The world is divided into two kinds of people – Homophobes and people I respect



Since the past week, my friends and I have been dancing to Desi Girl because two of our friends are getting married to each other in May.  We are rehearsing for the great Indian sangeet – the night for which youngsters practice their dance moves for months only to have their thunder stolen by a 60-year-old uncle on 5 pegs of neat whisky with moves that would put the cast of Grease to shame. But I digress.

In the midst of complex leg-hand co-ordination, the wedding choreographer declares in full filmifashion- “I have a dhasu concept for this song….it will blow everyone away….but only if you’ll are okay with it.” We were. So he tells us, “The concept is the Dostana theme itself.” Silence. Clearly he didn’t mean ’slide down your yellow underwear to reveal your toned backside’ theme. It was the other one. The gay theme. The three girls squealed in excitement. The three guys looked at each other in awkward incredulity. And then we all agreed.

So now, in front of a great many uncles, aunties and unknown entities, two of my male friends will check out my third male friend’s rear while he preens to the beats of Desi Girl leaving the girls in the lurch. The climax of the sequence will have us girls looking longingly into our respective partners’ eyes while the three of them hold hands behind our backs. And amidst all the cat calls and peals of laughter during rehearsals, I felt proud of my three heterosexual friends for not being uncomfortable and thinking, “This is below my manly dignity to pretend to be gay.” They were not only okay with the concept; they played their parts to perfection without making a mockery of homosexuality like Bollywood usually does.

Since the past few months, one straight friend of mine has had several close encounters of the gay kind. He has this inexplicable vibe that many gay men seem to find irresistible and has been hit on persuasively by some of them – in one extreme case it turned embarrassingly physical. But instead of being sexist and deriding homosexuality like many, many Indian guys my age do, he just got over it and continues to be on good terms with them. In fact he’s part of the gay trio in Desi Girl!

Now I’m not championing him as the messiah of homosexuals. But when I see educated, cosmopolitan youngsters call homosexuality a disease and think of gays as mentally unbalanced while auditioning for shows like MTV Roadies, I think it’s commendable that my friends are so open to the concept without making a big deal of their acceptance of it. In India, coming out of the closet is not as common an occurrence as it is in the US. So many twenty-somethings, straight or otherwise, are unsure of how to deal with it. Which is why we have innumerable homophobes in our presence, and I’m ashamed to say a few in my friend circle as well.

I think homophobes are a despicable lot. I know it’s a strong word to use and many might counter me with the old “Everyone is entitled to their opinion” spiel. So in my opinion, being homophobic is nearly as bad as being racist. To be fair, I have been fed on a diet of American sitcoms and Hollywood films where homosexuality is a popular theme and often the most memorable characters are gay. (Will from Will and Grace, Ross’s wife Susan in Friends, Heath Ledger in Brokeback Mountain, Sean Penn in Milk, Tom Hanks in Philadelphia.) And many my age may not be privy to these shows and movies that explore the concept so overtly. But perceiving gays as abnormal is not a result of television viewing habits. It stems from an intolerant, insecure, and highly-bigoted attitude. This especially does not excuse some guys I know, who endorse American brands, are addicted to Hollywood films and who appear to be intelligent in every other way, except in their prejudiced perception of gays.

Just the other day, two male friends of mine mistakenly ended up going for a ‘couples massage treatment’ at a plush spa. They were taken to a candle-lit room, with rose petals in bowls and romantic music in the background. They were made to wear translucent ‘granny panty’ like gear and were massaged mere inches away from each other. One of them was a self-proclaimed homophobe. After he narrated the incident amidst raucous laughter, I pointedly asked him, “How did you go through with it? Wasn’t your alpha-maleness threatened?” He thought for a while and replied, “Nah, it wasn’t that bad.” I think that’s a start.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (15 votes, average: 3.93 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
  • KTang

    Thank you for such an enlightened post Tasneem, I completely agree with you. I have had the good fortune of working with and being friends with many gay individuals throughout my life and I can honestly say that many of them are among the people I most respect in the world. I like to think that they are just good people and it has nothing to do with being gay, but then again, look at what society puts gay people through and I can see why some of them have overcome it all to focus on what truly matters – being a considerate and thoughtful human being.

    No one should ever be judged solely on whom they love. Thank you Tasneem!

    [Reply]

    Dylan Reply:

    Haha.. even I have homophobes in my friend circle! But they’re in minority.. at least I think they are.. (I dont exactly go around asking people if they’re ok with gays.. though I think i should?)

