The Blues Revisited



There were two reasons why I picked up an album a couple of weeks back and they had nothing to do with the music. The first, was the name of the band Dr. Fong & Friends. I liked that. The second, was the name of the album Beethoven of Da Blues. I liked that even more. Dr. Fong is the pseudonym of self-taught American blues musician, Jay Wilfong, and in reality he and his band play a brand of mean rock-infused blues, almost all of it original compositions.

Muddy Waters died in 1983 at 70, but many consider the mid-1950s to be the time when the blues musician’s career reached its height.

Muddy Waters died in 1983 at 70, but many consider the mid-1950s to be the time when the blues musician’s career reached its height.

I tried to find out more about Dr. Fong but besides learning that he’s a bit of a recluse who taught himself to play and sing the blues, didn’t get anything else. Dr. Fong’s music reminded me of guitar stars such as Stevie Ray Vaughn and Eric Clapton. And the music seemed to me ideally suited for such times when I like to take a break from listening to what keeps coming out from the hyperactive indie-rock scene.

Actually, my blues interlude had nothing to do with Dr. Fong but with a sudden craving one night to soak myself in the music of the late great Muddy Waters. I have a cache of five or six gigabytes of classic blues tracks, which includes a Muddy Waters album, a compilation really, called His Best, 1956 to 1964.

Waters (real name: McKinley Morganfield) died in 1983 at 70 but many consider the mid-1950s to be the time when the blues musician’s career reached its height. Songs like Got My Mojo Working or Good Morning Little School Girl are classics that brought out the best in Waters.

Many years ago, when I was first discovering the Chicago blues’ an electrified, amplified version of the trad stuff we used to have a perennial argument amongst friends. Who do you like better Muddy Waters or Howling Wolf? Some of my friends preferred Wolf; others liked Waters. The rivalry between the two contemporaries was legendary and for fans, it was like a ‘Do you like the Beatles or the Stones’ kind of an issue. Speaking for myself, I always preferred Wolf to Waters.

Wolf had a booming voice and brought more edge to the songs although Waters was great too. The two, along with Bo Diddley, came together to do 1968’s The Super Super Blues Band, which many people love but I think is an over-rated set of seven songs where each of the greats tries too hard to outdo the others. I’d rather listen to them separately.

My blues period carried on last week as I re-explored many blues musicians: Lightning Hopkins from Texas, whose two-disc Mojo Hand is an excellent collection of 40 of his songs; and, of course, Robert Johnson, who is considered the most accomplished of all the Mississippi Delta bluesmen.

Johnson died in 1938 at 27 (rumoured to be poisoned by a juke-joint owner who suspected the musician of having an affair with his wife) and his music was discovered and recognised posthumously. Johnson’s music has had tremendous influence—not only on other blues musicians but also on rock. From Johnson to John Lee Hooker; from Magic Sam to Little Walter; and a host of other greats, I spent a good part of the week turning on to the blues once again.

I also downloaded some episodes of the excellent weekly blues podcast, The Roadhouse, and one of its more recent ones had a feature on women blues musicians, such as Koko Taylor, who died in June this year aged 80. Taylor was the daughter of a Tennessee sharecropper and found fame after moving to Chicago in the 1950s. She was gifted with a rich and powerful voice and even in her last years was a prolific live performer, often more than two shows a week. Many of today’s women singers, such as Bonnie Raitt and Susan Tedeschi, have been influenced by Taylor.

I discovered some contemporary women blues singers too. Such as Candye Kane, whose spunky style and bold lyrics are quite infectious, and Janiva Magness, whose startlingly good voice I’d never heard before. The Roadhouse podcast, along with the Bandana Blues podcast, are two rich sources for blues music, especially so if you’re looking to discover unknown blues musicians. I’d never heard of Norwegian singer and guitarist, Bjorn Berge, for instance, before listening to his music on the Bandana podcast.

Or Ruthie Foster, who comes from a family of gospel singers in America and whose rendition of the classic Woke Up this Mornin was refreshingly different. Or even James Johnson, a guitarmaker and also a musician whose band believe me– is called Super Chikan and the Fighting Cocks.

Download PDF

Listen to ‘virtual’ tracks:

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (3 votes, average: 3.67 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • Irshad Daftari

    Now here’s something I can totally sink my teeth into – Blues! I assume you were focusing strictly on the genre and just randomly picked out what you liked best, otherwise there would certainly have been some mention of BB King! Now here’s a man who played his Tele like his life depended on it… and performed well into his 70s. Also love stalwarts like Buddy Guy, Muddy Waters (Already spoken about). It was a privilege to watch Buddy Guy and Bernard Allison in Mumbai in 2007., magical blues guitarists.

    Surprisingly, it’s the white man’s blues that has become more mainstream… i.e. early Fleetwood Mac and John Mayall, and the peerless SRV. Even in more recent years, its been guys like Jonny Lang, Kenny Wayne Shepherd and to a lesser extent John Mayer who are the current flag bearers. Have always been curious to know how that worked out!

    Hell, I’m running now to listen to my Deuces Wild album (BB King and a whole host of star guests). Particularly awesome is “The Thrill is Gone” with Tracy Chapman.

    [Reply]

    Sanjoy Narayan Reply:

    Thanks for your comment. yes, of course, it wasn’t supposed to be a holistic piece on the blues. This column and blog is more than just a bit self-indulgent as you may have guessed :)

    [Reply]

  • Shiva_17

    Hey Sunjoy
    Check out “White Lies”,they sound a lot like Morrissey….or The Smiths…
    N have you heard “Death Cab For Cutie”…?

    [Reply]

    Sanjoy Narayan Reply:

    Yes, I have heard both those bands. White Lies used to be called Fear of Flying before I think. And Death Cab for Cutie is big. Good bands both.

