on in civilised societies.

    Incorruptible! Only looking at corruption vis-a-vis rupees and paises is taking a very narrow view of the probity in public life. What about moral and political dishonesty? So what list are you talking about?

    Anna Hazare is a simple honest and selfless man and I feel has been used by the NGOs and others to push their agenda, which was going nowhere.

    [Reply]

  • Kushagra Bhatnagar

    Sharmaji, why do you have to be skeptical of anything and everything remotely related to BJP? Yes, Anna Hazare praised Modi, but he himself clarified that he is against communalism and only praised his development work. What can be more reasonable than that?

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    even i have wondered many a times , how come he doesnt write anything regarding the scams of Congress , 84 riots or the immature comments made by Rahul Gandhi

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    ~~ :) ~~~ :) ~~~ :) WHY ANNA HAZARE SHOULD GO ON FAST AGAIN !! :) ~~~ :) ~~~ :) ~~ :)

    Anna Hazare’s fast has changed things dramatically in India. It stirred the people, scared the Government and became the avalanche… !!

    And now everyone wants to claim his part played for the positive result, leading to people saying “anna Hamare ! ”

    So let us request Annaji to go on fast again, like Gandhiji, and this time pick up a number of burning issues which denigrte and damage our democracy. He should call for effective legislation against

    1) DYNASTIC SUCCESSION : The most dangerous thing in our democracy which makes the politicos think that India is thier jagir. Nehru got in Indira who gave us Sanjay and then Rajiv and now the COngress says that in true democratic style the people of India can choose between Rahul and Priyanka or Sonia !! :D :D Wah Wah !! Kya democracy hai…

    Other clans like karunanidhi, Pawar, Lalu, Mulayam etc etc pass on the baton to their family members. So much so Shiela Dixit got in Sandeep and Pranab Da says that since I am going… my son should be an MP !! :D :D :D Wah … Wah… Ha ha ha !! Kya democracy hai.

    Annaji you should fast against this. Get in a law that family members should not be allowed to succeed a politico. Otherwise rajneeti becomes a family business. This causes standards to fall and makes partymembers sycophantic. !! : (

    Vinod Sharma ji, I humbly request you to forward this proposal to Annaji.

    Vinodji before opposing this, kindly remember that in case the previous generation of journalists in HT had mandated that only their children could succeed them… where would you have been !! ??????????????????

    Please remember that in case the previous generation

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    Dear Manohar,

    Sorry, but life in general, and Gujrat-Modi-Godhra in particular, does not lend itself to black and white judgements. Here in UK, the former IRA terrorist Martin McGuinness sits in govt, much to the displeasure of all. David Cameron slams Pak last year so bad that the latter cancel a proposed trip by their Prez- today, alarmed by the rise of anti UK terror emanating from Pak again, Cam goes to Pak and eats dirt, offering 600 million £ for aid.

    Went down very well here in recession hit UK !!! But that’s life, one has to move on. Let Modi be investigated and punished in due course, but let us not forget the progress which surprisingly does more for communal harmony than any thing else. Let us face it Modi surprised everyone with his governance.

    I asked you to supply a list of leaders who were both incorruptible and excellent at governance. I stuttered after- Modi (flinch), Nitish, Chandrababu Naidu ??, ….
    Maybe you can add to the list- remeber in a country of a billion, we need at least 1000 such names.
    BW- since you asked, I am a consultant Physician in Yorkshire

    [Reply]

    ISI Agent & SHAN's KUTTAR Reply:

    Dr Mishra.

    Slabodan Milosovitch, and now Radovan Karadich were/are being tried in the world court in the Hague.

    Knowing how judiciary operates in India, would you recommend that Mr Modi be tried in the Hague??

    [Reply]

    Manohar Reply:

    Doctor Saheb

    You are apparently advocating a more forgiving attitude towards Narendra Modi by the Indian society at large, by citing the UK-IRA example as a precedent and on account of good work done on the development front.

    If the Indian society on the other side (practically the rest of the political class, NGOs, majority of the population) of the divide is not ready to forgive him, what can one do? One may accuse of them bipartisanship or whatever, that is not going to make them change their minds.

    Yes, Modi and his administration is being investigated, however given the track record of our system, hardly any politician has ever been convicted of any crimein the last 60 years or so. Modi would be no exception. Even If he gets a clean chit from the courts, I have my doubts if the society at large would be willing to forgive him. There are many reasons.

    My original poser. Why he and his supporters hanker after certificates on account of good development and progress under his leadership? Why indeed? Isn’t it his duty and responsibility to make sure of good development and progress or to use a golfing analogy – isn’t that par for the course? Hasn’t he taken an oath that he would do his best on all fronts and if has indeed made sure of good development and progress in Gujarat, then what is the big deal and why anyone should be surprised?

    Unless you indicate on what basis you have selected these three names, how can I add ot that list?

    [Reply]

    ishwar Reply:

    @ Manohar

    You have reached the epitome of human stupidity. Most sane people would do well to give up on you.

    [Reply]

    Manohar Reply:

    By making such statements, if it helps you to let off steam built up on account of seething anger and allows you to sleep well at night, I have no problem with it.

    I wish you a very good and peaceful night.

    Manohar Reply:

    Correction

    If the Indian society on the other side (practically the rest of the political class, NGOs, majority of the population) of the divide is not ready to forgive him, what can one do? One may accuse of them partisanship or whatever, that is not going to make them change their minds.

    [Reply]

    jimmy Reply:

    yeah they shuld make u judge manaohar…

    yeah and where were u when rajiv was killing sikhs..and why dont u talk about him..

    at least modi’s police tried and even killed 250 hindus…what about rajivs police…and that was not a communal riot it was congressgoons vs sikhs..there was no godhra train

    modi inherited communal riots since 1947 ..why dont u condemn the gandhi nehru duo for 1947 masacre of amillion

    but expecting u to know facts is harder than expecting a donkey to know facts..

    that is why get a donkey’s brain..at elast ur braying will make sense

    even the donkeys will not make u a judge and u rtalking like one…

    what apathetic evil clown…

    [Reply]

    Manohar Reply:

    More blah, blah, blah from Jimmy or whatever, who has lost his cool. What else is new?

    A double ice-cold nimbu-paani should go a long way in reducing your temperature.

    Manohar Reply:

    Jimmy or whatever

    “oh Mano the great ,so now the topic is i have lost my cool….genius..anyone who crticizes a patriot for false reasons is an antinational…

    even the donkeys will refuse to give u a brain….unka bhi standard hoga…”

    It gives me great pleasure to inform you that it is an absolute delight to see my comments are causing you so much discomfort and I expect that you will not disappoint me and would let go another round of blah, blah, blah in response to this comment.

    Manohar Reply:

    Jimmy wrote

    Quote

    April 15th, 2011 at 12:30 pm
    mano.. u r showing ur self..
    just days agao u were lecturing about modi’s humility and respect…
    now ur talking about delight at being exposed as an idiot who cannot even rebut with facts and logic which even school kid knows without being on the debating team…
    it is i and ur other opponents who have exposed u who renjoying idiot…
    how about another nimbu pani and steam reply…
    that is ur genius….
    and u have the nerve to talk about modi and lie for antinationals..
    u rnot even bray bray….and u call others blah blah…

    Unquote

    I was having an intelligent, sensible and peaceful debate (without a) use of foul language, b) casting aspersions c) name calling) with Dr. Mishra. Shenoy saheb intervened without any rancour and the response was without any malice. We agreed to disagree.

    Now, someone masquerading under an alias Jimmy chooses to jump into the discussion (he has all the rights to do so). Instead of adding anything worthwhile and sensible to the debate, he chooses to let go a volley of abuses, name calling and casting aspersions, in short polluting the atmosphere. Such ranting can only come from a person, who has lost his cool and has become incoherent and says whatever comes to top of his mind – sense and logic be damned. This Jimmy has so blinded by rage that he wrote – “jimmy as usuaul u show ur empty brain.. blah blah ” He tried to make make amends, like trying to lock the stable door after the horse has bolted.

    He got an appropriate response. BTW, I am not going to be provoked and respond in the same coin. That would amount to stooping down to his level.

    If a person expects an intelligent and sensible response, he should first and foremost learn to respect other people and their views, not abuse them, not call them names and suspect their motives.

    This may provoke Jimmy to launch another angry outburst. One, I give a damn and two, no amount of virulent attacks on me is going to make me change my opinions and views on any subject, unless I am convinced otherwise by intelligent debates and reasons. Pardon my expression, he is barking up the wrong tree.

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Manohar,

    you are living under the delusion that “Modi or his supporters are always so desperate for showers for praise, encomiums and certificates of approval for him from any quarter”

    Good work itself is a certificate, which Anna Hazare mentioned. Even though the US government has denied Modi visa for ten years, the US sent representatives to the vibrant Gujarat sammelan. The consul general of the US in Mumbai came calling on his own and met Modi. Modi didn’t invite him to come. According to Wikileaks, he sent a report to the secretary of state that Modi is doing wonderful work. Did we ask the consul general for a “good chit” or for “glowing encomia”?

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Manohar,

    as for your “opinion” that “the Indian society on the other side (practically the rest of the political class, NGOs, majority of the population) of the divide is not ready to forgive him”, again you are fooling yourself that the other side is bothered, except disgruntled NGO’s in the pay of foreign Christian funds. The majority of the population, meaning the Hindus have no issues with him and now even Muslims are being asked to “move on”.

    Manohar Reply:

    Shenoy Saheb

    You wrote
    1) you are living under the delusion that “Modi or ………….. Did we ask the consul general for a “good chit” or for “glowing encomia”?

    it is not about praise being showered. The point I was putting across was blowing one’s own trumpet. If that is acceptable to you, then I have nothing more to say.

    2) as for your “opinion” that “the Indian society ……. meaning the Hindus have no issues with him and now even Muslims are being asked to “move on”.

    I wish you all the best for your convictions.

    You are free to disagree with my opinion, it does not bother me nad you are entitled to have your views, just as I am entitled to have my opinion. I take bouquets and brickbats in my stride and get on with life. I have no time to lose my temper and indulge in outbursts directed at people, who may choose to abuse me and/or suspect my motives.

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Dr Mishra

    Cruel as it may sound, but you are correct on the effect of condoning terror by the state as in Bhinranwale’s case or in the case of Islamic terror — in both cases the culprit being mostly Pakistan which had learnt these leassons from the experience it gained in Afghanistan.

