The Rs. 20-lakh car offer



A few years back while hunting stories for our India Yatra series, I bumped into Phoolmati. As she walked into a dilapidated house in Ramma Khera village with a heavy stack of hay on her head, someone in the rustic crowd said, ‘Yeh vidhayak ji ki patni hai’( She is wife of an MLA).

I was thunderstruck. MLA’s wife! How could it be? But the wife of late Shiv Charan Pasi, four-time Congress MLA, smiled, hiding her poverty behind her wrinkles. ‘He served all and not himself alone. As he never took bribe, he had nothing to leave behind.’ Shiv Balak Pasi was MLA from Salon assembly constituency in Rae Bareli from 1980 to 1992. He died in 2001.

I remembered her after senior Congress leader Pramod Tiwari told the media how late Rajiv Gandhi had to once give jeep to one of the party MLAs from Amethi after he failed to reach an important meeting on time. The MLA had to walk several kilometres and then take a bus to reach the venue.

Those days are gone. The MLAs today travel on the most expensive vehicles, no less than an SUV. According to the Election Watch, which conducts surveys of criminal cases and assets of peoples’ representatives, 67% of the UP legislators were millionaires. As Pramod later told me that there were still a few MLAs who travelled by bus and were agitated over the assembly secretariat’s decision to withdraw their passes.

There is nothing wrong in being rich if it is hard-earned money. I don’t know if there is any direct connection between the MLAs and MP’s fund with the economic growth of public representatives vis a vis that of their constituency, but an analysis would certainly help both the central and state governments as they would know it’s utility and utilisation.

Obviously, when chief minister Akhilesh Yadav announced Rs. 20 lakh from MLA fund, there was a huge hue and cry. Reasons were two. One, why use development fund for buying cars for personal use. Second, why the MLAs need Rs. 20 lakh SUVs and not the cheaper ones?

The government has promptly rolled back the offer while Opposition has come forth with suggestions on how cars could be given to them — cheaper loans to official vehicles.

Apparently government is keen to discourage MLA’s from taking government contracts in their name or that of their family members. The car offer won’t have helped as ‘ yeh dil always mange more’.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (8 votes, average: 3.38 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Logic RK

    Every elected member declares his asset, whether he has car or not.

    In case they dont have car, let them buy Comfortable Jeeps on Loan from Govt at 1% interest from his own salary, he can take his jeep anywhere but govt will pay only for diesel for this much per month as allowance.

    When he/she already has a car declared in his affidavit of election, the govt will pay him the standard depreciation as per Income Tax law at the end of his tenure + Allowance for diesel.

    Why to give them car , boss ? It will affect their self -respect.. !

    [Reply]

  • Ramesh Kumar

    WHERE DO YOU POSITION YOURSELF IN STANZA QUOTED FROM ‘MACBETH’.
    NO WONDER SHAKEASPEARE RIGHTLY COMMENTED,’ FRAILITY THY NAME ,O WOMAN.’
    COMMENT EXPECTED DEAR AUTHORESS.

    [Reply]

    Kushal Reply:

    I’m sorry, I don’t know what you mean, Ramesh. Is there are problem with quoting Shakespeare?

    [Reply]

    Ramesh Kumar Reply:

    I have no problem of Great Shakespeare being quoted.All i had asked was in what phase ,do you find yourself.
    The state of mind depends on the attitude of a individual. With your permission i will quote Dr.Viktor Frankel,” every thing can be taken away from a man,except his attitude.”
    The kind of state you have mentioned in your blog is brought by a person herself.

    [Reply]

    Kushal Reply:

    What you’ve said is exactly what I wrote, Ramesh. “I’m feeling particularly cynical today.”

