Somebody stop him



While planning today’s Page One a decent spread inside, which is going to be all about – you guessed it –the death sentence for Ajmal Kasab, I was struck by a suggestion to do a story, and not a very flattering one, about the special prosecutor, Ujjwal Nikam.

Did you see Nikam showing the V sign as he left the court? I thought it was apt – after all he had managed to argue successfully for Kasab to be sent to the gallows for a crime that no Indian will forget in a long time. He had won the battle for India, didn’t he?

But c’mon, I was jeered, even a four year old with no knowledge of law would have succeeded in getting a death sentence for Kasab, and without trying. No court in the country could have given him anything else, not for a crime that the entire nation watched Live.

Yet, the special prosecutor is behaving as if he was a tremendous achievement to, one, win a Guilty judgment for Kasab and, two, get him the death penalty. It could not have happened without him, he wants the country to believe.

And hope you didn’t miss the two spiral books Nikam had done specially for the occasion. He posed with the first the day Kasab was pronounced guilty – the cover said: “Yes, he is guilty.” Very subtle. And it made the point who

made it possible, in case you missed the hysterical coverage. The second book was in arms when he walked towards a bank of cameras outside the court today for the sentencing. One hand held up the V sign and the other clutched the book, titled: “Death penalty.” Again very subtle, and again reminding people who was responsible.

Mr Nikam doesn’t believe in half-measures. And he could well become a national celebrity as a result.

But does he have to rub it in?

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (26 votes, average: 2.69 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Dr. KRS Murthy

    I have no idea of the background of the author of this article. However, you may not know that most Indian Americans may not know the words of the American Anthem. Singing loudly will also give out that Indian Americans, especially the first generation immigrants can not carry on the tune with the American tune. However, the same people are able to sing the Indian national anthem easily as they grew up singing it as kids and young adults in various occasions.

    You may also not know that many attendees who look Indian are only with green card or H1 / L1 visas, and thus not American citizens.

    The practice of both anthems in most Indian events is still commendable. It is the spirit behind this counts, not singing, knowing the words or their hands on their heart.

    It is interesting that you are reading too much more than needed.

    You are probably a journalist, who does not understand basic fundamentals of life and people, want you are an expert when you have a pen or a computer key board in your hand.

    Grow up and give up your pathetic journalism.

    Dr. KRS Murthy krsmurthy2011@gmail.com

    [Reply]

  • RajX

    The only American Americans are the native Americans. The author seems to imply that American Americans are Caucasians.

    [Reply]

    Indian Reply:

    That is really uninformed opinion. America was founded and created by caucasians, the name is caucasian …actually after Italian ..Amerigo Vespucci. All concepts, constitution, colonies ..all were caucasians until 1960’s civil rights movement. Black were slaves and some Chinese brought in as rail road laborers had no rights or say in anything. So yes early Americans were all caucasians.

    [Reply]

  • Snuffy

    I think the author’s intent was that “American Americans” are American citizens born in the US, as opposed to immigrants. Although both are American citizens, immigrants find an inner conflict about which national anthem(s) to sing.

    [Reply]

  • Balasrini

    The INDIAN AMERICANS like me feel proud of our INDIAN origin&heritage&equally feel the same of our AMERICAN citizenship.We are also comfortable with both national anthems when recited at functions.This transition offered to us by the constitutions of both great democratic nations of USA&INDIA.

    [Reply]

  • Raja Cavale

    Have you heard about ‘Norman Tebit’s Law’ that is well known in the U.K.? Mr. Norman Tebit is a well known old Conservative Minister in Margaret Thatcher’s Government. During his time when there was a hot debate about immigration and there was some arguments regarding the loyalty’ of British Indians to wards Britain. He suggested a simple test to find out the loyalty of British Indian Citizens. If there is a Cricket match between teams of England and India, find out which team the British Indians support. Mr Tebit’s argument was even if the Indians had assimilated British way of life and hold a British Passport, they would support the Indian team and this reflects their loyalty to the country they live. Obviously the older generation do support the Indian team, it not necessarily mean they are disloyal to Britain. On the contrary, most of the Britis Indians are well assimilated into the British society and they are equally contributing to the British society just as a native British citizen.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    We need Patriotic & decisive leaders like Narendra Modi to keep the country on track of progress. Nominees like MMS & Mukharjee have doomed the nation. There is sole aim of grabbing power & looting the country. The Janlokpal would have gone a long way in bringing accountability in the system.

    [Reply]

  • Partha0307

    At a time when RIL is unable to produce gas from D6 its owner has recently flown some favored journalists to Europe in their fantasy plane to cover some science story that didn’t pan out.Let Narendra Modi get their black money stashed in
    off shore accounts (since this jaunt couldn’t have come at company expense)
    and use it to fund his solar park or whatever.
    Both parties are equally culpable when it comes to policy paralysis at
    returning our national wealth for socially useful economic progress.

    [Reply]

  • Prasad Mantrala

    Very well said Mr. Sarkar. I am the Press & Media Secretary of United Kingdom Telugu Association (UKTA) who rushed to the hospital upon hearing the stabbing news of Mr Reddy. While I have repeatedly warned the media not to cook up stories, the fact that there was a lady among the 11 arrested became another loose end for the love triangle conclusion. We sincerely appeal to all media representatives to approach a reliable source such as Minister for Press & Information of High Commission of India or an association like us who are willing to help Indians in distress instead of probing the case from different angles and trying to tread on the Police’s toes!

    [Reply]

  • Dipankar

    Pranav D, I don’t know if I have the answers to your big questions, because I actually think that we have hit a point where we need to (re)familiarise ourselves with the basics of good journalism.

    But certainly the industry can devise schemes to seek out people who are passionate about journalism. It needs to train them well in all aspects of the craft before encouraging them to specialise. This is happening already in some parts of the industry but it’s obvious that there are gaps.

    Skills that you speak of, such as reasoning, analysis and balance, are not acquired overnight. They need time, resources, hard work and patience.

    [Reply]

  • Chris

    Fair comments, but the media’s audience is not only the government. I would say that the Indian public has a legitimate interest in violent attacks carried out against people of Indian origin even if they are not citizens of India (though I agree reporters need to make clearer what they mean by “Indians”).

    [Reply]

  • rushabh chitalia

    can you tell me what are the important factors considered while designing the cover page/ first page to increase sales / attract consumers.

    [Reply]

  • Anatoliasmith

    Police and CRPF are always alert about Naxalities in the tribal area.

    http://savingnext.com/coupons/ashford-promo-code-exclusive-discounts-coupon-code.html

    [Reply]