    I think if tywenty Muslims pick up a gun in India and kill a few of these Pakistani trained terrorists who want to disturb harmony in India, it really would end all discord between Hindus and Muslims. Unfortunately we have a sorry spectacle, where an Antulay and a Burney want to cast doubts on the origin of 26/11 while Rahul’s main advisor Digvinash Singh winks at it.

    This is the root cause of distrust between Hindus and Muslims. I know from my interaction with Muslims that they are largely against the Pakistani terrorists. Unfortuntely again, idiot like Arundhati ran to Batla house and publicity seeking mischief mongers like Amar and Mulayam as well as the Muslim League can only get their votes by creating barriers between Hindus and Muslims.

    Vinay Reply:

    As once Balwinder Sandhu mentioned (after all those Bhindranwale’s terror, attack on Golden Temple, Indira Gandhi’s assassination, Delhi Sikh massacre); it was mainly KPS Gill’s efforts (another strategic move from PVN) which brought Punjab, which was on the verge of separation back to India. Unfortunately, Kashmir has not found its Gill (or Indian government, deliberately do not look out for such a person). It has been compensated (?) with Ms. Roy.

    I feel media is trying to take people’s mind away from the Hazare. Vinod Sharma’s blog tries to hijack it towards Gujarat riots. Rajesh discredits there is any movement, because there were no riots.

    @Mishra I suppose, you noticed Usman’s reply.

    Dr Mishra, UK Reply:

    Vinay, thank you very much, just noticed it

    jimmy Reply:

    oh Mano the great ,so now the topic is i have lost my cool….genius..anyone who crticizes a patriot for false reasons is an antinational…so any indian shuld be angry at antinational agents like u …if empty skulled creatures like u were quiet…ppeole would understand and so wuld donkeys..just like they lost the cool with corruption and british and pakistani crime against india…

    anna blew modi’s trumpet u brainless anti-indian…not modi himself…and there is no rule that congress can lie about garibi hatao for 60 years and loot country…and modi cannot
    tell people the truth…

    r u a creature from the planet of the empty-skulled or just from enemies likepakistan

    do u get it moron what is blowing trumpet…just look at congress claims like rahul is like JP …and worse they r false….at least modi has beeen praised by none other than anna..dimwit…where is the blowiing of trumpet

    manohar as usuaul u show ur empty brain..

    just writing some characters is no use….nimbu pani…sharbat etc ..can they replace logic and facts…looks like u cant even read….forget logic…..u may need an eye transplant too
    or may be it is just that empty skull effect

    anna praises modi

    modi thanks him and warns of vilfication which turns out to be true immediately…

    brays will be better than ur inanity like nimbu pani..chaii coffee whatever

    media as usual screams for money because it gets hits and trps from modi ….and also
    impresses congress masters..did modi had any thing to do with media headlines..

    even donkey will say no…

    but manohar genius concludes….modi is not humble but proud and arrogant and modi admirers look to praise him…idiot…modi admirers have aright to react to evil media and so does modi…

    u can give it but not take it…even a kid knows rules rthe same in a game but not u..

    genius where is the lack of humility…..the only conclusion here is u have no ability to raed facts and logically make inferences…

    and u r a typical anti-national modi hater….who feels a stomach ache if people get fed and live better under modi…..u love congress looting india for 60 years and switzerland banks
    growing…

    even the donkeys will refuse to give u a brain….unka bhi standard hoga…

    jimmy Reply:

    jimmy Reply:

    mano.. u r showing ur self..

    just days agao u were lecturing about modi’s humility and respect…

    now ur talking about delight at being exposed as an idiot who cannot even rebut with facts and logic which even school kid knows without being on the debating team…

    it is i and ur other opponents who have exposed u who renjoying idiot…

    how about another nimbu pani and steam reply…
    that is ur genius….

    and u have the nerve to talk about modi and lie for antinationals..

    u rnot even bray bray….and u call others blah blah…

  • http://incorrectpolitically.wordpress.com/ Akhilesh

    Dear Vinod Ji,
    I quote to you the great Vinod Sharma, Political Editor of HT : “….respectable men like the SP’s Mohan Singh and the RJD’s Raghuvansh Prasad”

    Now, if you look from a neutral viewpoint and this line does not make you laugh or cry or both then what can I say to you?

    Raghuvansh Prasad – the greatest ally of the serially corrupt Laloo Prasad is a “respectable man” in fight against corruption????

    Your pathological hatred for Modi may as it be, at least have some mercy on yourself and not let yourself be open to caricature by presenting some arguments.

    Much Thanks,
    Akhilesh

    [Reply]

    ram Reply:

    this funny character called vinod sharma is a joke,

    i don,t know about others, but i never read his article or HT, i come here for readers responses and each one is 100 times better than this joker.

    [Reply]

  • B.V.SHENOY

    Vijay Kumar, Saxenaji, Dr.Anand and Dr. Mishra,

    in one of his ‘rare’ repostes here, Vinodji said this blog is about Anna Hazare. Yet, he, as if it is a second nature to him, took pot shots at Narendra Modi.

    “Regardless of his relatively better record of governance, the Gujarat CM evokes extreme reactions that aren’t in the interest of a united fight against corruption sans caste, language, region or religion.”

    Reading some of the other comments too on Modi, I do sense some kind of despondency, a sense of hopelessness and resignation that despite having done everything humanly possible and even superhumanly impossible, still Narendra Modi manages to get certificates from people like Anna Hazare and Maulvi Vastanvi.

    There is a sense of desperation among these anti-Modi gangs, which erupts violently at most unintelligently inappropriate occasions like the present movement against corruption.

    One most important reason for this we-have-lost-eveything kind of dejavu is because the SC appointed SIT is said to have given Modi something akin to benefit of doubt, which also is akin to a clean chit. It goes without saying that the entire pseudo secular bandwidth had invested heavily in the outcome of the SIT report.

    I therefore feel we should treat remarks from Vinod Sharma kindly and not take umbrage at them.

    [Reply]

  • Praveen Saxena

    Shenoy Saab
    You are aboslutely right. There is a pattern behind this sustained campaign. This is the way to frighten a segment of the voters and to herd them into their own camps . But for the present let us concentrate on not allowing the momentum for the Jan Lokpal Bill to get dissipated. The congress its agents and allies will try to lay a lot of such booby traps to entrap and derail the whole process.

    [Reply]

  • http://rediffmail.com ram

    Activist Anna Hazare has issued a formal appeal to the lakhs of people who supported his campaign last week, to continue to be united in the fight against corruption, to keep the issue alive and not let it fall prey to forces that he says are trying to break it.

    these foreces r none other than Mr. VINOD SHARMA and gang (alibaba and ……………………..)

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    To all those who indulge in obfuscation to divert attention from loot by politicians I will sing

    Maati Kahe Kumhar Se, Tu Kya Rundhe Mohe
    Ek Din Aisa Ayega Main Rundhungi Tohe…

    Aaye Hai So Jayenge Raaja Rank Fakir
    Ek Sinhaasan Chadh Chale Ek Bandhe Janjir

    Durbal Ko Naa Satayiye Jaaki Maati Hoye
    Bina Jeev K Shwas So Loha Basam Ho Jaye

    Please dont take the janata for granted !!

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    A great piece of poetry with profound meaning.

    [Reply]

  • http://CongressManifesto=VinodSharma Gourav

    Mr.Sharma, the uniqueness about Anna movement was the evident distrust in politicians shown by the country. Earlier ploiticians would cajolwe the protesters with fake utternaces now people know the game. you can find faults but even Mahatma and JP could not get the true blue middle class support them in such a way . Anna galvanized them against corruption and has shown us that there is a chance for democracy for the people in India…. India against corruption has around 10,000 members on facebook, all educated and getting news from different sources. We form a formidable adversary to the corrupt practices and we represent the youth of India.

    There was a time when journalists thought their duty was to bring to light the faults with the government so that govt. corrects its mistakes. But HT is different and Vinod Sharma is unique. I come time to time on his blogs to read the response of the readers and honestly enjoy them .

    He thinks that 70 hindus in the train and 700 hundred hindus in the riots that followed committed suicide and were not killed since yhe can not say that Modi killed those hindus too as this might cause minority vote bank split. and for him sikhs and Muslims dying in other riots were non minorities.
    Has he blogged about the north east situation I am sure he must have written blogs about Kashmir. Congress uses votebank policies to win elections and journos like you play your part in formulating and giving shape to the votebank policies. By the way, I heard there were riots in Bombay too in 1990’s. Do you know who the CM of the state was???? Would anyone let the readers know???

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    @Manohar and others- regarding Modi and Godhra- context is everything –

    By 2002- Islamist / Pak inspired attacks on India and specifically hindus happened almost on a yearly basis- they were ghastly, murderous and indiscriminate-
    Kargil 1999,
    Kandahar hijack 2000,
    Parliament 2001,
    Akshardham temple,
    Mumbai stock exchange,
    Diwali blasts in Jaipur and Sarojini Nagar
    Mumbai train blasts,
    and later- Maraad, Hand cutting incident in Kerala, Deganga, Jaipur 2008, Mumbai- Kasab 2008 etc etc, even- heavens forbid- an international science convention in Bangalore when a professor was shot on stage. I have not mentioned the systematic ethnic cleansing of hindus and sikhs from Kashmir from 1989 .

    So when Godhra happened, there was a reactionary orgy of evil violence. The very fact that of the 1200 dead there were 100 policemen, testifies to a public fury out of control. A bit like Americans after 911- Afghanistan bombing was brutal, the invasion of Iraq was, to A NEUTRAL, AN ACT OF BLOODY MINDEDNESS.

    Now judge Modi on those 48 hours. My gut feeling is that he held back the police and army and is guilty, but we need to wait for an SIT investigation to be completed.
    ——————
    Sorry, what I have said is very provocative. The facts stated above also explain the rise of saffron terror from 2006 onwards which caught us napping.

    [Reply]

    Dr Mishra, UK Reply:

    LET THE CRITICISM BEGIN

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Dr. Mishra;
    In these four words, you have proved your credentials. Beautiful words but so out of place where secular bigots can chant only rape rape, modi modi.

