Is Pak Foreign Office run from Rawalpindi?



I really wonder on whose advice ISI chief Ahmed Shuja Pasha would have cancelled his trip to the United Kingdom? His reporting line is to the Army Chief, Gen Asfaq Pervez Kayani, not the civilian set-up headed by Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani.Pakistan’s democratically elected regime had tamely let the arrangement be when the Army blocked its July 2008 move to place the agency under the Ministry of Interior.

Pasha’s trip to the UK was to discuss cooperation in fighting terror. The fact that the head of the dreaded spy outfit will stay home rather than keep his appointments with British counterparts is conclusive evidence of the Army’s decisive role in key foreign policy issues.

Cameron has stood his ground in the face of the Pakistani reaction that had its High Commissioner to UK, Wajid Shamsul Hasan terming his comments as “immature reaction from an immature politician.” The Pak envoy’s brazenly personal attack on the British Premier reminds one of the adage that war’s too serious a business to be left to the generals.

But can Rawalpindi (seat of Pakistan Army) sustain the coercive diplomacy it has foisted on Islamabad? The last word on the prickly face-off is yet to be heard as Asif Ali Zardari’s scheduled visit to the UK is still on. It will be interesting to see whether the Pak President will use the kind of language his country’s envoy employed against Cameron?

Shamshul Hasan’s idiom was reminiscent of Shah Mahmood Qureshi’s broadsides against S M Krishna. Scriptwriters who penned their pieces seemed more adapt at intimidating (which is a fauji’s forte) than at communicating (which is a diplomat’s trait). Both instances were proof, if there was a need for one, of civilian leaders playing second fiddle to army bosses.

The Pak Army’s strident reaction to Cameron’s perfectly legitimate concerns cannot but have its genesis in the Wikileaks’ expose of its two-timing tactics in the Afghan war. Rather than being on the defensive, it has chosen to brazen out international outrage over thousands of war documents now in pubic domain. In that limited sense, Gen. Kayani has drawn a leaf out of the Chinese book that often saw Beijing lock horns with Washington.

Like the Chinese market eyed by US multinationals, Rawalpindi is leveraging its frontline status in the war on terror to pursue its agenda of turning Afghanistan into a client state. Wikileaks’ Afghan diary is a wake up call for the Americans, the Brits and other NATO allies. If ISI could be that pernicious under their very nose, what’ll happen when they turn their backs on Afghanistan?

Cameron read the writing on the wall rather aloud to the world. The ISI may want to run away from the truth. But the questions it’s ducking will have to be faced— sooner than later.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (15 votes, average: 4.33 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • S Singh

    Man, get a life. Why are you so obsessed with the wormy Pakistan? You pick up a mole and make a mountain..You bring Pakistan to relevance ..to the community of nations..Ignore them man

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    He is not alone Singh, your whole cuntry is obsessed. ISI has and is doing a great job. Sardarji you have become irrelivent after the beating the hindu’s gave you guys in the 80’s. Mar Mar key ser narum ker diya hey sardarji.

    [Reply]

    S. Singh Reply:

    @Azhar

    It just shows that you Pakistanis cannot view anything other than through the prism of religion. Sikhs were attacked by congressmen (belonging to all religions, Hindus being the largest because Hindus being the laergest religion); not Hindus.

    So, whom do you think Man Mohan Singh is? or AJP Abdul Kalam? Or Mrs Sonia Gandhi (she i not even born in India)? Or Ak Antony? (or one of his predecessor George Fernandez)?
    Or AR Antulay?

    Get a life Azhar. Give a lifeboat to your people. There is no reason why Pakistanis should not eb as good as Indians/ we are all from the ame stock. Get your army out of your administration.

    [Reply]

    Pakistani Reply:

    ofcourse it is… if it wasnt for the ISI our so called leaders wouldve sold the entire country and moved to England already… ofcourse our president wouldve taken 10%… revolution is comming.. behold.. !

    Shah Alam Khan Reply:

    Dear Vinod Sahib,
    As expected, your analysis is spot on. Having said this let me remind you, that the origin of some of the so called democratically elected elements of present Pakistani establishment. I presume Gilani was part of Zia-ul-Haq’a Majlis-e-Shoora (correct me if I am wrong). Most of the present members of their assembly are feudal lords, businessman who are connected in one or more ways to the coercive Zia regime (in all honesty under Zia there were limited choices- either you are with him or you are against; and we know what happened to those who were against! ). Do we really expect them to follow the spirit of democratic principles when it comes to rational thinking vis a vis institutions like the ISI? I presume the common Pakistani (not those who live in the US and are more patriotic than their in-house lot as shown by comments on this blog) is too effete to get out of the tangle of the army-political nexus, where the army is always the active partner. I won’t be wrong if I say that Pakistan has a controlled democracy (although there is no dearth of sane voices from within who oppose this association). ISI is essential for the army to run the country “appropriately”.
    As for the Afghan war leaks, you are right in pointing out that Pakistan wants to present Afghanistan as a client state in the war against terror and the situation suites Uncle Sam. I only hope that the foreign office in New Delhi limits our interference in Afghanistan on a more logical (read economic) basis. Any experimenting in a region as volatile and as unstable as Afghanistan can endanger our own security….we surely don’t want the nation to be bled white by a group of drolly dressed mullahs carrying a rocket launchers on their shoulders!
    Truly,
    Dr. Shah Alam Khan
    AIIMS, New Delhi
    Blog: http://www.indiaandbharat.blogspot.com

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    Dear Dr Khan,
    I agree with you broadly sir. But let us not assess the civilian leadership on the basis of its past. Nawaz Sharif began as a child of the establishment but grew up to challenge it like nobody before him. He even opposed the extension given to Kayani as Army chief.

    Paul Reply:

    Azhar, remember Hindus and Sikhs are brothers. Sikhs were created by hindus by giving the eldest son to create Sikhs. My mother was a sikh and I am proud of my heritage. In India hindus do not go killing hindus. Whereas in Pakistan, sunni’s are killing shia every day. No body even
    condemns it. What a shame. India can never forgive what happened in 1984 at the hands of the few. We are ashmed of it.
    Now coming back to ISI. The sad think is that ISI reports to the Military and not to the
    civilian government. Civilian Government is non entity any way. Prime Minister had to extend the
    term of Kyani by 3 years. If it was not extended, the general would have taken control of the
    Government and kicked Gilani and Zardari out. Good luck Pakistan. I wish Pakistanis start realizing as to what is wrong with their thinking so that things can be set right. If you do not the problem, you can never find the solution.

    [Reply]

    Jeff Reply:

    Paul, what have you learned from 1984, did you apply that in Gujrat, or Mumbai, or Ayodiah, or Kashmir? You should be ashamed of not just killing your fellow indian muslims but practicing caste aparthied as part of your religion and social fabric. Before you look to throw a rock at Pakistan, have a look at yourself and the glass house you live in. In Pakistan, we have our religious nuts that go around killing innocent people but at least that is a accepted part of our culture. As for ISI, I laugh whenever I hear indians calling Pakisan a failed state and in the next breath blaming ISI for every ill in their country and now in the whole world. Listening to Indians, one would think ISI has all James Bond 007 working for them. Man, I really wish ISI is as efficient as you all, and the idiot GW Bush clone Brit PM Cameron seems to believe. Now if the Brit Idiot PM will essentially blame ISI for double dealing, why would the ISI chief show up at the Brits house of innuendo? To get more insults? This writer is emotionally biased to not see a simpler explanation of why ISI cheif just piss*d off on Brits and instead is making a mountain out of a mole as sardar ji said (except he said it under the superiority complex of india so much better than Pakistan – LOL). Indians are emotional people, lots to like about them too but many of them are just idiots like Paul and Sardar Ji.

    PD Reply:

    Well said, Paul. Thanks.
    I think exactly the same way as you do, you really read my mind.
    PD

    ahmed Reply:

    Well, i do agree with sardar ji that indians are obsessed with Pakistan. Maybe it is some sort of collective inferiority complex on the part of india.

    Just compare a pakistani newspaper with an indian newspaper. Indian newspaper carry at least one headline concerning Pakistan or the ISI every day, on the other hand a Pakistani newspaper rarely even mentions India.

    Running of Pakistan’s military and ISI is an internal matter and why should ISI be answerable to the president when its a military organization. There are other civilian outfits like the FIA which are responsible for collecting intelligence for the prime minister. Theirs another problem in Pakistan which is, that Kayani and the pak army are immensely popular in Pakistan where as Zardari and Gillani are hugely unpopular.

    And indians should stop reading too much into this democracy/dicatatorship debate. India has a poverty of around 42% (UNDP figures) compared to Pakistan’s poverty of 17% (UNDP figures). After 60 years, Pakistan’s dictatorships have delivered more compared to India’s democracies.

    Mukesh Reply:

    Azhar, what do you mean by obsessed, who the heck is obsessed here. Why does Pakis have so many militant training camp and why Pakis government always helping militants in creating trouble inside Inida.
    And what are you trying to say by 1984 riots, it was insane act done by few who are getting the right punishment by judicial system here. This might sound alien to you because in your country justice to minority is never even heard of.

    [Reply]

    Legionnaire Reply:

    Seems Pakistanies have not learnt lesson of 1971. Just wait and watch another partition of Pakistan is on cards.

    [Reply]

    Web Friend Reply:

    Man have some self-respect especially when you come begging to play in IPL :-)

    You can’t protect a visiting cricket team, no country wants to visit you and your cricket board is entirely dependent on India for its survival :-)

    You hate India but are the first ones to play in IPL and even come begging to us.

    The world cup in 2011 is taken away from which is like a slap on every Pakistani’s face :-) Does anyone in Pakistan has any shame left?

    Your own so-called brothers from Bangladesh sided with India when it came to the issue of shifting the world cup.

    What a great nation – Pakistan!! nothing but a dustbin!! lol

    [Reply]

    Jeeta Reply:

    Your habit of seeing everything through the prism of religion has got you in the gutter in which you are lying today. We look at human as a human being irrespective of his religion. I belive amongst all the religions Islam is most backward, barbaric and intolerant and is responsible for turmoil in the world. and Your country (?)is a prime example.

    [Reply]

    Lalit K Jha Reply:

    Pakistan’s begging capacity is kabil-e-taarif but as long as you obey uncle sam they will keep giving and you can stay alive on their leftover.. the day uncle sam thinks that you are liability, you won’t be on the map.

    [Reply]

    DF Reply:

    Azar, Truth hurts. The shit has hit the Pakis blank on the face. Landyaji you and your country has become irrelevant beggars that your Pakistan is, you’ll still cannot fathom out that you are living on coins thrown in your begging bowl without it your country will be bankrupt. Gir gaya phir bhi taang upaar. It was your own terrorist Pakistan that supported Khalistan, now that things are not going your **** ways you blame the Hindus. You and your terrorist nation Porkistan are only fit for inciting violence just as your terrorist nation is doing in Kashmir right now. Sooner that later the US will be forced to designate your nation as a state sponsorer of terrorism the writing is on the wall. Just to prove a point our Prime Minister is a great Sikh and every Indian is proud of him. We have no problems between our Sikh brothers, your country incites problems. If the ISI is doing a great job howcome the whole world is clearly pointing a finger to your terrorist shit hole Pakistan.

    [Reply]

    Prudent Injeeli Reply:

    There they go again, something to protest against; the dreadful bearded 4000 year BC, wild looking baboon like creatures on the streets of Pakistan, again showing to the world how unreasonable, fanatic and mentally twisted , warped and retarded they are. “Zardari must cancel his visit to the UK”, is what they are demanding. How hilarious, I thought there was nothing left under the sun to laugh at. But here we have it again. The opposition leader Mian Nawaz Sharif has said, if Zardari went to the UK, it will be a disgrace and humiliation of the whole nation. Disgrace and humiliation? Please tell me Mia Sahib, where is there “grace” and “honor “in the land of the pure. How often do you (Mian Sahib) visit the UK? Or have you now given up the idea of ever going there again to safeguard your country’s honor and “ghairat”? And now listen to this joke of the millennium, the MQM chief, who is enjoying all the benefits of the UK luxuries life for years , has made a towering remark, by saying that, President Zardari must not visit the UK ,as it is against the national “honor”. So, the beggars do have an ego. Interestingly, UK has been the home of this “great” Pakistani leader who dares not returning to the “holy land” for the fear of facing numerous cases registered against him. What a leadership and what patriotism! I wonder why the “civil” society of Pakistan has not called for the Pakistan cricket team’s immediate return after Mr. Cameron’s remarks. Why haven’t they boycotted rest of matches of the series? They better had, as things are looking quite bleak there for them anyway. The UK had kindly offered their country venues to the Pakistanis to come and play their “home series” in the UK, this is what they get back, and effigies of their PM are being burnt in the streets of the land of the pure. The truth of the remarks that the British PM has made, is no secret to the world after the revelations made by the wiki-leaks, but there is no cure for obstinacy and obduracy, and worst of all a death wish to continue to wallow in one’s miseries and stupidities. The trouble again is not with Pakistan, but their patron, the mighty Americans, whose hand they bite, yet who keep feeding them, under the notion that Pakistan is an “ally” in the war against terrorism. “How dumb of the Americans, even to imagine Pakistan as an ally in the war against terrorism. No doubt, they are making a “wonderful “progress in “winning” this war. Continue they may for a thousand more years; they will not win this war, as long as they have Pakistan a their “ally”. On one hand they are fighting terrorism on the other hand they feeding the terrorists. Can anyone please help me to understand this, are the Americans really so dumb, or they just pretend, for the fun of it. Anyway, God bless America!

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    @Ats
    It will be interesting to see what transpires at Zardari’s meeting with Cameron

    Raja Reply:

    Are Azhar ji,

    Maar to Pakistan ko ek Sardarji ki leadership ne lagaayi thi; aur itni maar lagaayi thi ki 95000 Pakistani faujiyon te tauba tauba bol kar 1971 december mein ghutne tek diye the.
    Aur ab wohi fauj phir gurra rahi hai – bechare Afghanistan par! Pew research ke survey ne yeh bhi pata lagaya hai ki abhi bhi 84% Pakistani Punjabi aur 74% Pakistan Hindu stan se darte hain. Isay kahte hain maar padna.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    Its good to see, more people wake up to the truth that Pakistan is run by Pak army and ISI.

    The UN report on Benazir assasination, laid out how the country is held hostage by ISI.

    The three-member panel, which was headed by Chilean Ambassador to UN Heraldo Muñoz and included Marzuki Darusman, former attorney-general of Indonesia, and Peter Fitzgerald, a veteran official of the Irish National Police, had this to say about Pak establishment.

    This is what the UN report stated as per report in NY Times.
    w ww.nytimes.com/2010/04/17/world/asia/17bhutto.html

    “The report stated in black and white what Pakistanis sometimes have to whisper: that a nexus of elites, known as the establishment, whose core is formed by top military and intelligence officers but also includes politicians and bureaucrats, has busied itself with everything from rigging elections to making deals with militants. ”

    The report details how the police was scared to investigate the murder , fearing that Pak ISI was involved!

    Pak is a throughly criminal entity, which is made more venal by the free flow of Western aid into it.

    [Reply]

    hussein Reply:

    It’s ISI that’s keeping Pak safe from Indian and US hypocrisy. If it wasnt for ISI, india/us would have over run Pak long time ago.. and ofcourse nukes are there to deter you guys.

    Go ISI, Go Pak

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    .Vinodji,

    You have rightly pointed out that the ISi has come out in the open and now challenging the world that it will pursue its agenda come what may.

    Don’t you think that the West has leverage through its aid packages to armtwist pakistan.

    Further on, I talked to a few Chinese friends and they too are genuinly worried that a new rogue state, which shows it nuclear blackmail to enforce its terroristic designs is coming out in the open.

    Under these circumstances, do you feel that they new idea floating on the net that the West may balkanize Pakistan just to attain a balance of terror among its states, may happen?

    I look forward to hearing from you,

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    Vijay kumar the west is running from the region after receiving a beating in Afghnistan, just like your cuntries father in law USSR received prior to this war.

    [Reply]

    MM Reply:

    Azhar, I am not sure whether you are from ISI or is one of the common men. Pakistan common public wants army and ISI to be out of Pakistan and wants corruption free politicians and democracy. Unfortunately Pak has none of them. I am looking for uprising from people of Pakistan when they show the army there place and send them to barrack. Which is their rightful and proper place.

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    And most of us Pakistanis agree to your statement. But on the other side ISI is very important institution of Pakistan and they are a very strong line defence against the enimies of Pakistan.

    sathish Reply:

    pakis in usa do not want to admit that they are from pak. instead they claim to be indians.. shame on you and your country

    Paul Reply:

    If this really happens. It will be a sad day for Pakistan. Pakistan lost Bangladesh, Musharaff cried
    that day. If Taliban succeed in Afganistan, Pakistan is not too far. Pakistan will be living in the last millenium. It will break in many little fiefdoms. Shias would certainly want a separate state.
    India may help them again. I hope that day never comes.

    [Reply]

    DF Reply:

    Yes the West is run by a bunch of idiots that beleived back stabbers Pakistan. Remember the phrase “Hunting with the hound and running with the hare” . How long will your terrorist state Pakistan go on, where and whom will you’ll beg to. Your beggar country will spit in the plate that feeds it. What a bunch of loosers the people of Pakistan can be, it glorifies those that support terrorism. Well thats part of your terrorist mentality. Don’t count on the west to leave Afghanistan yet the game is not yet over. Maybe it is a new beginning now that the Wiki leaks have occured. The fun starts now. Enjoy the show.

    [Reply]

    ahmed Reply:

    Balkanize?

    currently the only insurgency hit area in Pakistan is Waziristan which is approximately 2% of pakistan’s landmass and less than 1% of the population. Sindh is peaceful, so is karachi apart from the pathan and mqm ethnic violence in a few slums, punjab is largely happy, NWFP and Hazara are quite satisfied, most of the talibans in the tribal areas which were never governed by Pakistan have been kicked out, northern areas and kashmir are also satisfied. I wonder how they can build on the 2% to balkanize pakistan, especially when NATO is running out of money, and completely dependent on Pakistan for supplies and intelligence.

    Let’s compare Pakistan with India. 30% of india is run by naxals, Kashmir is under curfew, sikhs can easily be coerced into becoming separtist, Assam and north east is almost out of control. Go figure, which is the better candidate for balkanization.

    Just to add to that thought, almost 42% of indians live under $1.25 (UNDP) compared to 17% in Pakistan. You can easily find more desperate people in india to accomplish balkanization for a few bucks.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    ‘Is Pak foreign office run from Rawalpindi’ ?

    The answer is known by all, so its a rhetorical question.

    ( Meanwhile, a country that is bombed regularly by drones from a different country is not even an independent , soverign country like Bhutan or Nepal or Haiti .

    Its just a temporary entity, 1/2 of which is already gone and th other 1/2 tottering on the brink. )

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    Just today, 8 unarmed Kashmiris has been martyred from Indian secuirty forces for the cause of Independece. This will be a matter of time when Kashmiris will get Independence from a country where 2 dozens of bloody separatist movements going on that will ultimately break India into small pieces.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Our forces are incompetent..They should have shot 800 traitors and sent their bodies to pakistan in pig-skin.

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    Sal I am glade these monkeys don’t see it that way. They are too obsessed with Pakistan, and by defination obsession is either you are madly in love or you are too scared. I think you know it is the later. ISI is doing a great job.

    They are scared that uncle Sam and NATO forces are getting a beating in Afghnistan, and undia is about to become irrelevent as far as Afghanistan is concerned.

    [Reply]

    gaurav Reply:

    Pak is altogether in bagging with big katora. zardari is always making trip to get money to eat for his family and country.. and when he gets money kayani takes all his money and leave his country man sleeping hungry.. so naturally azhar is one of hungry country man of pakistan whose roti is robbed by kayani and ISI and thats why he is crying foul for america , europe. ask yourself azhar if other countries are not there today there will be big hording “Pakistan for Sale” .. Good luck and wake up

    Legionnaire Reply:

    Its amazing isn’t it that your so-called ’scared’ country ended up breaking Pakistan in 1971 :-)

    Pakistan Reply:

    @Azhar
    Bro you are waisting your precious time, reasons are accepted where the logic and better sense prevail, which is lacking in these poor urine drinkers and deadbody eaters aghories. He is stopping us from poligamy but its ok to drink cow piss and eat dead decaying human bodies, its OK to burn the churches, its ok to rast the innocent humans in ahmedabad, its ok to kill thousands of sikhs, its ok to burn their sacred places, its ok to burn the whole train, but still they are peace loving and darling of the world. Their narrow mindness, ego and enemocity has blinded them. Let them fly in high fantacies, the honey-moon will end at last. India is a baloon which is heated by west and US to fly high over china. let it land on some prick and you ‘ll see the result. Just wait and see, time will reveal alot. We are beggars, we dont have anything to eat nothing to wear everything is comming from west, …lolz as if in India they have zero debt, ppl eat gold not grain, rivers are overflowing with milk and honey, their cattle graze on golden grass, they wear gold embroided dhoties and the list goes on……

    iqbal Reply:

    Bugti ZIndabad,,,,

    Pakistan se Zinda bhaag !

    Vorshal Reply:

    I think the ISI Chief did the right thing by not going. What would he be doing and discussing after all his cover was blown, and the host nation, nay several countries hold an adverse opinion. It would have been shameful for him to face the authorities and the media! Who would share any secrets or details with people who live double life. Well done, stay at home and plan for flood relief!!

    Jai Vaidya Reply:

    Dr. Shahid, I just watched the video of your lecture in Nebraska. I must say that as a Hindu and an Indian I disagree with a lot of your analysis. Let me start from the top.

    1. Aryan invasion theory is very discredited..

    2.Taxila and Nalanda were destroyed by Muslims.

    3. Sikhs, Marathas, Rajputs had liberated themselves before the British had arrived.

    4. No Pakistani believes that NWFP voted in a referendum top be with India.
    5. Direct action days , by any other name was jihad.

    6. If the Gurdaspur principle is to be applied why is Khoprapur and Munnabao in Pakistan?

    7. India stopped transfer of asssets because Pakistan invaded Kashmir.

    8. The ‘71 war was a two-front war. India had to fight West Pakistan as well as Bangladesh.

    9. The source of the Indus River is not in India. It is in Tibet.

    10. What happened to the 15% Hindu-Sikh population of West Punjab after Partition?

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay

    You have a full right to disagree but let me tell you I disgree too with the points you made.

    1) “Aryan invasion theory is very discredited.. ..” Can you explain how this theory is discredited.

    2) Taxila has destoyed a long ago before arrival of muslims.

    3) “Sikhs, Marathas, Rajputs had liberated themselves before the British had arrived.”…What does it proof. Anyways delhi was in hands of Moguls till 1857 and Aurangzeb died in 1707. So till 1707, muslims were ruling big part of India and after the death of Aurangzeb, Mogul Empire started decline.

    4) NWFP joined Pak through referendum. Every province of Pak has joined Pak through referendum/Jirga. Dont give me any conspiracy theory.

    5) “If the Gurdaspur principle is to be applied why is Khoprapur and Munnabao in Pakistan”….Gurdaspur cannot be compared with Munnabao and Khoprapur…How…Gurdaspur was in Punjab and Punjab was partioned according religous line and Gurdaspur should had been in Pak according to majority of muslims while Munabao is in Sindh and sindh didnt get partition.

    6) “India stopped transfer of asssets because Pakistan invaded Kashmir.” If that is true what you are saying..Still you dont have a right to stop transfer of money to Pak..Why..Becasue according to 3 June 1947 partition plan, 1/3 of assets had to be transfered to Pak and that money was Pak right.

    7)”. The source of the Indus River is not in India. It is in Tibet.” That is correct.

    8) “What happened to the 15% Hindu-Sikh population of West Punjab after Partition?” Wrong..This is incorrcet. Can you provide me any reliable source which says non-muslims were 15-20% of West Punjab at the year of 1950.

    As I told you..you have full right not to agree with me as I dont agree with you. And Why I dont agree with you..I explained earlier.

    Sal Reply:

    Err Correction

    5) Munnabao is in Rajhstan, India while Khoprapur is in Sind, Pakistan.

    PD Reply:

    It’s a matter of time you just wait and see Azhar Hussain — Pak’s ISI will be shreded in countless pieces by the Godly powers — and you’ll not be even able to collect it’s pieces.

    DF Reply:

    We are not obsessed with pakistan. Its your army chief Kayani that is obsessed with India, the guy cannot get a wink of sleep as he wants India out of Afghanistan and nobody is willing to tow his line. Guess what all the shops in Pakistan have run out of cigarettes, Mr. Kayani has doubled and trippled his smooking quota with the stress.

    Paul Reply:

    Good they were not pelting stones in Pakistan, 800 would have been sent to heaven.
    Look at what you are doing in NWFP. If America did not give you alms, you would be starving.
    You eat out the american hands and curse them too. This is you.

    [Reply]

    ahmed Reply:

    Well firstly, you pay us for a service and if you didn’t pay us, then there would be a lot more body bags arriving in america from afghanistan.

    Americans are just sissies who can’t fight their own wars and this is you. You just shit in your pants the moment you see a taliban fighter, this is you.

    DF Reply:

    With terrorist **** help and its terrorist ISI . Whats happening in Balochistan, and what about Pathanistan, Sindhustan etc. Don’t forget Bangladesh.

    [Reply]

    Concerned Human Reply:

    Mr Ramiz – Did you ever heard – What you sow so shall you reap – Pakistan & their countrymen are paying the price of their deeds – What goes around that comes arround – Whole world know over & over it has been proven any terrorist activity happen any where in the World, road always lead to Pakistan training centres. You & ISI, Pak Govt. can deny to satisfy their false ego, matter of fact speaks for itself.
    watch your PM/ Sherry Rehman & Gilani Viodeo on Face Book?Google she the realty of your own peoples capabilities. Show to your Mum/Dad & Your younger brother sister, do you have a guts.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    Even if Couple of stone throwing hooligans die in Kashmir, Pakistani start salivating.

    Well they have been salivating for last 60 years, as they have lost 1/2 the country and the remaining 1/2 tottering. Stone throwing Jihadi mobs are like small mosquitos, as far as the democratic, secular republic of India is concerned.

    Here is what is happening in Karachi today.

    1. Karachi in flames,
    2. 27 Karachi citizens, brutally murdered. Mostly Pushtun people as buses set ablaze all over the city…

    From BBC ..
    http://ww w.bbc.co.uk/news/world-south-asia-10843123
    Raza Haider, of the MQM political party, was gunned down with his guard as he attended a funeral near the centre of Pakistan’s business capital.

    The killing triggered violence in which at least 27 people were killed and more than 100 wounded, officials say.”

    I am not talking about Waziristan or Swat, where Pak claims to kill 20-20 Pakistanis every day !!!!!!!!

    This is Karachi, financial capital of Pak-land, where two communities – MQM and Pushtun(ANP) are fighting a war !!

    And here, while Pak burns, foolish Pakistani are salivating at few hooligans killed as they attacj security forces in Jihadi anger.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    As usual a lier comes with his lies…

    8 civilians get killed for Indepndence, not couple, today. And these 8 peopple adds up to the list of more than 2 dozens civilians who get killed alone in this week for Independence in Valley. Remember..they are unarmed and I wish ISI will give them AK47.

    Leave Karachi…There is not a independence movement going on in Karachi where a police station gets burnt..There is a political rivalry going on in a city of more than 2 millions where different ethinic communities lives and moreover news of ” 27 people get killed cannot be verified” to this date from different sources other than bbc which didnt tell the source of their news.

    You people are really pathetic…Does anyone talks abt the situation in Assam, or Bihar or UP here ….

    The Kashmir will definitely get Independence from Indian occupation. Yes..I am talking abt Indian Kashmir which is less than half of the total Kashmir.

