Temple politics



BJP President Nitin Gadkari’s call to revive the mandir agenda could not have been more ill timed.

In a recent interview Gadkari said that the mandir issue is an important one for the BJP: “It is not about politics. It is about the faith of Hindus. It is not that the elections are here and we need to bring in Ram Lalla” he said. Even while denying that the BJP wants to cash in on Ram mandir for electoral benefit, Gadkari ended up doing just that. His denial was more an affirmation that the BJP is looking at Ram and his mandir to revive its fortunes.

Gadkari, it seems, is totally out of tune with current mood of the nation and its people. Gripped with the issue of corruption and rising prices, the electorate does not want to rewind bloody times. Nor go back to the communal divide that had ripped the nation post Babri masjid demolition. The scars have yet to heal: perhaps they never will. Yet Time drowned Memory and people decided to get on with their lives rather than spend time hating each other. Today they are united in fighting corruption and decrying the Government’s misdeeds. Today they come together as a nation to tell the Government that enough is enough and if it does not set its house in order, then it would be shown the door sooner than later. If that happens, then there is open space for opposition parties like the BJP to step in and take charge if possible. That is only if Gadkari lets them.

By giving the mandir call, he is only doing what is suicidal and misreading the writing on the wall. The disenchanted people of this country are looking out for someone—a person or party– to steer the nation out of the clutches of religion, caste and misgovernance: in other words free it from archaic mindsets and leaders who have exploited non issues to the hilt and often used irrelevant themes to ride the wave of power.

Gadkari’s mandir call is a reminder of that past which had once whipped up a religious frenzy. While it cannot be denied that the issue helped revive the BJP and brought it centre stage, it also must be remembered that BJP’s failure to honour its promise of constructing the ram mandir was its undoing. Consequently, Gadkari’s attempt to bring ram mandir back on track is a non-starter. It is one, which has a sting of betrayal and suffers from trust deficit. Under the circumstances, the BJP would do better if it confines itself to contemporary issues. On these it is proving to be an effective Opposition: in other words doing a damn good job be it stalling Parliament on the issue of corruption or staging protests outside.

But all this till Gadkari opened his mouth and with one single statement erased the gains that had showed up in BJP’s balance sheet in recent months.

This brings me to another point: rather a problem the BJP faces in projecting a national face. Gadkari certainly is nowhere near being one. Its younger leaders be it Sushma Swaraj or Arun Jaitley cannot match up to Manmohan Singh who even though he is non performing is still seen as a man with integrity. This is not to suggest that Swaraj and Jaitley are not but when it comes to the issue of national acceptability, they fall short.

To my mind BJP’s best bet is LK Advani. For the moment, till its younger leadership is ready to don the mantle, Advani is the party’s answer to the Congress. He is a tall leader and the BJP can look upto and depend on him to fill its leadership vacuum. If the BJP intends to remain relevant and make a national impact then it has no choice but to turn to Advani. The timing could not be better given that the Congress is on a backfoot. The BJP needs to seize the opportunity and the sooner it does this the better for it. Unless ofcourse it wants to write its epitaph. Gadkari’s mandir call, to my mind, seems to be the first step in that direction.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (13 votes, average: 2.62 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • ishwar

    Mandir bhi banayenge aur corruption bhi mitayenge.

    The HC gave its verdict last year saying: The disputed land in Ayodhya (where a makeshift temple was built after razing the Babri Masjid) IS the birth place of Bhagwan Ram.

    The BJP would not fight the election on issues dictated by pro-10 Janpath family journos like you. They have enough intelligence of their own. Even if they don’t get people’s support and don’t get voted to power, they should still fight for the cause and issues they stand for rather than making compromises and let the Raja’s, Kalmadi’s and Kanimozhi’s of the world loot the nation in the name of secularism and stability of government.

    Mr. Advani is still the BJP’s tallest leader and its all credit to him (alongwith Mr. Vajpayee) to bring the party to the position which it enjoys today in Indian politics.