    [Reply]

  • Maddy

    A couple of months back I stumbled upon “Fleetwood Mac: Blues Jam at Chess”.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fleetwood_Mac_in_Chicago/Blues_Jam_in_Chicago,_Vols._1%E2%80%932

    Now listen to it all the time…

    Madhav

    [Reply]

  • Gt12563

    If Rajeev Gandhi would have lived longer he may have done lot of good things for India.I do not think he was corrupt all these bofor talks are just to defame him.Since he is dead know we should leave him alone and let us pray peace for his soul.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    See the funny side of news at site satiresofindia

    [Reply]

  • Fact

    Sujatha, you of all people know very well that there no permanent friends or foes in politics. The Congis are skilled in this game. While you are happy about the alleged ‘clean chit’ for late ‘clean’ Rajiv Gandhi despite Mr Quattrochi, you are most reluctant to accord the same courtesy to Narendra Modi who has been found personally clean by an SC appointed SIT no less. Double standards to put it mildly. However I expect no better from an HT hack.

    [Reply]

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/OHJK3TTRTRYEPDELSMR45CBEVI Raghavendra K

    sujata what did your great leader rajiv gandhi do when thousands of sikhs were murdered by die hard congressmen after indira gandhi’s assassination?
    rajiv gandhi becomes secular for people like you even if he quitely watched murder of sikhs in delhi and murder of muslims in bhagalpur.

    stop these blatant double standrads atleast now.
    i knwo your symathies always lie with congress party.

    [Reply]

  • Ramdhir Singh , Jaunpur

    Akhilesh should bring in private players like
    Bihar to resolve issue related to power crisis

    [Reply]

  • Abu Ahmed

    When somebody in the family dies, do we book huge halls to place his/her body therein for relatives & friends to pay their respects to the departed soul? No. May be a tent is erected in the courtyard or on the street outside the house / flat, chairs are placed for visitors and simple food is served after the last rites. That should be the bench-mark for a wedding celebration too. It will be, if the economic downturn continues for some more time in the country and the world – people would smell coffee sooner than later.

    [Reply]

  • SL Rastogi

    Very well written article…80% of brides and grooms returning the rented marriage attire even in Delhi is quite revealing… but it makes sense to do so because it avoids some kind of wastage. I wonder how many people would like to keep it for emotional reason or wear it again and on what occassion. Perhaps 20% who do not rent the dress are the one in later category.

    Surely emotional bonds and family togetherness is missing not only in marriages but in every day to day life as well.Mechanics of day to day life and ecnomic pressures are taking its toll on every one.
    with best wishes
    SL Rastogi

    [Reply]

  • Brown American

    There is never a bad time to do something positive. Looking for the perfect time is like for a perfect spouse. Both are elusive. To do something positive in face of such animosity takes courage. One has to admire the courage of BCCi and PCB to take right step in such hostility, mostly from Indian side. Admire it, move on and if you have reservations that it will bring the two nations closer, then just watch it for the Cricketing Rivalry and enjoy it. Those who are negative about it in my view are just born losers.

    [Reply]

  • http://twitter.com/StuartLarner StuartLarner

    But this is nothing compared to some of the farcical tricks and antagonism that is documented betweeen English village clubs in the new ebook novel, “Guile and Spin” by Stuart Larner ,available on Amazon Kindle.
    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Guile-and-Spin-ebook/dp/B008FBZPHE/

    [Reply]

  • The Shaft

    Sunil Gavaskar opposed – he should be involved in decision-making processes so that he remains a part of the honchos of BCCI. I mean, his ego would be satiated – after all he was the greatest before Sachin.

    [Reply]

  • Kushal

    Grin. There’s gotta be SOME reason you’ve been reading this blog for so long, Deb. Shared interests.

    [Reply]

  • Kushal

    Thank you, Parvana. Now you’ve made MY day brighter.

    [Reply]

  • http://www.facebook.com/kanikadhupar Kanika Dhupar

    Once in a while you write a little-something about yourself which ends up as a delightful read, reminds me of your ‘Expletive Deleted’ column when it was a regular feature on the editorial page of HT.

    [Reply]

    Kushal Reply:

    Thanks Kanika. And gosh, I had completely forgotten that column. I’m sure it wasn’t called Expletive Deleted, though.

    [Reply]

  • sunila

    Loved this read, Kushal..it is delightful…also will bring back many memories for most people, like it did for me. thank you!.

    [Reply]

    Kushal Reply:

    Share the memories, Sunila?

    [Reply]

  • sunila

    Too many, Kushal, to put down here. Besides, across a view of so many years, some, i suspect, are more rose-coloured than what was reality! And there are so many desks…ours (my sisters) then mine, my childrens’,…but all the memories are of happy times, absorbed totally in the act of the moment, whether it was reading or writing, pasting pressed flowers and leaves, or painting, of an uncomplicated time…But mostly it’s a warm feeling of happiness. Later it was a refuge,(wrote poems, yes, really about green leaves and flowers and love!!) where mainly family left you alone to do whatever, unless you had cheated on your chores and someone else had to do them!My desk was like my own private room, with a do not disturb sign, unless invited by me to enter. i can’t imagine my world was so much my own when i was young…and oh, the ink of those days…how can i forget that! filling ink pens…doing all kinds of things with ink bottles, droppers, nibs….the most wonderful time spent with ink, smelling it, spilling it, ink in my nails, yes, in,!! wiping the mess, hoping no stains would stay…..Kushal, you really brought back lovely memories..

    [Reply]

  • Kushal

    Gosh, Sanjana, that is truly the nicest thing anyone has ever said about my writing. Thank you. And I cannot believe ANYone remembers my blog in Delhi! Going through yours now :)

    [Reply]

  • Mona Oak

    Whoever wrote this article does not know the West is still looking down on India being the slum dwellers nation where almost half of its population lives on subsistence level so wake up you silly writer and face the reality. Ravi Shankar made no difference to India’s standing except that hippy Beetle George Harrison help Ravi Shankar to become get quick rich and produced an illegitimate child abroad and precisely in the USA. Got it you ignorant twit?

