When England Ruled the Mind



Several years ago a young US diplomat told me, “Wherever in the world I’ve been posted, I always found that the British had been there before me.” Luigi Barzini and Ian Buruma both wrote excellent books describing how in 19th century Europe the British came to define continental culture. Liberals admired British constitutional democracy. Conservatives their naval strength and sporting culture. Baron de Coubertin, founder of the Olympics, saw the English public school’s inculcation of rugby and cricket playing in young boys as something France should emulate. The rugby stayed but the cricket died on the vine.

The Americans and their culture of course replaced the British as The Model Nation after World War II.

What, one wonders, will a future China and India offer to the world to inspire similar emulation?

China’s will most likely be the example of going from mass poverty to mass manufacturing at an incredible pace, creating an enormous infrastructure and financial stock along the way.

India will be about developing democratic structures and a robust civil society amid poverty and illiteracy. The real test is the next stage of both countries’ development.

India has to build the sort of industrial base that China has. China has to build the sort of political flexibility that India has. Whoever succeeds in this crossover game, I suspect, will be this century’s Model Power. I give India the edge if only because political systems are a lot harder to change than physical landscapes. But time will tell.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (6 votes, average: 4.83 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • ABC

    But what about the most difficult change of all: the social system.

    In China there are no castes. Pretty much just one ethnicity. Even class distinctions are relatively easy going. (Even the lower rich class of Beijing and Shanghai don’t have full time domestic workers.) Gender equality is good. (On any subway in China you will find a 1:1 ratio of men to women. On the Delhi Metro it looks more like 5:1. Why are women staying inside the house?)

    China has a lot more than physical infrastructure going for it.

    [Reply]

  • sunit

    Most people today are confused as to who they should “follow “to look “different”. Isn`t there a contradiction? Why should we emulate any body? Why should we not preserve our caste system which helps massively in creating identity and ,consequently, stability? Why should we not preserve our class system which creates diversity and ambition and enterpreneurship? What`s wrong in preserving ancient tribes of Andaman which were on the verge of extinction due to tsunami? Should we expect them to emulate the British or American? Sustainable development should include conservation of identity otherwise we will all “become” schizophrenic.

    [Reply]

  • Abu Ahmed

    We cannot go meet relatives, friends due cost of gas, distance and traffic jams. We have stopped going to neighbourhood mosques 5 times a day, temples or churches. Minimal contact with people outside of the work place have rendered us TV/Web bound. Out of 120 crore people, if somebody sitting in a remote corner of a small city or village gossips about Rakhee Sawant or Pinky Pandey, hats off to these ladies for reaching out to fame without making any worthwhile contribution in any walk of life.

    [Reply]

  • p. vijay menon

    its not “Reporter’s dairy” but Diary”!!!!!!

    [Reply]