    By the way, what is your suggestion for the Italian prince who celebrates his B’day in London (no photos – no media coverage) and suddenly props up in Bhatta Parsaul (with media following him)?

    [Reply]

    Good one Reply:

    I fully agree with you Ishwar. I hope we have many more people like you in India who are assertive and confident about their faith and beliefs , Only then we can take the nation to its full potential else we will continue to stay a third world country for years to come, given the devisive politics played by Congress and duly assisted by some paid-journos.

    [Reply]

    Mangesh Reply:

    Very rightly said…. This is all pay-roll media of the CON-gress (I-Italian..)

    Mandir Wahi Banega,….!! Jai Shri Ram.. !!

    [Reply]

  • Funny Side

    After Baba Ramdev’s antics and Anna Hazare’s vintage tricks, BJP figured that the polity is now sufficiently “secularly-saffronized” to initiate a hard-core saffron issue to garner votes – loha garam hai, hathoda maarlo – type of logic. Its a high-skied shot, either would cross the boundary for a six or Gadkari would be caught at Mid-On and get out of the leadership.

    [Reply]

  • RAMESH AGARWAL

    IF BHAGWAN RAM TEMPLE CAN BE CONSTRUCTED IN INDIA WILL IT BE CONSTRUCTED IN PAKISTAN/ITALY.BHAGWAN RAM IS PART OF NATIONALISM BUT WRITER LIKE YOU HAVE GIVEN IT COMMUNAL COLOUR.CONGRESS IS VERY COMMUNAL BUT HT/TOI/AND FEW WRITERS/COLUMNISTS LIKE KUMKUM CHADDA HAVE TREAT HER A SECULAR.STILL IT WAS FAULT OF NEHRU OTHERWISE LIKE SOMNATH TEMPLE RAM MANDIR WOULD HAVE BEEN CONSTRUCTED.WRITER IS CRITICISING BJP BUT NOT CONGRESS FOR BRING COMMUNAL VIOLENCE BILL/DISCREMINATION BILL/SACCHAR/RANGNATH COMMITTEE REPORT ARE THESE NOT MEANT FOR ELECTION PURPOSES?WHY BJP IS BLAMED?DR MMSINGH HAS NEVER WON ANY ELECTION AND CAME THRIOUGH BACKDOOR TO THE PARLIAMENT AND WAS NOT ELECTED BUT NOMINATED AND FAILED IN ALL FIELDS AND TAKE INSTRUCTIONS FROM 10 JANPATH.WHY MEDIA WAS SILENT ON SECREAT TRIPS OF SONIA/RAHUL GANDHI FROM 8TH TO 15TH JUNE TO SWITZERLAND AND 3 DAYS AFTER THEIR TRIP THE ATTITUDE OF SWISS BANKS SOFTENED.LEADER IS ELECTED AFTER PARTY GETS MAJORITY BY ELECTED REPRESENTATIVES UNLIKE IN CONGRESS WHERE THERE IS DYNASTIC RULE.PM IS FAILED IN ALL FRONTS AND INDIRECTLY INVOLVED IN ALL BIG SCAMS.IT DOES NOT MATTER WHETHER YOU ARE BENEFITTED FROM SCAM OR OTHERS ARE BENEFITTED THROUGH YOU.THIS GOVT IS NOT INTERESTED IN FORMULATING AN EFFECTIVE LOKPALL BILLNOR INTERESTED IN BRINGING BACK MONEY.FROM TIME TO TIME SC PASSES STRONG STRICTIRES AGAINST GOVT BUT SHAMELESS GOVT HAS NOT LEARNT FROM IT.HT AND CHADDA DID NOT CONDEMN POLICE ATTROCITIES ON RAMDEVJI SUPPORTERS WHICH WAS LIKE JALLIANAWALA BAGH.OUT OF SHEER NERVOUSNESS AND DESPERATION HER LEADERS ARE TALKING UNORDODOX LANGUAGES WHICH SHOWS LOST OF POLITICAL MORALITY AND DECENCY.NOTHING WILL CHANGE HT AND KUMKUM CHADDA FOR CARRYING OUT PROPOGANDA AGAINST BJP/HINDUS/VHP/RSS.