    I think this is about equal rights for everyone. Even a ‘live and let live’ kind of situation. It’ll be long before India accepts any of this though. Long Loooooong time for a country not prepared for bar-going women.

    But who says we can’t try? Equal rights for all! :D

    [Reply]

    Tasneem Reply:

    Dylan,
    Touche. You wont believe it but I was thinking of the EXACT same thing yesterday. That people think its against “Indian culture” for women to be seen at a nightclub, how in the world are they going to accept homosexuality?! But with ppl like you, me and a couple others here we could set the ball rolling forward…..cheers to equal rights!

    [Reply]

    Unsung Psalm Reply:

    Hi, that was a most delightful read! Glad to see such attitudes spreading in Indian society… I suppose there’s ever-growing hope for our lot here :)

    Vijay Jung Thapa Reply:

    Nice post Tasneem. Since I pretend to be a “Sex Guru” — here are my two bits. Indians don’t seem to be homophobes, quite the way you see in the west. In fact, in rural and semi-urban areas — some amount of homosexual activity before marriage is seen as normal — they term it “masti”. Of course, it is supposed to disappear once you get married — so I don’t know if they guys indulging in “masti” were really gay or just plain repressed. However, my point is I don’t see the kind of fury and gay bashing ( I may be wrong) that I saw in the west — where people of different sexual orientation need “gay-friendly” areas to feel secure.

    [Reply]

    Tasneem Reply:

    Hey Vijay,
    I agree that gay-bashing is much more common in the US than India. But thats because the US has more out of the closet gays and homosexuality is much more out there than in India which in turn makes gay bashing more of a common occurence. I reckon that if in India, especially in urban cities, if coming out of the closet was as overt as it is in the US, then we would have almost as much anti-gay bigots as in the west. And I was referring more to the educated class in my post. MUmbai is full of happy, hand-holding men walking its streets, but its those who live in their highrises and party at clubs that tend to feel repulsed by homosexuality.

    [Reply]

    Samar Halarnkar Reply:

    I hope you all know that the Hindustan Times, Mumbai, was the proud recipient of the newspaper most sensitive to gay and lesbian issues. I have the award, given to us last year, if I remember correctly

    Tasneem Reply:

    you got it right, KTang! Bravo :)

    [Reply]

  • http://blogs.hindustantimes.com/expletive-deleted Kushal

    Great post, Tasneem.

    [Reply]

    AMITA Reply:

    Hi Tasneem,

    Really nice post. Sexuality is a BIG issue in a country like India and talking about it can make u the centre of attraction when u r among old aunties and uncles. I believe its one’s choice and one’s right to be who he or she wants to be. All it requires is a little understanding by the society, friends and family.

    I really appreciate your efforts and wish u all the best for the future.

    Amita

    [Reply]

    Tasneem Reply:

    “A little understanding”… Amita, people think gays are born with dysfunctional hormones….It will take a LOT more than a little understanding to change their thinking!! Thanks for your wishes….I wish there were many more like you!!

    [Reply]

    Mayank dixit Reply:

    what i think tasneem ,base of homosexuality is on harmonic grounds ,it hurts because we are reffering indirectly that they are not medically fit.However we have to accept the realities and look forward to understand it and help them(homo peoples ) to live a good life rather than to change the basic norms of homosexuality.

    Antara Reply:

    Mayank,

    You need a severe intervention! A crash course in basic human biology will do. Can you provide a scientific citation to back your claim (from a credible science journal )? I do not believe that ignorant people like you should drag science into a social debate. For the last time – it is biologically NORMAL to be a homosexual. Homosexuality is as abundant in the rest of the animal kingdom as in homo sapiens (translation-humans).

    Tasneem Reply:

    Thanks Kushal!

    [Reply]

  • Mayank

    Hi Tasneem,

    Homosexuality is not an issue.Those who are gay should not be embarrassed because of that.But is it right to spread the gay culture in society?I accepts that only few people came on earth as gay by birth beacuse of disfunctional in their harmones…howver now days most of people are attracted towards gay culture just to enjoy or fun..
    Once in newspaper a actress said that she wish to get married but most of the people near around her are either married or GAY.so don’t u think that way we are higliting and encouraging the issue of homosexulity will change the culture and laws given by god one day..The plays of homosexulity which we all do just for fun sometimes make people homosexual…
    Its very open , if 1 or 2 members in your group are gay then they will look forward to include some others also from the group and will definetly covers other also in homosexulity frame…Homesexuality is nothing its all about ur feeling towards sex which directly operated from brain..I m ver much sure if u put 1 gay person in group of 10 no gay persons ,he will definetly make a team .

