Fear and Loathing in Jaipur



There are two occasions when I have felt as though I have woken from the dead. The first was, aged 16, after I had an operation on my back, which had required a general anesthetic.

The second was last Friday when I came ‘to’ so to speak following a week off work ill following my trip to Jaipur.Coming out of a general aneasthetic isn’t like waking up from sleeping: it’s like waking up from unconsciousness, or from being dead, (a feeling one doesn’t have too often.)

Likewise, recovering from the acute bronchitis and laryngitis that I caught in Jaipur gave me a similar feeling when I recovered – waking from the dead.

That week of illness is a hazy memory. Day became night and night became day. During the day I was in and out of bouts of sleep. At times I would wake and set myself a task like make a hot drink of lemon. Once done, I would have no energy and then sleep again for four hours. At night I had hot and cold sweats. The cough was so deep sometimes I felt like I had stopped breathing.

When such a coughing fit was over, I would feel shell shocked – my whole body had heaved so much…

And I had an uncomfortable feeling throughout my body, especially my legs -a feverish feeling, a restlessness. My temperature was sometimes 102.  I went from being boiling hot, my head emanating heat, to being cold, wearing a fleece in my Mumbai room. Throughout I had no appetite. But I could consume orange juice and so I drank and drank that and ate nothing. It all felt like how I imagined malaria would feel. I hated it. I vowed never to smoke a cigarette or shisha pipe again…For this is an illness smokers get, before they get lung cancer. This illness is not worth having, it’s horrid. My parents rang me every night. “Will your maid know what to do if she finds you in a worse condition?” my Dad would ask.

The reason for this grip of fever?  The answer is: Jaipur.

Every time I see that irritating AD on TV with that blond girl in a red dress skipping along and hear that man’s voice booming: “Come to Rajasthan,” I want to strangle someone. It’s all marketing and no delivery, in my view.

You see, while there is nothing wrong with the monuments, forts, palaces and so on in the Pink City, there is everything wrong with the budget hotels, drivers and rickshaw drivers.

I took a hotel at Rs 900 a night.

I knew Jaipur would be cold at this time of year, but presumed (naively) the hotel would have central heating.

But No, it was one of those converted heritage palaces that did not just not have heating, but was designed not to let heat in, so in January, my room was colder than the freezing weather outside. What did the hotel provide to compensate? A thin blanket.

Every night I shivered to sleep, literally, and that was wearing a thermal top, two jumpers and a fleece.

I have no idea how the people who sleep in the streets there survive. What beats me is, why don’t they install radiators and carpets?

The entire experience in the hotel was like an episode from Fawlty Towers.

I asked for a fan heater and was given an instrument, that looked like it was 200-years-old.

I switched it on and smelly black fumes blew in my face. The choice appeared to be death from carbon monoxide poisoning or the chill. I choose the former.

I then touched the heater to move it to face me and got an electric shock. This heater had never been tested by an electrician, I mulled.

I rang up room service form the room phone.

Naturally, there was no line. I called from my mobile instead and ordered hot water, to take medicine with. The man arrived with room temperature Bisleri. “Garam hai” he insisted. In the morning I could see my breath in the air. I switched the shower on and cold water came out.

I touched the switch on the water heater, and a huge part of it fell onto me, broken by rust. I called the reception form my mobile. A man arrived, touched the water heater and more fell off. I had a shower in another hotel room down the corridor.  My hotel sheets looked like they had never been cleaned. Dust was everywhere. The place was crumbling.  There wasn’t a single Indian person in the hotel, which was telling.  It was full of foreigners. I don’t understand why these budget hotels insist on making their rooms and experiences for tourists as horrible as possible. If nothing else, they give a very bad impression of India to foreigners. (When I first came to India as a backpacker aged 19, I remember staying in these kinds of places, and thinking that was how Indians actually lived like that…in crumbling rooms, with bursting water heaters, and toxic fume heaters.. Now I live here, I know it is not the case.)

The state government should start visiting all these hotels, and striking them off its list, when they do not conform to basic safety, hygiene and ‘liveable’ standards, rather than throwing so much money at TV adverts.

I have since been told by some Indian friends I should have spent Rs 3,000 minimum on my Jaipur hotel, and bribed the management to get better facilities. Is it true?

Even last year I took a week holiday in Rajasthan, that cost me and a friend Rs 1 lakh. That time we had a nightmare time with the driver that the reputable travel agent had provided.

He drove like a maniac around the state, insisted on stopping at certain restaurants en route, that charged us a bomb for food (and he clearly got commission), made deals with touts and annoying guides, even offering them lifts in our vehicle, so they could try and sell their services to us. When we stopped at a Costa Coffee, he strolled in and joined us, and when we stayed up late, he refused to pick us up the next day until after 12pm, ruining our schedule. I vowed never to have a driver again, after that.

This time, apart from my woes at the hotel, I had to suffer at the hands of the auto rickshaw drivers in Jaipur.

Every rickshaw driver in Jaipur speaks fluent English, unlike those in Mumbai.

“Where are you from?” one asked excitedly as he met me outside the festival. “Mumbai,” I replied.

“How come every foreign woman at the festival is from Mumbai?” he  muttered disappointingly.

The same guy ended up getting me to use him to go to and from the festival. He said he knew better hotels, I stupidly let him take me to them – they were very shady and worse. I said I wanted to go to Barista. I sat down at the table, and he joined me. Bizarrely, he ordered an expresso. He then said he found me attractive and there was chemistry between us and listed previous a string of previous girlfriends he had – from Mexico to Denmark I told him I wasn’t interested.. He kept insisting he was in love with me. I kept telling him I was not.

I was so tired of having to shake this guy off. He clearly didn’t “get” that I was not a tourist. I’ve no idea what he wanted from me, but from experience of backpacking I know, that when these rickshaw drivers or guides or random street kids get extra friendly with you, and start joining you for coffees, at the back of their mind, they have some kind of scam planned, and the friendly banter is all a means to win your trust.

It is no surprise then it was in Jaipur, when backpacking around India aged 19, that I nearly got lured into a gems scam.

I’m sure these things don’t happen to Indians in Rajasthan – it is just something to welcome us foreign tourists.