    [Reply]

  • http://- Rajeev

    In short, Kumkum wants to say “Please vote for Congress else you will have a 80+ Advani as your PM and Communal BJP aa jayegi”.

    Another paid blog.

    [Reply]

  • Dr. Atul K. Sahni

    He is a Gadha. Has a poor education, poor culture and very corrupt. Has no understanding at all of global politics. Mr Vajpayee was a class apart. Very crude as well this Gadhkari

    [Reply]

    Anjana Reply:

    I agree absolutely, he is a super stupid. Indian public deserve much better quality politicians. Recently this Gadh’s son got married and some 10,000 or 100,000 people were invited. From where this money came is not very difficult to guess. Income tax officials work keeping their eyes closed to these super corrupts.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    You should know that same gadha got Mumbai-Pune expressway constructed in record time in 1/4th the estimated cost without a single incidence of corruption.

    Now let us talk about Congress Gadha-Gadhi (sonia-Rahul) who are still stuck in 1970s style of populist and communal politics.

    [Reply]

    Pankaj Reply:

    And the Mumbai Flyoevrs as well which now conencts Thane to VT is 50 minutes. Also the “Gadha” is one of the biggest Sugar barons in Maharashtra (Legal Business not like the corrupt co-operatives). So the money fo rthe marriage for feeding 1lac guests comes from there. It is called “Varahadi (Nagpuri) Pahunchaar” roughly translated “Taking Care of GUESTS” a la Atithi devo bhava.

    [Reply]

    Manohar_T Reply:

    Doctor Saheb

    As one of the RSS trolls here justifies, you do not need to have any understanding of the global politics and may I add economics to become the President of an ‘exalted’ party like the BJP. All one needs is to construct one expressway (93 kms long) and lo and behold – the RSS deems it fit to appoint him to the post.

    You are right about his crudity.The language he has used against his political opponents in the past is proof enough.

    [Reply]

    Arvind R P Reply:

    Ha ha, this is a really good one.

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Congressi fascist like Manohar will make excuses to defend Congress dictatorial attitude and blame everything on BJP.
    According to them construction of first expressway in 1/4 estimated cost is small achievement but some nautanki 4 day padyatra is earthshaking event.

    Rajeev Reply:

    Congressis are the real trolls defending congress loot everywhere and blaming RSS/BJP for civil society protest.
    The congressi trolls like you support Islamic terror against India in the name of secularism.

    [Reply]

  • Anjana

    Indian public needs Hospitals, Schools, Roads, Uncorrupted and strong Institutions, Intelligent, wise and uncorrupted politicians and not Mandir

    [Reply]

  • indian

    Yeah , Gadkari Is Suicidal Kumkumji .

    But why don’t you write about Sonia , her trips on corporate jets, the scams in UPA , the loot of temple wealth , the unsecured loan to Robert Vadra by DLF . Kumkumji it is ironical that you are ant Hindu but have your name as kumkum.

    [Reply]

  • Prabhat

    BJP raked the temple issue ?

    Then the election must be round the corner !

    Election kab hai ? kab hai election ?

    [Reply]

  • ANIL

    Having a Mosque in Rastrapati Bhawan at Tax payer’s expense is OK but having a Temple in Ayodha is not OK!
    I like Kumkum’s article. It is as colourful as Kumkum!

    [Reply]

    bitter truth Reply:

    I think comparision is made between similarities. If you have mentioned the place for mosque location, mention the same place for mandir location also. You very well know that there is a mandir in Rashtrapati Bhavan as you have mentioned about mosque.

    [Reply]

    Manohar_T Reply:

    It does not suit Anil to state that there is a Mandir in the Rashtrapati Bhavan, otherwise his reasoning to justify for a Ram temple in Ayodhya falls flat.