    [Reply]

    Mahesh Reply:

    Dr. Mishra,
    I have a basic question for you .
    What does does the term “terror” mean in your undertsanding ?
    Does the act against Sikhs in 1984 qualify as terror ? Does the act by Shiv-Sena in Mumbai and subsequently a co-ordinated action by Memon qualify as terror ? Does the Godhra incident and its state sponsored asymmetrical fallout qualify to you as terror ? All of these were before 2006, right ? And yet you have chosen 2006 as the benchmark for rise of “Saffron Terror” .
    Care to explain your reasoning ?
    Thanks,
    Mahesh.
    p.s.: On a very very un-related note to Vijay Kumar and Vinay ….
    We were debating the topic on Ms. Roy and Ms. Patkar in Sharmaji’s earlier blogpost. Abrupt travel plans on my side truncated the discussion. Please let me know if you both intend to discuss the topic further.

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Mahesh

    Of course… we can continue it out here…

    BY the way terror in our country largely happens because we have a rabid mad dog called Pakistan as a neighbour and some idiots in high places in India who feel that by eating free kababs with the Pakistani High commissionar will make Hafeez Saeed sing “johny Johny yes papa…”

    [Reply]

    Vinay Reply:

    @Mahesh,
    Would like to share your views. (Not sure, whether I would be able to reply. But want to hear what you say).

    [Reply]

    jimmy Reply:

    mishra peole like u r something else..

    do u have any proof against modi…why has congress and court not found that…why r u hiding in the sewer..go and testify..people like u live in UK an ddo not even know there is something called court and proof…

    may be india shuld make u supreme judge..

    u r the same guy who shows love sarhad par….do u ever think about the victims of pakistan in india like 26-11 and the jawans in kashmir

    even us citizens dont throw flying kisses to cnadian citizens even if their countries are friends for
    centuries…

    but u r a hindu who loves to be slave and thinks peole will clap if u show ur love for indian killers…genius… …man peole like u make me puke…if u r ahindu or indian…i am not one….

    if given achance u will lick the feet of musharraf who admitted to killing indians thru terror…
    that is what media did at agra…shame on u

    [Reply]

    tajender Reply:

    Kandahar hijack 2000,
    Parliament 2001,
    Akshardham temple,
    Mumbai stock exchange,
    Diwali blasts in Jaipur and Sarojini Nagar
    Mumbai train blasts,
    and later- Maraad, Hand cutting incident in Kerala, Deganga, Jaipur 2008, Mumbai- Kasab 2008 etc etc, even- heavens forbid- an international science convention in Bangalore when a professor was shot on stage. I have not mentioned the systematic ethnic cleansing of hindus and sikhs from Kashmir from 1989 .s

    So when Godhra happened, there was a reactionary orgy of evil violence. The very fact that of the 1200 dead there were 100 policemen, testifies to a public fury out of control. A bit like Americans after 911- Afghanistan bombing was brutal, the invasion of Iraq was, to A NEUTRAL, AN ACT OF BLOODY MINDEDNESS.

    perpetuators of all above voilence are caught and now in jail.terrorism was fabricated to rob minorities.u are dreaming the events.hindu terrorists were involve in this.this was good bussines put the bomb pay to media,catch the muslim youth kill few of them in fake encouters
    remaining will pay.killing of of innocent will fetch high goverment awards like in batala killings.

    I have not mentioned the systematic ethnic cleansing of hindus and sikhs from Kashmir from 1989

    hindus from kashmir were removed by jagmohan,a hindu nazi ,to communalize matter and save from pain of round the clock curfew.muslims never touched them.

    Now judge Modi on those 48 hours

    RIOT WAS PREPLANNED BURNING OF BOGEY WAS PART OF PLAN.U ARE SPREADING LIE THAT 100 POLICEMEN WERE KILLED.POLICE WAS PART OF CROWD WHO WILL KILL THEM.THEY WERE RMUSLIMS DIID NOT RETALIATED.ECEIVING INSTRUCTION FROM CONTROL ROOM WHICH WAS UNDER CONTROL OF MODI.MODI IS MONKEY OF BRHMNST.BEING TEELE HE IS BEING ASKED TO
    DO ALL DIRTY WORKS BY BLOOD THIRSTY CHITPAVAN BRHMNS OF NAGPUR.
    HE SHOULD PAY FOR HIS EVIL ACT.BRHMNST PRESS IS ELEVATING HIM THROUGH STORIES OF DEVELOPMENT.

    [Reply]

  • shikha

    Interesting article in Washington on corruption in India -
    Some of the quotes from the article
    “Indeed, under the direction of its popular and apparently incorruptible chief minister, Narendra Modi, Gujurat’s government may have taken the lead in wiping out big-ticket bribery.”

    Another one -
    “Meanwhile, the state of Gujurat is using the Internet to bring transparency to the billions of dollars in infrastructure investments that it is making each year, so everyone can see what is being spent and what is being approved. Residents will be able to keep track of how much the government is paying to individual landowners to acquire and assemble the land necessary to locate new industrial plants and develop new cities, and how the payments are calculated”

    “The political business is also a family business, whether at the village, state or national level. Since independence, India’s national government has been dominated, with only one interruption, by a Congress Party that has been under the control of Jawaharal Nehru and his descendents, from daughter Indira Gandhi to her son Rajiv to his Italian-born widow, Sonia, with her son Rahul waiting in the wings.”

    And btw, for your kind info , Mr Vinod Sharma has spent one full blog eulogizing Laloo Prasad Yadav. I think it was last year.

    [Reply]

    shikha Reply:

    The link to the Washington Post article -
    http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/indias-costly-culture-of-corruption/2011/03/28/AFXoUMPC_story.html

    [Reply]

  • Jai Vaidya

    Anna Hazare is a simple Gandhian who has been duped by very sophisticated group of denationalized NGOs.Now let’s look at the draft they presented, they want to be “deemed police’” and “deemed judiciary”without any checks on themselves.What really got my antennae up was that they wanted all Ramon Magasaysay and all Nobel Prize winners of Indian origin to be members of
    the Lokpal. So vey clever!The Magasaysay and Nobel awards are mostly political.THey are given to people who eventually would be of some use to international finance capital. thw Magasaysay awards are controlled by the famous Rockefeller banking family; and the Nobel by the Rothchilds.
    Remembbber, Gandhi never got the Nobel Peace Prize while Obama got it for being a “community organizer at the bbeginning of his preidency.The point I’m trying to make if somebody says that the India Today or Hindustan Times Man of the Year has to be included in the Lokpal then does it not give the owners of these groups great leverage and back door entry into the Lokpal.

    The question to ask the author of thris blog is who has allowed these NGOs to get close to 10 Janpath who are the people who have facilitated to get so close to the center of Indian power.
    The very mention of the name Modi sends the author into a Pavlovian frothing momentHe starts pulling out those famous dead rabbits out of his hat. Modi , Togadiya, Gujarat, Godra Now we all know the Indian Army was at Pakistan’s border following the Parliament attack. Normally when a state is in trouble, and the police cannot contain violence, they ask for help from the nearest army cantonemet In Modi’s case he did not enjoy this option since our troops were at the border.So he did the next best thing. He asked the states of Maharashtra and Punjab for help. Now we ask ourselves “why these states?” Since Independence, Gujurat has had a problems in itd recruitment drive for the police force. Therefore It relied on and gave incentives to Punjabis and Maharashtrans to join the police force. These two states at the time of the Godra incident had Congress chief ministers Both the states refused. Should there not be a commission of inquiry to find out how these two chief ministers arrived at their decision? Did they get instruction from NewDelhi? Why and who were the people that were involved in the decision to let Gujurat burn?

    Sure Anna Hazara’s movement was urban, and took centre — stage but in the background you failed to see Baba Ramdev , he was addressing the constituency that you feel Anna Hazare ignored. . Also, socialists are so squeaky clean wonder why the character assaassination of an exemplary person who was never lured by lucre.

    These innuendoes about Hazare and Ramdev will not work, justa s they have not worked against Modi. This is a new generation of Indians who can sift through the muck for truth.

    [Reply]

  • Jai Vaidya

    The socialist leader I refer to is George Fernandez

    [Reply]

  • Praveen Saxena

    The lead story of the Times Of India this morning is that Nira Radia has told the CBI that D B Reality is actually controlled by Sharad Pawar. This statement is filed before the court.
    My goodness what an allegation to make against a such great secular politician., who has always opposed communal phorces, a worthy ally of the Congress, a great party which fought for India’s independence.

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    @ Praveen,

    Just watch out this space. Soon there will be more shouts of Rape… rape… modi modi… :D

    Today another article by Javed Anand does exactly that !

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    ~~ :D :D ~~ WHY ANNA NEEDS TO FAST AGAINST DYNASTIC SUCCESSION ~~ :D :D ~~

    I had taken this issue some time back and the issue has only become more relevent. Today the first anointer of the Yuvraj, the super– servile servant Arjun Singh’s son has been appointed head of the COngress in MP.

    The action plan by joker DIGVINASH Singh is toi appoint mini Yuvraj’s in the state so that they all then cry out that we want the bigger Yuvraj at the centre !! :D :D :D

    What a democratic party !!! Ha ha aha ha HA !! :D :D

    Vinodji, in case the older reporters of HT had mandatated that only their children will become HT correspondents, where would you be???????????? :D :D :D

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Vijay Kumar,

    Under the ‘expert’ tutelage of this super guru, Digvinash Singh, the clown prince went to Kerala and called the 87 year old Achyuthanandan too old to head the state as its CM. In return, he called the clown prince ‘Amul Baby’. This guru-shishya team is working more and more like a Laurel and Hardy team. In recent times the two are also re-enacting the Don Quixote-Sancho Panza stories of tilting at Hindu-terror wind mills.

    Now, close on the heals of Bihar’s slap on his ‘youth leadership’, Tamil Nadu is ready to give a resounding thappad on the Amul Baby’s baby cheeks.

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Shenoy

    I think to these jokers, their ally, the supercorrupt Karunanidhi at 87 looks like a spring Chicken ! :D

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    @ Shenoy

    Seems that the Digvinash Singh line of winking at terrorism is encouraging the COngress and Yuvraj to play ball with the “Terror Republic of Pakistan.” The Congress may send the cricketers there and make them risk their lives, but in the end it will be scoring a self goal. The world has isolated Pakistan– nobody wants to got there. The Lankans who went there were attacked by the real face of Pakistan– the LeT .

    and now Laurael and Hardy want to end Pakistan’s isolation and tell the world that the real problem is MOdi and Hindus or something of this sort….