If only the Rajasthan government would star experiencing a trip round the state from the eyes of a firang tourist rather than making these TV Ads. Currently the only safe way to travel round the state is to do so five star. Yet, it should be possible to go to Jaipur and have a perfectly nice time staying in a three star or two star hotel.

So, the best part about Jaipur was the airport. It was a huge modern building that ticked all the boxes, and was warm.

I sat in a really trendy café and drinking hot drinks waiting for my flights…By that time I had lost my voice and had fever. Luckily I didn’t have the rickshaw driver to contend with.

Back in Mumbai I was overjoyed to be home. The taxi driver at the airport didn’t declare he was in love with me.

The following day a doctor came to my house and diagnosed acute bronchitis and laryngitis. I went on to antibiotics and other medicines.

From my sick bed I sent an email to Natures Basket with a shopping list of drinks and fruits I needed. Then at 12.30pm the next day I took a call from a man with perfect English informing me they didn’t have cranberry juice or chamomile tea in stock. I was impressed.

Within minutes the groceries, exactly what I had ordered with no errors, had arrived. My maid checked on me very day (the invaluableness of maids). After a week of being ill in bed, I went to have a reflexology treatment at one of the many superb Bandra spas; I took a walk along Bandstand to gain fresh air, I started to read Maximum City, and started to regain energy.

Who cares if that girl in the red dress found love or not in Rajasthan. I’m not in a rush to go back there and find out. Not until someone improves the quality of accommodation. Or I can afford to stay at the Rambagh Palace.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (8 votes, average: 3.5 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Dev

    Never ever go budget hotel hopping in India, no matter what the advertisements, touts and officials tell you.
    If it’s a tourism hotspot, like Rajasthan, Goa, Kerala, go in groups, preferably with 2-3 males in the group of largely females, stay in 5-star hotels which give value for money, book your drivers from the hotel you are staying in.
    Backpacking by oneself , if you are a single female, makes you an automatic rape target, whatever be the color of your skin.
    As an Indian male who learnt the hard way at a Benaras seedy hotel, I know something about backpacking in budget hotels in semi-rural India.
    Does that make me afraid ? No.
    Does that make me cautious ? Definitely.

    [Reply]

    KJSS Reply:

    Sorry to hear the ordeal you have been through! Wish you early and fast recovery.

    [Reply]

    US Reply:

    Dear Expat,

    Sorry to hear your ordeal. Obviously you don’t have the time to do a bit of R&D before heading out like Christopher Columbas. Well, don’t blame yourself. Its not your job. It’s certainly the poor 3rd world country you travel to. Yes, we have corrupt political goons chewing away at funds for public infrastructure, in fact at almost everything. Now, the situation demands, when travel, try and be a little respectful. Blogging, is a public platform. It’s not the local quack’s hangout, right? It’s impolite to first, visit our country, then criticize it all over the place. Its probably not your imagination. But your lucky to be getting a roof to sleep under with a budget of 15 $ a day. Yes, we don’t have good budget hotels at all, the tourism industry has realized it and if you notice groups like Lemon Tree, Ginger (Taj), etc are investing in this sector. Till then, book yourself at 4 – 5 star hotels, or at least check ratings on TripAdvisor or some such sites. But please, don’t travel around these areas, if you don’t like them and going on a rampage with a vengeance. Why not concentrate on better things, such as the dwindling tiger population, poverty, corruption or wars which take place in this day and age.
    Many thanks

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    Hi US, whoever thou art. Below is a piece I wrote for Hindustan Times about a trip I made to a village in India…

    Sitting on the patio outside my mud hut, I breathe in the fresh air, gaze at the crystal clear green and yellow landscape ahead and I don’t think once about watching TV.
    Listening to the music of the birds and crickets, the idea of going to the latest bar is removed from my mind.
    I am content just to sit, breathe and stare.
    This is because in the remote tribal village of Kohane, situated 895 metres high in the mountains, 250kms from Mumbai, there is plenty to do.
    You can sit and watch women wander past carrying pots on their heads, or men in dhotis moving cows and goats shouting “Yearr”….and that scene becomes your TV.
    The air is so clean and fresh, you don’t need a radio to unwind because you are not stressed, the scenery is inspiring and your thoughts naturally wander.
    When I arrived (after a nine hour journey from Mumbai), the first thing I did was switch on my laptop and mobile.
    There was no connection on either.
    The villagers, who belong to the Mahadevkohli tribe, wondered what I was doing.
    I felt like an urban freak clutching my bag filled with Cadbury’s, Bisleri and Frooti.
    But as I spent time there, my stress slowly dissipated and my need for material possessions decreased.
    Kohane is untouched by modernity and westernisation. Hidden in the Akole region of Ahmadnagar district of Maharashtra, the people living there are not aspiring to move to Mumbai, buy cars or wear Calvin Klein. They are content to carry on living their lives as people did in ancient times. They are not poor, far from it if you consider that living in a scenic place, with loving people and having enough food to eat means that.
    I was the first tourist ever to stay in their new mud hut.
    A simple environmentally-friendly building, it is so cool inside that you do not need A/C. It is tastefully decorated with cushions on the sparkling clean floor, a bamboo table and two double beds.
    NGO Watershed Organisation Trust (WOTR) persuaded a tribal family to offer its ancestral land up to build the hut, and they and the village now own a stake in the new rural tourism project.
    There are plenty of activities on offer for the urban professional like me– such as trekking – but I chose to spend the day as a villager.
    This started with the harvesting of rice with a sickle, which I found quite easy. I enjoyed the brisk exercise in the fresh air.
    Next was the flattening of the earth for re-seeding. This involved me performing a strange balancing act standing on a plank of wood while being pulled along by two bulls. Then came the beating of the rice – again nowhere near as difficult as it looks – you thrash bundles on the ground and lots of rice falls out.
    Next I sat in a dark cool mud hut with an old woman and ground the rice into a white powder. It felt similar to doing arm weights.
    Then I became a shepherd. I stood in a field and shouted “Brrra” and three cows lifted their heads and started moving towards me.
    My guide got nervous and so we quickly learnt the words for ‘move away from’ from the shepherd, bemused I was trying to help out in the first place.
    Finally, I tried my hand at milking cows but this was hard work and I really had to push hard until any milk squirted out at all
    At night we sat on the floor in a village family’s home next to the room where pulses were stored in cow dung parcels. Copper pots hung from the mud ceiling and my fears the food would be unhygienic or simply unpalatable were unfounded.
    The crockery was spotless and the food was mild, bland and delicious. It was a type of Maharashtrian tribal cuisine that I have never come across before – a light and delicious mix of organic suede, pulses, cabbage with fresh herbs.
    As we chatted and laughed together, with the help of a translator, I felt like I was seeing true Indian values of people caring, sharing and being hospitable.
    At night, as I sat on the patio chatting to a WOTR worker, watching the dragonflies buzz about, I felt touched I had had the opportunity to experience this. To me it was like witnessing ancient history living and breathing. In England the closest you would get to this would be through the glass panels of a museum.
    In many ways these people were more advanced than us, I also thought. They used sewage from the toilet for composting, there was no plastic and at night there was no need for electric lights as they used the light of the moon.