    [Reply]

  • MP

    I have watched Nitin Gadkari’s performance as the BJP Chief since beginning. He has never shown maturity in the national politics, not to say of international politics. He is hurting the BJP sentiments and the Party’s chances for next elections. Even though the Congress has many holes, still BJP is not able to take any advantage. Gadkari should be replaced as soon as possible if BJP wants to achieve good results. He has a very narrow attitude. He is neither well informed nor does he speak well. how can such a person head the main opposition party? Earlier the better.

    [Reply]

    E.S.Shridhar Reply:

    Anyone can perform and be assessed for performance if and only if they are allowed to perform. Congress can not tolerate anyone being better than them. They have tried to disrupt normalcy in every non-cong. ruled states. Before rubbishing Nitin’s performance, it is only prudent that he be allowed to act and in that course commit mistakes

    [Reply]

  • Anoop Verma

    This mandir issue may be important for the BJP; but not for the now awakened people of India. Maybe, they should take up the temple related treasure as a new goal to ensure its proper utilization. Usually, such treasure are found, they remain in the headlines for a week or so, and then they just vanish. Not sure if with the vanishing of these headlines, what happens to the treasure.

    [Reply]

  • Sucheta

    Kumkum looks corrupt talks corrupt has senseless sense of politics. These journos only know to highlight few things and ignore lot others. Why they never said NDA govt. initiated the national highway scheme and the national ID project which the congress turned into its money making business. What a shame we have people like this reporting and we have to endure it.

    [Reply]

  • Peter

    Just as a mule is a cross-breed between a horse and a donkey, ‘indians/pakistanis/bangladeshis/sri lankans’ are cross-breeds between Aryan and Dravidian (austral-african, black, negrito).

    The muslims/christians in the sub-continent are just converts over a period of time. Babar was a half-mongol from Samarkand in present day Uzbekistan.

    For eg. Salman Khurshid is Aryan type while APJ Abdul Kalam is Dravidian admixture (cross-breed). The classification is based on skeletal/skull anthropometrics.

    All humans are members of the primate (apes, monkeys etc.) family of animals. They are vertebrate mammals. That is the scientific view.

    Gods etc. are just mythical folklore used in older (un-scientific) times to explain humanity.

    [Reply]

    Sucheta Reply:

    What is the point Mr. Peter. You sound in-coherent – was there a alcoholic hangover?

    [Reply]

  • sam

    kumkum is this your journlisim ,you sound like a child writing an essay in grade 5 class grow up write something investigative look around you will see billons of dollars worth pot belly polticians eating the poor indian money raise some voice against them ,write against the rotting system ,encourage the young indian minds to achieve ,your blogs are very passive and negative as if you are paid writer from 10 janpath repeating diggy and manish tewari and at times imititating sibal by cunningly trying to find meanining bettween the lines .i hope pankaj vora has given his post to you as people were fed up with him HT appointed you .pl grow up for india sake ,help india be on the right side .

    [Reply]

  • Candor

    BJP has already done its role in temple by demolition of Babri Masjid and Lord Ram is being worshipped at the place. However, Indians are known for forgetting those who had sacrificed for them. UP is known for making and spoiling any party calculations. BJP was forced to put temple issue on the back burner because they never got absolute majority to implement their agenda. It is better Hindus vote BJP to power alone and get rid of all Hindus related matters.

    [Reply]

  • Prabhat

    BJP raked up Temple issue all over again ?

    Then the election must be round the corner.

    When is the election ?

    election kab hai? kab hai election ?