    But one of the beneift is that we can control the population if homosexuality increases in india :-)

    I know my thoughts are very much different from yours …but if u think practically that my words are vry much true.If its just a matter of discussion then u have written very nice article.but if we really think about the consequences then society will be in danger in future.

    [Reply]

    D10 Reply:

    Mayank,

    I have heard and read many people with views very similar to yours and I am genuinely curious. What exactly do you mean by dangerous consequences of homosexuality? or for that matter the problem with ’spreading gay culture in society’? I am yet to read an intelligently and rationally articulated defence of homophobes like yourself and I am honestly willing to give you this chance, because I don’t think you justify your stand very well by talking about general things like ‘dangerous consequences’!

    And one more thing, what precisely do you mean by ‘gay culture’?!? Homosexuality is not a ‘culture’ as you seem to think. It is a matter of personal orientation and choice. I do not understand any kind of cultural ramifications that it has!

    If you feel that you can rationally respond to my queries, please do so. I am, like I said, genuinely curious!

    [Reply]

  • Nutsure

    Nice blog. I would like to differ. Barring a few individuals which are in a minority, homosexuality is a perversion. Someone may champion a cause for bestiality. Homosexuality is just not a normal biological phenomenon. There are many grey areas where it is seen as what we call in hindi as “majboori”. The sailors in the past era, all male or female hostels, and list is endless. It would be just for the heck of it. in a particular phase of adolesence. These people could never be termed as homos. They are bisexuals. But the bisexuals who put the gay or lesbian tags on their sleeves would be travesty. If there are genuine homophobes or lesbians respect their feelings. But calling a few individuals who express their opinion as bad or good on MTV and forming your opinion on their opinion is not just. If you are comfortable with gays or lesbians fine if you are not all the more fine. Sex and sexuality is very personal. In the mean time enjoy your steps on ‘Roop tera mastana’ or ‘Dostana’. By the way Dr Jabbar Patel with Late Smita Patil and Girish Karnad was the first Indian who tackled the problem of Lesbianism in a Marathi film ‘Umbartha”.

    [Reply]

    D10 Reply:

    Nutsure, I respect your opinion, but I do think that it is offensive to equate a relationship with a human being with an animal. I am just glad that you feel that sexuality is a personal issue.

    [Reply]

    Nutsure Reply:

    Sorry if offended someones feelings. But some very strong views on this subject. I have already said that there is a miniscule of people who belong to gay or lesbian sects. In these cases it is a medical problem of identity. On that ground respect their feelings. A strong comparision with bestiality for bisexuals wearing this homophobs tag on their shoulder because of the disrespect to this phenomenon. Incest is one practice which is widely accepted in west and some parts south of Vindhyas. Accepted marriages are taking places between uncle (Mama) and niece (bhanja) in southern states. You can’t shun them. Good cinematic topic so enjoy your beats.

    [Reply]

    Dylan Reply:

    You should hav given your opinion on that Miss USA – Perez Hiltion thing.

    [Reply]

    Tasneem Reply:

    I know! Just saw it on the news the other day. Well, what do you expect from Miss USA? Beauty? Of course. Brains? Errmm…. Bigotry? YES.

    [Reply]

    Mayank dixit Reply:

    A general question to all those ladies and gents..wat will u do ,if ur husband or wife became homosexual or lesbian after marriage , just because of interaction with others who are oriented towards same sex.

    before posting your replies , just think practically.

    Nutsure Reply:

    What do you mean by “became” homosexuals or lesbians. They are born that way. It’s an identity crisis. A female mind trapped in a male body or a male mind trapped in a female body. You can’t change your sexuality overnight. One may hide it before marriage. But then that’s terrible. They should be more worried about infidelity !!

    Mayank dixit Reply:

    No man,

    I accept they are born that way..but not every one having same set of dysfunctional harmones..but it infulenced more as they come towards a group..or we can when they get environment.

    Dylan Reply:

    If your sense is anything like your grammar, I fear for you, man.

    D10 Reply:

    Mayank, what sort of ‘practicality’ argument have you been peddling around against homosexuals?! If someone develops an attraction for another person while married, it’s a question of infidelity, not ‘practicality’. People don’t ‘develop’ homosexual ‘tendencies’ because of ‘interaction’ with homosexuals!!! In any case, I am curious about these ‘dysfunctional hArmones’ that you refer to. What are these? Can you enlighten people a bit about them?

    coffee break Reply:

    one question:
    1. would 5 pegs of neat whisky simply have done the trick for you guys as well, and saved you months of practise?

    [Reply]

    Tasneem Reply:

    Probably not.