    [Reply]

    Gautam Sehgal Reply:

    Naomi,
    You don’t have to defensive, nothing wrong with what you said. Facilities for tourists are sorely lacking. I remember going to Mahabaleshwar as a student on a budget, my experience was very similar.
    Advice, on a budget only go to places completely off the tourist map. Don’t know how safe that would be if you were alone though.

    But really, fresh air in Bandstand????!!!!!

    Proj Reply:

    The difference between an Indian elite (Indians born and raised in the developed world included) and a well intentioned white. The difference is subtle and difficult to explain in words but it’s there as the above story exemplifies.

    I like this reporting, based on facts and sharing experiences as opposed to being judgmental.
    An interesting piece on Punjabi students recently immigrated to the UK. Desperate females are even turning to prostitution to pay the rent, makes one wonder if staying home with self-esteem is that bad a deal.

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/8481493.stm

    Mick Reply:

    In a village untouched by modernity she has a mobile and laptop and expects them to work you really do need to get in the real world but of course you where never brought up in the real world were you, sent to Oxford to learn Japanese so that you could marry a Japanese investment banker as they were the only significant ones in the 1990’s is surely the best intro to the real world that you can get. Then you thought you would grace India with this sort of approach.

    I really cannot believe that anyone there takes you seriously.

    Naomi Reply:

    I have stayed at one of the Indian hotels in the mid-range of hotels you mention, and without naming it, I can say I was far from impressed.
    Have you ever stayed in one yourself?
    Something like a Travellodge,Travel Inn or Holiday Inn Express is what is needed. Or a bed and breakfast.
    Having said that I stayed at a four star hotel in London, when I was back at Xmas, and wasn’t impressed with that either. I wrote a letter of complaint to the manger as the room was cold, tiny and cramped, the service and wecome were bad, and there were London prostitues hanging outside it. It was off Tottenham Court Road. That cost me 65 pounds per night (Rs4,800), for central London. London hotels are not great either. They tend to be in old buildings, the paint is cracking , the rooms are very small and so on…

    [Reply]

    Amit Reply:

    Sadly majority Indian budget hotels suck big time. The so called Five Stars are not too good either. The problem is not that we lack the technical knowhow or the infrastructure to have all these facilities by the Indian apathy towards customer satisfaction.

    [Reply]

    Mick Reply:

    After 6 weeks in India Dev using all sorts of hotels I didn’t afraid In fact in my time in India recent and 28yrs ago I never for one momment felt afraid but for sure i let one Indian with a broken nose and a few others wishing they had never tried to rip me off. So India change your rip off ways or next year you wont know what hit you

    [Reply]

    Dev Reply:

    Mick, I am surprised the Indian police, or the public whom you beat up, let you off so lightly. India doesn’t need tourist trash like you.

    [Reply]

    Mick Reply:

    I’ll direct these sort to people to you then shall I after all when you tell someone you are not gay as clearly as possible and they try to get into your room at 3.00am then tell me what would you do hey.

  • arindam

    Hey Naomi

    Sorry to hear you are down with bronchitis and laryngitis.Get well soon.
    Yes I agree we treat foreigners in our tourist places quite shabbily and in general we the common people also don’t speak up for them when they are in trouble.As far as hotels goes frankly speaking central heating is an concept still very much alien to our country and only star hotels have them.Its not because we like to live in the cold its just because we are a energy poor country.But hopefully as we go up the development ladder all these things will be taken care of.
    You description of the water heater and the room heater was hilarious(}forgive mefor having a laugh).But yes I do understand in europe all houses have central heating and its a way of life.
    Your life at the budget hotel might have been better if you had ‘tipped’ the reception desk and the bellboys upon arrival.That happens to us Indians too.
    But yes I do believe the government does needs to check these things out before promoting a tourist destination as it will only tarnish the image of India .

    [Reply]

    ZG Reply:

    Hi Naomi,

    Good description of the dreaded flu, and I thought I was in danger of being the ‘flu-queen’ having got a bug twice in a row- the first time while waiting at a very cold Delhi airport when the fog delayed my flight to Mumbai by 5 hours! (More recently i found the airport to be warm so i guess their does work- at least on the 2nd floor).

    On Jaipur Auto guy- I recall some news from last year. An American girl (blond from what I remember from the TV!) travelled around Jaipur (I think or another city in rajasthan) in an auto and after 10 days or so fell in love with the auto guy. (!!) They ended up getting married in an Indian ceremony. The auto-driver declared his love for her in the public. The family said on TV how happy they were with a ‘firang bahu’. My sister and I (and everyone else who heard) rolled their eyes. The next day the guy said on TV he would go anywhere on earth with his beloved…… and i guess he got an easy way into the US… or the woman came to her senses and filed for divorce. So you see, there are a few precedents, and you can see why the auto guys will be too willing to take a chance.

    A handy trip from a girl: Its NOT really acceptable for anyone like a car driver or auto driver to join you in a restaurant/ coffee shop etc. I would say, don’t encourage them esp. if you are on your own, and be rude if you have to. You probably realised already, there is a definite people ‘hierarchy’ in India. My weekly cleaning lady in London was welcome to sit on the sofa with me & have coffee in my house. In India, I would never imagine doing this. (Although I do still like saying ‘Thank you’ to house help here which everyone thinks is weird! )

    For some strange reason (historic) most Indians ‘reporting’ to you in any way operate better when the limits are clearly defined.