    What intellectual ants !! :D

    Hey bhagwan… hai ALlah… aise Yuvraj se desh ko khatra hai ! :D

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Vijay Kumar,

    I wish Vinod Sharma and all our friends would read this article by G.Parthasarathi:

    http://www.dailypioneer.com/331511/Bogus-cricket-diplomacy.html

    The following excerpt, from an article by Shri Rajiv Dogra, a former diplomat, is also very interesting and informative:

    The prime minister’s ultimate faith is in the Indian people who forgive all and forget everything. That must be the reason for his beatific expression; for his supreme indifference to mayhem over scams that have now become a routine in Parliament. He has shown uncharacteristic emotion only once in the recent memory; when he was reciting a Urdu couplet in the Lok Sabha. For those few seconds his face was flushed and he kept fluttering his eyes. It was a remarkable burst of emotion for an otherwise reticent man; like a hesitant teenager declaring his first love.

    But with Pakistan it is an enduring affair. There is no sign of hesitation; there are no furtive glances as was the case while he was reciting that Urdu couplet for BJP leader Sushma Swaraj. A reference to Pakistan brings a ready smile to his lips. It is as if he has made up his mind to forgive them all their trespasses. Such indeed is the power of true love; it is trusting and it is blind even when it is so obviously one-sided.

    http://expressbuzz.com/opinion/op-ed/starting-afresh-with-pakistan/265314.html

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Shenoy

    I think G Parthasarthi is a brilliant man who should be given charge of the foreign office!

    A part of the problem with some of our Pakistani lovers is their fantasy and itch to talk to thick hipped Pakistani women. Hope the PM does not suffer from such an affliction. Khushwant SIngh and Vinod Mehta (NOT Sharma) certainly do.

    What else can explain such a huge blunder….

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Shenoy

    A better foreign polcy would be to manipulate things so that Americans bomb the LeT and Jaish headquarters in Lahore and Karachi. The American senate is already rating LeT as the bigger threat compared to Queeda.

    We need a jaswant Singh and a Parthasarthi and not chickens like Mani AIyar or Krishana to manipulate a result where American drones attack the terrorists who attack us

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    When Hafiz Saeed attacked our home secretary, G.K.Pillai and our esteemed Krishna was asked to comment about it, he said, after much thinking, “I think Hafiz Saeed saab is speaking out of turn”. What is “in turn” for a terrorist?

    I am giving an illustration of what kind of wet towel ministers we have the misfortune to have in our government. With a queen who cannot speak, a wazeer-e-aalam who cannot govern, with an FM who is only concerned with his wig, only Allah can save India from the machinations of Allah ke nek bande in the land of the pure.

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    @ Vijay Kumar

    Sir I agree with you that Mr. G. Parthasarthy is very impressive both on Tv debates as well in writing. He presents his case with such powerful arguments that one only marvels at his brilliance. His memory of the events is simply remarkable.
    We would not have got that pleasure of listening to his thoughts if he were in foreign office.
    BNA

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @V ijay kumar
    I know both (retired) diplomats very well.Their position on Pakistan is well known. Pl flag their pieces only when they have stated anything different.

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @BV Shenoy
    If my memory serves me right, Krishna was on Shah Mahmood Qureshi and not on Hafeez Sayeed.

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Vinod Sharma,

    I think we need to be consistent in our Pakistan policy. Trying different things only spoils the effort. The UPA had won 2009 after it took a strong stance against the attacks on innocents by jehadis in 26/11. Now if the PM launches an initiative which is willing to sideline our demand for Lakhvi and Hafeez Saeed, the country will surely turn against him.

    Pakistan today is at the lowest point in its existence. We shoudl ram ham our advantage and the backing the world gives us to either dismantle it, or convert it into a secular democracy. NOt make them feel that we would eventually come around to what they want.

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    @Mahesh, thank you for your question reg my post on previous page. (MODI etc)

    All acts of murder are terror whether it is 3000 Sikhs killed in Ovt 1984 or whether it was the brutality unleashed by Bhindranwale and co from 1978-84, which almost bought India to its knees and almost did result in another bloody partition of India.
    Context is everything- mentioning Sikh deaths while not mentioning the setting in which they occured, is incorrect. Read ‘Knights of falsehood’ by KPS Gill, and other books by Mark Tully and Satish Jacob

    [Reply]

    Dr Mishra, UK Reply:

    further MAHESH you wanted to know about the date 2006. I had simply ponted out that from 1988-2000, local Islamist or Pak inspired / initiated terror had bought things to a boil (for details see prev page). You bomb an American disco in Germany today, they bomb Libya tomorrow.

    However, the Indian govt, because of minority appeasement, vote bank politics or sheer incompetence did little to counteract these acts of Islamist / Pak terror. Hence around 2005-6, counter terror from Hindus appeared- saffron terror
    Context is evrything

    [Reply]

    tajender Reply:

    further MAHESH you wanted to know about the date 2006. I had simply ponted out that from 1988-2000, local Islamist or Pak inspired / initiated terror had bought things to a boil (for details see prev page).

    doctor in last 10 years all bombs are planted by rss goons headed by abhinav bharat.not by pak inspired terrorists.they are fighting in kashmir.india was hijacked by brhmnst after babri mosque demolition.this started chain of reactions.

    ur letter in last page is bundle of half truth an untruth.why u call javed naqvi,anti-indian.will it not be better if u challange the facts submitted by him and prove him wrong.

    However, the Indian govt, because of minority appeasement, vote bank politics or sheer incompetence did little to counteract these acts of Islamist / Pak terror

    bullshit there was not.since the terrorist of abhinav bharat are caught there is no bomb blast.
    they using this opportunity to kill innocent muslims plunder btheir wealth and rob them.
    there is no minority appeasement in india.otherwise modi and advani would have been in jail.

    [Reply]

    tajender Reply:

    blaming modi for gujrat roit is politics.since 1969 lot of riots were perpetuated by rss in gujrat.ferocities and brutalities in all the riots are almost same.just to deflect the blame from
    sangh parivar,modi is brought in picture.brhmnst should be blamed (rss).modi is only cadre

    being backward(teelee) he should pay for evilness of brhmns

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    ~~ :D :D ~~~ NOW THE FUNNY PART ~~~ :D :D ~~

    Writing in Dawn Jawed aNaqvi much like some of our media men made fun of Hazare saying that it was a media spectacle created between the WOrld Cup and IPL !! He further says that Hazare is tainted as he like Shivaji !! WoW!!…

    How is liking Shivaji bad and loving Aurangzeb secular ?

    To top it all he laso makes fun of India’s world cup win saying that it is tainted because Dhoni shaved his head off and Gambhir dedicated his win to the martyrs of 26/11. Is “Jawed the joke’ trying to make the Pakistanis happy by writing all this??? :D :D :D

    I think this is proposed visit by the Indian cricketers is the worst foreign policy blunder India can do. Not only are we giving legitimacy to a state which sponsors terror in India, we are also signalling that “hey Pakistanis you can keep killing innocents… we are really not bothered about Jaish and Lashkar…”

    I would have let this pass because this is finally going to derail the Congress as the people are not going to swallow “Aman ki aasha” sort of shit without Hafeez Seed’s head on the platter. :D

    But the fact is we are seriously putting the life of our cricketers at risk….

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    @ Vijay Kumar
    Sir
    I think the UPA govt. is at again with Sharm-el- Sheikh agenda . It is evident so as Mr.. Krishna, the pseudo diplomat, retorted to a reporter to remember Sharm-el- Sheikh declaration when the reporter asked him some inconvenient question regarding the newly initiated peace agenda with Pakistan. The poor commandos and the people who were martyred in Mumbai must be crying in their graves at the inconsistent policies of the govt. It beats the logic as to why we staged the drama of disconnecting everything with Pakistan. It is amystery under whose pressure the Indian govt.has decided to resume the normal dialogue process when nothing has changed on the ground.
    The idea of playing cricket at this stage with Pakistan would hardly serve any purpose. I am even doubtful as to whether the Indian players would at all agree to play against Pakistan and that too in Pakistan
    BNA

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Dr Anand

    You are right. The players are hating the idea. Even the HT carried the news today. When Pakistan could not protect the Lankan team, Benazir Butto, Shahbaz Bhatti and Taseer, what protection can the offer the Indians? In all cases the murderersw were the jehadi assets of Pakistan and the ISI…

    We need to remember Gambhitr dedicated hiw win to the martyrs of 26/11…

    On the other side, Sonia Mata and Yuvraj themselves have refused to fo to Pakistan because
    of a possible risk to life….

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Vijay;
    Realize that these journos, including Kuldeep Nayyar and some one goes by name Ram, writes
    to make **** Editors happy and to continue drawing their pay check. There is nothing in their writing, which tackels serious matters. Failed to understand the idiocy of Pakis praying on the field in a sham public display of their piety( In fact, had they won, they would have ascribed this victory to Allah and/or Islam, that was the real intention, never knew that they do this public Tamasha in west). Tonsuring head by Dhoni, was his personal act, never made a public hue and cry of his act of fulfilling a vow. Gambhir’s comment was totally appropriate, timely as lot of **** was being bandied in Pakistani media and Afridi.. These people have two standards, one for themselves, which they think, can not be criticized and one for others, where they think, they can criticize as their right.

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    ~~~ :D :D ~~ HUE AND CRY NOTICE FOR VINOD SHARMA ~~ ::D :D ~~

    SIr we the bloggers of this site urgently need your expert comments !! :D :D :D

    A SMALL example of “secular Congress” corruption has been reported in the NDTV. Part of of the report is excerpted below. Sir, I humbly request, with folded hads that the Lok Pal be immediately put on the job on this one. What is your opinion on this?

    Do you think wish should forgive this and start shouting MOdi Modi… rape rape… ? Can you please give ur views???
    ———————————————————————————————————————

    Om Metals and Triton Hotels use Mr Gehlot’s son, Vaibhav, as a legal consultant. Vaibhav joined Om Metals in 2006 – his salary was Rs. 10,000 a month.

    Two years later, the Congress government headed by Ashok Gehlot came to power.

    In May 2010, the Rajasthan government awarded a Rs. 457-crore contract to Om Metals – whose main business was hydro-power projects – to construct a dam across the River Kalisindh near Kota.