    [Reply]

  • h.mani

    Thanks Summit Bose,for so well researched thought.It is very sad,you had to write this when Singhavi saheb could have written a more balanced obitury,but then he would than be not bleeding heart liberal pseudo secular,won’t that be so?Thanks any way,I appreciate little truth in factless nation of yours.It counts wherever it may comes.Nice day

    [Reply]

  • h.mani

    Iwas at Madision Garden that day,it had nothing to do with India or Indian music,it had all to do with man’s brutality to fellow humans,and in US young caresand even today they do.NAM and Iraq War are our best expression of desent which we American are good at,with or without Indian music.

    [Reply]

  • s.asim

    what does vir Sanghvi kbows about classical Music or for that matter Pt. Ravi shanker. can he what are the characterstics of his Gharana. He is more adept in lobbying, he should concentrate. See how these people are getting back to public life-sanghvi,Barkha,Abhishek Singhvi just because public memory is short.

    [Reply]

  • ge

    Really?, You must be smoking Vir!

    [Reply]

  • Pravin shah

    Another piece of silly and wishful thinking. The West i.e the proverbial man on the street….considers India filthy,( it is !) backward ( surely yes…) corrupt ( read Ms Radia conversations !) and self-anointed repository of culture and civilization ( yes, read MMS)

    [Reply]

  • Swaroop Mitra

    @BoseJi, expecting pliable “dalals” to have any modicum of culture or a dash of intellectual honesty is as good as expecting the descendants of the Nehru/Gandhi vansh to have honesty in any molecule of their being.

    [Reply]

  • milkha singh

    the author is smoking something very strong. I like the thinking pattern here, Ravi Shankar and foreign policy influence??? In any case, majority of people in the west don’t know Ravi Shankar, don’t care about Ravi Shankar. And may I remind the author, people in India don’t care about Ravi Shankar. The people that I talk of in West and in India are those who wake up everyday in the morning, and commute to work, and are working very hard to have savings. I am not talking of spoiled “civil-society” [whatever the hell it means]

    [Reply]

  • XYZ

    I wish what he writes is true. Because being poor unhealthy unfit socially illiterate and illiterate is better than people killing other people. To maintain the harmony. And if he managed to do that to even a little extent it was something good.

    He did not try to change the image for the world but help the unhelped indians through someway.

    People in US – shut up… Like we do not have much idea about what happens there when a mad guy comes and shoots around your schools or for that matter what happened during pearl harbour, you wouldn’t understand the extent of saddness our country has faced either. I do respect your country! and the incidents that happened there were sad too. Melanchony is all that left you dont understand ours we do not understand yours.

    [Reply]

  • Dee

    Seems the rats are leaving a sinking ship.

    [Reply]

  • truth

    vir? what’s wrong, are the checks from the congress party no longer coming? the Italian maid no longer your hero? so sad….we “were” so secular…no?

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    No. He just thinks people are idiots to have forgotten about him and Radia et al. And, the Hindustan Times (the Company) is like the rest of India – corrupt people and corruption are just ways of life for them. No more!

    [Reply]

    bobg123 Reply:

    Oh…its another “Rat” who is abandoning the sinking ship…..no wonder. Then you never know he is trying to give a sincere advice to his “Masters”

    [Reply]

  • Manik

    Wow Mr Sanghvi…..What a surprising article and for a change a journalist was talking….Hope your reporting will be unbiased as this one….

    [Reply]

    geekay09 Reply:

    It will be naive and too early to conclude this as unbiased. He has to write advice to the govt coated not in sugar which is what is making you feel he has become unbiased. He has to reason and plead that pretend like Obama – show your tears and empathy. Wao. He is not advising nothing beyond. No genuine criticism of this govt.

    [Reply]

    Manik Reply:

    Agreed but at least it’s a start and hope he can bring out ills of dynasty politics of India..

    [Reply]

  • PPrasad

    How about discussing HT’s disconnect with the middle class ??
    During the ant-corruption movement, some of English Print Media’s “intellectual” journos termed the middle class as “intellectually handicapped” , “cattle class” etc..
    Instead of taking on the ruling establishment on issues of Governance, HT kept dishing out meaningless articles on non-existent “secular”/”minority” issues, anti Modi articles and projecting Rahul G as the next PM candidate !!

    [Reply]

    Har Gobind Bhukkal Reply:

    They will all fall in line in due course of time. Most of them have been feeding for a long time on the discharge of 10 Janpath sewers and have got scabies as a result. The itch doesn’t let them see the truth around them.

    [Reply]

  • Krishna

    UPA II is a GONE CASE.

    They are a failed corrupt gang of goons. They want to rule India like in medieval times thinking that the Indians can be taken for granted and India is a banana republic.

    [Reply]

  • lalit bagai

    the problem with this govt is that its top leadership eg sonia gandhi is corrupt,
    and completely uninterested in the well being of the indian people. sonia,s main
    interest is skimming of the cream, liveing as a empress, and planning for her
    retarded son to take over. this was indira,s way of ruleing the country.and leaveing her job to rajiv gandhi.

    sonia is now stricken with cancer, and the congress is knee deep in scams.
    it is faceing nemesis. the graceful thing would be for her and her brood to
    leave politics and india. india should be governed by patriotic and nationalist
    leaders, eg narendra modi, shiv raj singh chauhan and others like them.

    as for mmdingh. he is 80 years old. he should prepare to meet his maker to
    express regrets for the shameful betrayal of his country.

    [Reply]

  • Har Gobind Bhukkal

    What happened Sanghvi? Not a favourite baby of CONgross anymore. Or Is it a break to breathe the fresh air. I hope that it’s an enlightenment as to the reality around us nowadays (of an awakened India). I hope Queen Maino and her motley gang won’t reprimand you for calling a spade a spade as You are used to calling it a spoon. Anyways, Best of luck. I hope you come out with more articles like this one that expresses public sentiments and eventually connect to them. Tell Barkha also past is past and not to eat any morsels thrown off by politicians. An unbiased Media is the strongest pillar of democracy. More than the problem of – voter fatigue and anti-incumbency, it’s the problem of arrogant rulers looting every resource of this country and then behaving atrociously with public if they protest. R@pes may happen but the protests shouldn’t, it is dictatorial attitude and not democratic.

