Should every hungry hand pick up arms?



This is in reaction to reports coming post Dantewada. Some revolutionary writers are trying to defend the naxal movement saying it stems from poverty. Just because people don’t have ‘roti’, they pick up arms.
To some extent, it can be justified. No mother can bear the sight of her wailing hungry children day in day out. But is that the only way to fight hunger?
Perhaps not! There are reports emanating from all over the country about brave men and women who are finding legal ways to fight hunger – that too without depending on the government aid. Sometimes, I feel the government’s policies of providing easy loan and subsidies actually kill the killer’s instinct.
Here I recall a lesson that I learnt from women of Bhandara in Maharashtra. Every day they trek on the road to their economic development, layered with danger. Guess what gives them strength—their traditions and beliefs.’ One of them told me, “Baba would never harm us.” I thought she was referring to robbers or dacoits, active in the dense forest that she trudges every day to earn bread and educate children.
“We call a tiger Baba. He often warns his presence by pounding the mud; either we move away or yeroo (tiger) goes away. He also guards us from other wild animals,” Sushi Kala Dhurve in Koknagad village had told me. She has been going to the jungle for past 25 years.
Hard to believe, but they insist:  “The tiger is our God, how can he harm us.” Other animals that they encounter every visit are wild elephants, leopard, deer et al.
Women from Koknagad, Golewada, Munsi, Khapa, Ranwadi villages surrounding the thick Sakoli forest in Bhandara visit forest every alternate day to pick up leaves for making patravali- leaf plate. They go deep inside the dense forests, plucking and picking leaves, putting them in their sacks they carry on their backs. The only precaution that they take is of moving in a group of 20 to 25 with two men providing the protective cover.
Next day they tie these leaves into disposable ‘patravalis’ still considered cheaper and hygienically better than the paper and plastic plates.
What worries them, however, is the growing scarcity of Char Mahua leaves, from which pattals are made, and Sheelka, used for binding them. Thanks to the flourishing Indian customs and ceremonies, these courageous women have never been short of work.
And look at the men, they work as daily wagers only to spend their earnings on liquor.
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (3 votes, average: 5 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Anil Kumar

    If tomorrow some hungy guy kills while trying to rob me I can understand why he di that.. but I most certainly do not approve thsi organized crime syndicate called Maoist their motive is power grabd and have nothign to do with providing food to the poor.

    [Reply]

  • Nikhil

    The culture of violent revoluions, bandhs, rasta or rail roko etc must be put to an end. Such acts exacerbate the misery of millions of poor instead of alleviating the problem, howsoever real or acute that cause may be. Only a select few – politicians, TV personalities, celebrities – benefit to further their careers from such pseudo-revolutions.

    [Reply]

  • Nutsure

    If a hungry soul can learn to shoot and kill he certainly can learn to earn. Maoist are big time organised crime with political patronage. They have a huge funding from from powers that want to destabilise the democracy. A Gun costs a lot more than the what a family might require for worth of 3 months’ ration. Probe into their funds and strangulate their sources. If the Govt. is willing it is not difficult.

    [Reply]

  • http://- Rajeev

    Sunita,
    Pl. accept my apologies for getting off topic.
    Looking at your neutral stand (politically), I think-
    1. You are out of place in Hindustan times because you are not OVERLY pro-congress but MILDLY neutral.
    2. You don’t own a cell phone. This means Congress can not tap your phone and blackmail you as it does in case of other HT columnist.

    I have full symapthy for media.

    [Reply]

  • A.C. Sethi

    Hello Sunita ji,

    I just now was looking at the blog of Mr Pankaj Vohra about Sachin Tandulkar, and found that 185 persons commented on his blog. However when I looked at your this blog which involves such a serious social issue, only four people commented on it. Is it not sad that how indifferent we are to our social issues?

    [Reply]

  • http://mywriterkeeda.wordpress.com Ishmart Alec

    Well, I can just say that logic, rationale, virtues, righteousness are not something that would be on your mind, when you are hungry (hungry as in food for survival), watching your home being slowly eaten away in the name of development. Add to that, lack of education and virtually no job market…

    [Reply]

  • Rajesh Kumar

    One of my acquaintance was abducted by the maoist in the Jharkhand last year. He is into Nursery business and went there to finalise an order. The maoist who abducted him took him and a couple of government employees into the Jungle. It was then revealed by the high ranking government employee to the Maoist that the order was for 35 lacs for which the government grant is close to 80 lacs. On the top of the 45 lacs that these government employees were cornering, they were also demanding cuts from the 35 lacs order that they would place on the said acquaintance.He was shown the first hand account of how some of the adivasi family survive with hardly any grain in their meal. They literally survive on some leaves and fruits. The moral of the story is that all the government development fund allocated for the welfare of the adivasis are cornered by these government employees who spend hardly anything on the adivasis. It is outrageous and shameful that some of the comments here demand violent actions against the maoist knowing fully well that it is a social issue which doesn’t require violent response. The said acquaintance is now a changed man and openly says that the issue to be addressed is our greed and exploitation of the adivasis. For those of you who comment that a hungry mouth shouldn’t pick up arms, I’d suggest that you go hungry for just 48 hours and let your child also be hungry, and then come here and write comments about this issue.