    [Reply]

    BigApple99 Reply:

    Yes the **** bureucracy and the military are long known as bedfellows.Forget Gilani,Qureshi and Mr 10 percent. The **** will attempt to do all to have and keep Kashmir burning. India had to by habit may be Vajpayee,Indira,Rajiv or that no so great Nehroo tolerated these crooks across for too long. One hit on the head of this scoundrel the **** Army is what one wants. I hardly have any connection with India or **** for that matter, but we have lost thousands of ISAF to these Unworthy B****rds in Afghan. **** wants to keep Afghan tied to their apron strings forgetting that they are getting disintegrated very soon. A deal where China will take half of POK and give the rest to India. Does these crooks in the Khaki know? The present Pak will be two independent countries esp. Baloch and NWFP. Sindh is going India way, so is Punjab. Enough is enough. **** sympathisers in USA and world over have been sounding this as they are tired with the mechanism which is presently stifling them and the Military and Bureau havinf the cake and eat it too. This credit shall primarily and undoubtedly go to the ISI the **** Army coming second.

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    “until you stop polygamie, degrading women and childrens life” says Indian rocket scientist ghallughara. Look at your ugly face and stop the —-

    Child prostitution in India
    – By Sarika Misha

    I. Introduction
    Child labour is not a new phenomenon. It has existed in one form or the other in all historical periods. What is new, however, it its perception as a social problem and its being a matter of social concern.

    In older days the child was viewed with a tender feeling and treated with warmth, mercy, and compassion. But the fund of knowledge about the psychophysical needs and the environmental influence impinging on his growth and development was rather meager. The mechanics and dynamics of child development were not adequately and scientifically understood. Today on scientific grounds it can be asserted that work as a direct fulfilment of child’s natural abilities and creative potentialities is always conducive to healthy growth but work when taken up as a means for fulfilment of some other needs becomes enslaving in character of a social problem in as much as it hinders, arrests, or distorts the natural growth processes and prevents the child from attaining full blown personality.

    The lions share of the value generated by it is appropriated by some one else and the child is left with a fraction that can not meet comfortably even the survival needs.

    Child labour is thus defined as work performed by children that either endangers their health or safety, interferes with or prevents education or keeps them from play and other activity important to their development. Child labour of this kind is considered a social evil.

    The problem of child labour is a multi-dimensional one as the children from a large segment of the total population. Child prostitution involving both boys and girls is very common today but female child prostitution is more common than male child prostitution.

    Termed as the oldest profession, prostitution has become an integral part of ‘all sorts’ that make the world. Women who resort to this rarely get a sympathetic word from the society and their life is wasted away selling momentary pleasures for a meal and existence in cubby holes called ‘cages’. If their plight is pathetic, worse still is that of the child prostitutes.

    Today there is existence of ‘kid porn’ where children and not adults are chosen for sexual exploitation.

    Ironically child prostitution is a special category of rigorous case of child labour and it raises more troubling ethical problems than child labour in general.

    II. Extent
    Many surveys have been conducted to find out the extent of child prostitution. Dr. Gilada’s paper on perspectives and positional problems of social intervention” shows that,
    “70% of women are forced into prostitution and 20% of these are child prostitutes.”

    Statistics of the survey done show:-

    City Population Prostitute Population

    Bombay 10 million 100,000

    Calcutta 9 million 100,000

    Delhi 7 million 40,000

    Agra 3 million 40,000

    A survey conducted by Indian Health Organization of a red light area of Bombay shows:-

    1. 20% of the one lakh prostitutes are children.
    2. 25% of the child prostitutes had been abducted and sold.
    3. 6% had been raped and sold.
    4. 8% had been sold by their fathers after forcing them into incestuous relationships.
    5. 2 lakh minor girls between ages 9yrs-20yrs were brought every year from Nepal to India and 20,000 of them are in Bombay brothels.
    6. 15% to 18% are adolescents between 13 yrs and 18 yrs.
    7. 15% of the women in prostitution have been sold by their husbands
    8. Of 200m suffering from sexually transmitted diseases in the world 50m alone were in India.
    9. 15% of them are devdasis.

    III. Cases
    There are several causes of child prostitution but some of the most important ones are as follows:

    1. Devdasi system:- many of the devdasis are the girls who were dedicated to the Goddess Yellamma by their parents at a very young age. They are the servants of God as they are married to the Goddess. This ceremony takes place twice a year. The main one is during the second fortnight of January at Karnatakas Saudatti village in South West of Miraj. Once the girl is married to a Goddess she cannot marry a mortal.

    The procurers frequent the place inorder to get the fresh supplies of girls as 4000 to 5000 girls are dedicated every year to the Goddess.

    Attaining puberty is a secondary thing as there is a ceremony known as heath Lawni (or touching ceremony) whereby the girl is made over to the highest bidder.

    A study revealed that one third, of which three fourth are under fourteen years, are in Bombay’s cheapest brothels. They belong to the low castes like Mahars, Matangs, etc. who give low priority to education. They are so poverty stricken that Fathers, brothers and husbands do not hesitate to sell their daughters, sisters and wives.

    Prevention of devdasis Act has been in the statute book since 1935 and amended recently but the system continues even today despite governmental ban, Still the girls are dedicated to the Goddess and forced into virtual prostitution and made to entertain males in order to invoke the blessings of the deity.

    It was estimated that in Delhi 50% of the prostitutes are devdasis and in Bombay, Pune, Solapur and Sangli. 15% of them are devdasis,

    (2) It is also noticed that young and old men prefer young and new girls.

    (3) Growing poverty, increasing urbanization, and industrialization, migration, and widespread unemployment, breaking up of joint family system etc. are also responsible for the prevalence and perpetuation of the child prostitution.

    (4) The influx of the affluent and not so affluent people from Gulf countries in India has boosted the flesh trade in cities like Bombay, Hyderabad etc. The parents are forced to part with their daughters for as little as 2 rupees tow two thousand in the fond hope that they would get two square meals in the moneyed new world.

    (5) Quick marriages without proper knowledge of the bridegroom’s family background leading to a divorce initiates the gravitation of girls to the red light area.

    (6) Another inaction is after rape. A fifteen years old girl was brought to Dr, Gildas Clinic as she was suffering from the symptoms of an STD she had been raped and sold by a self styled social worker. The poor girl was forced into silence by the threats of dire consequences.

    (7) The children are not lured into it but are thrust into it. There was a case of a sixteen years old girl who was sold to a brothel owner by her father following incest. 8% of these girls are victims of incest because of the myth-that one of the causes for an STD is intercourse with a virgin.

    (8) Many a times when a child who has lost both his parents is looked after by the relatives and these relatives too force the child into prostitution.

    (9) Child marriages are a common phenomenon even today and the bride is very much younger to the bridegroom so the husband drives the innocent wife into prostitution. There is a case where a girl of 13 was married off to a man of thrice her age three months later he abandoned her and married another girl. She returned to her poor parents and three months later a man promised her a good job and took her to Bombay from where he went and sold her to a middle aged woman at Kamatipura for rupees ten thousand and did not come back to take her.

    (10) Some of them are lured to Bombay the tinsel town. They dream of stellar roles in films and mostly end up as prostitutes in the cages.

    IV. Who are these girls, where then they procured from? How and why?
    Tribal Kolta women and girls from Garhwal hills are compelled to become prostitutes to rescue their family from debt bondage. Poverty stricken young girls from Bengal and Nepal are lured with promises of attractive jobs and marriage. The agents came to know about the existing condition in the areas of U. P. Tehri Garhwal. Dehradun etc. The local Rajputs used to keep the men as animals and exploit their wives, sisters and daughters too. The agents were successful in convincing these women well and hence brought them to Delhi and Agra and sold them to the brothels there.

    The phenomenon of commercialized trafficking of their girls found an easy acceptability among kollas as Nadeem Hasnain, an anthropologist researched the Socio-economic and cultural variables responsible for the bondage. In his book Bonded for ever (1982) says. “… Centuries of exploitation and extreme degrees of material and non material deprivation and the resultant wretchedness have taken the fight out of them and they can hardly resist the temptation of getting some hundred rupees even at the cost of selling their offsprings and wives. It is an economic battle for life”.

    Nearly 5000 teenagers and women in a Tehsil of sangli district in South Maharastra wait for the month of June when the Arabs come and the year long poverty and hunger of these women, children, and babies is dispelled over night. The flesh trade flourishes from June to September and makes all the people connected with it happy.

    In Rajashtan teenage prostitution is catching up as men sit and smoke hukkas while women fix bargains years after passing of the suppression of immoral traffic of women and children act. The children of the age group between 12 yrs to 20 yrs practice prostitution after school hours. Most of these children are later sold to the brothels of Agra and Delhi.

    In big cities women procures are on a lookout for girls and they get girls from Basti, Gonda, Gorakhpur, Shahjahanpur, which are particularly notorious areas. Trilokpur police said that in a period of a year one thousand girls were sold in Doomariyaganj tahsil alone.

    Nepal has a very large female population and majority of them are illiterate and are very gullible and can be lured under any pretext. They are very religious and succumb to the promises of being taken to temples in India. They are fair skinned and attractive and a promise to get them into films tempts them. There is widespread unemployment in Nepal and the girls are totally unexposed to the outer world.

    About 40% of these girls are habitual bidi smokers so a little bit of the soporific can be mixed in the cigarettes for e.g. Ganja, Charas before abducting them. The Govt. of Nepal plans to ban smoking for women for this reason. The procurers find new ways of abducting them. One of the ways is giving them the ‘magic paan’ (betel) which is cocaine mixed, as most of the girls are abdicts of paan and beedi fall an easy prey to the cocaine intoxication.

    Another bait is that of dowry which exists in reverse from in Nepal. A man can buy a bride and then he brings her to Bombay or anywhere and sells her at a brothel. Bombay seems to be an end of the rainbow when the daughters disappeared, the parents did not try to find out because they neither had the resources nor the ability to do so. They are assured that each girl can look after herself and if she does not reach so far. But when the girls started disappearing more frequently the rumours filtered back to the villages the neighbours were told that she was working in Bombay.

    The parents do not accept the girls back but the money they send to them 80% of the girls crossing the Indo-Nepal border fall victims to racketeers who include Government officials of the two countries.

    Girls are also brought from Karnataka, Rajasthan and Andhra Pradesh and are assaulted and raped till they submit to this shameful life.

    V. Conditions
    In the seamy and sordid world where each painted faced hides its own talk of abduction coercion an submission the ‘gharwali’ or the ‘madani’ rules by force and is helped by ‘Goondas’. The prostitute is deprived of her earnings till the price which was paid to buy her is procured. If she utters a word of dissatisfaction she is whipped. They are kept in sophisticated cages by their owners. The child prostitutes who are minors and virgins are kept under strict vigil in reserve as they are in great demand. The Arabs and Koreans are used to paying thousands for these girls. The girls are never lodged at the same place permanently and they are shifted occasionally to a dozen of brothels owned by the procuress of their own country to avoid familiarity with the customers or police detection.

    The procurer first rechristens the girl and the cautions them against revealing their real names and also disclosing there true addresses to the customers. Thereafter they are trained on the ethics of flesh trade never to turn away any customer, to treat all customers well equally courteously and superficially and never to discuss personal matters and keep themselves clean. They are also given one weekly holiday. The brothels where minor girls are kept, have two entries so as to escape during the sudden raids.

    The girls have to live in a really unhygenic condition with very little food. A dozen girls have to live in a 10 x 10 room and that too without any medical check ups. These girls are forced to work round the clock. They are excused only when they are physically very weak.

    Madams have quacks to treat them who dispense debilitating remedies and also use dangerous and unhygenic methods of abortion. The quacks inject coloured liquid in the infected areas as the treatment for various sexually transmitted diseases such as syphilis, scabies, venereal wart etc. making the children never totally cured thus extending their hold on them. The girls are seldom taken for treatment as sex with a minor girl is a crime so the madams are scared of the criminal proceedings.

    For decades the most important red light areas have been enjoying the police protection. The policemen themselves go to the brothels for tea snacks and girls. They inform the brothel keepers in advance about the raids which are scheduled to take place.

    The police, the brothel keeper, and pimps share the major part of the earnings of the prostitutes and the rest of it that percolates down to the prostitutes is a mere pittance. It is alleged that the police and abet the running of the brothels. They accept the hospitability, money and free use of the girls. The police helps the brothel keeper even by bringing back the ones who have run away. In a case where a girl named Geeta who was ten years old was rescued by a hawker after many attempts was returned back to the brothel keeper by the inspector himself on the same day.

    The escapes by the victims and recovery by the police are rare. The recoveries do not account for even 2% of the actual number of girls procured it different places.

    Child prostitution does not exists only in India but also in other parts of the world.

    “60 sex salves all from impoverished Dominican republic were found hidden in sealed containers unloaded at the port St. Thomas in U. S. Virgin Islands. 28 of these died and survivors were weak with no identity papers. They work for 18 hrs in a day and get only 20 dollars per client.”

    “Millions of third worlds young women and children are sold. Sexual slavery is becoming increasingly international and industrial incharacter”.

    An organization of Manila which exports girls had 18 girls between the ages of 10 yrs to 17 yrs ready to be exported with same sign tattooed on the right thigh.

    In Thailand child prostitution is relatively discrete and tolerated by police.

    VI. Effects
    Practice of child prostitution is economically unsound, psychologically disastrous, and morally dangerous and harmful on even and individual child. One can hardly imagine the extreme trauma that a child under goes. There is a case of a child prostitute who lost her speech after being raped by one who had hired her. She is now placed in a deaf mute school for speech recovery.

    The case of Tulsa a Nepali girl is more pathetic. Since the age of 13 she was sold and brought by many people and shifted from brothel to brothel and was forced by five to seven men every day. In this process she ended up with many diseases. She was taken to J. J. Hospital at Bombay. She was said to be suffering from meningitis, tuberculosis of brain, bone and chest and had an STD in advanced stage. The police took over sixteen months a file a charge sheet. Finally she was repatriated to Nepal. The culprits in the Himalayan. Kingdom were tried and imprisoned for 20 years.

    Child prostitutes become ready recruits for flesh trade for they are rendered unfit for any other trade or calling not being educated or having any knowledge of any other trade.

    Child prostitution itself is a criminal activity and serves as a catalyst for further criminal association in other fields. The helpless children are turned into mere pawns in the criminal syndicates which lead to a steady deterioration of morals.

    50m of the worlds 200m prostitutes who suffer from STD are in India and they are mostly found to be affected by tuberculosis, meningitis scabies, chronic pelvic injections anaemia, syphilis, chaneroid. Tineacrutis, vevercal war etc. This was the scars that the child prostitution leaves on the child prostitutes can not be erased but to a certain extent can be minimised by the medical help.

    VII. Law and child prostitution
    The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act passed by both houses of parliament last August come into force from Monday 26th January 1987.

    Under the amended act detention of a woman for purposes of prostitution is punishable with a minimum of seven years of imprisonment and maximum of life imprisonment Equally Stringent punishment will be awarded to those procuring children for prostitution.
    Earlier, the act was known as suppression of Immoral Traffic in Women and Girls Act (SITA). The name of the act has been changed and it has been made more effective and stringent. The definition of prostitute itself has been changed to include persons of both sexes. Earlier it included girls and women only. The amendment takes into account the growing menace of male prostitution especially that involving young boys.

    Under the new act there are three categories of victims-children, minors and majors. The children are those upto 16 years and minors are those between 16 to 18yrs and majors are those above 18 yrs. The earlier act recognized only women and girls – a women being one who has completed 21 years. Punishment for offences committed against these categories differ in severity Offences Committed against children and minors will be dealt with more severely than those against majors.

    The new act provides for the appointment of a special police officer for investigating offences with inter-state ramifications the women who are resended by the police during raids will be questioned only by women police officers and if none is available they can be interrogated only in the presence of a female representative of a recognised welfare institution or organisation. To make a search or conduct a raid too the police officer has to be accompanied by at least two police women.

    VIII. Rehabilitation
    Rehabilitation of the prostitutes is a big problem because people donate for different causes like handicapped people, blind etc but when it cames to helping these girls not many are willing. There is a stigma attached to this profession once rescued the girls are sent to the Remand houses or the protective houses which are overcrowded, mismanaged, without facilities or vocational training and living conditions threadbare. The Government gives an aid of just Rs. 75/- per girl per month. So the girl realises that the life before was better and so when the pimp comes to claim them as a brother or a sister she readily goes with him or her to the old life.

    IX. Conclusion
    Our society has not only turned a blind eye to minor girls being enticed into prostitution but also is directly responsible for the continuance in growth of child prostitution. First the demand for virgin prostitutes, and secondly it abets child prostitution by failing to provide adequate facilities for orphan and destitute children. Unless so called respectable sections of the society rise in revolt against exploitation the future of younger generation looks bleak. We have to forget the idea of once a prostitute for ever a prostitute and think how can a child help what has been done her by an unthinking adult? We have to overlook their past and rehabilitate them as one of the agencies in Bombay called Savadhan headed by Mr. Gupta is doing. They have got 30 of prostitutes who were rescued married to respectable people of the society. The IHO has been clamoring for women police to patrol red light area because policemen themselves exploit the inhabitant of the Red light area. The Government should divert more funds for rehabilitation and private charitable institutions should also contribute what we achieve in science and technology will be negated if we cannot protect our minor girls who are being exploited. The Government should severely punish the people connected with this inhuman practice should be totally banned for the good of the future citizens of our country.

    X. Bibliography
    1. Child Prostitution: SC notice to state 15th February 1984, Indian Express (Bombay).

    2. Forum against child prostitution formed 3rd August 1985, The Times of India (Bombay).

    3. Women in Bondage, Prashant Kumar, 11th November 1984, Sunday Observer.

    4. A doctors crusade against child Prostitution by Chaya Srivastava. 18th June1986, Deccan Herals (Bangalore)

    5. Rescue, Protect, Destroy: Sheela Barse, 10th February 1985, Statesman.

    6. Miraj’s monsoon harvest, Anand Agashe, 8th May 1986, Indian Express (Bombay).

    7. From Nepal without Love, Shashi Menon, 7th April 1985, Indian Express.

    8. Profile of sexually transmitted diseases in child prostitutes in the Red light areas of Bombay, V. R. Bhalerao.

    9. Courtesans in the house of God, 8th September 1985. Free Press Journal.

    10. Child Prostitution, 3rd August 1985. Times of India.

    11. 60 Girls as Cargo to Virgin Ils, 21st April 1985, Indian Express.

    12. Teenage Prostitution up in Rajasthan, 28th December 1984, The Daily.

    13. 20% of the Prostitutes are minors. V Mathews, 11th August 1985, The Daily

    14. Encyclopedia Americana

    15. Urbanization a hell for poor kids, 2nd November 1986, The Times of India, Bombay.

    16. New act to curb, child Prostitution, 24th January 1987, Times of India (Bombay).

    17. Prostitution Thrives in Bombay, 7th April 1987, Times of India, (Bombay).

    Jeeta Reply:

    You have to work still harder. If cut copy and paste would have been a science than evry noble peace prize would have gone to Pakistan. ahhahahha

    neetu Reply:

    Baap baap hota hai beta beta hi hota hai. Looks like “****” stan was born out of such illegitimate relationship and thats why it is such a rogue state. You people have nothing good to see. Look where India stands in the community of nations and look where you are standing. The international community sees you as the epi-centre of terrorism who are exporting terrorism everywhere. India is at a different level and is an emerging superpower. What have you to offer to the world while India is the software powerhouse with hundreds of industries while you are happy producing handmade footballs besides terrorists. You are not even capable of standing on your own legs and needs the crutches of America’s donations to run your country and still talk about India.

    We don’t even want to stoop to your level and should just ignore you as you have already pressed the self-destruct button. God bless you and hope good sense prevails.

    Rajiv Reply:

    Crime exists in every society.

    Civilized governments and societies, fight it.

    Criminal governments or entities like Pakistan state, actually promote it .

    Thats the only difference between civilized states and criminal ones.

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Dear everyone,

    As I said I am studying the perverted Pakistani brain, using Azhar and Sal as guinea pigs! :)

    My observations for the day;–

    “Unable to give a reason why Pakistanis are into “Horse sex”, “donkey sex”, and ‘Camel sex” as well as child rape– a fact proved by google trends, the guinea pigs have gone incomprehensible.

    They are doing cut and paste, cut and past, cut and paste, yet cannot hide their guilt !!

    ha ha ha… what a country ! :)
    What a people :)

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    I am posting facts where you people are posting your opinion which is not worth a single rupee

    Jai Vaidya Reply:

    Just as Hong kong was given back to China so has NWFP to be given back to Afghanistan.Even pakistani assets like mullah Omar are not willing to budge on that.No afghan can survive byb accepting the Durand line.NWFP is in Pakistan only because it was annexed by Maharaja Ranjit Singh,however Durand line which was signed in 1893 had a shelf life of 100yrs.Pakistans international borders are at West Punjab.

    Mukesh Reply:

    Keep dreaming..as you are in past 60 years.you will loose your western half too…like you did with Bangladesh. You lier what do you mean by unarmed, they are militant in disguise throwing stones and buring police station. They should be shot at sight. There is a well defined way to deals with mad dogs.

    [Reply]

    Legionnaire Reply:

    Lol…

    [Reply]

    Papa Reply:

    Hey, Sal, this is your Papa to make you realize that Rajiv is right. I am reading the Dawn News Paper (dawn.com), the headlines says that 30 are killed and many injuried in big chaos. I feel pity for you as you dont believe in truth; you can’t read Dawn and other international news papers since your head is dumbed in madarshas. God bless a modern school to inoccent kids in Pak.

    [Reply]

    Pradeep Reply:

    27 went up to 46! Here is a genuine Pakistani source: http://thenews.com.pk/updates.asp?id=109671.

    [Reply]

  • dfsltd

    I am surprised that these Pakis can read and write english. Isn’t the whole of Pak is full of Madrasas. Although their brains don’t function like normal human being These sons of O’ bin Laden are retarded. These people live on hate and jealousy. This is a failed state which is running with the hare and hunting with the hound. Terrorism is the biggest industry of that country. Unless they promote and export terror, how will they get the billions of dollars from US and West. In NY and NJ where I live, the Pakis are identifying themselves as Indians so that they are not thrashed. The whole world hates them for what they are and have realized the double game they play.
    Just to remind you brain less creatures, the GDP of **** ($164.54 Billion ) is less than the total revenue of top ten companies of India. So instead of thinking of harming India, you people should think of earning a living ,as very soon, there would be nothing left for you guys to do. Not even export terror.

    [Reply]

  • Riaz Kashmiri

    Most of the Indians are obsessed with Pakistan. So they are, with ISI . A piece of advise ” Just mind your business”. ISI & Pak Army belongs to Pakistan. Non of your business.

    [Reply]

    kristalsoldier Reply:

    Fair enough! But the undeniable fact remains that Pakistan was dismembered in 1971 and going by the looks of it stands on the threshold of suffering the same consequences this time around. The only difference being that this time it will not be broken into two pieces, but into three – the first to go will be the NWFP (it’s almost as good as gone); the second will be western Pakistan where Iran will and already has muscled in – remember that Iran (like Pakistan) also needs strategic depth and Balochistan is waiting all ready and primed; and what is left will be the Punjab-Sindh provinces, which are like festering wounds already. Already the viability of Pakistan as a functioning nation-state is suspect. As for Kashmir, Pakistan has tried three times and has failed to wrest it out of the hands of India. A fourth attempt will be existentially disastrous for the Pakistan. And, in the midst of all this, do you know what the tragedy is? The common Pakistani is probably sick and tired of the secterian violence that is constantly destablizing the country and they are dying in their tens and hundreds with many other thousands suffering. As things stand now Pakistan is an isolated state – perhaps not the extent the DPRK is. But it’s getting there soon. And, if as you say, it is not our business to see a stable and confident Pakistan, then so be it. We will just build an “iron curtain” along our common borders and let you guys finish your death-games! Maybe 50 years later, we will peek over the wall and see if the conditions are right to intervene and if yes, how and in what manner.

    Cheers!

    [Reply]

    Rana Reply:

    You Pakis are shameless creatures, everywhere you spread hatred and terrorism and in turn you are beaten then you beg for your life.

    [Reply]

    DF Reply:

    Both are terrorist outfits. Hence they belong to terrorist pakistan.

    [Reply]

  • Vinod

    PAKISTAN IS TERRORISTAN. India needs to just sit back, relax and enjoy Pak’s self destruction !!

    [Reply]

  • Paul

    In USA, if you ask a Pakistani as to when he is visiting Pakistan. The answer is “not any time soon,
    Life is too uncertain. You leave your house for shopping, elders sit praying till you safely come back.”
    It is not uncommon that most of the robberies are committed with the knowledge of the police.
    ISI is another rogue institution to intimidate the people and train and send terrorists to Afganistan, USA,or India. Is this the behavior of a civilized society.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    Average American of Pakistani origin in USA is scared of the , Pakistani stamp on its passport !

    That means, he will be viewed as a terrorist or suspect the world over, whenever he produces the passport.
    But then , people who welcome a criminal entity like Pak army/ISI , maybe deserve this ?

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    Paul I live in the States, and I visit Pakistan every year.

    [Reply]

    DF Reply:

    Azar You visit Pakistan. Scared it will not exist. Packing up the remaining begging bowls to take to the US. Azar are you starting a begging business on behalf of Pakistan.

    [Reply]

    ROHIT Reply:

    guys just ckeck this guy…”he visits Pakistan every year”….saala juroor terrorist hai aur pakistan aa kar training leta hai….

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Probably pretending to be Indian when the Americans call you an ISI terroroist!

    Wahi baat hai… roti khai amrika ki, bums chatto Amricans ke…aur unhi go gali di…

    Typical Pakistani!

    Ha ha ha :) what a country !

    [Reply]

    ahmed Reply:

    Paul i doubt whether you’re an american.

    Anyways, just check the number of indians running out of india. Western countries are being flooded by indians desperate to work as sweepers and really really low paying jobs. Their is sheer desperation in india economically.

    Compared to that very few pakistanis ever think of leaving home. and even if they leave home for studies abroad they mostly come back and settle in Pakistan. I have seen very few indians doing that.

    As far as karachi is concerned, there were on average 2500 average murders in New York in the 1990s mostly due to gang violence. Every city has its neighborhoods and gangs. Stop comparing gang fights with political movements for freedom and justice. Just to give you more information, their is an area in karach called Lyari which has seen gang fights for the past couple of years that has killed almost 3000 gang members. And to add to that, i have been living in karachi for 10 years, and i have no idea where layari is or whether there was a gang war going on. Karachi has a population of almost 15-20 million and is extremely spread out. Try getting some perspective before spewing utter gibberish.

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Dear deluded Pakistani brother Ahmed,

    All of Pakistan wants to leave Pakistan !!!

    Remember the slogan now is “PAKISTAN se Zinda BHAAG !!:) ”

    “Pakistan se Zinda bhaag…

    Nahi toh…

    Tera bhi ban jayega Murda Kharab !!

    Ha ha ha !!

    Come let us all improve Pakistan by

    a) Banning ISI
    b) Banning burka and polygamy
    c) Freeing women from 11 th century thinking
    d) Giving freedom to Baluchis, SIndhis, Pakhtoonis
    e) Letting minorities like Ahemdiyas, CHristians, SHias , Hindus and Sikhs flourish and propogate their religion
    f) Banning blasphemy
    g) stopping heroin smuggling and financing of terror
    h) Jailing and hanging jihadis who kill innocents

    [Reply]

  • PAKISTANI

    Such is HINDU obsession with PAKISTAN that now they are wondering how PAKISTAN is being run. Mr. Slum dwellers please focus on your slum. PAKISTAN know how to deal with it’s business as well as with HINDUSLUM.

    KASHMIR Bane Ga PAKISTAN.

    HINDUSTAN MURDABAD.