    [Reply]

  • Partha Bhattacharyya

    I am more than a little disappointed by Kumkum’s blog coming as it does from a person whose
    stated purpose is to give us ‘a little known and lots unknown’ about those whom we elect.The
    continued harping on Advani as the BJP leader most qualified to take on Manmohan Singh is
    a ‘ghisa pita’ routine proved wrong time after time in national politics.Please tell us why the BJP
    can go no farther than its old leader and its communal agenda by simply appealing to the
    Supreme Court judgement at a time when the PM has stolen a march over the opposition by
    agreeing to keep his office within the Lok Pal.Let us in on the secret arrangement which keeps
    an old man in power when his leadership has proved to be unequal to the challenges of the
    information age.

    [Reply]

  • Manohar_T

    Kumkumji

    As I see it, the temple business has nothing to do with religion as far as the Sangh Parivar is concerned. It is the source of funds that would accrue from the temple that the RSS and its affliates would be after (perhaps the temple in Ayodhya would match or surpass Tirupati). With unlimited and mostly unaccounted funds at its disposal, the Sangh Parivar then hope to carry on with their nefarious agenda of Hindu Rashtra with more vigour.

    What one can say about Nitin Gadkari? He is being remote-controlled from Nagpur and that would explain his actions and utterances. Cannot blame the poor fellow.

    [Reply]

    ishwar Reply:

    Mr. Gadkari is the man behind Mumbai-Pune expressway and got over 50 flyovers in Mumbai completed before time and at less than the budgeted cost.

    You see what you want to see (or your pea-sized brain asks you to see).

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    These congressis only appreciate nautanki padyatra…all sound no substance. Before Mumbai-Pune expressway, India did not have a single road that was 4-lane. Gadkari was the one who got mumbai 52 flyovers in 1 year.

    These congressis have only lost up 50 years of percious time.

    [Reply]

    Manohar_T Reply:

    Ishwar and Rajeev

    I always thought that the BJP was a political party and not a construction company. May be I was wrong. (TIC).

    Rajeev Reply:

    Manohar,
    You are never old to learn…Keep reading.

  • My Thoughts.

    One one hand we have Manmohan Singh – a “non performing” PM with integrity (only claimed in media does not appears so if one looks at his (in)actions) who is worried about coalition dharma, Made in Italy fake gandhi leaders forced on us along with their sycophants like Digvijays, Tiwaris, Sibbals et al .

    And on the other hand we have self-made leaders like Arun Jaitley , Sushma Swaraj, Navjot Siddhu, Rajeev Pratap Rudy and others who have risen to national leadership by working for nation and without any sycophancy and are guided by seasoned leaders like Mr Vajpayee, Advani and MM Joshi etc. I think the choice is very clear.

    The need of the hour is to make people aware of the false propaganda unleashed by Congress of calling BJP communal, Asking for ones right is not communal — BJP is clearly saying temple should be there and by the way this is what SC also has agreed by stating that temple existed there.
    HAving said that i fully understand that nation has other issues too besides temple.
    After 50 years of Congress rule we are still a third world country – whatever little progress we have made is despite this government and not because of this. India has much more potential to grow but for that to happen we need a nationalist government and not minority appeasing, pseudo secular govt.

    [Reply]

  • tasneem

    You want the original instigator of communal hatred to take the reins of the government…..god bless you and the country !!…you really have lost your mind

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    The original instigator of riots Rajiv Gandhi was made PM of this country and then given Bharat Ratna.
    What is wrong if Modi is rewarded in the same way?

    [Reply]

  • http://esshridhar.blogspot.com E.S.Shridhar

    Dear Kumkumji, This blog conveys it is another of those paid trash. To mention LKA as the only bet for BJP is mischievous. It is in resonance with mind set of Cong. spokespersons and exposes your attitude is same as theirs- condescending towards BJP. I am sure you can write more constructive real articles. I look forward to reading them if they are forthcoming

    [Reply]

  • ram

    Advaniji is past his sell by date and should make way for younger leaders. Advani for PM means BJP is bankrupt of talent and ideas!

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Ha ha! Well written sir! The movie was a throwback to the 90’s, all bluster and no substance. After Kahaani, I was hoping that this one would be a step forward, but I guess Kahaani was a one-off wonder :(

    [Reply]