  • http://twitter.com/onsanjana Sanjana S

    I woke up early this morning. At 3am. Couldn’t sleep so I turned to my iPad for comfort. Tried to watch some shows, but, fortuitously enough, none of the links were working. So I decided to read one of the iBooks in my collection. Great Expectations.
    That poor wretched boy, born into that wretched life, so confused, so scared and so hungry all the time… that poor prisoner who escaped into the freezing cold, with chains on his legs and dressed in rags with nothing to keep him warm, no food nor drink…
    When it turned light, I looked outside to a beautiful wintry morning sky, able to appreciate its beauty cos I was warm, inside an insulated house, cocooned in a blanket and a cup of hot tea in my hand. Counting my blessings came easy today. :)

    Hope you feel better.

    [Reply]

    Kushal Reply:

    Oh, this is just one of those futility of life phases that I go through every now and then, Sanjana. I’m sure I’ll get over it, but in the meantime, I’m wallowing.

    [Reply]

    Sanjana S Reply:

    Chocolate helps! The darker, the better! :)

    [Reply]

    Kushal Reply:

    Hahahaha!

    Nutella is my poison.

  • http://www.facebook.com/kanikadhupar Kanika Dhupar

    I am becoming this person who is not affected with murder, rapes, kidnappings etc. We wait for murders to our page 1 now, so yes, journalism makes you cynical (and emotionless). As for Indian men, they have some serious anger management issues and they are the reason behind most of our page-ones. The big-bloated ego’s are good-for-nothing.

    I sum how wonder, am I doing any good by editing all this **** each day or just getting more cynical each day?

    [Reply]

    Kushal Reply:

    Yes, I know. It becomes a story.

    Dunno how this helps except perhaps brings justice to SOME victims.

    [Reply]

    Abhiroop Reply:

    How else are we supposed to know about ‘things’? Doordarshan? BBC? Amar Chitra Katha?

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/kanikadhupar Kanika Dhupar

    Hahahha, you are funny, Buuny :P

    PS: You have taken to technology like a fish takes to water (hint hint: Fb alerts (;)

    [Reply]

  • http://twitter.com/SankarParu Parvathy Sankar

    After buying a couple of unreadable books from bookshops in a hurry, just based on blurb and cover without reading some pages, I wish we could randomly open a page of the book and read when buying online. On the other hand I did not have the reviews at my finger tips.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/kanikadhupar Kanika Dhupar

    Nooooooooooooooooh, Don’t please.

    [Reply]

  • NSG

    well said …..

    [Reply]

  • Deepak

    Well said – Indian leaders and leadership is full of BS – nothing moves em. If India wants to be respected as a Leader it needs to take care of its own dirty laundry. Take lesson from israel and US – clinical attacks are the way forward, provided leaders understand the word “Clinical”

    [Reply]

  • ad

    And what when you turn a blind eye toward activities Jihadists aka Pakis? Gandhism will not stand up against rabid dogs. The only solution is to cull them …all

    [Reply]

  • BVSat

    Love for your eye will leave you blind and the other guy with sight. Sounds fun? Take your Gandhian logic somewhere else. Won’t apply these days.

    [Reply]

  • Magoma

    It is the task of the Government to respond. And if you have a Government, consisting of lawyers and politicians with unpatriotic attitude, ridden with Himalayan corruption led by not an original person from the land who would have some nationalistic feelings, this is to be expected. It is a tragedy that such a Govt is ruling for 10 years with the help of corrupt people and parties coming to power by hook or by crook. Still there are parties like SP who believes that organizations like SIMI is not a bad organization. When we have half of the voters BPL, what can a democracy do in this land.

    Unless there is regeneration of the nation through intense education including moral and ethical according to the teachings and message of Swami Vivekananda, there is not very much of of a quick improvement of the present situation.

    [Reply]

  • MMR

    Bull Shit. Tell this to the Americans and Israelis. They will tell you how they got Osama to the hell where he belongs. That is the only language these animals will understand. Grow up you are dealing with barbarians who deserve no mercy.

    [Reply]

  • himalaya

    Not only USA, even China and Israel silently knock off high value enemies in other countries that attack their countries. Chanakya neeti also favours such covert operations; but present day Indian leaders are so timid.