    And Yes- Please ‘up’ your hotel budget if possible……you will be able to see the difference. I stayed in the RTDC (Rajasthan Tourism Development Corp) Hotel Sarovar in Pushkar over Xmas for Rs 2600 and the room was good, with a working heater and extra blankets.

    Here’s to better travelling for you!

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    Oh thanks for your sweet message. I also heard about a firang that married a rickshaw driver…Someone was telling me about it…It’s weird because there is a big cultural difference there, as you say. My parents have a cleaner (as we call them in England) and my mum bends over backwards for her: she tidies the house before she arrives (and when I was living there, I had to tidy my room up); my mum makes her cups of tea and coffee as she does the work; the girl stops for hours on end in the kicthen and chats and gossips with my mum. And, to boot, my mum often cleans the house herself the very next day! Snap with the gardeners..They come to our house and the first thing my mum says to me is: ‘Make him a cup of tea.” I then offer him biscuits…..we chat…it’s kind of like that…So, here, to “refuse” to sit with a rickshaw driver would to me smack of racism/prejudice. After all in my mind, what makes me superior to anyone? I don’t believe in the concept of ‘untouchables’….So, if the rickshaw driver joins me for a coffee, what can I do? I’m a Christian and am brought up to be nice to everyone and not look down on anyone…Hence.
    As for Pushkar, wow, that is my favourite place in the whole of Rajasthan, and one of my favourites in India. It is such a cute, calm, sweet place. I think it “works” too because a) You don’t need rickshaw drivers or taxis to get around b) the hotels there seem to be properly geared up for travellers (and have the facilities) and also the people seem less inclined to want to rip you off. When I was last there I bought so many silver rings and they were so cheap. I would have paid double what he sjopkeepers wanted. By the way I went there for the Camel Fair once and it was amazing, truly. I highly recommend it. One of the best things I have done. I loved seeing all the camels decked out in jewel-studded cloths and so on….Anyway seems like one needs to spend Rs3,000 minimum in Jaipur…for a hotel …..if you paid Rs2,600 in Pushkar…

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    So you mean to say that Christians treat everyone nicely. We didn’t see that happening when europeans arrived at our shores and also in north-south America.
    Pl. do not bring your narrow chritian (evangelical) propaganda into matters like this.
    Looking at the past records, I have seen that you mostly delete posts critical of you.

    Good luck and please don’t be cheap. Stay in good hotels. We have also seen crappy people in west.

    Naomi Reply:

    I don’t mean to say that Christians treat everyone nicely. Christians have been responsible for many wars, unlike, say peace-loving Buddhists..You are extremely defensive….
    However, I was brought up (and I am only referring to myself) to make cups of tea for gardeners and cleaners in our house.
    I am certainly not evangelical. I can’t stand evangelical Christians, evangelical atheists or evangelical anything. I respect all faiths. I have worshipped at the Hare Krishna Temple as I like that faith a lot. I sometimes chant Hare Krishna and find it very powerful….I have been to Muslim, Sikh, Hindu and Jewish services many times in India and the UK, conducted pooja many times in Hindu temples….I actually believe in a God, and think all religions worship the same God…the religion is unimpoirtant.I would marry someone from any religion, inclding an atheist, and my friends are from all faiths and backgrounds….I would never suggest someone converts to Christianity and am against what evangeical Christians have done in India….I am only Christian because I was born into that and brought up as one, but I don’t think it is necessarily the best religion. I also don;t care what other people do and whether they follow a religion or not, it’s very personal.
    You are so funny in how you react to my posts…higly defensive. As for deleting posts, I don’t have the powers to delete posts. It is done by the technical team who manage the blogs and they delete posts when they people use foul or threatening langauge, that is all.
    As for the hotels, these budget hotels may be fine in the hot season, but my point was their facilities are not up to scratch in the cold season.

    vivek Reply:

    You slipped there Naomi with ‘I’m a Christian and am brought up to be nice to everyone and not look down on anyone.’ Untouchability is not a definite part of Hinduism – Hindus don’t follow any books so you can’t find it written anywhere – where it says – I am a Hindu and so I have to look down on someone as I believe in untouchability. You don’t have to be a Christian, Hindu or Budhdhist to be nice to everyone – just be a human!

    On the question of hotels – for 11 Quid a night – you can’t expect a lot! winter is very short in most bit of Northern India so you won’t find central heating anywhere. It is a shame that the hotel couldn’t even provide you with decent blankets and a heater. I think we should have an Indian trip advisor sort of website for budget hotels – any volunteers?

    Rajeev Yadav Reply:

    I agree with what vivek says.Usually Naomi is fairly circumspect with what she has to say however this time I guess she was caught off-guard by some other guy called Rajeev.

    anyway on a more lighter note,Naomi!How come I dont get to see your columns in ht and why dont you interview more bollywood actresses.Your interview with katrina kaif was pretty lame and straight-laced.why dont you interview priety zinta?ask her inappropriate questions,and generally make her uncomfortable,make sure she squirms.

    Sam Reply:

    did the medieval lords have coffee/tea/drink with their serfs in England (or europe ) ??

    Even if they did, Lord could have been sitting on a higher chair..

    these social differences have more to do with human evolution than religious based..

    Naomi Reply:

    You are saying that India today is akin to/comparable to Medieval times in Britain? You are saying I should judge India according to Medieval values from Britain? Not sure the people running Bangalore and the Shining India campaign would agree…The Medieval period is from the 5th century to the 15th century…AD

    Deb Reply:

    Sad as it may sound, ZG’s advice is very valid. In India (more so than in many other part of South Asia even), you have to maintain a distance mostly, else there could be people who’d try to take undue advantage of the proximity sooner or later. In South Asia itself, I’ve traveled to Sri Lanka & Nepal, and things on this count seem markedly different there – the person who drives your around would be cool having food with you on the same table. But this is not the case in, say, Bangladesh and especially India.

    Outside South Asia, of course the story is totally different. In any South East Asian country (and I’ve been to seven of them), it’s perfectly acceptable (even expected) of your junior colleagues or the person who’s driving you around, for instance, to sit and have lunch with you. And same in Africa.

    Difficult to fathom the reason for this. Can it be put down to colour differences, feudal history, lack of education, or what? Beats me.