    [Reply]

  • Tvk

    Vir Sanghvi is as usual pretending.He talks of anti incumbency and voter fatigue as reasons for middle class anger instead of corruption and corruption and corruption and the politics of reservations and the police raj of UPA for the uprise.As for Hidustan Times ,I pity the News Paper for its highly biased editorials and journalists who come on TV Channels trying their best to support the UPA and the Italian colonists in Delhi ruling class

    [Reply]

  • Mauren

    Excellent analysis! Thank you.

    [Reply]

  • ram

    let see how neutral VIr can be..

    [Reply]

  • Kokila

    Mr Prime Minister, you the leader of the country and your people solace in times of distress. Needless to say ,you disappoint us. You have nothing to loose,just go after the corrupt and goonda politicians. Do you read the newspapers? or you are barred from knowing what is happening in you country? Please ,wake up.

    [Reply]

  • dm

    One thing this article shows is that the UPA and the PM have become soft targets for the middle class media, and let us not even go into the Sanghi trolls whom they seek to placate with ever stupider columns. Dude, the rape incident has little or nothing to do with the govt and everything to do with India as a society, as a handful of intelligent persons writing in Indian newspapers have already pointed out. But as usual most of the media likes to stick to lazy and false assumptions and doesn’t really want to dig deep. so journos like this one take the easy and lazy way out, since it offers yet another easy opportunity to hit out at the govt. As for the govt not being media savvy, frankly nothing can satiate the nasty, partisan, and lying monster the Indian media has become. Taking digs at the govt. may win lazy journos brownie points with the Sanghis, but it does terrible disservice to that poor victim who just died, since it does nothing in terms of discussing the root of the rape problem in India.

    [Reply]

    kanishka Reply:

    Have you ever heard the hindi phrase, YATHA RAJA TATHA PRAJA.

    Fish rots from the top. Law and order is the responsibility of the government. Children easily learn what works and what does not. Greed and dishonesty works in India so does blatant violation of the law, whether financial (corruption at the top like 2G, CWG, COALGATE and no accountability of the government), legal (misusing CBI and bribing to manipulate the votes of MPs to stay in power at the center) or ethical (Vadera Gate or veerbhadra gate).

    Why no reforms has been brought in police and judiciary despite stricture from the Supre Court of India.

    Why some parties are still opposing 33% reservation of seats for women who constitute 50% of the population?

    [Reply]

  • kanishka

    Any objective analyst would blame Sonia, the super PM and Raul, the duper PM for their extra-constitutional seat of power and the media who does not raise the real issues that affect the real people.

    No media person talks about exponentially exploding population, lives of 70% population living under less than a dollar a day (almost 50% of the population still def@cate in the open in India, a shame for the entire nation) and deteriorating law & order situation in cities and villages while a section of the society is getting richer and richer using corrupt and dishonest means at the cost of average Indian.

    The UPA II has not vision, no direction, no game plan except coopting the media in their attemp on how to indulge in corruption and malign opposition especially Modi.

    Neither Sonia/Rahul duo nor MM Singh has ever given an open press conference and interview to the national and international journalist for objective assessment of their state of affairs. No journalist has courage to seek an interview with Sonia/Rahul who manage the seat of power with some hidden character. All three are used to read the written speeches so is coward Indian voters.

    UPAII must go along with attitude of english media if India has to progress.

    [Reply]

  • raju shah

    Italian bar maid has not paid dec check to Vir. that is why he is barking

    [Reply]

  • Ramesh Kumar

    What has gone wrong with Vir Sanghvi,has been commented by many.But what has changed with mmsingh,whom probably some admired , in his own words,is as he admitted during his speech in debate on Nuclear deal that left parties have made him “BONDED LABOUR”. That check has gone.Now he is in control of rival forces.Afterall slavery is a mental concept.
    Bonded is not a free soul.The action are in tune with like a string instrument, whose sound depends on tightening of wires.
    LACK OF GOVERNANCE IS VISIBLE AT ALL LEVELS.EVEN VIR SINGHVI IS ALSO CHANGING.

    [Reply]

  • raj

    Hi Vir, you are like a wind sock, change your political direction based on where the wind is blowing from…haha..MMS is a joke and so are you….everyone knows that sometime back you were defending the fake gandhis and MMS and now that tables have turned back on them, so have you…what next, you will start praising NaMo ?

    [Reply]

  • tbr

    That is why the Americans crack a joke for the rest of the world–That by wearing American Jeans- you can not become a American. That hawker as part of the gang rape team was probably wearing jeans-but he was a Indian idiot by brain. True or False ??

    [Reply]

  • tbr

    The other very well noted point in this article is greatly appreciated –UPA did bring in fresh and young faces in the Govt. but it is the same 70-85 year olds running the top Govt policy directive!! Worth noting a point. I have a closed relative at 93 who does not want to go away and very stubborn to use a mobile device! What are you going to do?? Wait for them to disappear or do something for the mess we are in !! Advani in the waiting for becoming a PM???? A point to be noted.

    [Reply]

  • JB

    All that Vir Sanghvi has stated is true. And there is a moral of the story: you cannot run a a government in a democracy through a hired CEO: it just does not run.

    [Reply]

  • tbr, USA

    CEO is a very-American Corporate world acronym –somehow it does not fit in the Indian culture. Just a point.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Finally, Vir has written a piece that resonates with what every Indian (except Robert) feels. Sonia should resign from the Chairperson of UPA and President of AICC posts and join us in the streets. Ofcourse, please leave those SPG guys with their Israeli guns at 10J.

    [Reply]

  • Javed Mian

    These guys like Veer now feel Congress’s days are numbered. Clearly evident from Rajdeep Sardesai’s, Burhkha Dutt’s and this id$$iot’s wrtings.