    [Reply]

    ghallughara Reply:

    **** patriot, internationa FAKIRS, shameless society, begging from KAFIRS,
    your BREAKFAST, LUNCH AND DINNER come from begging money. Every 3 month your govt. dust their begging bowl and go around the world asking for BHEEKH, MUGALS ruled India and now, MUGALS become beggars, shame on you people, go smell the coffee, your country will not come out of hole, untill you stop polygamie, degrading women and children’s life, look at India, criticism always welcom and we correct our mistakes, David Cameron, made little statement, whole country burning PM’s effigies, Anybody give you finger to hold and you guys bite that finger and eat his hand. ISI is the one will start the nuclear war, and destroy the pakistan, there is limit to everything, India had enough from crupt ISI and crupt ARMY., nobody will come to rescue you, whole world tired of your country, it is like cancer to the whole world.

    [Reply]

    Indian Reply:

    I see so many Pakistani people commenting on Indian blogs, do you not realize? You guys are so IRRELEVANT to us. Were it not for the terror you guys export (as pointed out rightly by the British PM, others know it but do not say it so plainly because of diplomacy and strategic needs), we would not even bother to check up the news in Pakistan. India’s view of it in 10 years from now is not based on Pakistan, while going by the Pakistan people reaction, they seem to tie their existence to India-hatred. Tell me, why does it even matter to you what an Indian blogger thinks about Pakistan? I know that it does not matter to me what you think about India, I know it is DIVINE, regardless of what you say. I do not go to Pak blogs looking to comment the hell out of people. Please keep your esteemed opinions to yourself. Thats it. No need to fight.

    I am not saying you are good or that you are bad. All I am saying is, to the modern Indian generation, you DO NOT MATTER, were it not for my brothers and sisters being killed in other parts of my country I would not even give two hoots about what is happening in Pakistan. Please mind your own business and keep your opinions to yourself.

    [Reply]

    PD Reply:

    *** for tat — that’s what they need. I’m with you, ghallughara.

    [Reply]

    ROHIT Reply:

    bhai hum bhi manaa kahaan kar rahe hain, bas yehi to kah rahe hain (oops! kar rahe hain) ki :BHAI HIMMAT HAI TO KAR KAY/ YA LE KAY DIKHAO….kashmir to bana nahin pakistan but haan EAST PAKISTAN juroor bangladesh ban gayaa hahahahaha!!!
    and as u say, inshaallah, baluchistan banega alag desh aur sindh banega Sindhu Desh

    RAAJ KAREGA KHALSAA ….. wait for sometime

    [Reply]

    DF Reply:

    If Pakistan knows how to deal with its business then how come your country is begging. Your pakis are good at seeing colourful dreams. Kashmir bane ga Pakistan sapne mei.

    Pakistan Murdabad, Balochistan zindabad.

    [Reply]

  • Ali

    The author had confused the facts at lot of places. Even if DG ISI reports to Army Chief, sanctioning of foreign trip is done by Civilian Defence Secretariat. He then denounced the statements issued by two civilians, Pak envoy to UK and Pak Foreign Minister as General’s language and Armed Forces inability to communicate. The fact of the matter is US is siding Pakistan in war against terror because they know the realities behing these reports while UK and other are issuing irresponsible statements on a very sensitive area because of their economic interests. Sane elements in India and else where fully realize the importance of establishing good relations with Pakistan for the larger sake of India. However, unfortunately, there are short-sighted and biased elements on both side of the border. India’s PM, being fully cogzinant of ground realities, wish to have a peaceful region by engaging Pakistan. We all must realize that peoples’ lives and betterment in this region is too serious a business to be left to generals, petty politicians and others who seek to gain by fanning hatred and other differences.

    [Reply]

  • manoo

    Hey leave fighting ,ISI and the dirty politicians See Bangladesh seperated from Pakistan , and has far developed than Pakistan its GDP is far more better than pakistan( Isi supported)and tell all the pakistanis go to England and see how Bangladeshis are prospering and getting their country prosperous

    [Reply]

  • Pakistan

    Mind your own business Mr. writer, pakistan is of Pakistanies its all assets its land and its everything you just focus own feeding your 400million+ underfed and below powertyline ppl and stop behaving like a policeman of the world. You guys are just on the path of development like us and china. Once you become something then start fingering otherz. A crow shouldn’t pretend swan. Don’t try to step in more than one boat otherwise you know the consequences, from where you ‘ll get tear-off. keep focusing on making more bollywood sagas like mumbai attacks its a good recipe. Remember the days when there wont be any NATO in your neighbourhood to cry on the shoulders, when you ‘ll be having more kicks from naxalites in 4 states and in nagaland and in Kashmir fear that day, its closing in…….remember.
    Dont get so excited about David C’s statemnt. you know he was a sales man on business tour to sells his toys to you guys.

    [Reply]

  • Nazir kashmir valley

    Time has come to liberate kashmir from Indian ” Ugly faces on earth”. then see how the peace is pravailed in kashmir, Pakistan and India. Hindus never understand peace, hindus are called kafir becase they attack from back, just like killing civilians in kashmir. Pakistan Army and ISI need to attack kashmir then see how Indian Army will leave kashmir. Pak army needs to take action like Gouri, baber.

    [Reply]

  • PD

    Don’t be mistaken, Azhar Hussain — that WikiLeaks has no meaning. The truth has already been exposed to the world.
    There are more WkiLeaks are awaitnig for you — soon all the answers will be given to you by the world.

    [Reply]

  • LD Bhatia

    This is another proof if at all another one was needed that Pak army is an independent,powerful
    and separate entity, a part of the Troiqua far more powerful than the other two members which goes
    by its own rules. The ISI Chief was going to discuss terrorism and the ways to meet it effectively.
    But when the agency has been exposed as never before, how could the ISI Chief face his counterpart
    in Britain who would have asked searching questions from him? We should not forget that British
    forces are also fighting and shedding their blood in Afghanistan. There have been terrorist incidents
    in Britain also resulting in death and destruction. Those who indulged in it were trained in Pakistan.
    Apart from the utterly puerile comment of the Pakistani High Commissioner, there is the statement
    of a Labour British MP who, in order to please the constituency that has elected him has asked his
    P:rime Minister to offer an apology to the Muslims of Britain who, as the MP has said, have felt
    offended by his remark. As a distinguished columnist has said, Pak army wants Pakistan to be a
    different state from India. If the army in that country does not play the destructive role it is playing
    in training and arming terrorists and exporting terror to other countries, it would have no locus
    standii in that country. Pakistani army knows that its country is considered to be front-line state
    against terrorism and without its help (which in reality is a facade, a subterfuge to hide its real
    object), Allied forces in Afghanistan would not be able to fight their war against the terrorist group. P:ak army has got Swat valley free from terrorists to show to the world at large that it is serious
    in tooting our terrorism and terrorist groups from its soil. But it wants to be left alone in helping
    the terrorist bodies to hit Indian interests in Afghanistan and also India at the time and place of its choosing. The blunt statement made by British P:rime Minister, Mr Cameron, has put the ISI in
    a cleft and it is now squirming to wriggle out of it. The ISI Chief has acted brazenly in the knowledge that nobody can call him to account.

    [Reply]

  • Jeeta

    Pakistan is a failed state infact it is not even state, it is a big desert tribe being ruled by a contract killer militia army. They are nothing more than donkeys tied to a 1400 year old pole. They dont know how to live in 21st century.
    Army/ ISI being supreme in Pakistan has a reason.Basically they are just invaders/marauders and like savages they can invade/loot and destroy all in the name of religion but they can never run the affairs of a country. All little bit whatever Pakistan has survived this far is affect of eastern religions.
    Who gains prominence in a goonda mindset tribe ???? people with guns !!
    This world is yet to figure out what to do with a fragmented Pakistan and seem to have decided that the filth better be contained in a bag called Pakistan for the time being.

    [Reply]

  • Lalit K Jha

    Pakistan is still in existence due to its begging style.. all the western powers give away something every few months and that’s feeding this terrorist country. I am very amazed with Pakistan’s begging capacity… they must never leave it… beside that they can not progress in any other field.

    [Reply]

  • Jagdish

    It is really comical to see Pakistani suicide bombers pulling their hair and beating their chests trying to intimidate the civilized world from speaking the truth about their rogue country. ahahhahah
    They want an apology from British PM, They would ban facebook/ twitter, they would seek clarification from Afgan President when he said attack terror factories in Pakistan, they would call 92000 paper leak by Wikileak….
    How many mouth you will shut ? or blow them up ??

    [Reply]

  • Pakistan

    @LD Bhatia,
    Lets talk about RAW’s exported terrorism in east pakistan resulting in BD, in Sri lanks which has just avoided creation of a tamil state, in Nepal, in BD, in Pakistan from eastern and now from western border via its “Interests” in Afghanistan. We know that you have your puppet madressas setup in Afghanistan to harbour terrorist to carry out suicide attacks in Pakistan your paid fake mullahs are doing their duties in Afghanistan for this. Would you plz tell me that for all these actions, RAW is accountable to anyone in your country? does it? My dear, we are @war since our very creation, dont expect your enemy to kiss you if you hit em. Always be prepared for some counter measures. Dont try to always use the same recipe of 9/11 drama, the london bombing the madrid and then mumbai, that all was to board the same train going to Afghanistan.

    [Reply]

  • Jai Vaidya

    Peace in South Asia can come only with the transfer of NWFP back to Afghanistan. The Durand Line expired in 1993. Pakistan is legally obligated to transfer this territory to Afghanistan.Of course the final choice is with the Pakhtoons, to join Afghanistan or live an independent Pakhtoonistan. IThe Baloch and Pakhtoons simply want no part of Pakistan.

    [Reply]

    Concerned Human Reply:

    Mr Azhar Husain – Why do not Pakistani in USA says that they are from Pakistan & Tell their original muslim name – if you watch news recently when Pakistan desent was cought in bomb blast case why were muslims from New Ork & many in Canada feel ashame to be recognised as a Pakistani Muslims, they try to say they are from India & on cell when they call to people they try to disguise their identety. Did you watch Pakistan PM & Sherry Rehaman vedio on Face Book, Goolge it & watch you will come to know your roots standard. World knows Pakistan is a fail state, your ISI is a crupt organisation, time will tell how they are killing you/theirr own muslim contry people, first they should try to solve their own problem then think any thing else. Pakistan is paying the price for their own deeds, wait & see Afganistan will be progressing better than Pakistan in near future just like Bangladesh, you people will be busy kiling each other.

    [Reply]

    Ramiz Reply:

    Your selfish thinking is not going to pay off anything to slumdogs. Durand line is a symbolic border line between the two brotherly neighboring countries with blood relatives living on both sides of the border. What the heck these Indian slumdogs have to do with this? Pakistanis are in fact justified in kicking the *** of these mischievious Indian slumdogs in Afghanistan because these evils are there only to sow the seeds of hatred and make the two neighborly countries fight.

    [Reply]

    ROHIT Reply:

    we do not need to “sow the seeds”….pakistan is nothing just an extention of punjabis and every self respecting pathan is totally against these filthy pigs who are ruling them for the past 60 years…i have met tons of pakistanis in my life who are of the same “slumdog” race as others (read- jats,rajputs, gujjars etc.) the only difference between us and pakistanis is that we remained a “pure” race and theirs got mixed with filthy races like Arabs/iraqis (remember Quasim!!!) ….. no wonder whenever a pakistanis walks in front of me he/she smells like “pork kebab” (turkish style)!!!!!!

    [Reply]

    vijay Kumar Reply:

    It is a fact that the military runs this fascist country and only wants to promote what it thinks is right.

    It uses terrorism, heroin smuggling, human bombs and democracy destruciton worldwide as its tools

    The viewpoint of the Pakistani military is contrary to what we require for a just and humane world.

    The whole world needs to see how to supress this uniquely evil force called the Pak Army and ISI.

    [Reply]

  • Ramiz

    The author is either silly or ignorant. IsIndian RAW under the control of the babus of Indian home ministery? Then why this silly trying to make an isue out of nothing. ISI is under the direct control of Pak PM and not the Army Chief. The fact is that these coward Indians are so scared by the mighty ISI that they are frightened of ISI even in their dreams. These sillies are now make hou and cry just for nothing because nothing is going to change. ISI can not be less hard on the enemies of Pakistan just because some silly Indians or stupid immature David Cameros want it to change.

    [Reply]

    MM Reply:

    Ramiz, ISI is under Pakistan Army. There was directive to put it under PM but then Army exerted control and the order was cancelled. Fact check here.

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Dear Pakistani brothers,

    Today when you guys were enjoying yourelf on google, watching, horses, camels and donkeys having fun with Pakistanis, 87 people were killed in Karachi.

    Can you tell me whthere the killers will go to jannat and dance with houris and have red wine??

    If you do think this way…

    very sad :)
    Very bad :(

    PAKISTAN se ZINDA BHAAG….
    Yeh Watan hai bahut kharab…
    Nahi toh ban jayega MURDA barbaad….

    Bugti Zindabad !! :) :)

    [Reply]

    ROHIT Reply:

    pehle ek “made in pakistan” bi-cycle to banaa ke dikhao….baat karta hai “hard on the enemies”…bhikhari kaum hamesha bhikhari hi rehti hai….arbiyon ke ghulamon just keep your filth to yourself only….

    [Reply]

  • Pakistan

    @Vidya,
    Go get some piss drink with sharma and then shed the light on drawing the line. Why not to redraw the map of your country and break it into pieces like indep Kashmir, Naga land, and a Naxalite estate etc etc. coz none of these nations wants to live with Endia? what you think shall we? …..stop dreaming the blues, I think you guys ve enough bollywood movies.

    ISI, whether its under army control or PM control who are you to bark @? its totally internal pakistani matter, its none of anybody else’s business…not even David Moron ( rightly to be named, the idiot brit salesman).

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    Yes,

    Uncle Sam who throws small peices of moth eaten rotis to at our Pakistani brotheres is already planning to amalgamate NWFP with Afghanistan, while Baluchistan and MOhajirs are to be given freedom.

    Ajgar Hussain, Sal and a few donkeys and camels will remain in Pakistan :)

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Dear Vinod Sharma ji
    Of late I am glad you have been writing at the same frequency which is in resonance with most of us here. Going by the reaction of govt. of Pakistan to the British PM’s comments, do you still believe that people to people contacts between our two countries have any meaning when the Pakistan rulers have such a mindset. You also now agree that Pakistan army is calling the shots by proxy and the civilian govt. is just a puppet arrangement. to have come out becuase of world sanctionsand criticism when the military govt. took over the civilian govt. See first the reaction of Mr. Qureshi to Mr. Pillai’s comments and now the reaction Pak. diplomat in USA reacting to British PM’s comments and that too on personal level, calling him an immature. By such standards, Mr. Qureshi’s comments regarding Mr. Krishna can be rated as just mild. As I had mentioned earlier, it is sad that Pakistan leaders still have a feudal mindset and you can not expect the finesse that is expected from a trained diplomat having a non-feudal background.
    Sir,whether you agree with me or not, but I am glad that you are echoing , rather unwittingly, the views of majority of us on your blogs.
    Regards
    BNA

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Dr Anand,

    The civilian part of Pak establishment, is just the ‘begging wing’ of the Pak army, so that it can collect western aid.

    Its just a mutually arranged facade, whose power is restricted to collect money for the pai,k army and isi.

    Regarding Zardari, he knows that in 3 years, he will be living in London, the spot were all ex pak politicians, when not hangedor imprisoned , but out of power, end up. So he is just making sure he has good relations with his future hosts.

    [Reply]

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    Dear Dr Anand,
    First of all, I resent the “I told you so” tenor of your letter. One’s assessment of a dynamic, unfolding situation can not be cast in stone. Pl note that I am writing on the current scenario without the belli-gerence that comes so naturally to many visitors to this blog site. I also believe that we have to evolve a strategy to engage with Pakistan with its many-layered power centres.

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Dear Vinodji,

    I am trying to to understand the issues of belligrance which comes naturally to many visitors of this blog site.

    But Can you also spot the difference?

    a) The indians are mostly exasperated and worried that the Pakistanis are launching terror attacks on India and are proud of their ISI and military leadership.

    b) Many are worried that they talk only about their version of Islam being superior to all other versions and better than any other religion.

    c) Many of the Indians do praise the saner elements in Pakistan who can live with an idea of united India, with its secularism, demacracy and economic achievements.

    While the Pakistanis are mostly, in fact 99% time

    a) Trying to prove that India is poor and worse of than Pakistan, while the reverse is true

    b) Trying to prove that India is not secular, even though they show a pride in eliminating all other religions except Islam

    c) Take pride in their ISI and military as well as the killings of 26/11 and other murders of Indians in Afghanistan

    d) Feel that they they would soon swallow Afghanistan as well as succeed in breaking India, once NATO leaves Aghanistan

    Where is the possibility of reconciliation?
    The two sides are so fundamantelly different that it is like chalk and cheese. Maybe it was good that we are partitioned. NO Pakistani ever ever says that two brothers have left the house. yes, they are some sentimental Indians who may say that.

    What do you have to say on that.

    Rajiv Reply:

    Substance matters more than tone and tenor.
    Unfortunate the substance is lost and diluted to some meaningless platutudes ( like ‘we are common victims of terror’ when Indian PM Manmohan speaks.)

    India makes the foolish argument that it is encouraging the democratic element in Pakistan, by engaging the civilian face.

    In fact, Indian government is an active partner in the massive charade the Pak establsihment perpetrates, by engaging it in any talks, knowling full well that there is absolutely no change in the anti-India policies being active persued by its army and ISI through direct overt and covert operations inside India.

    India should not fool itself into believing that it can bring democracy in Pakistan and sideline its military and ISI, who have both there feets on the throats of any civilian set up.

    Its a self-serving argument made by India, because it is not willing to explore other options to deal with Pak duplicity.
    India should think twice before mouthing that asinine inanity that a ’strong Pakistan is good for India’.

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Absolutely brilliant Rajiv ! Your words need to be read by all policy planners.

    Mr Pillai and Chidambaran, probably know this. MMS and the rest of the Congress, who are still innocent virgins in the minefield of Pakistan, need to read this.

    Senile idiots like Mani Aiyar would not be able to make head or tail of this, though….

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Dear Vinod sharma ji
    I feel bad if you have any resentment to the the tone and tenor of my response, though I hardly used any word which is either derogatory to you or goes against your dignity. But please allow at least a free and frank discussion which sometimes you may not relish, especially when we happen to differ on some points. But may I assure you, it is all without any malice. However I agree with Rajiv that generally speaking substance matters more than tone and tenor.

    I have another suggestion to make ( it is not advice). It will be better if you are able to moderate the comments of some who go off the track from the topic of your blog or be using some unprintable language? It is especially so with the guest bloggers from across the border which then starts the chain reaction as a retaliation from this side of the border.
    Regards
    BNA

    Vinay Reply:

    I just wanted to bring this piece of news from UK, in front of the readers here.

    British media have been speculating the reasons for Gandhis (Sonia and Rahul) not meeting Cameron, PM of UK during his visit. They consider, Rahul Gandhi’s decision to visit London when
    Mr. Cameron was touring India giving no reason, is a genuine snub.

    According to the Financial Times, Rahul Gandhi enjoys a close relationship with former foreign minister and likely future Labour Party leader David Miliband. Allegedly, the young Gandhi was bitterly disappointed when Labour lost the UK election. Also, Cameron conspicuously cut “poverty tourism” out of this trip to India, focusing instead on the country’s economic progress. They speculate, this may have irritated the Gandhis who view themselves as champions of the rural poor.

    What should bother us Indians here is, this person (Miliband), visited India a month after Mumbai attacks (which India blamed on LeT), spent a night in rural UP with young Gandhi, came out and gave a statement “Resolution of the dispute over Kashmir would help tackling extremists in the region”. Our leaders are choosing to be close to him over Cameron, who actually is holds a Prime Minister post, appreciates our progress rather than highlighting our poverty and supports India on terrorism.

    ——– We can never get betrayed by our enemies. We never trust them at first place. It is only the people whom we trust have the capacity to betray.

    The media in UK were wondering, when the PM’s visit to India was taking prime place in every channel in UK, there was hardly any such response in India. True, today UK is not an economical
    power. But its support to India on cross border terror would have definitely sounded strong
    Internationally. Why did our leaders ignore this fact? If an international company comes offering 500 jobs, it will be all over papers. If a leader of a country comes, but has nothing to offer on the table as his country is not prosperous at the moment. Does that mean, we should ignore them? One could have atleast appreciated him for being genuine.

    We can’t make these leaders (Gandhis) liable for any of their action/inaction, as they hold no responsibility, but they have all the power. As long as everything is going fine, it will be nice. If something wrong happens, whom are we supposed to blame? If a railway mishap happens, railway minister will resign. Tomorrow, say a scam of Billions of Rs unfolds (so many companies have invested in this decade), who will bear the responsibility ? Manmohan Singh might resign. If all parties are involved, Gadkari will also resign. But we know none of these people had real power. People who had power, never sat on the posts, so we can never ask them to resign from their position.

    ——– Whatever be the rule Democracy or Dictatorship, rulers owe some responsibility. India is
    an exceptional case.

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    A very informative piece. Many thanks. I myseldf noticed that the visit of Mr Cameron to New Delhi was the lead story on BBC in its bulletins.
    Also , although not directly related to the subject of the post , I was wondering why the floods in Pakistan is not getting place in Indian media , whereas for BBC/CNN it is a priority story.
    As for the Gandhi / Nehru family the less said the better. This family considers itself the ” Mai Baap ” of India and there is a section of Indian society who are too happy crawling before it.

    Paritosh Reply:

    why should Pakistan floods bother us Indians??!!! these Pa-kis are getting killed is only a good news.

    Vinay Reply:

    We need to resolve our problems with another country politically. But, being blind with hatred when someone’s home is flooding, I don’t consider it humane. I don’t think, our culture has taught us this level of intolerance. I oppose Pakistan strongly for the violent acts committed in India and expect my country to take strict action. I also wish, Indian governmet to drop food packets to the victims caught in flood near Indian border.

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    @Paritosh
    The point I was making was just the missing news about the floods.. There was no intention to say that we should go out to do something about it . Who can be sure as to how that loony country shall respond . In any case they have the Taliban /ISI /PAK Army cadres and alms from US to handle the floods.

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Sir
    It irritates me a lot when for nothing too much importance is given to Rahul Gandhi. Are we following a system of Monarchy in the garb of democracy in the country so that the prince-in-waiting, like prince Charles in England, to become the head of the govt? Why the visiting head of a state has to call on Rahul Gandhi or even Mrs. Sonia Gandhi? I can understand that Sonia Gandhi, being head of the ruling political party may have some justification but not Mr. Rahul gandhi at all.
    BNA

    Usman Chaudhry Reply:

    Greetings Dr Anand,

    Which of the two are more likely to be next candidate for PM either Rahul Gandhi or Mr Chidambaram?
    The news that flows it is assumed Rahul to be next on the seat. Is this impression correct?

    Regards,
    Usman

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Usman
    Thanks for asking my opinion in this regard.
    Honestly, I shall be the last person to wish that Mr. Rahul Gandhi becomes the next PM of the country after the next general elections. He hardly has done any thing in his still nascent political life to have articulated his views on the socio-economic problems of the country. The media alone is touting his candidature for this job because most of the Congress leaders feel that only supposedly the charismatic Gandhi-Nehru family may help it to come to power. In any case, if it were left to me to choose the next PM amongst the Congress leaders, I would prefer either of the two of Mr. Chidambram and Mr. Pranab Mukherjee. But regretfully, Congress is not the party of my choice.
    Regards
    BNA

    Rajiv Reply:

    Our present generation of Indians , accepts Pakistan as a seperate entity.

    All that India wants is Pakistan criminals, many of them motivatd by the religious bigotry of Sal and Azhar, stay away.

    I repeat, all India wants is Pakistani zealots and bigots rstrict themselves to Pakistan.

    Here is a good piece in Pak paper daily.times.com.pk.
    It will give you some idea, from a Pakistani about the criminal nature of the Pak state, criminal nature of its identity and criminal nature of Jinnah.

    While Gandhi went on a fast to prevent senseless riots that killed so many people, irrespective of religion. In Pakistan, this is what Jinnah did

    ” In Sindh, the provincial government led by Ayub Khuhro from the Muslim League was dismissed and Khuhro was thrown into prison for he tried to contain the killings of Hindus in Karachi,”

    Just imagine that. Thats why Pakistan is such a criminal entity and Sal, Azhar such religious bigots.

    —————————————————————————–
    Does Pakistan make sense : By Haider Nizamani
    —————————————————————————–

    http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=201088\story_8-8-2010_pg3_5

    Pakistan will be turning 63 this month, but a question Ayesha Jalal posed 25 years ago has not lost its validity: how did a Pakistan come about that fits the interests of most Muslims so poorly? Professor K B Sayeed’s question asked, “Pakistan has a state, but does it have a nation?” Answers to these questions trigger heated debate amongst Pakistanis without leading to any satisfactory answer. Although a country of about 170 million faced with multiple challenges, of which religious militancy tends to get the most attention, we must remember that Pakistan was the first major post-colonial country to break apart because its ruling elite failed to accommodate the political, economic and cultural aspirations of its Bengali citizens. In fact, the separation of East Pakistan, which resulted in the emergence of Bangladesh, is one of those rare instances where the majority ethnic group of a country struggled, and succeeded in attaining independence. It is something that would appear incredibly bizarre to those who study separatist movements. Imagine an English-speaking population wanting to secede from Canada complaining of Quebec’s dominance, or the Sinhalese waging separatist movements in Sri Lanka citing Tamil dominance.

    Nationalist challenges did not disappear in Pakistan with the emergence of Bangladesh. Why is that the case? My answer to this question is premised on four assumptions regarding present-day Pakistan. First, Islam is a shared religion of a vast majority of Pakistanis, but there neither was nor is “such a thing as a Muslim political monolith. Politically, Muslims were and are a diverse group.” Second, centralised expression of Pakistani nationalism has always been challenged by regional identities and that will remain the case, unless there is major overhauling of the political and economic system of the country. Third, no ongoing separatist movement in Pakistan has enough power to completely break up the country. Last, international powers, in this case the US, India and China, are not too keen to dismember Pakistan.

    Nation and nationalism, as commonly understood, are recent ideas dating hardly four centuries back. Therefore, we should always be wary of claims of nationalists regarding the age of their nations, as most of them tend to exaggerate the age of nations. It so happens that global political cartography has carved up the world into nation states. The 20th century principle of national self-determination implicitly expects neat alignment between boundaries of a state and its constituent nation. However, state and nation alignment is an ideal that very few, if any, states in the world meet. As a result, when overly centralised states like Pakistan try to erase social and political differences within a diverse society like theirs, in the name of creating a ‘true Pakistani’, the project is bound to be challenged.

    Pakistan wrong-footedly started its innings while dealing with domestic diversity and that remains the case as the country turns 63. If any country fits the story of blind men describing an elephant, it is Pakistan. Both before and immediately after the country’s independence, leaders from Muslim majority regions had quite different, often conflicting, views on why those regions should have a separate country and what will that country be like, should it come into existence. Much is made of the uniting force of the Two Nation Theory now, but as late as 1946, when Pakistan was becoming a viable proposition, many influential leaders from regions that were to comprise Pakistan had not fully bought into the Two Nation Theory. Hussain Shaheed Suhrawardy, premier of united Bengal, “demolished the Two Nation Theory by claiming that religion was not the only determining factor, and attached great importance to linguistic ties. Mamdot wanted [the] whole of Punjab. Hidayatullah’s only interest was to keep the Centre out of Sindhi affairs.”