    [Reply]

  • Dr.RAJ

    if only some follow what ever you say, then it is the non-violent who would go blind while the rogues will rule the world.

    [Reply]

  • Oglipogli

    “Badle se badla nahi jaayega, Badla to barbadi hi laayega”…!!!

    [Reply]

    Pakorachai Reply:

    Well said….I shall come and f**k your mother. No “badla” ofcourse because it will take you to barbaadi.

    [Reply]

  • Prakash

    Vir, covert action against who? Pakistan military? Isn’t that a war?

    [Reply]

  • koushikgrs

    whenever thereis a fight between 2 children in the class they may beat each other, but they will never go ask their parent’s permission for retaliation this is
    simple ,let our goverment not complicate matters when pakistan has dared to
    kill our fouji naujawan , we shall not keep quite no waiting,,let’s not think of consquence,it is this conquence that is creating fear in our leader’s mind not
    prompting for action, enough is enough Pakistan should be taught a bloody
    lesson of their life.

    [Reply]

  • Sameer

    Pigs deserves only shit…not fruits.. they never understand the value of our big heart.

    [Reply]

  • Mr. India

    Take out Hafiz, things will change on the ground soon.

    [Reply]

  • Raj

    Vir, Did Nira Radia dictate this story?

    [Reply]

  • johnD

    corrupt, discredited journos taking the easiest path to redeem themselves, “patriotism”, demonizing a fictional ‘enemy’ and war mongering!

    [Reply]

  • jagsharma

    Stop all trade with Pak and close the Bagga Border. No more cricket matches with Pak.

    [Reply]

  • Bharat

    Good analysis, Mr. Sanghvi. It is so sad that no humiliation, no matter how severe, stirs our leaders. Even the public would protest for a few days and then get back to focusing on their own interests. Nationalistic fervor is all but dead..woh kehtey hain na..”khoon paani ho gaya hai”. You are absolutely right about them only huffing and puffing..it is really very sad and unfortunate. Some of the comments (here) on using Gandhian approach are the most ridiculous ..they have their heads stuck in sand for the past 6 decades. How many eyes do they have to sacrifice before they become totally blind..more than two? ..there was the parliament attack, several bombings in cities, attack on Akshardhaam, 26/11, and on and on… Kab tak saho ge?

    [Reply]

  • Amit

    It was an epic failure of India to let Pakistan acquire nuclear weapons. It could have stopped it by hook and crook. I believe the fault lies with so called foreign policy experts. And now that we have been caught between the rock and hard place, we are still playing a defensive game. What is needed is a policy to further break up Pakistan. Obviously it is a country which is created on Hindu hate instead of other factors like nationalism that is common with other countries. So it will be foolish to expect a change in attitude of people from across the border.

    [Reply]

  • raina

    This all started in 1989 when 10 lakh kashmiri Hindus were forced to flee the valley their homes burnt so that they can not come back spine less Indian Govt and Indian Army watched and did nothing India will pay a heavy price for this mistake at that time it was ISI strategy

    1 make kashmir 100% Muslim area
    2 Bring terror to streets of India from Kashmir
    3 bleed India to death till it diintegrates

    India has been lucky because of 9/11 USA and Nato landed in Afghnistan this kept ISI and Pak army busy now USA is withdrawing means attntion will be on Kashmir now
    we Indians ( hindus) are weak and clumsy pakistan is ruthless as a nation they will definitley hurt and bleed India

    [Reply]

  • anil

    This is first time Vir Singvi wrote something that makes some sense.

    [Reply]

  • Shamir

    What an immature article , jingoistic to its roots to say the least . In this recent border incident it was first india who killed a pakistani soldier and remember sanghvi, india is not USA

    [Reply]

  • Arjun

    India acted once in 1971 and diveded you in to two it is time for India to act again Balochistan and Khybar pakhtoon are fighting for freedom India will free them

    [Reply]

    Shakir Reply:

    here u have accepted what indian govt is denying since 1971. u must also accept that indian have killed thousands of innocent people in kashmir and inside india

    [Reply]

  • Joey15

    Well said. Thank you for writing this article. What we need is not full scale war but retaliation enough to take out the terrorists hiding withing Pakistan territory. That will silence them enough. Or so called leaders need to see the movie ‘Munich’ and take a lesson.