  • Prabhakar Deshpande

    Hope you are well.

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    I am fine now, thank you very much. I didn’t realise you were still reading this blog!?

    [Reply]

  • http://bollywood-actresseswallpaper.blogspot.com/ romi sinha

    Jaipur also very popular as the Pink City, is the capital of the state Rajasthan. Jaipur was the capital of the princely state of Jaipur During the British rule. From last few years Jaipur has become a developed centre for education. There are few good MBA Colleges in Jaipur City. There are some very old Universities in Jaipur like University of Rajasthan.

    [Reply]

  • Harish

    A decent tip on arrival with a hint that more will follow would have made the hotel a better place.
    Rickshaw folks , yeah i wonder what scam he was trying to pull…probaby some trust based con..are you not curious…
    Can you elaborate on the Gem scam..there was a mention in another blog of yours…

    [Reply]

    Craig Reply:

    Hello Naomi, I hope you recovered by now. Great piece, but I think back to our visit to Jaipur. I remember the intense heat. So hearing of it in the cold is so strange. Howver, in saying that I grew up in Africa and recall that for one month of the year the temperature there too dropped to near freezing point.
    As arindam seems to imply, it is all about the money and for a larger tip, I am sure the staff would have gone out of their way to help you. Not ideal, but a way of life…
    Craig

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    What are you talking about?? Since when did anyone have to tip a hotel upon arrival…? Have you ever done that in India? As for the weather, don’t think you are familiar with how cold it gets in places like Delhi and Jaipur at this time of year. It’s as cold as the UK…as anyone living in India would know.

    [Reply]

    Proj Reply:

    I am sorry I will have to disagree with this. Spoiling the staff with handsome tips can actually backfire, no wonder foreigners are always pestered for money everywhere they go in India and it’s bad for the system in general too.

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    Oh the gem scam was really interesting. What happened was I arrived in Jaipur and got a rickshaw driver who offered to take me to various shops and so on…And, well one place he took me to was this really gorgeous shop, with a man running it, who was so good-looking, he looked like a Bollywood star. He gave me cups of tea and biscuits and kept me engaged for hours with stories on India, Jaipur, life, the universe, you know…It really added to my overall ‘travel experience’. Then, after several hours, he revealed he ran a jewellery business and sold precious and semi previous stones. He said that he needed to get them to the UK and asked me if I would carry some. He said that in London, I would meet a contact of his in Convent Garden, where the jewels were sold in a shop at a far higher price than they are in India, and that I would need to hand them over to this person….He then got out this huge file, full of photocopies of foreigners’ passports (there must have been more than 200 in there, they looked genuine), which he said were people who had done it before and the passport copies were his security that they didn’t run off with the jewels. He then said I would need to give him a deposit to ensure I didn’t disappear with the jewels….I thinkhe claimed the jewels were worth 2,000 pounds (2.5 lakhs) and he wanted about 200 pounds (25,000 Rs) from me in deposit….Im not quite sure what the incentive was – maybe he gave me a jewel (!) or the person in London would give me some money….anyway he was a very smooth talker and very persuasvie, but I smelt a rat and felt something was dodgy…The matter was later covered in LP Guides…as a warning of a scame to avoid…seems like the jewels were worthless and you basically would pay this geezer Rs25,000 for no reason, get to London and noone would meet you and the shop in Covent Garden didn’t exist. Or similar.

    [Reply]

    Mick Reply:

    How long have you been there , and you supposedly backpacked around India and you let a rickshaw driver tell you anything almost everything you write about India and westerners makes you sound stupid. Firstly you need to come back here and learn to live with English people who aren’t investment bankers or the such before you even think about going back there, your a danger to yourself no wonder you don’t eat the food, and run back to the NHS when you need it. So come home to your rich little village where you will be safe.
    At least I’m tough enough to both look after myself and eat the food Heart problems not withstanding let alone asbestos probs how do I do it at my age well a 6 mile bike ride an hour in the gym and a 4 mile walk all between 8.00am and 2.00pm. This is the sort of training you need to travel in India. I think they shouldn’t let you out by yourself. Oh and if you deleted my last email, next time I’m in India we will have a chat about you attitude problems won’t we.

    [Reply]

  • Atul

    Well, sorry to hear about your trail at jaipur, but let me not mislead you. You just became a poor target and it is not like that in Jaipur. The people in general at Jaipur are friendly and warm let alone the ones from the hospitality sector.

    I understand the water heater part and that is becuase of the energy crunch in our country and the poor condition was totally to do with the management. I am sure there are many decent budget hotels in Jaipur, I have stayed in a few. You should have probably done some research before going and not simply followed the commercial or could have got in touch with a friend/accquantaince/local to get a good hotel. But anyways hope that does not repeats the next time.

    Wish u a speedy recovery..tc

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    I asked several Indian friends for recommendations of hotels in Jaipur..All said they would get back to me but none did….(some even come from there!…..)

    I’m sure a Five Star hotel would have been amazing. I once had breakfast at the Rambagh Palace, I think it was, or one of the Taj group’s anyway, and it was serene…the breakfast spread was suitably lavish with everything from green tea smoothis to idlis…and whilst eating a sitar player performed…
    So, I know a five star would have been lovely and hospitable. It’s just these budget hotels really go out of their way to give you a miserable time. I had no idea I was supposed to tip upon arrival….

    [Reply]

    raj Reply:

    There is Jaipur Inn. It is decent hotel (not lavish though) and well managed. We recently stayed there, for money it is worth and clean.

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    But did you stay there in the cold season and did it have proper central heating?

    raj Reply:

    I was there in Dec, 2009. They have portable heater (typical in India) for each room. was good enough for us but not sure about how well will it work in Jan weather. Please note, the moment one goes for centralized AC/Heat (specially heat which has little usage in India), well stars will go up and so will price.

  • Hrithik

    I have not been well myself off late,its the weather in which infectious virus thrives.I am waiting for summers.

    I cant believe that auto driver joined you for coffee,usually these guys dont have the gumption to pull these kind of stunts with desi women,they know whats in store for them if they do.
    and Naomi forgive me for saying this but I think its high time you got hitched,you are pushing 40 if am not wrong,pretty soon you will be past your sell-by date,If you havent already.