    The Centre trampled upon the rights and aspirations of the constituent units with impunity during the first year of the country’s existence. All of the following happened while Mr Mohammad Ali Jinnah, considered the founder of the country, was alive. Mr Jinnah tells Bengalis, who were the largest linguistic group of his newly minted country, that Urdu and only Urdu will be the official language of the country. In Sindh, the provincial government led by Ayub Khuhro from the Muslim League was dismissed and Khuhro was thrown into prison for he tried to contain the killings of Hindus in Karachi, and balked at taking Karachi away from Sindh to hand it over to the Centre. The government of Dr Khan Sahib was dismissed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Reluctant about the accession to Pakistan, the Khan of Kalat was forced to submit by the threat of a full-fledged army action.

    While the arbitrary removal of chief ministers was one factor, it was a combination of concerns over economic opportunities, political representation, cultural grievances and historical injustices that fuelled regional nationalisms to challenge the overly centralised state. Regional nationalisms in the present-day Pakistan have intra- and international facets and they contribute in shaping Islamabad’s relations with its constituent units as well as neighbouring countries. Any discussion of ethnic movements, as they are pejoratively termed by proponents of Pakistani nationalism, or understanding genuine nationalist movements, as viewed by their supporters, without discussing Punjab is like staging Hamlet without the Prince of Denmark. Monographs dealing with the ethnic nationalisms in Pakistan seldom allocate a chapter on Punjab. Late Feroz Ahmed, a perceptive analyst of the national question, did not have a separate chapter on Punjab in his book Ethnicity and Politics in Pakistan because “being the dominant group…Punjabis do not have an ethnic problem”. Their identity is subsumed in the Pakistani identity. Other scholars have variously called Punjab as an ‘ethnic hegemon’ and what occurs in the name of the state as the ‘Punjabisation of Pakistan’.

    As a result of dominating the state apparatus of Pakistan, Punjab ends up with a paradoxical role as it considers itself as the custodian and cornerstone of Pakistan, but is viewed by all other groups as the major hindrance to national integration on an equal footing. This reservation is reinforced when the Punjab-dominated military has periodically resorted to brute use of force to suppress dissent in regions such as East Pakistan, Balochistan, and Sindh.

    Usman Chaudhry Reply:

    Thank You for the answer. It appears that most of the bloggers from your country share opinion against Congress and congressmen. Recently Mr Mani Shankar’s remarks against CWG is another fresh example that has sparked annoyance against him and onto the face of political party. It is an impression in Pakistan that Congress is the only strong political party in India unlike few other like BJP have small share as well.

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Usman
    Well, Mani Shankar Aiyar is not a good example. The ordinary middle class person in the country treats him with contempt because of his uncivilised and vitrolic expression for any one who does not agree with his views. That is unbecoming of any veteran congress leader. Anyway, he is now a defeated politician and could enter the Rajya sabha because of the generosity of the Chairman of the house who has nominated him as a member fof the House from his quota. That should be because of support of congress party. On the other hand, Mr. Chidambram and Mr. pranab Mukherjee are high decent people with not only an impressive educational background but also having grassroot political support.
    Regards
    BNA

    Vinay Reply:

    Well Anand,
    I agree, India is a democracy and ManMohan Singh is chosen (by whom?!) to be PM. But who do you think in India has the power to make decission ? PM or Gandhis? Media attention is natural because of this fact. It doesn’t matter whether I or you (or bloggers here) aprove Gandhis are not, we need to agree the name ‘Gandhi’ is still a crowd puller among masses (compared with any other leader).

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Vinay
    Yes sir, India is a democracy but we would have liked a sort of American type of democratic system for direct election to the highest office rather than to have inherited and adopted the sysem from our colonial masters. Yes. Dr.MMS , though highly educationally qualified is still a nominated PM who has fought one Lok sabha election and then lost. It is still more disappointing that he got RJ seat from Assam though he could have esily got elected from his parent state. He is bureaucrat par excellance but not a politcal leader of the same stature. So even Gandhi crowd puller strength could not get him elected. As you are fully aware, crowd pulling not always translates into voting but that is more of out of curiosity about the Chrisma that the Nehru-Gandhi family still holds in some section of our population. At least I never felt enchanted about any congress leader, except for Mrs. Indira Gandhi, not becuasue she was a congress leader but the courage she showed in dealing with many complex problems of the country, the top of which was the nationalisation of banks.
    Thanks
    BNA

    Jai Vaidya Reply:

    Hey Gopi.
    The Mahatma was influenced more by Christianity of the Tolstoy variety. If you read the Gita carefully Krishna tells us how to deal with violence very clearly.

    Gopi Thomas Reply:

    @Jai

    Mahathmaji did not run away from violence; he is like Dharmaputra , a yogic king, who wants welfare of the people but not the physical jewels of the kingdom.

    He was for second world war; and fully cooperated with British because he saw the evils of nazism were world killing than a community or nation killing stuff .

    And it is not true that he never admonished Muslims. In his cunniness (being a gujju), he coopted the Muslims Khilafet movement to be a part of the independence movement; however when violence broke up in Malabar,a nd nava jouri (??) , he broke away from khilafet after criticizing Muslims for the violence.

    Ours is “arsha bharatha”, a bharatha of saints; not kings . I would say it is not coincidence, but divine, that Mahathmaji became our father/leader in our liberation movement. i believe, we as a mnation and people, are better off because we had him; and we had Patel and Nehru as his followers. .

    Mahathmji ko pranam! Father, guide us!

    Jai Vaidya Reply:

    Gopi
    I did not mean that the Mahatma was a coward,he and later Martin Luther were very brave.however after so many years I have come to beleive that his policies were complete failures.what was the point of co opting the khilafat movement,his support to the Ali brothers is baffling.As someone from Kerala you should know that the Moplah rebellion was nothig short jihad the Mahatma till the end called them freedom fighters.Finaly partition happened,mahatma thought this to be his biggest defeat.So why follow down path.

  • Ats

    Dear Vinod,
    Zardari has gone on an offical visit not a state visit, primarily to launch his son in politics, strangely from Birmingham. Kayani is not sending him to seek an apology from Cameroon. Cameroon has only stated facts supported by Kayani’s mentor Mike Mullen and now by ex canadian envoy. Role of Kayani and army is open to the world as per wikileaks, and who else is to be blamed for this but the Pentagon.

    [Reply]

  • Azhar Hussain

    40,000 Indians ‘disappear’ in Malaysia, visa on arrival scrapped
    Indo-Asian News Service
    Kuala Lumpur, August 03, 2010First Published: 18:40 IST(3/8/2010)
    Last Updated: 18:48 IST(3/8/2010) Email printBookmark & Share more…

    Malaysia revoked its visa on arrival (VOA) facility for Indians after 40,000 visitors from India “abused” it and “disappeared”, Deputy Prime Minister Muhyideein Yassin has said. The cases of Indians abusing the scheme topped the list of unauthorised immigrants from eight South Asian nations related stories
    UK to tighten foreign student visa regime
    and China to whom the VOA was offered.

    The facility has now been “scrapped permanently”, The Star newspaper reported on Tuesday quoting the deputy prime minister.

    The Cabinet Committee on Foreign Workers and Illegal Immigrants felt that it needed to be revoked as it brought certain problems for the country.

    “In the past, we gave flexibility to several nations. If their citizens came to this country and they didn’t have a visa, one could be issued at the entry point.

    “We have noticed that this was being abused. We (the Cabinet committee) agreed that the VOA facility be revoked or discontinued,” he said after chairing the committee meeting in Kuala Lumpur on Monday.

    Apart from Indians, the facility was extended to tourists from China, Bhutan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Myan­mar, Taiwan and Comoros.

    It has been reported that thousands of tourists have abused their VOA, which was introduced in 2006 in conjunction with Visit Malay­sia Year 2007, by overstaying.

    In February, the government suspended the facility for visitors from India following reports that the highest number of VOA abuse involved citizens from that country.

    Last January, prior to his India visit, Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak had also expressed concern over the “disappearance” of almost 40,000 Indians who had entered the country through the VOA.

    Multi-ethnic Malaysia is home to 1.7 million ethnic Indians. Many have problems registering themselves as voters. They are denied the Mykad, the national identity card.

    In a related development, Election Commission deputy chairman Wan Ahmad Wan Omar said online registration was “risky, costly and unnecessary”.

    “It is not easy to set up online registration because there will be many loopholes for people to cheat and it’s difficult to check who is registering for whom,” he said.

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Ajgar ,

    Your voice is staid and tired!

    87 Pakistanis disappeared in Karachi last night and more are disappearing right now !
    Worry about them !

    Pakistan se zinda bhaag…
    Yeh hai nation barbaad….:)
    Pakistan se zinda bhaag :)

    [Reply]

  • http://- Rajeev

    Baloch hoga Azaad
    Pakistan hoga burbaad

    Balochistan Zindabad

    Sindhudesh Zindabad

    Altaf Bhai Batti lagao
    hum tumhare saath hai

    Altaf bhai hamara Imaan hai
    aaj ka Mujbir rahman hai.

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    Indian ‘honour killings’ up as young shun customs
    Tuesday, 03 Aug, 2010 This photo taken on June 24, 2010 shows Indian prisoners (L to R) Ankit, Mandeep and Nakul standing in a police station in New Delhi. The three are accused in a series of triple ‘honour killing’ murders in the city of Ghaziabad. – AFP World
    In rapidly modernising India, caste fatally lurks “HONOUR KILLING”
    In rapidly modernising India, caste fatally lurks NEW DELHI: The uncle was unrepentant about savagely killing his niece and her fiance who had the audacity to want to wed each other in defiance of Indian marriage traditions.

    “I have no regrets and I would punish them all over again if given another chance,” the uncle, Om Prakash, told the news media after his arrest by New Delhi police, asserting he had acted to save the family honour.

    Asha Saini, 19, and her 21-year-old boyfriend Yogesh Kumar were found stabbed to death in mid-June with their legs and arms bound and their bodies covered with electric shock burns.

    The murders came amid a spurt in so-called “honour killings” of couples who seek their own partners, breaching deeply entrenched tradition which dictates that the parents decide who their children should wed.

    Asha Saini’s family believed it would bring dishonour if the girl, whose father was a prosperous vegetable wholesaler, married her boyfriend, a poor taxi driver. Even more importantly, the couple were from different Hindu castes.

    Such “honour killings” have multiplied even among upwardly mobile social groups that are often considered less conservative as new conflicts emerge between generations, say experts.

    “The number is rising because women are more educated, they feel they have the capacity to take their own decisions about their lives,” said Anand Kumar, a social studies professor at New Delhi’s Jawarharlal Nehru University.

    Last month, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh ordered a cabinet-level committee to look at imposing heavier punishments for “honour killings” which are most prevalent in India’s northern states.

    There are no official figures, but one independent survey cited by New York-based Human Rights Watch said 900 such murders occur a year in the northern states of Haryana, Punjab, and Uttar Pradesh alone.

    Indian parents choose partners for their children most often for religious as well as financial reasons.

    The rules are complicated and choosing to marry within the same sub-caste or outside of one’s caste can both lead to a couple paying the ultimate price.

    Weekend newspapers have supplements jammed with marriage ads specifying caste as one of the main sought-after attributes along with a good job and a “fair” complexion.

    “The new generation faces a double challenge: it wants to eliminate the authority of the patriarchal family and reject the caste system,” said Kumar.

    They want marriages “based upon love” – a concept which has become increasingly popular as India becomes more Westernised, Kumar adds.

    In another case that has gained national attention, police are probing the death in April of Nirupama Pathak, 22, a journalist at a leading financial daily, the Business Standard, who wanted to marry a man of a caste lower than her own.

    Pathak belonged to the Brahmin caste, the highest in the ancient Hindu hierarchy, while her fiance, a journalism classmate, came from a middle-upper caste called Kayastha.

    Her death shocked India because she came from an educated and affluent family. Her father was a bank manager.

    Just days after she returned home to northern Jharkhand state, she was discovered dead in her bedroom. Police said she was suffocated – the family initially insisted she was electrocuted, then said she committed suicide.

    Police have arrested her mother on suspicion of murder.

    “Nirupama took her decision to marry, even though she knew her parents would not agree,” said 23-year-old Deepthi Bathini, a close friend of the woman.

    The director of the New Delhi-based women’s rights group WomenPowerConnect, N. Hamsa, also says honour killings are rising because of “a clash of generations.”

    “The young generation does not believe in the family (decision-making) structures because there are more opportunities — more girls have the courage to make their own decision,” she said.

    Cases of honour killings are also rife in rural areas, where village caste councils – “khap panchayats” – wield huge extra-legal powers.

    While under the constitution people are free to wed whomever they choose, the councils often issue edicts against couples who marry outside their caste or religion and condemn marriages within a kinship group or “gotra” – considered incestuous even though there are no biological links.

    In March, a court in Haryana state sentenced to death five people who had killed a young couple who had dared to wed despite being deemed “brother and sister” by village elders.

    Underlining how hard it is to change tradition, when the court passed judgement, village councils in the region staged big protests and demanded that the government change the law to ban such marriages.

    Nirupama’s friend Deepthi Bathini believes “honour killings” must stop.

    “For whose honour are they killing?” she said. “Every person must become aware of their rights and be able to defy these traditions.” – AFP

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Azhar,
    Mukhtar Mai was raped for honor in pakistan. So don’t tell us about what happens in India.

    By the way 40 people were killed and hundreds injured in 24 hours in Karachi..This is far worse than what is happening in J&K.

    We will provide moral support to MQM in their fight againt punjabi imerialism.

    Down with punjabi imperialism
    Long live Altaf Bhai..

    Altaf Bhai is pir of modern age who openly said that partition of India was biggest blunder. I salute this true muslim.
    Altaf Bhai tum pungi lagao…
    Kerosene humare saath hai..

    Pakistan mein Aag lagao
    Hindustan tumhare saath hai..

    Pakistan murdabad..
    Hindustan Paindabad..

    [Reply]

  • Azhar Hussain

    Go ISI a job well done in Kashmir

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Don’t worry..We will repay you double in Sindh and Balochistan..

    Sindh Banega Hindustan..
    pakistan banega kabristan…

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    AUr Kabristan mein cabaret karega hafeez Saeed aur Ajgar hussain :)

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    Ajgar ,

    Your voice is staid and tired! Look out of your window,,, the drones are coming! u r aout to become a peice of history !

    87 Pakistanis disappeared in Karachi last night and more are disappearing right now !
    Worry about them !

    US, Canada and UK are about to make Pakistan into history…

    Pakistan se zinda bhaag…
    Yeh hai nation barbaad….:)
    Pakistan se zinda bhaag

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    These white forks could not make Iraq history, there are getting the beating of their lives. Afghanistan has already taken care of India’s father USSR and and now the same is happening to Uncle Sam and NATO forces.

    You indians don’t have balls, I can underdatand u talking about usa and Nato.

    We are proud of ISI taking good care of you in Kashmire

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    The one person who realised the importance of Altaf Hussain was Narasimha Rao. In ealry ninties, Narasimha Rao managed to give Pakistan a taste of its own medicine thru Altaf bhai.

    Till IK Gujral sold everything for a Kabab platter.

    Let’s start talking to Altaf Bhai again!

    mOHJIRSTAN ZINDABAD !!

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Vijay,
    We should talk to Baloch and Sindh leader to solve Balochistan and Sindh disputre. This dispute has been going on for 63 years and it is time we start providing MORAL support ;) to opressed people.
    The pakistani punjabis have been treating Shindhis, balochis, Pathans and Balwaris as slaves, the time has come to free them from Punjabi domination.

    I think trifurcation of J&K should go hand in had with quadrafication of Pakistan.

    [Reply]

  • Jai Vaidya

    according to the recently released wikileaks, one of the wishlist of Pak army is “to keep Pakhtoon nationalism down.” Do you seriously think changing the name of NWFP to Khyber Pakhtoonwa will achieve that ? At some point Pakistan will have to come to terms with the illegal occupation of Pakhtoon lands.
    Please read Chris Alexander, former Canadian ambassador to Afghanistan and Matt Waldman, Harvard Kennedy School of Government. Oh, and yes, please feel free to quote extensively
    The use of PAF against the Marris and Bugtis are nothing less than war crimes.
    What is currently working in your favour is india’s visionless , lethrgic foreign office.

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted Sal

    There is the raw informations in wikilinks made by low level agents in afganistan and these information is neither verified nor confirmed. These 90,000 page documenst talks about more of civilians casualities by Nato & US troops in Afganistan than Pak’s ISI double dealing. And US itself didnt give so much importance on Wiki-Links except some informations of ground operations, military personnel etc.

    As far as ISI is concerned, these kind of news and/or David Cameron’s statement in Banglore comes from one ear and pass through other ear of ISI. Doesnt effetc ISI in any manner.

    US and Nato is happy to get whatever help from ISI as they can. They cannot afford to make ISI angry. At the end, there has to be some kind of arrangements between Karzai’s govt and Taliban and this process has already been started from last year. Only ISI has the capability to turn the table in Afganistan.

    @Vijay

    Pak is not using PAF against Marris and Bugti. I know a lot. What Pak will get to use PAF against few hundreds peopel who are dispersed when it can be done by other ways too..BTW..Bugti and Marris are armed though…What do you feel of killing of unarmed civilians who are stone pelting in Kashmir by your security forces for Independence.

    I guess even vinod Sharma will not talk abt that truth and he will talk about that truth which suits him most.

    [Reply]

  • Jai Vaidya

    Sal, You serial liar, Nawab Akbar Khan Bugti was killed by the PAF. Are you going to deny the PAF sorties agaibst Pakhtoons in South Waziristan? Of course NATO accepted what input they got from the ISI because they thought they were fighting on the same side. That nuance is now changing.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Jai Vaidya

    You are the one who is lieing. Nope..Akbar bugti was not killed by PAF. Akbar bugti was killed in a explosive but that explosive was not caused by PAF.

    Yes. Pak is using PAF in South Waziristan but I am talking about Marris anf bugtis who live in bugti and Mari area of Balochistan not FATA.

    Nope..it is not changing. ISI is sufficient enough.

    [Reply]

  • MM

    There is fire, deep resentment in common public against many politicians, Army, ISI. This is because this triangle are fighting, supporting each other. In the process they are making money for themselves. The enemy is not India for Pakistanis. It is enemy by propaganda created mainly by Army and ISI. India never attacked Pakistan and will never do. As I said previously situation is evolving in Pakistan against ISI and Army. Days are not far when final push will be given by common public and Army/ISI will be shown door. Earlier these three entities used to fight each other and not much effect was there on public. Now effect is very evident on common public in terms of lawlessness, poverty, less opportunity and cut fro mainstream of development. Any true Pakistani will tell you that these three organs of government are curse to his/her country and they need democracy and better governance. There has been many exchanges of people in sports, arts, culture etc. but the ISI/ Military duo has spoiled everything and it is there everyone to see it!

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @MM Meray Bhai

    Every politician of Pak, every citizen of Pak, Army, ISI are united when a word of “Kashmir” comes. Pak Army is very respected instituion of Pak and it is Kashmir issue that cause conflict between India and Pak. You said India had never attacked Pak then May I ask who captured Siachin. India captured Sachin because it was an empty land then. Had Pak Kashmir an empty land, India would have captured it a long time ago. The problem is you people look only one side a picture.

    [Reply]

    M.Shahid Kamal Reply:

    Any one who is interested in India- pakistan relationship will benifit from watching my lecture on “India-Pakistan Past, Presnt and Future.” Search Praire Fire news paper on Google.Go to any past or current issue. Cliclk on Winter Lecture Sreies And watch the fifth and last lecture on the above subject. Dr.Shahid Kamal

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    Dear Sal :)

    Do you really think KaSAB will get jannat, even after he is hanged in India after a free trial ?

    If u do u r a madcap fanatic like most Pakistanis…

    Do u r really think that Bugti died a natural death ?

    U got to be mad…

    Do you really think Pakistan will survive by cut and paste (like ur bro Ajgar Hussain thinks) and papering over the b urka problem?

    .And that of polygamy, which converts young people to become suicide bombers, thinking that they will get sex in jannat as they cannot get it on earth bcos the Rich and powerful of Pakistan marry all women thru polygamy?

    Sal, u joker, pakistan se jaldi bhaag
    Yeh hai Kabristan barbad…

    Pakistan se zinda bhaag
    yahan par hai Nark ABAAD ;)

    Cheers,

    Your pal

    Vijay kumar,

    (originally from Sialkot– his grandparents house and farm is still there…

    But coming back soon to eliminate communal killers and fanatics :)

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay meray bhai

    I have never said that Bugti died a natural death.

    [Reply]

    Jai Vaidya Reply:

    SAl
    Then tell us what your take of the sitiution forget about the % just tell us what happened?

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    Good to hear that Yor are origfrom Sialkot

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    *originally

    [Reply]

  • MM

    @Sal Why Nawaz Sharif is against these two entities? Why there are protests against Army? Why Pakistanis comes to India to earn and mingle with Indian citizens? Regarding Siachen India has not annexed it form Pakistan or attacked it. Again fact check here.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @MM

    Nawaz sharif is against the role of Pak military in politics. Nawaz Sharif is not against Pak military.

    “Why Pakistanis comes to India to earn and mingle with Indian citizens?”

    Even vijay and Rajiv didnt dare to say this who are the biggest of ***** here. If you are referring some singers or players then this is another thing..But if you are talking about common people then you need to go to a doctor.

    There are thousands of indian muslims leaving in Karachi who arrived here last decade. Should I ask why they came here.

    India captured Siachin in 1984 because it was an empty land. What does it mean…India has a right to capture any land which is empty.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    Fools keep repeating foolsih/false facts.
    The same ‘fake-degree syndrome’.

    ———————————————————————–
    Regarding Siachen, these are facts.
    ———————————————————————-

    1. Indo-Pak boundary commission demarcated LoC after 1971 war.
    Line of control maps, that were exchanged after 1971 war ( after India graciously returned 12,000 km of Pak territory in the West ) , did not mark Siachen. The maps stopped at the glacier and just said, the line of control , continues northwards from here.

    2. Siachen lay barren. Then in 1980 ties, Pak started giving permits to foreign mountain climbers to go to siachen, claiming the glacier to be its. Pak set up military posts and started building access roads.

    3. India protested. Pak pre-varicated.

    India interprets ‘northwards’ to mean simply ‘North’
    Pakistan said , northwards doen not mean North, but to just go along the same trajectory at which the LoC stopped !

    4. Then Indian PM Mrs Indira Gandhi, ordered operation Meghdoot to throw the Pakistani occupiers out of Siachen.

    5. Qatl-e-azam, ‘Qaid Post’ was also liberated and is now known as ‘Bana Post’ , after legendary hero of Siachen, Bana Singh.

    I have told the foolish ****-s , that the more they fight with India, the more they will lose.

    Its a self evident truth.

    If Pakistan wants to save what it has, the first step it must do is
    accpet the current LoC in Kashmir as international boundary.

    If it keeps fighting, its survival is at stake.

    Its a take it or leave it advice and Pakistanis are not known to be either rational or intelligent.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Rajiv

    You are the victum of your ignorance…

    Siachin was on the Pak side of LOC according to 1949 Karachi agreement (I doubt you ever heard it)…Pakistan had de facto control up to Line NJ 9842-Karakoram Pass (KKP) that includes Siachin. Here are some facts/figures below.

    1) Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Jawaharlal Nehru’s address to the Indian Parliament on 7th May, 1962, acknowledging Pakistan’s de facto control up to KKP (includes Siachin) , by stating “the defense of which is under the actual control of Pakistan.”

    2) The government of India’s protest note of 10th May 1962 to Pakistan, which referred to the area west of KKP (Siachin) as “…presently under Pakistan’s unlawful occupation.” (Muhammad, 1991) in response to communiqué issued about Pakistan China boundary negotiations.

    3) Indian Prime Minister Nehru’s address to Parliament of 5th March, 1963, again referring to Pakistan’s actual control of the area by stating. It then reached the Karakoram Pass.

    4) The words “thence north to glaciers10” in the Karachi Agreement and the actual location of the glaciers in the area i.e. Siachen ,Terram , Northern, Central and Southern Rimo Glaciers and the general direction as well as alignment of the line of control (LOC) leading up to Pt NJ 9842.

    Read more on Karachi agreement.

    Pak was sending foregin mountain climbers right from 1950s. It was in 1984 when Indra Gandhi launched operation to capture siachin. It was empty land. And It was another Indian lie in order to justify the occupation of siachin that Pak has captured first.

    Jai Vaidya Reply:

    amhooria Islamia, a monthly Baluchi magazine published from Panj-gar, published an interview in its 1999 February issue with Maulana Nawabzadaa Nabiullah Khan, a confidant of and adviser to Maulana Qazi Ahmed—the Amir of the leading Pakistani Islamic party, Jamaat-e-Islami. The interview was conducted by Jalil Amir. The following constitutes are excerpts from that conversation which reveals the fundamentalist ideology and designs of the organization and its leader.

    EQUALITY OF MEN AND WOMEN IS STUPIDITY

    Q: The women issue is very controversial nowadays. Taliban and some fundamentalist organizations restrict the freedom of women while some progressive Muslim intellectuals are insisting that the women are equal to men in all spheres. What are Qazi’s views on women?

    A: As I said earlier, the Prophet Mohammad’s (PBUH) views on women are the exact views of Qazi Ahmed and the Jamat. Equality of men and women is stupidity. What men can do, women cannot do. Women are weak physically and mentally compared to men. Men have to take care of women all the time.

    WOMEN MUST STAY HOME

    Women should not have a life outside the family. Education can be provided to them, but not to compete with men in public.

    NO VOTING RIGHTS FOR WOMEN UNDER SHARIA

    Qazi had said once that when JI comes to power in Pakistan, he will abolish the voting rights of women and minorities. Only the Muslim men can participate in voting or standing for elections. When I asked the proof from Hadiths, he had quoted many Hadiths in support of that. I asked him why is it that it is never talked about openly in the public by the Jamaat? Qazi had said that the hints are all over the place. But JI did not make it a big issue since the women who currently have the voting rights may vote against JI in the elections if such a thing is said openly.

    NON MUSLIMS IN MUSLIM COUNTRIES MUST PAY JIZYA

    Q: That brings us to the question of minorities. Will they have to pay Jizya tax?

    A: Yes. They have to pay the tax. As explained by Qazi Ahmed , the idea of Jizya is not protection money. But it is a monetary force on the non-Muslim to convert to Islam. Once the Jamaat comes to power, the minorities will be induced (forced) to become Muslims either by monetary or psychological factors.

    ALL INDIAN HINDUS WILL BE CONVERTED INTO ISLAM

    JI is already equating India with Hindus so that the Hindus of Pakistan will be forced to become Muslims. This was a very successful strategy during the Babri Masjid riots. JI was actively involved in destroying the Hindu temples in Punjab and Sindh. We ordered the destruction of the Hindu family property too. But our main aim was to destroy the Hindu temples. We wrote in the JI pamphlets that destroying each pagan temple makes a Muslim move closer to the heaven of Allah. We used the Hadiths in all the pamphlets. Babar destroyed the Ram temple in Ayodhya because he was a true believer. The same way, every Muslim should take it upon himself to destroy the Hindu temples in Pakistan. O! ur idea was to encourage the Muslims of India also to destroy the Hindu temples in India. But this was not met with much success since the Hindu police in India started attacking the Muslims who were doing Allah’s duty.

    Q: What kind of government does JI envisage for Pakistan?

    A: It will be the Sharia government. Sharia will be made our constitution so that the eminent Muslim scholars who had completed the schooling in Madrasas will be appointed as the Judges in every court. Qazi wanted to make the presidium on the same model as the Khalifa. Presently our idea is that the entire top leadership of JI as well as all three military Generals will be part of the presidium for which the Qazi will be the Khalifa.

    OUR MOTTO IS CONSTANT JIHAD

    Our motto is “Constant Jihad”. The idea is to keep Pakistan in a constant state of Jihad all the time. Qazi’s vision is that Pakistan will be! the centre of the new Islamic Empire that stretches from Burma to Afghanistan and from Srilanka to Tajikistan including Kashmir

    Towards that end, the Jamaat will use all tactics from terrorism in the kafir-controlled areas to negotiations in the Muslim controlled areas. Already the Jamaat leaders of Bangladesh and Jamaat leaders of India have accepted the primacy of Pakistani leadership in this regard.