    [Reply]

    Tasneem Reply:

    We could go on and on about this. The bottom line is Nutsure, there are men who like women, men who like men, women who like women and some like both men and women. And if sexuality is a personal issue like you said, I wonder why you deride it because it is between two people, whoever they maybe; and why you and others might not be fine with it, because it has absolutely nothing to do with you and isnt affecting your personal life in anyway. Its not a “medical problem”. It’s a choice of who you love and who you want to be with.
    However, I resign myself to the fact that “everyone is entitled to their opinion.”

    [Reply]

  • http://arambhusal.sulekha.com Aram

    Nice Blog Tasneem, Well I have seen how people react so strangely and dramatically when they encounter homosexuals!! And in another case people go to extremes of depicting themselves as homosexuals just to be known by people around them (Although they r hetero)…

    [Reply]

  • http://flygye.blogspot.com/ flygye12

    i was referred to ur post by a friend in response to one of my posts….well American sitcom/ Hollywood movies fed homophobes doexist as i recently found out….the only satisfaction is that they also like Himesh Reshamiyya (so something mentally wrong with them ain’t there? :D )

    [Reply]

  • http://creyzeee.blogspot.com Aditi

    It’s terrible how certain people are treated so shabbily solely on the basis of their sexual preference. and then justify it using lame excuses like ‘brain dysfunction’ or ‘abnormality’. I used to be under the happy delusion that such a point of view is restricted to “older ppl”…sadly, it’s pretty much a part of my generation too. Very very sad.

    [Reply]

  • http://kaaliyakapoor.wordpress.com Ruchika

    Its funny to see in a blog against homophobes, Samar’s comment “…proud recipient of the newspaper most sensitive to gay and ******* issues. …”

    If the newspaper has to hide legitimate words for gays, isn’t there a problem somewhere. :)

    The comments moderators might need to revisit their policy.

    [Reply]

  • Ankit

    hey,

    Well i wont totally agree with you on this topic, first of all being racist and being a homophobe are two different things and should NEVER be read together. Racism is against natural factors like color of skin etc. But homosexuality is un-natural. I am what u call addicted to Hollywood films and appear to be intelligent and yes i am a homophobe. Just the very thought of a guy with a guy gives me creeps. So my opinions are bound to be biased. I may be a homophobe but that’s only at a personal level, on the larger screen I do not care if the whole world decides to embrace homosexuality . I do not hate then to such an extent that i would go out and distribute fliers for the next anti-gay parade( even for money) I got better things to do. I believe everybody has the freedom to do whatever they want. And if you want to date your that guy/girl of your sex from the gym you are free to do so. Just ummmm stay away from me.

    have a nice day :-)

    [Reply]

  • http://thestoryofmyassasins.blogspot.com Abhishek

    Hey Tasneem,

    I really fail to understand why labels come about ? So what’s so different about homosexuals ? I see nothing except the sexual orientation , why is that such an issue ?

    Why can’t we be more accepting ? Why do we need Kashish and an odd Azaadi March to prove a point , to liberate , to hear them out.

    Acceptance is an issue , people don’t look beyond what is shown to them all their lives and specially the ones who use “how gay” as common slang , how I want to slap such people.

    Social conditioning is an issue , where it has to be stopped treating like a problem or something unnatural , its disgusting how people react to someone who cross-dresses , why is that a problem and how does it affect their lives , i fail to understand.

    Choice lies with an individual , and it cannot be enforced. If someone is L/G/B/T then we have to respect their choice and carry on with our lives and not wonder what miracle they might bring up next , its not monkey man for christ sake , its a human being and you *have* to respect him/her. Then again , its not a choice at all , its something which comes from within.

    I am straight and well I have loads of homosexual friends , but I only time I label them as homosexual or think of them that way is when there is a discussion , I don’t believe in the fakeness of “tolerant” people who love to show off their gay friends. Its plain stupid and immature.

    They have a name and they look human now unless they grow horns or their eyes turn red or they start looking like Jason from Friday the 13th , nothing will change.

    P.S : Celebrations of Gay festivals , is not just for homosexuals but for straight people like us , who accept homosexuality . So try and be there :)

    [Reply]

  • Tkmsundaresan

    I agree with the findings.Indian business captains and others having black money resources equally identical in views with rich nations.
    tkmsundaresan@gmail.com

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    thanks for the information you have given above i looking for this things so alone

    get delicious votes

    [Reply]

  • Anonymous

    That was exactly what I was looking for. You have done a wonderful job communicating your message. Keep up the good work.

    [Reply]