    [Reply]

  • ZG

    Hey Naomi,

    I see where you are coming from on ‘differentiating’ between people. I too found myself thinking over the last few months why I’m comfortable doing some things in the west that I’m not here- and I guess its way more complex than what you said. I grew up in a broad minded educated urban family, and my friend circle (even those who havent studied/ lived abroad) understand about equal rights, opportunities and so on . For us, things like ‘untouchability’ only exist in the history books. (I agree this is not true at all for the whole of India, and we are probably a small, but growing percentage of people who think like that)

    Indian society has been very layered and hierachical since centuries and breaking all the layers too fast can also cause chaos (I see it happening in many urban cities already). On the auto/ taxi thing- I agree as a individual you don’t want to be rude, but I’m also looking at it more from a ‘woman’ point of view. You see ’single independent woman’ is still an evolving concept in India. And especially one who is a foreigner and a tourist.

    In Europe it didnt take me a second to pack my bag and catch a train/ flight to almost any major city. In India- believe me I have never ever ventured out alone to a new city as a tourist, and actually never intend to do so either in the near future, unless its to a 5-star hotel or a spa holiday! Thats how uncomfortable I feel travelling on my own inspite of being a fluent Hindi-speaking, Delhi-born girl (and someone who has pushed her way into a Blue Line bus at peak hour, which is not nearly as bad as a Mumbai Local Train but closest comparison…).

    And its difficult to explain but I think you having chai with an auto-rick guy gives him the message that more is possible. Maybe ask some other girls at work and see what they say….

    I also want to say, there are exceptions to the ‘chai rule’. A cleaner we had in Delhi saw me grow up from a baby. When her son got a job, she moved away but always came to our house with flowers on my b’day. And of course she had cake and food with everyone. But that really was a rare case.

    I have a work example thats better: as a woman manager in India, I have discovered that short, firm sentences help to get the work done most efficiently. I’m always polite to everyone and I say way too many ‘Thank yous’ that are necessary in india, but I still think its possible to be firm & polite!

    Here is a UK example to the Reprographics guy at work: G’Morning Lionel! When you have a moment could you bind this report for me? Thanks!”

    And this is me here: ” Raju-ji, 2 photopies. Thanks”

    Works much better ;-)
    And I tasted success recently when a very senior client from a big corporate (and everyone is terrified of him!) responded with a rare ‘thank you’ to my email.

    [Reply]

    Deb Reply:

    Very sensible perspective. And believe me, it’s not always the ‘woman’ aspect. Even I feel uncomfortable going out alone late evenings in cities (e.g. Muzaffarpur in Bihar) where I go to for the first time. Or even during daytime to places (e.g. temples) where I could be fleeced.

    [Reply]

  • http://desiderata-mumbai.blogspot.com desiderata

    I think you might have chosen a bad hotel. I’ve stayed at budget hotels in Jaipur and both were great.

    [Reply]

  • http://blog.hardeep.name Hardeep Singh

    Hi Naomi,

    This was an interesting read. I have never experienced this India – maybe being an Indian, and a male helped. I have visited a lot of places (though not Rajasthan so far), stayed at clean budget hotels that may not offer 5 star service. Recently I went to Goa and stayed at a 3 star hotel, it may not be the best but was clean, and had basic services that worked (AC included – it was hot those days).

    I think the easiest way to get to a good hotel is through a good travel agency. I always use DPaul’s in Delhi – they have a website you can check them out.

    I am surprised how many people are defensive in comments. We know this is India, yet we all love it – don’t we? There are a lot of countries where cheating is even more rampant – Egypt for example.

    I had gone also to Taj Mahal with some European friends, and had no problem their either.

    Regards
    Hardeep

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    The Taj Mahal Palace and Tower you mean (ie the five star hotel)? Or do you mean the monument in Agra? If you are referring to the hotel in Colaba, I am not surprised you didn’t face any problems, as it’s one of the best hotels in India!

    [Reply]

    Mick Reply:

    That chain of hotels is killing the real India so shut them down

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    There is absolutely no justification in this point. The Taj Group Hotels are the best in India and they are also extremely Indian, do great justice to Indian arts and culture, have unrivalled service and hospitality, and are one of the great assets India has in the F&B industry. They make up a very great part of Indian heritage and help promote India and all its best values to the world. What should be shut down are flea-ridden backpacker hostels.

    Mick Reply:

    Your a ******* joke sure hostels of the sort you describe should be shut but only rich pigs would defend a hotel chain that won’t allow someone in to their shop to buy a book by a local author. Mr P G Padmanabhan of Kumarakom kerala, whom told me that was the only place i could buy a copy of Kumarakom, An insiders Guide. My arrival at the guarded gates sparked a security scare, the fact that I could have stayed in their most expensive room made not a jot of difference. then a manager wallah arrived and said he would check to see if they had a copy while I waited outside the gate. I told him he could buy it for me, fortunately they had a copy so I was let in. Because of this and other hotel groups catering for rich pigs both Indian and western the cost of most things there that we need is more expensive, there can be no other reason for this than people who do not see what the rest of India is like. Certainly the Taj group wants to keep any money in it’s grubby little hands so they arrange houseboat trips etc. Oh and the only people I saw on house boats in and around there were FAT Indians. i like to think the rest of us have a bit more sense, and while I’m at it the tatty ugly houseboats should be shut down as well they are polluting the backwaters. then there’s the speed boats that by local by laws are supposed to stay well away from the bird sanctuary there but when their once again FAT indian passengers want to show off thats where they do it. This is surely a sign that the bird sanctuary will not be there in ten years time because it is on the shore of Lake Vembanad and is just the right size for a hotel group to build on.

    Naomi Reply:

    You are saying that the Taj Mahal Palace and Tower five star hotel in Colaba refused entry to you? On what grounds?