    SRI LANKA AND BURMA WILL BE PRESSURIZED TO CONVERT TO ISLAM

    Q: What about Srilanka and Burma?

    A: Both are Buddhist nations. For that matter even Baluchistan and Afghanistan were Buddhist once while Sindh and Punjab were Hindu earlier. Buddhists are generally weaker in matters of faith. Hence we hope they will become Muslim with a little pressure. But that will happen only after Jamaat conquers first Pakistan and then India.

    Q: What are the plans for India? It looks like the entire India policy of the Jamaat revolves around Kashmir.

    A: Yes that is true. But that is for a very good reason. See Kashmir is like a keystone that sits on top of the arch. It is true that the arch holds the entire weight of the keystone. But if you remove the keystone, then the whole arch falls down. That is why it is called the keystone. Kashmir is the keystone for India. Once you remove that, then India can no longer be secular and it will not be a united country either. Once Kashmir is taken out, these militancy movements will break India by asking the similar freedom for Nagaland, Kerala, Mizoram, Meghalaya, Manipur, Assam, Jharkand, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal and Khalistan.

    INDIA WILL BE MADE A 100% MUSLIM NATION

    Q: Coming back to the same point, if India was to become many countries, how do you deal with the individual Hindu States? They may even become big enemies of Pakistan. Or they may again re-group to challenge Pakistan.

    A: Given the differences between the nationalities in India, the options for Pakistan are endless. Qazi’s vision is to make the entire India a 100% Muslim Nation. A United India, where Hindus are majority is an impediment to that. Like Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) made Muslims out of pagans of Arabia, Qazi also wants to make Muslims out of the pagans of India.

    Q: This is a great vision since this was not even possible for the Muslim dynasties and Moguls who ruled India for the last 700 years.

    A: True. That is because they had never really established the Muslim Empire. Though the Kings were Muslims, they had entertained the Hindus in positions of power. When you make an unequivocal statement that only Muslims are voters and declare that India is an Islamic Republic, then automatically the people will become Muslims. Little bit of terror had to be applied to the heart of Hindus and Christians. I will give you a best example. The portions which now constitute Pakistan had 25% Hindu population before Independence.

    TERRORIZATION IS THE BEST CONVERSION TOOL

    After Independence, a lot of Hindus migrated to India. Yet after the migration, the Pakistani Hindu population was 15%. Do you know what is the percentage now? It is less than 1%. How was this made possible? How did the Hindus convert to Islam in a short span of 20 years whereas for 700 years they had never converted to Islam? That is purely because of the terror of the Partition.

    That terror forced the Hindus who remained in Pakistan to become Muslims. Pure and simple. JI used similar techniques in Punjab and Sindh. Each time a riot breaks out in India, we had used that pretext to strike terror among the Hindus, Christians and Ahmaddiahs. The similar terror will be at the heart of every non-Muslim, both Hindu as well as Christian, in the coming years in the entire of India. PRPOHET SUCCEEDED WITH TERROR SO CAN WE Qazi is an analytical genius who knows every strategy that was used by Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) and which will be and should be used in India to achieve the total submission to Allah.

    Q: Do you envision a possibility that when Kashmir becomes part of Pakistan, there could be large-scale riots in India against Indian Muslims? Hence unwittingly Kashmir could lead to more deaths of Indian Muslims and damage Islamic Ummah.

    ANY MUSLIM ASSOCIATING WITH A POLYTHEIST BECOMES A POLYTHEIST

    A: Yes that is a possibility. But our ideology is based on Quran and Hadiths. Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) in numerous Hadiths and Allah in Quran had said that any Muslim who associates with a polytheist is a polytheist. Muslims cannot be friendly with a non-Muslim. This includes the Christians, Jews and Hindus. Also Mohammad (PBUH) says that even if the Muslim ruler is not good, the Muslims stay with the ruler rather than go out to a non-Muslim country. Hadiths and Quran are very explicit regarding this. All the Muslims who did not migrate to Pakistan during Partition are in essence Hindus. They may think that they are Muslims. But not before Allah.

    They are as self-deluded as the Ahmaddiahs who think they are Muslims when everyone knows that they are not Muslims. Hence the Muslims of India who had decided to stay in India during Partition are not Muslims and their progeny are not Muslim (since they did not migrate to Muslim lands).

    Another thing that I noticed in my journeys in India is that the Hindu farmers generally offer their entire harvest to their gods at the end of their harvesting season. This makes the entire crop as haram for Muslims. Yet these so-called Muslims of India are forced to eat this food which was already offered to some other God other than Allah. This is explicitly forbidden in Quran.

    MUSLIMS GOING TO NON MUSLIM COUNTRIES TO SETTLE DOWN ARE KAFIRS

    And this is one of the serious problems of living in non-Muslim countries. Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) knew such things; that is why he ordered Muslims not to live in non-Muslim areas. Yet knowingly these so-called Muslims live in India. AGAIN ALL THE MUSLIMS WHO MIGRATE TO OTHER NON MUSLIM COUNTRIES AND US ARE NON MUSLIMS . Only the Muslims who intend to come back are Muslims not the ones who decide to stay in such countries. Hence we do not care if such Indian Muslims die in the riots.

    But due to strategy reasons we do have excellent relations with these Muslims. All the Muslims who work for Pakistan and for the glory of Ummah are real Muslims. They are our front line troops in non-Muslim countries. Hence we have to distribute the arms and ammunitions to these real Muslims in case riots come to their door.

    The Kashmiri Muslims are pure Muslims who are toiling under the yoke of Hindu rule. They are victimized by the international conspiracy to keep them under the Hindu rule. That issue is part of the incomplete Partition, whereas the Indian Muslims have accepted Partition and stayed on in India knowingly.

    JAMAT WILL BRING SLAVERY BACK TO PAKISTAN Arabians own slaves. Though Allah says that the slaves should be treated in a nice manner, he did not advocate the abolition of slavery. If slavery is bad as considered in today’s world, Allah certainly would have said that slavery is wrong. Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) also said that the slaves should be treated in a good manner and the slaves should be released often. But if there is no slavery, how can anyone release slaves? Hence the re-introduction of slavery in Pakistan is one of the future plans of the Jamaat.

    ALL CAPTURED HINDUS WILL BE MADE SLAVES

    All the captured Hindu Indians and Srilankans will be made slaves to work for Pakistani Muslims. Every God-abiding Pakistani Muslim will get slaves once we conquer India. All the slaves who embrace Islam will be set free. Slavery is Islamic. Jamaat is the only political party, which does not voice any opposition to the slavery in Pakistan. We went around all over Arabia. We were surprised to know that there are some Hindus in Yemen. These ancient Yemeni Hindus are not Indians. In my opinion, these Hindus are traders from India in the ancient times. I was also surprised to know that they have a Shiva temple in Yemen. Qazi was very unhappy over this. When he talked to the Yemen leaders, he broached this subject. But the Yemeni leaders refused Qazi’s suggestion of forced conversion of these people to Islam. I don’t know why they refused. I think it may be due to the large population of Hindus from India who work in Yemen and Arabia. He disliked the current leadership of Arabia for this reason.

    In his opinion, Arabia should not allow any non-Muslim into the holy lands of Arabia. Arabia should be 100% pure. A large number of Hindus in Arabia is corrupting the Arabians. Though they live as contractors, they have the potential to corrupt the minds of the Arabians.

    HINDU TEMPLES POLLUTE MUSLIM LANDS

    One such thing is the presence of Arabians in the Qatar Hindu temple. First the king allowed the Hindus to build a temple and church in the holy lands, thereby polluting the Holy Land. Second is that even a member of the Royal family visited that temple to inaugurate that temple. To the horror of Qazi, he had learnt that one of the powerful members of the Qatar Royal family is a devotee of a god called Aayappan. This news resolved Qazi to fight the force of the devil thousand fold.

    Q: Such things happen in Pakistan today. I mean a friend of mine goes to a Hindu temple. Another friend goes to church meetings.

    A: Yes. One of Qazi’s relatives wanted to become a Hindu. He did not have a child for many years and it seems he had prayed to a Hindu God and got the child. Hence he felt thankful to that god and wanted to become a Hindu. Qazi got to know of this and called him and threatened him with dire consequences. That relative did not become a Hindu. But that incident made Qazi read more about apostasy.

    PUNISHMENT FOR APOSTASY IS DEATH

    Quran and Hadith clearly say the punishment for abandonment of Islam is death. Since Sharia is not the law in Pakistan, and the current Pakistani Constitution grants the right to change religion, it is legally correct to declare oneself as Hindu or Christian. But once the JI takes over the government, it will make Sharia as the Constitution. Then Pakistan will also legally execute any person who leaves Islam and joins Ahmaddiah, Christianity or Hinduism the same way Iran and Taliban treats its apostates. He also opined that the presence of the Hindu temples in Pakistan is the root cause of the problem and hence we want to destroy all the Hindu temples and Churches in Pakistan.

    Q: This brings us into another area. Right now the Internet is becoming widespread. Even Saudi Arabia is connected with the outside world. Destroying the temples may be good, but how can we insulate the Pakistani and Muslim people against the corrupting knowledge totally?

    A: JI had taken a principled stand on the matter of science and religion. Religion is far superior to science.

    ALL THE WORLD�S KNOWLEDGE IS IN QURAN AND HADITHS

    Whatever man needs to know is in the Quran and Hadiths. Knowing more will create problems like the Atom bomb and Television.

    MUSIC TV AND PHOTOGRAPHY ARE SATANIC AND HARAM Quran and Hadiths are explicit in denouncing pictures. Yet the lure of Satan in the form of photography and television is eating our lives.

    Music previously was confined only to the vocal singing. Now science and technology made the music widespread at a cheaper price. These are the lures of Satan. We have to be on guard against these harami things.

    SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY ARE BAD FOR CIVILIZATION

    Hence, more science and technology is bad for the civilization. I had completed civil engineering. Hence I am privy to scientific knowledge. I can tell you how corrupting that is. It even makes you question the glorious Quran.

    EARTH IS FLAT There are many Hadiths, which say that the earth is flat. But any science will tell you the earth is a sphere. But you can use the same science like the relativity theory to prove that the earth is flat. It is the same case with evolution. But the point being that doubt is sown in the minds of the people on the validity of the Quran as the word of God. More and more we work hard to prove the Quran’s scientific correctness, more and more people will get apprehensive of the truth of the Quran. This is an abomination.

    WHEN ISLAM TALKS OF GET EDUCATED IT MEANS QURANIC EDUCATION

    This is why when we talk of education, we talk of religious education and not scientific education.

    It is true that science grew after the Prophet’s revolution in Arabia. That was the start of science. Now each and every science is filled with anti-god stuff. If you want to become a doctor, you have to read evolution. If you have to read any engineering, you have to believe in the billions of years old universe theory which effectively says that human beings came to the world only just one or two million years back.

    Q: But we still need the arms and knowledge of the Western world, which believes in science. And again you had referred to television as evil. If we abolish photography how can we have passports or identification cards?

    A: Yes. That is strategic. With the help of Allah, we will be given oil for them to run their cars and we will have arms in that place. We will use their arms to destroy them in the course of time.

    PHOTOGRAPHY WILL BE BANNED UNDER JI

    As far as photos are concerned, they will be banned as it was done in Afghanistan under Taliban. If there is no need for people to go out of Pakistan, where is the need for the passports? For those who have to travel to other countries like the leaders of the revolution, they only will be given the passport with photos. For that, we will allow limited photography licensed only to the government. And the biggest corruption in today’s Pakistan is Indian satellite TV and Indian cinemas and Indian songs. We have to abolish these too.

    ARABIC WILL BE MADE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE OF PAKISTAN

    Q: Currently we have a lot of opposition from Mohajirs regarding reservations. What kind of reservation policy will the JI will have in Pakistan?

    A: We approach that problem as the problem of language. Urdu-speaking Muslims and Sindhi-speaking Muslims are fighting now. We plan to abolish all the regional languages like Pashto, Sindhi, Baluchi, Urdu, Punjabi and Brahvi. We want all the people of Pakistan to speak Arabic which is our divine language. This will make everyone equal before everyone else and there would not be any need for language or region based reservations. We also hope that this will make the Quran and Hadiths easier to understand and will make the people follow the Quran and Hadiths to the letter.

    Q: There could be language riots. One such language riot resulted in Bangladesh.

    A: Bangladesh was not a result of language riot. The very idea that they are Muslims will bring the Bangladeshis to Arabic. We already fund heavily the Arabic language courses all over India, Bangladesh and Pakistan. From Morocco to Iraq speaks in Arabic, I don’t see any reason why from Morocco to Burma we will not bring Arabic to the people. Even Bangladesh will start speaking in Arabic. That time there won’t be any Bangladesh where the country name itself has the name of the language. Yes. Right now our aim is just for reunification without touching on the language issue of Bengali. JI of Bangladesh is working towards this aim.

    Q: The secular journalists of Pakistan oppose the JI. For example the Dawn and News are very critical of the JI. How do you see their role in the future?

    A: Ardheshir Cowasjee is able to work only because of the present Constitution of Pakistan. When Sharia becomes the Constitution, he cannot even approach the court, as he is a kafir. We see secular journalists as our main enemy in the current struggle to reach power. These secular journalists are digging our statements we made during the pre-Independence days and trying to beat us. Of course we opposed the creation of Pakistan during the British times. But that was a different Jamaat. Our history starts with Independence.

    SECULARS ARE KAFIRS

    Secular journalists are not Muslims even though some of them are carrying Muslim names. Let them come to us and let us ask questions on the Quran and Hadiths. We will prove each and every thing we say is from Quran and Hadiths. Let them prove what we say as wrong from the Quranic angle. Then we will accept them. But they cannot. They cannot match us in any debate concerning the Quran and Hadiths. We can comprehensively prove that they are indeed non-Muslims.! They are like Quadianis who say that the Muslim need not take up Jihad as an obligation. That is pure nonsense.

    Q: Thanks for your time.

    A: May Allah’s blessings be with you.

    ——————————————————————————–

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Jai Vaidya

    Basically what the ‘great Islamic scholar of Pakistan’ is asying what every fascist, criminal ideology and cult has professed – from Nazism od Hitler , to communism of Stalin, to the Islamic fascism of Jinnah-Yahya perpetrated on the East Pakistanis.

    However, all such intolerant cults meet there end. Western world is waking up to the fact that Islam, as practiced in Pakistan, is incompatible with any civilized society.

    Rajeev Reply:

    Jai,
    Please provide link for this.

    A true revealing interview..now I know why pakistan is biggest producer of NUTS.

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    Thanks for posting this interview and for your information JI hardly wins any seat in the National or provisional assemblies in any elections.

  • Rajiv

    ————————————————————————
    Lesson 1 :
    Writing on the Wall : The more Pakistanis crave Kashmir, Jihad etc and fight India , The more they lose
    ———————————————————————————————————————————
    ———————————————————————–
    Regarding Siachen, these are facts.
    ———————————————————————-

    1. Indo-Pak boundary commission demarcated LoC after 1971 war.
    Line of control maps, that were exchanged after 1971 war ( after India graciously returned 12,000 km of Pak territory in the West ) , did not mark Siachen. The maps stopped at the glacier and just said, the line of control , continues northwards from here.

    2. Siachen lay barren. Then in 1980 ties, Pak started giving permits to foreign mountain climbers to go to siachen, claiming the glacier to be its. Pak set up military posts and started building access roads.

    3. India protested. Pak pre-varicated.

    India interprets ‘northwards’ to mean simply ‘North’
    Pakistan said , northwards doen not mean North, but to just go along the same trajectory at which the LoC stopped !

    4. Then Indian PM Mrs Indira Gandhi, ordered operation Meghdoot to throw the Pakistani occupiers out of Siachen.

    5. Qatl-e-azam, ‘Qaid Post’ was also liberated and is now known as ‘Bana Post’ , after legendary hero of Siachen, Bana Singh.

    I have told the foolish ****-s , that the more they fight with India, the more they will lose.

    Its a self evident truth.

    If Pakistan wants to save what it has, the first step it must do is
    accpet the current LoC in Kashmir as international boundary.

    If it keeps fighting, its survival is at stake.

    Its a take it or leave it advice and Pakistanis are not known to be either rational or intelligent.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Rajiv

    You are the victum of your ignorance…

    Siachin was on the Pak side of LOC according to 1949 Karachi agreement (I doubt you ever heard it)…Pakistan had de facto control up to Line NJ 9842-Karakoram Pass (KKP) that includes Siachin. Here are some facts/figures below.

    1) Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Jawaharlal Nehru’s address to the Indian Parliament on 7th May, 1962, acknowledging Pakistan’s de facto control up to KKP (includes Siachin) , by stating “the defense of which is under the actual control of Pakistan.”

    2) The government of India’s protest note of 10th May 1962 to Pakistan, which referred to the area west of KKP (Siachin) as “…presently under Pakistan’s unlawful occupation.” (Muhammad, 1991) in response to communiqué issued about Pakistan China boundary negotiations.

    3) Indian Prime Minister Nehru’s address to Parliament of 5th March, 1963, again referring to Pakistan’s actual control of the area by stating. It then reached the Karakoram Pass.

    4) The words “thence north to glaciers10” in the Karachi Agreement and the actual location of the glaciers in the area i.e. Siachen ,Terram , Northern, Central and Southern Rimo Glaciers and the general direction as well as alignment of the line of control (LOC) leading up to Pt NJ 9842.

    5) Delhi’s protest note to China “at this de facto recognition of Pakistan’s control of Hunza and
    Baltistan11” in the wake of Pakistan China Border Agreement (1963)

    Read more on Karachi agreement.

    Pak was sending foregin mountain climbers right from 1950s. It was in 1984 when Indra Gandhi launched operation to capture siachin. It was empty land. And It was another Indian lie in order to justify the occupation of siachin that Pak has captured first.

    And Siachin has an area of roughly 1000 sq miles which adds upto India’s total Kashmir of 38,000 sq miles. The situation is out of control in Kashmir valley and Omar Abdullah himself is saying..No one or no one group is responsible for uprising in Kashmir. Kashmir will definitely get independence from India as blood of Kashmiris will not go waste.

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    Sal I commend you for teaching these blind undians a lesson in history….but as always these monkeys will come back, start the ritual of abuse of Pakistan, Islam and Muslims.

    Keep up the good work

    Our pride ISI doing a great job, thats why these jokers spend sleepless nights

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    Well, as I said venal criminal Pakistanis and there fake degrees and fake history.

    Everything I say can be checked on the web and independentlyt verified.

    If you can read english and understand it, search for Siachen glacier or operation Meghdoot and learn for yourself.

    Sal Reply:

    @Rajiv…

    Everything you write here is from Wikepedia and I know it very well.

  • Jai Vaidya

    Sal,
    This is what j happened to the 15% Hindus and Sikhs in Pakistan after Partition. You have, however, skirted the issue of why NWFP should be in Pakistan. You say Nawab Akhtar Bugti was killed by” explosive”. Akhbar Bugti lived in a cave deep inside a mountain. Please explain this explosion business?

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Jai Vaidya

    1) No..I dont accept that 15% of Pakistan were hindus and Sikhs at the year of 1950. You have to give me a reliable source…Yes a reliable source supporting your claim.

    2) NWFP has joined Pak thorugh referendum. OK..Dont give me conspiracy theory.

    3) Nawab akbar bugti has died in a explosive in a cave. Pak Gove claim that Bugti had exploded himself in order to avoid arrest and few soldiers too had died in that explosive. While Barahamdad Bugti claim, he was died in a explosive which is caused by Pak troops but certainly not PAF. You can buy any of the claim. I dont care.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Jai Vadiya

    One more thing..you are keep changing your stance. First, you said that 15% of West Punjab was Hindus & Sikhs. Now you are saying that 15% of Pak were hindus and Sikhs.

    The same case is with Akbar Bugti.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    http://pakistanhindupost.blogspot.com/

    “The Hindu population in Pakistan, which was between 15 and 24 percent in 1947, at the time of partition of India, has now been reduced to less than two percent.”

    The wikipedia and other sources also give similar figures.
    Almost all the big cities in Pakistan, had Hindu/Sikh majority.
    45% of Lahore was Hindu-Sikh.
    70-80% of Lahore properties, were owned by Hindus and Sikhs.
    3 of the largest cities in Sindh had Hindu majority.

    You can read ‘Freedom at Midnight’ , one of the greatest partition history books , by French researchers on the subject.

    Sal Reply:

    @Rajiv

    I didnt find anything on your link. Second, I doubt its credibility too.

    “45% of Lahore was Hindu-Sikh.” This is true.

    “70-80% of Lahore properties, were owned by Hindus and Sikhs.” That also true. Have you ever though why muslims were in a backward place in such a city like Lahore where they were in majority as compared to Hindus and Sikhs.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    Sal and Azhar are ‘jewels in the crown of Pakistan’ , just like criminals Kasav, every terrorist organization from
    Jesh-e-Mohammad, Lashkar-e-toiba, Lashkar-e-mohammad to Muhammaded-e-muhammad ( If it does not exist, it will soon) .

    There fake history should be an eye opener for every Indian why Pakistan today is what it is.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    Pakistan and Baluchistan.
    ————————————————
    http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?266484

    There is a very revealing and detailed article in Outlook on this subject.
    Definitely a must read.

    Some excerpts

    Baluch leader , Khair Bux Mari , In a recent interview to a Sindhi newspaper,declared

    ” “The British only laid the foundation of our slavery but the Punjabis bathed us in blood and kept us slaves. What would we do in such circumstances? Obviously, we would retaliate.”

    Ex US Ambassador Robert Blakewell and journalist Michael hughes argue

    Hughes’ essay, “Balkanising Pakistan: A collective national Security Strategy – Breaking Pakistan to Fix It” argues that,

    …as a result of flawed boundaries combined with the nexus between military rule and Islamic extremism, Pakistan now finds itself in rapid descent toward certain collapse and the country’s leaders stubbornly refuse to do things required to change course. But before allowing Pakistan to commit state suicide, self-disintegrate and further destabilise the region, the international community can beat them to the punch and deconstruct the country less violently.

    Sooner or later, India has to stop mouthing that stupid argument that a ” strong Pakistan is good for India”

    [Reply]

  • ahmed

    keep on fighting, i do have an idea, in future y dont we fight at borders via hockeys and sticks?

    i think fight with india is right option but v(pak) should pay atntion to our economy first, indians have gotten advantage of our current grround conditions(terrorism),just see as the time went by what will happen to inidianz keep trust in ur leadership, japan 2nd largst econmy with 120 million people, we 170 millon(30-40 bi economy see cia fact book) can do alot of things, just try to focus on the article said above, rawalpindi is key foreign policy making unit in pakistan, it is a fact and v(pak) dont have any problem/

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    The bad bad news coming from beloved Pakistan;

    It does not surprise anyone since the height of intolerance comes out of this evil vile mafia state:

    Read this: It from THE HINDU, the most tolerant of Indian newspaper, when it come to Pakistan>
    ===========================================================================

    Was it ignorance, oversight or bigotry? This is the question doing the rounds on the Internet as young Pakistanis come to terms with the coffin of Premchand – one of the 152 passengers killed in last week’s plane crash in Islamabad – being labelled as `kafir’ (non-believer).

    A bit of everything seems to be the answer from the discussion triggered on various websites. The reactions range from remorse and disgust at denying the youngster respect in death to anger at why an issue is being made of what may have just been a clerical error.

    Premchand, a social worker from Sanghar in Sindh, was among the six members of the Youth Parliament killed in the plane crash. What made his death stand out was what happened later. Summing it up, the first post on the online discussion forum `pakistaniat.com’ said: “His death – like the death of everyone on that flight – was a matter of national tragedy; the treatment of his dead body a matter of national disgrace.’’

    Friends who identified Premchand’s body were quoted by news reports as saying that the coffin came marked `kafir’. The word literally means ‘infidel’ or ‘non-believer’, but it is seen as an insult in these parts. “It was shocking. He could have been marked as Hindu or non-Muslim, but using the word `kafir’ is the worst example of intolerance.’’ Muneeb Afzal, a member of the Youth Parliament (MYP) said; recalling that the night before the crash he had received greetings from Premchand to mark the 15th of Shabaan.

    ================================================================================

    Intolerance and hatred of non Sunni Muslims has seeped into every aspect of Pakistan. This episode just proves that.

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    I am adding a chapter from personal history. Sal, just that “it was good to hear that you are originally from Sialkot.’

    Well, Sal, I am just letting you know why he had to leave Sialkot.

    On 2nd August 1947, a mob of at least 5,000 surrounded, his house as it did of the other Hindus in the district. The message was simple.

    Get killed or convert to Islam. Or Just get out.

    Some friends, including a few Muslims, managed to keep the mob at bay for the day.

    This was the stark truth. NO papering over.

    Some of the HIndus, especially the women were lifeted and converted. He just chose to leave Sialkot and go to what was to be India.

    MOst of the Non Muslms chose to leave. Many were killed on the way.

    In contrast, the message to the Muslims in India was very different.

    Pakistan has been created. If you want to go there, it is your choice. If you stay India welcomes you.
    In fact many Muslims did go. Many opted to stay here. After some days there was a curious signal from the authorities in Pakistan. That no more Muslims were welcome. we have had our fill.

    Now Sal, look deep in your heart ande tell me, which ideology is superior?

    I look forward to your answer.

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    The first para should read as–
    I am adding a chapter from personal history. The story of my grandad who had to leave Sialkot with his two sons and wife.

    Sal, just said that “it was good to hear that you are originally from Sialkot.’

    Well, Sal, I am just letting you know why my grandfather had to leave Sialkot.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Vijay,
    Thanks for sharing your personal anecdote.
    You also brought out the contrast between India and Pakistan well.

    There are thousands of stories on both sides of the border.
    You can read history books from indepndent souces and find out who started the riots and which political parties existence and ideology depended on communalizing the situation.
    You can read, reports filed by the British Governor of Punjab about which leaders and which party was going around, trying to incite the vilest of human emotions, based on religion.

    Tens of millions of Muslims, chose to stay in India. Indian political leaders ideology of secularism, Gandhi , Nehru’s political ideology of treating all Indians as equals, was among the reasons. Today India has almost as many Muslims as Pakistan itself.
    Thats tells the story of tolerance and bigotry, good Vs bad, India Vs Pakistan more than anything else.

    [Reply]

  • Jai Vaidya

    Vijay Kumar
    I really feel for what your family went through.I ggrew up in Delhi ,most of the peaple in my neighborhood held similar memories.I wish i had met your grandad,I would have touched his feet.

    [Reply]

    Vijay Kumar Reply:

    THx Jai

    He is no more.. but I have very fond memories of him :)

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar

    Obivously, this happened to your parents/Grand parents in Sialkot at the time of partition and then they have told you about that. It was not just you but millions have faced that situation. This happened to muslims too. I feel sorry for that.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    but the difference is that India has 15% muslims up from 10% in 1947 whereas hindus who were 20% in pakistan have gone down to 1.5%.

    Sal Reply:

    You didnt provide me any reliable source yet to support your claim.

    Rajeev Reply:

    Sal,
    It is a fact that there were 20% hindus in pakistan..where did they disappear?
    If you google for it, you will get lots of links to prove this. It is not our duty to educate ignorant people.

  • Rajiv

    @Vijay,
    Thanks for sharing your personal anecdote.
    You also brought out the contrast between India and Pakistan well.

    There are tens of thousands of similar stories on both sides of the border.
    You can read history books from indepndent souces and find out who started the riots and which political parties existence and ideology depended on communalizing the situation.
    You can read, reports filed by the British Governor of Punjab about which leaders and which party was going around, trying to incite the vilest of human emotions, based on religion.