    [Reply]

  • insideeye

    Why no word on the role on the heir apparent Rahul Gandhi? Being the face of the Congress, he should be articulating the party’s position on the gang-rape. Bot time and again, when he needs to stand up and be counted, he goes underground.

    [Reply]

  • H.Mani

    Vir saheb,I’m not in the habit of kicking a fallen guy.I will try my best not to be mean spirited.I will just ask you to buy a globe of the world.Just a cheap one.Take a look at the size of China,Russia,Canada,USA,Brazil,Australia even Saudi Arabia and compare with the size of India.You do not have to be rocket scientist or even have all 52 cards of deck.What do you see.?And then get the census figure from UN.You will see,why and how India has all the trouble?Has any news paper or Jouranlist or any politacal heavy weight starting from Nehru ever showed any concern for exponential explossion population??.I will tell you what,rapes,murder,people’s problems are no longer real people or concern,they are just numbers,numbers do not have faces.Why should Sonia or Rahul or MMS acknowledge these faceless numbers and address a open press confrence or give interview?More than the Congress,I’m more disappointed by guys like you and Indian media,you have failed the sorry unfortunate countrymaen.That is the real tragedy.I can say a lot,for I was once your fellow countryman,I wept when my President wept in Newtown when innocent kids were mowed down.He has asked Vp Biden to prepare gun control of assult weapon,legislation.Where was need to send this commotose girl to Singapore?You guys are a sorry lot.I’m ashamed to be once part of India by birth,I can not change that.I weep as I type this.With malice towards none,nice day ,STILL.H.Mani,NJ,USA

    [Reply]

  • mms

    Hello Hello I am Nira Wadia…Vir, my darling, what are you talking all this?…I just talked to Sonia madam and Rahul baccha and they are sending cheque to you through their sweepers MMS and Shinde. Pls stop writing against your beloved party. Love you darling. Bye – yours Nira.

    [Reply]

  • Deep

    Vir, there is hope for your rehabilitation after all. Keep in mind that the UPA won a second term due to the lethargy of the Indian voter rather than their brilliance in the first term. Keep on taking your daily dose of reality and truth and it will all work out!

    [Reply]

  • Seema Sangra

    I have always been a Vir Sanghvi fan,but this one is an extremely well written piece. It’s a good insight about changing scenario and the need for the political parties to consider it.

    [Reply]

  • Vinod

    So, you say that UPA is lurching from crisis to crisis because of voter fatigue? And a global recession causes them to have crises and lurches? And finally, both crisis and lurch are caused by mass media! Brilliant.

    I thought I just saw a 1.76 Lakh Cr elephant, a 75K Cr Gorilla, a 1.4 Lakh Cr Godzilla, etc. etc. zip by. Must be my imagination.

    UPA1 was just as bad as UPA2 – they simply sailed on the winds of a well managed economy that they inherited – look at the economic figures like the Current Account ratio. UPA 1 didn’t get caught until UPA 2 happened. The crookery was well in place, despite the communists fighting against it.

    Manmohan is not a badly sold image, neither are the rest in the Congress’ management. They ARE bad at governing this country, they are collusive in the loot and plunder that we have had to bear for the past 9 years.

    And people like you are guilty of protecting them and hiding the truth.

    [Reply]

  • Bhaskar Bhattacharya

    It’s not that UPA can’t handle the media. There are no LEADERS like Obama who have won their positions by campaigning the length and breadth of the country. In other words they are afraid of peopkle, forget about engaging with them. Contrast this with Obama who is ever ready to talk directly with the people, be it town hall meeting, or in a school or auditorium or just an open field. They are not afraid to connect directly with their own citizens. Obama does not think that he is in any way superior to the ordinary citizen. He feels that it is his responsivility to serve them. Unfortunately such values are not imbued in our politicians.

    [Reply]

  • shame

    see who is writing this. our own congressman Vir

    [Reply]

  • shame

    Hey Vir, just read all the comments written on your article and if you feel a bit of shame then stop writing

    [Reply]

  • Anil Sharma

    Mr. Singhvi, I raced through your fluent article imagining there would be a line or two about the failure of “Gandhis” to connect with the masses, to address the protesters or assure the people of India. And you singled out MMS? Someone always controls a puppet’s strings, or will you have us believe otherwise.

    [Reply]

  • kabir awadhi

    how can a rape in a city show ineffeciency of our national government ?? vir sanghvi and most of d commenters here have just politicized it when in fact its a social and law n order issue.

    [Reply]

  • Guest

    The biggest change is in the state of the economy. The world is no longer a rising tide that lifts all boats.

    [Reply]

  • Manish Kumar, Patna

    Why blame Dr Singh alone when UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi is the de facto leader of the government…Vir Sir why no mention of the Gandhis? They are always there to take credit for a NREGA and Right to Information or a Right to Education Act but when it comes to real governance issues like the ongoing Delhi protests or inflation or the economic crisis you will never find them taking any responsibility!

    [Reply]

  • Kedar

    I disagree on many counts, Vir.

    1] The Congress is not behind when it comes to media-savviness. Whenever I watch any TV debate on any topic, I always find their representatives – Manish Tiwari, Renuka Chowdhury, Kapil Sibbal, Digvijaya et al very well prepared, aggressive and far more confident than they ought to be. Contrast this with the ever-fumbling BJP spokespersons. Have you ever wondered that whenever the Congress is in troubled waters, Digvijaya comes to the rescue with his carefully crafted, digressive and diverting two penny comments? Besides, folks like Sibbal, Tharoor, Montek and many others come across as suave yet fierce orators, what with their superb English and presence of mind, even when they are lying through their teeth.

    2] I’m no fan of the BJP and her sick, bronze age ideology, but let’s give credit where it is due. The NDA rule was way, I repeat waaaaayyyyyy better and progressive than even UPA-I and in fact the UPA-I bore many fruits of the former’s policies. And I see you only going ga-ga about one of them that too when it is not required here.