  • Chinz

    Hey naomi..u have written quite a honest view abt the treatment u received at jaipur so called budget hotel. for me..all the time that i lived in west..Uk primarily..i never had an issue travelling or staying alone..i have stayed in eurohostels in shared dorm (thats what i wud call a budget hotel) and never faced any issue at all..and felt completely safe as well.
    But In india..u are not safe even in ur own home. I am a working woman in delhi and i can say this for sure that women are never safe here. and travelling alone is even more tuff. even though i have travelled alone a lot..i had to learn the tricks of fending off people and even being rude to make them flee. I found it tuff and actually bad that i had to b rude..but now i have understood that its the only way ppl here understand to stay away.
    my only piece of advice is choose ur hotels from websites and always go for one which has good reviews, no need to tip the hotel on arrival..i have never done that..n be demanding when asking for services.. In india its completely acceptable to throw ur weight arnd..so tell ppl outrightly that ur from media..HT..and if they fail to give u ur money’s worth..with proper services..then u will make sure every1 knows abt it and will ensure no one visits it in future..its sounds absurd..but indians r quite used to such atitudes and will comply happily!
    I lived in a 3 star hotel in agra for 1 night..and my exprnc wasnt that good either..so i told them that i have many clients/frnds who keep visiting agra and if this is the service they offer..m going to ensure that no one visits this hotel for sure. This made the manager alert and he apologised and then ensured that i get my moneys worth over there. they had very smartly switched off the AC in the middle of the night during the month of may, which is quite hot!
    as for the auto rickshaw ppl..as many pointed out here..there is clear hierarchy here..irrespective of which city/religion ur from .. one doesnt interact much with these auto drivers/rickshaw wallas etc..so when in india..follow indian rules..else u wud b inconvenieced like this even more.
    and last word..pls be careful ..a single woman traveller cannot be safe anytime here!like it or not..its the truth :)
    n whosoever over here is commenting that india is great and blah blah and being defensive..pls ignore such comments..they havent seen much of this world n seems are not aware what inconveniences their mothers or sisters face during day to day life in the city!

    [Reply]

    Rajeev Reply:

    Brown nose.

    [Reply]

    Proj Reply:

    Most men of colored skin face racism in some form or other in the western world, that does not make the “entire” western world racist, it’s very unfair to generalize and make sweeping statements pointing fingers at others for their ignorance of worldly affairs when someone is so ignorant of spelling basic English words like experience, friends etc. Well these days Indian women, specifically of Punjabi origin don’t mind taking to prostitution in the UK to get a foothold there as has been reported by the BBC, no wonder life is so rosy out there in the west and it’s all India’s fault.

    [Reply]

    vivek Reply:

    Proj – what has knowledge of spelling of basic English words got to do with having an opinion? I am appalled that you think women take to prostitution as a choice – punjabi or polish! There may be an exception here and there but predominantly the sex industry exploits women. If some Indian women are taking to prostitution to get a foothold in UK – it is in sheer desperation…

    Naomi
    Can you please get your IT guys to install a spell-check here so that we can move over spellings and grammar!

    [Reply]

    Proj Reply:

    O my god, at least you got it right that these Punjabi women reported by the BBC are desperate for a mere toehold, leave alone a foot and are willing to do whatever it takes including being devdasis to their illusory Firang devatas, Greek Gods if you will but this does not necessarily imply a lack of choice or else why would the British Immigration order a stop to visa applications only in NORTH India. Maybe a class or two in logic and causality can help, if that’s out of bounds, the article below which clearly illustrates where the choice lies

    http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Several-Indians-pack-bags-head-home-from-Australia/articleshow/5546740.cms

    Don’t tell me that Englishmen are poaching women from Punjab hinterland or even Delhi with a predominantly Punjabi population for that matter, so the question of sex industry does not arise.

    About the spelling expertise in a language other than one’s native, not too much of a ask I guess from someone, who is lecturing the world on their expertise in world affairs or the lack of it

    vivek Reply:

    I just the checked the BBC article you have been quoting from – one line in the whole article?

    ‘Gurdawara President Mr Randawa says he has even heard of some desperate female students turning to prostitution to pay the rent and warned those travelling to the United Kingdom to study against it unless they can financially support themselves.’

    ‘Has even heard of’ – is that what you are talking about? Is that fact for you? Pathetic…

    Chinz Reply:

    proj..get a life..thats what i would say to you!!
    coz you have nothing to point against my argument..you choose to pick on words like eprnc/frnds..
    i find people like you extremely funny and yeah..incredibly frustated as well! :P simply said.. GET A LIFE!

    [Reply]

    Dev Reply:

    I guess what Proj was mentioning was , as long as 1GBP = 76 INR, Indian males and females alike will find a reason to trash India in favour of the UK.

    @Vivek,
    Asian voluntary prostitution in the UK is something that never gets reported, but always gets ‘heard of’. How you treat that information is upto you. The participants stay outside the reach of the organized sex industry, and have regular day jobs like anyone of us. Think Belle de Jour. Of course, they get out of it as soon as they reach a financial threshold. The keywords are voluntary, un-organized.

    @Chinz
    Selective areas in the UK do offer greater safety to brown, single women.
    Backpackers do have a structured approach to providing lodgings; hence sexual crimes are a rarity if you live in mixed dorms. But then, there are areas in East London where single white women are verbally abused, intimidated and groped after 7 pm by immigrant trash.
    To get a perspective on gender safety in the UK, do try an unarmed walk around the non-CCTV-ed lanes of a disco around a Friday /Saturday midnight.
    Trashing India without a perspective is dull. You can do better.

    Proj Reply:

    Dev,
    Appreciate your comments. India bashing and mindlessly eulogizing the west without any reality checks is in fashion for the new money Indian elite. I have spent sufficient time in all major business centers of the US and realized India is not that bad as it is made out to be by the Indian new money elite. Most American cities have areas which are considered unsafe Chicago southside, rogers park and the list is endless. Since this article is about budget hotels, leave alone me, even white Americans have had similar experiences in hotels chains as famous as Sheraton, Mariott etc. One of my senior managers had bed bug issues at Sheraton Eatontown in New Jersey. A lot of the budget motels, apartments, in fact as much as 60% in the US are owned by Indian Americans, mostly Gujaratis and Punjabis and they have such pathetic living conditions. In fact, my first six months in the US, I lived in an apartment complex owned by a Marwari American(last name Garg) because a lot of Indian students lived there and I was new to the US then. The complex was more than half a century old and the central heating was completely dysfunctional. I did not even realize that until first my Taiwanese friend pointed it out and then my American friend who had his own house confirmed and advised that I call the city authorities if the owner doesn’t provide me with a room heater right away. This Marwari American guy was one of the two wealthiest real estate barons of Indian heritage in Minneapolis, the other one had a Punjabi last name Khurana, . One of my friends Brian Woolsey who is a manager at Colliers Towles, a reputed commercial real estate firm did business with this Khurana guy and was completely at a loss as to how unprofessional and shady one could be in business dealings, no wonder he amassed such obnoxious amount of wealth in a decade or so. Brian doesn’t do business with either Khurana or Garg any more.