    Tens of millions of Muslims, chose to stay in India. Indian political leaders ideology of secularism, Gandhi , Nehru’s political ideology of treating all Indians as equals, was among the reasons. Today India has almost as many Muslims as Pakistan itself.
    Thats tells the story of respect of diversity Vs bigotry, good Vs bad, India Vs Pakistan more than anything else.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Rajiv
    your opinion that Hindu -Muslim animosity was initiated by the British is a good demonstration of how much Indians are deluded. Hindus , right from the beginning had a feeling of hatred for the Muslims because of the atrocities committed by the Muslim emperors and religious fanaticism inherent to Islam.

    this resentment against Muslims faded down a bit after the advent of the Raj , because of the common enemy , but it didnt die down. the British having understood this used it for fulfilling their own purpose. i frankly believe , creation of Pakistan was one good thing one by the British to the Hindus and other Indians as well.

    the diversity and respect that you talk of is nonsense. Nehru and Gandhi were just hypocrites. their attitudes of fake nationalism and fake secularism are reflected in modern India in the form of our media , biased judiciary , Congress and the bunch of pseudo secularists that we see today.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    by the way the interview presented by Jai Vaidya is quite interesting and informative and gives a detailed explanation for the fact that why Pakistan is such a s-h-i-t hole.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Paritosh,

    You completely mis-understood what I said. Re read what I wrote.
    No where do I blame the British.

    I am referring to politics of Jinnah and Muslim League , in the reports filed by the British governoe of Punjab.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Paritosh,

    Other point is that one can sensibly argue that there is nothing wrong with the creation of Pakistan but everything is wrong about the way it was created.
    There is something viciously wrong with way it was created , based on primacy of one religion in the region which disenfranchised, killed, converted or expelled millions of Hindus living there.
    Ends don’t justify means and its that ideology that created Pakistan and the political-religious rhetoric that accompanied it, which has crippled the state of Pakistan , prevented it from becoming a democratic, pluralistic state and vitiated the relations between India and Pakistan.

    Ofcourse, I disagree with your remarks about Nehru, Gandhi and tolerance of diversity.

    Gopi Thomas Reply:

    @Paritosh@rajiv

    i disagree on Paritosh’s comments about Mahathmaji. Mahathmaji was a true leader who knew what Indians wanted and what their destiny was. A Karmayogi he was; he lived like Dharmaputra of the great mythology/great creation of Ved Vyasa. Satya and Dhrma were his bedrock principles; and Ahimsa (non-violennce) a way to achieve them. He in deed is a “yug purush”; and we should be proud that he was our father of nation — a great country is blessed with a father like that; in the lineage of Budha, Jesus, may be even the Prophet. He did “nishkama karma”.. We may feel animosity based on how certain things ended up; a lot of that had to do with Nehru. Mahathmaji did everything for the people; and in that one of his faults was that he did not care about his wife and children. While that is bad; it is 100 times btter than what the modern day leaders do to perpetuate family dynasties; Nehru being the prime example.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Gopi

    the so called “Mahatma” was only a hypocrite who preached Hindu-Muslim peace but was always biased against the Hindus. he blamed the Hindus for every riot that occured at the threshold of independence.

    he neglected his family as well , is another example of his faulty character.
    he even used to freedom fighters with other ideologies like S.C Bose and Bhagat Singh and his fellows.

    Buddha and Jesus may be Yug Purush , but the rapist paedophile , sex maniac prophet Muhammad of Islam is not even worth of being called as slush pig

    Rajeev Reply:

    Gopi,
    That’s way over the top… :)

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Gopi Thomas
    Please allow me to intervene. Though Gandhi became to be known Mahatma Gandhi for unknown reasons, even ST/ST people resent being called “Harijan” now as making them tagged by this name brought division in the society. This resulted their being discriminated in general public. Besides this, Mahatma Gandhi was lucky to have been fighting the apparently civilised Britishers as colonial rulers. The actual revolution which ultimately brought independece to the nation was the initiation of 1857 armed forces mutiny and then the struggle and sacrifices of Bhagat Singh, Lala Lajpat Rai and Subhash Chander Bose and many other unnamed and unsung martyrs.
    It is simply to put my perception in this regard without being disrespectful to Mahatma Gandhi.
    Regards
    BNA

    vijay kumar Reply:

    Sal, you genius of dodging and fudging … :)

    Sorry if you get the meaning wrong. But I asked you a straight question.

    What is the better ideolgy and what is the ideology the world should follow. You are not willing to give me the answer.

    Probably you the answer in your heart. That any ideolgy which eliminates people of other religions, which also sends terrorist all over the world is evil. But of course you cannot say this.

    Now let me ask you another question.

    Pakistan is right now submerged in floods. Its President and PM are begging the world for aid, money and food to help the 6 million Pakistanis who are submerged. India, US and many countries are giving this aid. People who give this aid are HIndus, Christians, Muslims, Jews and Buddhists.

    Yet you guys have no qualms of accepting the aid, the food, the technology yet will start sending your LeT, your mad preachers, your Al Qaueda, Sipahi-Sabah etc etc to thes very countries you get this aid from.

    QUESTION: Is’ nt it your duty to kill the Taliban, LeT etc etc before you take this aid? Why should you take aid from Christians and Jews, when you canot allow Christians to preach, or Become the PM. Why should you not reappeal laws which stop Muslims from changing religions before you take this aid? Hindus and Sikhs and Christains can be converted to Islam in your country, but the reverse is not possible. Why Why?? WHY ???

    If you say you believe that Islam is supreme and is the best religion and the religion of Pakistan, than why beg for aid from those you consider Kafirs, infidels and worthy of being killed by your squads and schools of suicide bombers.

    Answer my question without dodging. :)

    Vinay Reply:

    Gandhi might or might not have initiated Indian freedom struggle. He may not be the sole reason for us to get freedom (England was not in a stage to control India after the world war, anyway). But his main achievement was his discovery of “alternate fighting”, leading the entire country in this route and never budging to shortcuts of violence (saying means is as important as goal). This is what makes him apart from so many revolutions happening in our society.

  • Usman Chaudhry

    Bazeecha-e-itifal hay dunia meray agay
    hota hay shabo roz tamasha meray agay (Ghalib)

    It took me a lot to collect the inside of me to have a final go as the same old rant/chant is making lesser and lesser of an interest to read quality remarks and even to stick to this blog.

    In the statement below

    Wikileaks’ Afghan diary is a wake up call for the Americans, the Brits and other NATO allies. If ISI could be that pernicious under their very nose, what’ll happen when they turn their backs on Afghanistan?

    I’d like to draw an attention that within the afghan diary more criticism is sighted towards washington for its henious crime against humanity and not ISI/Islamabad. Nearly 70% of massive artillary usage resulted against civilian population, people who had no links with any terrorist activity. Furthermore, it was also made aware that Pak involvement is due to biased opinion of the afghan intelligence agency which obviously are against Pak and its one time strategic partner Taliban so nothing concrete can be said but the speculations can be right/wrong. Afterall it is Washington that is more vocal on the issue these days.

    Even if ISI is involved and causing serious harm i wonder how come they were not able to contain the pakistani section of taliban.

    Usman

    Ref: http://wardiary.wikileaks.org/

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Usman Chaudhry

    agreed that in the American military operations against the Taliban in Afghanistan , many innocent civilians were also injured or killed. however your blame on the Afghan intelligence shows your lack of knowledge about the issue.

    in some documentary that i watched last month, the host asked ordinary Afghans , the reasons for the dilemma their nations is going through , and they would point towards the mountains and say “PAKISTAN”

    Wikileaks , furhter more reveals that it was general Ashfaq Kayani was providing armed equipments to the Taliban for fighting against NATO and American troops and potentially against India too.
    now i came to know , why our embassies were bombed and by whom.

    anyways , this Frankenstein monster of Taliban that you have created will ultimately destroy your very own worthless s-h-i-t piece of Pakistan.

    will you b-l-o-o-d-y P-a-k-i-s ever learn!!??

    [Reply]

    Usman Chaudhry Reply:

    Mr Paritosh,

    Please use inverse approach to judge the situation. Afghans do blame us for the mess that ISI would have created in the form of weapon support to any militant organization against NATO use. The point is which one has created more destruction. Either Taliban or the operation strikes that caused 20,000 lives in 6 yrs. Irrespective of that if Taliban is what we support then why is on daily basis we face the same threat at the hands of Taliban who cause militancy in Pakistan. Is ISI financing and supporting them to create havoc in Pakistan? That is beyond comprehension. So atleast if we sponsor out terror then why is terror inside?

    If you watch the clip of the reference mentioned above you’ll witness that it is wikileaks claim and not mine that complete authenticity cannot be penned down for support of Taliban by ISI. Speculations are there.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Usman Chaudhry

    i am not an America supporter anyway in the first case. indiscriminate American bombing in Afghanistan is also in some way responsible for intensifying the conflict and destruction. however much of their targeted bombing goes against Taliban camps. there are a very few instances where American bombing has caused civilian destruction. in majority of times , its the Taliban that gets killed and its necessary.

    now coming back to Pakistan. taking the disadvantage of this situation of chaos , Pakistan is digging its own grave by helping Taliban re-establish its power , by supplying weapons. this help is directed against U.S and NATO troops and peaceful Indian establishments in Afghanistan.

    Taliban perpetrated bombings in Pakistan because Pakistan was forced by the U.S to bomb their targets , and the P-a-k-i-s exactly did the same.
    this truce between the Pakistan army and the Taliban , that the army will provide support to them has led to some kind of patch up between both the parties.( pak army and Taliban). that is why today you dont get to hear many bombings in Pakistan.
    the relationship between both is a bit topsy turvey.

    but ultimately , Pakistan ko jahannum toh naseeb hona hi hai.

    Usman Chaudhry Reply:

    Thanks for the reply and good that you are able to disscuss well with some reasonable arguments.

    If you have any credible news for Pak army making truce with Taliban please do share it with me. What im aware of and even following the news excerpts so far all talks within previous three years have been turned down from either side. The reason for drop down in bombings is something else and the source of which originates from Afghanistan. But i agree with those who claim Afghanistan is muddled with conspiracies. Who comes out winning is another riddle.

  • http://deleted Sal

    @Rajiv

    Sorry to say you, you are the lier. Here is what I found in your link.

    “In August 1947, at the end of British Raj, the population percentage of Hindus in what is today in Pakistan was perhaps as high as 15-20%, but would drop to its current total of 2% in the years since independence.”

    by http://pakistanhindupost.blogspot.com/ (from Rajiv Source)

    It clearly says that in August 47, Hindus in Pak were as high as 15-20%. But doesnt tell anything about the % of Hindus in the year of 1950 (or 1952 when border was open and people could have migrate) . A very mass migration has been done from India to Pak and Pak to India after partition (August, 1947). This is why I ask you about the % of Hindus in Pak at the year of 1950.

    Atleat, you should read the link.

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    This liars can’t even stick to the topic at hand. Vinod Sharma is just sitting on side instead of moderating, what a farce this blog.

    Sal cut and paste gives more facts than liars can rant and rant.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @Azhar Soower Hussain

    whatever be the topic , you losers can never see the truth.
    by the way your knowledege of the world and related aspects is also copy and paste.
    copy from the s-h-i-t book Quran and paste it in the minds.

    [Reply]

    Usman Chaudhry Reply:

    @Paritosh
    Beware of those words and mind your language.

    @Azhar
    Best is to ignore and dont add more to futile discussion if no decent response in reply.

    @Mr Sharma
    Please use moderation/filter to wipe out comments that do not add any useful meaning.

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    @Paritosh
    Pl do not misuse the freedom we have on this blog to state our side of the picture. It is really sad that you time and again use language that does not behove any civilised person. Your description of the holy Quran is both regrettable and condemnable.

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Paritosh,
    Though I have much regards for you as a fellow blogger with whom I share views and which are very often almost identical. But I beg to differ with you on your making such an unbecoming remark about the Muslim holy book “Qoran”.
    We may like this holy book or not but we shall also not appreciate someone abusing our holy books like Ramayana and Bhagwad Gita.
    We must observe restrain while commenting on any holy book. That is my sincere view and rest assured, it is not for appeasing any one.
    Regards
    BNA

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    @Azhar
    I am not watching the fun as suggested by you. Sometimes I am so shocked by the kind of language you people use here that I find it demeaning to join the debate.
    I am not going to discontinue this blog as the trolls who visit it are vitiating the debate to make me do exactly that. Their agenda will not succeed.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    I guess all anti-Indian people are decent one and others are troll..
    Did you even bother to read ***** posted by Azhar and Sal?

    You are the biggest troll in media..Shame on you.

    Rajiv Reply:

    @bigots

    In India , the % of Muslims that make up India today is actually more than the % of Muslims that made up the current boundaries of India, in 1947.

    In Pakistan, the most venal Islamic state in the world, they have been annhilated, reduced from 15-20% in 1947 to like 1% today.

    The period 1947-50 is the most important period, when a criminal state launched a religiously driven victimization of its citizens and has carried forward that same ideology to today in Pakistan.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Usman

    i need not mind my language nor keep any restraint in insulting your country men because you people are worthless losers deserving no respect at all.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Rajiv

    correction in my previous reply – ” he even used to curse freedom fighters with other ideologies like S.C Bose and Bhagat Singh and his fellows.”

  • Vijay Kumar

    @ Rajiv,

    Thx.

    The current situation in Jammu, Ladakh and Kashmir is only a grim reminder that we are being lax in doing our homework, regarding tri-furcation. I hope you are send some mails on the subject. On my part I have already sent out at least 100 and getting a huge positive response.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Vijay,
    On my part , I am bringing that up when ever I communicate on the Kashmir issue with others.

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted Sal

    @Eveyone

    A very big portion of 15% of Pak i.e. (Hinus & sikh) had migrated to India from time period of 1947 to 1952 and even after 1952.

    Roughly 7 to 10 Millions Hindus and Sikhs had migrated to India from 1947 to 1952 from Pak. This migration has reduced to % of non-muslims in Pak.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    That’s a big fat lie..Hindus were harrassed, converted, killed and made to flee between 1947-1965.
    That’s the main cause of decline.
    There were many hindu pundits in Pakistan occupied kashmir who were forced into Islam.

    You guys have no shame.

    [Reply]

  • Ankit

    Are yaar, Vinod Sharma is a totally petty shameless chamcha of Congress party. I used to think that at least he is intelligent but was laughing my brains off yesterday watching him on TimesNow. He got so worked up about criticism of Suresh Kalmadi on CWG, he started on a tangent about BJP and started abusing the other panelists.

    With journalistic pretenders like these, the future of HT is quite bright. With this level of intelligence Mr. Sharma may not be able to get a Rajya Sabha seat he is looking for. He will continue to ensure one for the proprietors with his shameless pandering though.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    I think he should call himself pro-congress journalist. There is no shame in that.

    [Reply]

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Oh boy, was someone ” frothing at the mouth” last night.( this phrase borrowed from a blog written by Mr VS’s compatriot Ms Sujata Ananadan , which she had used for a BJP leader who is no longer alive.) As the Congress Party has now decided to distance itself from the CWG loot and Kalmadi and they decided to send in their proxy Mr VS to do their dirty job. . Mr VS made a remarkable attempt to derail the discussion . He smiled at Dipankar Mukerjea MP , tried to ” Dipankar Da ‘ him , , tried to bamboozle Swapan Daspupta, tried hard to convert it to an “Anti BJP – Secularim discussion ” but failed miserably. All panelists unanimously said Kalmadi has to go and go now.
    Now The Congress and its proxies keep throwing ” National Pride at stake ” to duck all questions about the loot of public money but the leader of the Nation , the ” Nominated Prime Minister of India ” continues to be in hiding . Actually he is yet to recieve instructions from his Appointing Authority. The Appointing Authority is waiting to see which way the cookie crumbles. In the meanwhile , a safety route has already been opened through old time crony Mani Shankar Iyer.

    [Reply]

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    @
    ankit, rajveen and praveen
    Reading out from the same script. You guys have nothing original to say except abuse and question the integrity of those who do not agree with you. I don’t get rattled or intimidated that easily boys…..ha ha ha. Keep boiling your blood for you cannot shed it in defence of a cause.

    [Reply]

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Dear Mr VS

    Pl don’t boy me . I have probably seen more summers than you.What I write is what I feel, on issues which concern all of us. After all you are also in the public domain and therefor there shall be criticisms and praises as well. Also I have never used abusive or profane language.. But I must praise you for one thing , that you never delete the comments even though can be bitter on you personally and oftentimes they are in quite abusive and objectionable language.

    But by the way , when shall we see you as a Member of the Rajya Sabha. Pl be quick as UPA may not last long. It is hurtling towards disaster the way it is out of its depths on Kashmir, Prices , Pakistan and now CWG.

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    @Praveen
    You know nothing about me and yet you choose to pass value judgement. By the way, what do you have to say about the BJP’s trojan horses in the media. Nothing perhaps because you are hitched on the same ideological bandwagon. That is why you defend those who cannot defend themselves in televised debates with me.

    Ankit Reply:

    I like that “ha ha ha” thing; really shows Vinod Sharma’s class. If political editor of a major newspaper of our country writes at this level, it is not surprising that people have such a low opinion of the media.

    I also like the fact that Mr. Sharma has accepted that he is the Congress’s trojan horse in the media. Morality requires that he make it clear every time he goes on TV instead of pepetrating a fraud on the viewers.

    Rajeev Reply:

    Wow..Calling some one Congress loyalists is an ABUSE in the eyes of Mr.Sharma…

    He has such low opinion of congress.

    Rajiof this blog wv Reply:

    @Praveen,

    I dont think its a good idea to abuse the writer of thie blog, who offers you the opportunity to freely express your view, without moderation.

    [Reply]

    Praveen Saxena Reply:

    Mr VS

    Congratulations on your new public assignment . I heard it this morning on the Akashvani News.

    Rajeev Reply:

    Sal,
    You need to listen to this and shut up.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tO4GJuKMrak

    Sal Reply:

    I know Hassan Nissar better than you.

    vijay kumar Reply:

    sAL,

    Its your fake history books written by idiots with fake degrees whcih tell u India is poor. We are much much richer than Pakistan and soon will be the third largest economy of the world.

    Paksitan of course will only be the biggest producer of suicide bombers and terrorists :)

    Just because you are a failed nation dont try to include us in yhour category :) :)

    All that news of Indians being poorer than Africa is hypperble induced by a few communists of India who want us to follow the Marxist pattern. Copme here and see.

    We are middle calss and getting richer :)

    While Pakistan id drowning in jihadis and suicide bombers :) :)

    Aha ahh H aha ah :)

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    @Parveen Saxena
    Thanks, but I haven’t heard anything formally about it yet dear.

  • Rajiv

    ——————————————————————
    Sultan Sahin, in New Age Islam
    —————————————————————

    Cultural and ethnic minorities in Pakistan are in great distress, with suicide bombers routinely killing sectarian minorities like the Shia and the Ahmadi during prayers inside mosques, cross border terrorism once again raising its head after a brief lull, terrorists trained in Pakistan seeking to perpetrate terror even in the West.

    After a few threatening noises following the recent Times Square bombing attempt, the international community appears to be treating its dealings with Pakistan as business as usual. But if we are to get rid of the menace of massive violation of the human rights of sectarian, religious, ethnic minorities and women in Pakistan as well as cross border terrorism, it’s high time the world took the issue of neutralising the epicentre of terrorism in the world more seriously.

    Recently, nearly a hundred Ahmadis were killed while praying in their mosques in Lahore. This kind of killing has become virtually routine for another sectarian minority, the Shia. Suicide bombers regularly invade their mosques on the pretext of praying with them and explode themselves, killing scores of their co-religionists. Ethnic minorities like the Baluchis, Mohajirs, Pashtuns and Sindhis are under constant pressure of varying intensity at different times on different pretexts.

    Religious minorities

    Religious minorities like Hindus and Christians face similar persecution. There have been several incidents of these religious minorities having had their prayer houses burnt down, killing scores. Forced conversions to Islam, particularly of Hindu girls, who are abducted first, have become another routine. Hindu minorities who constituted 23 per cent of the population at the time of Pakistan’s creation in 1947 have now been reduced to barely 2 per cent. These religious minorities, along with the Ahmadis, also suffer from Pakistan’s notorious blasphemy laws which prescribe death for alleged defamation of Islam. In the case of Ahmadis their mere claim to be Muslim constitutes blasphemy. This leads to some ridiculous but deadly situation for the minorities. Two Ahmadi teachers were put under detention and faced the threat of death penalty merely because their bikes had a sticker containing a verse of the Holy Quran, (Is God not sufficient for His servant?). Ten important functionaries of the Ahmadiyya Community were detained under PPC 295-A, 298-C and 295-C which carry long imprisonments and death penalty for writing the following in their correspondence:

    (In the name of God, the Gracious, the Merciful)

    (We praise Him, and invoke blessings on His Noble Prophet)

    (May peace and Allah’s mercy be with you)

    A case was registered under the Blasphemy law on 12 October 1994 against three Ahmadis for translating the Quran in Sindhi language. Subsequently, two more Ahmadis were added to the final charge sheet, alleging them to be the publishers.

    In this age of the internet it will not be difficult for anyone to find hundreds of examples of such persecution of the ethnic, religious and sectarian minorities in Pakistan.

    International dimension

    Pakistan’s violation of human rights is not only causing distress to millions of its own citizens; it has an international dimension as well. For Human Rights defenders around the world, the most worrying aspect is the involvement of State laws and state machinery. It is no accident that the recent attacks on Ahmadis took place in the backdrop of the recent 18th Amendment to the Pakistan constitution which has sealed off the office of prime minister to non-Muslims by declaring that the post will be held by a Muslim. The presidency has, since 1956, already been reserved for Muslims alone. State’s growing intolerance of minorities inevitably encourages extremists to perpetrate more terror.

    For Pakistan’s neighbours like India, the concern arises from the fact that Pakistan continues to ignore, if not actively support, the terrorist groups it had spawned earlier under some misplaced strategic imperatives to export terrorism to other countries.

    For Muslims around the world, the concern is that Pakistan maintains such discriminatory laws and allows its misuse by the state machinery in the name o Islam, supposedly to promote Islam. After all, the terrorists who blow themselves up, killing scores of people in Ahmadi or Shia mosques, do not do so just because they have been offered some money, but because they have been brainwashed into believing that this act will take them instantly to heaven. There are ostensibly Islamic institutions preaching this evil, brainwashing their pupils and training them to do so. These institutions are well-known, their leaders strut around Pakistani cities, addressing large gatherings, preaching terror, openly collecting donations for their nefarious acts. Pakistani state cannot possibly be unaware of these events, particularly as it organises security for the leaders of these institutions like Hafiz Mohammad Saeed of Jamaat-ud Dawa and Lashkar-e-Tayyaba.

    Pakisani civil society

    It is heartening that Pakisani civil society is seized of the matter and many intrepid journalists are condemning such dastardly suicide bombings and other terrorist acts at great personal risk. But at the same time, and very unfortunately, one hears voices, even in the English media that used to be the one corner of sanity in Pakistan, justifying killings of Ahmadis and persecution of other minorities in the name of maintaining the purity of Islam. This is largely a result of the ongoing project of Wahhabisation around the world that has spawned many vested interests promoting a very dry, desiccated version of Islam in which the beauty and generosity of Islam, its compassion and mercy have no place. It is necessary for mainstream Muslims to sit up and take notice. Let us hope there is still time and Islam can still be retrieved from the hands of these marauders.

    Pakistani state’s continued involvement in promoting acts of terror abroad, even if it is more an act of omission rather than commission, as it claims, has to be inevitably viewed with concern by all those who believe in the indivisibility of human rights. One cannot protect human rights in one country and allow their violation in another country. But this is a cause for even greater alarm for Muslims who see the goings on in Pakistan, as tarnishing the fair name of Islam, thus immensely fuelling Islamophobia around the world. It is no accident that Islamophobic political parties have begun to gain ground in several European countries in the aftermath of continuing massive human rights violations in some Muslim countries and by Muslim extremists even after 9/11.

    UN, OIC must intervene

    Humanity in general, but Muslims in particular, have got to become very careful about how Islam is being projected by Muslims in the eyes of the world. Thus not only world organisation like the UN, but also Muslim Organisations like OIC must intervene and seek to impress upon offending Muslim countries like Pakistan to stop following domestic and foreign policies that sully the name of Islam. Suicide bombers trained in Pakistan are not only creating havoc in their own country, but also crossing land and seas to terrorise the world. It is strange that while the International community seizes upon the slightest violation of human rights in some countries to condemn them from all corners, it is quite reluctant to put pressure on Pakistan to change course. This is presumably because it is perceived as an ally in the ongoing war on terror. But it has to be understood that by its acts of omission and commission Pakistan is actually fuelling this war. It is not in Pakistani interest or at least in the interest of all-powerful Pakistan Army for this war to end. So those of us who are working towards creating a more peaceful world should take the issue much more seriously than we have done up to now.

    ——————————————————————————–

    The above is from a speech titled Human Rights in Pakistan: Cultural and Ethinic Dimensions made by Sultan Shahin, editor, New Age Islam, on 11 June 2010, addressing a parallel seminar on Human Right Concerns in South Asia organised by Inter-Faith International during UN Human Rights Council’s June 2010 session at Geneva

    Copyright: http://www.NewAgeIslam.com

    [Reply]

  • monty

    Hi Vinod, saw you on Times now. You made a pathetic picture. whats with you guys in HT you forget that you are journalists first and not congress mouth pieces. very shabby. you should have stuck to the debate for which you were invited. i thought that was a very crass attempt on your part trying to subvert the topic. isnt there something like integrity or journalistic pride in your newspaper?.
    i felt swapnadas gupta was very dignified in his rebuff to you.

    [Reply]

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    Hi Monty,
    I very clearly said that I would have quit had I been in Kalmadi’s place. That said, I wanted to know from Swapan about the different standards of public moralilty he applied to Amit Shah and Kalmadi. What’s wrong with that? You question my integrity but remain silent on what ’s said in the BJP’s defence. Is it your case that there is nothing to question as those chaps have no integrity?

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    Dear Sal,

    I had asked you a simple question.

    Which is in the end a better ideology.

    a) Pakistan– which drove away its HIndus and Sikhs at partition time, through violence and forcible conversions. And today puts pressure on them as well as CHristians, Ahemadiyas and SHias to convert to Islam or migrate or live as second class citizens in the Islamic republic.

    b) Or HIndustan which chose not to drive away its Muslims though violence to Pakistan. And today wants its Muslims to live as equals.

    Let us see whether you answer this straight.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar

    I do not agree with you. Let me tell you muslims were killed more in numbers than Hindus & Sikhs during partition in 1947. And obivously Hindus and Sikhs killed muslims.

    Immediately after partition, riots broke out. If Hindus were drove out of Pak then muslims were drove out of India. You ignore your part and talk about Pak.

    And why all muslims didnt leave Hindustan (though 75% of muslims of all over the India came in Pak) then my answer is Pak was made for those muslims of India where they were in majority.

    And as far as conversion is concerned, then let me tell you again, no conversion has occured in Pak forcibly.

    And as well as minorities of Pak are concerned, is it not better for you to concentrate on your minorities afterall Babri Mosque, Bombay Riots in 1992, Golden Temple 1984, then Gujrat riots all they are occured in India the there are christians riots too in India. Have you suggested your people to act upon Sachar commsion report which was published in 2006. I can quote many serious examples.

    But I dont want to write same thing again and again.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    “75% of Muslims from all over India came to Pak ”

    These are deliberate, thuggish lies from Sal and Azhar, because both of them are wilfully dishonest.

    The talk is of people forced out of there homes or those that chose to migrate. The talk is not about people who continued to live where they lived.

    As per Wikipedia and other independent historical sources

    “The partition was promulgated in the Indian Independence Act 1947 and resulted in the dissolution of the British Indian Empire. The partition displaced up to 12.5 million people in the former British Indian Empire, with estimates of loss of life varying from several hundred thousand to a million.”