    3] The Delhi rape case is in no way the fault of the Government, or even our laws. It only stems from our sick, misogynistic and hypocritic society. It is only the pathological liars or the incorrigible fools who would blame the Congress for that! And I don’t think any one else in the shoes of Sheila Dikshit, or Shinde or Manmohan or Sonia would have handled the aftermath of the rape any better. The damage had already been done and the Congress was merely unfortunate.

    4] I am astonished to find that you can only see the so-presumed media disconnection being the cause for the alienation between the Congress and the common man. As if the multitude of record breaking corruption scams, clear inefficiency, nepotism, sycophancy, arrogance, power-misuse and numerous other ills as epitomized by the ruling party carried no weight at all! And please, voter fatigue, anti-incumbency and global recession come across as pigmies when the above mentioned players are in gear!

    [Reply]

  • Kedar

    I disagree on many counts, Vir.

    1] The Congress is not behind when it comes to media-savviness. Whenever I watch any TV debate on any topic, I always find their representatives – Manish Tiwari, Renuka Chowdhury, Kapil Sibbal, Digvijaya et al very well prepared, aggressive and far more confident than they ought to be. Contrast this with the ever-fumbling BJP spokespersons. Have you ever wondered that whenever the Congress is in troubled waters, Digvijaya comes to the rescue with his carefully crafted, digressive and diverting two penny comments? Besides, folks like Sibbal, Tharoor, Montek and many others come across as suave yet fierce orators, what with their superb English and presence of mind, even when they are lying through their teeth.

    2] I’m no fan of the BJP and her sick, bronze age ideology, but let’s give credit where it is due. The NDA rule was way, I repeat waaaaayyyyyy better and progressive than even UPA-I and in fact the UPA-I bore many fruits of the former’s policies. And I see you only going ga-ga about one of them that too when it is not required here.

    3] The Delhi rape case is in no way the fault of the Government, or even our laws. It only stems from our sick, misogynistic and hypocritic society. It is only the pathological liars or the incorrigible fools who would blame the Congress for that! And I don’t think any one else in the shoes of Sheila Dikshit, or Shinde or Manmohan or Sonia would have handled the aftermath of the rape any better. The damage had already been done and the Congress was merely unfortunate.

    4] I am astonished to find that you can only see the so-presumed media disconnection being the cause for the alienation between the Congress and the common man. As if the multitude of record breaking corruption scams, clear inefficiency, nepotism, sycophancy, arrogance, power-misuse and numerous other ills as epitomized by the ruling party carried no weight at all! And please, voter fatigue, anti-incumbency and global recession come across as pigmies when the above mentioned players are in gear!

    [Reply]

  • pankaj#1

    Vir;
    I can not understand, why you refuse to see or acknowledge the obvious.
    Everybody knows that UPA II came to power on the shoulders of Urban middle class but continued to look for its voters amongst rural people, and muslim vote bank. Nothing wrong in looking after your underprivilaged populace but it was done so much shoddily that, majority started feeling discriminated in place of being a partner. for this progressive step. Like, MMS saying -muslims have first right on national resources, What???? Howcome????
    Then, you are not pointing out this glaring fact, admitted indirectly by even congressis. MMS was never given full freedom to work as Rahul was being foisted on UPA II and Indian population brazenly. Digvijay was always snipping at MMS’ heels. For your information, Digvijay has caused considerable harm to Congress apart from other contributors, including Sonia.

    [Reply]

  • ruchi

    Sir, we have read so much about the UPA-II’s direct benefits scheme. Last Minister Jairam Ramesh was heard giving statements about it with reference to what Rahul Gandhi was talking about it. Oddly Gandhi is not an office holder but a Congress Party member. The scheme (with its positives and negatives is just now a supposed trump card for the Congress in the name of the UPA where tax payers’ money is being used.

    [Reply]

  • ruchi

    Sir, we have read so much about the UPA-II’s direct benefits scheme. Last Minister Jairam Ramesh was heard giving statements about it with reference to what Rahul Gandhi was talking about it. Oddly Gandhi is not an office holder but a Congress Party member. The scheme (with its positives and negatives is just now a supposed trump card for the Congress in the name of the UPA where tax payers’ money is being used.

    [Reply]

  • Vox Populi

    Inept foreign policy as well as economic policy. Outside of call rooms and BPOs there is much to show for our illiteracy and cramming.

    [Reply]

    Babu Khan Reply:

    Shut up hey ****

    [Reply]

  • s subramanyan

    We
    should strive to get the headquarters of the Brics Bank to India. Mumbai could
    be an ideal candidate. We have here one of the globally acclaimed central bank
    which had given us several experts in development banking functions too. Let us
    proudly tell the global nations of our stellar
    achievement viz. we score over China, we have a parliamentary democracy,
    conducted periodical elections in the
    last 60 years not with a small population,
    but with huge one covering different religions and communities and classes;
    our experienced institutions like the Election Commission, Lok Sabha and Rajya
    Sabha can help African nations to imbibe truly effective democratic processes
    and institutions like conducting fair and free elections and operate ; we have far
    excelled even Britain which claims to have the mother of parliament. Recall
    what Thomas Pakenham wrote in his monumental work of 1992 the Scramble for Africa: “…Britain launched a crash programme in nation-building. Constitutions
    were borrowed from elsewhere, hammered out overnight, parliaments were thrown
    up like theatre-props(designed to the westminster model including the Speaker’s wig), elections held, prime ministers lectured
    on the intricacies of British democracy.” We had under difficult and widely differing conditions
    in every facet, religion,caste and class etc -such as those obtaining in many
    African nations, conducted fair and free elections and built
    our own parliament with two houses and legislative assemblies in our states
    an experience which is nearer African environment. Lastly, our PM has had vast experience
    in this field. He is eminently qualified to pursue and achieve this goal of
    getting Brics bank to India and thus hep us serve Bric nations.