    I can go on and on about numerous other experiences and should specifically mention that the only help I received in navigating this conundrum was from well intentioned whites. I find it interesting and worthwhile that Naomi came up with this idea of discussing such stuff on a blog and can only wish there were such blogs a decade ago..

    vivek Reply:

    Poor Proj – you decided to go live with other indians in US and got duped by Mr Garg! Wish you had named your Taiwanese friend too like Brian Woolsey or should we know who Mr Woolsey is? Dodgy people are everywhere – Bernie Madoff is white and I am sure has no Marwari or American blood. What is your point? American Indians are cheat? And what is an well intentioned White? This blog is getting so racist! Oh actually I do know a well intentioned white – my wife – she is a white and British.

    Shall we just stick to being getting duped by people without going in to who they are – black, white, marwari, punjabi… or does it matter to you proj? Get a life…

  • Mick

    Sorry but I’ve to write this here. In one of your earlier blogs some one started slaging me off because I’m English and i didn’t give a toss about the past association of England and India usually called the Raj. Some one who is probably a RHS member ranted about us introducing slavery to India. I basically said that was nothing to do with me or anyone else alive today. Ms canton rushed to his defence and said SHE felt guilty about it. This is the most pathetic thing this woman has ever written. How can i say this well anyone whos interested in the truth about slavery in India needs to visit the Show case records Govt Archives Thiruvananthapuram where they will see a slave sale deed dated 1763 rather along time before we had any real influance in India

    SO MISS CANTON GROW UP

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    So, you are saying Indians introduced slavery to India, and the British did not? Or another country brought slavery to India? Please clarify. I don’t have time to visit the Govt arvchives in Kerala right now.
    Also, I said I never said I felt guilty for slavery as I am not responsible for it, but I said I am/was totally against the atrocities committed by the British in India in general (such as mass murders). I also said I am against the colonisation of India by the British. I am opposed to, and would have been opposed to, had I been alive, any kind of colonisation of any country. I am also opposed to the invasion of Tibet by China (that is ONGOING).
    I don’t recall mentioning slavery. Which blog are you referring to?

    [Reply]

    Mick Reply:

    You didn’t I think a git call Raju did, cause your a holy roman catlik you would have opposed the dissolution of the monasteries by Henry 8Th which is basically what the Chinese did do you really think that Tibet can go back to that. i can assure you that if you do your dafter than you look there would/will be a civil war there if that is tried. can’t find which blog it was and don’t care IF YOU CAN REPLY TO MY EMAILS DON’T REPLY TO MY COMMENTS

    [Reply]

    Naomi Reply:

    So, you are for the invasion of Tibet??? Interesting. How do you justify that, then?

  • Chinz

    mr dev…
    just to clarify..m not trashing india for the heck of it!
    I have lived a sizeable portion of my life in india and in various other parts of the world including UK, US, south asia etc and even though i do like delhi coz its my native..i really wish india was much more safer for women!

    men may have a different sentiment coz they r not the ones facing these problems!

    i cant comment on mumbai..as i dont live there..but the amnt of harassment a lady has to face in delhi n NCR is unimaginable. its due to this lack of safety/respect for women that one has to avoid late nights/public transport etc. and how many times will one keep complaining and raising one’s voice against all this?

    Very honestly, at the cost of sounding biased or traitor as u may prefer to qualify it as..my stay in countries like UK, US, singapore, Malaysia, east Africa has been much more pleasant n smooth, like it or not. and oh btw..i happened to stay in east london as well for good 1 year….i had heard many nasty things abt this place but somehow never faced a single problem. same is the case with other people i know.I have spent many fridays / saturdays in Uk to know how safe it is.
    So please! The point is , i cant think of going out on a friday./saturday/ any nite in delhi after 8pm unless i have some guys frnds for so called protection with me!!

    I can only judge a place/country by my own experience and not by what someone else has to say.
    Hope that makes things clear to you on my perspective!

    n yeah just so you know..i m contributing for my country’s development and it is very slowly getting better but its still many many years before one can say mera bharat mahaan!

    [Reply]

    Deb Reply:

    Agree, mostly. Sad truth. To open another front: are the happenings which are the cause of women feeling unsafe in cities/towns, especially in North India, the result of gender segregation from an early age in schools etc. so that males in many communities or social/economic/ geographic strata just don’t get exposed and sensitised to such issues & aspects of life?

    [Reply]

  • Naomi

    Proj – Good you have brought in the perspective of disgusting hotels in the US. Im sure there are non liveable hotels, with appalling conditions in all parts of the world, not just India. It is a scam against tourists that needs to be halted wherever it occurs. The only way to stop it is to have regular inspections by government bodies and to set up helplines that disgruntled tourists can ring….

    By the way did any of you read Lokhandwala Lad in HT cafe (Mumbai) last Monday? He is on a movie shoot somewhere in north India and complained endlessly about the hotel he was staying in…If I can find the link, will post it.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.travelexpertguide.org tourist attractions

    Why do we consider travel a basic desire nowadays? In 2008, only 30 percent of trips over 50 miles were done for business – the rest- for pure pleasure. Work is nerve-racking, the family needs to be fed and money is and will always be a problem. Meanwhile, there are hot deals on flights, romance is in the air in Paris no matter the season and life is still waiting for you at the corner

    [Reply]

    Deb Reply:

    (:-)

    [Reply]

  • Mick

    Ms Canton is not qualified to have an opinion about anything requiring creative ability just newspaper stuff and we all know they never let the facts get in the way of a good story

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sanjay-Choudhry/703891475 Sanjay Choudhry

    Vinod Sharma — Congress ka dalal

    [Reply]

  • www.anindianmuslim.com

    Thanks for an amazing article. Such reports are what are needed on blogs. Parashar sahab has done us a favour by informing us as also helping to draw the attention towards need for reforms in Japan’s prosecution system.

    [Reply]