    [Reply]

  • nisant

    i remember making a comment when first this new broke out that india is going to act all angry and then that’ll be it, and as you can see nothing happaned…typical indian. btw, i am an indian.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ajil-Philip/1366882224 Ajil Philip

    How bout India send its own drones over the border, drop some ordinance and keep quiet about it…. They’ll think its American drones and not bother….

    [Reply]

  • Ramesh Kumar

    ONLY FULL SCALE WAR CAN ENSURE LONG TERM PEACE.EUROPE HAS NOT GONE ON WAR SINCE 1945.DONOT ALLOW INDIANS TO BE HUMILIATED BY KAYANIS OR HAFIJS ETC.HOW MANY HEADS MUST BE CUT BEFORE INDIAN GOVT REALIZES THEY ARE OUR BOYS.HOW JUMPY WAS SALMAN KHURSHID WHEN HIS WIFE WAS CHARGED WITH SOME CORRUPTION CHARGES BY KEJRIWAL.IT WAS ONLY A CORRUPTION CHARGE.

    [Reply]

  • Manik

    Wow and this is call a journalism. But will India. Govt. listen as they do not have a balls and when you have mafia and criminals in control of a country, the people will play a price. It’s a shame to be an Indian since indeed we have become a banana republic.

    [Reply]

  • Singh

    Only Hari Singh Nalwa and Ranjit Singh can kick their a**…….these dhotiwalas have no balls……..Hari Singh conquered Kabul and Ranjit Singh had Lahore as his capital and Jagjit Singh Arora kicked their a** and created Bangladesh…….

    [Reply]

  • singh

    O Gandhi Kay chalay……go and preach this to pakis…..

    [Reply]

  • Raja

    For a butcher class it makes no difference to behead a human or an animal. It took forever to hang 26/11 culprit. That is the state of our country and its politicians who are weak and are only concerned about their “ghotals” and political seat.What will it take for this impotent government to wake up

    [Reply]

  • s ramji

    Best things is to hire someone in Pakistan to end the fugitives in Pakistan. there should be enough persons to do the job or money. It has to be an international tender. If America can do it why not we?

    [Reply]

  • prashant saxena

    sadly, beheading as a form of adding insult to injury is not unprecedented in the Indo-Pak conflict. In fact old timers would remember the Gurkha regiment as the prime culprits in this regard. I met a Bengali Colonel Saheb who had received a Maha Veer Chakra after he beheaded a couple of Pakistanis. So, rather than lamenting he transgression of the Geneva treaty, we should condider who should be beheaded on their side. The Colonel of the Regiment of the Baloch regiment? The CO of the 29 Baloch battalion? His children? Those would all be valid targets. The only aim would be to inflict severe and unacceptable damage, to prevent recurrence of such an incident.

    [Reply]

  • Sanjay

    What is the role of Islam in this?

    [Reply]

  • TheHinduNation

    Very sensible and balanced article by Vir “Radia Gate” Sanghvi for a change. Hes right, no point in empty chestthumping, actions speak louder than words. If we could have our own Seals taking out and beheading Hafiz Saeed, video record it, and later broadcast it. Imagine the message it will send to all enemies of India, including Pakistan. The keyword here is IF….

    [Reply]

  • TheHinduNation

    Very sensible and balanced article by Vir “Radia Gate” Sanghvi for a change. Hes right, no point in empty chestthumping, actions speak louder than words. If we could have our own Seals taking out and beheading Hafiz Saeed, video record it, and later broadcast it. Imagine the message it will send to all enemies of India, including Pakistan. The keyword here is IF….

    [Reply]

  • piyush

    very true

    [Reply]