    [Reply]

  • vip- mop mop sweep sweeps

    I am just assuming if it sfact on foreigners then citizens of INDIA should thank Foreigners can at end of day can think, All you have been doing over decades afeter the independence in SOUTH EAST CONTINENT is bully bicker, act lazy and act nothing but fight and mud sling oneach other. Most of the politicians have failed in performing or delivering on right moral duties to serve citizens. Corruption, lack of vision how to run show, align priorties how to mange right population control and take robust moves to educate warn and alert people on their obligations towards the state and force feed in their conditioned braions by Babas that rights come with full responsibilty under citizens charter. Takers kahin ke and all in the name of Bhagwan by divering foolish ignorant mans attentions from all the right tasks.

    [Reply]

  • KP

    As usual,a very interesting view on BRICS bank by Mr.Pramit.The Soft power trumpcard could prove to be a game changer for both India and china

    [Reply]

  • Reader

    What a horrible, unsubstantiated piece of opinion. The argument is so shallow.

    [Reply]

  • balaji

    india should go forward more and more in all financial sectors of world like world bank/bricks banks , as it is unavoidable for progress/devlopment of country/world in future world …..

    [Reply]

  • http://twitter.com/Farrukhabadi Praveen Saxena

    Do you plan to join Brookings India ?

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    This dilemma was once addressed in one of the blogs by this humble yours truly when got into an extensive duel with a certain blogger called BOBBY who happened to be a nuclear physicist.The topic was the justification of ATOM BOMBS on hiroshima and nagasaki.Bobby’s argument was japan was already on its knees and would have surrendered , I proved it conclusively quoting AKIO MORITA founder of SONY that IT WAS A NECCASARY EVIL.
    Now we hear KOREANS THINK IT WAS A DIVINE JUSTICE for the COMFORT WOMEN used by the *** military.Comfort women are korean women FORCED AS SEX SLAVES in service of japanese infantry.
    SAME I CAN HEAR A MILLION BANGLADESHI RAPE VICTIMS of 1971 war and ironically all the rapist were KHAN SENA in bagladeshi parlance , thus hailing from the very areas in NWFP where DRONES ARE DOING A MARVELLOUS JOB.
    Tasleema Nasreen’s aunt was raped by khan sena , she subsequently hanged herself.
    ISLAM RELIGION OF PEACE OR PISS
    also now shove the concept of UMMAH up your arse

    [Reply]

    engricn Reply:

    Tasleema Nasreen’s

    many indian respected writers tried to rape her also.this 5 times divorced women called tasleema nasreen is headache for society.if islam is bad become hindu.who stops this ***** to convert.she is tool in the hands of some foolish bengalees to defame islam.for them anybody writes some bad words for muslims or islam is HARDAY SAMRAT.u are unnatural people so always live on hate and lies.bloody idiots.

    [Reply]

    engricn Reply:

    SAME I CAN HEAR A MILLION BANGLADESHI RAPE VICTIMS of 1971 war and ironically all the rapist were KHAN SENA

    nothing but bullshit.khans were running from village to village for shelter.i am in contact with mukti bahini leaders according to them,

    first mukti bahini and his supporters killed 150000 people which include lot of pak supporting hindus as well.then pak army killed around same numbers to maitian law.hindus suffered more in pak action.
    grand daughter of bisr has written a book lately on this after good research.this is factual not propaganda.read .

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Zia my pal

    Give us also an article on how this Islamic shit has created havoc all over the world. They want the rule of Hafees saeed to prevail even over Lal qila. SO what is wrong with droning them?

    Remember Kandhahar. We had no solution to exterminate the scum. If Americans are doing our dirty work, you should celebrate and not cry.

    [Reply]

  • prashant saxena

    Zia,

    The awesome one (who refused to take Arabic lessons when he was a kid, and now we must all listen to his BS), as a moderate Muslim you probably agree that it is sad that innocents are being killed all over the world by Muslims who the moderates like you call terrorists. You will not and can not do anything to stop them.

    So, how can you ask for the US to stop it’s drone strikes, which admittedly and regeretably also have innocent victims?

    If you are indeed what you claim to be, launch a Jehad against terrorism. Clean your own house first, so called liberal.

    [Reply]

  • Faulitics

    Zia is fighting for the “human rights” of terrorists by protecting these terrorists while the drones are fighting for the human rights of the victims by attacking these fanatical Islamist terrorists. A drone is more humane and has a better understanding of justice than this Zia.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    You are seeing things through the biased prism of a neo-convert. Every major terrorist strikes in the past few decades has an inspiration in the tribal areas of Pakistan. The war onterror is with an organization that unlike a nation, does not respect the conventions of war. This is a guerilla warfare. Sending in our troops to hunt the terrorists renders our troops as sitting ducks, when the terrorist blends in with the populace and landscape.
    And hence the justification for drone usage. That said the drones have been modelled on using precision guided weapons, thus minimizing the collateral. But then, if the regular population prefers to be in the vicinity of a terrorist, then US has no option. Contrarily you should blame the terrorists and their enablers for using the general population as shields and/or collateral to incite a public opinion against the fight on terror.

    [Reply]

    engricn Reply:

    believe me nothing can save them.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    You are seeing things through the biased prism of a neo-convert. Every major terrorist strikes in the past few decades has an inspiration in the tribal areas of Pakistan. The war onterror is with an organization that unlike a nation, does not respect the conventions of war. This is a guerilla warfare. Sending in our troops to hunt the terrorists renders our troops as sitting ducks, when the terrorist blends in with the populace and landscape.
    And hence the justification for drone usage. That said the drones have been modelled on using precision guided weapons, thus minimizing the collateral. But then, if the regular population prefers to be in the vicinity of a terrorist, then US has no option. Contrarily you should blame the terrorists and their enablers for using the general population as shields and/or collateral to incite a public opinion against the fight on terror.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    GOOD NEWS ! GOOD NEWS !! DRONES KILL TALIBAN LEADER !!!

    Even Pakistan celebrates as the leader of the scum called Taliban was killed by American drones. SO Zia , should you not celebrate?

    [Reply]

  • Abhi

    I would like Zia to write about Pakistan killing Indians through their policy of “a thousand cuts”. Magnanimity is a two way street.