    Two months later , Om Metals was granted another Rs. 250 crore contract to build a two-lane 200-km stretch of the Rajasthan State Highway between Jaipur and Bhilwarah.
    _____________________________________________________________________

    The tip of an iceberg of a party which protects its own !

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar
    Thanks for drawing my attention to the NDTV report. I take the point. Am keen also to hear from you on the Supreme Court quashing land allotted by the MP government to a trust with Advani, Venkaiah Naidu and perhaps Uma Bharti as members :) ) Do you also have some data to share on lands allotted to Corporates in Gujarat —- especially the Adani group?
    I accept that two wrongs can never make a right.That’s why graft and corruption have to be fought wherever they exist.

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Vinod Sharma,

    The Supreme court has probably done the right thing. Precious public land has been alloted all over INdia in the name of Nehru and his descendents. In fact many a million trusts exist which just use the Nehru- Gandhi name for private enterprise. We should probe and cancel that also. Remember how Antulay used Indira’s name for private trusts and “self growth?” :D

    In UP, Mayawait is using public money and public land to make her own memorials and statues. Wonder why nobody is fasting against that… :D

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar
    U have not answered my question. I take your response to mean: Let the sleeping dogs lie.

    VIjay Kumar Reply:

    I think the land allotment should be cancelled as it should be be for the fake trusts on the Nehru Gandhi name. And as for the statues… every body seems stupified ! :D

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    @ Vijay Kumar, thanks for sharing this gem of news with us. For every 1 Gehlot type scandal uncovered, there must be 100 lying undetected. While I admire MMS for what he has done in the past, the fact that biilions worth of scandals has occured ON HIS WATCH, means he is guilty.

    Guilty of lack of leadershi. Oh what wud I give for 1 Sardar Patel today !!

    @Vijay and Dr Anand, agree- sending our cricketers to Pak right now is very dangerous. If the most elite of commandoes, hand picked to protect Governors, could include Qadri who then killed Tasseer, then why on earth shud we risk Tendulkar and co is beside me.

    @Vijay, did you know Jawed Naqvi is an Indian and lives in Delhi. His writing is rabidly anti Indian and sneering to hindus. Ignore him

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    @ Dr Mishra

    At one point I was a huge admirer of MMS. But he seems to be a good no 2 man and not a leader who leads thru fiery rhetoric and charisma. Unfortunately, lately, he seems to be biding his time and planning for retirement. Maybe he has taken a cue out of his former boss, PV Rao.

    However sleepy looking Rao was blessed with a third eye. He gave complete charge to KPS Gill in Punjab and achieved results. His Pakistan policy was brilliant. He matched ISI with RAW, bullet to bullet. By 1995 he had mentored Altaf bhai and MQM. MMS should now take a leaf out of Rao’s book :)

    [Reply]

  • B.V.SHENOY

    Dear Friends,

    Here are some snatches of the Indo-Pak “dialogue” that is said to have taken place at Mohali between the Wazeer-e-aalam’s of India and Pakistan.

    Gilani: Sardar Saab, maine aapki shaayiri suni, aapne to Sushma Behn ko Hila hi diya.
    MMS: Chhodo ji, Sushma ji ko bhala kaun hila sakta hai? Maine to unko meri shayiri se khila dee aur who yekdum khil uthi.

    Gilani: Humein bhi kuch sunayiye naa?
    MMS: Uraz hai: “vaqt karataa jo vafaa aap hamaare hote
    ham bhii Gairo.n kii tarah aap ko payaare hote
    vaqt karataa jo vafaa …

    apanii taqadiir me.n pahale hii kuuchh to Gam hai.n
    aur kuchh aap kii fitarat me.n vafaa bhii kam hai
    varana jiitii huii
    varana jiitii huii baazii to naa haare hote
    vaqt karataa jo vafaa …”

    Wah, wah, ab iska matlab bhi sunayiye naa?

    MMS: Chodiye naa.

    Gilani: let us now talk of business. Can you send your cricket team to Pakistan?
    (it was in the last stages of the match when Pakistan was already defeated)

    MMS: Not only will I send the team, I will ask them to lose all the matches to your boys, even without their indulging in match fixing. With that, your nation can bring itself back from the smashaan ghat and go about their normal (terrorist) activities.

    Gilani: To baat pakki?
    MMS : sau ki sau pakki.

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Shenoy

    Am tempted to make a comedy of this script!! Will have Digvinash and Mani “Silencer” dancing in the background ! :D

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    as cheer-leaders (male) waving Pakistani flags.

    [Reply]

  • http://rediffmail.com ram

    our one more great secular politician jayanthi natak rajan not to be seen these days

    Is it true she ate 300 crores ?

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    She must be suffering from acute indigestion.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.rediff.com Paritosh

    @ Vijay Kumar

    i guess its totally futile to expect from MMS to have some spine and a Machiavellian approach towards Pakistan

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    @ vijay any proof of this statement- Rao- His Pakistan policy was brilliant. He matched ISI with RAW, bullet to bullet. By 1995 he had mentored Altaf bhai and MQM.
    i would be impressed

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Dr Mishra

    Karachi and Sindh were sent boiling after PVN realised that Pak-shit-stan would continue fomenting trouble in J&K and Kashmir. Check out the newsreports then. I got my info from a RAW officer.

    Shri Kabab platter I K Gujral surrenedered all that in the name of Jhelum diplomacy :D

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Vijay Kumar,

    It is known as Gujral dog-s.h.i.t.rin.

    [Reply]

  • Jai Vaidya

    The Scamathon continues. Finance capital disguised as NGOs with innocuous sounding names. While Our Assamese PM seems to have made a new best friend. Great ol;d–school journalism by Kapil Bajaj.

    http://kbforyou.blogspot.com/2011/03/manmohan-singhs-public-private.html

    [Reply]

  • B.V.SHENOY

    Vinodji,

    There is a Sanskrit saying, :Vinasha kaale vipareeta buddhi”

    Do you think this Digvinash Singh is approaching that stage in his life? Look at the way he has taken on Anna Hazare. he even has a problem with the Bharat maata’s photo hung as a back-drop at the Jantar Mantar venue of his fast. Does he want that M.F.Hussain’s Bharat Maata would have been more “suitable” for the occasion? What do you say to his accusation that Anna is being supported by the RSS and the BJP?

    [Reply]

  • Praveen Saxena

    Some of us have expressed fears that the Congress Party shall do its utmost to derail the process for the Lokayukta. That it shall quitely unleash all its dirty tricks. It is becoming quite evident now. It started with the Gujarat Gujarat , Modi Modi chorus . Then the ever so eager Digvijay Singh made his appearance . Then a fake CD on Shanti Bhushan which has suddenly surfaced, There is Mohan Singh of SP threatening that SP shall also go on unto death if not included ( wonder who shall ? is it going to be Mulayam singh or his brother Shivpal or his son , we are all waiting for that fast to begin ? Let us see what Lalu and his friend Paswan are thinking of?
    Methinks It is going to be a roller coaster ride for Anna Hamare and us too.

    [Reply]

  • shikha

    Please read the report on fake CD mess by Vinod Sharma on HT
    http://www.hindustantimes.com/Lokpal-co-chairman-Shanti-Bhushan-lands-in-CD-mess/H1-Article1-685748.aspx

    As per Mr. Sharma this is a genuine CD. Mr. Sharma, can I trust you that our emails with you are secure?? With computer forensics, you can provide our where abouts to your favorite Congress party so that they can come after us!! I wonder how you face your loved ones, see them eye to eye with this act. Throttling people’s movement..this is all you can do??

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Shikha, this CD should be called seedy evidence.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    And when the person who has committed the fraud must be tried for sedition.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    correction:And when the person who has committed this fraud is found, he must be tried for sedition.

    vinod sharma Reply:

    Like Binayak Sen?

    ram Reply:

    this is as expected from cancer party.

    [Reply]

  • tajender

    xc

    [Reply]

  • Praveen Saxena

    Read the Link Shikha. Thanks
    Not too surprising that the name of the Forensic Lab is not disclosed and a chatty quote from Amar Singh’s for more credence.

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Praveen Saxena
    I don’t expect any fair comment from you. But HT is the only newspaper that did due dilligence before carrying the CD’s contents. Several other newspapers and TV channels didn’t find that necessary.
    As for the source of the forensic report, the agency concerned was kind to me to get it done in one day. I don’t want to cause them any trouble. Shall furnish their identity when the need arises as the CD is about two lawyers and other rich people who can harrass me in courts. I am on a surer footing about the story than most others.

    [Reply]

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Mr Vinod Sharma
    Now u are not being fair to me. There have been occassions in the past when I have concurred with your views, Yes it is true that we do not happen to be on the same side of the Communal- secular divide as laid down by you.
    As for your story, pl allow me to narrate an old episode to you. ( Probably a sign that I am getting old when I keep going back into history).
    Many years ago , after completing my education I had come to Delhi and landed with my first job with an ad agency here. My branch manager once called me during lunch time , that we have to go for a meeting at Hindustan Times around 3 o clock. I do not know what is on their mind , but could you do a quick survey on their image.At that time the circulatuion of Hindustan Times was more than the circulation of all the English dailies put together. So I quickly made a short questionnnaire and spoke to whoever was availble in the agency. The findings were on expected lines that the govt servants/ proffessionals/ non Punjabis were more keen on reading the TOI. Whereas the HT was more popular among the Punjabis kar traders etc . Now armed with the ” research findings” and the glib talk of my Branch Head , we trooped into yr office and taken to S L Khurana, your ED at that time. We all looked forward to meeting Khushwant Singh who was the Editor at that time , but he did not come. Needless to say that nothing came out of that meeting.
    The moral of the story . With deadlines breathing down the neck , Ad agencies and newspaper editorial do happen to follow the same practices . Don’t u think so.

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Praveen Saxena
    I am sorry I’m unable to see the parallel. But HT worked better on the story in question than several others who ran the contents without even cross checking whether the CD was a cust and paste job?
    I rest my case.

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Praveen Saxena
    Am surprised really that you missed Shanti Bhushan’s quotes—- especially the one after the passage relating to forensic report. Your reading of the story is selective and your comments biased.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Vinodji,

    I too read your article. I am sorry to say that even your so called expert forensic laboratory report says, after “due diligence” that the talk ‘appears to be continuous’. with the ‘expert technology’ why are they still hesitant to be conclusive?