    [Reply]

  • balwant

    The main reason of picking arms by common man is the corruption. Today NAREGA grants are being enjoyed by the mediators like Panchayat Mantris, Pradhans etc by overbilling the Musterroll and collecting the money from labours who can never dare to protest it as it will adversly affect thier ROTI by not given work by these influenced people. 60% grans of centre / state government goes to the pockets of government officials. Where the food grains are going which are sent for mid day meals ? Is there any criteria to square up the money spent versus the work done by grants? If I am eating someone’s share, what that fellow will do? How many days he can afford seeing me eathing his share? These are the burning questions forcing common man to pick arms to kill devils like me who is eating their share and also threating them. Similar is the case of our governments who are are protecting criminals and high profile people and the recent exampls are – Nithari case, Aarushi murder case, Kasab case which is an example saying that the money spent on him could have provided food to thousand people, large number of mercy petitions pending since long time which is admiring the foreign terrorists to come to India and kills innocents as they know FOOL INDIAN SYSTEM WILL ALWAYS PROTECT THEM, IPL scam and tax exemption to the WORLD’S RICHEST CRICKET BOARD ( BCCI) – WHY? as the government is penalising a common man by putting tax liability as if one is the earning member and four family members are only dependents how he can survive? I am not favoring the act of picking arms of common man, but I as seeking reply of above questions and if these questions are honestly solved, such things will never happen

    [Reply]

  • Rahulsk

    I agree with rajesh kumar, you don’t appear to have an understanding of the problem. Writing to popular newspaper topics should require at least some research. You seem to be taking a very limited view.

    [Reply]

  • http://o3/indiatimes.com/JYOTI RAMAN LAL RANIGA

    HUMANS IN WARS HAVE BARREN THE MOTHER EARTH
    WHO COULD TEACH THEM TO LIVE IN PREM PRABHU
    FOR NO ONE SEEMS TO LISTEN
    JUST WARS TO BLOW UP MILITARY HARDWARE
    MILK THE TAXPAYERS MANUFACTURE
    AGAIN THE MILITARY HARDWARES
    CREATE WARS AND BLOWUP
    BARREN THE MOTHER EARTH
    POISONING THE MOTHER EARTH.
    THIS IS THE GREED OF ARM MANUFACTURERS
    THAT CREATE WARS.

    http://ca.news.yahoo.com/nphotos/NATO/ss/events/wl/20060926_nato;_ylt=AvVw6lRbl4ku4vSg1vedARSAAIl4/im:/22042010/24/photo/photos-n-usa-gathering-tallinn-first-focus-plans-reform-nato-deal-modern.html/#photoViewer=/22042010/24/photo/photos-n-world-gathering-estonian-capital-tallinn-first-focus-plans-reform-nato.html

    [Reply]

  • http://o3/indiatimes.com/JYOTI RAMAN LAL RANIGA

    YOU HAVE BECOME ANTI HUMAN SOUL SO YOU DO NOT ALL TO LISTEN TO BHAJANS YOU TRY TO MANIPULATE THE POSTING

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    AIR INDIA SOLUTION – SPLIT IT, SPLIT IT, SPLIT IT AND THEN PRIVATISE IT, PRIVATISE IT, PRIVATISE IT FOLLOWED BY CUT SHORT HEAD COUNT, CUT SHORT HEAD COUNT, CUT SHORT HEAD COUNT!

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000656432934 Bhargav Thantry

    I dont understand why all of us are so narrow minded. If you feel something is not proper then u should have the guts to change it instead of crying over it. Whoever has posted this aricle is very immature. Air India is a fantastic airline and it is the airline of my choice. Just because it is a govt airline, all of you are just bragging about it.
    Have you checked out AI’s US routes…??? It is a superhit and AI has won numerous awards on those sectors too. If you dont wont to travel by AI then shut up and find some other airline, speculation hurts the brand image.
    The current problem what AI is facing is because of the UPA govt. Their services are just excellent. Its not justifiable to take up the issue of what happened long long ago and judge the airline on it. Think practical guys…!! wake up..!!
    Its easy to sit and brag about anything without knowing what it is..!

    [Reply]