    [Reply]

  • engricn

    94000 killed in syria in last 2 years also had mother and father.there was no blood from dead and on body of killer.he approached by mi15 few months back.

    [Reply]

  • engricn

    now americans are using drones in america on their own people.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    The big issue is what do the Taliban want?

    Is Obama carrying on the drone attacks because these people are Muslims or is it because these people have attacked the US, attacked India, attacked even sensible and liberal Pakistanis and their minorities.

    The world will stop favouring drone attacks in case Taliban is replaced and dies a natural death and a liberal regime which allows all religions ot flourish takes over Afghanistan.

    I cannot figure out how the holy Koran has been interpreted to justify the haraam Taliban.

    [Reply]

    engricn Reply:

    see a documentary film coming on aljazeera

    AFGHANISTAN ,PRICE OF REVENGE.

    u will understand everything.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Islamists are a curse on humanity and a disease.

    [Reply]

  • junaid

    Islamophobia is a phobia in the minds of Muslims planted to make them feel that the world is after them.I quote from your letter. Is this not true? Look whenever, America and other western countries find, the christianity is in danger or something is possible, they will get together to do it in no time. Take for example South Sudan, an Island in Indonesia. They created states for christians in no time. Look why they are there in Afghanistan and Iraq. What are they doing to Pakistan, Yemen etc. Are not only the Muslims who are the target of their “kindness” Tell me if America is fighting against any other religious group except Muslims. The facts are facts.

    [Reply]

  • Ganapanty

    The same way Muslims fear BJP, the world fears Muslims.

    [Reply]

  • jumanji

    good reply. No need to post any more replies, you said it.

    [Reply]

  • mehak

    It is people like you with half knowledge of the holy Quran and shariah and the place of women in Islam, who write and speak things this like this.There is so much hatred in your words and in a country like India where muslims co exist as citizens ,this is not acceptable or appropriate.

    [Reply]

    Dude Reply:

    It’s not acceptable for your people of islmaic background to have killed and converted 80 million Hindus, Buddhists and Jains from the time you invaded and tried to rule for 7/800y years!

    Where is your remorse for this? We all know what happened! Only you muzzos think you converted ppl peacefully….. All you can say is where is the evidence…..

    I mean you must be a ****** if you think an average joe will want to convert to such a pitty ful religion!

    It’s fact! its history ! it happened! it is why your sorry a s s ancestors were converted down the line to be what you are now a fake follower of a rubbish 3rd generation book of abraham which was created a by a illiterate warmonger

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    Muslims need to ask themselves what do they prize more ALLAH OR ISLAM.If it is ALLAH then that unholy book and its supplementary written 1000yrs after the original need to be junked. But the problem is muslims like islam and not really bothered about allah . Thus the BEARD , HEAD SCARVES , SNIPPED FORESKIN all external appearance , INTERNALLY VACCOUS.
    I can only speak of UK. Thus we see MUSLIMS PACKING UK JAILS and majority non terrorist offences. Thus muslims depend on all the modern inventions made by the non muslims for their amenities and even their survival for left to their own , they wont be able to extract a drop of oil.. THEY ARE IN SUCH A PITIABLE STATE TOTALLY AT THE MERCY OF THE WHITE CHRISTIANS. Now they need to ask why, the same civilization that built AL HAMBRA , and algebra (Al-jibra, as it was known).produced minds such as AlBiruni, and that book Al Muquaddama.
    For answer refer to 95 thesis pinned in front of a church. Thus began the chasm.
    OH YES THEY DID NOT HAVE LOW CASTE HINDU CONVERTS LIKE ZIA FULL OF MALCONTENT leading the muslims like the pied piper of hamlyn , another one being Zakir Naik another ANTAJA

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    I have always called Zia extremist and this blog is a confession by Zia.

    No US visa for him…ever.

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    The extremists like Zia blame non-muslims for the plight of muslims but can they answer this…

    http://www.genocidebangladesh.org/

    [Reply]

  • mumtaz mehnaz 90

    Stupid to write such a blog.

    Why dont you turn the gaze inwards Mr Zia. People like me who travel to France, UK and US know that Muslims are now identified with killers and bombmakers. On top of it all the male Muslims want to put us, the girls in a Chaddar or tent and flirt with the Hindu, Christian or white girls who are smarter just because they have more freedoms and are not bound down by a book. So the woman in the house is the dependable ruck sack and the woman outside — Non Muslim– is all glamour and fun.

    Have the Sharia in your house Mr Zia. Would you want your sister or daughter to be an unequal partner in matrimony? Or be bound down by the dictats of a 75 yr old Maulvi who himself lusts for child brides.

    Reform islam. Instead of trying to force us to become fundamantalists just becasue this column makes you popular with orthodox Muslims.

    PLEASE TELL ME WHICH VERSES IN KORAN ARE ADDRESSED TO WOMEN. WHY SHOULD I BE DICTATD BY A DISCOURSE AIMED AT MEN?

    [Reply]

  • Dude

    Reform reform get these muzzos out of India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangerstan all of which belongs to India!

    Why don’t you do an article on the Hindu Holocaust? 80 Million plus Hindus, Buddhists, and Jains massacred or converted by force by the scum of the earth Islamites……..80 milion sunshine not 6 million like how the west has coveted the 6 mill jews that died in the jew holocaust at the hands of Hitler….

    Go back to arabia!……
    Wish there was an ashoka type figure that would reclaim all the lands unite India and rid these lands of all Islams……Putrid abrahamic religion!

    We all know how muslims like to fabricate all evidence and history claiming they invented everything even pre islam…..but most of all they like to bully and take land! and convert by force…….

    If I was in power 1000 years ago I would have discarded of all Hindu traitors who were too weak and helped these scum enter the land of hope! peace and tranquility!……..

    Sanatana Dharma long live!

    [Reply]

  • Abhi

    Does, “guided by a commitment to his religion” automatically imply hating other religions, for adherents of some religions. How else, do you explain, “my initial reaction was to be remarkably pleased”.

    [Reply]