    Another interesting point is about Amar Singh, who seems to be getting high marks from you for integrity, fairness and for not being an interested player in the “CD business”.

    Why is it that whenever a CD of this nature appears anywhee in India, Amar Singh is a player?

    Even while mixing his mataphors, he involuntarily speaks out his mind. Sample this:

    He uses the idiom, “what is good for peter should be good for Paul”, whereas the correct idiom is what is good for the geese is good for the gander. The other correct idiom is Rob Peter to pay Paul.

    In the back of his mind, he must be thinking of the Rs4crore “goose”, which will come by robbing some Peter to pay Paul Bhushan.

    All in all, you have done a good job in muddying the already muddy waters.

    [Reply]

  • tajender

    blaming modi for gujrat roit is politics.since 1969 lot of riots were perpetuated by rss in gujrat.ferocities and brutalities in all the riots are almost same.just to deflect the blame from
    sangh parivar,modi is brought in picture.brhmnst should be blamed (rss).modi is only cadre

    being backward(teelee) he should pay for evilness of brhmns.

    [Reply]

  • tajender

    Hindu India is emerging as the world’s largest country of illiterates. But the Hindus are not bothered about it because illiteracy has helped the 15% ruling upper castes (Hindus) to remain as permanent rulers.

    The mantra is: Keep the SC/ST/BCs (65%) plus Muslims/Christians/Sikhs (20%) — a total of 85% — poor which will force them to remain illiterate and also peaceful.

    NO COURAGE TO PROTEST
    Once you are both poor and illiterate you lead an animal existence. Brainwash them with Hindu poison which will dope them into eternal silence. Wonderful.

    Otherwise, by this time Hindu India would have exploded — blown into pieces if only the 85% of the sub-humans had some strength to stand and protest, a courage which they will get only if they are literate.

    HINDU RULE
    This is the secret of the eternal, unquestioned Hindu rule.

    Hinduism is a poison pill that can lull you to permanent sleep. Is it not working wonders with 1,300 million slaves enjoying their slavery? May be in the eastern part of India, some stray tribals are protesting. They are dubbed maoists and will be soon gunned down by their own brothers in the equally illiterate police force.

    SOUTH INDIA AS EXCEPTION
    Barring the four southern states of AP, Karnataka, TN and Kerala and to some extent Maharashtra, the rest of India is packed with hungry, illiterate Bahujans. It is in this part of India, called the “cow belt” (also called BIMARU states) that Hindu terrorist party is having its rule. The most stinking Hindu holy places are in BIMARU states.

    How the Hindus are ruling India?

    WORLD’S LARGEST ILLITERATE COUNTRY
    The secret is already revealed above.

    There are hardly any schools in rural areas. The rural India is totally devastated.

    Even if there is a school, it has no teacher. If it has a teacher, it has no building.

    The teacher is so ill-paid, he or she has no desire to teach. Because the teacher is so ill-paid. That is how India has become the world’s largest country of illiterates. But the Hindu rulers are least worried. Because there is not even a protest. Once upon a time, teaching profession commanded the highest respect. Guru Devo Bhava.

    Brahminists realised the danger and quickly killed the very teaching profession. Today the teachers command no respect from their own students.

    EDUCATION AS A LUXURY
    Many schools go without teachers because he or she gets no place to stay. If he is a Dalit or “low caste” nobody will give even a room. The basic salary of a govt. primary teacher in Karnataka is Rs. 6,235 which is less than the pay of a bank peon. Schooltext books and midday-meals are there only on paper.

    As you go North there is neither schools nor teachers. If both are present there will be no students because the parents are so poor that they can ill-afford to send their children to schools as they are needed at home to work.

    When filling the stomach of so many in the house is the problem, education is a luxury in Hindu India.

    See, how beautifully and effectively Hindus have kept India poor, illiterate and also peaceful.

    ——————————————————————————–

    Web is dying as China starts building its own internet
    OUR CORRESPONDENT

    Bangalore: Two big sensational news: (1) The worldwide web (WWW), popularly known as the internet, created by the American Jews, is dying.

    (2) The second more sensational news is China, the rising super power, is creating its own internet. It has pressed 35,000 engineers to do the big job which needs wiring under and over the oceans, round the globe. The Chinese wonder is not yet reported in the Western media but the West, particularly the US, is fully in the know of it.

    Fall of the West: As the US and the Western influence is fast declining, China, which has already taken over the No.2 place of Japan, is getting ready to replace USA. DV was the first in the world to predict it and we have proved correct.

    Hindu India falling: We have also proved right that “Hindu India” is fast slipping. The Jews are killing the US and the West. And the “Jews of India” are killing India after breaking it (1947) into three pieces — India, Pakistan, Bangladesh. Afraid of more divisions. The world famous weekly, Economist (Sept.4, 2010) has announced the “web is dead”.

    Christian surrender to Jew: The world is anyway divided racially, class-wise, politically, and religiously. Added to this comes the disaster of the digital divide.

    This is the result of the White Western Christians surrendering to the zionist Jews.

    The Economist says the internet is getting divided. Each country including China and India are putting up its own “wall” and concludes saying “web is dead”.

    Did we not say that anything the Jews and the “Jews of India” touch is bound to die?

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ ASHAMED of being ****-shit-ani, “fake Tajender”

    Go home and kill a few Jehadis. Your Pak-shit-stan will then improve. Dont waste ur time here :D

    [Reply]

  • http://rediffmail.com balakumaran

    Sharmaji’s HT says

    “The file 1.MP3 was burnt on the CD on 15/01/2006. The analysis further shows that the software ‘itunes’ was used for recording the said file and CD was burnt using an Apple Macintosh System,” the report continues.

    its simple even my 8yr old son can do, why u need foren SIC for that

    right click on the 1.Mp3 file goto properties change it to 15/10/1947

    and dowload frm the web audio rip, audio split, u name it u get and play around, have a happy weekend

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @balakumaran
    The operative part is that the audio file was continuous and not tempered with. The other details don’t matter really. The matter to be probed is whether the voices consistently are of the protagonists —- bhushan, amar singh and mulayam

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    Who is to validate that the guys who analysed the tape are themselves not fraudulent like most Congress leaders and their peddlers in the media ? In fact , the emergence of the so called tape is further proof of how the political establsihment ( read thug corrupt politicians ) is opposed to any accountability. The leaders of this corrupt criminal cabal are Congress enablers like Mr Sharma ( who reports to Sonia ) who was mentioned in wikileaks for bribing legislators and politicians like Amar Singh, Mulayam, Mayawati , Dig Vijay Singh and such assorted criminals.

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    In a rape case, to acquit the accused, try and blacken the character of the girl. In a similar way, the govt is trying to blacken the character of Anna, Ramdev and the Bhushan family.

    Maybe there is some truth in the allegations against Ramdev and Bhushan- let there be a fair investigation. Oh dear, for that we need a Lokpal.

    Catch 22 ha

    All that Digvijay, Jawed Naqvi (Indian who writes sneeringly in Pak newspaper Dawn) and Saba Naqvi in Outlook, could come up against Anna was the bharat mata backdrop and a reference to Shivaji. In a country that is 85% hindu-sikh, I did not know that was a crime.

    btw, a brilliant blog going on at Gautam Chickermane. Shenoy, Dr Anand, Saxena, Shikha, Balakumaran , Jaivaidya, Vijay, Vinay, Usman, Pankaj etc and you Vinodji- are also welcome there to attack or support me ?!

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Dr Mishra

    U R right ! The whole gang is at work to destroy the flower of honesty .

    I have written a comment on the truth as I know it, having extensive dealings with the government. Love to hear ur views !

    [Reply]

  • http://- Rajeev

    In the last blogs, when I alleged that Bhushans have sympathy for maoists, Sharma vouched the integrity of Bhushans. What has changed in one week for Sharma to change his opinion of Bhushans?

    Is it direction from Digvijay Singh? Do you need any more proof that Sharma is Congressi paid agent?

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Rajeev
    Nothing has changed Rajeev. I got the CD examined and went by the report I received. In the same story I carried the version of Shanti Bhushan. That’s it. Now in retrospect, you can
    impute motives to this journalistic due dilligence if you like.

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    @Vinod Sharma ji
    Sir, the forensic examination of CD as per an American lab. has confirmed that it was doctored and that some parts of the contents were spliced to insert Bhushan voice. The Bhushans got similar findings from an Indian labtoo. Mr Bhushan has filed a defamation case in the apex court against Amar Singh. That is where now the matter rests. I believe Bhushans have been very courageous and true to their character are following the logical way to sort out this mess. Amar Singh is surely now in trouble. Mr. Amar Singh had been all the time acted as a power broker and now all of a sudden has surfaced in the media. The country is indeed tired of such manipulators.

    Don’t you think that such CD sting operation was bound to happen? For all their good outward appearances , the UPA and the entire political class are quite nervous at the prospect of civil society having a say in drafting the Lok pal bill. The politicians could drag this bill for 42 years and could have dragged it for another 42 years. The expediency of the process has indeed given some confidence to the common man about the future course vis-a vis corruption in the country. The results of Shunglu committee appointed by the PM himself are there for every one to see how the politicians will never accept any verdict that proves them guilty. May be the Lokpal bill change the situation.
    Regards
    BNA

    [Reply]

  • http://- Rajeev

    When we show VIDEO TAPES of ‘Cash for Vote’ scam, same Sharma comes up with multiple excuses to trash the visual evidences.
    Great piece of journalism indeed…Corrupt media protecting their corrupt masters.

    [Reply]

    ankit Reply:

    what can you expect from this man devoid of all integrity? he has been appointed on the minority commission as a quid pro quo for putting out pro-congress stories in his newspaper. head of that minority commission was caught intimidating a victim of the 1984 riots to drop the case against sajjan kumar, but you will not hear a whiff from sharma. imagine the level of shamelessness when the same sharma writes stories accusing others of communalism etc.

    how do these guys get sleep?