    “Massive population exchanges occurred between the two newly-formed states in the months immediately following Partition. Once the lines were established, about 14.5 million people crossed the borders to what they hoped was the relative safety of religious majority. Based on 1951 Census of displaced persons, 7,226,000 Muslims went to Pakistan from India while 7,249,000 Hindus and Sikhs moved to India from Pakistan immediately after partition.”

    The population transfer was over whelmingly between West Pakistan and India. East Pakistan saw very little population transfer.

    The population of West Pakistan in 1951 was 33.7 million

    http://www.statoids.com/upk.html

    So if , 7.2 million Hindus and sikhs came from mainly West Pakstan, that means about 20% of 33 million people , were uprooted and expelled from there lands.
    That means about 90% of Hindus and Sikhs were expelled from Pakistan assuming they made about 20% of the population in 1947 .

    In 1951 India’s population was 360 million.
    http://indiabudget.nic.in/es2002-03/chapt2003/tab97.pdf

    Muslims were 11% of India’s populatiion in 1951 census ( they are 14% of the pupulation currently )

    So out of about 47 million Indian Muslims ( 11% of 360 million + 7 million Muslims who left for Pakistan ) about 15% left or felt compelled to leave for Pakistan.

    So there you go . To summarize, while about 15% of Indian Muslims ( 7 million ) left for Pakistan , 90-95% of Pakistani Hindus and Sikhs ( 7 million ) were compelled to leave for India.

    15% Vs 90%.

    Good Vs Evel

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Ediot & Lier Rajiv

    75% of Muslims of all over the India before partition came in Pak includes muslims of Pak and muslims of Bangladesh plus those muslims who migrated to Pak from India.

    In other words, what I means was in 1947, Pak absorbed 75% of muslims (muslims of Pak + muslims of Bangladesh + muslims who migrated to Pak from India) of all over the India.

    But that is good to hear from you that 90-95% of 15-20% of Pak (Hindus + Sikhs) had migrated to India after partition and this is the reason their % has declined significantly.

  • http://www.rediff.com Paritosh

    @ Vinod Sharma aka the “vangaurd of secularism”

    i am not abusing my freedom in any way. you feel distasteful when i say something critical about the Quran , but have you ever bothered to lecture Sal , Azhar and other Pakistanis on the blog , the same way , when they post insulting comments about Hindus?? they have referred to Indians as Hindus and have posted degrading comments.

    but as i expected , you ignored these insults very conveniently. others may see a pro-Congressi in yourself , but more than that , i see yourself as a pseudo secular pro-Pakistani Indian journo.

    you are a kind of person who cannot see things that are occuring openly. right from the birth of Islam , Muslims have acted aggressively against non-Muslims , following instructions from the Quran and the paedophile prophet.

    overcome your hypocrisy before preaching others of civilized behaviour!!

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Azhar Hussain

    your decision of leaving the blog is most welcome. it will give this blog some quality and standard , that was degraded by typical Pakistanis like yourself.

    by the way , a person who repeatedly refers others as “baita” ( the spelling itself is wrong) , is enough to be called as a troll himself. you are a hypocrite , just like rest of your countrymen , threatening to leave the blog , similarly the way Pakistani leaders threaten that “Pakistan will go into chaos if so and so action is taken by India” . what an analogy :)

    [Reply]

    Vinod Sharma Reply:

    @Paritosh
    I cannot understand how somebody with even an iota of civility can justify the kind of abuse you hurled at a holy book. I don’t hink I need to waste any time responding to yiou. The words you mouth show your lack of culture that is no better than that of others who use the same language on this blog— Indians or Pakistanis alike. .
    Sorry, I cannot quit this blog. But I can surely quit responding to you.

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Vinod Sharma

    if you find that i lack cultural values , then similarly in my opinion you lack journalistic ethics (being a pro-Congressi) and simple common sense as well ( pro-Pakistan )

    the “holy book” that you talk of , is only a manual of destruction. i am sure you lack the same kind of respect for Hinduism.

    if you honestly concede that even Pakistanis show uncivilized behaviour , then why the heck you dont ever say anything to them??!! coz you are a hypocrite ( i guess so )

    [Reply]

    jai vaidya Reply:

    Sal
    “Pakistan was made for those muslims of India where they were in a majority”.Sal where do you get your Facts? Pakistan was created for ALL Indian muslims,you got 30% of undivided India because you were 30% of the population at the time,and btw you have left 3 lakh Bihari muslims stranded in Bangladesh.These Biharis muslims had helped the Pakistan army during the 71 war Kashmiris who agitate on your behalf should check yor track record.
    Pakistan could care less for muslims in India It closed its border with india and refused to accept muslim migrants from India in 1950.

    [Reply]

    jai vaidya Reply:

    Azhar Hussain,
    I bet you this will make you really proud of Pakistanis. This informmation is on the August 7 edition of the UK Daily Mail..
    At 13, Emma still played with dolls and loved nothing more than walking with her pet spaniel, Yet by her 14th birthday, that innocent childhood was over. Emma had been raped and sexually abused in the most grotesque manner by 54 MUSLIM men in Britain.
    ‘It feels as if one minute I was playing with dolls, the next I was a sex slave.’ ‘I was wearing my favourite candy-striped ankle socks when I was first raped. Afterwards, my white coat was covered in blood.’

    Stolen childhood: ‘Emma’ in 2001, just 18 months before she was groomed into becoming a sex slave

    Emma remembers every detail. Two of those ‘friends’ in the shopping mall were teenage boys, Niv and Jay, who were being used by a criminal gang to lure naive local girls into an underage sex ring. They introduced Emma to older relatives, in their 20s and 30s, who said they wanted to be her friends, too. They plied her with vodka, cigarettes and cannabis spliffs.

    ‘I thought I was having a great time. I had no idea the men were part of a gang,’ she says now. With rap music blaring, the men drove her around Leeds in a expensive cars, including a Bentley with personalised number plates. They bought her cheeseburgers at McDonald’s and gave her a new mobile phone.

    One, 24-year-old, Tarik, took a particular interest in her. He was the gang’s ring leader – and one day he imposed his authority on her in the most brutal fashion. He led Emma to a patch of wasteland near the bus station and raped her.

    The whole episode was watched by a group from the gang who, laughing, recorded the attack on their mobile phone cameras. Afterwards, Emma was left to pick herself up, try to wash the blood off her clothes in the nearby public lavatory, and catch the early evening bus home.

    Almost equally wicked were the threats that went with the rape. Emma, who is now 21 and virtually living in hiding in the North of England, recalls: ‘It was like joining a cult.

    ‘They threatened to firebomb my home with my parents inside if I told anyone what they’d done, shoot me with a pistol, rape my mother and kill my older brother if I told anyone.

    ‘In my child’s mind, I wanted to believe Tarik had feelings for me. But he was just a pimp, and soon he was making money out of me by selling me to other men — I don’t know how much for.’ ‘He would give me presents, vodka and cigarettes. But soon I was paying him back by having to do what I had to do with man after man, in empty flats, in parks and down alleyways.’

    If Emma’s story were a one-off it would be distressing enough, but the reality is that it is not. Many schoolgirls – some aged just eight – all over the north of England are falling prey to gangs who groom them to be lucrative sex slaves.

    Emma says: ‘Most of the men running the sex slave gangs in the north of England are MUSLIMS of Pakistani origin. But very few of the authorities will admit this.’ Is she right to say so? If she is, why are so few people in officialdom willing to discuss the issue?The mothers say that political correctness and a fear of being branded racist is at the heart of the taboo.

    One mother from Yorkshire, whose 13-year-old girl was lured into sex slavery, told me: ‘Almost every man found guilty of grooming under-age girls in this part of Britain is MUSLIM, and everyone knows that.

    Scotland Yard estimates that 5,000 British-born children are today under the control of sex-slave gangs across the UK. At least ten towns on both sides of the Pennines face the problem.UK Daily Mail H/T Scottish Infidel

    RELATED STORIES:

    rampant-rape-epidemic-of-british-girls-by-muslim-men

    rape-by-muslims-epidemic-in-europe-and-headed-this-way-thanks-to-ever-increasing-muslim-immigration-to-the-

  • Rajiv

    I haven’t seen the comments of Azhar Hussain leaving the blog !

    If its true then its like a LeT operative or an ISI sympathizer, restricting himself to Pakistan !

    In my opinion, Cheers and good riddance .

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    well not on this blog though , but on some previous blog he had said something similar. i emember that very well.

    by the way Mr Sharma called me a “troll” on the current blog and this is exactly something what Azhar called me again in some previous blog , over an intensified debate coupled by some abuse:)

    [Reply]

    Azhar Hussain Reply:

    One more time, India will never take unilateral action against Pakistan unless Uncle Sam and its lap puppy (your gora father) supports it. We are already helping our brothers in Kashmir, wand we will continue helping them till we can, understand P A R I T U S H.

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    Dear everyone,

    Since the question of Commonwealth games has arisen, let me say in a loud voice, that “yahaan par bharat ki izzat ka sawaal hai”… we have to do a good job, The world is watching us.

    I have been assosciated with the CWG as a project Engineer for a company which tried to get some construction related work, but could not as upfront kickbacks asked were high.So I have some knowledge of what is happening, even though our company did not get the work.

    But…. Let me say one thing. THIS HAPPENS IN ALL GOVERNMENT PROJECTS IN INDIA.

    In CWG, the del;ay in the works was too high. Right till 2008 when Mani Aiyar was the sports minister, everything was vetoed and India would have fallen flat on its face,.Mani Aiyar is basically a noise creater who cannot do anything except create bureaucracy and delay things.

    You cannot expect him to create stadia or plan anything big and execute it.

    Things like the Metro, the airtport terminal were gfoing on fine. But the Sports Ministery was frozen.
    .

    We would have become the international joke Pakistan wants us to be. Then Shiela Dixit went and met MMS and Sonia and Mani Aiyar was removed and GIll came in.

    Presto! THings started happen. But everything went into a panice mode because of the sheer paucity of time. A coterie culture where kalamadi and a few men suddenly got extreme powe arose.

    The result is for everyone to see..

    More later :)

    [Reply]

  • vijay Kumar

    Pyaare bandhu Sal,

    I do not share your view that the conditions of religious minorities in Pakistan is rosy. Maybe very few people outside Pakistan will believe this.

    However…..

    I am asking you a straight and simple question.

    What is a better ideology?

    a) The ideolgy which lets all religions prosper, inspite of some tensions somethimes. ALlows them to aspire for highest officies in Defence, civil adminstaration, politics and governance and declares the country to belong to all religion and races. And also remains democractic all the time.

    OR

    b) An ideology which says one religon is supreme and the PM, President can only be from that religion. It does not permit the higher defence officers and civil administration to have officers from any other relgion; It has ‘non state” actors of this one religion who create acts of terror worldwide and kill innocents; It has been a military dictatorship most of the time and a fragile fig leaf of a democracy with headquarters in the Army cantoment. THis ideology jails writers, thinkers and poets. And kills, jails and imposes jaziya on people who do not follow a particular hardline version of one religion.

    Can you answer my question without getting India and Pakistan into it. On what is better and what ideology should all countries of the world follow. A or B ???

    Let us if you have the courage to answer this straight…. :)

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Vijay Kumar

    hello friend. its very interesting to know that you are involved in the CWG related developmental projects. i am sure you must be working hard for that , but our incompetent leadership has messed up all the efforts of our people and has absolutely no consideration for virtues like national spirit.

    the degraded quality of newly constructed sports arenas , roads , side walks , staying facilities for foreign players built for the CWG , speak a volume of the incompetency of our leadership and the results when tremendous amount of work is done at the nick of time.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay…Meray bhai

    I have never said that minorities of Pak are living very good in Pak. But I sincerely believe minorities in Pak are in much better condition if you compared them to their Indian counterparts. Second, minorites are hardly 2% of Pak and this 2% includes Hindus, Sikhs,Christians, Ahmedis etc. And this 2% are in a every civil departement of Pak but because they are in such a small numbers, they are not visible to you.

    As far as the post of President of Pak is concerned, it has to do more with religon. In Islam, ruler of a muslim country has to be muslim. And we muslims are first muslims then we are Pakistanis, Afganis, turks or Saudis…This is what Nehro didnt even understand and he gave the same rule A which you gave to me.

    Your rule A doesnt apply to India. Why? Then ask this from Kashmiris…Even Women, Children, youth, teenagers are stonepelting in Kashmir valley to oppose your claim/rule A.

    For me, the govt that take care of their people well is good for the people. And this govt can be Dictatorship, Caliphate, Kingdom, Democratic or theocratic. For me, that doesnt matter.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Is this a Joke? Minorties are better off in Pakistan!!! What a gem!!!

    [Reply]

    muslim bhagawat Reply:

    I do wonder why Pakistan asks for only Kashmir. It should have demanded that they should get the whole of India as it has 20 crores Muslim population, thousands of Muslim majority villages, Kashmir is a part of India and most appropriately India was a Muslim state ruled by Moghuls till British takeover the nation by force. So Muslims has first right on India and Pakistan should get it. We will support its demand as we have lost all our hopes and we have no option left as our people are lazy, impotents, peace-loving, patience, passive and weak. If China would take over India by 2020 it would be welcomed by Congress as in that period it would be under stress by its misrule and anarchy and chaos all over the country.
    We cannot make it a Hindu majority country as our rulers were themselves clandestinely worked in support of Muslims due to their nefarious liaison,designs and attributes. First our leaders have accepted the partition on communal lines of the great country, Bharat for which we have got two enemies in our neighbourhood, one is China and another is Pakistan. If our leaders wouldn’t have accepted the British Conspiracy to divide a great and large country into three parts then they would not have succeed in their conspiracy and for that they have used Nehru. Although Gandhijee and all other leaders were against the formula of partition on communal lines but lord Mountbatten and his wife had enticed Nehru to accept the formula and the country was partitioned in which lakhs lakhs of people were butchered, lakhs of women were ravished,lakhs of kids were made homeless and orphan. So what do we achieve with so much hatred and colossal loss? The Freedom we see is facade and meant for only rich and political leaders. If Nehru would not have accepted the partition then the country would have emerged as one of the largest,developed country in world unchallenged. But the Christian conspiracy played havoc. But our leaders failed to understand the conspiracy. The roman Catholics have a clever and clear vision in which they have succeeded by sending one of their ladies to India to marry the prince Charming of Indian emperor.Rajiv’s marriage with Sonia Gandhi was a pre-planned conspiracy by the roman Catholics to make India as a Christian country. Now her son is also in the footsteps of his father and married one Roman Catholics girl.
    We need to understand the conspiracy of Islamic fundamentalist and Roman Catholics. If we would not be awakened we would be in dire straits one day. BJP,RSS.VHP are the only Hindu organisation which is fighting for Hindus only and all other are fighting for the loaves and breads offered by the colonial forces. The ARMY,AIR FORCE AND NAVY ARE also in deep resentment by the policies of the UPA govt which shows them in poor light.It is most highly condemnable that the Media is highlighting smallest of errors on the part of our COAS and all other military officers. We have full support to the media if they found any grave crime or design by our military but by shouting loudly all over the media for smallest of errors and mistakes by any of our army officers, chief of staff’s they are not doing any good to the nation and also not good to them. It is dangerous trend developed in Media supported by UPA govt in which the army is being dragged to infamy. This would endanger our democracy and we would be in peril.
    Media should be aware of the fact that army cannot go to media for rebuttal of the allegations against them and the Govt seems to have encouraged the media to put blames on Army to demoralise it. In sukhna lake land allocation case the media had done more harm to army. In the Malegaon blast, samjhouta express blast case also it had damaged the army by giving concocted and fabricated media reports through CBI to media .But our media is controlled by some NGO’s who are controlled by Christian Groups churches and also petro dollars of Arab countries.Indian Hindus were slaves, are slaves and would be slaves of these Christians and Muslims for ever.
    LET US ALL DECIDE WHAT IS OUR OPTIONS TO SAVE THE GREAT COUNTRY OF HINDUS.

    [Reply]

    Ram Reply:

    Friends, lets see the devotion of mr. Vinod sharma to con-gress in CWG irregularities.

    “One activist recalls that when they pleaded the violations case in front of the political editor of the Hindustan Times, he simply brushed them aside saying: “how can such things happen in Delhi”!! ”

    http://thehoot.org/web/home/story.php?storyid=4734&mod=1&pg=1&sectionId=1&valid=true

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Sal
    Please allow me to add a word to just show that minorities in Pakistan have no respect even in their deaths what to speak of their being treated well during their life time. Take the case of a Hindu by the name Prem Chand who was killed in the plane crash on July 28 in Pakistan. His coffin was marked as “Kafir” because he was a non-muslim. The religious fanaticism in your country has reached to such a level that even a dead non-muslim is not respected.
    Well, I am not surprised by this incident going the way your country had treated the only Pakistan Nobel Laureate Professor (Dr.) Abdus Salam who died an unsung death and his grave was even defaced only because he was a non-muslim (An ahmedian)
    I know you will still find some reason to explain this.
    Thanks
    BNA

    [Reply]

  • vijay kumar

    Sal, my pal,

    I had asked for a straight answer. A or B. Forget India or Pakistan. Just tell me what system should all countries of the world follow.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Dear Vijay Kumar

    I will reject both of them. You are not getting what I am saying to you.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    Its useless to argue with wilfully dishonest people.

    Statistics reveal what Pak did to its minorities

    West Pakistan had about 8 million Hindus and Sikhs out of a population of about 44 million in West Pakistan in 1947.

    It expelled, 7 million of its 8 million Hindu Sikh minorities from West Pakistan.
    The East Pakistani Bengalis were relatively better. Hindus continued to make 15% of East Pakistan population til 1971 when again West Pakistan army launched a genocide, particularly against Hindus in East Pakistan. The biggest migration of Hindus from East Pakistan happened in 1971.

    In contrast , India had about 47 million Muslims, in 1947. Of which about only 7 million left for Pakistan.
    40 Million Muslims stayed in secular, democratic India. That number has increased to 150-160 million today.

    The intolerance and bigotry that the system Sal represents, is self evident in the above numbers.

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Rajiv

    You are the one who is dishonet and lier. But one thing, I must admit that this time atleast your statistics are correct.

    The numbers of Hindus & Sikhs who migrated from Pak to India are approx same the numbers of muslims who migrated from India to Pak i.e roughly 7 million on each side.

    But we have to analyze how this migaration occured. Immediately after partition riots broke out in all parts of India especially in Punjab. Punjab was the region which suffered most because Punjab was one who got partitioned (besides Bengal) and as a result, most of the killings occured in Punjab. So the people who migrated from Pak to India, almost of them belong to Punjab. The same case is with muslims from East Punjab (India) though muslims were forced to leave India from different parts of India too.

    Sindh didnt get partitioned and Sindh remain relatively calm during 1947 events. Hence, many hindus remained in sindh and even sizeabale population of hindus continued to live in Sindh today.
    .
    Why not all muslims left India? Again my answer is same i.e. Pak was not made for all muslims of India. It was made for those muslims where they were in majority. Pak could not take those roughly 40 million muslims who remained in India after 47.

  • Rajiv

    As I said, statistics say it all about crminal Pkaitsna and the criminal ideology its based on.

    1. It expelled 90% of its minorties from West Pakistan.
    ( In India 85% of Muslims stayed in India !!!!!!!!! From India only 15% of Muslims migrated to Pak ).

    2. Made vile criminal laws like non Muslims cannot become President, PM of Pakistan.

    3. Made even more vile Huddod and laws pertaining to Blasphemy to terrorize the few minorities left behind.

    As I said , numbers say it all. Pak is a thug and venal entity to its core.

    That is state sponsored discrimination and venality.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    —————————————————————————————————–
    US, UN declare Harakatul Jihad al-Islami terrorist group
    ——————————————————————————————————-
    http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=201087\story_7-8-2010_pg7_7

    The US and the United Nations on Friday declared Pakistan-based group Harakatul Jihad al-Islami a “foreign terrorist organisation” and targeted its commander for supporting acts of terrorism, the US Treasury Department said. Mohammad Ilyas Kashmiri, who the US labelled a “Specially Designated Global Terrorist”, will have any of his assets frozen in US jurisdiction and the move will also “prohibit US persons from engaging in any transactions with him”. The Treasury Department said the UN had taken similar action against the HuJI and Kashmiri. As the group’s leader, US officials said Kashmiri “provides support to al Qaeda operations, including logistical support for al Qaeda’s terrorist attacks”, the Treasury Department said, detailing deadly assaults on the Pakistani government personnel and facilities.”

    …………………………………

    Important to note Mohammad Illayas used to work for the Pak army special operation group.
    He was also one of the contacts of Headley in Pakistan along with other Pakistan army/isi officers in organizing the attack on Mumbai.

    Religion inspired criminality runs through the spine of Pakistan state as represented by its army/isi.

    [Reply]

  • Ankit

    Finally years of hard work of Mr. Vinod Sharma has shown and Congress has rewarded yet another of its loyal soldiers.

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article558205.ece

    Readers of this newspaper have suspected the dealmakings of this journalist for a long time, after all Mr. Sharma does not even try to be discreet about being Congress’s trojan horse in the media. The journalist held up his side of bargain for a long time, now the goverment has obliged with its side of the bargain. QED.

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Ankit
    Thanks for this bit of news. Finally, the cat is out of the bag. How come, Mr. Vinod Sharma , who is too biased in favour of one particular minority community, be the right choice to represent the majority community in the National Commision for Minorities. Someone with more secular and unbiased credentials should have succeeded Mr. Dilip Padgaonkar.
    BNA

    [Reply]

  • http://www.rediffmail.com muslim bhagawat

    India was plundered by Islamic terrorism since time immemorial. The Muslim invaders invaded India and plundered all its wealth. All the wealth from the temples were looted and taken away by them. India got some breather from invasion after Moguls ascended the Delhi throne. They had made India safe by their strong fighting skills and warriors.The Mulsim invaders came from Persia and Iran.When Britishers came to India to do trading with Moguls were weakened by internal divisions and British soon captured the last mogul and imprisoned him and banished him to Rangoon (Burma) which was also a territory of British.
    Although British had also plundered India of its wealth during the period of East India company rule, but after the queen take over the rule by sending governor general to India, the east India company rule was stopped.
    That British had won over all the major areas and included it into the British Colonialism. At last India was united under the British rule which would have been never possible as the Muslims had never dared to get all the small states and areas under them. All the 600 odd princely states were merged to British India and the British had appointed political agents for all the states.
    All these shows that Hindus were never a fighter clan and force. They were betrayed by their own clan and people. If Hindus would be a fighter clan and force they would have never been under subjugation of all these Moguls and British. After we got freedom at midnight of 15th August 1947, we think that our good fortune has come and we would live a decent life free from corruption and subjugation but that was a mirage. All the British Civil Servant’s role was taken over by the Indian Civil servants who lead a lavish life style with unbridled power and absolute hangover of British India.All the British officers,generals,governors and agents were replaced by the present day Minister,CM,PM and their chamchas.
    That there is no difference between British rule and Present day democratic rule.The conspiracy, under hand dealings are as they were. Only difference is that we call ourselves citizens of a Sovereign,free,democratic,secular,independent,republic country.But we have not replaced all the laws,rules,acts etc which were run by British to administer the slave India.We have the IPC and CRPC made by them. We have fabricated our constitution by copying the same from the British Constitution. Our leader never had the inkling that the constitution of an island cannot be suitable for a country like India whose population may be 120 crores by 2000.We are suffering all the problems of discontentment among states, corruption, regionalism, nepotism, terrorism, minority appeasement for votes and vendetta politics.
    Now we cannot cry if our officers and ministers are found involved in corruptions. We are simply watching them savouring crores of our taxes by falsified and fraudulent method,bills,invoices.Our media which had brought Indira Gandhi to her knees is now kneeling down before her daughter-in-law.so shame on our media which is crawling before her, when she had asked them to bend.
    We as Indian are ashamed of ourselves seeing the colossal loot in CWG games. Yesterday Mr.Digvijay Singh had deplored the CVC, who had the temerity to investigate the corruption in CWG without taking orders from her madam. So all these shows that the scam is as big as the Bofors scam and all the high level leaders are involved in the loot. No one is saying anything as the matter is in high level and the media is also getting silent under directions from top. Our PM and Sonia itself are silent.
    Are all Hindus of India should leave India and go to any other country on earth but there is no such place which can reside 100 crores of Hindus.But it would happen any day in future as they are silent,peaceful,lazy,foolish,carzy,impotents .we would rather wait for the day when all these pseudo secular parties would sell India to American forces and Hindus would be converted to Islam and Christianity by force, terrorism .We all Hindus have no respect for any Hindus, Gods and Goddesses ,Religion and primarily our NATION,HINDUSTAN,BHARAT,INDIA.We are simply hungry for power and money. What can a man need as his basic needs:- clothes,homes,foods.But we all Hindus want everything except our nation and religion. Shame to us being A Hindu.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.rediffmail.com muslim bhagawat

    How does anyone expect MMS to be a gentleman? he has not been elected to lokasabha and instead entered parliament by back doors of rajyasabha and although there is no precedent of any rajyasabha member being the pm of the great country ,he became chosen as pm by madam sonia gandhi who need a goonga gudda to get her rule with impunity, being a extra constitutional authority. mms is simply a goonga gudda who can never open his mouth unless and untill so directed by madam to open and say. we all Indian are ashamed of ourselves thatw e are ruled by two nautankis who are doing nothing although country is passing through grave crisis. Our forces are being browbeaten in Kashmir by the anti national forces. How can security forces remain calm under so much provocation & being beaten by the anti Indian forces. We cannot fathom being a brave Indian. why do he is in the seat of pm if he is unable to save his forces killed in Kashmir as well as in naxal affected areas. Why he is playing Nero? if he feels himself helpless by circumstances he should resign and go to academics. He is unfit for pm post and good for academics.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.rediffmail.com muslim bhagawat