    [Reply]

  • Pankaj#1

    @ Everyone;
    I did not read the blog-Anna Hamare- as I was not interested in reading the biased comments on Anna but Karan Thapar’s balanced article in HT made me to go back to Anna Hamare.
    You can immediately make out the difference between two Journalists. Vinod is biased and Karan appear more balanced.
    What amused me is his demand for declaring assets from people supporting Anna. So far he has not asked any politician from DMK infamy to NCP supremo, who is involved in every big scam this country has seen. Starting from Daud Ibrahim’s mentorship to getting into BCCI, even when he was once defeated by Dalmia, to recent housing society, Balwa connection and other numerous scandals, which I do not recall.
    His effort to deifying Mahatma Gandhi is laughable. Mahatma was great soul, but human being and should be open for balanced criticism. His defence of Mahatma in tone that he is untouchable reminds me of latest controvery on a book on Mahatma, where people sought ban on thisbook, Gujrat included. This appear akin to some muslims obsession with Prophet. He is trying to be cosy with infamous Laloo acolytes, praising them to be respectable people. It is laughable indeed.
    Anna has given voice to millions who are suffering from depredations of political class and Vinod wants him to seek these politician’s help to destroy themselves. Be reasonable Vinod. Do not jump to the conclusions before getting deeper into Anna’s intention and motives. He is a simple person, not well versed into the intricasies of Delhi smart’s way and singling him out to mention Modi and Nitish, while whole wide world is praising them look ridiculous.

    [Reply]

    tajender Reply:

    i hope u will agree with me that What is needed is not a drive to curb corruption but to destroy the very value system that prompts you to become corrupt. But the value system comes mostly from the religion. Who is ready to touch the religion?

    May be the India will rot, stink and degenerate — until another foreign invader comes and takes over.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Tajender
    You got me here dude. Which foreign power you are talking about? please name it. Is it your wish list that some foreign power should come and rule India? do you seek your emancipation there? Who are you? you are certainly not a Dalit from India, where Dalits have tasted fruit of power, because of reservation, any number of high government officials and chief minister is a living proof. Think about your madre watan, where feudals are making a mince meat of you, how long you will continue to stick to the system, where Army, Mullah and feudals will keep you in bondage.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Tajender;
    So you think that India’s religion is putting her in a difficult situation? What about Pakistan, where you have purest of pure religion and every body sporting religion on their sleeves, from keeping a beard to shalwar 2 inches above ankle and after every sentence, uttering that prophet had said this and that. Man, God has not created any bigger hypocrites than Pakistanis.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Pankaj ji, will you please stop carrying on this dialogue of the deaf with this Ram Fake Autar?

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    @ Shenoy;
    Aye, Aye, Sir.

  • Vijay Kumar

    @ Vinod Sharma

    Sir, I am amazed how the story on corruption of Congress CM in Rajasthan amounting to a thousand crores has sunk in the media!! Do you think it is not worth reporting ??? :D

    Oh ! HO !! I understand now ! Arre baba Congress ki chori toh koi chori nahi… woh toh puja hai !! :D

    CM ka Chadawa, goes to who all incuding the Mata rani.

    I am tempted to sing a chanchal song.

    ” Abhi bulawa aaya hai….

    Maata ne bulaya hai… ”

    Every time I have raised this topic, you have deflected it in true Congress style by talking about Advani. Sir, catch the thief. PLEASE DO NOT GET SCARED OF THE CONGRESS THIEVES !! :D :D

    Remember the Vinod Sharma who fought against the Energency and dynastic rule, as you told us.

    Kya Kursi ki temptation se woh ideals tyag diye??? :D :D :D

    [Reply]

    peter gomes Reply:

    jagan reddy declared assets of 350 crores…..

    media mafia r also hiding and were hiding ysr corruption for years…including mining

    they change the rules for yeddy and scream…

    but ofcourse everything happens for the first time in bjp state…

    just like communal riots in gujarat and that too after congressis burnt train..

    wow what a elmedia …..in any other country such media wuld be a watchdog of govt..but here they r lapdogs hired to bark lies at opposition

    [Reply]

  • Vijay Kumar

    ~ :D :D :D ~~ SCARED POLITICIANS AND CHAMCHA FIXERS PISSING IN THE PANTS~~~ :D :D :D

    :) ~~ I am revealing the sordid truth which all of us need to swallow ~~ and act against ~~ :)

    VINOD SHARMA, Shenoy, Vinay, Mahesh, Rajeev, Rajiv, Dr Mishra, Dr Anand, Jai Vaidya,Pankaj
    Everyone– Please PLEASE COMMENT>

    Amar Singh, an ex Employee of the Hindustan Times group, was a liason guy who while liasing managed to convince Mulayam Singh, about the art of making mega bucks without resorting to kidnapping, murder and extortion, which Mulayam Singh’s earlier hechmen like D P Yadav and Mukhtar Ansari undertook.

    Here was born a partnership which took 15% on each state contract and bigger amounts on land allotments…. :D :D

    There was some danger to UPA 1 in case this coalition became bigger and threatened them at the national level. So one day the Yuvraj decided to tap Amar Singh’s telephone using the official machinery. So out spilled the truth !!!

    Everything was being fixed. Judges, contracts and media. The media — like say AAj Tak were giving Amar SIngh prime time, because they got land allotments. And Shir Prabhu was doing an un-Prabhu act by promising Amar SIngh good coverage !! They made him “happy’ — as he showered blessings and land allotments, calling him a playboy, a party animal, a “secularist” what not !

    Even some film stars like Biphasha Basu and some others were willing to showere thier goodies on our uncles.. :D just showing how hollow they were…

    I think this Shanti Bhushan tape is probably part of those tapes done by the Yuvraj.

    It is being used as a ploy so that NO POWERFUL LOK PAL COMES UP AND PROBES INTO THE LOOT BY THIEVES, CHORS, BURGALARS, MURDERERS, KICKBACK AGENTS and what not of the COngress . :(

    let not the agents of Congress derail this flower of honesty whach has germinated. Let them not destroy our country. Let them not use Modi or some other excuse to bash hoensty and good values.

    Jai HInd !

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar,

    “I think this Shanti Bhushan tape is probably part of those tapes done by the Yuvraj”.

    But, in the audio CD I got from the yuvaraj, the message is “Amul milk is the favourite drink of the children of India”

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Shenoy,

    The Yuvraj of the Congress will become its Yamraj ! :D

    [Reply]

    Pankaj#1 Reply:

    Vijay;
    This Amar Singh guy reminds me of Rasputin.
    Ra Ra Rasputin, lover of the Russian Queen——–Oh, those terrible Russians.
    This guy has to be treated like Rasputin and is to be brought to his natural end ( of career, of course). Whenever, Congress is in trouble, very conveniently, these CDs appear, are they stored somewhere in an template form and redesigned, according to the need of the hour??
    This time it was a very sharp job, probably too sharp. Indians have had enough of these CDs, the trick has lost its impact, they should research some other trick to employ for their diirty trick department. Truth and sheer truth and honesty has different meaning for MULAYAM, AMAR SINGH AND DiGVINASH SINGH.

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Pankaj

    Well Rasputin was the lover of teh Russian queen. !!

    When the kickbacks were flying high… Amar Singh was surrounded by a lot of queens, curtsy MR AB and money power !!

    But if the Congress now neeeds Amar Singh, it is their death hour !

    [Reply]

  • Dushyant

    Now that Prashant Bhushan in his press conference have shown that the tapes are not continuous and doctored, what do you have to say? The way part of the conversation of Mulayam was used has busted the plot. And it has also busted your connivance. Shame on You.

    DD

    [Reply]

  • Mohan Ramchandani

    As it was expected> CD was doctored.

    http://www.rediff.com/news/report/cb-fabricated-backed-by-powerful-people-says-prashant-bhushan/20110417.htm

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Mohan,

    what Vinod Sharma got as the “report of the forensic laboratory” is like what Laloo Prasad got from Justice Banerjee about the Godhra train burning.

    [Reply]

  • shikha

    Mr. Sharma,

    As expected the news of doctored CD is missing in HT. Mr. Sharma, show some conscience , please. This is a heart felt message from someone who loves India !!
    And for your kind information I have advanced coursework in Computer Forensics from American Univ. And your analysis of CD was extremey childish. Please do not mess up with digital content!!
    Please submit the report as to how it was arrived that the audio was continuous. I am interested in reading it.

    Also when I post to this blog, I have to provide my email id May I trust you with it? How can I be sure that they shall not be used to find my where abouts and do witch hunting?

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Shikha,

    Thanks for your strong rebuttal of the fake CD’s made-to-order forensic report.

    You said, “Also when I post to this blog, I have to provide my email id May I trust you with it? How can I be sure that they shall not be used to find my where abouts and do witch hunting?”

    Please, Shikha, you shouldn’t go so far as to impute motives to Shri Vinod Sharma. He has believed in this report, which HT has got made-to-order, just like the Banerjee commission report on Godhra train burning, which Laloo got made-to-order.

    And just as the pseudo secular brigade, which, unfortunately, includes our friend, Vinod Sharma too, believes the Banerjee report as “Gospel Truth”, he believes this report on the fake CD too. Please understand this.

    [Reply]

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @BV Shenoy
    Had I believed blindly in the CD, I would not have got it examined forensically. I did all this to ensure that I did not use the stuff without verification. Other newspapers showed no such due dilligence. Only HT did. So is it fair to villify us for carrying the story which most TV channels and newspapers did without due dilligence. Some reported the conversation on the CD in toto without any cross check.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Vinodji,

    As far as ‘due diligence’ goes, you did the right thing and without reservation I commend you for your professional integrity. It only goes to show that the congress party has perpetrated a fraud, which is technically too sophisticated for ordinary ‘experts’ to detect.

    It is also clear that Amar Singh, who was, in the 2004 dinner party Sonia Gandhi hosted for the high and mighty of the UPA, treated like a pariah and outcast, has now become a palace intriguer and it now looks like he has matamorphosed into an enfant terrible of the Indian politics, with a bagful of dirty tricks.

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Shenoy Saab

    Amar Singh is a former employee of the HT group and now marking time to gain entry into the Party which is always in need of such people . I remember reading a byelined article wherein Amar Singh had disclosed how he was approached by Late Shri K K Birla to counsel Mulayam Singh to support Sonia G when she laid claim that she has the support to form the govt. Don’t you see a running competition between the two Thakurs Amar Singh and Digvijay to outdo each other.

    vinod sharma Reply:

    @Shikha
    No you are wrong dear. Bhushan’s version is on HT’s page one— more prominent than my story that says the CD was examined by a government lab. There is no attempt to play down any point of view. A thorough probe into the issue will bring out the truth that all parties will be obliged and duty bound to accept.

    [Reply]

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Praveen Saxenaji,

    This fake “seedy” thing is getting curiouser and curiouser. Please see the article in OUTLOOK, readers’ views as well as the photo of the two thakurs in the following link:

    http://blogs.outlookindia.com/default.aspx?ddm=10&pid=2484#iframetimelinechronologicalmainpostname

    It is clear that the thakurs have, this time bitten off more than they can chew.

    [Reply]

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Thanks Shenoy Saab. Interesting reading but I am not surprsied. Rather Iam reminded of some old episodes … The St Kitts Forgery, The Fairfax conspiracy etc… history seems to keep repeating itself..

    B.V.SHENOY Reply:

    Vinodji,

    you will agree that the matter has now gone beyond the fake Vs genuine CD. It now involves Amar Singh as a litigant in SC, his probable contempt of court etc.

    As for the “seedy”, do you think, at this stage the congress party should “invite” Tehelka into the game to muddy it further, so that it can slip out of the grip of the Bhushans?

    [Reply]

  • tajender

    hundreds like anna hazare cannot make any change till we change our money based value system ,But making money is the easiest. You must have no scruples, no principles. Cheat, rob, bribe or take bribe, resort to any means including murder — you become rich. And once you become rich you become the Ambani. Your past is quickly forgotten. And get all awards, rewards. Front-page pictures, TV interviews, Rotary Club honour.

    Your wife, mother, father will all love you, run after you only if you are rich.

    [Reply]

  • tajender

    What is needed is not a drive to curb corruption but to destroy the very value system that prompts you to become corrupt. But the value system comes mostly from the religion. Who is ready to touch the religion?

    May be the India will rot, stink and degenerate — until another foreign invader comes and takes over

    [Reply]

  • Dr Mishra, UK

    If the CD was fake, then it means someone is desperate. The net closing in? Or do I celebrate too soon ?
    Vijay, what is the link to your story

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    @ Dr MIshra,

    The fact that they needed Amar Singh is a sign of the Vanprastha Ashram. His guru Digvinash has already taken Congress to the death bed !

    Wah re Wah Congress !! :D

    Arre yaaro, kaal Dhan waapis kar do… kyon janta ko pareshaan kart ho !

    [Reply]

  • jai vaidya

    Mr. Vinod Sharma should tell us where he got this CD verified from. I hope it’s not the same person who did the Varun Gandhi CD.
    On the lighter side, trhe lyrics of this song aptly describe the state of mind of the Congress and their media sympathisers..

    http://youtu.be/OjAkHBBpIL4

    [Reply]

    Divya Reply:

    Dear blog Manager
    Its getting difficult to see all comments here. I cannot accass posts later than 18 April. What’s the problem?

    [Reply]

  • Praveen Saxena

    Friends let us not panic. We shall see more dirty tricks emanating from the Congress Party , its collaborators and agents to derail the process of the appointment of an independent powerful Lokpal. It is going to be a long haul.
    In the meanwhile the doormat PM of our country , as expected goes about his busines unconcerned , oblivious to what is happening around him.

    [Reply]

  • http://twitter.com/AnilAarush ANIL KUMAR

    full of $hit this article is farmer still pays the same pittance middlemen most of them politicians crony corner all the profits. I would knowbeing a farmer’s son. Don;t give us nonsensical defence of congressi loot plunder inefficiency and corruption

    [Reply]

  • Ramesh Talwani

    PAWAR DESERVES BETTER THAN BEING SLAPPED.
    AFTER ALL ONLY POLITICIANS HAVE A RIGHT TO HIT PEOPLE. EVEN INNOCENT PROTESTERS.
    SUNITA WAS SLEEPING WHEN TWO BRAVE CENTRAL MINISTERS ALONG WITH PRAMOD TEWARI AND POLICE WERE HITTING ,KICKING A PERSON SHOWING BLACK FLAG ONLY .WHY SUNITA REMAINED SILENT IS KNOWN TO ALL ON THAT ISSUE. WHY THOSE MINISTERS ARE ROAMING FREE.
    THAT REMINDS ME THAT FAMOUS LINE “IN DEMOCRACY ALL ARE EQUAL,SOME ARE MORE EQUAL THAN OTHERS.”
    PAWAR HAS A VERY COWARDLY PAST.
    PARLIAMENT DISCUSSING THIS INCUDENT AND WASTING TIME IS HIGHLY REGRETTABLE.

    [Reply]

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RWNSJVQAYN63ND4LSNRYTMY6PU Injun Joe

    “Thus, I learnt to school my expressions in preparation for unpleasant surprises in various situations but I also learnt that if someone fell off a stair or even farted, you didn’t laugh and you didn’t even hold your nose. You bore up with the unpleasant smell for the few seconds ”
    You must have smelt quite a lot many farts while growing up. Just saying…..

    [Reply]

  • Abu Ahmed

    Throwing a boot at George Bush and missing him was a great form of offensive protest – the boot-thrower achieved the intended results without physically hitting the target. Hurling a boot at George Bush in itself generated more sympathy for Iraq’s cause worldwide than it would have had the boot hit its target. Harvinder, being crass, missed this fine point – throw a shoe, slipper, chappal or even a punch – BUT NEVER HIT THE TARGET. For as soon as the protester hits his/her target, he/she misses the goal of achieving unadulterated, undivided and wholesome sympathy and attention for his/her cause. Pawar is a very senior politician who commands great respect; also he is cancer-sticken and that demands care definitely – slapping Pawar had only belittled Harvinder and had completely defeated his cause.

    [Reply]

  • Abu Ahmed

    Agree fully with your viewpoint. Furthermore, advancement in science and technology dictates changes in the markets too. Apart from the old land line telephones, today we have the mobile and all those 2Gs and 3Gs and what have you in the market coming up. Nobody can turn back the wheel of scientific & technological advancement back, which would definitely reflect in changes at the market level too, whether retail or manufacturing. Millions of people use the aeroplane in India – did it replace the bullock-cart still in use in our villages? Middlemen of the retail sector would find other jobs to meddle in – like we have the travel agents for the airlines – and the bullock-cart and the bull sellers’ agents existing in our country – all in the same economy, enjoying their own margins of profit. the opposition is merely political manipulation more than any real fear of the unknown.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    That is what the existence of Government is all about. It has the machinery which does not work. The government is meant to provide governance, so that the system functions.

    [Reply]

  • arshi

    Touching tribute. Your mother would surely be smiling back in heaven.
    Down on earth, we could only hope to bring in professionalism in
    government departments, especially related with health. Are those in
    business of making manifesto reading?

    [Reply]

  • Ramesh Kumar

    I NEVER REALIZED SUCH A LAW EXIST.THE POLITICIANS OR ANY INDIVIDUAL WHO SELL THEMSELVES FOR LITTLE OR HEFTY SUMS ARE GLORIFIED BEGGARS OR EXTORTINIST.. AFTER ALL TO GET SOMETHING ,YOU HAVE TO SPREAD YOUR PALM.THE GIVER COULD BE ANYONE.
    BEGGING IS HIGHLY ORGANIZED PROFESSION,LIKE ANYOTHER.
    I HAVE NOT COME ACCROSS ANY SCRIPTURE ,I AM REFERRING TO VEDAS ,WHERE BEGGING IS TALKED.THERE IS DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OFFERING AND GIVING ALM.
    WRITER MAY COMMENT PLEASE.

    [Reply]

  • fairworldwide

    Malala Yusufzai deserves sympathy for her suffering like other girls who suffer just like her or even more in FATA. Behind all this hype, she is a propped up leader created by a power hungry father out of an ordinary girl whose sole merit is her looks. The statement “Malala Yusufzai symbolizes Pakistan” is a metaphor. She symbolizes the lies, deception, hypocrisy, and duplicity of Pakistan. Her father possesses the Pakistani skill to dupe the world and reap benefits for his daughter through parroted instructions, while secluding his wife, like any fanatic Muslim. Pakistani government manipulates this incident to cover up all their evil activities and bask on reflected sympathy. They succeeded in making the world forget that they are protecting the terrorists as a state policy. Propping up a leader out of an ordinary girl lacking much virtues; by money and influence is a deplorable precedence. There are plenty of children all over the world with more virtues than Malala Yusufsai. The hype attributed to her is an injustice to many deserving children manifesting more kindness, compassion and selfless motivation. Please look at the video clip youtube.com/watch?v=9F5yeW6XFZk and reason out whether this girl have virtues, to justify the accolades being bestowed up on her.

    [Reply]

    aswathy Reply:

    Her cruelty to her so called pet reveals her mean mentality. Her father demanding fees from parents when the whole place is war ravaged shows his merciless nature. good video. dont know why people praise them. she is a mean girl to demand ice cream in such times.

    [Reply]

    Iac Thiruvananthapuram Reply:

    The way she shouted “valley valley swat valley” is as mechanical and insincere as Chaprasi Singh or Sonia reading a speech. That courageous girl who tried screening Malala with her bare hand and severely damaged her hand deserves a thousand times more appreciation than this propped up leader.

    [Reply]

    Faulitics Reply:

    Dude, Taliban are real and they are fanatical murderers. It needs courage to openly say things against them. This girl has a lot of courage. I would go as far as saying that this Pakistani girl has more balls than all the Pakistani males put together.

    [Reply]

  • shimr choudhary

    hindus are bunch of idiots their minds are closed.victims of brhmnst/zoinist propaganda machinary.least knowledged english speaking gang of idiots.live on propaganda,pass their life on hoarding and stealing.

    [Reply]

    Faulitics Reply:

    Here comes another arabized idiot. There are just too many of these types for comfort.

    [Reply]

  • REX

    for 6 years sared hindu zoinists were planting the bombs and muslims were blamed and cursed.at the end they are cught and and imprisoned.SAME WAY ATTACKERS OF MALAL ARE ZOINISTS NOT TALIBANIS.TRUTH WIL COME OUT SOON

    [Reply]

  • vijay !

    I have only heard of malala from newsreports.

    She could be a symbol of hope of the hapless tortured woman of Pakistan and Afghanistan. The voice agaisnt the hopeless Sharia and the geder unequal Muslim personal law.

    I hope she comes out of the injury and takes on the mad fanatic Mullahas who want to convert the world and repress women into medieval ages.

    [Reply]

  • Faulitics

    What’s positive about a bunch of fanatics preventing girls from going to school and blowing up girls schools? Do you want such people where you live? Your brain seemed to be wired differently. Strange one.

    [Reply]