    Our govt has failed to check corruption in many fields and the media had exposed many of them.Like Telecom scam and IPL scam the present scam that is out for media is CWG scam.In cwg all runs on the whims and fancies of SURESH KALAMDI a congress leader from Maharashtra but the govt has slept for two years and when media get whiffs of it they get to act. Is it sponsored or natural we do not know but the timing of expose is not good.It can be put out one year before or it may be put in print after the game is over.But the main thrust is that these exposes are sponsored by interested media and parties who want that the CWG wouldn’t be held or the congress party would eb blamed .Whatever be the reasons of exposes it is shameful that we have no strong laws to prevent corruptions. We know that scam tainted people would not be touched..They are untouchables. Nothing would happen to these corrupt who had amassed huge money from CWG.The CBI,IB,CBDT may investigate the cases but after the game is over all will forget it and they would be richer by billions. We have know that corruption is the mother of all ills in India. But we do not dare to clamp is hands. We have no such law that can put a fear among them so that they dare not do such corruption. Recently our hon’ble supreme court had given a judgment that the corrupts has no right to remain in service and they needed to be dismissed from govt jobs.If our SC has said it ,it is the duty of the govt to enact strong law for awarding exemplary punishment like life imprisonment or hanging for the corrupts including total confiscation of ill gotten property and cash to govt.That would make India a nation of character and all the corruption would be minimized. Quantum of corruption should be judged by the punishment.
    We know that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. But why for the leaders of Congress is behaving arrogantly. They appear that they are not only arrogant but also egoistic. They have a notion that India is not a democracy and India is their father’s property a zagir, which no one can snatch. They have achieved what they want by their criminal minded policy to divide the Hindus by castes, creed,race and appeased Muslims and xitians.They have played vote bank politics always. As they were in power longer than they deserved many of their workers and cadres are infiltrated by goonda and anti social elements. NOW The party is one party of goonda elements in many states they ruled who collects hafta, protection money and rangdari tax/fees. It is one party which has never respected democracy. It believes in autocracy. But the people of India failed to recognize its true face. It is the most dangerous party which is not interested for well being of India.,but for its workers,cadres and leaders.Look to our defense preparedness, we are in a very sorry state by our weak defense strategy which should be aggressive in all nature as we are surrounded by two enemies i.e.pakistan and china. WE have still having all the fighters with us in which several of our young pilots are killed .We have no tanks and armored vehicles to go to borders of war zone. We have no surveillance equipments. We have no such large nbombs on equal to Pakistan. If Pakistan have 90/100 n.bombs ,we have only 60/70.Last year one of our scientist in atomic energy dep’t had called the bluff by the govt and showed to us that how weak we are in our atomic bombs stockpiles. All this is done by Indian national Congress and we all are responsible to the weak India.We have seen the language of Manish tiwari,Digvijay Singh etc who are shouting unabashedly.
    in Gujarat after the Godhra train burning incident the riot took place and about 900 odd Muslims and 200 odd Hindus were killed. Since then Congress (Christian party) has made it a holy war on Hindus of Gujarat to attack all of them. Muslim calls it as Jihad and Christians call it as their holy war. As Congress chief is a Christian Roman catholic she is spearheading the war as its C.O.A.S. The war is between Hindus and infidels of Christianity and Islam. Congress has engaged many NGO’s to harass the CM and his ministers. Although congress has lost two elections after the riot but it is relentlessly waging war on CM and his ministers with the engagement of some communalists NGO’s,Advocates,Jehadis,CBI and central forces. It is to be noted that India had suffered in past as our history shows, by betrayal by Hindus who are boot lickers of Christians and Muslims. We are inviting our peril by supporting such forces who are going tos ell the country to USA.By proclamation of Hindus as liberals and patient congress is harping on the theme to bribe them to betray their own clan. I doubt what the genes of our leaders who are betraying their own clan.I am not defending anybody for any crime he or she might have committed as there is God to punish him or her.But the Govts shouldn’t go for selective leakage of news or planting false hoods in the media only to tarnish any one or party. It would do more arm to him as the people are not idiots and novice. The media may be playing into their hands now but they would turn like chameleons if the opposition come to power next. It is needless to say that congress ah s no absolute majority of 272 seats in LS but it is dependent on parties like DMK,NCP,TMC who are extracting its pounds of flesh every time a calamity strikes.In the developing nations no such politicking goes as their parties are more or less inter-dependent on national matters and priorities.
    In USA the two parties like democrats and republicans never accuse their leaders in open. If any person does any crime he is being tried under law and no witch hunt takes place in that country. Likewise in all the European countries all the politicking is transparent and equal. So why congress govt is doing all these witch hunting? It would lead to *** for tat policy by next govt, when BJP or NDA would come to power in centre in 2014.
    If congress believes that Sohrabuddin and IshratJahan are innocent then it should raise the issue in Gujarat election and condemn the BJP and its ministers but by witch hunting through massive mobilization of NGO’s, Advocates and CBI it cannot change the hearts of people. It would lose all these sympathy of people of India, how cruel and strong its actions may be against the Gujarat CM and his ministers, it would backfire on him. In the last 10 years the centre and UPA govt may have seen that no other state is as peaceful as Gujarat. It is its heartburn seeing the developmental works in Gujarat and also the peace & tranquility prevailing in that state. It has pushed hard all the machineries of central govt against the Gujarat Govt, CM and his ministers and trying hard to implicate them in false and concocted cases. Will it answer? If the same terrorist groups who were in Ahmadabad in a Indica car in which Ishrat Jahan and Pillai were traveling with two LET jihadist to kill modi and would have killed him and his ministers, will the UPA govt would have revived their life? So it is evident that the congress govt is hand in gloves with all the terrorists in India to liquidate the Hindus leaders and savior of Hindus. It is a conspiracy by the Muslim and Christian govt which all of us should understand and wake up.
    This govt is working with a sinister design to make India a slave of USA and any day we would see that we are a colony of USA and our freedom in chains and democracy has been like it is in Pakistan. All those who were killed in Gujarat by its police are anti nationals and they were liquidated by the patriotic govt of Gujarat and saved many Indians from Bomb blast and attacks. If the UPA’s Central Govt has any proof that Mr. Sohrabuddin is not a criminal but an diligent citizen it should come forward with the evidence. Witch hunt of innocents or govt machinery are bad and reactive. It should know that every proactive action has a hardest reaction. Congress party of India behaves like a party of self styled leaders. It has chief who is ruling in dictatorial and ancestral style. The party is of sycophants and bootlickers. Whosoever he may be if any person did not fall in line with the chief he is not accepted anywhere. First it was Motilal Nehru, Jawaharlal Motilal Nehru, Indira Nehru Gandhi, Rajiv Nehru Gandhi, Sonia Rajiv Gandhi ,Rahul Rajiv Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra are descending and ruling congress. This party is working in a dictatorial and autocratic manner and conspiring with the support of huge money power it is trying to demolish all the opposition. Due to the policy of creating all the bottleneck and impediments in the ranks and fields of opposition parties it has demolished them. It is using all its weapon available to finish off its opposition and succeeded like SAMA,DANA,DANDA, & BHEDA.It is abusing the CBI for its nefarious activities.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Muslim Bhagawat,

    I don’t understand your nick-name. Hopefully it has no under-lying meaning.

    Religion should be kept seperate from politics and governance.
    Nor should state tolerate any abuse of that freedom it offers.
    Its also the duty of the state to oppose politically any political party or religion whose principles are against the principles of the Indian constitution.

    Protection of personal freedom, religious freedom and fight against narrow religious ideologies should be two sides of the same coin.

    Any religious state ( Hindu or Christian ) runs the risk of being as bad as any of the Islamic states.

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    Should I congratulate Mr Anand Sharma ?

    “Vinod Sharma, political editor of Hindustan Times, is slated to be appointed member of the National Commission for Minorities. He will be a representative of the majority community.

    He will succeed veteran journalist Dileep Padgaonkar. ”

    So what exactly makes Mr Vinod Sharma eligible as a advocate of the ‘majority community’ in National Commision on Minorities ?

    I think Mr Sharma should have declined that offer.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Wonderful. Congrats to Mr,Sharma. I am pretty sure he will get rewarded for being pro-congress in future too.

    Rajeev Reply:

    Rajiv, Vijay, Anand, Paritosh and others,
    Please do not enegage pakistanis like Sal and Azhar in debates as there is no point educating these jahils. They have been taught to hate everything non-muslims especially Hindus and India.

    You can never get to any convergence with these ignorants.

    There is a book by SGPC (Shiromani Gurudwara Prabhandak Committee) that lists State sponsored genocide of Hindus/Sikhs during 1942-1950. Here Gandhi/Nehru were agreeing to ‘Personal laws’ for muslims in contituition and there in pakistan Jinnah and his lackeys were busy killing hindus.
    We are truly a naive country.

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    @ Mr. Rajeev
    Yes, I shall never now engage any of these guests from across the border(with some rare exceptions) for any debate on any issue of the blog. It is no use talking to people who only resort to uncivilised language when they can not discuss with logic.
    I just feel pity for Mr. Vinod Sharma who just watches helplessely and does not take the trouble of moderating the comments.
    BNA

  • http://deleted Sal

    @Vijay Kumar

    You are not willing to understand what I am saying to you. And If you dont want to understand then this is not my fault. And which ideology is better or not, for that matter, I will answer as a Muslim not as a Pakistani. And as a muslim, I reject both ideologies as I stated clearly before.

    And here again, you have started telling lies. “PM & President of Pak are begging for Aid and Hindus, Christians, Jes, buddhist are giving Aid”. How come. First, give me a reliable source for begging and then give me another reliable source that shows Hindus, christians, Budhist, Jews (yes, all of them beacuse you have mentioned all of them) has given aid to Pak in the name of Flood.

    35% of World’s poor live in your country which is called India and some of your states are even below sub sahara African states in Hunger Index but you talk about Pak’s begging and look at condition of your minorities. 3/4 of your country live less than 2$ in a day. Leave them.

    Just give me reliable source that shows Hindus, Budhist, Jews, Christians has given aid to Pak in the name of flood in the past week. You have to include all of the religons.

    [Reply]

  • http://- Rajeev

    and also this one
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZoYC9YPkSw&feature=related

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    And I can give you much more information on history if that fit into your tiny brain.

    [Reply]

  • Azhar Hussain

    Rajiv you are like a reincarnated monkey who makes his own facts and then expects others to accept them. Yes other monkeys like Rajeev, Paritosh, Patels and Singh might agree to it but rest us don’t give reincarnated rats ***.

    Read and look in the mirror….Cut and Paste Facts for you monkeys

    Indian judicial system fails to deliver justice only when victims are minorities: SFJ
    By Gurtej Singh
    Published: July 12, 2010
    Related
    Sikh Genocide 1984: Investigate role of Congress: SFJ, AISSF
    Sikh Genocide (1984) Victims call upon G-20 Countries to impress India to Impart Justice
    Sikh Genocide (1984) Canadian Sikhs Successfully Introduce Petition Protesting Human Rights Abuse in India
    1984 Massacre: Sikhs protest against Indian Minister Kamal Nath in US
    Twisting the Process of justice: PSO says Sajjan Kumar is missing
    Sikhs for Justice, a human rights advocacy group which is striving to get justice to the victims of 1984 Sikh Genocide challenged the PM Singh’s claim that “there are visible weaknesses in Indian judicial system”.Gurpatwant S Pannun, Legal Advisor Sikhs For Justice stated that Indian judiciary’s inability is selective and it only fails to deliver justice in cases involving massacre of minorities.According to attorney Pannun, when it comes to prosecute the killers of minorities like Christian massacre of 2008, Muslim massacre of 1992 & 2002, and Sikhs massacre of 1984, the Indian government uses the lame excuse of weakness in judicial system.This becomes clear when the prosecution of minorities’ massacre is compared with other serious cases such as killing of Indira Gandhi, Indian Parliament attack of 1999 or Mumbai Massacre of 2008. In all these cases, the same so called weak judicial system of India delivered justice in matter of few years.According to the attorney Pannun, the real reason is not the inability of judicial system but the unwillingness of Indian political establishment to prosecute the killers of minorities and impunity given to the killers because they are members of one or the other political party.PM Singh’s also announced that his government will compensate the victims of November 1984 and therefore they should not look back move forward. Responding to this, attorney Pannun stated that PM Singh has become devil’s advocate because its exactly the statements like this that promote the culture of impunity, that encourages and ensures the criminals that if they attack weak and minority community they will not face justice and its discourages the victims from ever seeking justice and instead be content with “compensation”. Quoting Saint Augustine’s saying “charity is no substitute for justice withheld”, attorney Pannun further stated that PM Singh’s suggestion to victims “take compensation and forget about justice” is also immoral and against teachings of all religions.According to Attorney if PM Singh has any heart for the victims of November 1984, he could still take action as head of Indian Government that would facilitate justice. According to attorney Pannun, the following demands of the Sikhs are within PM Singh’s power and do not need any judicial action and if serious to his words, PM Singh could:• Recognize November 1984 massacre of Sikhs as “genocide” of Sikhs as per article 2 of UN convention on genocide-1948 which is binding on India through its signature and ratification.• Set up a commission to conduct a nation-wide inquiry to determine the exact number of Sikhs killed all over India in November 1984 and to investigate the organized campaign for the killing of Sikhs in November 1984.• Allow international human rights groups to enter and work in Punjab. This will ensure transparency and will cement India’s reputation around the world as a human rights respecting country.• Set up a commission to investigate and recommend prosecution of security personnel involved in decade long killing of Sikhs and human rights abuses in Punjab.• Present a constitutional amendment before the parliament of India to recognize Sikhism as a separate religion.Ludhiana (June 29, 2010): As per a newsletter sent by Sikhs for Justice, this human rights advocacy group which is striving to get justice to the victims of 1984 Sikh Genocide challenged the PM Singh’s claim that “there are visible weaknesses in Indian judicial system”.

    Gurpatwant S Pannun, Legal Advisor Sikhs For Justice stated that Indian judiciary’s inability is selective and it only fails to deliver justice in cases involving massacre of minorities.

    According to attorney Pannun, when it comes to prosecute the killers of minorities like Christian massacre of 2008, Muslim massacre of 1992 & 2002, and Sikhs massacre of 1984, the Indian government uses the lame excuse of weakness in judicial system.

    This becomes clear when the prosecution of minorities’ massacre is compared with other serious cases such as killing of Indira Gandhi, Indian Parliament attack of 1999 or Mumbai Massacre of 2008. In all these cases, the same so called weak judicial system of India delivered justice in matter of few years.

    According to the attorney Pannun, the real reason is not the inability of judicial system but the unwillingness of Indian political establishment to prosecute the killers of minorities and impunity given to the killers because they are members of one or the other political party.

    PM Singh’s also announced that his government will compensate the victims of November 1984 and therefore they should not look back move forward. Responding to this, attorney Pannun stated that PM Singh has become devil’s advocate because its exactly the statements like this that promote the culture of impunity, that encourages and ensures the criminals that if they attack weak and minority community they will not face justice and its discourages the victims from ever seeking justice and instead be content with “compensation”. Quoting Saint Augustine’s saying “charity is no substitute for justice withheld”, attorney Pannun further stated that PM Singh’s suggestion to victims “take compensation and forget about justice” is also immoral and against teachings of all religions.

    According to Attorney if PM Singh has any heart for the victims of November 1984, he could still take action as head of Indian Government that would facilitate justice. According to attorney Pannun, the following demands of the Sikhs are within PM Singh’s power and do not need any judicial action and if serious to his words, PM Singh could:

    • Recognize November 1984 massacre of Sikhs as “genocide” of Sikhs as per article 2 of UN convention on genocide-1948 which is binding on India through its signature and ratification.

    • Set up a commission to conduct a nation-wide inquiry to determine the exact number of Sikhs killed all over India in November 1984 and to investigate the organized campaign for the killing of Sikhs in November 1984.

    • Allow international human rights groups to enter and work in Punjab. This will ensure transparency and will cement India’s reputation around the world as a human rights respecting country.

    • Set up a commission to investigate and recommend prosecution of security personnel involved in decade long killing of Sikhs and human rights abuses in Punjab.

    • Present a constitutional amendment before the parliament of India to recognize Sikhism as a separate religion.

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    @at all criminal Pakistanis

    1st have a Hindu/Sikh or even and Ahmedi or Parsi PM or President of Pakistan, before you talk about minorities in India or anywhere else in the world!!!

    [Reply]

  • VIjay Kumar

    @Sal

    Read this very carefully. This is the truth….

    1) Pakistan is begging the USA for AId. THe US has Hindus and Jews as its highest taxpayers. And Christians are there in a majority. YOu should be ashamed that you are beggin to a nation you consider infidel and from begging for money from religions you want to destroy.

    2) Islamic terrorist Paksitan is begging the UK for aid. Here too Hindus are among the highest taxpayers and the majority is CHristian. Aren’nt you ashamed that as soon as the drowning Pakistani gets money from the UK he will immediately train terrorists and rabies infected Jihadis to bomb London?

    3) India is a donor to multilateral agencies like IMF, ADB etc, where Pakistan is a begger. Part of the aid you get is from Indian Hindus, sikhs, Muslims, jews and Christians. But as you get your alms you will train suicide bombers, murderers, terrorists, heroin smugglers to attack India. You should be ashamed. Is that what your religion teaches you?

    The joke of a cuntry called Pakistan is also blackmailing the world that if you dont give us money, we will take it from our islamic charities and then from a 77% jihad supporting cuntry, Pakistan will become a 88% rabid jihadi exporting country….

    Sal, you should aspire to change your blighted cuntry. Rather than keep saying Indian India India… :)

    [Reply]

    VIjay Kumar Reply:

    @Everyone,

    So Vinod Sharmaji has got a nomination to the Minorities commission. I wish him well. Now that he is there, for whatever reason, I hope he remains fair, unbiased and frank.

    He is there representing Hindus. I hope he takes up the following issues which worry Hindus.

    a) WHy should Polygamy be allowed in a secular, democratic nation in the name of Muslim Personal law. Is it not against gender equality? Is it not unfair to women? Why should women be forced to be in a BUrka and be chained to the house?

    b) Many Islamic terrorist organization endevour to convert and also cause terror in the name of religion. The Hindus of this country feel sad that this should happen in the name of secularism. So the minorities commission should evaluate the funding of some of the educational institutes. It should have a concentrated program of addressing misguided youth who cannot understand secularism which allows all religions to be practised but is against. induced conversion as well as religious sermons which try to create a wedge between people.

    c) In Kerala there is a surge of fundmantalism which is attacking Christians and HIndus. Should not that be investigated and cured?

    d) He should highlight the positive points of our secularism rather than try to blame Hindus and Hinduism for not being liberal enoough.

    He can of course follow a moronic, conventional route of trying to drag the BJP and Narendra Modi into every arguement and than end up as a spokeman of the congress. Or he can be like Gorbacheav. Get the position by following the rules and then upsetting everything through perestroika.

    Rajiv, Rajeev, Ankit, Dr Anand … everyone. Let us put a bet on what route he will follow. I am willing to put in a thousand bucks.

    [Reply]

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Mr. Vijay,
    Oh yes, Gorbacheav is an appropriate example. But it may be also a fact that CIA might have played an important part in the rise of Gorbacheav and to his ultimately becoming the architecht of break up of USSR.
    But I am not sure about the credentials of Mr. Vinod sharma to be able to represent the majority community in the minority commission. This is not in any way to belittle his credentials as being a leading journalist of the countyr in his own right. That is true as well for Mr. Shukla to have used his journalistic skills to rise in the hierarchy of Congress party.
    BNA

    [Reply]

    Rajiv Reply:

    @Mr Sharma,

    100.000’s of Kashmiri Pandits have been reduced to refugees in there own country.

    What are you going to do so that the minority commission ensures that they return to Kashmir Valley and ensure there safety and security in there own homes in Kashmir Valley ?

    How is the minority commission going to work to protect the minorities in Kashmir ?

    What is the role of minority commission to ensure religion is not used for political purposes and religious places like mosques, gurudwaras and temples are not used by political partis ?

    [Reply]

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ Rajiv

    it is totally improbable that our Kashmiri Hindu brothers will ever get to re-settle with their lives , only because they are Hindus. the entire fault lies in our pseudo -secular constitution , pro-Islam government of Congress , and the bunch of pseudo secular pigs like Barkha Dutt and other such retards.

    if someone asks me , what do i think is the root cause of all the major violence , terrorism and communal blood-shed in the sub-continent , i will answer ISLAM.

    ISLAM IS THE ROOT CAUSE OF ALL THE VIOLENCE AND TERRORISM OVER THE WORLD.
    DESTROY ISLAM , SAVE HUMANITY

    Paritosh Reply:

    @ VIJAY KUMAR

    if you frankly believe that Vinod Sharma , having got nomination of the minorities commission , will deliver without any communal bias , then you are deluded my friend. Vinod Besharma is a genuinly “Besharam” person who wont care about Hindu minorities in the country.

    i will just post a few facts about misdeeds by Muslims in post-independence India.

    1)- opening madrassas that are inherently unproductive in nature , but also are schools of anti-Hindu , anti-Indianism and pro-terrorism/ pro-Pakistan propaganda.

    2)- practicing polygamy , hardcore fuc-king and producing offsprings like cockroaches.

    3)- minimum contribution in national development , epitome of redundancy.

    4)- instigating riots all over India against non-Muslims , especially Hindus. activities like support for Pakistan , love Jihad in Kerala , support for Bangladesh , forceful conversions where they are majority.

    Paritosh Reply:

    why are Muslims so courageous in carrying out their demonic anti national activities.

    some reasons-
    1)- pseudo secular constitution
    2)- pro-Muslim govt of Congress
    3)-over tolerance of naive and gullible Hindus.
    4)- bunch of influential pseudo-secular swines

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar

    I expcet some maturity from you. Or am I asking too much from you.

    You didnt give me any realiable source. You have given me your views and I categorically reject them.

    [Reply]

    vijay kumar Reply:

    @ Sal…and ajgar

    Have some brains and thoughts, pyaare SAL. Check up which is the richest and highest taxpaying community in the USA and UK. This money paid as taxes by Indians out there is going to come to Pakistan as Charity and aid. And yet you hate and will continue to create terrorists against people who pay you theis aid…

    India is a donor to IMF and ADB. You can check up any link on this.

    Japan and CHina which are giving you aid are primarily Buddhist and now, somewhat CHristian countries. Yet you guys will take aid and keep destroying the remnants of Buddhism in Pakistan.

    You can check up the now destroyed statues of Bamiyan Buddha or the remnants of Buddhism and hinduism in Taxila and MOjenjodaro. But you will not. you and continue to believe the fake history taught and created by Hafeez saeed and his likes that all of Pakistan migrated from Kazakastan and Turkey.

    Fool yourself.

    Facts are facts.

    And the fact is that you take pride in converting to Islam but punish by death anybody who wants to leave Islam by saying that apostasy is punishable by death in islam. Very very funny.

    For examplae AJgar Hussain may be in US to earn dollars as well as preach his religion as well as other backword ideas. But will he allow an American pastor to do the same in PAKistan?

    Maybe I cannot change you. Bu the world has seen thru your game,especially the most naive who after wiki leaks are now converted into believeing that the present state of Pakistan is a threat to world peace. Read Blackwill’s thesis in Huffington post.

    Time is coming that the world will balkanize Pakistan.

    I wish you well. But I still feel that even if Pakistan breaks into four pieces you will keep saying “India…. Isreral… India… USA… India… India… India…. :)

    [Reply]

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar

    How pathetic are you.

    Pak has given aid to India when earhquake came in India (Perhaps in gujrat) some years ago. Pak has many sent of its C130 planes full of Aids to India at that time…Hence according to your logic, India hah begged Aid from Pak and Pak has given Aid to India. So would you say muslims of Pak had given aid to Hindus of India.

    When katrina hurricane came in US, the whole world has given aid to US. So would you say Muslims, Hindus, Budhist & jews has given Aid to US beacsue christians of US has begged aid from muslims, Jews, Hindus and Buddhist. Even today people give Aid to victims of katrina hurricane of US.

    When something disaster occur in every part of world, people and Govts of other countries help the victims of the country in the name of humnaity like hiati earthquake (there are thosands of examples) and country like India also is/used to accept the Aid and it has nothing to do with religons.

    And as far as IMF and ADB is concerned, first India’s share in them are very low as compared to other’s countries share. So you cannot quote their example. This is one thing. Second, IMF and ADB gives loan to other countries like Russia, spain, Greece, Poland, Purtagal and these loans gets returned to IMF and ADB by their respective countries.

    3/4 of India lives less than 2$ in a day and India is a wolrd record holder of highest numbers of poors on the planet which covers 1/3 of the whole poor humanity and 45% of India lives less than 1$ in a day and many of their states are below hunger Index as compared Sub shara Africa. And then when a citizen of the very same country talks about Hindus in US & UK and then tax payers, I feel pity on his mental capacity and he should get some treatement.

    Sal Reply:

    @Vijay Kumar

    Ome more thing to say you…Please go to Indian held Kashmir at 14th of august this month and see whole Kashmir celebrate Pak Independece Day as their Independece day and then very next day, the whole Kashmit will observe 15th of August as a black day.

    (Dr.) B.N.Anand Reply:

    Hello Vijay
    Your facts are just to the point. I shall also like to be enlighened whether seeking help from “Kafirs” (non-muslims infidels, non-believers whether christians, jews , Ahmedians etc. etc—) is not a haram according to the law of Sharia ? While the Muslim state of Pakistan can forget this in time of trouble because of a natural calamity, why it can not think positively about people belonging to other religions. The religious fanatacism in a section of society in that country has reached so high that even the coffin of a non-muslim Pakistani (Prem Chand )who died in the recent plane crash in Pakistan was marked as “Kafir”. The non-muslims are humiliated even in their deaths.
    BNA

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    @Paritosh

    Its unfair and unjust and seves no good purpose to use phrases like “misdeeds of Muslims in post-independence India”.

    That kind of phrases, are common place in Pakistan against other communities. We should not be using a generic brush or label all people of any community as good or bad.

    Its indefensible.

    [Reply]

  • http://deleted Sal

    @Vijay Kumar

    Yes..the history that goes against you is a fake history and I know it.

    India..third largest economy…Yes it will become in future due to its over 1.20 billion population but I bet you India will still be world’s largest country of poors on the planet at that time too.

    I can give you many statistics that shows clearly there are more % of poors in India than in Pak with references. But this I will not….

    Leave India and Pak… You told me that you are project engineer. So Please behave like mature person who talks with some sense. This will benefits you in future.

    Bye

    [Reply]

  • Rajiv

    Paktistan in need and begging , surprisingly USA, UK and Western world are thelargest donors., even as opinion polls show Pakistanis hate US the most !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Where is China ? Where is Saudi ?

    Are Saudis, Iranis not Pakistan’s friends anymore?
    http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=20108\13\story_13-8-2010_pg7_24
    By Muhammad Akram

    LAHORE: Except Kuwait, Turkey and the UAE, Pakistan has failed to receive any aid for its flood victims from any other Islamic country. The three countries have offered $5 million, $269,183 and $20,027 respectively, so far. While China with $1,479,290 and Sri Lanka with $26,667 are the only neighbouring countries that have come to the country’s aid.

    According to statistics, the countries most hated by Pakistanis – as per various opinion polls – the US and UK are the two major contributors so far, while the list of remaining donors does not include any Islamic country, however, prominent donors include Germany, France, Greece, Czech Republic, Sweden and Australia. According to the information available, the total amount pledged to Pakistan so far is $84,294,357, much lower than what the UN has sought in its various appeals to the international community.

    The UN has launched an appeal for more than $450 million to help those affected. At least 1,600 people have died and many more are missing. This has happened at a time when Pakistan has issued new flood warnings that could last into the weekend as government and relief agencies scramble to confront the toll from a growing into a humanitarian disaster. The UN says, “Floods have decimated Pakistan: the number of people suffering could exceed 13 million – more than the combined total of the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, the 2005 Kashmir earthquake and the 2010 Haiti earthquake.”

    The people of Pakistan, particularly flood victims, want to know what has happened to the rulers and people of Iran and Saudi Arabia, which have not expressed any intent, let alone offering anything in aid to their Pakistani brothers and sisters. The aid to Pakistan would not be for its rulers, if there existed any misgivings, but for the people who have yet to find means to survive, as a new flood of an almost equal intensity is about to hit various districts of Sindh and Punjab this weekend.

    As far as neighbours such as India and Afghanistan are concerned, Pakistan can least expect from both, since none of the two had offered anything so far. As for India, which offered $500 million in aid during the 2005 Kashmir earthquake, the offer was refused by Pakistani authorities in the first place and whatever was allowed in was let to rot at security checkposts on the border.

    Pakistan has always looked to Saudi Arabia whenever it faced a difficulty. According to diplomatic sources, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia are not enjoying the best of ties since the PPP government assumed power, replacing the quasi-military government of Gen (r) Pervez Musharraf, with whom the Saudi rulers had the best of relations like they had with every military ruler in Pakistan. The FO had always played down the souring ties with Saudi Arabia, said a source in the office.

    However, international relations experts say a lukewarm response from Saudi Arabia and Iran is difficult to understand, as it is not the government but the people of Pakistan who are suffering and awaiting aid from both the countries.

    It is important to mention here the appeal made by Ruet-e-Hilal Committee Chairman Mufti Munibur Rehman on the eve of the Ramazan moon-sighting, to the Pakistanis intending to perform Haj and Umra this year to cancel their plans and spend the money for the flood-hit people instead. Taking a hint from the appeal, the government would be justified in banning Haj by Pakistanis this year as done by Tunisia last year due to fears of swine flu.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.iceinnovation.co.uk Online Marketing in Leeds

    I really liked your blog! It helped me alot…

    [Reply]